FLASHPOINTS: THE 2015 ELECTIONS IN

Issue Ten: 17 Mar 2015 Days to Presidential Poll: 11 Days to Governor and House of Representatives Poll: 25

“IT’S OUR FUTURE. NO VIOLENCE. JUST VOTE”

2Face, Oritsefemi and Chidinma

Popular Nigerian music It is believed that the Many members are recruited to stars 2Face, Oritsefemi and reoccurrence of violent cult the cult gangs from secondary Chidinma have come together clashes is driven by politicians schools, so a peace pledge to speak out against violence in that depend on some to do their from prominent musicians will Nigeria’s 2015 elections. In the dirty jobs, rewarding them with hopefully connect with the public service announcement immunity and cash rewards. youth and show them that developed with BBC Media violence does not pay. Action, the stars pledge is that While it is not clear if the “It’s our future. No violence. proliferation of weapons in the SDN have developed the Niger Just vote.” region is a direct consequence, Delta Watch platform which it is clear that the two factors documents reports of electoral The vibrant, competitive combined will be deadly. Last violence. To explore the reports media sector in the country weekend alone there were at from across the Niger Delta in has helped to engage voters, least 12 deaths confirmed from more detail, visit promote peaceful elections, cult clashes in Port Harcourt. www.nigerdeltawatch.org and provide platforms for the public to question leaders on most pressing issues. SDN has been working closely with local radio stations in Rivers State on programming, debate content and announcements.

Rivers State Violence Tensions in Rivers State have escalated in the run up to the elections, which is notorious for clashes between the two main cult groups – the Icelanders and the Greenlanders - engaged in a battle of supremacy over who controls Port Harcourt, the state capital, and its environs. Rivers Gubernatorial Candidates Set to Engage in Debate

After adjustments to political developments in Nigeria, and specifically in Rivers state, The Rivers Debate 2015 has been scheduled to hold by 06:00pm on Monday, 23 March 2015. The Rivers debate, which will set the precedent in the race for the seat of governor in the state, is an initiative of Stakeholder Democracy Network (SDN), the Rivers Entrepreneurs and Investors Forum (REIF), and talkback news and current affairs radio station NigeriaInfo 92.3 Port Harcourt. The initiative was borne out of the organizers’ desire to raise the standard for individuals and political parties vying to direct the ship of governance in the state. In the elections of 1999, 2003, 2007 and 2011, citizen- aspirant/candidate engagement deviated from critical issues and dwelt on parochial considerations and sentiments and attacks on opponents’ character and private lives. Vote soliciting at best was at open air rallies where the candidates only spoke and never entertained questions from prospective voters. Sixteen years on, the experience has not improved. Political analysts are almost unanimous that never in an election season in Nigeria have politicians strayed from issues as they are doing in the 2015 election season. A Platform for Issues citizens would require a focused Their opinion draws from and controlled forum to quiz frightening evidence of attacks As a result, a significant the various candidates’ on their on rivals at rallies and in the number of potential voters are plans for critical sectors on the media. In many instances the undecided on where to swing bases of which they might pick a personal attacks have graduated their votes. These disappointed candidate to give their votes. to violent attacks that have led to incapacitation and deaths. The situation is particularly worse in Rivers State, where in almost two years the major political parties and candidates have deployed undemocratic strategies, including hiring armed thugs to disrupt opponent’s public events and attack their supporters. Almost 40 politically motivated deaths have been recorded in the state by National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) since December 2014.

(Right) Citizens were able to engage with aspirants at the previous live radio roundtableorganized by SDN These concerns therefore (APC) and Labour Party (LP) the candidates explain how informed the organizers’ in an intellectual discussion they intend to improve citizens’ decision to put together a with focus on the Economy, welfare and determine a debate where the candidates will Security, and Open Governance preferred candidate, the records engage each other to articulate - sectors that are critical to the of the commitments made their plans and how they intend development of the state. by the candidates will form to achieve them. In the past post-election accountability civil society organizations have It will take the candidates engagements that the focused more on Presidential away from situations where organizers will carry out as Debates. This season, debates personal attacks happen freely, follow-up to the debate. for governorship candidates and engage their problem- have been given equal priority solving ability. The debate will and the Rivers Debate 2015 is be broadcast live on a national much anticipated. television- Channels TV and on NigeriaInfo 92.3. The debate will bring the gubernatorial candidates of While the event will afford the Peoples’ Democratic Party yet-to-decide members of the (PDP), All Progressives Congress electorate the chance to see

In a welcomed move, the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) has launched an open-all-hours service to advise citizens on all voting-related queries. INEC LAUNCHES 24/7 HOTLINE Whether individuals have lost their Permanent Voter’s Card (PVC), or are having difficulty locating their collection centre, the all new ‘7411’ National Directory Service aims to answer thousands of different frequently asked questions. Calls cost N12/minute, as approved by the NCC. However, when called at the time of writing – from both Glo (the ‘official directory partner in accurate information’ and MTN networks – the service could not be reached. Hopefully this is a momentary glitch and INEC can make up for the lack of education and sensitisation of voters, as many prospective voters encountered recently are still in the dark regarding the most basic procedures.

PVC Distribution Update • 55,904,272 or 81.22 percent distributed

81.2% •12,929,204 Permanent Voter’s Cards (PVCs) yet to be collected 78.9 % 80.6% • 68,833,476 PVCs produced for people on the national register of voters

• 22 March is the new PVC collection deadline, 6 days before 75.9 % 75.6 % the election

(left) PVC distribution since the original date set for the presidential election (14th Feb) has remained linear following the postponement IN FOCUS: ELECTIONS AND MEDIA INTEGRITY IN THE 2015 ELECTIONS

Amid the preparations for Informing Citizens Setting the Agenda conducting free and fair elections in March, the media – Front and foremost, the media But being the gatekeeper to the the Fourth Estate of the Realm is a public forum for ideas and content of the public debate – is one critical stakeholder discussion. It is the primary does not ascribe the media whose behaviour must not be avenue for the public to know the power to determine what ignored. what is going on with a view to we actually think, but it can better understanding. determine what we are thinking Indeed, analysis of media about. coverage in past Nigerian Democracy requires the active The capability lies in the elections has been damning. The participation of citizens. It is presentation content and Commonwealth Observer Group therefore the duty of the media style of reporting – such said in its report on the 2007 to provide accurate information as repeated coverage and elections that “significant state and objective reporting sensationalised tone – which ownership of the broadcast and analysis to educate and raises the importance of an media negatively impacted on engage citizens in the business issue in the public mind-set. This and influenced the coverage in of governance, who can in endows influence over what favour of incumbents’ parties” turn move the public debate issues society regards as being forwards through their informed important at any point in time. Similarly, in the 2011 elections participation. coverage of most state-owned Marriage with Politics media appeared to favour (Below) Defamatory adverts with little incumbent parties and censor basis appear in National print press daily What the media reports can criticism of the government, therefore set the agenda for according to EU observation political campaigns. Coverage of mission. 80% of the Nigerian the ebola pandemic naturally led Television Authority’s (NTA) to scrutiny of national healthcare coverage allocated to political provisions, just as declining oil actors was devoted to PDP, price and currency devaluation has steered discussions towards and rejected General Buhari’s proposals to diversify the (CPC) campaign ad because economy. it contained messages they deemed ‘offensive to the In addition, they have the choice government’ to include or omit coverage of party political events, statements The overall role of media in made at press conferences, election coverage is an issue or messages from candidates that has generated debate and during campaigns. controversy internationally. It is therefore beyond the scope of ‘Brown Envelope’ Press this article to try and define it, but we can discuss the power of Unfortunately however, the the media and outline how it is typical journalist in Nigeria is not vulnerable to exploitation in the driven by the aforementioned electoral process in Nigeria. duties.

Professional journalists are paid low salaries by their employers, with payment withheld for many months not a rarity. According to writer and novelist, Adaobi Tricia Nwaubani, bosses justify non-payment of salaries by saying “I’ve given you a platform to make money. Use it.” Adaobi is referring here to the practice of ‘brown envelope’ journalism, whereby press briefings and political events are followed by handing out of envelopes stuffed with cash to journalists. This may be viewed as an extension of the national culture of ‘the dash’, which Peter Enahoro describes as “the sweetly quaint custom of expressing gratitude in anticipation of services about to be rendered.” We therefore cannot expect the average Nigerian journalist to be fair in the presentation of factsIf not, even the work of the most Harassment Fanatics are picturesque, tenacious investigative reporters mankind would rather see get pushed to the sidelines. While the lack of financial support to journalists is creating gestures than listen to ‘Jukebox Journalism’ opportunities for ‘jukebox reasons. journalism’, the lack of legal The global phenomenon of and security support further While elections in themselves corporate media is reliant on endangers the integrity of the are only one element of commercial partners for financial profession. democracy, they create the sustainability, and has often basis for democratic governance been accused of supressing When the media becomes the by ensuring that leaders have stories that may compromise the target of reprisal from powerful credible and accepted mandates lucrative arrangement. groups and individuals who to govern. When people have the benefit from the silence of a opportunity to participate freely In Nigeria the most regular muzzled press, journalists need in public life and choose their funding for advertisements to be protected by laws that leaders through a free and open comes from political parties. guarantee their rights and to process, they are less likely to With up to one-third of total unify to monitor, protest and feel a need to resort to violence pages devoted to campaign raise public outrage against the to resolve their differences or to adverts it becomes clear that attacks on journalists. make their voices heard. influence may be enough to keep damaging stories off the front This practice pushes even the page of established newspapers. most tenacious investigative reporters to the side-lines. Access to Journalists “I’VE The Fourth Estate Those involved in the political power struggle in Nigeria are The media is the responsive GIVEN usually the rich and privileged. organ that can help build peace With media coverage reliant on and social consensus, without payments, many politicians with which democracy is threatened. YOU A financial weight – either with Instead, in Nigeria the media seemingly unlimited campaign has been observed as fanning funding or the backing of their the flames of discord by taking PLATFORM personal private ventures - have sides, reinforcing prejudices, and had undue access to the mass muddling facts with half-truths. media. Elections will come and go but TO MAKE Nigeria will remain - remain These same people on account as what? The fundamental of their prominence have tended parts that constitute a MONEY. to abuse their free access functioning democracy must with unmetered production be strengthened otherwise it is of campaign adverts and all just a superficial display to contradictory statements, satisfy observers. USE IT.” thereby confusing the electorate. SENATOR IMPLICATED IN EKITI RIGGING TAPE CLEARED AS MINISTER

Former Nigerian Ambassador Obanikoro’s confirmation. He “We wonder whether we want to to and Minister of State said he had not been served, grow democracy in this country for Defence, Musiliu Obanikoro, and cannot act on a newspaper or whether we want to destroy has been confirmed minister report. it. Rule of the senate forbids it of the Federal Republic of not to act on any issue in court Nigeria despite allegations of As a statement of intent, the but the Senate leadership had involvement in election rigging. lawmakers rejected the ruling by ignored this. walking out of the chamber. In the tape, Obanikoro is alleged “Nigerians are being deceived to be ordering for military Leader of the caucus, George by the behaviour of the senate. control of voting and lays out the Akume, told press, “The alleged They do not want to listen to us specific tactics to be employed action, is a breach of the and this is highly unfortunate to make sure that the People’s constitution. In a civilised world, and we are very disappointed in Democratic Party (PDP) won the his name should not have come the action of our leadership.” Ekiti Governorship election in up for screening in the first June 2014. place. Hence, we are all opposed to him.” Some senators vehemently “THE opposed the confirmation, Breach of Senate including Bukola Saraki, Olugbenga Ashafa, Babajide Akume argued that the Senate ALLEGED Omoworare, George Akume, President had altered the rules Olubunmi Adetunmbi, Ali of the Senate, which states that ACTION, IS Ndume, and Ganiyu Solomon. any nominee rejected by at least two senators from his state of The reason they gave was that origin should not be cleared. A BREACH Obanikoro was implicated in “very sensitive issues that touch “The three senators from OF THE on national interest,” and is opposed the nomination of tangled in court cases. Obanikoro but the Senate President and his PDP colleagues CONSTITUTION” Senate President , decided to take the advantage of who presided over the plenary, their numbers to override what is strongly resisted all appeals supposed to be basically a very and arguments made by the straight forward issue,” he said. opposition lawmakers against DIGITAL DEMOCRACY

Digital democracy is a long “Elections may not be won on Furthermore, the number of way off for even the most social media but perceptions active social media accounts is established democracies, but are shaped here,” says Japeth. J. equivalent to roughly 7% of the people are starting to notice Omojuwa, political commentator total population. Many of these and test the potential for new and social media expert. On will be below 18 years of age, technologies to improve the elections he argues that “The and therefore not currently able political process in Nigeria. die is cast and social media is to participate by voting. Nigeria’s new battleground.” The internet can play a vital role in the electoral process because The space for dialogue and of its interactivity, relatively low discussion is promising, but the costs of entry and freedom from potential for discrimination and state control. unregulated misinformation is worrying. “THE DIE IS The internet population of Nigeria is roughly 70.3 million, “What degree of responsibility or around 38% penetration of or norms will be in demand CAST AND the country. While still relatively from a platform of delivery low – in the United Kingdom that is based on social media 86% of the population are online and algorithms? The so-called SOCIAL – the rate of internet access is algorithm accountability,” asks increasing rapidly in Nigeria. The Dap Olorunyomi, the Editor-in- number of active internet users Chief of Premium Times. MEDIA IS has more than doubled from 31 million in 2009, and growth “With the advent of the citizen between January 2014 – 2015 journalists as news gatherers, NIGERIA’S was at 26 percent. how do we take care of critical concerns about sourcing, Social Media authenticity and, above all, NEW fairness? One area of serious potential is in social media. As of a count “What happens to verification BATTLE in January 2015, there are 13.6 in the wake of the now relaxed million active social media editing standards that come with accounts in Nigeria. digital first via social media and GROUND.” twitter in particular?” he asked. FOR ELECTION UPDATES AND TO REPORT YOUR PERSONAL OBSERVATIONS, STAY IN TOUCH WITH SDN

Across the 2015 elections cycle you can report incidents you observe in your area to SDN.

The SDN network is spread across every LGA across Delta, Bayelsa and Rivers State, and will aim to respond to verified reports of incidents within the shortest possible time. This initial response will be followed by a number of positive steps for resolution where appropriate.

SDN has experience working with communities on tackling election related violence. Our aim is to help communities voice their experiences with the election process, whether good or bad.

There are a number of ways you can send a report:

1. ONLINE at www.nigerdeltawatch.org under the ‘Submit a Report’ tab

2. ANDROID download the ‘Ushahidi’ app and search for the map ‘Niger Delta Watch’

3. TWITTER to our twitter handle @SDNNigerDelta

4. EMAIL to [email protected]

5. SMS to 0701 067 9724

We will be circulating regular updates on elections and educational materials. Please keep in touch by following www.stakeholderdemocracy.org

Written by Stakeholder Democracy Network: