XXII Symposium of archaeological investigations in Guatemala Archaeological sites in the Maya area: a conservation challenge summary XXII Symposium of archaeological investigations in Guatemala Archaeological sites in the Maya area: a conservation challenge summary Copyright © 2009, J. Paul Getty Trust Every effort has been made to contact the copyright holders of the material in this document and to obtain permission to publish. Any omissions will be corrected in future volumes if the publisher is notified in writing. Cover photograph by Jorge Valencia García The Getty Conservation Institute 1200 Getty Center Drive, Suite 700 Los Angeles, CA 90049-1684 United States Telephone 310-440-7325 Fax 310-440-7709 E-mail [email protected] www.getty.edu/conservation Editors Carolina Castellanos Françoise Descamps with the collaboration of: The Getty Conservation Institute works internationally to advance conservation prac- Jennifer Carballo tice in the visual arts—broadly interpreted to include objects, collections, architecture, and sites. The Institute serves the conservation community through scientific research, Designer education and training, model field projects, and the dissemination of the results of both Soluciones de Comunicación its own work and the work of others in the field. In all its endeavors, the GCI focuses on www.sol-com.com the creation and delivery of knowledge that will benefit the professionals and organiza- Mónica Rodríguez de la Parra tions responsible for the conservation of the world’s cultural heritage. XXII Symposium of archaeological investigations in Guatemala Archaeological sites in the Maya area: a conservation challenge summary XXII Symposium of archaeological investigations in Guatemala Archaeological sites in the Maya area: a conservation challenge Table of contents 1. Preface 7 2. Introduction 9 3. Structure and content of the discussion panel 13 4. Considerations derived from the discussion panel 17 5 Table of contents Table 5. Panel schedule 21 6. Abstracts 23 7. Author biographies 27 Preface he cultural groups that developed through at Joya de Cerén in El Salvador and the methodology Ttime in the Maya area constituted one of the for the study of the state of conservation and the defi- great cultural traditions of the world, developing nition of a conservation strategy for the Hieroglyphic in a territory that today includes portions of Mexico Stairway of Copán, Honduras. To share the results and Central America. The Maya civilization has been from these projects and other conservation programs the focus of attention of scholars and academics sin- in the region, the GCI proposed to the symposium or- ce the 19th century and continues to be the center ganizers the structuring of a conservation panel in the of numerous research and conservation programs. As symposium, to highlight the importance of conside- archaeological research has progressed, new methods ring and integrating conservation during the different have been developed to better understand decay me- phases of an archaeological project, from excavation chanisms and to design intervention alternatives that to site presentation. enhance the understanding and presentation of this important historic legacy. Although there has always This publication presents the results from the conser- been concern about the decay of materials and struc- vation panel Archaeological sites in the Maya area: a tures, in recent years the importance of considering conservation challenge, developed for the XXII Sym- conservation possibilities prior to any action has posium of Archaeological Investigations in Guate- been underscored, as well as the need to implement mala. The publication includes a brief introduction to articulated and sustainable actions at sites. the Maya area and the work carried out by the GCI, a presentation of the structure and contents of the panel, The Tikal Association is a nonprofit cultural entity, the conclusions derived from the dynamic discussion founded in 1964 in Guatemala City. It centers its during the panel between professionals and other par- efforts on the protection and conservation of pre-Co- ticipants involved in the research, conservation and 7 lumbian and historic heritage in Guatemala and on presentation of sites in the Maya region, the schedule Preface the cultural traditions of today. The Association pro- of the presentations and their respective abstracts. The motes the dissemination of knowledge about this he- full presentations are only included in the Spanish ver- ritage, implements study and research programs, and sion of this publication. supports museums and similar entities. Since 1987, they have collaborated with heritage institutions in This publication constitutes an important step in the Guatemala and with the National Museum for Ar- research, conservation and use of archaeological he- chaeology and Ethnology to organize the Sympo- ritage, as it reflects how different disciplines colla- sium of Archaeological Investigations in Guatemala. borate and the importance of sustainability for site Each year, this forum brings together more than three conservation and management. hundred professionals carrying out research projects in Guatemala and the Maya region as a whole to ex- The success of the meeting would not have been change information and to present the latest progress possible without the valuable collaboration and con- of projects at specific sites. tributions of the members of the Tikal Association, the organizing committee for the symposium, the pa- Within the framework of the Maya Initiative, a his- nelists and numerous individuals from participating toric heritage conservation project focused on Meso- institutions who worked to develop and organize the america, the Getty Conservation Institute (GCI) un- panel. dertook a conservation management planning project Françoise Descamps and Juan Antonio Valdés Panel moderators Introduction Carolina Castellanos Preliminary considerations about the Maya area and challenges for the conservation of heritage ultural and natural heritage in Mesoamerica one month of five extra days (called nemontemi by Cis as rich and diverse as the cultures that cre- the Aztecs and uayeb by the Maya). Societies were ated it through time and the ecosystems in which hierarchical and differentiated into groups that in- they thrived. This cultural region, first denominated cluded merchants, warriors, artisans, farmers and as such by Paul Kirchhoff in 1943, encompasses religious and political elites. an area between 10º and 22º northern latitude and includes central and southern Mexico, Guatemala, Archaeological sites in the Maya area, developed Belize, El Salvador and some portions of Honduras, through different periods, reflect the adaptation of Nicaragua and Costa Rica. different groups to their environment and landscape and consequently reflect different stylistic features Over more than 3,000 years of evolution, cultures and architectural technology, responding to particu- in Mesoamerica evidently had territorial shifts and lar ideologies and the availability of certain con- significant variations in cultural aspects. Features struction materials. The diversity of materials and 9 that were later considered as typical of Mesoameri- cultural features entails a significant challenge for Introduction can groups were generated at different moments and the conservation and management of heritage plac- places, and separated by a considerable distance. It es. One of the most significant is the deterioration is only through the interrelation of people, occur- of prehispanic construction materials. To address ring across several centuries, that a cultural plat- this issue, a precise knowledge and methodological form was created which later integrated different analysis is needed so as to understand the interrela- groups under the so-called traditions and features tion of all factors involved in complex deterioration of Mesoamerica. mechanisms. Consequently, conservation projects must consider both the conditions inherent to the Various groups in the area reached a high level of environment as well as the specific transformations cultural sophistication, reflected in the great cities, of materials themselves and the effects derived art, architecture, etc. that evidence complex social, from inadequate conservation and management political, economic and religious organizations. practices. Arts and sciences had specific characteristics in dif- ferent areas; the diversity of natural environments Material deterioration varies from site to site and also played an important role in development pro- even within the same building or decorated feature, cesses, by offering inhabitants conditions and op- depending on factors such as climate, cultural con- portunities to develop various responses. Features text, design and construction technology as well as that characterize Mesoamerican cultures include the materials themselves. Decay is considered as the the construction of ballcourts, slash and burn ag- transformation initiated by one or several agents, riculture, hieroglyphic writing, human sacrifice, such as water, temperature, wind, biological agents, construction of stepped pyramids and a 365-day pollutants, etc. However, decay is also a mecha- calendar divided into 18 months of 20 days plus nism, inherent to material properties and behavior, which attempts to stabilize in specific environmen- sues, from technical considerations to long-term tal conditions so as to reach equilibrium. maintenance