PINK BOOK 3 Sebacic Acid/Dicarboxylic Acids CIR EXPERT PANEL MEETING AUGUST 30-31, 2010
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PINK BOOK 3 Sebacic Acid/Dicarboxylic Acids CIR EXPERT PANEL MEETING AUGUST 30-31, 2010 Memorandum To: CIR Expert Panel Members and Liaisons From: Monice M. Fiume MMF Senior Scientific Analyst/Writer Bart A. Heldreth, Ph.D. BAH Chemist Date: July 30, 2010 Subject: Draft Report on Dicarboxylic Acids (previously called Diisopropyl Sebacate) The draft report on dicarboxylic acids was last reviewed in December 2009, under the title Diisopropyl Sebacate. At that time, the report was tabled for reorganization. Also at that time, it was determined that oxalic acid would not be part of the safety assessment. The entire report has been reorganized and rewritten. It will be obvious that the Chemistry section is now prepared in a way that allows you to view the dicarboxylic acids in order of increasing chain length. Also included are charts demonstrating the relationship between molecular weight and the log octanol – water partitioning coefficient. Additionally, the report, from the General Biology section on, is now divided into two sections, as was suggested by the Panel in December. The first section addresses dicarboxylic acids and their salts, while the second part addresses esters of dicarboxylic acids. These two subsets of ingredients have different functions in cosmetics, and this will allow the Panel to view the data on each subset separately. In addition to the reorganization, the report has change greatly in the extent of data included. A complete new search of the literature has been performed, and a substantial amount of new data has been added. A great deal of the information included in this report has come from summary documents, such as HPV robust summaries, that cite unpublished sources. Whatever details were available have been included, but often the summaries were brief. Additional unpublished data received from Council, including concentration of use data, have been added. Also included are summaries of information from the 1984 Final Assessment of Dioctyl Adipate and Diisopropyl Adipate and from the 2006 Amended Final Report on the Safety Assessment of Dibutyl Adipate as Used in Cosmetics. (Dioctyl adipate is now correctly named diethylhexyl adipate.) These reports have been included for your use. The diesters have been shown to metabolize. Accordingly, data on esterase metabolites have been included as support information. For your ease in use of this data, an Appendix to the report, that CIR Panel Book Page 1 summarizes these data, immediately follows the reference section. When applicable, these data are also included in the appropriate tables. There are many aspects for discussion in this report, and we have tried to present it to you as cohesively as possible. The following are included as paper copy: 1. Final report on the Safety Assessment of Dioctyl Adipate and Diisopropyl Adipate; 2. Amended Final Report on the Safety Assessment of Dibutyl Adipate as Used in Cosmetics; 3. Updated concentration of use data – dated February 25, 2010; 4. Unpublished data on Diethylhexyl Succinate, Diisobutyl Adipate, Diisocetyl Adipate, Diisodecyl Adipate, Dioctyldodecyl Adipate, Diethylhexyl Sebacate and Diisopropyl Sebacate; submitted January 27, 2010. (One in French has not yet been translated, so is not included in text.); 5. Unpublished data on Diisostearyl Adipate, Diisocetyl Dodecanedioate, and Dioctyldodecyl Dodecanedioate; submitted January 15, 2010; and 6. Unpublished data - Physical/Chemical Properties on Dibutyl Octyl Sebacate, Dihexyldecyl Sebacate, and Dioctyldodecyl Sebacate; dated February 15, 2010 CIR Panel Book Page 2 CIR Panel Book Page 3 REPORT HISTORY: DICARBOXYLIC ACID AND THEIR SALTS AND ESTERS July 10, 2009: SLR was issued September 2009 Panel meeting Initial review of the draft report. The recommendation was made to add 5 additional dicarboxylic acids – oxalic, malonic, succinic, glutaric, and adipic – and their salts and esters December 2009 Panel meeting The report was tabled for reorganization into (1) acids and salts and (2) esters. It was also agreed that oxalic acid should be removed. It was also felt that more data should be available. August 2010 Panel meeting The report has been completely reorganized. A new search was done and the text was updated with much new data. CIR Panel Book Page 4 Sebacates Search Update June 2010 Toxline NTP HPV EU/SCCP EPA IARC OTC SIDS Sebacic Acid 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dibutyl Sebacate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dibutyloctyl Sebacate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dicapryl/Capryl Sebacate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diethyl Sebacate 0 x NR/NS 0 0 Diethylhexyl Sebacate G 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dihexyldecyl Sebacate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diisooctyl Sebacate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diisopropyl Sebacate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diisostearyl Sebacate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dioctyldodecyl Sebacate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Disodium Sebacate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Isostearyl Sebacate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Malonic Acid G 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diethyl Malonate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Succinic Acid 0 x NR/NS 0 0 Sodium Succinate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Disodium Succinate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 x Dimethyl Succinate G x NR/NS 0 0 Diethyl Succinate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diethylhexyl Succinate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Decyl Succinate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dicapryl Succinate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dicetearyl Succinate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diisobutyl Succinate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Glutaric Acid G x NR/NS 0 0 Dimethyl Glutarate G x NR/NS 0 0 Diisostearyl Glutarate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diisobutyl Glutarate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Adipic Acid G x NR/NS 0 0 x Dimethyl Adipate G x NR/NS 0 0 Diethyl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diethylhexyl Adipate C,G x NR/NS x 2 0 x Dipropyl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dibutyl Adipate 0 x NR/NS 0 0 x Di-C12-15 Alkyl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dicapryl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dicetyl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diheptylundecyl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dihexyl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dihexyldecyl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diisobutyl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diisocetyl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diisodecyl Adipate 0 x NR/NS x 0 0 Diisononyl Adipate 0 x NR/NS x 0 0 Diisooctyl Adipate 0 x NR/NS x 0 0 Diisopropyl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Diisostearyl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dioctyldodecyl Adipate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Ditridecyl Adipate 0 x NR/NS x 0 0 Azelaic Acid 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dipotassium Azelate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Disodium Azelate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dodecanedioic Acid 0 x NR/NS 0 0 x Diisocetyl Dodecanedioate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Dioctyldodecyl Dodecanedioate 0 0 NR/NS 0 0 Totals 2744 CIR Panel Book Page 5 Toxline - searched 6-10-10; included Medline NTP - searched 6-20-10; G - genotoxicity, C - carcinogenicity HPV - searched 6-20&21-10; x - listed in HPV database EU - searched 6-20-10; NR - no restrictions; NS - no SCCP opinion IARC - searched 6-21-10 OTC - searched 6-22-10 (April 7, 2010 update) EPA - searched 7-8-10 found updated Robust Summaries for HPV items TOXNET Search Strategy: Sebacic 06-11-10 306 hits 111-20-6 OR 184706-97-6 OR 109-43-3 OR 110-40-7 OR 122-62-3 OR 359073-59-9 OR 10340-41-7 OR 7491-02- 3 OR 69275-01-0 OR 17265-14-4 OR 478273-24-4 OR (DICAPRYL AND CAPRYL AND SEBACATE) OR (DIISOSTEARYL AND SEBACATE) Malonic-Succinic-Glutaric 06-10-10 2511 hits 141-82-2 OR 105-53-3 OR 110-15-6 OR 2922-54-5 OR 150-90-3 OR 106-65-0 OR 123-25-1 OR 2915-57-3 OR 2530-33-8 OR 14491-66-8 OR 93280-98-9 OR 925-06-4 OR 110-94-1 OR 1119-40-0 OR 71195-64-7 OR (DIISOSTEARYL AND GLUTARATE) Adipic 06-10-10 1167 hits 124-04-9 OR 627-93-0 OR 141-28-6 OR 103-23-1 OR 106-19-4 OR 105-99-7 OR 105-97-5 OR 26720-21-8 OR 155613-91-5 OR 110-33-8 OR 141-04-8 OR 57533-90-1 OR 58262-41-2 OR 59686-69-0 OR 27178-16-1 OR 33703-08-1 OR 108-63-4 OR 6938-94-9 OR 62479-36-1 OR 155613-91-5 OR 85117-94-8 OR 16958-92-2 OR (ALKYL AND ADIPATE) OR (DIHEXYLDECYL AND ADIPATE) Azelaic-Dodecanedioic 06-10-10 208 hits 123-99-9 OR 9619-43-3 OR 52457-54-2 OR 17265-13-3 OR 27825-99-6 OR 132499-85-5 OR 693-23-2 OR 131252-83-0 OR 129423-55-8 Combined files minus existing references – 2744 June 21, 2010 – 47 published papers ordered July 8, 2010 - 20 additional papers ordered July 15, 2010 – 10 additional papers ordered *Metabolite alcohols and monoesters were searched for supplemental information in TOXLINE and RTECS, via STN. CAS Registry files were used to search in each of the databases. 55 published papers were ordered. Numerous other references on metabolite alcohols were available from prior safety assessments. CIR Panel Book Page 6 Transcripts/ Minutes PANEL - DEC 2009 CIR Meeting day 2 Page: 40 CIR Meeting day 2 Page: 41 1 isononanoates and all that -- those parts. And, 1 the aim of splitting the acids and salts into one 2 hopefully, we can have our -- you know, at the 2 group -- they are used as pH adjusters -- and then 3 next meeting, have a good discussion on whether 3 the esters into another group, rather than having 4 these are long shots or not, in other words, if 4 them all mixed in as is in the present document.