Seismic Performance Assessment of Buildings, Volume 1 -- Methodology

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Seismic Performance Assessment of Buildings, Volume 1 -- Methodology Seismic Performance Assessment of Buildings Volume 1 – Methodology Second Edition FEMA P-58-1 / December 2018 FEMA P-58-1 / December 2018 Seismic Performance Assessment of Buildings Volume 1 – Methodology Second Edition Prepared by APPLIED TECHNOLOGY COUNCIL 201 Redwood Shores Parkway, Suite 240 Redwood City, California 94065 www.ATCouncil.org Prepared for FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY Michael Mahoney, Project Officer Robert D. Hanson, Technical Monitor Washington, D.C. SECOND EDITION PROJECT TEAM APPLIED TECHNOLOGY COUNCIL STAKEHOLDER PRODUCTS TEAM Christopher Rojahn Laura Samant (Team Leader) Jon A. Heintz (Project Executive) David Mar Ayse Hortacsu (Project Manager) Lori Peek Maryann T. Phipps PROJECT MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE Sharyl Rabinovici Ronald O. Hamburger (Project Technical Director) L. Thomas Tobin John Gillengerten William T. Holmes PERFORMANCE PRODUCTS TEAM John D. Hooper John Gillengerten (Team Leader) Stephen A. Mahin David R. Bonneville Jack P. Moehle Dominic Campi Khalid Mosalam Vesna Terzic Laura Samant Steven R. Winkel PRODUCTS UPDATE TEAM John D. Hooper (Team Leader) PROJECT STEERING COMMITTEE Russell Larsen William T. Holmes (Chair) Peter Morris Lucy Arendt Deborah Beck Christopher Deneff H. John Price Jonathan C. Siu Jeffrey R. Soulages Eric Von Berg Williston Warren (ATC Board Contact) STAKEHOLDER PRODUCTS PRODUCTS UPDATE CONSULTANTS CONSULTANTS Sandra L. Grabowski Robert Bachman Taline Mitten Jack Baker Stacia Sydoriak Dustin Cook Jennifer Tobin-Gurley Scott Hagie Angie Harris PERFORMANCE PRODUCTS Curt Haselton CONSULTANTS Wyatt Henderson Shreyash Chokshi Monica Huang Travis Chrupalo Gilberto Mosqueda Erica Hays Farzad Naeim Nirmal Kumawat Barbara Rodriguez Abe Lynn Kathrina Simonen Daniel Saldana Siavash Sorooshian Vinit M. Shah Katherine Wade Udit S. Tambe Farzin Zareian Duy Vu To Peny Villanueva FIRST EDITION PROJECT TEAM APPLIED TECHNOLOGY COUNCIL RISK MANAGEMENT PRODUCTS Christopher Rojahn (Project Executive) TEAM Jon A. Heintz (Project Manager) John D. Hooper (Co-Team Leader) Ayse Hortacsu Craig D. Comartin (Co-Team Leader) Mary Comerio PROJECT MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE C. Allin Cornell Ronald O. Hamburger (Proj. Tech. Director) Mahmoud Hachem John Gillengerten Gee Heckscher William T. Holmes (ex-officio) Judith Mitrani-Reiser Peter J. May Peter Morris Jack P. Moehle Farzad Naeim Maryann T. Phipps (ATC Board Contact) Keith Porter Hope Seligson STEERING COMMITTEE William T. Holmes (Chair) STRUCTURAL PERFORMANCE Roger D. Borcherdt PRODUCTS TEAM Anne Bostrom Andrew S. Whittaker (Team Leader) Bruce Burr Gregory Deierlein Kelly Cobeen John D. Hooper Anthony B. Court Yin-Nan Huang Terry Dooley Laura Lowes Dan Gramer Nicolas Luco Michael Griffin Andrew T. Merovich R. Jay Love David Mar Steven McCabe Brian J. Meacham William J. Petak NONSTRUCTURAL PERFORMANCE NONSTRUCTURAL PERFORMANCE PRODUCTS TEAM PRODUCTS AND FRAGILITY Robert E. Bachman (Team Leader) DEVELOPMENT CONSULTANTS Philip J. Caldwell Richard Behr Andre Filiatrault Greg Hardy Robert P. Kennedy Christopher Higgins Helmut Krawinkler Gayle Johnson Manos Maragakis Paul Kremer Eduardo Miranda Dave McCormick Gilberto Mosqueda Ali M. Memari Keith Porter William O’Brien John Osteraas RISK MANAGEMENT PRODUCTS Elizabeth Pahl CONSULTANTS John Stevenson Travis Chrupalo Xin Xu D. Jared DeBock Armen Der Kiureghian FRAGILITY REVIEW PANEL Scott Hagie Bruce Ellingwood Curt Haselton Robert P. Kennedy Russell Larsen Stephen Mahin Juan Murcia-Delso Scott Shell VALIDATION/VERIFICATION TEAM P. Benson Shing Charles Scawthorn (Chair) Mohamed Talaat Jack Baker Farzin Zareian David Bonneville Hope Seligson STRUCTURAL PERFORMANCE PRODUCTS AND FRAGILITY SPECIAL REVIEWERS DEVELOPMENT CONSULTANTS Thalia Anagnos Jack Baker Fouad M. Bendimerad Dhiman Basu Dan Dolan Charles Ekiert Andre Filiatrault Aysegul Gogus Kerem Gulec Dawn Lehman Jingjuan Li Eric Lumpkin Juan Murcia-Delso Hussein Okail Charles Roeder P. Benson Shing Christopher Smith Victor Victorsson John Wallace Notice Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the Applied Technology Council (ATC), the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), or the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). Additionally, neither ATC, DHS, FEMA, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, expressed or implied, nor assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, product, or process included in this publication. Users of information from this publication assume all liability arising from such use. Cover photograph – Collapsed building viewed through the archway of an adjacent building, 1999 Chi-Chi, Taiwan earthquake (courtesy of Farzad Naeim, Farzad Naeim, Inc). Foreword The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) is committed to reducing the ever-increasing cost that disasters inflict on our country. Preventing losses before they happen, by building to withstand anticipated forces, is one of the key components of mitigation, and is the only truly effective way of reducing the impact of disasters on our country. One of the most promising tools that can be used to reduce damage from an earthquake, or other similar disasters, is performance-based design. Performance-Based Seismic Design (PBSD) is a concept that permits the design and construction of buildings with a realistic and reliable understanding of the risk of life, occupancy, and economic loss that may occur as a result of future earthquakes. PBSD is based on an assessment of a building’s design to determine the probability of experiencing different types of losses, considering the range of potential earthquakes that may affect the structure. This allows a building owner or regulator to select their desired performance goal for their building. Current building codes are prescriptive in nature and are principally intended to provide a life-safety level of protection when a design-level event, such as an earthquake, occurs. While codes are intended to produce buildings that meet a life-safety performance level for a specified level of ground shaking, they do not provide designers with a means to determine if other performance levels would be achieved. During a design level earthquake, a code-designed building could achieve the goal of preventing loss of life or life-threatening injury to building occupants, but could still sustain extensive structural and nonstructural damage and be out of service for an extended period of time. In some cases, the damage may be too costly to repair, leaving demolition as the only option. FEMA’s early work in this area included the development of FEMA 349, Action Plan for Performance Based Seismic Design (FEMA, 2000). PBSD development work began in earnest in 2006, when FEMA contracted with the Applied Technology Council (ATC) to initiate Phase 1 development of a seismic performance assessment methodology. This work included development of an updated project plan, published as FEMA 445, Next- Generation, Performance-Based Seismic Design Guidelines, Program Plan for New and Existing Buildings. Phase 1 work built upon research performed FEMA P-58-1 Foreword v Second Edition by others, including the three Earthquake Engineering Research Centers and other universities, private industry, various construction materials trade associations, and individual product manufacturers and suppliers who have performed research to facilitate the use of their products and materials in a performance-based design environment. Phase 1 work was completed in 2012 with the publication of FEMA P-58, Seismic Performance Assessment of Buildings, Volume 1 – Methodology, Volume 2 – Implementation Guide, and a series of supporting electronic materials and background technical information. For practical implementation of the methodology, work included the development of an electronic tool, referred to as the Performance Assessment Calculation Tool, or PACT, to help capture building inventory data, input a given earthquake shaking probability or intensity, apply specific fragilities and consequences to each building component, and present the results of a large number of runs, or realizations, in a logical format. Unlike earlier versions of PBSD, the FEMA P-58 methodology utilizes performance measures that can be understood by decision makers. Performance objectives relate to the amount of damage the building may experience and the consequences of that damage including: potential casualties; loss of use or occupancy; and repair and reconstruction costs. They can also be used to assess potential environmental impacts. FEMA recently completed the Phase 2 development of design guidance, which used the FEMA P-58 methodology to develop performance-based seismic design guidelines and stakeholder guidelines. This five-year effort also included an update of Volume 1 and 2 products to capture improvements to the FEMA P-58 methodology. FEMA wishes to express its sincere gratitude to all who were involved in this project and in the development of the FEMA P-58 methodology. The entire development team numbered more than 200 individuals across all phases, and it is not possible to acknowledge them all here. However, special thanks are extended to: Ronald Hamburger, Project Technical Director; Robert Bachman, Nonstructural Team Leader; John Hooper, Risk Management Team Leader; Andrew Whittaker, Structural Products Team Leader; William Holmes, Steering Committee Chair; and Jon Heinz, ATC Project Manager. The hard work and dedication of these
Recommended publications
  • Cornell Alumni Magazine, NY, and Additional Mail C/O Public Affairs Records, 130 East Seneca St., Suite 400, Ithaca, NY 14850-4353
    c1-c4CAMjf11 12/16/10 10:18 AM Page c1 January | February 2011 $6.00 Alumni Corne Magazine Ghost World Photos Bridge Ithaca’s Past and Present cornellalumnimagazine.com c1-c4CAMjf11 12/16/10 10:18 AM Page c2 001-001CAMjf11toc 12/17/10 10:35 AM Page 1 January / February 2011 Volume 113 Number 4 In This Issue Corne Alumni Magazine 4 2 From David Skorton Money matters 4 The Big Picture A big blow-up 6 Correspondence Suicide prevention 9 Letter from Ithaca Shirt off their backs 10 From the Hill Oh, the humanities! 14 Sports Wrestle mania 17 Authors It’s all right 24 Summer Programs and Sports Camps 20 40 Wines of the Finger Lakes Swedish Hill Cynthia Marie Port 54 Classifieds & Cornellians in Business 55 Alma Matters 58 Class Notes 95 Alumni Deaths 48 96 Cornelliana 42 Through a Glass, Darkly Conserving a conservatory? FRANKLIN CRAWFORD Urban renewal was kinder to Ithaca than to some Upstate cities, but over the past cen- Currents tury many stately buildings have still been lost—from Ezra Cornell’s Free Circulating Library to Alonzo Cornell’s mansion to the grand old Strand Theatre. In a series of photos recently exhibited at the History Center of Tompkins County, former visiting professor Mark Iwinski captures the ghostly images of bygone structures superimposed 20 Flour Power over what stands in their place. Often, it isn’t pretty. Milling the old-fashioned way Starry Nights 48 Vegging In Cosmic storyteller BETH SAULNIER Eat Different Promoting a plant-based diet When the Moosewood Restaurant served its first meal thirty-eight years ago this month, the owners were still trying to figure out how to run the steam table (and the entrée Learning Curve was two hours late).
    [Show full text]
  • Amateur Filmmaking at the Lakehead, 1929-1930 Michel S
    Document generated on 09/26/2021 10:32 p.m. Ontario History “We did it just for fun” Amateur Filmmaking at the Lakehead, 1929-1930 Michel S. Beaulieu Volume 99, Number 2, Fall 2007 Article abstract This article chronicles the brief existence of The Port Arthur Amateur Cinema URI: https://id.erudit.org/iderudit/1065738ar Society and its attempts to produce three feature-length films, including DOI: https://doi.org/10.7202/1065738ar Canada’s first amateur feature-length film, A Race for Ties, in 1929. I argue that the existence and success of such a society in the then remote city of Port See table of contents Arthur, Ontario, owes as much to the dedication of two people – Dorothea Mitchell and Fred Cooper – as it does to the growing culture of consumerism that was a hallmark of the early twentieth century. Publisher(s) The Ontario Historical Society ISSN 0030-2953 (print) 2371-4654 (digital) Explore this journal Cite this article Beaulieu, M. S. (2007). “We did it just for fun”: Amateur Filmmaking at the Lakehead, 1929-1930. Ontario History, 99(2), 168–189. https://doi.org/10.7202/1065738ar Copyright © The Ontario Historical Society, 2007 This document is protected by copyright law. Use of the services of Érudit (including reproduction) is subject to its terms and conditions, which can be viewed online. https://apropos.erudit.org/en/users/policy-on-use/ This article is disseminated and preserved by Érudit. Érudit is a non-profit inter-university consortium of the Université de Montréal, Université Laval, and the Université du Québec à Montréal.
    [Show full text]
  • Table of Contents
    Table of Contents Festival Schedule 2 Venues, Accessibility and Tickets 6 Staff and Board Listing 8 About Inside Out 9 Welcome Letters 14 Funders and Sponsors 20 Members and Donors 24 Galas and Special Presentations 30 Premieres 38 Episodic 52 Icons 62 Spotlight on Canada 74 International Showcase 84 Shorts 104 Industry and Special Events 122 Awards and Jury 124 Festival Lounge 126 Parties 130 Thank You 139 Film Index 140 Festival Schedule Festival Schedule 11:00am 12:00pm 1:00pm 2:00pm 3:00pm 4:00pm 5:00pm 6:00pm 7:00pm 8:00pm 9:00pm 10:00pm 11:00pm Opening Night Film: Rocketman Thurs. 7:30pm | TBLB 1 | p 30 May 23 Opening Night Film: Rocketman 7:45pm | TBLB 2 | p 30 Fri. Shorts: Top of the Billie and Emma Bit Special Presentation: Sell By May World 4:45pm | TBLB 7:00pm | TBLB 1 | p 41 9:30pm | TBLB 1 | p 34 24 1:00pm | TBLB 1 | 1 | p 85 p 114 Drag Kids Circus of Books Before You Know It 5:00pm | TBLB 2 | 6:45pm | TBLB 2 | p 63 9:15pm | TBLB 2 | p 40 p 74 Sat. Shorts: Give It Up or Gay Chorus Deep South Scream, Queen: My Good Kisser The Blonde One May Let Me Go 2:15pm | TBLB 1 | p 64 Nightmare on Elm 7:15pm | TBLB 1 | p 31 9:30pm | TBLB 1 | p 42 25 12:00pm | TBLB 1 | Street p 107 5:00pm | TBLB 1 | p 66 Dykes in the Shorts: Not Ready to Shorts: Wide EastSiders: Season 4 Zen in the Ice Rift Streets Make Nice Open Spaces 7:00pm | TBLB 2 | 9:15pm | TBLB 2 | p 99 12:15pm | TBLB 2 | 2:00pm | TBLB 2 | p 109 4:45pm | p 54 p 75 TBLB 2 | p 115 Sun.
    [Show full text]
  • MIAMI UNIVERSITY the Graduate School Certificate for Approving The
    MIAMI UNIVERSITY The Graduate School Certificate for Approving the Dissertation We hereby approve the Dissertation of Aaron W. Miller Candidate for the Degree: Doctor of Philosophy ____________________________________________ Erik N. Jensen, Director ____________________________________________ Andrew Cayton, Reader ____________________________________________ Kimberly Hamlin, Reader ____________________________________________ Kevin Armitage, Graduate School Representative ABSTRACT GLORIOUS SUMMER: A CULTURAL HISTORY OF NINETEENTH-CENTURY BASEBALL, 1861-1920 by Aaron W. Miller In the decades after the Civil War, Americans turned baseball, a fad from New York City, into their national obsession. Baseball’s apostles used the game’s Civil War experience to infuse it with militaristic, nationalistic, and patriotic themes. They mythologized the history of the game. Baseball’s explosive growth across the nation came with profound implications. Baseball formed a mass, united culture. Although Civil War soldiers played baseball to escape the dreariness and terror of life during war, the process of militarizing and imbuing the game with patriotic themes started even before the guns fell silent. As the sport spread nationally, it advanced a northern, middle-class vision of masculinity. Baseball shaped gender roles in the late nineteenth century. In the early days of baseball, women were important as spectators, yet the sporting culture lambasted their play. Of course, baseball also excluded racial minorities. Baseball’s promoters saw the game as a restorer of white masculinity, which many believed was atrophying. By the end of the dead-ball era, Americans thought that baseball was essential for national strength. Baseball helped reunify the nation after the sectional crisis. As Americans remembered the war, and baseball, in glorious military terms, they ignored the racial and political issues which drove the nation apart.
    [Show full text]
  • Man Injured in Crash After Being Ejected from Vehicle
    June 30th, 2016 The Ocean County Gazette - www.ocgazette.news 1 The OC Gazette P.O. Box 577 Seaside Heights NJ 08751 On The Web at: www.ocgazette.news JUNE 30TH, 2016 VOL. 16 NO. 567 THIS WEEKS Man Injured in Crash After Being ISSUE Pages 10-11 Ejected from Vehicle Ocean County Manchester Twp NJ – On Friday, June 24, Featured Events 2016, at approximately 1:11 AM, members of the Manchester Township Police Department Pages 12-18 responded to the intersection of Route 571 Around all the and Seminole Street for the report of a multiple Ocean County vehicle crash. Upon arrival, officers learned Towns - News, Information that it was a two vehicle crash involving a 2011 Events Nissan Altima and a 2001 Mazda Tribute. The Nissan was being operated by Joseph M. Diperi, Pages 22-23 23, of Manalapan and the Mazda was being Ocean County operated by Jevon I. Cotte, 24, of South Toms Library Weekend River. The investigation revealed that the Nissan Events and Exhibits was making a left turn from Seminole Street on to Route 571 when it collided with the Mazda, Page - 26 which was traveling eastbound on Route 571. Long Beach Island The impact caused the Mazda to overturn. Foundation of the The operator, Cotte, who was not wearing his Arts & Sciences seatbelt at the time, was ejected through the Events Manchester Township Water Utility sunroof. Cotte sustained injuries and was transported via ambulance Eastern Service Area Customers Page 30 to Jersey Shore University Medical Center by MONOC Paramedics for Museums, Historic, treatment.
    [Show full text]
  • Service Line Page 1 Service Line
    Service Line Page 1 Service Line Volume XVI Issue 3 November 15, 2010 Letter from Cathy SideOut Club, I hope this newsletter finds everyone well and excited for the final few matches of the season. As you know the Big Ten has been crazier than ever this year. Any team In This Issue: is able to beat any other on any given night! (UM lost to Iowa last weekend…) The tough, and constant, battle with the injury bug has tested our depth, but we are • Letter from Cathy working to get everyone healthy for the final four matches of the season. The team is continuing to work hard and has kept improving in the final few weeks of the regu- • Upcoming Events lar season. Their consistent commitment to excellence and learning has us optimistic for the remainder of the season and the future of MSU Volleyball. November 10 was National Signing Day—which means that 3 of our incoming 2011 players were able to OFFICIALLY sign a National Letter of Intent (NLI) declaring their commitment to Michigan State! We are very excited to add them to our roster and know they will be able to contribute in a variety of ways. Read more about them on the next page! We are encouraged by the constant support from the SideOut Club as well as the community! Our last home weekend boasted crowds of over 4,000 people each night—aided in part by the fantastic Pajama Event to aid Children with Cancer. It really was a unique night and a wonderful even to be a part of—even if it meant me looking goofy in an MSU Robe! Letter from Cathy 1 We look forward to seeing you all this weekend
    [Show full text]
  • Level Playing Fields
    Level Playing Fields LEVEL PLAYING FIELDS HOW THE GROUNDSKEEPING Murphy Brothers SHAPED BASEBALL PETER MORRIS UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA PRESS LINCOLN & LONDON © 2007 by the Board of Regents of the University of Nebraska ¶ All rights reserved ¶ Manufactured in the United States of America ¶ ¶ Library of Congress Cata- loging-in-Publication Data ¶ Li- brary of Congress Cataloging-in- Publication Data ¶ Morris, Peter, 1962– ¶ Level playing fields: how the groundskeeping Murphy brothers shaped baseball / Peter Morris. ¶ p. cm. ¶ Includes bibliographical references and index. ¶ isbn-13: 978-0-8032-1110-0 (cloth: alk. pa- per) ¶ isbn-10: 0-8032-1110-4 (cloth: alk. paper) ¶ 1. Baseball fields— History. 2. Baseball—History. 3. Baseball fields—United States— Maintenance and repair. 4. Baseball fields—Design and construction. I. Title. ¶ gv879.5.m67 2007 796.357Ј06Ј873—dc22 2006025561 Set in Minion and Tanglewood Tales by Bob Reitz. Designed by R. W. Boeche. To my sisters Corinne and Joy and my brother Douglas Contents List of Illustrations viii Acknowledgments ix Introduction The Dirt beneath the Fingernails xi 1. Invisible Men 1 2. The Pursuit of Pleasures under Diffi culties 15 3. Inside Baseball 33 4. Who’ll Stop the Rain? 48 5. A Diamond Situated in a River Bottom 60 6. Tom Murphy’s Crime 64 7. Return to Exposition Park 71 8. No Suitable Ground on the Island 77 9. John Murphy of the Polo Grounds 89 10. Marlin Springs 101 11. The Later Years 107 12. The Murphys’ Legacy 110 Epilogue 123 Afterword: Cold Cases 141 Notes 153 Selected Bibliography 171 Index 179 Illustrations following page 88 1.
    [Show full text]
  • By Peter Morrisuna
    up from the e by Peter Morrisuna An excerpt from the recently published DAVID CRONENBERG: A DELICATE BALANCE, a biography of David Cronenberg by Peter Morris, reprinted by permission of Ecw Pre„ Toronto. Watching David Cronenberg's first two short films today is to see barely a sketch of the themes and styles of his later films. Both Transfer and From the Drain are one-note films for two performers, somewhat sur- realist in tone but technically awkward. Both have the off-centre humour that we associate with Cronenberg. Both touch on issues of science: Transfer is a dialogue between a from straight narrative to experimental because of a seminude sex scene. psychiatrist and an obsessive former works inspired by the New York under- Screenings at McMaster and Carleton patient; From the Drain is a dialogue set ground. Many of them focus on the lives universities were halted by university in the future between two fully clothed and loves of young people. Others officials, and the print was later seized by men in a bathtub discussing biological emphasized experimental imagery. Many the Ontario Censor Board. However, mutations when a plant emerges from broke sexual taboos and ran afoul of the receipts from the screenings enabled the drain and kills one of them. This provincial censor boards. Some of the Kent to finance a second feature, Sweet later latter film contains elements of filmmakers involved went on to careers Substitute, in 1964. The film won critical Emergent Evolutionism' and hints at a in film, and a few are now well-known praise, was shown at several festivals, and similar use of bathtub drains in Shivers.
    [Show full text]
  • Cornell Dedicates Its Newest Training Ground--The Kane Sports Complex
    VA CAT o N BUL LET N December 1996 Vol. XI, No.9 Florida Everglades V·C 0 ian Eng and February 22-27, 1997 ay 30 - June 9, 1997 Not so long ago, Southwest Florida was a vast, subtropical wilder­ Queen Victoria's reign coincided with the apogee of British wealth ness whose sparkling beaches and great swamps nurtured count­ and power, the rise of the Victorian middle class, and a remark­ less species of plant and animal life. Much has changed, but with able period in British literature, politics, and political thought. From the help of good friends who know the region well, we'll explore charming Harrogate in the midlands, to Oxford, Winchester, the and appreciate special places where nature's heritage still reigns. Isle of Wight, Brighton, and London this study tour with Isaac Join CAU favorites Dick Fischer and Ollie Hewitt in Shark Valley, Kramnick, Miriam Brody, and Glenn Altschuler will explore the among the Ten Thousand Islands of Everglades National Park, on marvelous, complex world of Victoria and the Victorians. Sanibel Island, and in Corkscrew Swamp. (An extension to Lake Okeechobee is planned as well.) C·vil War Along the iss·ssippi March 15-22, 1997 The campaign to seize the Mississippi was one of the critical en­ . g. deavors of the Civil War. With historians Joel and David Silbey we II retrace the war in the west at Jackson, Vicksburg, and New Or­ CAU's agenda for Summer '97 includes courses leans, and spend time at beautiful places (including Natchez) that on Contemporary India, Christianity and Judaism, reflect the character of the antebellum South.
    [Show full text]
  • Issue 141 December 2011
    Bimonthly Magazine for the Association of British Scrabble Players Issue 141 - December 2011 SCRABBLE ® is a registered trademark of J.W.Spear & Sons Ltd, Maidenhead SL6 4UB committee matters Minutes of ABSP Committee Meeting: Sunday 2nd October 2011 Venue: Philip’s house, London Present: Peter Ashurst (PA), Wayne Kelly (WK), Ross Mackenzie (RM), Philip Nelkon (PN), Steve Perry (SP). Standing apologies: Anand Buddhdev (AB), Elie Dangoor (ED), Darryl Francis (DF), Anand Buddhdev (AB), Elie Dangoor (ED), Paula Davenport (PD), Alec Webb (AW). Apologies: Laura Finley (LF), Stewart Holden (SH), Elisabeth Jardine (EJ), Anne Ramsay (AR) Ratings Officer: John Grayson (JG) Resignations/appointments: Allan Simmons stepped down from the Committee as of the AGM but will remain on the Committee discussion group, at least during the handover period. Minutes of the previous meeting: agreed via email Team member reports and discussion Treasurer’s report: • Barclays mandate has been updated with PA, RM and LF as signatories • Bank balance – £14,359.22 nett of payment of £27,605.62 for Yarnfield Park • 2010 accounts have been audited and approved • Standing Orders – the matter was deferred at the AGM. PA is investigating further. • Membership database has been reformatted, PA / AR are to review the current set up. • Out turn cost for BMSC was a loss of £860.55, prize money was increased by using 2010 surplus of £540. • BMSC giveaway mugs – surplus were sold to Tilefish • Out turn cost for Masters was a loss of £37.00 • 50 Short Scrabble boards have been
    [Show full text]
  • IMA MUMBAI WEST Editor Contact for Write-Ups, Articles, Interviews and Dr
    1 CONTENTS PRESIDENT’S DESK............................................................................. 3 WEEKLY SCIENTIFIC LECTURES ..................................................... 4 G.P.FORUM ............................................................................................. 4 SECRETARY’S DESK ............................................................................ 5 EDITORIAL ............................................................................................. 7 PUBLIC HEALTH & WELFARE SUBCOMMITTEE A REPORT ............... 9 REPORT OF “DENTISTRY UPDATE” ................................................... 11 AWARENESS PROGRAMME ON “CANCER OF THE FEMALE GENITAL TRACT”.................................... 13 PROGRAMME ON “WORLD HEART DAY” ......................................... 14 “CARDIOLOGY CAMP” ON OCCASION OF “WORLD HEART DAY” .... 15 WOMEN’S WING PROGRAME .............................................................. 16 IMA HQ ................................................................................................... 17 ALTER EGO ........................................................................................... 19 ‘SCRABBLE’.......................................................................................... 21 CHELATION THERAPY ......................................................................... 23 ARE WE ‘OVER’ OXYGENATING OUR MI PATIENTS ?........................ 27 EDITORIAL BOARD Published by : IMA MUMBAI WEST Editor Contact for write-ups, articles, interviews and Dr. B.
    [Show full text]
  • The Next Destin'd Post
    The ball once struck off, Away flies the Boy To The Next Destin’d Post And then Home with Joy Vol 2, № 3 — April 1, 2013 Page 1 Interview with Peter Morris Protoball: What personal trail led you to your role as one of early base ball’s best and most prolific authors? Peter Morris: A fascination with the early history of baseball and a feeling that there were topics that deserved a book-length treatment but had not yet received one. In one way or another, every book I’ve written has been one that I first wished someone else had written. Only when I realized that nobody had done so and nobody was likely to do so, did I decide to write each of them. This Issue’s Features Protoball: Academic writing on base ball in its early context (Guttman, Reiss, Rader, etc.) flourished less than a generation ago, * P.1 -- Interview with Peter Morris and then pretty much stopped. Where did it * P.2 -- The Wheaton Find, by Randall Brown come from, and why did it end? * P.3 -- Digger News * P. 4 -- New at the Protoball website Peter Morris: That’s a great question. I think * P. 6 -- Tom Altherr’s Latest Find two major factors are that the academics who * P. 6 -- Bob Tholkes’ 19CBB Digests became most prominent in the field: (1) were way too devoted to modernization theory, an extremely narrow vantage point that left little theoretical room for subsequent researchers, and (2) produced work that often wasn’t very good, at least when it came to baseball, but formed a little closed work in which they all praised one another’s work whether good or bad.
    [Show full text]