Denying Genocide: “America's” Mythology of Nation, the Alamo

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Denying Genocide: “America's” Mythology of Nation, the Alamo Denying Genocide: “America’s” Mythology of Nation, The Alamo, and the Historiography of Denial by Robert Anthony Soza A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Ethnic Studies in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Patricia Penn Hilden, Chair Professor Ula Taylor Professor José David Saldívar Professor Paul Thomas Fall 2010 Denying Genocide: “America’s” Mythology of Nation, The Alamo, and the Historiography of Denial © 2010 by Robert Anthony Soza Soza 1 Abstract Denying Genocide: “America’s” Mythology of Nation, The Alamo, and the Historiography of Denial by Robert Anthony Soza Doctor of Philosophy in Ethnic Studies University of California, Berkeley Professor Patricia Penn Hilden, Chair History, the adage goes, is written by the victors. As a result, history represents the values, ideologies, and most importantly for this dissertation, the remembrances of the victorious. Their remembrances never remain ethereal or disembodied; they become the object lessons about the past for those living in the present. And these object lessons, the lessons of history, become the narratives and locations that transmit a nation’s idealized values and origin stories. It is in this confluence of remembrances, object lessons, values and origin stories that this dissertation examines in the Alamo. The Alamo represents a consummate site of memory for the United States. As a cultural narrative it persists from a mid-nineteenth century battlefield through the present day as a cinematic narrative. The Alamo is one of the historical watershed moments of the Westward expansion. However, the tales of the victors (ironically, in this case, the victors at the Alamo are the Euro- Americans who died in the battle) transmit values, lessons and stories steeped in narratives of denial. They engage in what this dissertation calls the historiography of denial. Simply, the Alamo, according to the victors, represents a shrine dedicated to personal liberty, familial security, economic development, and a furthering of the best values of humanity. The victors, however, fail to acknowledge the consequences of their victory for people of color. The victorious Texans reintroduced chattel slavery, exterminated Native America, and engaged in cultural genocide against the remaining Mexican/Chicana/o population. It is these omissions that mark the Alamo as a location where the historiography of denial permits the United States to remain invested in its own belief system that genocide did not occur at the hands of “America.” The ultimate aim of this dissertation is to demonstrate how the Alamo represents a location that both borrows from and recreates the consummately “American” historical practice of holocaust denial, a denial that stretches from the United State’s origins to the present-day. Soza i For Francis, Gladys, John, Ramona, and Pilar In memory of those who have yet to be acknowledged in the pages of “history” Soza ii Table of Contents Dedication ............................................................................................................................ i Table of Contents ................................................................................................................. ii Introduction .......................................................................................................................... iii-x Acknowledgements .............................................................................................................. xi-xiii Chapter One: The Origins of Denial: “Finding” the Empty Continent .......................................................................................................... 1-25 Chapter Two: Remember the Alamo! Forget White Supremacy! .......................................................................................................... 26-47 Chapter Three: Norming the Historiography of Denial: The Alamo’s Media “Blitz,” Part I .......................................................................................................... 48-63 Chapter Four: Norming the Historiography of Denial: The Alamo’s Media “Blitz,” Part II .......................................................................................................... 64-83 Chapter Five: Norming the Historiography of Denial: The Alamo’s Media “Blitz,” Part III .......................................................................................................... 84-101 Chapter Six: The “Right” Kind of People of Color Shall Inherit the Earth .......................................................................................................... 102-118 Chapter Seven: As American as Apple Pie: Genocide and the Art of Denial .......................................................................................................... 119-139 Chapter Eight: Toward a Strong Messianic Moment: A Historiography of Accountability .......................................................................................................... 140-161 Works Cited ......................................................................................................................... 162-175 Appendices: One .................................................................................................................. 176-179 Two ................................................................................................................. 180 Three ............................................................................................................... 181-182 Four ................................................................................................................. 183 Five ................................................................................................................. 184-185 Soza iii Introduction “Memory and consciousness are inseparable. But language is the means of memory, or, following Walter Benjamin, it is the medium of memory.” (40) —Ng ũgĩ wa Thiong’o, Something Torn and New : An African Renaissance “If intolerance of unorthodox views continues unabated, American will soon become adept in the art of self-censorship as the citizen’s of the world’s most dictatorial regimes. When Americans are intimidated into keeping dissident views to themselves, our public discourse is constricted, the First Amendment is diminished, and democracy itself is under attack.” (102) —Nancy Chang, Silencing Political Dissent : How Post -September 11 Anti -Terrorism Measures Threaten Our Civil Liberties This dissertation begins with the assumption that the national story exists to maintain both narrative and social order. This order informs the roles of its citizens, and assures the individual that s/he has a place in the on-going production of the nation. And ultimately, the national story provides a framework of meaning that aids people to discern right from wrong, patriotic from rebellious, and productive from disruptive. However, this national story, as will be discussed in detail below, is not an innocent narrative. The order that it instills precludes the realm of “disorder” and in fact, defines the “disorder,” as destructive, or in the case of the United States, “un-American.” The key values of the United States can easily be reduced and recited: life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Subsequently, those things that are “un-American” hinder the quest for these three sacred “American” values. Additionally, as individuals living within this society, there is an ongoing educational process that inculcates U.S. citizens in the right-minded nature of “America’s” core values. School text books, television commercials, political speeches, editorial pages of the newspaper, and for the purpose of this dissertation, museums represent platforms upon which the national story and its values are promulgated. “America” exists as a social contract where its citizens possess a series of inalienable rights, and this story is broadcast as “truth.” However, this narrative is also a narrative of power. David Theo Goldberg argues: The social contract tradition, far from being a realist(ic) account, then, is more aptly conceived as the prevailing modern story or narrative form, a gripping and telling myth about state origins, constitution, legitimation, and justification (Taussig 1997: 124-5). It is an account modern political theory in the European tradition has fashioned for itself as a way of coming to terms with – of accounting “magically” for – such social constitution. After all, it was fifty-five men, every one white, who were party to the agreement that fashioned the United States of America, the paradigmatic case of a contractually based state if ever there was one. The constitutional contract was fashioned between thirteen states at the time, the additional thirty-seven added over roughly a century and half through seizure, Soza iv conquest, expansion, wheeling and dealing more often than not to the detriment and exclusion of those who already lived in those spaces that became states. (Racial 38-39) It is the power behind the “magic” that elevates the narrative of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness over the “seizure, conquest, expansion, [and] wheeling and dealing” resulting in the destruction, displacement, and deaths of the peoples, who were almost always people of color, living on the land that would become the United States. The colonial growth and progress of the United States
Recommended publications
  • Cora Carleton) Papers, 1862-1958
    Texas A&M University-San Antonio Digital Commons @ Texas A&M University-San Antonio Finding Aids: Guides to the Collection Archives & Special Collections 2020 Glassford (Cora Carleton) Papers, 1862-1958 DRT Collection at Texas A&M University-San Antonio Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.tamusa.edu/findingaids Cora Carleton Glassford Papers, 1862-1958 Descriptive Summary Creator: Glassford, Cora Carleton (1886-1958) Title: Cora Carleton Glassford Papers Dates: 1862-1958 Creator Cora Carleton Glassford was active in a number of organizations, Abstract: including the Daughters of the Republic of Texas, and devoted her time to writing fiction, historical articles, and biographical works, much of it based on personal experience. Content Consisting of manuscripts, research material, and some personal Abstract: material, the Cora Carleton Glassford papers reflect a lifelong interest in history and family. Identification: Col 892 Extent: 17 document boxes, 2 oversize boxes Language: Materials are in English Repository: DRT Collection at Texas A&M University-San Antonio Biographical Note Born on the campus of Texas A&M College in 1886, Cora Arthur Carleton was the first child of career Army officer Guy Carleton and his wife Cora. Accompanying her family to most of the postings of her father's military career, she spent her childhood in Arizona, New Mexico, Minnesota, Kansas, Texas, the Philippines and China. Her military association would continue in adulthood, when she met and married another Army officer, Pelham Davis Glassford (1883-1959) while at Fort Riley, Kansas. Her travels also continued as she accompanied her husband to assignments at the U.S. Military Academy, Hawaii, Texas, Kansas and Washington, D.C.
    [Show full text]
  • The Roots of Middle-Earth: William Morris's Influence Upon J. R. R. Tolkien
    University of Tennessee, Knoxville TRACE: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange Doctoral Dissertations Graduate School 12-2007 The Roots of Middle-Earth: William Morris's Influence upon J. R. R. Tolkien Kelvin Lee Massey University of Tennessee - Knoxville Follow this and additional works at: https://trace.tennessee.edu/utk_graddiss Part of the Literature in English, British Isles Commons Recommended Citation Massey, Kelvin Lee, "The Roots of Middle-Earth: William Morris's Influence upon J. R. R. olkien.T " PhD diss., University of Tennessee, 2007. https://trace.tennessee.edu/utk_graddiss/238 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at TRACE: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange. It has been accepted for inclusion in Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized administrator of TRACE: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange. For more information, please contact [email protected]. To the Graduate Council: I am submitting herewith a dissertation written by Kelvin Lee Massey entitled "The Roots of Middle-Earth: William Morris's Influence upon J. R. R. olkien.T " I have examined the final electronic copy of this dissertation for form and content and recommend that it be accepted in partial fulfillment of the equirr ements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, with a major in English. David F. Goslee, Major Professor We have read this dissertation and recommend its acceptance: Thomas Heffernan, Michael Lofaro, Robert Bast Accepted for the Council: Carolyn R. Hodges Vice Provost and Dean of the Graduate School (Original signatures are on file with official studentecor r ds.) To the Graduate Council: I am submitting herewith a dissertation written by Kelvin Lee Massey entitled “The Roots of Middle-earth: William Morris’s Influence upon J.
    [Show full text]
  • The Life of Harriet Beecher Stowe
    The Life of Harriet Beecher Stowe Charles Edward Stowe The Life of Harriet Beecher Stowe Table of Contents The Life of Harriet Beecher Stowe..........................................................................................................................1 Charles Edward Stowe...................................................................................................................................1 INTRODUCTORY STATEMENT...............................................................................................................2 CHAPTER I. CHILDHOOD, 1811−1824.....................................................................................................2 CHAPTER II. SCHOOL DAYS IN HARTFORD, 1824−1832..................................................................10 CHAPTER III. CINCINNATI, 1832−1836.................................................................................................21 CHAPTER IV. EARLY MARRIED LIFE, 1836−1840..............................................................................30 CHAPTER V. POVERTY AND SICKNESS, 1840−1850.........................................................................39 CHAPTER VI. REMOVAL TO BRUNSWICK, 1850−1852.....................................................................49 CHAPTER VII. UNCLE TOM'S CABIN, 1852.........................................................................................60 CHAPTER VIII. FIRST TRIP TO EUROPE, 1853....................................................................................69 CHAPTER IX. SUNNY
    [Show full text]
  • Galveston, Texas
    Galveston, Texas 1 TENTATIVE ITINERARY Participants may arrive at beach house as early as 8am Beach geology, history, and seawall discussions/walkabout Drive to Galveston Island State Park, Pier 21 and Strand, Apffel Park, and Seawolf Park Participants choice! Check-out of beach house by 11am Activities may continue after check-out 2 GEOLOGIC POINTS OF INTEREST Barrier island formation, shoreface, swash zone, beach face, wrack line, berm, sand dunes, seawall construction and history, sand composition, longshore current and littoral drift, wavelengths and rip currents, jetty construction, Town Mountain Granite geology Beach foreshore, backshore, dunes, lagoon and tidal flats, back bay, salt marsh wetlands, prairie, coves and bayous, Pelican Island, USS Cavalla and USS Stewart, oil and gas drilling and production exhibits, 1877 tall ship ELISSA Bishop’s Palace, historic homes, Pleasure Pier, Tremont Hotel, Galveston Railroad Museum, Galveston’s Own Farmers Market, ArtWalk 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS • Barrier Island System Maps • Jetty/Breakwater • Formation of Galveston Island • Riprap • Barrier Island Diagrams • Town Mountain Granite (Galveston) • Coastal Dunes • Source of Beach and River Sands • Lower Shoreface • Sand Management • Middle Shoreface • Upper Shoreface • Foreshore • Prairie • Backshore • Salt Marsh Wetlands • Dunes • Lagoon and Tidal Flats • Pelican Island • Seawolf Park • Swash Zone • USS Stewart (DE-238) • Beach Face • USS Cavalla (SS-244) • Wrack Line • Berm • Longshore Current • 1877 Tall Ship ELISSA • Littoral Zone • Overview
    [Show full text]
  • Frontier Culture: the Roots and Persistence of “Rugged Individualism” in the United States Samuel Bazzi, Martin Fiszbein, and Mesay Gebresilasse NBER Working Paper No
    Frontier Culture: The Roots and Persistence of “Rugged Individualism” in the United States Samuel Bazzi, Martin Fiszbein, and Mesay Gebresilasse NBER Working Paper No. 23997 November 2017, Revised August 2020 JEL No. D72,H2,N31,N91,P16 ABSTRACT The presence of a westward-moving frontier of settlement shaped early U.S. history. In 1893, the historian Frederick Jackson Turner famously argued that the American frontier fostered individualism. We investigate the Frontier Thesis and identify its long-run implications for culture and politics. We track the frontier throughout the 1790–1890 period and construct a novel, county-level measure of total frontier experience (TFE). Historically, frontier locations had distinctive demographics and greater individualism. Long after the closing of the frontier, counties with greater TFE exhibit more pervasive individualism and opposition to redistribution. This pattern cuts across known divides in the U.S., including urban–rural and north–south. We provide evidence on the roots of frontier culture, identifying both selective migration and a causal effect of frontier exposure on individualism. Overall, our findings shed new light on the frontier’s persistent legacy of rugged individualism. Samuel Bazzi Mesay Gebresilasse Department of Economics Amherst College Boston University 301 Converse Hall 270 Bay State Road Amherst, MA 01002 Boston, MA 02215 [email protected] and CEPR and also NBER [email protected] Martin Fiszbein Department of Economics Boston University 270 Bay State Road Boston, MA 02215 and NBER [email protected] Frontier Culture: The Roots and Persistence of “Rugged Individualism” in the United States∗ Samuel Bazziy Martin Fiszbeinz Mesay Gebresilassex Boston University Boston University Amherst College NBER and CEPR and NBER July 2020 Abstract The presence of a westward-moving frontier of settlement shaped early U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • {PDF} Godless Kindle
    GODLESS PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Pete Hautman | 198 pages | 01 Nov 2005 | SIMON & SCHUSTER | 9781416908166 | English | New York, NY, United States Godless PDF Book It fully launched my interest in westerns … Expand. Bill goes off in search of Frank, leaving his deputy Whitey Winn in charge of Roy. Lila 1 episode, Jake Dashnaw Share this page:. Ben Broome 1 episode, John C. Season 1 Review: Godless represents a near-perfect melding of both forms [movie and TV series], making good on the boundless promises of the streaming frontier. Olagrande Townsman uncredited 1 episode, June Hobbs 3 episodes, The awkward case of 'his or her'. Melissa Chambers. Chief Narrienta 2 episodes, It was the evil in Griffin that made it so. Grigg ensures Frank stays in the know. Pastor Moore 1 episode, Tabatha Shaun Or something like that. Name that government! More From Metacritic. Watch Now. Current series template Original ended series onwards Continuation series template Specials template Upcoming series template. Hank Stuever Nov 22, Victim uncredited 1 episode, Scott Frank did a fantastic job here; the story is very intriguing and one of the best character building in recent westerns. Get Word of the Day daily email! Emily Green. When an injured outlaw shows up at her ranch, a headstrong widow sees that her life -- and the lives of those close to her -- will never be the same. March 1, To be fair, it is also gorgeous to look at; despite of few cringe worthy images, lately it looks like, these artists are working aplenty in details, just for the authenticity.
    [Show full text]
  • Resurrection in Daniel 12 and Its Contribution to the Theology of the Book of Daniel
    Andrews University Digital Commons @ Andrews University Dissertations Graduate Research 1996 Resurrection in Daniel 12 and its Contribution to the Theology of the Book of Daniel Artur A. Stele Andrews University Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.andrews.edu/dissertations Part of the Biblical Studies Commons, and the Religious Thought, Theology and Philosophy of Religion Commons Recommended Citation Stele, Artur A., "Resurrection in Daniel 12 and its Contribution to the Theology of the Book of Daniel" (1996). Dissertations. 148. https://digitalcommons.andrews.edu/dissertations/148 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate Research at Digital Commons @ Andrews University. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Andrews University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Thank you for your interest in the Andrews University Digital Library of Dissertations and Theses. Please honor the copyright of this document by not duplicating or distributing additional copies in any form without the author’s express written permission. Thanks for your cooperation. INFORMATION TO USERS This manuscript has been reproduced from the microfilm master. UMI films the text directly from the original or copy submitted. Thus, some thesis and dissertation copies are in typewriter face, while others may be from any type of computer printer. The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. Broken or indistinct print, colored or poor quality illustrations and photographs, print bleedthrough, substandard margins, and improper alignment can adversely affect reproduction. In the unlikely event that the author did not send UMI a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted.
    [Show full text]
  • Jihadism in Africa Local Causes, Regional Expansion, International Alliances
    SWP Research Paper Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik German Institute for International and Security Affairs Guido Steinberg and Annette Weber (Eds.) Jihadism in Africa Local Causes, Regional Expansion, International Alliances RP 5 June 2015 Berlin All rights reserved. © Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik, 2015 SWP Research Papers are peer reviewed by senior researchers and the execu- tive board of the Institute. They express exclusively the personal views of the authors. SWP Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik German Institute for International and Security Affairs Ludwigkirchplatz 3­4 10719 Berlin Germany Phone +49 30 880 07-0 Fax +49 30 880 07-100 www.swp-berlin.org [email protected] ISSN 1863-1053 Translation by Meredith Dale (Updated English version of SWP-Studie 7/2015) Table of Contents 5 Problems and Recommendations 7 Jihadism in Africa: An Introduction Guido Steinberg and Annette Weber 13 Al-Shabaab: Youth without God Annette Weber 31 Libya: A Jihadist Growth Market Wolfram Lacher 51 Going “Glocal”: Jihadism in Algeria and Tunisia Isabelle Werenfels 69 Spreading Local Roots: AQIM and Its Offshoots in the Sahara Wolfram Lacher and Guido Steinberg 85 Boko Haram: Threat to Nigeria and Its Northern Neighbours Moritz Hütte, Guido Steinberg and Annette Weber 99 Conclusions and Recommendations Guido Steinberg and Annette Weber 103 Appendix 103 Abbreviations 104 The Authors Problems and Recommendations Jihadism in Africa: Local Causes, Regional Expansion, International Alliances The transnational terrorism of the twenty-first century feeds on local and regional conflicts, without which most terrorist groups would never have appeared in the first place. That is the case in Afghanistan and Pakistan, Syria and Iraq, as well as in North and West Africa and the Horn of Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • Movie Mirror Book
    WHO’S WHO ON THE SCREEN Edited by C h a r l e s D o n a l d F o x AND M i l t o n L. S i l v e r Published by ROSS PUBLISHING CO., I n c . NEW YORK CITY t y v 3. 67 5 5 . ? i S.06 COPYRIGHT 1920 by ROSS PUBLISHING CO., Inc New York A ll rights reserved | o fit & Vi HA -■ y.t* 2iOi5^ aiblsa TO e host of motion picture “fans” the world ovi a prince among whom is Oswald Swinney Low sley, M. D. this volume is dedicated with high appreciation of their support of the world’s most popular amusement INTRODUCTION N compiling and editing this volume the editors did so feeling that their work would answer a popular demand. I Interest in biographies of stars of the screen has al­ ways been at high pitch, so, in offering these concise his­ tories the thought aimed at by the editors was not literary achievement, but only a desire to present to the Motion Picture Enthusiast a short but interesting resume of the careers of the screen’s most popular players, rather than a detailed story. It is the editors’ earnest hope that this volume, which is a forerunner of a series of motion picture publications, meets with the approval of the Motion Picture “ Fan” to whom it is dedicated. THE EDITORS “ The Maples” Greenwich, Conn., April, 1920. whole world is scene of PARAMOUNT ! PICTURES W ho's Who on the Screcti THE WHOLE WORLD IS SCENE OF PARAMOUNT PICTURES With motion picture productions becoming more masterful each year, with such superb productions as “The Copperhead, “Male and Female, Ireasure Island” and “ On With the Dance” being offered for screen presentation, the public is awakening to a desire to know more of where these and many other of the I ara- mount Pictures are made.
    [Show full text]
  • FRIENDS of THC BOARD of DIRECTORS Name Address City State Zip Work Home Mobile Email Email Code Killis P
    FRIENDS OF THC BOARD OF DIRECTORS Name Address City State Zip Work Home Mobile Email Email Code Killis P. Almond 342 Wilkens San TX 78210 210-532-3212 512-532-3212 [email protected] Avenue Antonio Peggy Cope Bailey 3023 Chevy Houston TX 77019 713-523-4552 713-301-7846 [email protected] Chase Drive Jane Barnhill 4800 Old Brenham TX 77833 979-836-6717 [email protected] Chappell Hill Road Jan Felts Bullock 3001 Gilbert Austin TX 78703 512-499-0624 512-970-5719 [email protected] Street Diane D. Bumpas 5306 Surrey Dallas TX 75209 214-350-1582 [email protected] Circle Lareatha H. Clay 1411 Pecos Dallas TX 75204 214-914-8137 [email protected] [email protected] Street Dianne Duncan Tucker 2199 Troon Houston TX 77019 713-524-5298 713-824-6708 [email protected] Road Sarita Hixon 3412 Houston TX 77027 713-622-9024 713-805-1697 [email protected] Meadowlake Lane Lewis A. Jones 601 Clark Cove Buda TX 78610 512-312-2872 512-657-3120 [email protected] Harriet Latimer 9 Bash Place Houston TX 77027 713-526-5397 [email protected] John Mayfield 3824 Avenue F Austin TX 78751 512-322-9207 512-482-0509 512-750-6448 [email protected] Lynn McBee 3912 Miramar Dallas TX 75205 214-707-7065 [email protected] [email protected] Avenue Bonnie McKee P.O. Box 120 Saint Jo TX 76265 940-995-2349 214-803-6635 [email protected] John L. Nau P.O. Box 2743 Houston TX 77252 713-855-6330 [email protected] [email protected] Virginia S.
    [Show full text]
  • Forgiveness 52-With Refs
    Uganda’s Road to Peace May Run through the River of Forgiveness: Designing Playable Fictions 1 to Teach Complex Values Sasha Barab, Indiana University, USA Tyler Dodge, Indiana University, USA Edward Gentry, Indiana University, USA Asmalina Saleh, Indiana University, USA Patrick Pettyjohn, Indiana University, USA ABSTRACT While gaming technologies are typically leveraged for entertainment purposes, our experience and aspiration is to use them to encourage engagement with global, politically-sensitive issues. This chapter focuses on our game design concerning the struggle of Uganda, a design that allows players to experience the atrocities and inhumane conditions and, by illuminating such values as peace and justice, helps them more generally to appreciate the moral complexity of a humane intervention. Rather than theoretical constructs to be debated in the abstract, the ethical struggles involved in determining a humane intervention in the game setting are grounded in different Non-Player Characters’ perspectives and operationalized within the underlying game dynamics. Beyond reporting on the designed game, the chapter draws the reader into the struggles of designing such an ethically contentious game. KEYWORDS curricula, design, designer, ethics, fiction, game, identity, immersion, interactivity, learning, play, player, role, story, storyline, values, videogame 1- To appear in K. Schrier & D. Gibson (ed.) Ethics and game design: Teaching values through play (Vol. II). IGI Global, Hershey, PA. INTRODUCTION One of the most persistent problems of this period is how to reconcile conflicting goals in the aftermath of severe criminality…. The regime responsible for crimes against humanity or genocidal behaviors [remains] as part of a bargain by which its impunity was “purchased” in exchange for its voluntarily relinquishment of power (Falk, 2000, pp.
    [Show full text]
  • 01A-Front Page
    July 2005 Volume 36, Issue 3 Court Rules: Historic Designation of Coronado Belt Line Unlawfully Set Aside by City Council SUSAN BRANDT HAWLEY The San Diego Historical Resources Board has declared after careful review that the portion of the Coronado Belt Line railway located in San Diego is a historic site. At the request of the MTDB and Councilmember Ralph Inzunza, the City Council overturned the Board’s desig- nation in 2004 against the recommendations of City staff and the City Manager, with Councilmember Donna Frye as the sole dissenting vote. Save Our Heritage Organisa- tion (SOHO) sued the City because, as City staff pointed out, there was no legal basis to overturn the historic status. (San Diego Superior Court Case GIC837743.) On July 15th, San Diego Superior Court Judge Ronald S. Prager ruled in favor of SOHO, agreeing that the City acted unlawfully and granting a peremptory writ requir- ing the City to set aside its action. (See ruling at www.sandiego.courts.ca.gov.) Photo/Bruce Coons The Coronado Belt Line looped around the San Diego coastline and up the Silver Strand to Coronado as part of the Spreckels railroad empire, contributing to San Diego’s growth and vitality as it linked the City with the harbor and South Bay communities. From 1888 until the mid-20th century, the Belt Line regularly transported residents, visitors, World War I and II military shipments, agricultural products, building materials, and commer- cial and industrial wares through the region. SOHO Executive Director Bruce Coons said, “This is an important precedent proving that the City Council can not arbitrarily overturn historic designations just because they want to approve some ill-advised development scheme.
    [Show full text]