THE BIOSYNTHESIS of SOME PHENOLIC ALKALOIDS a Thesis Submitted by GEOFFREY MELVILLE THOMAS for the Degree of DOCTOR of PHILOSOPH
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
/1 THE BIOSYNTHESIS OF SOME PHENOLIC ALKALOIDS a thesis submitted by GEOFFREY MELVILLE THOMAS for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY of THE UNIVERSITY OF LONDON Imperial College, June 1963. London, S. W.7. ABSTRACT A brief review of the biosynthesis of alkaloids, other than those of the Amaryllidaceae and morphine groups, is given. The biosynthesis of these two groups is discussed more fully with particular reference to the evidence for the Barton and Cohen concept of phenol oxidation as a biogenetic mechanism. The incorporation of labelled phenolic precursors, derivatives of norbelladine, has been shown and by means of multiple labelled experiments incorporation as a whole, without degradation, has been proved. Other experiments described have thrown light on the earlier stages of biogenesis. The norlaudanosine derivative, (±) reticuline, has been shown to be incorporated into morphine, and an in vitro synthesis of thebaine from (±) reticuline using a radiochemical dilution method is de-scribed. I am deeply grateful to Professor D. H. R. Barton and Dr. G. W. Kirby for the privilege and pleasure of working under their supervision and for their great help in matters chemical and non-chemical. To the Salters Company I would like to express my sincere thanks for the award of a scholarship and for their interest during the tenure of it. My thanks are also due to Dr. D. W. Turner for advice on counting techniques, Mr. D. Aldrich and his staff for valuable technical assistance, Miss J. Cuckney for microanalyses, Mr. R.H. Young who grew the daffodils and poppies and to my many friends and co-workers at Imperial College. REVIEW Alkaloid Biogenesis 1 THE AMARYLLIDACEAE ALKALOIDS Introduction 12 Early tracer experiments 16 Synthesis of precursors 21 Feeding experiments 23 Nature of the C - C unit .....34 6 1 THE MORPHINE ALKALOIDS Introduction 40 Feeding experiments 43 The configuration of morphine 52 EXPERIMENTAL Amaryllidaceae alkaloids 58 Morphine alkaloids 74 REFERENCES 83 REVIEW 31.,.r,•••• ALKALOID BIOSYNTHESIS There has been much thought and discussion about the way in which the wide variety of plant alkaloids are produced. With the advent of tracer methods in which compounds with a radioactive label have been fed to living plants, a rapidly growing amount of information on this subject is now available. 1, 2, 3 Recent authoritative reviews of this subject are now available and, for this reason, only a brief survey will be given here. One of the alkaloids from each of seven main groups has been taken, and the way in which tracer experiments have been used to investigate the mode of biogenesis, is described. Pyridine and piperidine alkaloids Nicotine Nicotine (I) the main alkaloid of many Nicotiana species, has been [2.1 extensively studied by tracer methods. 4C] Ornithine (II) was fed4' 5 to N.tabacum and N. rustica plants and found to be a good precursor for the 4 5 alkaloid. Oxidative degradation with nitric acid to nicotinic acid ' (III) 6 and the nitropyrazole (IV) showed that the label was equally divided between positions 2' and 5', NO2 CO2 H 5' 2 Me 2, These results indicated the formation of a symmetrical intermediate 7 which has been suggested by Leete to be putrescine (V) or the mesomeric anion (VI), dliO )* r* ".- H N *%••CO H 2 2 1/47" o2}1 (II) ••••••••,..3, nicotine (I) Support for this scheme came from the incorporation, albeit less efficiently than ornithine, of putrescine (V), proline and glutamic acid into the 7 pyrrolidine ring of nicotine . Experiments to investigate the derivation of the aromatic system have 14 been carried out. Although it was shown that [2 - C] lysine (VII) can serve as a precursor for the piperidine ring in the closely related alkaloid anabasine (VIII), it was found that it did not provide the aromatic system in either 3. 8 anabasine or nicotine . Nr "Z‘` H 2 z (VII) (VIII) Nicotine labelled in the pyridine ring was, however, isolated from plants fed with ring labelled nicotinic acid (III) whereas the carboxyl labelled 9 acid was not incorporated . Information about the derivation of the aromatic ring has come from 14 feeding experiments with labelled acetate. [2 - C] Acetate and 14 10 11 [2 - C] propionate have been shown to be incorporated into the pyridine 14 ring of the alkaloid whereas [1 - C] acetate provided only the pyrrolidine 14 ring, and [1 - C] propionate was not incorporated. [1, 3 - 14C] Glycerol provided nicotine with 57% of its activity in the ll aromatic nucleus . Tracer experiments have also shown that the N-methyl group of 12 13 nicotine can arise from choline or methionine and in the latter case that 14 14 a true transmethylation occurs . [Methyl- C] Nicotine has also been shown 14 to give rise to [methyl- C] choline in the plants so that methyl transfer from the alkaloid to acceptors can also occur. In the light of these results the biogenesis of nicotine may be summarised as follows. 4. CO2H Cozx Ornithine .160••••100,00 Proline Me Glutamic acid Choline Me . .,filethlonme Tropane alkaloids Hyoscyamine (IX) One relationship between the tropane alkaloids, based on the skeleton (X), and the pyrrolidine bases is shown by the incorporation into 14 15 hyoscyamine of [2 - CI ornithine , the precursor for the pyrrolidine portion of nicotine, Degradation proved the incorporation to be specific with the label inpositions 1 or 516'17 . The other three carbon atoms of the tropane system were shown, by the appropriate tracer experiments, to be 18 derivable from acetate . The biosynthesis of the tropic acid (XI) residue of the alkaloid was studied in three separate experiments in which phenylalanine (XII) labelled 19 in the 1-, 2- and 3-positions was fed to Datura stramoniurn . Hydrolysis of the alkaloids to tropic acid and subsequent simple degradations proved that phenylalanine is a direct precursor. The respective positions of the labels 5. were those indicated. H °2 C + HO 2C Ph CH 0H z 0 (XI) (IX) 14 *, o and + indicate [ C] labels from different experiments) Isoquinoline and phenethylamine alkaloids As early as 191020 before the advent of tracer experiments, it was 21 suggested that the main precursors of this large group of alkaloids are the aromatic amino acids phenylalanine (XII), tyrosine (XIII) and dihydroxy- phenylalanine, Hordenine (XV) Decarboxylation, oxidation and methylation, all well known in living systems, are all that are required to convert these amino acids into hordenine. Phenylalanine (XII), tyrosine (XIII) and tyramine (XIV)22 have all been shown to be incorporated into the alkaloid in sprouting barley. The 6, positions of the labels were as expected and the quantitative results suggest that hordenine is formed from tyramine in a stepwise methylation process. 23 24 This is supported by experiments in which methionine (XVI) and betaine (XVII) were shown to be sources of the methyl groups in the alkaloid. The biosynthesis may then be summarised thus: CO H 2 ed•-\\,,C0aH NH NH HO 2 HO 2 (XIV) (XIII) (XII) NH 2 Me CO H (XVI) z NMe HO Me V. + - (XV) 'Me N .0" CO (XVII) 3 2 CH 2 Papaverine (XVIII) 20 In 1910 it was suggested that norlaudanosoline (XIX) is formed from two moles of dihydroxyphenylalanine and it is apparent that papaverine could be derived from this by dehydrogenation of the heterocyclic system, 25 possibly by way of the N-oxide . 7. HO HO OH OMe OH OMe \OMe (XIX) (XVIII) (XX) Papaverine and laudanosine (XX) occur together in the opium poppy. 26 Battersby and Harper established the biosynthesis of papaverine from two molecules of tyrosine by feeding Papaver somniferum with 14 [2- C] tyrosine and showing equal activity in the expected positions of the alkaloid (XVIII). 27 14 In further work the same group showed that [1- C] norlaudanosoline provided papaverine specifically labelled at position 1. The relationship between the benzylisoquinoline and morphine alkaloids will be discussed in detail later. Berberine (XXI) An examination of the structure of berberine (XXI) suggests that it might also be derived from norlaudanosoline (XIX) and evidence of this came 28 from the specific incorporation of two molecules of [2-14C] tyrosine . In recent experiments in this laboratory, Mr. R. H. Hesse has isolated active berberine from Hydrastis canadensis fed with the norlaudanosoline derivative 3 (±) reticuline (XXII), labelled as shown. This also adds weight to the suggestion that the berberine bridge carbon atom (arrowed) arises from the N-methyl group but the degradation to prove this has not yet been carried out. 8. MeO /•?. - Me HO OH NO Me OMe (XXI) (XXII) Colchicine (XXIII) A complete picture of the mode of biogenesis of this alkaloid, found in the autumn crocus is not yet available. 14 [3 - C] Phenylalanine (XII) was specifically incorporated into 29 colchicine in Colchicum izirantium the label being at position 5. Me Me 0 Me0 0 (XXIII) (XII) Independently30 [2 - 14C] tyrosine was found to be incorporated into Colchicum autumnale but position 6 was virtually inactive. Half of the alkaloid activity was, however, found in the N-acetyl group. This suggests 9. that degradation of the amino acids to a C - C fragment takes place prior 6 1 to incorporation. 14 30 31 L-[methyl- C] Methionine was also found to be incorporated ' but provided only the methyl groups of the alkaloid. The origin of the tropolone part of the molecule is still unknown 14 30 31 since, although [1- C] acetate gave active colchicine, all the activity was found in the N-acetyl group. Indole alkaloids Ajmaline (XXIV) Although [2-14C] tryptophane has been shown to be the precursor of 32 the f3-carboline moiety of ajmaline , the origin of the remainder of the molecule is still not clear and has been the subject of much discussion, 33 34 Woodward and Robinson suggested derivation from dihydroxyphenyl- 35 alanine with subsequent 'Woodward' fission, Wenkert suggested derivation 36 from prephenic acid (XXV) and Thomas from a monoterpene skeleton (XXVI, numbered as would be expected in ajmaline).