Representations of Prostitution on the Elizabethan and Jacobean Stage Trish Thomas Henley
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Florida State University Libraries Electronic Theses, Treatises and Dissertations The Graduate School 2007 Dealers in hole-sale: Representations of Prostitution on the Elizabethan and Jacobean stage Trish Thomas Henley Follow this and additional works at the FSU Digital Library. For more information, please contact [email protected] THE FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF ARTS AND SCIENCES DEALERS IN HOLE-SALE: REPRESENTATIONS OF PROSTITUTION ON THE ELIZABETHAN AND JACOBEAN STAGE By Trish Thomas Henley A Dissertation submitted to the Department of English in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Degree Awarded: Summer Semester, 2007 UMI Number: 3282617 UMI Microform 3282617 Copyright 2007 by ProQuest Information and Learning Company. All rights reserved. This microform edition is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest Information and Learning Company 300 North Zeeb Road P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, MI 48106-1346 The members of the Committee approve the dissertation of Trish Thomas Henley defended on April 9th, 2007. _________________________ Bruce Boehrer Professor Directing Dissertation _________________________ W. Jeffrey Tatum Outside Committee Member _________________________ Celia R. Daileader Committee Member _________________________ David Johnson Committee Member _________________________ Gary Taylor Committee Member _________________________ Daniel Vitkus Committee Member Approved: _________________________ Ralph Berry, Chair, Department of English _________________________ Joseph Travis, Dean, College of Arts and Sciences The Office of Graduate Studies has verified and approved the above named committee members. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract ...............................................................................................................v INTRODUCTION. WHAT LIES BENEATH: MIMESIS, THEATRICAL TRANSVETITISM, AND THE PROSTITUTE STAGED...........................1 Theatrical Mimesis......................................................................................4 The Early Modern Gaze..............................................................................8 The Prostitute Staged ..................................................................................17 1. MEDIEVAL AND TUDOR ATTITUDES TOWARD PROSTITUTION....28 The Early Modern and Postmodern Prostitute............................................28 Catholic Saints, Protestant Martyrs, and the Crux of the Material Body ...33 Saintly Whores............................................................................................40 The Whore of Babylon................................................................................55 2. THE MATERIAL CONDITIONS OF THE EARLY MODERN PROSTITUTE.............................................................................................59 Feminists, Sex, and Whores—Oh my! .......................................................60 English Law and Prostitution: A Brief History...........................................65 The Material Conditions of Elizabethan Prostitution .................................75 Geography, the Theaters, and Prostitution..................................................79 3. “THEY DO BUT BUY THEIR THRALDOMS”: MARRIAGE AS PROSTITUTION........................................................................................82 Early Modern Marriage Contracts ..............................................................83 Everyone’s Price Is Written on his Back ....................................................86 Nuns and Prostitutes ...................................................................................91 Isabella’s Silent Consent?...........................................................................104 4. “I THINK THEY THINK ME A VERY LADY”: SOCIAL-CLIMBING AND THE PROSTITUTE ..........................................................................106 Velvet Women Within................................................................................108 Ride and be Ridden.....................................................................................118 Selling Yourself..........................................................................................121 The Market as Dangerous Fantasy..............................................................126 5. “CRACKED IN THE RING”: CHANGEABLE PROSTITUTES AND THE LONDON MARKETPLACE.....................................................................129 The Prostitute as Market Allegory..............................................................130 iii Dirty Money ................................................................................................134 6. DESDEMONA UNPINNED: PROSTITUTES ON PARADE ON THE RESTORATION STAGE...........................................................................150 Enter the Whore ..........................................................................................161 The Interpellating Mirror ............................................................................166 REFERENCES ................................................................................................170 BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH ...............................................................................191 iv ABSTRACT This study focuses on the representation of prostitution on the Elizabethan and Jacobean stage. After delineating the historical, religious, and juridical contexts of medieval and early modern whoredom and prostitution, this study provides a close reading of representations of prostitution in several late sixteenth- and early seventeenth-century plays, including works by Christopher Marlowe, William Shakespeare, Thomas Middleton and Ben Jonson. Arguing that the theatrical convention of transvestitism allows pre-Interregnum playwrights to use the sexual ideology of whoredom as an analogy, the dissertation traces the playwrights’ use of prostitutes to indict various “social ills,” from the chaotic proto-capitalist market to the class-climbing of the middling sort. The study concludes by claiming that these analogies are foreclosed when the Restoration actress takes the stage. Once the female body inhabits these roles, these roles are no longer analogous; instead, the staged prostitute is limited to the embodiment of the patriarchal nightmare of uncontrolled feminine sexuality. v INTRODUCTION WHAT LIES BENEATH: MIMESIS, THEATRICAL TRANSVESTITISM, AND THE PROSTITUTE STAGED This project began as an inquiry into the theatrical analogy between the prostitute and the marketplace in early sixteenth-century city comedies. After reading Jonson’s Bartholomew Fair and Middleton’s A Chaste Maide in Cheapside, I expected to find a fairly homogenous representation of courtesans and prostitutes as metonymic of the proto-capitalist market.1 The terms of comparison seemed obvious: both the prostitute and goods in the market circulate; the prostitute is her own commodity, allowing for a critique of usurious market practices as unnaturally productive; like the theater, the prostitute might represent a debased market microcosm where what is sold is seemingly without “real” value.2 Though I certainly found plays where the prostitute worked in exactly the manner I expected, I also discovered plays where the staged prostitute exposed hypocrisy and double standards in early modern culture, such as the exchange of women between men in licit marriages. Even within the city comedy, a genre overtly concerned with city stereotypes and economics, the representation of prostitutes does not function simply as a moralistic condemnation of the unnaturally propagative and usurious market nor is the prostitute limited to an embodiment of the patriarchal nightmare of uncontrolled female sexuality. Instead, playwrights employ the prostitute in a variety of metaphoric analogies, analogies that are not always indifferent to the plight of women in general or even the prostitute specifically. Certainly, all early modern representations of the prostitute, even the most sympathetic, reiterate misogynist sexual ideology. The prostitute represents the prodigious example of 1 Throughout the beginning of this introduction I am, for the sake of clarity, using our modern connotations of a “courtesan” as women who exchange sex for material gain or higher status and “prostitute” as one who exchanges sex for monetary gain. These “categories” though are not stable, even by modern definitions. In the Webster’s New College Dictionary, the courtesan is described as “a prostitute; esp. a mistress of a king, or a man of wealth or nobility,” while the OED defines “courtesan” as “a court-mistress; a woman of the town, a prostitute” (n2). Thus, though our connotations seem to imply a clearer delineation, the denotations define a courtesan as a type of prostitute. The difference in both the denotation and the connotation is simply one of class and number of customers, a fact that will become clearer in later discussions of the prostitute. For the early modern prostitute, these categories are even more thoroughly elided. Later in this chapter, I will discuss in more detail the early modern terminology of prostitution. 2 For an insightful comparison of theater and prostitution, see Joseph Lenz’s “Base Trade: Theater as Prostitution” ELH 60:4 (1993): 833-55. 1 whoredom, and in the playwrights’ various denunciations, they make use of the prostitute’s ability to express insatiable appetite, moral degradation, the contaminated body, and the devil’s