Butlers of the Mohawk Valley: Family Traditions and the Establishment of British Empire in Colonial New York
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Syracuse University SURFACE Dissertations - ALL SURFACE December 2015 Butlers of the Mohawk Valley: Family Traditions and the Establishment of British Empire in Colonial New York Judd David Olshan Syracuse University Follow this and additional works at: https://surface.syr.edu/etd Part of the Arts and Humanities Commons Recommended Citation Olshan, Judd David, "Butlers of the Mohawk Valley: Family Traditions and the Establishment of British Empire in Colonial New York" (2015). Dissertations - ALL. 399. https://surface.syr.edu/etd/399 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the SURFACE at SURFACE. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations - ALL by an authorized administrator of SURFACE. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Abstract: Butlers of the Mohawk Valley: Family Traditions and the Establishment of British Empire in Colonial New York Historians follow those tributaries of early American history and trace their converging currents as best they may in an immeasurable river of human experience. The Butlers were part of those British imperial currents that washed over mid Atlantic America for the better part of the eighteenth century. In particular their experience reinforces those studies that recognize the impact that the Anglo-Irish experience had on the British Imperial ethos in America. Understanding this ethos is as crucial to understanding early America as is the Calvinist ethos of the Massachusetts Puritan or the Republican ethos of English Wiggery. We don't merely suppose the Butlers are part of this tradition because their story begins with Walter Butler, a British soldier of the Imperial Wars in America. We don't assume it because his son, John Butler and grandson, Walter Butler were Tories and Loyalists during the American Revolution. An imperial identity was one that they claimed for themselves in a country where other, alternative identities were possible. For the Butlers, the British imperial ethos informed the nature of their careers, their wealth, and the manner in which they were socially connected to other Americans. It is manifest in their claim of ancestral connection to the Butler-Ormonde family, a fountain of Anglo-Irish leaders for centuries. It is manifest in Walter Butler’s career on the garrisons of the New York frontier, at Fort Hunter and Oswego. It is manifest in the type of wealth the Butlers amassed and the traditions passed down to Walter Butler’s sons. Lastly it is manifest in the part the John Butler played in the transformation of a frontier garrison to an English county within the British Empire. They are not merely representative of the way an imperial ethos impacted early America, they are important as well for the lasting impression that they in particular made on the English frontier of New York. A close look at the Butler family reveals a reality of the frontier largely ignored in previous works. That the imperial frontier embodied colonial ideals not often realized to its full extent. That the advantages that came from being part of the imperial frontier could be significant, but were often contingent on circumstances beyond the reach of those that commanded frontier posts. That competing colonial interests festered for years before the American Revolution. Finally, That the British Indian Department, long thought of as not only the personal creation of folk legend Sir William Johnson but a bulwark of imperial strength on the New York frontier, was much weaker than earlier supposed, in terms of the ability to direct Indian peoples and control frontier settlement by European peoples. The Butlers amassed great wealth and power over three generations on the New York frontier, lost much to imperial and civil war, and helped forge the new British nation of Canada in the wake of the American Revolution. The Butlers were not aberrations, bogeymen bent on evil or herculean forest warriors. They were British frontier soldiers, carving out pieces of Anglo empire from a turbulent frontier land, and struggling to navigate the myriad of obstacles and opportunities that would spell success or doom for the British Empire and the Butlers themselves. Butlers of the Mohawk Valley: Family Traditions and the Establishment of British Empire in Colonial New York by Judd David Olshan B.S., SUNY Cortland, 2005 M.S., Syracuse University, 2010 Dissertation Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History Syracuse University December 2015 Copyright © Judd David Olshan Ph.D. History 2015 All Rights Reserved Acknowledgments: Thank you to Roger Sharp, Andrew Cohen, Judy Van Buskirk, Carol Faulkner, Susan Branson, Robert Wilson, and the History Departments at SUNY Cortland and Syracuse University for the support needed to bring this project to fruition. Both departments were full of kind and supportive mentors for which I am profoundly grateful. Thank you Hannah Spencer Olshan for patience and kindness. v Table of Contents Chapter One: The Shared Origins of Butler Heritage and English Colonial Doctrine ....……1 Chapter Two: Sergeant Walter Butler: Imperial Solider, 1690s-1710…………………....…15 Chapter Three: Lt. Walter Butler: Rank, Marriage, and Social Mobility: 1711-1725.............38 Chapter Four: Walter Butler and Government on the New York Frontier 1726-1746………45 Chapter Five: Imperial Service on the New York Frontier. Walter Butler’s Sons During the French and Indian Wars 1745-1763………………………………………………….…..82 Chapter Six: The Butler’s Ascendant: The Growth of Wealth and Prestige on the Colonial Frontier……………………………………………………………………………..……….100 Chapter Seven: The Seven Years War and the End of the French Frontier 1754-1763……107 Chapter Eight: John Butler and Pontiac’s War 1763-1764…………………………………190 Chapter Nine: John Butler and The Creation of Tryon County 1765-1775………..………205 Chapter Ten: The Butlers and the End of the First British Empire: 1775-1776…….………..224 Epilogue: John Butler, Patron of Niagara. Garrison Government at the Beginning of the Second British Empire 1788-1796………………………………………….………….…...237 Bibliography…………………………………………………………………………..……..255 Vita…………….………………………………………………………….…………………278 vi List of Illustrative materials Figure 1: Butler Lands in County Kilkenny c. 1640…………………………………………7 Figure 2: Home at Butlersbury (sketch)……..……………………………………….………78 Figure 3: Home at Butlersbury (photo)...…………………………………………….………78 vii 1 Chapter One: The shared origins of Butler heritage and English colonial doctrine England's experience with imperial colonization in Ireland dates back to the twelfth century. Unlike English frontiers in Normandy and Brittany, which shared the same history and ruling class at England’s inception, Ireland and Scotland were foreign lands. The English conquest of Ireland in particular created a perpetual frontier marked by frequent conflicts. By the close of the seventeenth century, nearly five hundred years of English colonial ambitions in Ireland had created a distinct Anglo-Irish society that was highly militarized. Martial rank in particular was extremely significant in a society where war and the threat of war was constant. The English attempt to control their colonial frontier in Ireland and create a civilian populace that could be drawn on for military support were rooted in contemporary understandings of ancient Rome's imperial example. Settlements at Ulster and Munster demonstrate the practical application of such theories. They were planned communities in which military rank, political power, and land ownership were inseparably linked. These “plantations,” as the English called their colonies, set a precedent of military rule and produced a culture of soldier-planters that would evolve for generations. Plantation imperialism, which relied on land redistribution, frontier garrisons, para-military planter militias, Anglican missions, and shire government, were all features of the Irish conquest.1 Distribution of lands in Ireland was loosely based on the theory that loyal English or Anglo-Irish planters would cultivate crown lands granted to them for the benefit of the wider 1 Hugh Edward Egerton, A Short History of British Colonial Policy (London, 1897), 8; Howard Mumford Jones, ‘Origins of the English Colonial Idea in England’, Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, v. 85 n. 5 (September, 1942), 450; John Christopher Guzzardo,“Sir William Johnson's Official Family: Patron and Clients in an Anglo-American Empire, 1742-1777” (PhD diss., Syracuse University, 1975), 9 2 colonization scheme. The English conception of land ownership shifted the Gaelic conception of collective property rights to one that was strictly based on individual title. This formed the base of the English Aristocracy’s power and influence. Distribution of lands to those who could manage them was a strategic necessity in borderlands regions that were unpredictable and vulnerable. Large land grants allowed lords to generate resources and attract military manpower. Grants given throughout the Irish conquest reaffirmed successful Anglo lords such as the Butlers, adding to their estates. Grants also introduced new lords to Ireland, extending imperial authority into newly conquered territories and replacing those who had fallen from favor and fortune. These grants represented fresh injections of imperial capital into the centuries long conquest. Ennobled families who thrived throughout the conquest did so only by accepting and projecting imperial authority.2 The success of English colonization in Ireland was