GEOZON SCIENCE MEDIA
ISSN 0424-7116
Quaternary Science Journal
Volume 59 / Number 1–2 / 2010 / 21–35 / DOI 10.3285/eg.59.1-2.02 www.quaternary-science.net
E&G
Late Quaternary morphodynamics in the Quebrada de Purmamarca, NW Argentina
Jan-Hendrik May, Ramiro Daniel Soler
Abstract:
is study aims to document the geomorphic, sedimentary and paleopedogenic arcives in the Qebrada de Purmamarca. e paleoenvironmental interpretation of these arcives and the reconstruction of landscape evolution are mainly based on field observations and geomorphological mapping (May 2008). A series of aggradational terraces mostly consisting of coarse debrisflow deposits are the main focus of this investigation. While the associated cut-and-fill processes are probably the result of an interplay between climatic and tectonic controls, the deposition of the youngest terrace level (> 150 m thicness) may likely be aüributed to a drop of the periglacial belt of more than 1000 meters below its modern elevation. For the time aſter terrace accumulation has ceased, the interpretation of alluvial fans, aeolian sand and a well-developed paleosol points to Late Qaternary humidity canges as an important control on landscape evolution. e major phase of downcuüing and incision significantly postdates the end of terrace deposition and may have been triggered by markedly increased amounts of monsoonal precipitation. Finally, minor humidity canges of possible Holocene age are indicated by paleopedogenic and geomorphic observations on terrace surfaces and along valley slopes.
(Spätquartäre Morphodynamik in der Quebrada de Purmamarca, NW Argentina)
Kurzfassung:
Ziel dieser Arbeit ist die Dokumentation geomorphologiscer, sedimentärer und paläopedologiscer Arcive in der Qebrada de Purmamarca. Die Interpretation dieser Arcive in Bezug auf die Paläoumweltbedingungen basiert hauptsäclic auf Feldforscungen und geomorphologiscer Kartierung (May 2008). Einen Scwerpunkt dieser Studie bildet eine aus grobem Material aufgeschüete Terrassenfolge. Während die Erosions- und Akkumulationsprozesse vermutlic auf das Zusammenspiel klimatiscer und tektoniscer Prozesse zurhczufhhren sind, steht die Ablagerung der jhngsten ca. 150 m mäctigen Terrassenfläce wohl in Zusammenhang mit dem Absinken des periglazialen Einflussbereices um mehr als 1000 m unter die heutige Höhenlage. Nac dem Ende der Terrassenschüung, bieten vor allem Scwemmkegel, äolisce Sande und gut entwicelte Paläoböden wertvolle Hinweise auf die durc Feuctigkeitsveränderungen gesteuerte spätglaziale Landscaſtsentwiclung. Die Hauptphase der Einscneidung datiert um einiges nac dem Ende der Terrassenaufschüung und wurde vermutlic durc eine Zunahme der monsunalen Niederscläge gesteuert. Abscließend konnten die Auswirkungen kleinerer, vermutlic holozäner Scwankungen der Feuctigkeitsverhältnisse hber paläopedologisce und geomorphologisce Beobactungen auf der Terrassenoberfläce und den Hängen bescrieben werden.
Keywords:
Andes, landscape evolution, Late Qateenaer, teeeaces, paleoenvieonments
Addresses of authors: Jan-Hendrik May*, Scool of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Wollongong, 2522 Wollongong NSW,
Australia; E-Mail: [email protected]; Institute of Geography, University of Bern, Hallerstraße 12, CH-3012 Bern, Switzerland. E-Mail: [email protected].c / Ramiro Daniel Soler, CNEA (Comision Nacional Energía Atómica), Avenida Bolivia 1235, 4400 Salta, Argentina. *coeeesponding authoe
1. Introduction
tions and relative importance of the climatic verse tectonic controls are a maüer of ongoing debate and should vary
e Andean ranges of NW Argentina are situated between on different timescales (Hilley & Strecker 2005). Consethe high-altitude plateau of the Puna and the vast Chaco quently, increasing effort has recently been concentrated lowlands, and are caracterized by steep climatic and topo- on the establishment of an absolute cronological framegraphic gradients. is makes them a highly dynamic ar- work for the Qaternary alluvial fans and valley fill deposea from geological, environmental and geomorphological its along intramontane valley systems of the Qebrada de perspectives. e thic and complex series of Tertiary and Toro and Qebrada de Humahuaca (Robinson et al. 2005; Qaternary depositional terraces and alluvial fans along Sancho et al. 2008; Spencer & Robinson 2008).
- the intramontane valleys of the Eastern Cordillera have
- Given the crucial role of climate in landscape evolution, a
drawn the aüention of early geologists (Keidel 1913; Kühn number of studies have been concerned with the reconstruc1924; De Ferraris 1940). Since then muc researc has tion of paleoclimate and paleoenvironments from different been directed towards a more detailed comprehension of arcives in the Andes of NW Argentina over various Qalandscape evolution on these Cenozoic timescales, particu- ternary timescales. Cyclic canges in moisture availability in larly with regard to the repeated and oscillatory filling and NW Argentina throughout the Qaternary were suggested excavation of the Andean valley systems in NW Argentina by the investigation of loess-paleosol-sequences in the Tafí by a complex interplay of climate and tectonics (Kleinert valley (Schellenberger, Heller & Veit 2003; Kemp et al.
& Strecker 2001; Hilley & Strecker 2005; Alonso et al. 2004; Schellenberger 2006; Schellenberger & Veit 2006).
2006; Strecker et al. 2007). In this context, the interac- Evidence for periods of increased humidity is provided by
E&G / Vol. 59 / No. 1–2 / 2010 / 21–35 / DOI 10.3285/eg.59.1-2.02 / © Authors / Creative Commons Attribution License
21
5.012 masl
a)
b)
Argentina
4.577 m asl
3.905 m asl
1
L
K
M
3
2
5
J
4
I
6
H
F
G
1
EDA
CB
Purmamarca
2.250 m asl
4.376 m asl
5 km
Fig. 1: Ovebview of the studr abea. a) Location of the Qebbada de Pubmamabca in South Amebica. b) Geogbaphic context and hillshaded topogbaphr of the studr abea (blac line denotes catiment divides, gber lines abe majob stbeams, white lines abe boads) including locations of sedimentabr pbofiles (letebs, see Fig. 3) and excavated pits (numbebs, see Fig. 4). Abb. 1: Übebblic übeb das Untebsuiungsgebiet. a) Lage deb Qebbada de Pubmamabca in Südamebika. b) Geogbaphisieb Kontext und Topogbaphie des Untebsuiungsgebietes (siwabze Linie kennzeiinet die Einzugsgebietgbenze, gbaue Linie kennzeiinet die Hauptgebinne, weisse Linie kennzeiinet Stbassen) einsiliesslii deb Lage deb Sedimentpbofile (Buistaben, siehe Abb. 3) und Bodenpbofile (Nummebn, siehe Abb. 4).
the coincidence of landslide deposits and lake damming in bitz 1999; Zipprich et al. 2000; Ahumada 2002; Haselton, various intramontane valleys in NW Argentina (Trauth et Hilley & Strecker 2002; Kull et al. 2003; Kull et al. al. 2000; Bookhagen, Haselton & Trauth 2001; Trauth 2008). On Holocene timescales, the analysis of sedimentary et al. 2003; Hermanns & Schellenberger 2008), and may and arcaeological arcives along the Qebrada de Humacorrelate to prominent lake transgression phases on the Bo- huaca and in the Eastern Cordillera has produced manifold livian Altiplano during the last glacial cycle (Argollo & evidence for variations in precipitation amounts and distriMourguiart 2000; Baker et al. 2001; Baker et al. 2001; Fritz bution with a marked dry phase during the Mid-Holocene et al. 2004; Placzek, Quade & Patchett 2006). In higher el- and the return to modern, semi-arid conditions within the evations, mapping and modelling efforts on mainly glacial last 2 ka BP (Fernández 1984; Alcalde & Kulemeyer 1999; but also periglacial arcives have documented evidence for Kulemeyer et al. 1999; Maas et al. 1999; Kulemeyer 2005; severe temperature reductions in NW Argentina, whic trig- Yacobaccio & Morales 2005; Lupo et al. 2006).
- gered the decrease of vegetation belts and snowlines, and
- Most of these results are based on the detailed analysis of
multiple glacial advances in the Late Qaternary (Schä- a single arcive or location. Only very few studies have fo-
E&G / Vol. 59 / No. 1–2 / 2010 / 21–35 / DOI 10.3285/eg.59.1-2.02 / © Authors / Creative Commons Attribution License
22
cused on a comprehensive documentation and interpretation anchi & Yañez 1992; Garreaud & Aceituno 2007). Due to of the extensive geomorphological records, whic are stored topographic and rain shadow effects, however, precipitation in the landscape of the intramontane basins in NW Argentina amounts may significantly vary at regional and local scales, (Werner 1984; Tchilinguirian & Pereyra 2001; May 2008). and average 96 mm at the village of Purmamarca (Bianchi Consequently, relatively liüle is known with regard to the & Yañez 1992; Endlicher 1995; Soler 2002). Temperatures relative importance of paleoclimate and paleoenvironmental in the study area are very variable and particularly at high canges, and their imprints and controls on landscape evolu- elevations, the thermal amplitude shows very strong daily tion and geomorphic processes over different timescales. An variations. Consequently, the annual average height of the improved understanding of landforms and their evolution at 0°-isotherm is subject to regional and even local variations and beyond catcment scale is also the base for the assess- and has been estimated between 4500 and 5400 m asl, while ment and management of modern local geomorphic proc- the regional annual temperature gradients in NW Argentina esses. is is of particular importance in the Qebrada de roughly average 0.5–0.6°/100 m (Prohaska 1976; Ruthsatz Purmamarca as a key location for intercontinental transport, 1977; Fox & Strecker 1991).
- tourism and cultural heritage throughout Argentina.
- Under these environmental conditions modern pedo-
us, this study aims to i) document the geomorphic, genesis is relatively weak, leading to the formation of thin sedimentary and paleopedogenic arcives in the Qebrada Ah-horizons and carbonate accumulation in the subsoil as de Purmamarca, and ii) discuss their relative timing and the dominant pedogenic processes (Werner 1971; Ruthsatz paleoenvironmental significance. ereby, the study es- 1977). Most other, more intensively developed soil horizons tablishes a framework of regional landscape evolution and are probably relics of weüer past climatic conditions (Krisl contributes to our understanding of the mecanisms and 1999). e morphodynamic situation in the Qebrada de controls of geological, geomorphic and climatic cange Purmamarca is dominated by strong badland formation and over different Late Qaternary timescales in NW Argen- gullying along and up the valley slopes, having led to flood-
- tina.
- plain aggradation and intense debris flow dynamics over the
last decades (Becker 1966; Aguero 1986; Chayle & Wayne 1995; Cencetti, Rivelli & Tacconi 2006). roughout the entire Qebrada de Humahuaca drainage basin, human im-
2. Study Area
e Qebrada de Purmamarca is a ~380 km2 drainage basin pact has likely enhanced the degradation of vegetation cover in the province of Jujuy, NW Argentina (Fig. 1). It is locat- and slopes since at least two thousand years (García Coed in the Eastern Cordillera of the Andes, whic forms the dron et al. 1999; Lupo et al. 2006). transition between the high-altitude plateau of the Puna to the west, and Subandean Ranges and Chaco lowland to the 3. Methods east. Geologically, the Eastern Cordillera is an active foldand thrust belt (Mon & Salfity 1995). Topographic ranges e major part of this study is based on the documentaare usually associated with high angle thrust faults, whic tion of geomorphological and sedimentological field work, are responsible for the development of asymmetric valleys whic was carried out between Marc and June 2001. Geoalong the lines of structural weakness (Igarzábal 1991). Sev- morphological field work encompassed the thorough and eral superimposed Paleozoic and Mesozoic tectonic stages GPS aided mapping of landforms and processes in all acare recognized, before major upliſt and deformation of the cessible parts of the catcment. In combination with reAndean orogeny commenced ~10 Ma ago, ultimately result- mote sensing data, this information was subsequently ing in the present structural and topographic framework of compiled and illustrated in a geomorphological map of the the Eastern Cordillera (Mon & Salfity 1995; Salfity et al. Qebrada de Purmamarca (May 2008).
- 1996; Kennan 2000; Reynolds et al. 2000; Reynolds et al.
- Sedimentological description and the classification of the
2001). Significant neotectonic events, whic have locally de- mostly coarse-grained valley fill deposits in the Qebrada formed and thrusted Qaternary sediments, did probably not de Purmamarca were predominantly based on existing apaffect NW Argentina syncronously, but generally occurred proaces by (Nemec & Steel 1984; Milana 1994; Miall 1996; >1 Ma ago throughout the Eastern Cordillera (Salfity et Nemec & Kazanci 1999), resulting in the differentiation of al. 1984; Strecker et al. 1989; Marrett & Strecker 2000; six different sedimentary facies (Table 1). Sedimentary proHilley & Strecker 2005). As an important factor for local files of terrace and alluvial fan outcrops were established at variability of erosional resistance, the main lithologies in the 13 different locations along gully walls. Plant remains exQebrada de Purmamarca comprise moderately soſt quartz- tracted from one profile were dated by AMS radiocarbon itic scists, phyllites and slates of the Precambrian Punco- dating at the University of Kiel, Germany (code KIA 17090).
- viscana Formation, the highly resistant quartzitic sandstones
- At 12 locations excavated pits and outcrops were docu-
and quartzites of the Cambrian Mesón Group, and the eas- mented on top of the terrace and alluvial fan surfaces in orily erodible pelites and greywaces of the Ordovician Santa der to gain information on soils, paleosols and cover deposVictoria Group (Ramos, Turic & Zuzek 1967; Turner 1970; its. e field documentation of these pits was based on FAO
Amengual & Zanettini 1974).
guidelines (FAO 2006), and the presence of CaCO3 was test-
e regional climate of NW Argentina is mainly influ- ed with 10% HCl. Finally, thin sections from carbonate and enced by tropical humid air masses of Atlantic origin, whic sand crusts were taken. eir micromorphological analysis are transported into the area by the South American Summer focussed on paleopedological features and the interpretation Monsoon, accounting for the large seasonality with most of of genetic processes of soil formation following FitzPatrick the total annual precipitation falling in austral summer (Bi- (1993) and Wilson & Nettleton (2009).
E&G / Vol. 59 / No. 1–2 / 2010 / 21–35 / DOI 10.3285/eg.59.1-2.02 / © Authors / Creative Commons Attribution License
23
4. Results
e exposed internal arcitecture of slope sediments likely reflects i) the onset of dominant permafrost conditions with intensified mecanical weathering of autocthonous (Precambrian) lithologies, and ii) the successive
4. 1. Geomorphological context and landforms
ree contrasting geomorphological zones are generally downslope transport and layered deposition of allocdistinguished throughout the Eastern Cordillera and dif- thonous frost debris (of Cambrian lithologies) by soliffer considerably with regard to their relief, i.e. topography luction processes, eventually smoothening a pre-existing and altitude (Fig. 2a). Eac zone comprises a typical suite of topography, whic had formed during a preceding phase genetic landforms and geomorphic processes (SEGEMAR- of enhanced fluvial processes. e marked dominance of
- ITGE 1998; Tchilinguirian & Pereyra 2001; May 2008).
- Cambrian quarzitic lithologies over Precambrian scists
i) e highest parts of the study area above ~4400–4500 m and phyllites results from their higher resistivity against asl are caracterized by steep, straight to concave slopes cryogenic weathering (e.g. frost cracing) and predisposiof 25°–40°, locally up to 50° inclination, covered by long tion for the production of frost debris, also implying their tongues of roc debris of different colours and lithologies preferential preservation in the sedimentary record. e extending downslope from crests, cliffs and ridges. ese lowermost evidence for past periglacial processes in the observations indicate active and intense production of study area are asymmetrically developed slopes, whic frost debris and effective downslope transport by shallow caracterize the drainage cannels on top of the higher, solifluction processes, pointing to the presence of perma- older terrace segments and reflect preferential solifluction frost and frequent (daily to seasonal) freeze-thaw cycles. processes along the north-exposed slopes as the result of Solifluction lobes were observed in the study area down past periglacial processes down to ~3100 m asl (May 2002).
- to ~4000–4100 m asl, where they are partially stabilized by
- ii) e transition between the upper catcment of predom-
vegetation. eir lower limit typically represents a transi- inantly periglacial geomorphology and the valleys is caractional belt caracterized by the discontinuous and spatial- terized by straight to convex slope segments (Fig. 2a). Most ly variable occurrence of freeze-thaw related active proc- of these slopes between ~2600 and 3800 m asl are strongly esses. us, over longer timescales, dominant cryogenic or dissected by parallel and closely spaced single-branced rills periglacial processes are responsible for the formation of and gullies of variable depth. A knicpoint marks their upsthe gentle, rectilinear to convexo-concavo debris-mantled lope initiation and actively ongoing headward growth. It coslopes of markedly smooth morphology, whic caracter- incides with the transition from convex and debris-covered ize mountain tops and mountain cains in the upper study periglacial mountain tops described above to the steeper, area and are referred to as ‘Glaühangg (glaü = smooth, straight slope segments where overland flow concentrates. hang = slope) in the German literature (Fig. 2a; Hagedorn Most of these cannels have adjusted to inactive terrace sur1970; Stingl & Garleff 1983; Abraham de Vazquez et faces, and only a few larger cannels drain onto the modal. 2000; Ahumada 2002). In the Qebrada de Purmamarca, ern floodplain. e onset of slope dissection should therefore the lower limit of this type of periglacial slope morphol- postdate terrace deposition and may have commenced synogy varies to some extent, e.g. due to dissection by ongo- cronously with terrace incision and degradation. e high ing erosional processes, but reaces well below the limit intensity of slope dissection observed today is possibly amof active periglacial processes to an elevation of 3300 m plified by grazing and degradation of vegetation leading to asl (Fig. 2a). As exposed along several roadcuts, the debris an additional increase in surface runoff, gullying and signifi- covering the slopes above ~3300 m asl is composed of an- cant contributions of sediment to the valley floors (Aguero gular clasts but varies considerably in thicness from few 1986; Cencetti, Rivelli & Tacconi 2006). In addition, severdecimeters to >10 m. e sediments show a clear stratifica- al landslides of up to 0.07 km2 were mapped along the lower tion of relatively fine clasts of the underlying dark grey valley slopes both within the terrace deposits and bedroc Precambrian scist at the base, and several subhorizontal (Fig. 2c; May 2002). Some of the landslides are partly buried layers of coarse, poorly sorted and angular clasts of mainly by modern floodplain deposits and must have formed within Cambrian quartzites whic are supported by a fine-grained an oversteepened valley, whic was probably created in re-
- matrix (Fig. 2b).
- lation to rapid and profound incision preceding the onset of
renewed floodplain aggradation.