Economic Sustainability of
Small-Scale Forestry
International IUFRO Symposium
Anssi Niskanen and Johanna Väyrynen (eds.)
EFI Proceedings No. 36, 2001
- European Forest Institute
- IUFRO Working Unit 3.08.00
- Academy of Finland
- Finnair
- Metsämiesten Säätiö –Foundation
- MTK – The Central Union of Agricultural Producers
and Forest Owners, Finland
University of Joensuu, Faculty of Forestry, Finland
EFI Proceedings No. 36, 2001 Economic Sustainability of Small-Scale Forestry Anssi Niskanen and Johanna Väyrynen (eds.)
- Publisher:
- European Forest Institute
- Series Editors:
- Risto Päivinen, Editor-in-Chief
Tim Green, Technical Editor Brita Pajari, Conference Manager
Editorial Office: European Forest Institute
Torikatu 34
Phone: +358 13 252 020 Fax. +358 13 124 393
- FIN-80100 Joensuu, Finland
- Email: [email protected]
Cover photo: Layout: Printing:
Markku Tano Johanna Väyrynen Gummerus Printing Saarijärvi, Finland 2001
- Disclaimer:
- The papers in this book comprise the proceedings of the event mentioned on the
cover and title page. They reflect the authors' opinions and do not necessarily correspond to those of the European Forest Institute. The papers published in this volume have been peer-reviewed.
- © European Forest Institute 2001
- ISSN 1237-8801
ISBN 952-9844-82-4
Contents
Foreword ........................................................................................................... 5
Special Session: Economic Sustainabiliy of Small-Scale Forestry – Perspectives around the World –
John Herbohn Pentti Hyttinen Ikuo Ota
Prospects for Small-Scale Forestry in Australia ............................................... 9 Prospects for Small-Scale Forestry in Europe ................................................ 21 The Economic Situation of Small-Scale Forestry in Japan ............................ 29
Paul Mitchell-Banks Small-Scale Forestry in Canada or
Mammals Living Amongst Governments and Dinosaurs ............................... 41
Special Session: Small-Scale Forestry Development in Central and Eastern European Countries
Ján Ilavský
Preparedness of Private Owners for the Management of Forests in the Slovak Republic ....................................................................... 53
László Jáger and Károly Mészáros
Current State and Conflicts of Small-Scale Forestry in Hungary ................................................................... 61
Stanislaw Zajac Pekka Alhojärvi
The Economic and Social Role of Small-Scale (Private) Forest Holdings in Poland .............................................................................. 71
International Financing Possibilities for Small-Scale Forestry Development Schemes ................................................. 81
Policy Measures and Forestry Extension to Encourage Small-Scale Forestry
Martin Lillandt
Forest Management Association – a Major Tool to Promote Economic Sustainability of Family Forestry .......... 93
Joakim Hermelin Olli Saastamoinen
Policy Measures and Forestry Extension, Education and Training to Encourage Small-Scale Forestry ................................................ 101
The Challenges of Small-Scale Forestry in Finland: Policy and Planning Perspectives ................................................................. 107
Sylvain Masse
Forest Tenant Farming as Tested in Canada by the Bas-Saint-Laurent Model Forest: Is it Socio-Economically Viable? ........... 119
Forest Management Planning – Tool for Sustainable Small-Scale Forestry –
Bill Wilson and Sen W a ng
Treading the Path to Sustainable Forestry: New Directions in Canada with Particular Reference to British Columbia 131
Laura Bouriaud
Sustainable Forest Management: with or without Privately Owned Forests? A Romanian Case Survey ................................... 143
Lennart Eriksson and A Model Indicating Effects of Multi-purpose Use of
Anders Lindhagen
Forestry at the Stand Level ........................................................................... 161
Karl Stampfer et al. Small-Scale Forestry Challenges in Austria ................................................. 177
Maria Iwarsson and Interactive Knowledge System for Sverker Johansson
Family Enterprise Forestry ........................................................................... 185
Jouni Pykäläinen
Supporting Selection between Individual and Joint Ownership in Private Forestry: a Planning Example in a Death Estate .......................... 191
Monitoring the Socio-Economics of Small-Scale Forestry
Steve Harrison Walter Sekot
Research Approaches to Environmental-economic Issues in Small-scale Forestry ................................................................................ 201
Analysis of Profitability of Small-Scale Farm Forestry (SSFF) by Means of a Forest Accountancy Data Network – Austrian Experiences and Results ............................................................. 215
Jussi Leppänen Esa Uotila
Measuring the Direct Financial Assistance in Small-Scale Forestry Accounting ................................................................. 227
Monitoring Farm Forestry in Finland Using Wood Sales Profit Tax Information .................................................................................. 241
Social Dimension in Small-Scale Forestry
J ø rgen Amdam Johan Barstad
Future Challenges for Small-Scale Forestry – Examples from the West Coast of Norway ................................................... 253
Lowland Crofting and Urban Sprawl: New Aspects to Sustainable Forest Management in Local and Rural Development ............. 269
Programme .................................................................................................... 277 List of Participants ........................................................................................ 283 Most recent EFI Publications ....................................................................... 291
Foreword
The European Forest Institute, together with the Central Union of Agricultural Producers of Finland and the Faculty of Forestry of the University of Joensuu, organised an International Symposium on 'Economic sustainability of small-scale forestry' on 20-26 March 2001 in Joensuu, Finland. The symposium was also a Working Group meeting of IUFRO 3.08.00 Small-scale Forestry. There were 84 participants from 25 countries, and there were 26 high quality presentations on small-scale forestry problems, development prospects, policies, extension as well as forest management planning. We highly appreciate the assistance of those people at the European Forest Institute who helped us during the symposium. Their help was most valuable to the success of the event. We would like also to thank those who contributed in a valuable way to the field trip and post-conference tour of the Symposium: Mr Lasse Finér (North Karelia Regional Environment Centre, Joensuu), Mr Kyösti Hassinen (North Karelian Forestry Centre), Mr Jarkko Huovinen (Private forest owner, Tuupovaara), Mr Ari Karhapää (Forest Management Association, Ylä-Karjala), Mr Heikki Karhunen (Metsäliitto Ltd.), Mr Lasse Lóven (Finnish Forest Research Institute, Koli National Park), Mr Jari Parviainen (Finnish Forest Research Institute, Joensuu Research Centre), Mrs Marja Pitkänen (Private forest owner, Lieksa), Mr Reijo Svanborg (Tulikivi Ltd.), Mr and Mrs Tervo (Private forest owners, Nurmes), Mr Sakari Tikka (Centre of Forest Management Association, Joensuu) and Mr Ahti Ullgren (StoraEnso Ltd). We would also like to express our gratitude to scientific committee for selecting the voluntary papers to this proceedings, to keynote speakers on their excellent presentations, and to Mr Tim Green (European Forest Institute) for checking the language and helping prepare these Proceedings. Our last and very warmest thanks go to the following organisations and foundations for supporting the Symposium in many different ways: Academy of Finland, Finnair, Metsämiesten Säätiö –Foundation, Metsäliitto Ltd., City of Outokumpu and Tulikivi Ltd.
Joensuu, May 2001
- Anssi Niskanen
- Johanna Väyrynen
- Symposium Chairman
- Symposium Co-ordinator
Anssi Niskanen and Johanna Väyrynen (eds.) Economic Sustainability of Small-Scale Forestry EFI Proceedings No. 36, 2001
Special Session:
Economic Sustainabiliy of Small-Scale Forestry
– Perspectives around the World –
Prospects for Small-Scale Forestry in Australia
John Herbohn
Natural and Rural Systems Management
The University of Queensland
Abstract
This paper discusses the prospects for small-scale forestry in Australia. The nature of forestry in Australia is reviewed, including the historical development and current status of farm forestry. A number of significant impediments exist to further development of farm forestry, the most significant of which are associated with the lack of a farm forestry culture, concerns over harvest rights, availability of markets, the long wait for returns and satisfaction with current land uses. Recent research has made significant contributions to the development of forestry. As a result, there has been progress towards overcoming impediments, with substantial increases in the establishment of new plantations on private land in the past two to three years. The prospects of small-scale forestry in Australia are bright.
Keywords: Farm forestry, culture, impediments, conservation plantings
1. Background
Traditionally, forestry activities in Australia have been based on the exploitation of the extensive eucalypt forests that existed at the time of European settlement. The native forest resource is finite. It has been depleted since European settlement, and large tracts of forest land have been withdrawn from timber production as a result of bitter public policy debate between the forestry industry and conservation groups. At present some 17.5 million ha are currently in conservation reserves (Table 1). It is likely that over the next ten years further significant areas of native forest will be placed within conservation reserves. Control over the exploitation of the native timber resource has traditionally rested with the various state governments. However, the Commonwealth government has exerted increasing influence through a combination of economic incentives and the application of external powers provided by the constitution. Exploitation of Crown controlled native forests has been used as a means of achieving a number of social objectives such as regional development and
Anssi Niskanen and Johanna Väyrynen (eds.) Economic Sustainability of Small-Scale Forestry EFI Proceedings No. 36, 2001
10 Economic Sustainability of Small-Scale Forestry
Table 1. Area of native forest and plantation estate in Australia. Sources: State of Forests Report 1998; NPI (2000).
- Forest type
- Area (‘000 ha)
Native Forest1 Conservation reserves Multiple-use forests Leasehold land Other crown land Private forests
T o tal native forest
17 580 13 351 66 103 15 597 42 018
155 835
Plantations2 Softwood Hardwood
948 389
- T o tal plantation
- 1 337
1 As at December 1997 2 As at September 1999
the provision of low cost housing materials in addition to timber production (see O’Regan and Bhati 1991 for a comprehensive discussion of the pricing and allocation of logs in Australia). The ready supply logs at artificially low prices from public native forests resulted in a past lack of interest in private plantation forestry and a corresponding high level of public ownership of the plantation resource.
Figure 1. Total area under hardwood (HW) and softwood (SW) as at September 1999 by tree ownership. Source: NPI (2000). 'Joint' refers to plantations in which both private and public interests have some equity in the tree crop.
Prospects for Small-Scale Forestry in Australia 11
2. The Australian plantation estate
Domestic timber requirements are increasingly being drawn from the plantations. Softwood plantations currently comprise over 948 000 ha (over 70%) of the current plantation estate of 1 337 000 ha (see Table 1). The majority of the plantation estate in Australia is exotic softwood species and are owned almost exclusively by state governments and large industrial companies. A breakdown in the ownership and types of plantations is provided in Figure 1. There have been significant efforts in recent years to expand the plantation estate. Under the 2020 Vision (a joint policy statement agreement between the federal and state governments) it is planned to triple the existing plantation estate to 3.3 million ha. As part of this agreement, no native forest is to be cleared in order to establish plantations. This thus dictates that most of the expansion in the plantation estate will have to be on freehold cleared land. As such, the 2020 Vision has important implications for an increased role for the private sector, including farm foresters. This represents a major shift away from the current state domination of the forestry sector. The efforts to expand the plantation estate are reflected in the recent rate of plantation establishment. In 2000, it is estimated that almost 150 000 ha of new plantations would be established, of which almost 129 000 ha were to be hardwoods (NPI 2000, Figure 2). This represents an increase in the plantation estate of more than 10% in one year. The vast majority of new plantations were established on private land (Figure 3), which is a major shift away from the previous focus of establishing softwoods on public land by state forestry organisations. Most of the new plantation establishment occurred in Western Australia, Tasmania and Victoria (Figure 4).
Figure 2. Annual areas of new plantations established in Australia 1995. Source: National Plantation Inventory (2000).
12 Economic Sustainability of Small-Scale Forestry
Figure 3. New areas planted to hardwood and softwood in 1999 (up to September) by tree ownership. Source: NPI (2000).
Figure 4. New areas of plantations established in 1999 (up to September) by State/Territory. Source: NPI (2000).
3. Private forestry in Australia
Three common types of private forestry can be identified in Australia based on the motivations for participation, which range from predominantly environmental to a very strong production focus (Figure 5). Large-scale industrial plantings established primarily for timber production constitute by far the largest areas of plantation establishment. These plantations are managed primarily for wood production. Private large-scale plantations are typically owned by large forestry companies; or alternatively established under joint venture arrangements, either with forestry
Prospects for Small-Scale Forestry in Australia 13
Figure 5. An overview of the factors influencing the development of small-scale forestry initiatives in Australia. Source: Herbohn et al. (2000).
companies or government. There is also an increasing number of forestry investment companies establishing large-scale plantations. Conservation plantings or initiatives are at the other end of the production/environment spectrum. These planting tend to occur in environmentally sensitive areas such as along water courses. They are commonly established to ameliorate environmental damage such as stream bank erosion, and rising water tables leading to salinity caused by past poor land management practices. A significant proportion of the conservation planting in the past ten years in Australia has occurred under the umbrella of 'Landcare'. Landcare is an Australian community-wide program with strong government support at all levels and currently involves over 4000 autonomous groups (Marriott et al. 2000). Most groups are comprised of farmers and other landowners restoring land and increasing sustainability, and to a lesser extent groups based in towns and cities. Marriott et al. (2000) have observed that increasingly landcare members are focussing on whole catchments and regional themes, rather than confining themselves to their own properties. Many groups have amalgamated into loosely bound, but highly task-orientated and opportunistic regional networks. There are also a large number of other groups active at a regional level that promote or assist in tree planting for environmental purposes, which are not directly associated with Landcare. Due to the high establishment cost, limited financial support and a lack of direct economic returns (at least in the short term) conservation plantings tend to be small in area. While timber production is not excluded as a potential forest use, the environmental sensitivity of many of the areas established, or significant non-wood benefits generated from these areas suggest that it is unlikely that these will produce significant volumes of timber.
14 Economic Sustainability of Small-Scale Forestry
Small-scale forestry involving the establishment of woodlots as an integrated part of farm activities is growing in popularity, although accurate figures on the extent of planting are difficult to obtain. There are also some 42 million ha of native forest under private ownership (Table 1). Logging of these areas is often ad hoc and uncontrolled. The importance of these areas for conservation and as a source of sustainable timber production has recently been recognised and programs have been developed to improve the management of these forests.
4. The nature and extent of small-scale (farm) forestry in Australia
The nature of small-scale forestry differs from country to country (see for example Harrison et al. 2000) and it is difficult to define what is meant by small-scale forestry. Harrison and Herbohn (2000) suggest that large-scale forestry is typically owned or managed by government or large companies, and has a focus on large, even-aged, single species blocks, with plantations of varying ages. The aim of large-scale forestry is to provide regular volumes of timber over time in a cost-effective manner with minimal labour input to supply established long-term market contracts. In contrast, small-scale forestry typically consists of a single or smaller number of planting blocks, non-professional management and often a lack of silvicultural skills, with little planning for future marketing. The term 'farm forestry' is commonly used in Australia, although its meaning is poorly defined. The common interpretation is simply ‘forestry undertaken on farms’, which involves small-scale farm woodlots, but may also include windbreaks and shelterbelts, agroforestry and ‘break of slope’ plantings. These activities are consistent with the interpretation of smallscale forestry outlined by Harrison and Herbohn (2000). Figure 6 illustrates the overlap between land protection plantings, farm forestry plantations and industrial plantations. It is clear from this figure that farm-based forestry may also involve large-scale planting of monocultures under joint venture arrangements, and the leasing of farmland to industrial forestry companies for industrial plantations. These latter activities are more consistent with the definition of large-scale forestry suggested by Harrison and Herbohn (2000).
Plantation data from the National Plantation Inventory (NPI) discussed above is based almost exclusively on large-scale plantations of 1000 ha or greater, although it appears that some plantations of smaller size are included in this data set. As such, it is difficult to obtain accurate estimates of the current extent of small-scale forestry in Australia. This situation has recently improved however, with the establishment of National Farm Forestry Inventory (NFFI) project as a subset of the NPI database. Future reporting of Australia’s plantation estate will recognise and attempt to quantify farm forestry plantings, as a subset of the overall plantation figures. More detailed analysis of the farm forestry resource will also be reported under the NFFI (NPI 2000). The NFFI will focus on plantations whose owners hold total estates less than 1000 ha.
Preliminary NFFI data (Table 2) indicates that there are 76 250 ha of small grower plantations in Australia, most of which are found in the states of Victoria, New South Wales, Western Australia and Tasmania. Queensland, despite very favourable growing conditions and an abundance of suitable land, has few small-scale forestry plots. Table 2 does not contain data on the large number of individual landholders who have entered into farm forestry via joint venture agreements or leasing arrangements with commercial tree grower companies. This is significant because it is likely that up to 20% of Australia’s total plantation resource has been established via joint venture arrangements (Stephens 2001). Early analysis of data collected through the NFFI suggests that the size and nature of plantations can vary significantly between regions (Stephens 2001).
Prospects for Small-Scale Forestry in Australia 15