UNCLASS FIE /

Member Briefings on Enhanced Interrogation Techniques (EITs)

9/4/02 Briefing Briefing on EITs including use of EITs on Abu Tim Sample Briefers Zubaydah, background on authorities, and a Michael Sheehy CTC description of the particular EITs that had been employed. Support OCA

2 9/27/02 Briefing Briefing on EITs including use of EITs on Abu SSCI Alfred Cumming Briefers ZUbaydah, background on authorities, and a Richard Shelby Bill Duhnke CTC description of the particular EITs that had been employed. Support OCA

3 2/4/03 Briefing Briefing on EITs, including the fact that SSCI Pat Roberts Chris Mellon Briefers interrogations of Zubaydah and Nashiri were John Rockefeller' Bill Duhnke NCS taped. CTC 'Later individual OGC EITs "described in considerable detail," briefing to Rockefeller including "how the water board was used." Support The process by which the techniques were OCA approved by DoJ was also raised.

4 2/5/03 Briefing Discussion of detainee interrogation HPSCI Porter Goss Patrick Murray Briefers program/techniques. Jane Harman Louise Healey NCS Michael Sheehy CTC Existence of AZ tapes briefed and that the tapes OGC to be destroyed as soon as IG completed his report. Support OCA It was also discussed that interrogation methods were similar to those taught/used in SERE training.

UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO 81

5 9/4/03 Briefing RDI Briefing: SSCI Pat Roberts Christopher Briefers John Rockefeller Mellon DCI Briefed on EITs, including a slide presentation Bill Duhnke DDCI where non-enhanced and enhanced NCS interrogation techniques were named, OGC described, and compared on the same slide. Support OCA

6 9/4/03 Briefing RDI Briefing: HPSCI Porter Goss Suzanne Briefers Jane Harman Spaudling NCS Briefed on EITs, including a slide presentation Patrick Murray OGC where non-enhanced and enhanced interrogation techniques were named, Support described, and compared on the same slide. OCA

7 7/13/04 Briefing 1. IG presented report on interrogations. HPSCI Porter Goss Pat Murray Briefers 2. Status update on interrogation process. Jane Harman Suzanne NCS 3. General Counsel informed of legal/policy Spaulding OGC issues. Support EITs were discussed, including a specific CTC mention ofwaterboarding as one of the EITs. OCA Discussion of CIA. currently seeking reaffirmation from DOJ on use of EITs as well as renewed policy approval from NSC principals to continue using EITs.

8 7/15/2004 Briefing Briefed on Interrogation Techniques, including SSCI Pat Roberts Christopher Briefers , abdominal slap, and sleep John Rockefeller Mellon NCS deprivation. Also briefed on actionable Bill Duhnke OGC intelligence derived from use of EITs. OIG

Support CTC OGC OCA

UNCLA881F1 /FOUO !

9 1/25/05 Briefing Interrogation Techniques briefed, HPSCI Peter Hoekstra Mike Meermans Briefer Jane Harman O'Keefe (First NCS name unknown) Support OCA

10 3/7/05 ~riefing Interrogation Techniques briefed, SSCI Pat Roberts Bill Duhnke Not Available John Rockefeller Andy Jonhson

11 3/8/05 Briefing Interrogation Techniques briefed, SSCI Pat Roberts Not Available HPSCI John Rockefeller Porter Goss Jane Harman 12 10/18/05 Briefing Interrogation Techniques briefed, SAC-D Ted Stevens Not Available Thad Cochran

13 Late Oct Briefing Interrogation Techniques briefed, Senate John McCain Not Available 05

14 10/31/05 Briefing Briefing on the specifics the EITs, Senate Bill Frist Mark Esper Briefers Leadership DI/OTA There was also a lengthy discussion about the CTC OLC memos, Support OCA

15 11/1/05 Briefing Interrogation Techniques briefed, Senate Bill Frist Mark Esper Not Available Leadership Briefed on interrogation techniques, including waterboard, facial slap, abdominal slap, sleep deprivation, and walling,

16 1118/05 Briefing Interrogation Techniques briefed, HASC Duncan Hunter Not Available

UNCLASSIFI !FOUO /

17 11/8/05 Briefing Briefing on the description of all 13 EITs, HPSCI Peter Hoekstra Briefer CTC

Support OCA

18 7/11/06 Briefing CTC Detainee Program: SSCI Pat Roberts Jim Hensler Briefer John Rockefeller Brandon Millhorn DCIA Briefing on the potential to revive use of the EIT Andy Johnson program, Specific mention and discussion of Support techniques by number. ODCIA OCAr

19 9/6/06 Briefing The Director "provided significant details, Senate Bill Frist Briefer naming all EITs and providing a verbal Leadership Harry Reid DCIA description of most EITs," There was also a specific discussion of waterboarding, Support ADMA ODCIA OCA

20 9/6/06 Briefing The Director "provided significant details, HPSCI Jane Harman Dave Buckley Briefer naming all EITs and providing a verbal DCIA description of most EITs," Support ADMA ODCIA OCA

21 9/6/06 Briefing Significant details of EITs were provided in this SSCI Full Committee* Jim Hensler Briefer briefing to include mentions of waterboarding, Andy Johnson DCIA diet manipulation, nudity, walling, and stomach * did not slap, attend Support ADMA ODCIA OCA

UNCLASSIFI /FOUO 22 9/6/06 Briefing The Director named all 13 EITs at this briefing HPSCI Full Committee Mike Meermans Briefer and verbally described most. Specific mention DCIA of waterboarding, water dousing, stomach slap, walling, and the methods used in carrying out Support these techniques. ADMA ODCIA OCA

23 9/6/06 Briefing The Director briefed on specific EITs, provided HPSCI Full Committee' Briefer detailed descriptions and answered numerous DCIA questions on the specific techniques. 'Mike Rogers did not attend Support ADMA ODCIA OCA

24 9/19/06 Briefing Briefing on full detainee program, including the House Paul Juola Not Available 13 EITs. John Murtha'

'Murtha did not stay for EIT portion of the briefing.

25 11/16/06 Briefing Latest Status of CIA high-value terrorist SSCI Pat Roberts Andy Johnson Briefer detention program, use of EITs and capture of a Mike Dewine Jim Hensler DCIA detainee and rendition. John Rockefeller Evan Bayh Support Christopher Bond ADMA Saxby Chambliss ODCIA Russ Feingold OCA Dianne Feinstein Carl Levin Trent Lott Barbara Mikulski John Warner

26 11/16/06 Briefing The Director briefed on latest status detention HPSCI Full Committee Michael Briefer program, use of EITs, and recent capture of a Meermans DCIA detainee, including a discussion specific EITs David Buckley and procedures. Jim Lewis Support Wyndee Parker OCA ADMA

UNCLASSIFI /FOUO 27 12/19/06 Briefing Briefing on a detainee and Detainee Program, HPSCI Mike Delaney Briefer including EITs, Wyndee Parker DCIA

Support ODCIA OCA 28 3/14/07 Hearing The Director described EITs and made it clear HPSCI Full Committee Staff Directors Briefer to the committee that waterboarding had not DCIA been used in years, Support ADMA ODCIA CTC OCA 29 4/12/07 Hearing Briefing on ICRC Report on Detentions, SSCI John Rockefeller 21 Staffers Briefers including a discussion of EITs. Christopher Bond DCIA Carl Levin CTC Dianne Feinstein ADMA Richard Burr Orrin Hatch Support John Warner ODCIA Russ Feingold OCA Saxby Chambliss 30 6/19/07 Hearing John Rizzo Nomination: SSCI John Rockefeller Randy Bookout Nominee Christopher Bond Andy Johnson A/GC Mr. Rizzo was asked to name the EITs, which Evan Bayh Louis Tucker he did. There was also much general Russ Feingold Support discussion about interrogation techniques Diane Feinstein OGC documented through this hearing. Carl Levin OCA Olympia Snowe OPA John Warner Sheldon Whitehouse Ron Wyden

UNCLASSIFI IFOUO 31 8/2/07 Hearing Hearing on the Executive Order, Common SSCI John Rockefeller 16 Staffers Briefers Article 3: Christopher Bond CTC Saxby Chambliss Discussions of the use of all currently-approved Russ Feingold Support EITs on a detainee. Dianne Feinstein CTC Carl Levin OCA Barbara Mikulski Bill Nelson Olympia Snowe Ron Wyden John Warner

32 10/11/07 Meeting The Director discussed the number of detainees HAC-D John Murtha Paul Juola Briefer sUbjected to EITs and discussed EITs. DCIA

Support ODCIA OCA 33 11/9/07 Briefing Briefing on EITs. SSCI Bill Nelson Briefer ADMA

Support OCA OGC

UNCLASSIFI /FOUO 34 12/11/07 Hearing Detainee Videotape Destruction: SSCI Dianne Feinstein Andy Johnson Briefer Ron Wyden Melvin Dubee, DCIA The specific EITs used against Abu Zubaydah Evan Bayh James Wolfe were read aloud during this hearing. Barbara Mikulski John Dickas Support Waterboarding of Abu Zubaydah was Russ Feingold Michael Davidson ODCIA discussed. Bill Nelson David Grannis OCA Sheldon Whitehouse Jack Livingston Carl Levin Don Mitchell John Warner Eric Pelofsky Chuck Hagel Kathleen Rice Orrin Hatch Jacqui Russell Olympia Snowe Alissa Starzak Richard Burr James Smythers Caroline Tess Louis Tucker Jeremy Bash Jay Heath

35 1/16/08 Hearing Videotape Destruction: HPSCI Silvestre Reyes Mike Delaney Briefer Anna Eshoo Wyndee Parker AIGC Discussion of EITs, including waterboarding. Peter Hoekstra Linda Cohen Janice Schakowsky Jeremy Bash Mike Rogers Brian Morrison Dutch Ruppersberger Jim Lewis Darrellissa Don Viera Elton Gallegly Eric Greenwald Mac Thornberry Chris Donesa James Langevin Jay Heath Robert Cramer Terry Everett Leonard Boswell John McHugh Todd Tiahrt Patrick Murphy Rush Holt

k'VJ~~vSIFIED//FOUO 36 2/5/08 Hearing Annual Threat Assessment: SSCI Dianne Feinstein Briefer John Rockefeller DCIA Discussion of the EITs used with a detainee, Evan Bayh Support Sheldon Whitehouse 011001 John Warner ODCIA Orrin Hatch Russell Feingold Olympia Snowe Saxby Chambliss Bill Nelson Kit Bond 37 2/14/08 Hearing OLC Oversight Hearing: HJC Jerrold Nadler Support Trent Franks OCA Discussions about interrogation techniques, Arthur David Specific mention numerous times of Melvin Watt waterboarding. Bobby Scott Darrellissa John Bradbury Keith Ellison

UNCLASSIFIEO//FOUO 38 3/6/08 Hearing Discussion of EITs with a detainee. SSCI Christopher Bond Briefers Sheldon Whitehouse NCS Orrin Hatch CFO Olympia Snowe Support Richard Burr OCA Evan Bayh Russell Feingold Dianne Feinstein Barbara Mikulski

39 6/10/08 Hearing RDI and DOJ OLC Opinions: SSCI Christopher Bond Briefer Saxby Chambliss CTC Discussion of EITs and the OLC opinions. Sheldon Whitehouse Specific mentions of waterboarding numerous Support Richard Burr times. Reference made to EITs. OCA Dianne Feinstein CTC Russell Feingold Bill Nelson John Rockefeller Olympia Snowe Ron Wyden

40 3/12/09 Hearing General references to EITs, interrogations, and HPSCI Roy Blunt IramAli Briefers the end of the use of EITs by the CIA David Boren Linda Cohen DCIA throughout. One mention of one specific EIT, Mike Conaway Mike Delaney NCS waterboarding. Anna Eshoo Stacey Dizon Elton Gallegly Chris Donesa Support Mike Eoyang ODCIA Peter Hoekstra Eric Greenwald OCA John Kline Kristen Jepson CFO Jeff Miller Jim Lewis NCS Patrick Murphy Brian Morrison Sue Myrick George Pappas Silvestre Reyes Kathleen Reilly Mike Rogers Don Viera Dutch Ruppersberger Janice Schakowsky Mac Thornberry Adam Smith

UNCLASSI ED/ FOUO