Stantec Consulting Ltd
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Stantec Consulting Ltd. Stantec 130-2886 Sunridge Way NE, Calgary AB T1Y 7H9 October 26, 2016 MV2016E0006 File: 144902381.300 MV2016E0025 Attention: Mr. Glen MacKay Assessment Archaeologist NWT Cultural Places Program Prince of Wales Northern Heritage Centre PO Box 1320 Yellowknife, NT X1A 2L9 Dear Mr. MacKay, Reference: Archaeological Impact Assessment: Department of Transportation – Highway Corridor Granular Supply Sources, Eastern Segment, Highways 3, 5 and 6, Interim Report #1 Archaeologist Permit 16-003 Permit Holder and Report Author: Matthew Moors, M.A. (Stantec Consulting Ltd.) Project Conservator: Prof. Elisabeth Robertson, Ph.D. Proponent Contact: Alexander Murray (Department of Transportation, GNWT) PO Box 1320, Yellowknife, NT X1A 2L9 – Ph: 867-688-1144, Email: [email protected] On behalf of the Government of the Northwest Territories (GNWT), Department of Transportation (DOT), Stantec Consulting Ltd. (Stantec) conducted an Archaeological Impact Assessment (AIA) for the proposed Eastern Segment of the Highway Corridor Granular Supply Sources along Highways 3, 5 and 6 (the Project). The proposed Project will involve the development of 18 borrow sources and related facilities (i.e., along Highways 3, 5 and 6 (Figure 1). In early 2016, a desktop Archaeological Overview Assessment (AOA) was completed for the initial comprehensive program of proposed GNWT DOT borrow sources, associated with highways 1, 3, 5, 6 and 7. The AOA report was submitted to the Prince of Wales Northern Heritage Centre (PWNHC), with recommendations for the completion of a targeted AIA for all areas of high archaeological site potential. The PWNHC agreed with this recommendation, as communicated by letter on April 5, 2016. The program was subsequently divided into two portions – one which encompassed the portions west of Fort Providence (primarily along Highways 1 and 7) and one which encompassed the portions to the east, along Highways 3, 5 and 6, in the Great Slave Lake area. An application for a Class 2 archaeological research permit to conduct an AIA for the eastern portion was prepared and submitted to the PWNHC on March 18, 2016. The proposed program was subsequently approved through the issuance of Northwest Territories Class 2 Archaeologist Permit # 16-003 (June 9, 2016). The western portion of the program was assessed under Permit # 16-004, directed by Ty Heffner. As discussed in the permit application, an interim report detailing preliminary results and recommendations is being provided to facilitate a proposed winter 2016/2017 construction start for the Project. Design with community in mind Gamètì Wekweètì Lac La Martre Whati` Edzo Yellowknife H:\External ProfitCentre\144 BC\144902241\mxd10\overview_map_1249.mxd Revised: 2016-10-21 By:EStrangward Yellowknife Highway 3 Km 122.0 Yellowknife Highway Km 3 285.0 Yellowknife Highway 3 Km 80.6 Great Slave Lake Fort Mackenzie HighwayProvidence 1 Fort Yellowknife Highway 3 Resolution Hay Kakisa Lake River Pine Point Fort Resolution Highway 6 Enterprise Fort Resolution Highway 6 Prospect #4,5,7,12,14,15 Fort Resolution Highway 6 Prospect #11 Fort Smith Highway 5 Km 63.0 & Km 64.5 + Extension Fort Smith Highway 5 Northwest Territories Fort Smith Alberta Saskatchewan Fort Smith Highway 5 Km 84-W, 84-E, 84-E 3200 & 3800, 89.1 Slave River Lake Athabasca Legend 0 50 100 Kilometres Borrow Source Wood Buffalo National Park 1:3,500,000 (at original document size of 8.5x11) Place Location Road Project Location 144902381 Watercourse NTS Mapsheet(s): Prepared by EStrangward on 2016-10-20 085 F/04, 095 B/11, Technical Review by KPeach on 2016-10-21 Provincial/Territorial Boundary 095 H/06, 096 E/07 Independent Review by JTischer on 2016-10-21 Client/Project Waterbody Client: Government of the Northwest Territories Project: Archaeological Impact Assessments of Highway Corridor Granular Supply Sources Figure No. Notes 1. Coordinate System: NAD83 / NWT Lambert 1 Title Disclaimer: Stantec assumes no responsibility for data supplied in electronic format. The recipient accepts full responsibility for verifying the accuracy and completeness of the data. The recipient Borrow Sources Overview releases Stantec, its officers, employees, consultants and agents, from any and all claims arising in any way from the content or provision of the data. Eastern Segment Highway Corridor Granular Supply Sources, Eastern Segment, Highways 3, 5 and 6 Interim Report #1 PROJECT DESCRIPTION The AIA focused on 18 borrow sources, intended to provide materials for maintenance of highways 3, 5 and 6. Many of the proposed borrow sources are extensions on existing pits or other existing disturbances. Because of this, the need for new access construction is minimal, with many locations utilizing existing access while others will require modification of an existing winter road and/or cut line. One location (Highway 3, km 80.6) also includes a stockpile location adjacent to the highway. Development of the borrow sources will result in vegetation removal, stripping, and excavation, resulting in deep and extensive impacts to these locations. In total, there are three borrow sources along Highway 3, eight along Highway 5, and seven along Highway 6 (see Table 1). Table 1 Overview of the AIA schedule Highway KM or Prospect # General Involved Local Total# of Dates Area Community Crew (2016) Yellowknife Highway #3 80.6 Fort Deh Goh Got'ie 3 Oct 1-3 Providence Yellowknife Highway #3 122.0 Fort Deh Goh Got'ie 3 Sept 30 Providence Yellowknife Highway #3 285.0 Behchoko Tlicho 4 Oct4 Fort Smith Hiahwav #5 63.0 Buffalo River Katlodeeche 3 Sept 25 Fort Smith Highway #5 64.5 Buffalo River No assistance 2 Sept 28- available 29 Fort Smith Highway #5 64.5 Extension Buffalo River No assistance 2 Sept 28- available 29 Fort Smith Hiohwav #5 84.8-W Buffalo River Katlodeeche 4 Sept 24 Fort Smith Highway #5 84.8-E Buffalo River No assistance 2 Sept 27 available Fort Smith Highway #5 84.8-E (3200 m) Buffalo River Deninu K'ue 4 Sept 21- 22, Sept 26 Fort Smith Highway #5 84.8-E (3800 m) Buffalo River Deninu K'ue 4 Sept 21- 22, Sept 26 Fort Smith Hiohwav #5 89.1 Buffalo River Katlodeeche 4 Sept 23 Fort Resolution Hiqhwav #6 11 (km 23.6) Pine Point Deninu K'ue 4 Sept14 Fort Resolution Highway #6 4 (km 25.5) Pine Point Deninu K'ue 4 Sept16 Fort Resolution Hiahwav #6 5 fkm 36.3} Pine Point Deninu K'ue 4 Sept15 Fort Resolution Hiohwav #6 12 (km 36.3) Pine Point Deninu K'ue 4 Sept15 Fort Resolution Highway #6 15 (36.3) Pine Point Deninu K'ue 4 Sept16 Fort Resolution Highway #6 14{km 36.8) Pine Point Deninu K'ue 4 Sept16 Fort Resolution Hiohwav #6 7 (km 36.8) Pine Point Deninu K'ue 4 Sept17 METHODS The proposed Project will traverse lands associated with the traditional territories of four First Nation Communities in the Northwest Territories including: the Tlicho, Deh Gah Got'ie, Katlodeeche, and Deninu K'ue. While within the traditional territories, the appropriate community was contacted and engaged (see Table 1). This engagement included the participation of wildlife monitors and/or community assistants during conduct of the field surveys, when participants were available. Preparation for the AIA began with the compilation of an Archaeological Overview Assessment (AOA) of available information sources including topographic maps, surficial geology information, the territorial archaeological site database, previous archaeological permit reports, aerial Page 3 of 66 Stantec Highway Corridor Granular Supply Sources. Eastern Segment. Highways 3. 5 and 6 Interim Report #1 photography. ethnographic and historic information. The assessment of archaeological potential was assigned through the evaluation of several criteria including: • the topography of an area (elevated. well-drained) • general proximity to water sources (streams, creeks, rivers. and lakes) • association with confluence areas (including lake inlets/outlets) • proximity to recorded archaeological. historical. and traditional features (including sites and trails) • any specific areas of traditional significance. Based on these parameters, the areas of archaeological potential were selected for each of the associated borrow sources. It was understood that these could be modified in the field, to refine and/or correct the desktop assessment. Each of the proposed borrow sources assessed in the AOA contained areas of high archaeological potential; these areas were mapped. The AOA was submitted to the PWHNC for review in early 2016. Based on PWNHC response (April 5, 2016), an AIA was required for high potential areas. As noted above, the program was then divided into two portions - one which encompassed the portions west of Fort Providence (primarily along Highways 1 and 7) and one which encompassed the portions to the east, along Highways 3, 5 and 6, in the Great Slave Lake area. The proposed program was subsequently approved through the issuance of Northwest Territories Class 2 Archaeologist Permit# 16-003 (June 9, 2016). The western portion of the program was assessed under Permit # 16-004, directed by Ty Heffner. The in-field assessments for the Project were conducted under the supervision of Matthew Moors, M.A. The crew worked through September and early October to complete the assessments (see Table 1) under snow-free and frost-free, late summer/early fall field conditions. Due to the proximity of the Project footprint to high grade highways, a single crew was assembled to conduct the field assessment. This crew consisted of two archaeologists with participation from wildlife monitors and/or aboriginal assistants drawn from the local communities associated with the various assessment areas (see Table 1). Each of the borrow sources was accessed via truck and pedestrian traverse. The archaeological potential of each granular supply source was refined in the field. Information available for the desktop assessment was sometimes lacking or not sufficiently detailed. Little previous archaeological research has been conducted in the area, resulting in a lack of previously recorded site locations.