Palen Solar Project Water Supply Assessment
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Palen Solar Project Water Supply Assessment Prepared by Philip Lowe, P.E. February 2018 Palen Solar Project APPENDIX G. WATER SUPPLY ASSESSMENT Contents 1. Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 1 2. Project Location and Description ...................................................................................... 1 3. SB 610 Overview and Applicability .................................................................................... 3 4. Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin .............................................................................. 4 4.1 Basin Overview and Storage ......................................................................................................... 4 Groundwater Management ............................................................................................................ 5 4.2 Climate .......................................................................................................................................... 5 4.3 Groundwater Trends ...................................................................................................................... 5 4.4 Groundwater Recharge .................................................................................................................. 7 Subsurface Inflow ......................................................................................................................... 7 Recharge from Precipitation .......................................................................................................... 8 Irrigation Return Recharge ............................................................................................................ 9 Wastewater Return Flow ............................................................................................................... 9 Colorado River Aqueduct ............................................................................................................ 10 4.5 Groundwater Demand/Outflow ................................................................................................... 10 Subsurface Outflow ..................................................................................................................... 10 Groundwater Extraction .............................................................................................................. 10 Evapotranspiration at Palen Dry Lake ......................................................................................... 11 5. Groundwater Budget ......................................................................................................... 12 5.1 Baseline Groundwater Budget..................................................................................................... 14 Normal (Average) Year ............................................................................................................... 14 Dry Year ...................................................................................................................................... 16 Multiple Dry Years ...................................................................................................................... 19 5.2 Groundwater Budget with Palen Solar and Cumulative Projects ................................................ 20 Normal (Average) Year ............................................................................................................... 20 Dry Year ...................................................................................................................................... 28 Multiple Dry Years ...................................................................................................................... 28 Analysis Summary ...................................................................................................................... 36 5.3 Groundwater Budget Reliability Considerations......................................................................... 37 6. Summary and Conclusions .............................................................................................. 38 7. References ......................................................................................................................... 41 Tables Table 1 Subsurface Inflow Recharge Estimates for the Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin ........ 7 Table 2 Precipitation Recharge Estimates for the Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin ................. 8 Table 3 CVGB Inflow/Outflow Summary .......................................................................................... 13 Table 4 Estimated Baseline Groundwater Budget for the Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin ... 14 Table 5 Estimated Baseline Groundwater Budget for the Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin Using NPS Estimates of Precipitation and Subsurface Inflow. ............................................. 15 Table 6 Estimated Dry Year Groundwater Budget for the Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin .. 17 February 2018 i Final Supplemental EIS/EIR/LUPA Palen Solar Project APPENDIX G. WATER SUPPLY ASSESSMENT Table 7 Estimated Critical Dry Year Groundwater Budget for the Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin ...................................................................................................................................... 18 Table 8 Estimated Dry Year Groundwater Budget for the Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin Using NPS Estimates of Precipitation and Subsurface Inflow .............................................. 18 Table 9 Estimated Critical Dry Year Groundwater Budget for the Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin Using NPS Estimates of Precipitation and Subsurface Inflow ....................................... 18 Table 10 Baseline Multiple Dry Year Groundwater Budget in Acre Feet Using Adopted Estimates of Precipitation and Subsurface Inflow. ................................................................................. 19 Table 11 Baseline Multiple Dry Year Groundwater Budget in Acre Feet Using NPS Estimates of Precipitation and Subsurface Inflow. ..................................................................................... 20 Table 12 CVGB Groundwater 30-Year Budget in Acre Feet for Average Precipitation Year with Palen Solar Project in Place Using Adopted Estimates of Precipitation and Subsurface Inflow. .................................................................................................................................... 21 Table 13 CVGB Groundwater 30-Year Budget for Average Precipitation Year with Palen Solar Project in Place Using NPS Infiltration and Underflow Recharge Estimates ........................ 22 Table 14 Cumulative Projects – Water Use Summary ........................... Error! Bookmark not defined. Table 15 30-Year Projected CVGB Groundwater Budget in Acre Feet for Palen Solar Project Plus Cumulative Projects Using Adopted Precipitation and Underflow Recharge Estimates ....... 24 Table 16 30-Year Projected CVGB Groundwater Budget in Acre Feet for Palen Solar Project Plus Cumulative Projects Using NPS Precipitation and Underflow Recharge Estimates. ............ 26 Table 17 Multiple Dry Year Groundwater Budget in Acre Feet with Palen Solar Project and All Cumulative Projects in Place ................................................................................................. 28 Table 18 Multiple Dry Year Groundwater Budget in Acre Feet with Palen Solar Project and All Cumulative Projects in Place Using NPS Estimates of Precipitation and Underflow Recharge ................................................................................................................................ 29 Table 19 30-Year Projected CVGB Groundwater Budget in Acre Feet for Baseline (No Project) Conditions Using Adopted Precipitation and Underflow Recharge Estimates and Assuming a Repeat of the Driest 30 Years on Record at Blythe. .......................................... 30 Table 20 30-Year Projected CVGB Groundwater Budget in Acre Feet Using Adopted Precipitation and Underflow Recharge Estimates and Assuming a Repeat of the Driest 30 Years on Record at Blythe, with the Palen Solar Project in Place. ......................................................... 32 Table 21 30-Year Projected CVGB Groundwater Budget in Acre Feet Using Adopted Precipitation and Underflow Recharge Estimates and Assuming a Repeat of the Driest 30 Years on Record at Blythe, with all Cumulative Projects in Place. ........................................................ 34 Figures Figures appear at the end of the appendix Figure 1 Chuckwalla Valley Regional Groundwater Basins Figure 2a Regional Geology Figure 2b Regional Geology Legend Figure 3 Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin Bedrock Topography Figure 4 Chuckwalla Valley Groundwater Basin Cross Section A-A Figure 5 Basin Wide Groundwater Hydrographs Figure 6 Annual Rainfall at Blythe, California February 2018 ii Final Supplemental EIS/EIR/LUPA Palen Solar Project APPENDIX G. WATER SUPPLY ASSESSMENT 1. Introduction The objective of this report is to provide a Water Supply Assessment (WSA) pursuant to the requirements of California Senate Bill (SB) 610/221, for the Palen Solar Project. This project was previously proposed as a solar trough project, the Palen Solar Power Project, and later as a solar power tower project, the Palen Solar Electric Generating System. SB 610, passed in 2002, amended the California Water Code to require detailed analysis of