DOCSLIB.ORG

Normative Standing: De Facto State Identity and International Legitimation

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Normative Standing: De Facto State Identity and International Legitimation Normative Standing: De Facto State Identity and International Legitimation Sebastian Tadeusz Klich August 2018 A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy of The Australian National University © Copyright by Sebastian Tadeusz Klich 2018 All Rights Reserved DECLARATION Unless otherwise acknowledged in the text, this thesis represents the original research of the author. The total word count for this thesis, excluding footnotes, bibliography, and appendices, is 74,244 words. Sebastian Klich 16 August 2018 2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The Centre for Arab and Islamic Studies at the Australian National University, under the leadership of Distinguished Professor Amin Saikal, provided institutional support and a vibrant intellectual environment for this research which greatly stimulated my growth as an aspiring scholar. I owe an unrepayable debt to my two supervisors. Associate Professor Mathew Gray's resolute support, often irrespective of time and physical location, has been invaluable. His belief in me and the research project, and his judicious incisive guidance have required nothing less than the best that I could give. Dr Kirill Nourzhanov became my supervisor in the later stages of the thesis and has been a thoughtful and stalwart bastion of scholarly standards with humour and grace in the collegial den. I am also greatly indebted to several other distinguished academics, who have provided key advice and guidance at crucial stages in the development and implementation of this project. Professor Nina Caspersen at the University of York in the United Kingdom, Associate Professor Jacinta O’Hagan, Director of the Graduate Centre in Governance and International Affairs at the University of Queensland, and Dr Mathew Davies, Director of the Coral Bell School of Asia Pacific Affairs in the Department of International Relations at ANU, have all assisted with generous time and insights on relevant theories and gave valued feedback on sectional drafts. My sincere gratitude to all my formal interviewees, and to many other individuals in Nagorno Karabakh, Somaliland, and Kurdistan who selflessly contributed their time and expertise to help this research (some in challenging circumstances) and made me welcome in their countries. I hope you feel that I have tried to do scholarly justice in difficult terrains with honesty, fairness and cultural respect. A special thank you to Dr Raihan Ismail, Dr April Biccum, Dr Jessie Moritz and Kieran Pender at ANU who provided friendship and encouragement, occasional sanity checks and reliable reference points for scholarly values, when it really mattered. I would also like to pay tribute to the work and support of Jacky Sutton, fellow student, whose untimely and tragic death deprived us all of a valued colleague and friend at the Centre. Jacky’s presence and assistance in facilitating meetings in Kurdistan, her willingness to share her knowledge, and her concern for my personal safety will always be remembered. My family’s support has been unwavering. My parents instilled a love of learning and a passion for thought and creative work from the cradle, my two sisters Rosie and Jess illustrate the fact that families exist to ensure you never take yourself too seriously, and their love has been my constant. My research and living costs while undertaking the research were covered by an Australian Postgraduate Award. I also received other grants for fieldwork and travel from the Australian National University, and I consider myself fortunate to have studied there. 3 ABSTRACT This thesis makes an original contribution to the field of de facto state studies. The robustness and durability of de facto states in the post-Cold War era has defied scholars’ earlier predictions of likely impermanence. In the de facto states literature that followed, a focus on rational choice approaches permeated the analysis of these states’ international engagement, however the concept of de facto state identity and how it shapes the relationship with international society has yet to be fully explored and analysed. A recent trend towards examining the legitimation strategies of de facto states has been restricted by an under-conceptualisation of the social system that they inhabit, restricting the explanatory utility of legitimacy as an analytical lens. Rather than an abnormality, non-recognition has been the norm in the relationship between de facto states and international society. A stasis has formed. The under-conceptualisation of the relationship has remained a partial void that has limited the understanding of a phenomenon that continues to challenge central concepts in the discipline of International Relations. The core objective of this thesis is to address that conceptual need by synthesising constructivist and English School approaches to build a conceptual framework of normative standing that enables a clearer articulation of the relationship between de facto states and international society. It employs a constructivist methodology to examine the recognition narrative of de facto states, in order to conduct constitutive analysis of their state identities, and to build the foundations of a theory of normative standing. Three case studies, with varying degrees of international engagement and parent state relationships, were selected for the examination of the application of the conceptual framework. Together, they provide for an effective generalisation across the spectrum of de facto states. The three case studies ― Nagorno Karabakh, Somaliland, and the Kurdistan Region of Iraq ― were informed by fieldwork interviews conducted in situ. The theory of normative standing proposed by this thesis proves to be a useful tool to explain de facto states' endurability, how de facto statehood has itself become a role identity in the international system, and the stasis of the relationship between de facto states and international society. 4 Table of Contents DECLARATION ....................................................................................................................................... 2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ...................................................................................................................... 3 ABSTRACT ............................................................................................................................................... 4 CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................... 7 1.1 OVERVIEW ...................................................................................................................................................... 7 1.2 THE DE FACTO STATES LITERATURE ......................................................................................................... 8 1.2.1 Theoretical Engagement in the De Facto States Literature .............................................. 12 1.3 RESEARCH QUESTIONS, APPROACH AND METHODOLOGY .................................................................... 16 1.3.1 Research questions ............................................................................................................................... 16 1.3.2 A note on terminology ......................................................................................................................... 16 1.3.3 Selected case studies ............................................................................................................................ 18 1.3.4 Methodology ............................................................................................................................................ 20 1.3.5 Interview selection and methods ................................................................................................... 22 1.4 THE SCOPE OF THE THESIS ........................................................................................................................ 23 1.5 THE STRUCTURE OF THE THESIS .............................................................................................................. 25 CHAPTER TWO: DE FACTO STATES AND THE INTERNATIONAL SYSTEM ...................... 28 2.1. DE FACTO STATES AND SOVEREIGNTY .................................................................................................. 28 2.2 DE FACTO STATES IN THE INTERNATIONAL SYSTEM ........................................................................... 33 2.2.1 Defining the De Facto State .............................................................................................................. 35 2.2.2 De Facto States in the International System ............................................................................ 38 2.2.3 De Facto State Identity in the International System ............................................................. 46 2.2.4 The Ontological Status of the State............................................................................................... 51 2.3 INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY AND THE POLITICS OF RECOGNITION ....................................................... 58 2.3.1 De Facto States in International Law .......................................................................................... 58 2.3.2 The Practice of State Recognition ................................................................................................. 61 2.3.3 Recognition after the Cold War ...................................................................................................... 67 2.4 CONCLUSION ...............................................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Somaliland's Investment in Peace: Analysing the Diaspora's Economic
    Working Paper No.4 Somaliland’s Investment in Peace: Analysing the Diaspora’s Economic Engagement in Peace Building Mohamed Hassan Ibrahim1 August 2010 1 The author would like to thank Nasir Osam Sheikh Hassan and Naima Abdullahi of the Academy for Peace and Development, for assisting me in the research process; Markus Höhne and Pekka Virtanen of Dispeace for their technical support in terms of research formulation and editing; Emily Houston of Tufts University for proofreading the first draft and the external reviewers, Prof. I.M. Lewis and Dr. Mark Bradbury for their detailed and helpful comments and suggestions on an earlier draft of this paper. DIASPEACE Working Papers are published by the research project Diasporas for Peace: Patterns, Trends and Potential of Long-distance Diaspora Involvement in Conflict Settings. Case Studies from the Horn of Africa (DIASPEACE), which is a three-year research project funded by the European Commission under the 7th Framework Programme. The project seeks to generate policy-relevant, evidence-based knowledge on how exiled populations from conflict regions play into the dynamics of conflict and peace in their countries of origin. It has an empirical focus on diaspora networks operating in Europe, which extend their transnational activities to the Horn of Africa. The project is coordinated by the University of Jyväskylä involving six partners from Europe and two from the Horn of Africa and will conduct field research in both Europe and Africa. All published papers have been refereed by at least two experts in the field. WEB: www.diaspeace.org ISSN: 1798-1689 ISBN: 978-951-39-4009-6 2 Contents 1.
    [Show full text]
  • REPORT on the Right to Freedom of Expression: Striving to Widen Democratic Space in Somalia’S Political Transition
    REPORT ON THE RIGHT to FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION: Striving to Widen Democratic Space in Somalia’s Political Transition Somalia August 2016 Mandate This report was prepared by the Human Rights and Protection Group of the United Nations Mission in Somalia (UNSOM) and covers the period from 2012 to August 2016. The UNSOM Human Rights and Protection Group prepared this report pursuant to UNSOM’s mandate under United Nations Security Council resolution 2102 (2013) which requires UNSOM “to monitor, help investigate and report to the Council on, and help prevent any abuses or violations of human rights or violations of international humanitarian law committed in Somalia”. This report received technical input from the Office of High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR). REPORT ON THE RIGHT to FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION: Striving to Widen Democratic Space in Somalia’s Political Transition Somalia August 2016 STRIVING TO WIDEN DEMOCRATIC SPACE IN SOMALIA’S POLITICAL TRANSITION i Design and Layout: Jennifer Odallo Printing: UNON Publishing Services Section – ISO 14001:2004-certified Job No.: 16-07535/200 Copies/jao ii THE RIGHT TO FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION Table of Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1 INTRODUCTION 2 I. INTERNATIONAL AND NATIONAL LEGAL FRAMEWORKS ON THE RIGHT TO FREEDOM OF OPINION AND EXPRESSION 4 1. International Human Rights Law 4 2. National Law 6 • The Federal Media Law 7 • The Penal Code 8 • The Counter-Terrorism Bill 9 II. FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION AND THE POLITICAL PROCESS 10 1. The Constitutional Review Process 10 2. The State Formation Process 11 3. The Electoral Process 12 • Women’s Political Participation 14 • Political Assembly and Demonstrations 15 III.
    [Show full text]
  • Kenyan Somali Islamist Radicalisation
    Policy Briefing Africa Briefing N°85 Nairobi/Brussels, 25 January 2012 Kenyan Somali Islamist Radicalisation tant government positions. The coalition government has I. OVERVIEW created a ministry to spearhead development in the region. A modest affirmative action policy is opening opportuni- Somalia’s growing Islamist radicalism is spilling over in- ties in higher education and state employment. To most to Kenya. The militant Al-Shabaab movement has built a Somalis this is improvement, if halting, over past neglect. cross-border presence and a clandestine support network But the deployment of troops to Somalia may jeopardise among Muslim populations in the north east and Nairobi much of this modest progress. Al-Shabaab or sympathisers and on the coast, and is trying to radicalise and recruit have launched small but deadly attacks against government youth from these communities, often capitalising on long- and civilian targets in the province; there is credible fear a standing grievances against the central state. This prob- larger terror attack may be tried elsewhere to undermine lem could grow more severe with the October 2011 deci- Kenyan resolve and trigger a security crackdown that could sion by the Kenyan government to intervene directly in drive more Somalis, and perhaps other Muslims, into the Somalia. Radicalisation is a grave threat to Kenya’s securi- movement’s arms. Accordingly, the government should: ty and stability. Formulating and executing sound counter- radicalisation and de-radicalisation policies before it is too recognise that a blanket or draconian crackdown on late must be a priority. It would be a profound mistake, Kenyan Somalis, or Kenyan Muslims in general, would however, to view the challenge solely through a counter- radicalise more individuals and add to the threat of terrorism lens.
    [Show full text]
  • Somaliland on the International Stage
    Received by NSD/FARA Registration Unit 04/06/2020 5:48:58 PM Somaliland Update / April 2020 Somaliland on the International Stage * % l w / r * Somaliland responds to COVID-19 President Muse Bihi Abdi recently appointed an inter-ministerial taskforce to coordinate Somaliland’s response to the Coronavirus outbreak, t pon launching the taskforce, President Bihi said, ”1 urge all Somalilanders to strictly adhere to all guidelines issued by the government," through the National Coronavirus Prophylactic Committee. Minister of Health Cumar Cahdillaahi Bedey, Information and Culture Minister Saleebaan Ali Koore, Interior Minister Mohamed Kahin Ahmed and Minister of Religion Khalil Ahdillahi are working together on the Committee to implement all necessary preventative measures. Some of these guidelines include school closures, restrictions on public gatherings and non-emergency travel bans for certain countries. The first two cases of COVID-19 in Somaliland were confirmed on March 3i. Read more. President Bihi meets with counterparts on sidelines of African Union Summit Received by NSD/FARA Registration Unit 04/06/2020 5:48:58 PM Received by NSD/FARA Registration Unit 04/06/2020 5:48:58 PM President Bihi traveled to Addis Ababa for four days in February to engage in meetings regarding diplomatic and trade matters with African leaders attending the African 1 nion (Al summit. President Bihi met with llie new A1 chairperson, South African President Cyril Ramaphosa and Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed of Ethiopia as part of bis broader efforts to encourage regional support for Somaliland's recognition by I be international community. Bead more. > ■ % Political leaders call for finance institutions to address Somaliland and Somalia separately In March, President Bihi and the chairmen of Somaliland's l Cl Hand \\ addani opposition parties together urged the \\ orld Bank and other international financial institutions to address debt relief, new projects and loans to Somaliland in addition to its programs in Somalia.
    [Show full text]
  • An Ecological Assessment of the Coastal Plains of North Western Somalia (Somaliland)
    IUCN Eastern Africa Programme Somali Natural Resources Management Programme An Ecological Assessment of the Coastal Plains of North Western Somalia (Somaliland) Malte Sommerlatte and Abdi Umar May 2000 IUCN Eastern Africa Programme Somali Natural Resources Management Programme An Ecological Assessment of the Coastal Plains of North Western Somalia (Somaliland) By: Malte Sommerlatte and Abdi Umar IUCN CONSULTANTS May 2000 Table of Contents SUMMARY....................................................................................................................................... i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ................................................................................................................ iii 1. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 OBJECTIVES OF ASSESSMENT ............................................................................................. 1 1.2 A REVIEW OF PREVIOUS STUDIES ...................................................................................... 1 1.3 SOCIAL STRUCTURES OF THE SOMALILAND COASTAL PLAINS PASTORALISTS ............... 3 1.4 LOCAL REGULATIONS CONTROLLING LAND USE AND NATURAL RESOURCES .............. 4 1.5 THE PRESENT POLITICAL SITUATION IN SOMALILAND..................................................... 6 2. SURVEY METHODS.................................................................................................................... 7 2.1. VEGETATION TRANSECTS..................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Tracking Conflict Worldwide
    8/4/2020 CrisisWatch Print | Crisis Group CRISISWATCH Tracking Conflict Worldwide CrisisWatch is our global conict tracker, a tool designed to help decision- makers prevent deadly violence by keeping them up-to-date with developments in over 80 conicts and crises, identifying trends and alerting them to risks of escalation and opportunities to advance peace. Learn more about CrisisWatch July 2020 Global Overview JULY 2020 Trends for Last Month July 2020 Outlook for This Month Deteriorated Situations August 2020 Mali, Democratic Republic of Congo, Conflict Risk Alerts Ethiopia, South Sudan, Sudan, Mozambique, Zimbabwe, Nigeria, Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict, Yemen, Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict, Iraq, Libya Tunisia Resolution Opportunities Improved Situations Afghanistan None https://www.crisisgroup.org/crisiswatch/print?t=Crisiswatch+July+2020&crisiswatch=14628&date=July+2020 1/51 8/4/2020 CrisisWatch Print | Crisis Group The latest edition of Crisis Group’s monthly conict tracker highlights deteriorations in July in 11 countries and conict situations, the overwhelming majority of them in Africa. In Ethiopia, the killing of popular Oromo singer Hachalu Hundessa sparked a wave of protests, which left over 200 dead. In Sudan, the government struggled to advance the transitional agenda amid continuing delays in nalising a peace accord with rebel groups and escalating deadly violence in Darfur. In South Sudan, intercommunal violence surged in the east, while the partnership between President Salva Kiir and VP Riek Machar suffered setbacks. In Mali, clashes between anti-government protesters and security forces in the capital Bamako killed at least 14 people. Looking ahead to August, CrisisWatch warns of three conict risks. In Libya, Egypt took preparatory steps toward a direct military intervention, which could escalate the war dramatically, while heavy clashes in Yemen’s north between the government and the Huthis could intensify.
    [Show full text]
  • Political Settlement in Somaliland: a Gendered Perspective
    The Bartlett Development Planning Unit Political Settlement in Somaliland: A gendered perspective Michael Walls, Marie-Luise Schueller and Amina-Bahja Ekman with Amina-Milgo Mohamoud Warsame, Suad Ibrahim Abdi, Kinzi Hussein Kowden, Haroon Ahmed Yusuf and Omer Eid Qalonbi March 2017 dpu Development Planning Unit Political Settlement in Somaliland: A gendered perspective By Michael Walls, Marie-Luise Schueller and Amina-Bahja Ekman with Amina-Milgo Mohamoud Warsame, Suad Ibrahim Abdi, Kinzi Hussein Kowden, Haroon Ahmed Yusuf and Omer Eid Qalonbi UCL Ethical Approval Project ID: 8171/001 Cover photo: © Kate Stanworth, Hargeysa, 2016 Financial support from ESRC and DFID is gratefully acknowledged. The views expressed in this report are those of the authors and not necessarily those of ESRC or DFID. Political Settlement in Somaliland: A gendered perspective Michael Walls, Marie-Luise Schueller and Amina-Bahja Ekman with Amina-Milgo Mohamoud Warsame, Suad Ibrahim Abdi, Kinzi Hussein Kowden, Haroon Ahmed Yusuf and Omer Eid Qalonbi March 2017 dpu Development Planning Unit 2 Political Settlement in Somaliland: A gendered perspective About the authors Michael Walls is a Senior Lecturer at University College London’s (UCL) Bartlett Development Planning Unit (DPU) and, for the past thirteen years, his research has focused on the political economy of the Somali Horn of Africa, including the evolving political settlement in Somaliland. He was part of the coordination team for international election observations to Somaliland elections in 2005, 2010 and 2012, as well as for the 2016/17 voter registration process. Marie-Luise Schueller is the Policy and Campaigns Manager at Progressio where she works on issues of gender and governance concerning Southern Africa and the Horn of Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • A Week in the Horn 19.1.2018 News in Brief President Dr. Mulatu
    A Week in the Horn 19.1.2018 News in brief President Dr. Mulatu Teshome’s State Visit to Cuba The Sixth High-level Ethiopian-Egyptian Joint Ministerial Commission meets in Cairo Foreign Minister Dr. Workneh’s visit to Khartoum The 30th African Union Summit starts next week IGAD Revitalization to continue despite concern over at ceasefire violations Al-Shabaab continues to recruit 8-year-old children as fighters… …and the President of Somaliland in Ethiopia for a three-day working visit A UN Security Council briefing on Darfur News in Brief Africa and the African Union The 30th Summit of the African Union (AU) starts on Monday next week (January 22) with the opening of the Permanent Representatives’ Committee. This will be followed by the Ordinary Session of the Executive Council of Foreign Ministers on Thursday and Friday (January 25-26), and the 30th Ordinary Session of the Assembly of the Heads of State and Government of the African Union will take place on Sunday and Monday (January 28-29). The theme of this year’s Summit is: “Winning the Fight against Corruption: A Sustainable Path to Africa’s Transformation”. (See article) Ambassadors and Representatives of Member States of IGAD held an informal consultation meeting on Thursday (January 18) at the Ethiopian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Chaired by Ethiopia’s State Minister for Foreign Affairs, Mrs. Hirut Zemene, the emphasized disappointment at violations of the Ceasefire Agreement, but underlined the next phase of the Revitalization Process, covering power sharing and transitional security arrangement would continue at the beginning of February.
    [Show full text]
  • Assessing the 2017 Somaliland Presidential Election by Dr Adan
    CONTENTS Executive Summary ............................................................................................ 2 Introduction ........................................................................................................ 3 Somaliland Elections ........................................................................................... 4 Methodology ...................................................................................................... 5 November 2017 presidential election................................................................... 7 Citizens’ concerns ................................................................................................................. 7 Citizens’ expectations ........................................................................................................... 9 Election dynamics ............................................................................................... 9 NEC as a key actor ................................................................................................................. 9 Political parties: views on electoral process ....................................................................... 10 The Media ........................................................................................................................... 13 Civil society actors ............................................................................................................... 14 International election observers ........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Somaliland Opinion Survey
    International Republican Institute Survey of Somaliland Public Opinion – Baki District June 29 – July 4, 2013 Methodology • The fieldwork was conducted from June 29–July 4, 2013 by Data and Research Solutions, a survey research company located in Hargeisa, Somaliland. • Questionnaire design, sample design, analysis of the data and overall supervision of the project was performed by Bob Carpenter of Chesapeake Beach Consulting, an international opinion research and consulting firm. • The population studied was registered voters in Baki District (16+). A representative random sample was designed based on the number of individuals who cast ballots in the November 2012 local elections. • Enumeration areas within each sub-district were randomly selected from a list of established polling centers; households within each sampling point were then identified using a random walk method and a skip pattern; respondents were randomly chosen using a Kish grid. • The sample size was 496. The questionnaire was offered in Somali language only. • The total number of registered voters casting ballots in the 2012 local elections in the sample universe is equal to 17,408 (SOURCE: Somaliland National Elections Commission). The margin of error for the total sample is +/- 4.5 percent. Please note that the margin of error for subsets (i.e. clans/age/education/etc.) is significantly higher and should be treated as indicative only. • The overall response rate (defined as the number of successful interviews divided by eligible houses visited) is 86 percent. To complete
    [Show full text]
  • Somaliland 2021 Special Pre-Election Report-FINAL UPDATED
    A VOTE FOR CHANGE: Somaliland’s Two Decades Old Electoral Democracy May 2021 cademy for Peace and Development kaademiga Nabadda iyo Horumarka 1 A Vote for Change: Somaliland’s Two Decades Old Electoral Democracy Contents 1. Executive Summary ......................................................................................................... 2 2. Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 3 3. Background ...................................................................................................................... 4 4. Methodology .................................................................................................................... 5 5. Politics of Extension: Formal Rules of the Game ........................................................... 6 6. The Eastern Factor: Creating More Inclusive Politics .................................................... 9 Context .............................................................................................................................................................................. 9 Table 1: Regional Distribution of Votes in Somaliland’s elections (2002-2017). ............................. 9 Table 2: Seat Distribution between Isaaq and Non-Isaaq communities, 1960, 1998, 2005 ..... 10 What has changed now? ....................................................................................................................................... 10 7. The Elephant in the Room: Informal
    [Show full text]
  • 2020 Annual Work Plan
    Annual Work Plan 1/15/2020 2020 Ministry of Finance Development Somaliland Table of Contents Minister’s Foreword ................................................................................................................................................... 1 Director General’s Foreword ..................................................................................................................................... 2 1. Ministry’s Mandate ............................................................................................................................................ 3 1.1. Vision ........................................................................................................................................... 3 1.2. Mission ......................................................................................................................................... 3 1.3. Core Values .................................................................................................................................. 3 2. Structure of the Ministry of Finance Development ........................................................................................ 4 2.1. Admin and Finance Department ................................................................................................. 5 2.2. Human Resource Department ..................................................................................................... 6 2.3. Budget & Planning Department ...............................................................................................
    [Show full text]