DOCSLIB.ORG

Reviewing and Improving Our Public Consultation Process Appendix 7A

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Reviewing and Improving Our Public Consultation Process Appendix 7A Reviewing and improving our public consultation process Appendix 7a Working with you for our energy future www.eirgrid.com Appendix 7a European Grid Report: Beyond Public Opposition - Lessons Learned Across Europe Renewables Grid Initiative EUROPEAN G R I D R E P O R T Beyond Public Opposition Lessons Learned Across Europe EirGrid • Reviewing and Improving our Public Consultation Process • Appendix 7a Page 1 EUROPEAN GRID REPORT Imprint The Renewables-Grid-Initiative is managed and legally represented by Renewables Grid gUG. Haydnstraße 1 12203 Berlin, Germany Managing Director: Antonella Battaglini Jurisdiction: AG Charlottenburg / HR 141989 B Tax number: 27/602/56382 Authors: Theresa Schneider, Antina Sander 2 EirGrid • Reviewing and Improving our Public Consultation Process • Appendix 7a Page 2 EUROPEAN GRID REPORT TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Contents 1. INTRODUCTION 8 COPE AND METHODOLOGY 1.1. S 9 2. CHALLENGES 12 LANNING AND PPROVAL ROCESS AND NTERACTION WITH TAKEHOLDERS 2.1. P A P I S 12 ATURE ONSERVATION AND NVIRONMENT 2.2. N C E 18 HANGE PROCESS AND INTERNAL STRUCTURES 2.3. C 20 3. BELGIUM 21 LANNING AND PERMITTING PROCEDURE OVERVIEW 3.1. P : 22 ERMINOLOGY 3.2. T 23 LANNING AND PPROVAL ROCESS AND NTERACTION WITH TAKEHOLDERS 3.3. P A P I S 23 ATURE ONSERVATION AND NVIRONMENT 3.4. N C E 26 HANGE PROCESS AND INTERNAL STRUCTURES 3.5. C 28 4. FRANCE 29 LANNING AND PERMITTING PROCEDURE OVERVIEW 4.1. P : 30 ERMINOLOGY 4.2. T 31 LANNING AND PPROVAL ROCESS AND NTERACTION WITH TAKEHOLDERS 4.3. P A P I S 31 ATURE ONSERVATION AND NVIRONMENT 4.4. N C E 36 HANGE ROCESS AND NTERNAL TRUCTURES 4.5. C P I S 37 5. GERMANY 38 LANNING AND PERMITTING PROCEDURE OVERVIEW 5.1. P : 39 ERMINOLOGY 5.2. T 41 LANNING AND PPROVAL ROCESS AND NTERACTION WITH TAKEHOLDERS 5.3. P A P I S 41 ATURE ONSERVATION AND NVIRONMENT 5.4. N C E 49 HANGE ROCESS AND NTERNAL TRUCTURES 5.5. C P I S 51 6. ITALY 53 LANNING AND PERMITTING PROCEDURE OVERVIEW 6.1. P : 54 ERMINOLOGY 6.2. T 55 LANNING AND PPROVAL ROCESS AND NTERACTION WITH TAKEHOLDERS 6.3. P A P I S 55 ATURE ONSERVATION AND NVIRONMENT 6.4. N C E 58 HANGE ROCESS AND NTERNAL TRUCTURES 6.5. C P I S 61 3 EirGrid • Reviewing and Improving our Public Consultation Process • Appendix 7a Page 3 EUROPEAN GRID REPORT TABLE OF CONTENTS 7. THE NETHERLANDS 62 LANNING AND PERMITTING PROCEDURE OVERVIEW 7.1. P : 63 ERMINOLOGY 7.2. T 64 LANNING AND PPROVAL ROCESS AND NTERACTION WITH TAKEHOLDERS 7.3. P A P I S 64 ATURE ONSERVATION AND NVIRONMENT 7.4. N C E 69 HANGE ROCESS AND NTERNAL TRUCTURES 7.5. C P I S 70 8. NORWAY 72 LANNING AND PERMITTING PROCEDURE OVERVIEW 8.1. P : 73 ERMINOLOGY 8.2. T 74 LANNING AND PPROVAL ROCESS AND NTERACTION WITH TAKEHOLDERS 8.3. P A P I S 74 ATURE ONSERVATION AND NVIRONMENT 8.4. N C E 78 HANGE ROCESS AND NTERNAL TRUCTURES 8.5. C P I S 79 9. THE UNITED KINGDOM 81 LANNING AND PERMITTING PROCEDURE OVERVIEW 9.1. P : 82 ERMINOLOGY 9.2. T 83 LANNING AND PPROVAL ROCESS AND OOPERATION WITH TAKEHOLDERS 9.3. P A P C S 84 ATURE ONSERVATION AND NVIRONMENT 9.4. N C E 90 HANGE ROCESS AND NTERNAL TRUCTURES 9.5. C P I S 91 10. LESSONS LEARNED 93 LANNING AND PPROVAL ROCESS AND NTERACTION WITH TAKEHOLDERS 10.1. P A P I S 93 ATURE ONSERVATION AND NVIRONMENT 10.2. N C E 99 HANGE ROCESS AND NTERNAL TRUCTURES 10.3. C P I S 100 11. CONCLUSION 102 – 12. ANNEX 103 – NNEX OURCES 12.1. A I –S 104 NNEX UESTIONNAIRES 12.2. A II Q 107 NNEX IST OF INTERVIEWEES 12.3. A III L 111 NNEX URTHER READING 12.4. A IV - F 113 NNEX ROCEDURE OF GRID DEVELOPMENT PLAN IN ERMANY 12.5. A V - P G 115 4 EirGrid • Reviewing and Improving our Public Consultation Process • Appendix 7a Page 4 EUROPEAN GRID REPORT LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS List of Abbreviations BBL .............................. Bond Beter Leefmilieu (Federation for a Better Environment; Belgium) BNetzA ....................... Bundesnetzagentur (Federal Network Agency; Germany) CCW ............................. Countryside Council for Wales CLER ........................... Comité de Liaison Energies Renouvelables (Committee for Renewable Energy; France) CNA ............................. Comité National Avifaune (National Committee on Bird Protection; France) CNDP .......................... Commission Nationale du Débat Public (National Commission for CommissionPublic Debate de; France Régulation) de l’Énergie (Energy Regulations CRE ............................... Commission; France) DCE ............................. Département Concertation et Environnement (Stakeholders and Environment Department; France) dena ............................ Deutsche Energie-Agentur GmbH (German Energy Agency) DSO ............................. Distribution System Operator DUH ............................ Deutsche Umwelthilfe (German Environmental Aid; Germany) DUP ............................. Declaration of Public Interest EDF .............................. Électricité de France (French energy producer) EIA ............................... Environmental Impact Assessment EMF ............................. Electromagnetic Fields EnLAG ........................ Energieleitungsausbaugesetz (Energy Grid Extension Act; Germany) ERDF .......................... Électricité Réseau Distribution France (French DSO) ERPA .......................... Exclusion, Repulsion, Problem, Attraction (Italy= EU ................................ European Union FAQ ............................. Frequently Asked Questions FNE ............................. France Nature Environnement 5 EirGrid • Reviewing and Improving our Public Consultation Process • Appendix 7a Page 5 EUROPEAN GRID REPORT LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS GRUP ........................... Gewestelijk Ruimtelijk Uitvoeringsplan (Regional land-use plan; the Netherlands) HVDC .......................... High Voltage Direct Current IET ................................ Institution of Energy and Technology (The UK) ISO ............................... International Standardisation Organisation LCF .............................. Local Community Forums LIPU ............................ Lega Italiana Protezione Uccelli (Italian BirdLife branch) LNE ............................. Departement Leefmilieu, Natuur en Energie (Flemish Environment, Nature and Energy Department; Belgium) LPO ............................... Ligue pour la Protection des Oiseaux (French BirdLife branch) MER ............................ Milieueffectrapportagebeheer (Environmental Impact Assessment) MoU ............................ Memorandum of Understanding NABEG ....................... Netzausbaubeschleunigungsgesetz (Grid Extension Acceleration Act; Germany) NCEA .......................... Netherlands Commission for Environmental Assessment NGO ............................. Non-Governmental Organisation NID .............................. National Infrastructure Directorate NSIPs .......................... Nationally significant infrastructure projects NVE ............................. Norges vassdrags- og energidirektorat (Norwegian Water Resources and Energy Directorate; regulator) OHL ............................. Overhead lines PAP .............................. Project Accompanying Plan (France) PEIR ............................. Preliminary Environmental Information Report (The UK) PPA .............................. Planning Performance Agreement (The UK) Q&As............................ Questions and answers RAVON ....................... Reptielen Amfibieën en Vissen Onderzoek Nederland (Reptile, Amphibian and Fish Conservation Netherlands) RGI .............................. Renewables-Grid-Initiative RSPB ........................... Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (The UK) RTE ............................. Réseau de Transport d'Électricité (French TSO) RTPI ............................ Royal Town Planning Institute (The UK) SAGE ........................... Stakeholder Advisory Group on Electromagnetic Fields (The UK) SCF ............................... Strategic Community Forum (The UK) SEA .............................. Strategic Environmental Assessment 6 EirGrid • Reviewing and Improving our Public Consultation Process • Appendix 7a Page 6 EUROPEAN GRID REPORT LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS SEV .............................. Structuurschema elektriciteitsvoorziening (Framework plan of electricity supply; the Netherlands) SOCC ........................... Statement of Community Consultation (The UK) TSO .............................. Transmission System Operator UK ................................ United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland WWF ............................ World Wide Fund for Nature 7 EirGrid • Reviewing and Improving our Public Consultation Process • Appendix 7a Page 7 EUROPEAN GRID REPORT INTRODUCTION 1 Introduction 1. Introduction The European Union has set the expansion projects is local stage for a significant increase in the opposition traced to environmental use of renewable energy sources and social concerns. driven by the adoption of its 20-20- 20 targets and the objective of The Renewables-Grid-Initiative creating a largely decarbonised (RGI) brings together two of the– power sector by 2050. Expanding main stakeholders from eight theand Europeanupgrading Union’sthe ageing ambitious grid different countries in this debate infrastructure is vital to achieving non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and transmission system Paper,energy and“Towards climate targets.a Thesecure, EU operators (TSOs). These groups Commission argues in the Green collectively endorse the effective European Energy network” integration of 100% renewable “Europe’ssustainable energy and networks
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Nordic Grid Development Plan 2012 Foreword
    Nordic Grid Development Plan 2012 Foreword The Nordic transmission system operators (TSOs) have a long history of successful cooperation within grid development. Three common Nordic grid master plans have been developed in the last ten years in the context of Nordel, the previous cooperative organization for the Nordic TSOs. Joint Nordic grid development is essential to support further development of an integrated Nordic electricity market, as well as increased capacity to other countries and integration of renewable energy sources (RES). The Nordic co-operation on grid development is now taking place within the wider regional context provided by the regional groups North Sea and Baltic Sea of ENTSO-E, the European organization for TSOs, in addition to bilateral co-operation when required. The Nordic Grid Development Plan 2012 is prepared as a response to the request from the Nordic Council of Ministers of October 25, 2010. The plan is prepared by Statnett, Svenska Kraftnät, Energinet.dk and Fingrid, and the Icelandic TSO Landsnet has provided input regarding the Icelandic grid. The plan presents the Nordic grid investment plans for the next ten years. 28. September 2012 Oslo Stockholm Copenhagen Helsinki Statnett SF Svenska Kraftnät Energinet.dk Fingrid Auke Lont Mikael Odenberg Peder Østermark Andreasen Jukka Ruusunen CEO CEO CEO CEO LIST OF TABLES....................................................................................................................... 2 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Public Participation and Transparency in Power Grid Planning
    Public Participation and Transparency in Power Grid Planning Recommendations from the BESTGRID Project Handbook – Part 1 BESTGRID PARTNERS Transmission System Operator (TSO) Partners Natagora asbl www.natagora.be 50Hertz Transmission GmbH Julien Taymans (Waterloo-Braine l'Alleud project) www.50hertz.com [email protected] Dr Dirk Manthey, [email protected] Phone: +32 (0) 81 390 720 Phone: +49 (0) 30 5150 3419 98 rue Nanon, B-5000 Namur Eichenstr. 3A, D-12435 Berlin German Environment Aid (DUH) Elia System Operator NV www.duh.de www.stevin.be Liv Becker (Suedlink / Bertikow-Pasewalk) Jeroen Mentens (Stevin project) [email protected] [email protected] Phone: +49 (0) 30 2400 867 98 Phone: +32 (0) 2 546 7957 Hackescher Markt 4, D-10178 Berlin Christophe Coq (Waterloo-Braine l'Alleud project) Germanwatch e.V. [email protected] www.germanwatch.org Phone: +32 (0) 2 382 2334 Leon Monnoyerkaai 3, B-1000 Brussels Rotraud Hänlein, [email protected] Phone: +49 (0) 30 2888 356 83 National Grid Stresemannstr. 72, D-10963 Berlin www.nemo-link.com International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IIASA) Phil Pryor, [email protected] www.iiasa.ac.at Phone: +44 (0)7795 641 431 Warwick Technology Park, Gallows Hill, Warwick, Joanne Linnerooth-Bayer, [email protected] UK-CV346DA Dr Nadejda Komendantova, [email protected] Phone: +43 (0) 676 83 807 285 TenneT TSO GmbH Schlossplatz 1, A-2361 Laxenburg www.suedlink.tennet.eu Marius Strecker, [email protected] Naturschutzbund Deutschland (NABU) Phone: +49 (0) 921 50740 4094 www.nabu.de Bernecker Str.
    [Show full text]
  • Facts and Figures 2019
    Contact and imprint Facts Publisher Design 50Hertz Transmission GmbH Heimrich & Hannot GmbH and Figures Heidestrasse 2 10557 Berlin Images T +49 30 5150 0 50Hertz 2019 F +49 30 5150 2199 Jan Pauls info@ 50 hertz.com Frank Wölffing Board of Management Printing Stefan Kapferer (CEO) PocketPlaner Dr. Frank Golletz (CTO) FP Werbung GmbH Dr. Dirk Biermann (CMO) Marco Nix (CFO) Sylvia Borcherding (CHRO) 50hertz.com For a successful energy transition in a sustainable world You can find our sustainability report online at csr.50hertz.com enmark About us Our tasks nerginet Key figures In the north and east of Germany, cleswig-olstein we operate the high voltage grid Lubmin Value TenneT reliably ensuring electricity supply Market facilitation – Gstrow GRID-RELATED KEY FIGURES WESTE for around 18 million people. EI CETE NORTHE 2 We are part of the amburg EI CETE Grid area 109,702 km TenneT European integrated Our grid with voltage levels of 150 kilo- Our locations Total lenghts of lines market. (equivalent to power 10,490 km volt (kV), 220 kV and 380 kV extends P circuit length) thereof overhead lines 380 kV 7,250 km over a circuit length of 10,490 km. 50Hertz Netzquartier Eastern Regional Centre Lower axony Poland CET We deliver the (Headquarters) Sigmund-Bergmann-Str. 1 EI CETE thereof overhead lines 220 kV 2,607 km 50ert-Netquartier Heidestrasse 2 03222 Lübbenau/ BerlinCarlottenburg Neuenagen At our eleven locations, over 1,100 infrastructure of bei Berlin thereof sea cables 220 kV 290 km 10557 Berlin Spreewald employees ensure that electricity the future TenneT Wolmirstedt thereof sea cables 150 kV 270 km flows around the clock in Berlin, Service location Röhrsdorf Trusteeship – Northern Regional Centre thereof underground cables 73 km Brandenburg, Hamburg, Mecklen- WESTE Lbbenaupreewald Substations and switching We transparently integrate Rostocker Chaussee 18 Southern Regional Centre EI CETE 74 burg-Western Pomerania, Saxony, stations (number) renewable energies 18273 Güstrow Zentrales Umspannwerk 8 Saxony-Anhalt and Thuringia.
    [Show full text]
  • Electricity Systems and Markets) EDF R&D
    European system with an efficient coordinated use of flexibilities for the integration of a large share of RES Vera Silva Research program director « Electricity systems and markets) EDF R&D EU-SysFlex overall objective EU SysFlex objective is to contribute to developing a market design and regulation framework able to foster the development of innovative flexibility approaches to address the technical shortfalls of a European system with high RES. These innovative approaches cover both the technical capability for providing the right flexibilities and system services and the ability of TSOs to integrate these into system and network operation. EU-SysFlex will make a major contribution to a cost effective system transformation to meet EU world leading RES objectives Three pillars of EUSysFlex approach System needs TSO driven Whole system driven Technical shortfalls Economic shortfalls Market driving innovation to respond to system needs Demonstrations/ Scalability Market design and Replicability/ TSO Services/ Products/ enhancement & operations simulation Procurement/Remuneration regulation evolution Flexibility Roadmap – Implementation and exploitation Scalability and System Implementation Exploitation of results replicatbility benefits Roadmap business creation EU SysFlex will provide a significant improvement of EU innovation capacity by combining “top-down” and “bottom- up” approaches to flexibility enabled by a strong consortium - Cost effective enhancement of flexibility and system services capability - new approaches and tools
    [Show full text]
  • 'A+' Rating Affirmed with a Stable Outlook Statnett SF
    Research Update: Statnett SF 'A+' Rating Affirmed With A Stable Outlook February 26, 2020 Rating Action Overview PRIMARY CREDIT ANALYST - The Norwegian Energy Regulatory Authority (NVE) has announced that Statnett SF receives a Daniel Annas 100% efficiency score; this leads us to expect the company will capture in full the revenue cap Stockholm of its cost base. +46 (8) 4405925 daniel.annas - We expect continued ample rating headroom as our base-case scenario stipulated FFO to debt @spglobal.com to be close to 9% on average in coming years, and debt to EBITDA on average at about 8.5x, both SECONDARY CONTACT which we consider well commensurate with the 'bbb' stand-alone credit profile (SACP). Per Karlsson - We continue to view the regulatory environment for Norwegian as supportive, despite declining Stockholm weighted average cost of capital (WACC), because we view the framework as stable and (46) 8-440-5927 predictable; the WACC estimate for 2020 is 5.47%. per.karlsson @spglobal.com - We are therefore affirming our 'A+' rating and stable outlook on Statnett. ADDITIONAL CONTACT - Statnett's positive momentum in credit ratios post-2020 are hinged on RAB increasing as Industrial Ratings Europe planned, and without cost overruns. Corporate_Admin_London @spglobal.com Rating Action Rationale The regulator has announced Statnett as 100% efficient, which supports its credit ratios. On Jan. 31, the NVE announced Statnett's revenue cap, including an updated WACC estimation, at 5.47% and confirmation of a maintained 100% efficiency score. The WACC estimate decreased 35 basis points from the actual 5.82% reported in 2019, pointing to declining free-rate risk, computed as the average five-year swap rate from the most recent calendar year.
    [Show full text]
  • Joint Messages Roundtable of European Energy Industrialists Brussels, 7 February 2013
    w JOINT MESSAGES Roundtable of European Energy Industrialists Brussels, 7 February 2013 Empowering Market and Consumers The Roundtable of European Energy Industrialists, meeting in Brussels on 7 February 2013, represents companies that will invest more than € 75 billion by 2020. Between now and 2050, the energy industry as a whole will create millions of jobs and make a considerable contribution to economic growth. Eu- rope is now preparing its next vital steps towards a green energy transformation so comprehensive, that it overshadows all previous attempts at climate change mitigation around the world. By taking global leadership in realizing a low-carbon future, Europe's investment in infrastructure may foster a recovery from the economic downturn. Above all, the Roundtable of European Energy Industrialists believes that the future is electric, and that efficient electricity markets must be crucial in implementing this transformation. We therefore support the commitment of the European Commission to complete the internal energy market without delay. In summary, better markets, stronger grids, and smarter technologies are keys to Europe's energy transformation. – 1 – w 1. Better Markets The internal market is fundamental to efficient use of resources. In the short-term electricity market integration leads to increased liquidity and transparency in wholesale markets, more competitive prices and more freedom for consumers. In the long term, well-functioning electricity markets, stable regu- latory regimes and a robust emission-trading scheme will provide the signals for efficient investments. The reality, however, is that progress to complete the internal electricity market is slow and many ener- gy companies are having to deal with significant and rapid moves back to re-regulation of the sector at national levels.
    [Show full text]
  • Eirgrid Plc Annual Report 2014
    EirGrid plc Annual Report 2014 www.eirgrid.com Our Mission Contents To provide quality, efficient, Chairperson’s Report 2 independent transmission and Chief Executive’s Review 6 market services for the benefit Financial Review 10 Operational Highlights of everyone across the island 14 Grid25 Initiatives 22 of Ireland. Europe 28 Corporate Social Responsibility 32 The Board 34 Organisational Structure 40 Executive Team 42 Financial Statements 47 Image Bibliography 113 EirGrid - It’s Your Grid Working with you for our energy future Ireland needs a safe, secure electricity network, to power our homes, schools, hospitals, farms and businesses. EirGrid Group is the organisation entrusted with the responsibility of managing the electricity grid in Ireland and Northern Ireland. As the designated Transmission System Operator and Market Operator, we operate the grid throughout the island of Ireland. We also own and operate the 260km East West Interconnector that runs between Ireland and Great Britain. We are a commercially run semi-state company, which operates in the interest of all people on the island. Our role is to deliver the electricity from where it is generated to where it is needed. We manage the network as safely and efficiently as possible, ensuring there is enough capacity to meet demand at any given time, 365 days of the year. EirGrid also operates the independent all-island electricity market, facilitating the buying of wholesale electricity by the suppliers who sell to the end user. We don’t participate in the wholesale or retail market, as we neither buy nor sell electricity. A quality electricity network is essential for everyone on the island of Ireland and one which we are proud to manage on your behalf.
    [Show full text]
  • Dansk Energi Brev
    To: Energinet Astrid Buhr Broge [email protected] [email protected] Dok. ansvarlig: CAC Sekretær: Sagsnr: s2013-388 Doknr: d2021-22033-1.0 30. august 2021 Energinet consultation on the methodology for procurement of counter- trade energy Dansk Energi welcomes Energinet’s consultation on the methodology for procurement of so-called countertrade energy. Energinet has highlighted several issues driving the proposed methodology over the past year. However, the central task of a TSO is not to arrange a border specific market setup according to cli- mate effects or according to the costs of specific market dispatches. The central task of a TSO is to facilitate markets that provides correct price and investments signals in compliance with EU-regulation. Energinet’s proposed methodology seeks to address an internal German issue – lack of capacity in TenneT’s transmission grid – which has previously resulted in heavy reduction of capacity on the Dan- ish-German border. While this was solved with the Joint Declaration and Tennet Commitments in 2017-2018, Energinet’s proposed methodology rolls back these advances. The proposed methodology will sustain a distorted day-ahead market price formation in Denmark, an intraday market in DK1 with no export capacity towards Germany and an intraday market in Denmark where Energinet directly or through a third party is by far the largest market participant. These are not efficient elements in a well-functioning wholesale market and Dansk Energi does not consider it compliant with EU-regulation, nor do we consider it a proportional solution to address the internal German grid congestion. At this stage, Dansk Energi would like to highlight the following concerns and objections: 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Tennet Integrated Annual Report 2019
    TenneT Holding B.V. Integrated Annual Report 2019 Key figures 2019 Safe workplace Diverse workforce Safety (TRIR) Gender ratio 4.8 23% 77% Satisfied capital providers* Environmental impact ROIC % Greened of our carbon footprint 5.1 27.4% Grid availability Safeguard capital structure* Grid availability FFO/Net debt 99.9998% 14.8% Future proof grid* Our workforce Annual Investments (EUR million) Number of employees (internal and external) 3,064 4,913 Engaged stakeholders Healthy financial operations* Reputation survey EBIT (EUR million) fairly strong to very strong 768 * Based on underlying figures Table of contents Integrated 2019 at a glance 2 Annual Letter from the Board 4 Report 2019 * About TenneT 6 Profile 6 Our strategy and value creation 9 Materiality analysis 14 * Our performance in 2019 16 Deliver a high security of supply 16 Ensure critical infrastructure for society 23 Create a sustainable workplace 30 Contents Create value to transition to a low carbon economy 36 Secure a solid financial performance and investor rating 44 Solve societal challenges with stakeholders and through partnerships 50 Statements of the Executive Board 57 Our Executive Board 58 Supervisory Board Report 60 Supervisory Board Report 60 Remuneration policy 66 Board remuneration 68 Our Supervisory Board 72 * Governance and risk management 74 Corporate governance 74 Risk management and internal control 76 Risk management and internal control framework 79 Compliance and integrity 80 Risk appetite 82 Key risks 83 Financial statements 87 Consolidated financial statements 88 Notes to the consolidated financial statements 95 Company financial statements 147 Notes to the company financial statements 149 Other information 152 Profit appropriation 152 Independent auditor’s report 153 Assurance report of the independent auditor 160 About this report 163 Reconciliation of non-IFRS financial measures 168 SWOT Analysis 169 Key figures: five-year summary 170 Glossary 171 * These sections reflect the director’s report as mentioned by Part 9 of Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code.
    [Show full text]
  • System Operation Stakeholders Committee
    System Operation Stakeholders Committee Materials for meeting 16th September 2020 1.1 Review of the Agenda Time Agenda Topics Documents Lead 1. Opening Uros Gabrijel 13:30-13:35 1.1 Review of the agenda Agenda 13:35-13:45 1.2 Review and approval of minutes from previous meeting Minutes 13:45-13:55 1.3 Review of actions Slides Ana Cigaran 13:55-14:15 2. Update on the implementation actions at pan-EU level Slides Ana Cigaran 3. System Operation Guideline Slides 14:15-14:30 3.1 Cost Benefit Analysis for FCR providers by Limited Energy Reservoirs: Luca Ortolano Status update 3.2 Information on Exchange\Sharing of reserves 14:30-15:00 Mohamed El Jafoufi 15:00-15:15 4. CGM Program Implementation Update Derek Lawler 15:15-15:45 5. NC ER Implementation update Slides Rafal Kuczynski 5.1 Update on TCM Status according to Art. 4. 6. Information on Low frequency Pump disconnection & energy storage units Rafal Kuczynski\Walter Sattinger 15:45-16:00 6.1 Why low frequency pump disconnection is triggered at different frequencies across Europe? 6.2 Outlook on the plans for the energy storage units 16:00-16:15 16:15-16:30 7. AOB – Next meeting 9th December Uros Gabrijel 2 1.3 Review of actions Ana Cigaran 3 1.3 Review of actions (I) ACTION ANSWER STATUS 1. Note for future SO GL active library to include pre- Preparation for SO GL Active Library Open qualification process aFRR, mFRR, RR. is in good progress both for the Digital and content part.
    [Show full text]
  • Tennet's Annual Market Update 2020
    Annual Market Update 2020 Electricity market insights 7 April 2021 Introduction Introduction Annual Market Update 2020, an electricity market review focused on the Netherlands and Germany, including wider European trends Main findings This Annual Market Update (AMU) is focussed on relevant developments on the Central Western European electricity markets, and the Dutch and German electricity markets in particular. This is the third edition of the Wholesale market prices TenneT Annual Market Update. Previous editions of the AMU and its predecessor the TenneT Market Review can be found here. Fuel prices & The developments in the Annual Market Update are structured alongside several main topics: generators • The chapter Wholesale market prices discusses wholesale day-ahead and identifies price trends. • As our electricity system is still highly dependent on fossil-fuelled power, the chapter Fuel prices describes Capacity & developments in hard coal, natural gas and emission allowance prices, as well as the margins for generators. generation • The chapter Capacity & generation focuses on the supply side of the electricity system and discusses developments in installed capacity and generation. RES support • Support for renewables in the Dutch and German system are discussed in the chapter RES support schemes, schemes by looking at budget distribution, awarded capacity and generation in the subsidy schemes. • In the chapter Wholesale market integration the storyline zooms out and includes the interactions of the Dutch Wholesale market and German electricity system with neighbouring systems. Additionally, the ongoing efforts of coupling EU integration electricity markets are discussed in this chapter. • The last two chapters focus on mechanisms in place to ensure the stability and functioning of the electricity system for both the Netherlands and Germany: Balancing measures, to ensure supply and demand is equal at Balancing all times; and redispatch measures, to resolve congestion in the grid.
    [Show full text]
  • Minutes SDAC Joint Steering Committee Meeting 30/01/2020,11:00 – 17:00 CET, Brussels Airport
    Minutes SDAC Joint Steering Committee Meeting 30/01/2020,11:00 – 17:00 CET, Brussels Airport Present parties 50Hertz Cropex EPEX Spot Litgrid PSE Terna Admie EirGrid (TSO) ESO MAVIR REE TGE Amprion Eirgrid (SEMO PX) EXAA Nasdaq REN Transelectrica APG ElecLink Fingrid Nemo Link RTE Transnet BW AST Elering GME NGIC SEPS TTG BritNed ELES HEnEx OKTE SONI (SEMO PX) TTN BSP Elia HOPS OMIE SONI (TSO) ČEPS EMCO Nord Pool HUPX OPCOM Statnett Creos Energinet IBEX OTE Svk Attending in person Attending by phone Proxy arranged Not present Present chairs, TF leaders, PMOs, observers BMTF leader JSC Secretary MRC OPSCOM PMO MSD PMO PCR chair & PMO TSO co-chair EC MEPSO MSD NEMO co-leader NEMO co-chair Procedures TF leader Entso-e MRC OPSCOM leader MSD TSO co-leader OST Swissgrid Attending in person Attending by phone Not present Meeting agenda # Topic For 1 Welcome, practicalities 1.1 Confirm quorum Inf 1.2 Adoption of the agenda Dec 1.3 Approval of minutes of past meetings/calls (incl. part for publication) Dec 1.4 Review open action points Inf 1.5 Participation in SDAC JSCs – overview 2019 meetings Dis 2 Decisions required 2.1 Way forward Central Settlement Entity (without JAO present) Dec 2.2 NRA access to Simulation Facility & cost sharing Dec 2.3 Mandate for co-chairs to take actions after a decoupling event Dec LUNCH 3 TF status reports and decisions requested 3.1 BMTF Dec 3.2 MRC OPSCOM Dec 3.3 Procedures TF 3.4 MSD Dec 3.5 MNA Implementation Coordination Group Inf 3.6 Legal TF Inf 3.7 Communication TF Inf 3.8 Feedback from 29/01 Internal Coordination Team (ICT) strategy meeting Inf 4 Important points for SDAC from ENTSO-E/ NC/ NRAs/ ACER/ EC 4.1 NEMOs status report Inf 4.2 Feedback from 10/12 TCG and 18/12 MESC meetings Inf 4.3 Update on Algorithm Methodology 5 Any other business 5.1 Baltic Cable – status update on TSO certification Inf 5.2 CCP default Dis 5.3 Next meetings Inf 1 List of decisions # Topic Decision 1.2 Adoption of the The meeting agenda is approved.
    [Show full text]