Excavations at Kommos (Crete) During 1980 241
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EXCAVATIONSAT KOMMOS(CRETE) DURING 1980 (PLATES 49-61) During our fifth season' at Kommos (23 June-27 August) we finished excavation of selected Late Minoan (LM) houses on the hilltop, now being preparedfor publication.On the hillside we uncovered Middle Minoan (MM) house levels. To the south, we nearly completed work on the later Greek Sanctuary(4th century B.C.-mid-2nd century after Christ) and exposed parts of two successive Iron Age temples below. Near by, along the shore, we explored furtherthe monumentalMinoan buildingsdiscovered in 1979.2 'The excavation is being carried out by the University of Toronto and the Royal Ontario Museum under the auspices of The American School of Classical Studies at Athens, with the cooperation of the Greek ArchaeologicalService. Financialsupport for 1980 was providedby the Social Sciences and Humani- ties Research Council of Canada (Grant 410-78-0590-X2S1), the University of Toronto, and the Royal OntarioMuseum as well as the SCM Corporationof New York and Leon Pomerance.Kodak Canada,Ltd., Keuffel and Esser of Canada,and the PolaroidCorporation of America helped provide equipment. Full-time staff during the fifth season consisted of the Director, representingthe University of Toronto and the Royal OntarioMuseum; Professor Maria C. Shaw, ScarboroughCollege, University of Toronto; Professor L. Vance Watrous, the State University of New York at Buffalo;Professor James Wright, Bryn MawrCollege; ProfessorJohn McEnroe, IndianaUniversity (formerlyof the University of Toronto). Also present were the following former or present students at the University of Toronto: Giuliana Bianco, excavationarchitect and artist, Lucia Nixon (presentlyat the University of Cambridge),and Douglas Orr. Of the above, Nixon, McEnroe, Orr, M. Shaw and Wrightworked as trench masters. George Beladakisof Pitsidiawas foreman again, in chargeof some twenty workmen from Pitsidiaand Siva. Majorcontributions were made during the summer by MaryK. Dabney, ColumbiaUniversity and Kath- erine A. Schwab, Institute of Fine Arts, New York University (cataloguing);Peter Callaghan,the British School of Archaeology at Athens and Robert B. Koehl, University of Pennsylvania (both working on pottery, along with Professor Watrous); HarrietBlitzer, IndianaUniversity (bone, metal and stone tools); David Reese, University of Cambridge (bones and shells). On the technical side were Catherine Sease, MetropolitanMuseum of Art and Marta Leskard, Queen's University (conservation); Taylor Dabney (photography);Danae Cotsis (pottery profiles). During the previous winter Sarah Stewart (now Mrs. Sharpe), University of Toronto, worked as Kommos ResearchAssistant. Special thanks are to be extended to certain individuals who joined us for a limited time: Dr. John Hayes, Royal Ontario Museum (pottery); Professor John Gifford, University of Minnesota (geology); Professor Daniel Geagan, McMasterUniversity (epigraphy);and Professors Jennifer and Thomas Shay, University of Manitoba (botany). The Shays spent over a month during the springcollecting and examin- ing flora in connection with our botanicalstudy of the Kommos region, and, during the excavation period, they set the groundworkfor the analysis of carbonizedseeds and wood from the ancient levels. We are also obliged to Ann Orr for helpingwith shoppingand other matters. To all the above I am deeply indebted. The plans and illustrationsfor this report were made by Giuliana Bianco. With the exception of Plate 61:d, by Robert K. Vincent, Jr., object photographsand Plates 49:a and 50:a are by Taylor Dabney; the remainingsite photographswere taken by the author. 2For earlier preliminaryreports see Hesperia46, 1977, pp. 199-240 (= Kommos,1976); 47, 1978, pp. 111-170 (= Kommos,1977); 48, 1979, pp. 145-173 (= Kommos,1978); 49, 1980, pp. 207-250 (= Kom- mos, 1979). See now J. W. Shaw, "In the midst of excavation at Kommos," ROM ArchaeologicalNewslet- ter, no. 172, September1979, and "Unravellingthe History of a Greek Sanctuaryin Crete," ibid., no. 184, September1980; M. C. Shaw, "Sir Arthur Evans at Kommos," Expedition23, 1980/1981, no. 3, pp. 4-12; M. C. and J. W. Shaw, "Recent Discoveries in Crete," Rotunda14 Spring 1981, pp. 12-19. For Minoan Hesperia50, 3 American School of Classical Studies at Athens is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve, and extend access to Hesperia ® www.jstor.org 212 JOSEPH W. SHAW 8 '888 S ' <_ _ ' _, 3A Hilltop IA ~~~~~~~11 LIBYAN SEA 'X!1 KOMM05~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Huei A Centrral Hitide 23 B 28 A r-- Geek Sanctuary A1\\ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~II KOMMOS SITE PLAN FIG. 1. General plan, site of Kommos (1980), by GiulianaBianco EXCAVATIONSAT KOMMOS(CRETE) DURING 1980 213 THE HILLTOP (Trenches 36C, Cl and C2, 38A; Fig. 1 [top], P1. 50:a) Excavationwithin the Minoan houses on the hilltop, where almost half our excava- tion effort was expended during previous seasons, was confined to a few limited probes intended to clarifypoints of constructionand chronology. In Trench 36C a blocked doorway was cleared in the "Oblique"Building between Spaces 0 15 and 0 16,3 revealing a handsome threshold slab indicating at least two periods of use. Pottery from a sounding to bedrock in 0 15 suggests at the moment that the Oblique Building may have been built in LM I, a relatively prosperous period on the site. To the west other blocking was removed from between Spaces 6 and 20 in the cliffside house,4 to expose a fine threshold, also with two periods of use. In the lane (7) outside the house, just to the west, a sounding clarifiedthe walls of earlier structures.It also exposed in Court 21 a covered drain leading north into an oval, slab-lined enclo- sure that may have functioned as a cistern or sump. Trench 38A explored the northern part of Space N 18 of the LM I North House,5 revealing that the eastern rooms of the MM predecessorof the North House were set into deep cuttings in the bedrock,just west of the north-south street (N 19) separating houses.6 Upon the completion of this probe excavation of the hilltop was terminated in order to allow study for final publicationto begin. THE CENTRAL HILLSIDE (Trenches 33B, 35A-35A2; Figs. 1, 2, Pls. 50, 51) On the hillside some cleaning and consolidation work was carried out within the LM I-III house largely uncovered during previous seasons.7 South of the house, in the intervening area between it and a sounding (23B) opened in another year, we began a trench8and excavated down to the LM I ground level. It was discontinuedas soon as it became clear that during LM 1-111this was essentially an outdoor area without struc- tures. If we had excavated further down, however, there is little doubt that we would have found ourselves within an MM house, for not only have such remains been found to the north and northeast9but in the process of clearing part of the north-south street along the edge of the hill (Space 1, P1. 50:c) we found that the street is borderedon the coarse ware at Kommos, see Philip P. Betancourt, Cooking Vesselsfrom Minoan Kommos,A Preliminary Report,Occasional Paper 7, Instituteof Archaeology,University of California,Los Angeles 1980. Brock, Fortetsa = J. K. Brock, Fortetsa,Cambridge 1957 Shaw, MinoanArchitecture = J. W. Shaw, MinoanArchitecture: Materials and Techniques( ASAtene, n.s. 33, 1971 [19731) 3Trench36C1. For this area, see Kommos,1978, pp. 152-153 and fig. 2:b; Kommos,1979, p. 211. 4Trench36C2. Kommos,1977, p. 117 and fig. 3; Kommos,1978, fig. 2:b. 5Kommos,1978, fig 2:a; Kommos,1979, pl. 54:a (mislabeledN 19 in the photograph). 6For a Geometric krater (C 1657) found in the levels above North House (House N), see below, p. 240. 7Kommos,1979, fig. 2, Rooms 2-6, 11, 12. Now being studied by John McEnroe. 8Trench33B. 9Kommos,1979, fig. 2, Rooms 7-9, 24, 25. 214 JOSEPH W. SHAW X 210 26 2> ~~~ 1)~~31 < > < 2 ~~~~~~~~~~~~{ KOMMOS 'PLAN CENTRAL HILLSIDE FMG.2. Hillside houses, easternmostarea, by GiulianaBianco east by an MM wall, preserved three courses high, neatly and evenly constructed of large squared slabs. As we had found when excavating a section of this road on the north, the road was built during the MM period, with the addition of earth and occa- sional rough pavement slabs raisingits level until it was abandonedin LM IIIB. Major excavation took place east of the LM building (Trenches 35A1, 2, Fig. 2, P1. 50:b, d), with the aim of uncovering more of an MM house of which only a western wall was exposed last year (that of Room 28 in Fig. 2). If there were no significant LM building above it, we might in this way be able to expose an entire MM building that EXCAVATIONSAT KOMMOS(CRETE) DURING 1980 215 could be taken as representativeof such buildings in this area. Fortunately, our hope was justified. As was the case with the area adjacentto the LM I building on the south, no LM structureswere discovered east of it, although there was a small slab enclosure (above Room 28) west of a terrace wall, and LM III re-use was noted in Room 30. Some four rooms were uncovered, and it is hoped that in a future season connecting rooms to the north can be uncovered to reveal most if not all of what remains of the house plan. We may also be able to penetrate below the floor levels of a few of these rooms in order to reveal more of an earlierMM building, presumablya house, of which at least two rooms (26, 27, and perhaps32) have alreadybeen explored. If we review the newly discovered rooms briefly, it is clear that the builders of 28 knew and took advantage of the lower MM rooms, for the east and west walls of 28 were built on what was left of the earlier walls. Concerning28 itself, the floor has been destroyed by erosion, which has removed any floor deposit or furnishings that might reveal its use.