ESPN.Com - NCAA - Garber: Culture Crisis in College Lacrosse 09/13/2006 03:15 PM
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ESPN.com - NCAA - Garber: Culture crisis in college lacrosse 09/13/2006 03:15 PM Member Services | FAQ [ Welcome, Geoffrey] Customize Your Teams | Help Customize your favorite teams to view personalized content INSIDER NFL | NBA | MLB | College Crasnick: List of permissible picker-uppers looks different now The amphetamine ban has prompted players to move down the spectrum to coffee and energy drinks or to seek other legal Search Download Toolbar | Shop alternatives. Neyer: Yankees' pitching is good enough NFL MLB NBA NASCAR + NHL College Golf Scouts Soccer Page 2 SportsNation Insider Fantasy 360 More + Do the Yankees have the pitching to win in October? Compared to the rest of the ESPNU | College Sports Home | TV Schedule | Rankings | Recruiting | Schools | Transactions | Message Boards | More league, yes. Crasnick: Disabled players who can help in Updated: May 25, 2006 September Some key players could come off the disabled list and give their teams a well- Lacrosse culture crisis: Play hard, party hard timed boost toward the playoffs. FANTASY By Greg Garber Fantasy Games Home ESPN.com Archive LACROSSE SCANDAL AT DUKE A year after graduating from Dartmouth College, Andrew Goldstein remains understandably proud of his accomplishments as an All-American goalie for An alleged sexual assault involving the the lacrosse team. Recently, Goldstein discovered that not everyone Duke University men's cherishes the sport as much as he does. lacrosse team has sparked controversy Goldstein, wearing a Dartmouth lacrosse T-shirt, was walking along among students, the school's administration and the Durham Fisherman's Wharf in San Francisco when a stranger approached him and community. stridently asked, "You're still willing to wear that shirt in public?" Taken aback, Goldstein said he believes that the decisions of a few do not Related Stories • Duke holds private pep-talk for represent an entire sport. athletes • Duke lacrosse returns to the field "What happened at Duke has reinforced how people view lacrosse players as • Judge to bar cameras from hearings the elite," says Goldstein, who will play Major League Lacrosse this summer • AD: School 'will be better' • Write-in campaign launched against for the Long Island Lizards. "It's completely unfair to pin all these things on prosecutor the sport." • Former Duke coach hired by Bryant • Duke player pleads guilty to DUI Yet, setting aside for a moment the charge • Duke hires Hofstra's Danowski as allegation of rape at a team lacrosse men's lax coach party just off campus in Durham, • Judge: Prosecutor has access to N.C., on March 13, critics continue to uncharged players' addresses • D.A. seeks access to uncharged suggest that the self-acknowledged players' ID cards behavior of the Duke athletes fits • Parents of Duke player say son can with the culture of lacrosse. And prove innocence • Duke player reinstated more than a dozen ESPN.com • Evans guilty of noise violation interviews with those involved in the • Police report: Duke accuser game at the college level indicate nervous, changed story • Pessah: Team life after scandal that the general party atmosphere • Recruits: Staying | Going that surrounded the Duke team is • Coach K breaks silence consistent with that generally found • Defense questions DA's comments • Duke professor calls for special in the sport. prosecutor • Second dancer calls allegations a The infamous party 10 weeks ago 'crock' spawned three arrests on charges of • Interim coach ready • Duke reinstates lacrosse team under rape, as well as allegations of racism watchful eye AP Photo/Miles Kennedy and the perception of a program out • Almost $23K spent on DNA tests of control. The Duke team that lost A year ago, Johns Hopkins beat • Sweatbands of support: Duke women show solidarity to Johns Hopkins in last year's Duke and celebrated a national lacrosse championship. • Lawyers ask for more evidence Division I championship withdrew • Judge won't fast-track trial from competition midway through the • One of team's captains indicted • Defense: DNA tests clear Duke season, and its status for next year lacrosse players remains uncertain. In the wake of the scandal, and only one year after a • Talks of accuser's credibility nine-page valentine to the sport appeared in Sports Illustrated, lacrosse -- overheard • Duke report: Police downplayed heading into the NCAA men's tournament semifinals and finals this weekend accuser in Philadelphia -- is under siege. • DA wins Democratic primary • Committee: Team can resume play, "The sport of lacrosse is taking a beating," says Dom Starsia, head coach of with monitoring the No. 1-ranked, 15-0 Virginia Cavaliers, who will meet Syracuse Saturday • Duke accuser involved in prior rape allegation in one of two national semifinals at Lincoln Financial Field. "For coaches and • Second dancer tells her story administrators, this is our absolute worst nightmare. The college game is • Alumni question Duke president on such a fragile little animal, anyway. If Duke doesn't bring the team back, I player suspensions • Scoop Jackson: Blame don't know where we're going to be." administration • Duke to keep selling lacrosse gear Says Yale University lacrosse coach Andy Shay, "That's the prevailing fear • Background on Finnerty, Seligmann among college coaches. When 99 percent of the country's first exposure to • Two Duke players indicted • Race a focal point in Durham lacrosse is this incident, well, first impressions are the most important thing. • Police: Accuser 'passed-out drunk' It's certainly not something that we're all proud of. It's not indicative of the • Whitlock: Men behaving badly culture, but it's the first thing people are pointing to." • Coach resigns, season canceled • Garber: Campus, community in turmoil In June, when the national board of U.S. Lacrosse meets in Baltimore, the issue of culture will vault to the top of the discussion agenda. As the current five-year strategic plan designed to elevate lacrosse into the mainstream -- which, arguably, has happened -- comes to a close, members will work to craft a new course of action that will reposition the sport. Before the Duke incident occurred, the organization committed $4.5 million to programs that focus on character and the sport's Native American roots. "As in any tragedy, these circumstances will certainly be a catalyst for even greater reflection on the sport's healthy development," says Steve http://proxy.espn.go.com/ncaa/columns/story?id=2456640 Page 1 of 6 ESPN.com - NCAA - Garber: Culture crisis in college lacrosse 09/13/2006 03:15 PM greater reflection on the sport's healthy development," says Steve Stenersen, U.S. Lacrosse's executive director. "I feel that the depiction of lacrosse in such a narrow way in the media as solely an elite, exclusive sport is not only inaccurate but almost irresponsible. "Without dismissing the circumstances in Durham, it's our goal to more accurately depict where the sport is today." After the story broke in Watch the NCAA championship Durham, it was reported that Saturday about one-third of Duke's men's Syracuse (10-4) vs. Virginia (15-0), 11:30 lacrosse team -- 15 players -- a.m. ET (ESPN2) had faced prior charges that UMass (12-4) vs. Maryland (12-4), 2 p.m. ET included underage alcohol (ESPN2) possession, creating a disturbance and public Monday National championship, 1 p.m. ET (ESPN) urination. Well before the March party, the university, hearing a stream of complaints from neighbors, purchased the house at 610 Buchanan Blvd., which had been leased for the 2005-06 academic year by three lacrosse players. Later, one of three players charged with the rape, 19-year- old Collin Finnerty, was ordered to stand trial for a previous assault charge. Finnerty and two friends allegedly punched a man in a Washington, D.C., Adjust Font Size: suburb after the man had told them, according to court documents, to "stop calling him gay and other derogatory names." Before he was charged in the Duke incident, the assault charge was to have been dismissed once Finnerty completed 25 hours of community service. "Drawing the line at sexual assault, I've seen stuff like this with our team and other teams at my school," said one Ivy League lacrosse player who, fearing the wrath of his coach, asked for anonymity. "The problem is, when alcohol becomes involved -- and it always does in college -- it impairs judgment. "You get 40 juiced guys and two girls, and it's a time bomb." Shay, the Yale coach, said the Duke story prompted many far-ranging discussions among coaches and players. Could it have happened at his school? Shea paused, and sighed. "Yes," he said. "It could have happened to any of us. It's scary. What we know has happened, it could have happened on any college campus, Division I, II or III. It just so happened to happen at a phenomenal academic institution, the ivory tower." The culture On the day Duke coach Mike Pressler resigned, university president Richard Brodhead announced the formation of five committees to investigate different facets of the scandal. Law professor James Coleman chaired a seven-member committee looking into the history of the lacrosse team's behavior. Less than a month later, on May 1, the report was made public. Brodhead summarized the 17-page report in two sentences: "The Coleman committee's report tells of a close- knit team that did well academically and excelled athletically but that was irresponsible in its repeated abuse of alcohol. The committee did not, however, find a pattern of racist behavior or sexual Joseph Labolito/WireImage.com abuse." Coach Mike Presser took the Blue Devils to the A detailed chronology title game last year, but resigned in the wake of the disciplinary of this spring's scandal.