Compilation and Analysis of Types and Concentrations of Airborne 3 Chemicals Measured in Various Indoor and Outdoor Human 4 Environments 5 6 7 8 9 1 2 10 J
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Chemosphere,127,70-86,2015 1 2 Compilation and Analysis of Types and Concentrations of Airborne 3 Chemicals Measured in Various Indoor and Outdoor Human 4 Environments 5 6 7 8 9 1 2 10 J. Enrique Cometto-Muñiz and Michael H. Abraham 11 1 12 University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, California, USA and 2 13 Department of Chemistry, University College London, London, UK 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Address for correspondence: 21 22 J. Enrique Cometto-Muñiz, Ph.D. 23 Research Scientist Emeritus, UCSD 24 8950 Villa La Jolla Drive, Suite C135 25 La Jolla, CA 92037 26 USA 27 28 29 Phone: (858) 622-5832 30 e-mail: [email protected] 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 Running head: Airborne Chemical Concentrations Indoors and Outdoors 41 1 41 Abstract 42 43 The main purpose of this article is to summarize and illustrate the results of a literature search on 44 the types, levels, relative concentrations, concentration spread of individual chemicals, and number of 45 airborne compounds (mostly volatile organic compounds, VOCs) that have been found, measured, and 46 reported both indoors and outdoors. Two broad categories of indoor environments are considered: 1) 47 Home/School, and 2) Commercial spaces. Also, two categories of outdoor environments are considered: 48 1) Non-industrial and 2) Industrial (the latter represented by the vicinity of a pig farm and the vicinity of an 49 oil refinery). The outcome is presented as a series of graphs and tables containing the following statistics: 50 geometric mean, arithmetic mean, median, standard deviation, variance, standard error, interquartile 51 distance, minimum value, maximum value, and number of data (data count) for the air concentration of 52 each reported compound in a given environment. A Supplementary Table allows interested readers to 53 match each single value included in this compilation with its corresponding original reference. 54 55 56 Keywords: Environmental Chemical Exposures - Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC) – Home/School 57 VOC Concentrations – Commercial Buildings VOC Concentrations – Outdoor VOC 58 Concentrations 59 2 59 1. Introduction 60 61 Humans are exposed to a wide variety of airborne chemicals both indoors and outdoors. Acute 62 awareness of such exposures often arises from chemosensory sensations, principally odor, nasal 63 chemesthesis (i.e., nasal pungency or irritation), and ocular chemesthesis (i.e., eye irritation). These 64 human chemosensations are the focus of our research interest (Cometto-Muniz and Abraham, 2008, 65 2010a; Cometto-Muñiz et al., 2010), with special emphasis on the search for quantitative structure-activity 66 relationships in terms of detection thresholds (Abraham et al., 2003; Abraham et al., 2007, 2012; Abraham 67 et al., 2010; Cometto-Muniz and Abraham, 2010b; Cometto-Muniz et al., 2005). In general, no matter what 68 the particular focus might be for the study of environmental chemical exposures, previous knowledge of 69 the kind and levels of airborne compounds that have been found in different types of broad environments 70 constitute an important piece of information. This reasoning led us to mine the scientific literature for data 71 on the types and concentration-ranges of airborne chemicals that have been found and measured in 72 indoor and outdoor environments. The questions addressed include: What compounds have been found in 73 various types of indoor and outdoor environments? At what concentrations where they found? Which 74 compounds are common to different indoor environments and which to different outdoor environments? 75 Which compounds are common between indoor and outdoor environments? For compounds common to 76 two environments, in which are they higher and by what concentration ratio? What spread of 77 concentrations have been reported for a given compound within and across these various environments? 78 This compilation presents the gathered data in the form of illustrative graphs and tables and can serve as 79 a useful and practical information guide for a wide range of investigators interested in the many aspects of 80 the topic. 81 82 83 2. Materials and Methods 84 3 85 Two main databases were used to collect data: PubMed (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed) 86 and Web of Knowledge (https://apps.webofknowledge.com). The search terms entered alone and in 87 combination included, among others: “Air Pollution”, “Air Pollution, Indoor”, “Volatile Organic Compounds”, 88 “Environmental Exposure”, “VOC levels”. Some of these terms were searched on PubMed via the MeSH 89 (Medical Subject Headings) from the NLM (National Library of Medicine) controlled vocabulary thesaurus. 90 From this literature search, 47 references were selected by focusing on those articles tracking a large 91 number of volatiles, typically more than a dozen, and by filtering the results by “Species: Humans”. The set 92 contained quantitative data on the concentration and identity of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), and 93 other airborne chemicals, present in a variety of indoor and outdoor environments. The geographical 94 distribution of the studies was very broad. It included areas and cities in the United States, European 95 Union (north, central and south countries), Japan, China (Hong Kong), Taiwan, Korea, Australia and 96 Argentina (La Plata). The references are listed at the end of this article under the title “Data Sources 97 References”, but readers interested in consulting the specific citation for each single value used in this 98 compilation can do so in a Supplementary Table accessible on the web. These papers constituted the 99 source to calculate the following statistics: geometric mean, arithmetic mean, median, standard deviation, 100 variance, standard error, interquartile distance, minimum value, maximum value, and number of data (data 101 count) for the air concentration of each reported compound in a given environment. The values presented 102 immediately below are geometric means across studies that measured a particular compound in a specific 103 environment (Tables 1 to 4, and Figures 1 to 6). In fact, as a rule, each value reported in a given study 104 was itself an average of a number of measurements. In this review, initial selection of the geometric mean 105 served to minimize the excessive weight on the mean of occasional extreme high or low individual values. 106 Further into the article, when analyzing the range of values reported for each chemical in specific 107 environments (Tables 5 to 7, and Figures 7 to 8), the rest of the statistical parameters mentioned above 108 are introduced. 109 110 3. Results and Discussion 111 4 112 3.1. Indoors 113 114 Indoor environments comprised two broad categories: 1) Home and School, and 2) Commercial. 115 The first category included homes new and old, with and without air quality complaints, homes and 116 schools located in industrial, urban, suburban, residential, semi-rural and rural environments. The second 117 category included car cabins, restaurants (non-smoking, smoking, and both), stores, non-residential 118 spaces (offices and non-offices) and newspaper stands. It did NOT include the air inside a pig farm’s 119 fattening house. 120 121 In the home/school environments, 152 volatiles were measured and reported (Figure 1, left side). 122 22 of them (14%) were present at concentrations ranging from approximately 10 to 200 µg/m3. 44 123 compounds (29%) were present at concentrations ranging from about 3 to 10 µg/m3. Another 44 124 substances (29%) were present at concentrations ranging from 0.55 to about 3 µg/m3. The remaining 42 125 chemicals (28%) were present at concentrations ranging from 0.01 to about 0.55 µg/m3. 126 5 1000 1000 Indoor Home/School GeoMean(!g/m3) Indoor Commercial GeoMean(!g/m3) VOCs 1 to 22 VOCs 1 to 22 g/m3) g/m3) ! ! ( ( 100 100 Concentration Concentration Mean Mean 10 10 Geometric Geometric 126 Ethanol Toluene Nonanal Xylenes Acetone 3-Carene Ammonia 1-Butanol n-Decane Limonene Isobutane n-Heptane VOC Ethanol Toluene 2-Propanol Nicotine Acetone Acetic Acid p-Xylene Isoprene m-Xylene Ammonia Ethylacetate Dodecane VOC Acetaldehyde m/p-Xylene Formaldehyde Ethylacetate Propylene glycol Acetaldehyde Formaldehyde Isobutyl acetate Nonane (n-Nonane) Tetrahydrofuran Dichloromethane Tetrachloroethylene 1,1,1-Trichloroethane 1,2,4-Trichlorobenzene Methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) MTBE (methyl tert-butyl ether) 2-(2-Ethoxyethoxy) ethanol Isobutylketone (diisobutyl ketone) Isopropyl alcohol (Isopropanol) Trichlorofluoromethane (Freon 11) 10 10 Indoor Home/School GeoMean(!g/m3) Indoor Commercial GeoMean(!g/m3) VOCs 23 to 66 VOCs 23 to 66 8 8 g/m3) g/m3) ! ! 6 6 4 4 I 2 2 n d Indoor Commercial GeoMean( Indoor Home/School GeoMean( o 0 0 o r H o m e Xylene Octanal Xylene Heptanal Isoprene p-Xylene n-Octane n-Hexane Nonanal Xylenes Isooctane Dodecane / Benzene o-Xylene n-Octane Isopentane Camphene n-Decane n-Hexane 1-Butanol m/p-Xylene Limonene n-Heptane Nitrous acid n-Tridecane n-Undecane Chloroform alpha-Pinene Cyclohexane Acetic Acid 2-Butanone n-Undecane Hexanoic acid Benzaldehyde S Cyclohexane alpha-Pinene Ethylbenzene Ethylene glycol n-Butyl acetate 1,3-Butadiene Hexanoic acid Benzaldehyde p-Chlorotoluene Trichloroethene m-Chlorotoluene n-Butyl acetate 1,2-Propanediol Trichloroethylene Furfuryl aldehyde 3-Ethenylpyridine Methylcyclohexane 2-Methyl-1-propanol 2-Ethoxyethylactate 1,1-Dichloropropene Cyclopropylbenzene 2,3-Dimethylpentane 2,4-Dimethylpentane Methylcyclohexane Dichlorofluoromethane Hexaldehyde (Hexanal) 1,2,4-Trimethylbenzene c Dichlorodifluoromethane 2,2,4-Trimethylpentane