2002 THE MICHIGAN BOTANIST 19

POA BULBOSA L. SSP. BULBOSA () IN

Allison W. Cusick and Michael A. Vincent Museum of Biological Diversity W.S. Turrell Herbarium The Ohio State University Department of Botany 1315 Kinnear Rd Miami University Columbus, OH 43212 Oxford, OH 45056 [email protected] 513-529-2755 [email protected]

The Eurasian bulbosa L. (bulbous bluegrass, Poaceae) is unique among North American grasses in its combination of tufted culms with bulbous bases and florets proliferating into bulbils (subspecies vivipara (Koeler) Arcangeli). Poa bulbosa grows in a variety of open, anthropogenic habitats, such as weedy fields, freshly-disturbed earth, campgrounds, and roadsides. This species is es- pecially common in the western United States, but is widespread in the north- eastern U.S. as well. The first published report of bulbous bluegrass in North America was by Piper (1924), from Virginia and Washington state. The species was being grown by the USDA as early as 1907 (both subspecies bulbosa and subspecies vivipara), and was known as a weedy species as early as 1915 (Schoth & Halperin 1932; Vinall & Westover 1928). Bulbous bluegrass is some- times cultivated as a turf grass (Diesburg et al. 1997; Mangess et al. 1971), though it may go dormant in hot, dry periods (Ofir & Kerem 1982; Ofir 1986; Ofir & Kigel 1999). Oldham et al. (1995) provide a summary of the North Amer- ican distribution of P. bulbosa ssp. vivipara. Novak & Welfley (1997) examined the genetic diversity of Poa bulbosa populations in the northwestern United States, and concluded that the high rate of diverse genotypes may be due to mul- tiple introductions of the species, or due to sexual reproduction. Kartesz & Meacham (1999) map bulbous bluegrass as occurring in 43 of the lower 48 states in the United States, and in 3 Canadian provinces. The nomenclaturally typical subspecies of Poa bulbosa has perfect flowers, rather than having the florets proliferating into bulbils. This typical variant has apparently been reported outside cultivation from North America only by one author (Halperin 1931), who reported subspecies bulbosa from California. It does not appear that the presence of subspecies bulbosa has been recognized as occurring in North America by any subsequent author. In the grass treatments by Weishaupt in Braun (1967) and by Weishaupt (1985), it is clear from the context that the scant references to Poa bulbosa in Ohio were entirely to Poa bulbosa subspecies vivipara, even though the subspecific nomenclature was not used in either work. We have discovered that Poa bulbosa ssp. bulbosa not only grows in Indiana and Ohio, but is quite common in a specific habitat in those states. We were col- lecting at the Butler County fairgrounds in the city of Hamilton, Ohio, 29 April 20 THE MICHIGAN BOTANIST Vol. 41

FIGURE 1. Distribution of Poa bulbosa L. in Indiana and Ohio. Solid dots represent ssp. bulbosa. Open circles represent ssp. vivipara (distribution in the four northwestern Indiana coun- ties follows Swink & Wilhelm [1994]).

1998, when we noted numerous clumps of a Poa with bulbous bases and perfect flowers. Later that same day, we found the same at the Darke County fair- grounds in Greenville, Ohio. Our collections were determined as Poa bulbosa ssp. bulbosa by Dr. Robert Soreng at the Smithsonian Institution. We broadened our survey to other counties of Indiana and Ohio. Eventually, we had found the typical subspecies in four Indiana and 13 Ohio counties. All these collections were made in agricultural fairgrounds, most often at the race- tracks on those sites. A search of fairgrounds in adjacent counties of Kentucky, Michigan, Pennsylvania and West Virginia located no populations of the sub- species bulbosa. Many of the Indiana and Ohio populations are quite vigorous with thousands of clumps over broad stretches of land. We also searched for Poa bulbosa ssp. vivipara. We turned up numerous new county records of this subspecies in Indiana and Ohio. However, at no place did the two subspecies grow together or occur adjacent to one another. Also, we never found subspecies vivipara on a fairground. The subspecies bulbosa was re- stricted to that habitat. The results of our survey are presented in Figure 1. See Appendix A for a list of representative specimens of Poa bulbosa ssp. bulbosa from Indiana and Ohio. 2002 THE MICHIGAN BOTANIST 21

Poa bulbosa ssp. vivipara obviously is more widespread in Indiana and Ohio than the typical subspecies. It, of course, grows in many more types of habitats than ssp. bulbosa. It also has been noted in the floras of those states for a longer time than the typical subspecies. The first Ohio collection of ssp. vivipara dates from 1963 (specimen at OS). The first Indiana reports of this subspecies are post-1991 (Swink & Wilhelm 1994). Perfect flowering vs. proliferation of bulbils in Poa bulbosa has been linked to environmental factors. Kennedy (1929) describes proliferation in this species, as did Halperin (1933), who also discussed the nomenclature of the proliferous form. Younger (1960) induced proliferation of bulbils in this species by increasing air temperature and day length. This result, however, may not be typical for the strains of Poa bulbosa found in North America. Younger did not identify which subspecies of P. bulbosa he used in his studies. His experiments were conducted entirely on strains of P. bulbosa from Afghanistan. in the Indiana and Ohio populations of this species were exclusively perfect-flowered or viviparous. No change in this status was ob- served over the course of the season. Two obvious questions need to be addressed. Where did these plants of Poa bulbosa ssp.bulbosa originate and how do they spread from site to site? The question of origin is more difficult to answer. It seems unlikely that plants of this subspecies were introduced into Indiana and Ohio directly from . Dr. Soreng (pers. comm., 1998) offers the following suggestion: “It is the na- ture of subspecies, in my opinion, to occasionally reform out of the genetic mix of other subspecies. Thus, it may be that your populations have arisen from subsp. vivipara and not from introductions of Old World populations of sexually reproducing plants of P. bulbosa subsp. bulbosa.” Certainly, the uni- formity of the populations over an extensive area argues for a single source of introduction. It is much easier to account for the means by which the plants of ssp. bulbosa spread from site to site. The key here is the common factor of racetracks. Seeds, if any are produced, and loose bulbous bases may easily travel in caked earth or mud on the hooves of horses or the wheels of vehicles. Many racecourses on county fairgrounds are used for tractor-pulling competitions. The tractors are an obvious vector as they travel from fairground to fairground. The distribution and spread of Poa bulbosa ssp. bulbosa parallels that of (L.) P. Beauv. (Cusick et al. in prep.), another characteristic species of racetracks and fairgrounds. Broader surveys of suitable habitats may reveal the true geographical extent of Poa bulbosa ssp. bulbosa in North America.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank the curators at herbaria CM, IND, KE, MICH, MU, OS for access to specimens in those herbaria. Dr. Rob Soreng (US) provided the identification of our first collection of this taxon. Dr. Richard Rabeler (MICH) provided information valuable to our study. 22 THE MICHIGAN BOTANIST Vol. 41

LITERATURE CITED Cusick, A.W., R.K. Rabeler, & M.J. Oldham. (In prep.) Sclerochloa dura (L.) P.Beauv. in the Great Lakes region. Diesburg, K.J., N.E. Christians, R. Moore, B. Branham, T.K. Danneberger, Z.J. Reicher, T. Voigt, D.D. Minner, & R. Newman. 1997. Species for low-input sustainable turf in the U.S. upper mid- west. Agronomy Journal 89: 690–694. Halperin, M. 1931. The occurrence of normal (unproliferated) florets in Poa bulbosa in the United States. Journal of the American Society of Agronomy 23: 511–515. Halperin, M. 1933. The and morphology of bulbous bluegrass, Poa bulbosa vivipara. Journal of the American Society of Agronomy 25: 408–413. Kartesz, J.T., & C.A. Meacham. 1999. Synthesis of the North American Flora, Version 1.0. North Carolina Botanical Garden, Chapel Hill, NC. Kennedy, P.B. 1929. Proliferation in Poa bulbosa. Journal of the American Society of Agronomy 21: 80–91. Novak, S.J. & A.Y. Welfley. 1997. Genetic diversity in the introduced clonal grass Poa bulbosa (bul- bous bluegrass). Northwest Science 71: 271–280. Ofir, M. 1986. Seasonal changes in the response to temperature of summer-dormant Poa bulbosa L. bulbs. Annals of Botany 58: 81–89. Ofir, M. & D. Kerem. 1982. The effects of temperature and photoperiod on the onset of summer dor- mancy in Poa bulbosa L. Annals of Botany 50: 259–264. Ofir, M. & J. Kigel. 1999. Photothermal control of the imposition of summer dormancy in Poa bul- bosa, a perennial grass geophyte. Physiologia Plantarum 105: 633–640. Oldham, M., S. Darbyshire, D. Mcleod, D. Sutherland, D. Tiedjem, & J. Bowles. 1995. New and noteworthy Ontario grass (Poaceae) records. Michigan Botanist 34: 105–132. Piper, C.V. 1924. Bulbous bluegrass (Poa bulbosa L.). Torreya 24: 7–8. Schoth, H.A. & M. Halperin. 1932. The distribution and adaptation of Poa bulbosa in the United States and in foreign countries. Journal of the American Society of Agronomy 24: 786–793. Swink, F. & G. Wilhelm. 1994. Plants of the Chicago Region. 4th ed. Indiana Academy of Science, Indianapolis, IN. 921pp. Vinall, H.N. & H.L. Westover. 1928. Bulbous bluegrass, Poa bulbosa. Journal of the American So- ciety of Agronomy 20: 394–399. Younger, V. B. 1960. Environmental control of initiation of the , reproductive struc- tures, and proliferations in Poa bulbosa. American Journal of Botany 47: 753–757. Weishaupt, C. in E. Lucy Braun. 1967. The Vascular Flora of Ohio. Volume 1: The Monocotyle- doneae, Cat-Tails to Orchids. The Ohio State University Press. viii + 464 pp. Weishaupt, C. 1985. A Descriptive Key to the Grasses of Ohio Based on Vegetative Characters. Bul- letin of the Ohio Biological Survey 7(1): v + 1–99.

APPENDIX A: COLLECTIONS OF POA BULBOSA SSP. BULBOSA FROM INDIANA AND OHIO. INDIANA: Fayette Co., Fayette Co. fairgrounds, Connersville, 28 Apr 1999, M.A. Vincent 8470 & A.W. Cusick (BRY, ILLS, MO, MU, OSH); Huntington Co., Hier’s Park, Huntington, 9 May 2000, A.W. Cusick 35388 & R.K. Rabeler (MU); Jay Co., Jay Co. fairgrounds, Portland, 9 May 2000, A.W. Cusick 35403 & R.K. Rabeler (MU); Wabash Co., Wabash Co. fairgrounds, Wabash, 9 May 2000, A.W. Cusick 35393 & R.K. Rabeler (MU). OHIO: Butler Co., Butler Co. fairgrounds, Hamilton, 29 Apr 1998, M.A. Vincent 8217 & A.W. Cusick (BRY, MU, NBYC, US, WSU); Darke Co., Darke Co. fairgrounds, Greenville, 29 Apr 1998, M.A. Vincent 8230 & A.W. Cusick (MU); Fayette Co., Fayette Co. fairgrounds, 20 Apr 1999, A.W. Cusick 34790 (MU, OS); Hamilton Co., Hamilton Co. fair- grounds, Wyoming, 30 Apr 1998, A.W. Cusick 34283 (MU, OS); Highland Co., Highland Co. fair- grounds, Hillsboro, 20 Apr 1999, A.W. Cusick 34799 (MU, OS); Lake Co., Lake Co. fairgrounds, Painesville, 2 May 2000, A.W. Cusick 35350 (MU, OS); Logan Co., Logan Co. fairgrounds, Belle- fontaine, 18 May 1998, A.W. Cusick 34351 (MU, OS); Miami Co., Miami Co., fairgrounds, Troy, 14 May 1998, A.W. Cusick 34316 (MU, OS), same location, 25 Apr 2000, A.W. Cusick 35330 (MU, OS); Monroe Co., Monroe Co. fairgrounds, NE of Woodsfield, 6 May 1998, A.W. Cusick 34295 (MU, OS); Montgomery Co., Montgomery Co. fairgrounds, 25 Apr 2000, A.W. Cusick 35337 (MU, OS); 2002 THE MICHIGAN BOTANIST 23

Preble Co., Preble Co. fairgrounds, 29 Apr 1998, M.A. Vincent 8224 & A.W. Cusick (ISC, MU, US); Shelby Co., Shelby Co. fairgrounds, Sidney, 25 Apr 2000, A.W. Cusick 35324 (MU, OS); Union Co., Union Co. fairgrounds, N. of Marysville, 14 May 1998, A.W. Cusick 34327 (MU, OS), same location, 4 May 1999, A.W. Cusick 34872 & R.K. Rabeler (MU, OS), “Past-time Park,” N of Plain City, 4 May 1999, A.W. Cusick 34874 & R.K. Rabeler (MU, OS); Wyandot Co., Wyandot Co. fairgrounds, N of Upper Sandusky, 9 May 2000, A.W. Cusick 35835 (MU, OS).