T HE J OURNAL OF SANDIEGO HISTORy VOLUME 50 ■ WINTER/ SPRING 2004 ■ NUMBERS 1 & 2 IRIS H. W. ENGSTRAND MOLLY MCCLAIN Editors COLIN R. FISHER DAWN M. RIGGS Review Editors MATTHEW BOKOVOY Contributing Editor Published since 1955 by the SAN DIEGO HISTORICAL SOCIETY Post Office Box 81825, San Diego, California 92138 ISSN 0022-4383 T HE J OURNAL OF SAN DIEGO HISTORy VOLUME 50 ■ WINTER/SPRING 2004 ■ NUMBERS 1 & 2 Editorial Consultants Published quarterly by the MATTHEW BOKOVOY San Diego Historical Society at University of Oklahoma 1649 El Prado, Balboa Park, San Diego, California 92101 DONALD C. CUTTER Albuquerque, New Mexico A $50.00 annual membership in the San WILLIAM DEVERELL Diego Historical Society includes subscrip- University of Southern California; Director, Huntington-USC Institute on California tion to The Journal of San Diego History and and the West the SDHS Times. Back issues and microfilm copies are available. VICTOR GERACI University of California, Berkeley Articles and book reviews for publication PHOEBE KROPP consideration, as well as editorial correspon- University of Pennsylvania dence should be addressed to the ROGER W. LOTCHIN Editors, The Journal of San Diego History University of North Carolina Department of History, University of San at Chapel Hill Diego, 5998 Alcala Park, San Diego, CA NEIL MORGAN 92110 Journalist DOYCE B. NUNIS, JR. All article submittals should be typed and University of Southern California double spaced, and follow the Chicago Manual of Style. Authors should submit four JOHN PUTMAN San Diego State University copies of their manuscript, plus an electronic copy, in MS Word or in rich text format ANDREW ROLLE (RTF). The Huntington Library RAMON EDUARDO RUIZ The San Diego Historical Society assumes no University of California, San Diego responsibility for the statements or opinions ABE SHRAGGE of the authors. University of California, San Diego RAYMOND STARR ©2005 by the San Diego Historical Society San Diego State University ISSN 022-4383 DAVID J. WEBER Periodicals postage paid at San Diego, CA Southern Methodist University Publication No. 331-870 (619) 232-6203 www.sandiegohistory.org CONTENTS VOLUME 50 ■ WINTER/ SPRING 2004 ■ NUMBERS 1 & 2 PREFACE by Dr. Mary E. Lyons President, University of San Diego iv ARTICLES Una Casa del Pueblo — A Town House of Old San Diego by Victor A. Walsh 1 El Congreso in San Diego: An Endeavor for Civil Rights by Carlos M. Larralde 17 The Rancho Tía Juana (Tijuana) Grant by Antonio Padilla Corona translated by Paul Bryan Gray 30 The Development of Spanish-language Television in San Diego: A Contemporary History by Kristin C. Moran 42 BOOK REVIEWS 55 PREFACE ■ Joan B. Kroc Institute for Peace & Justice, University of San Diego ith the publication of this issue of The Journal of San Diego History, the University of San Diego (USD) is pleased to inaugurate its new rela- Wtionship with the San Diego Historical Society. Professors of History, Iris H. W. Engstrand and Molly McClain, have generously offered their expertise and editorial skills to the Journal and brought our University into the heart of the enterprise. USD’s own history suggests why this match is good. For more than fifty years, the University of San Diego has been a vital partici- pant in the growth and development of San Diego and the surrounding region. At a time when jackrabbits dominated the landscape of our Linda Vista mesa, the founders of USD—Bishop Charles F. Buddy and Mother Rosalie Clifton Hill, RSCJ—imagined and then built something grand: a scholarly community where the sons and daughters of San Diegans might seek the truth and beauty on a hill overlooking the sea. The founders intended to preserve the rich legacy of learning and culture imported to San Diego by the Franciscan missionaries from Spain through the art, architecture, and curriculum of the colleges. The inspiration for this project was the great Spanish University of Alcalá de Henares, the home of our city’s namesake, iv PREFACE San Diego de Alcalá. This humanistic center of learning educated people like Ignatius of Loyola and Teresa of Avila during Spain’s Golden Age. Today, a San Diegan who visits the remnants of the old university at Alcalá de Henares immedi- ately recognizes the architectural inheritance given to the University of San Diego. Our campus contains some of the best revival Spanish Renaissance architecture outside of Spain. It is fitting, then, that the University of San Diego join in a new and vital partnership with the San Diego Historical Society. The Journal of San Diego History will benefit from the editing of two superb historians, Professors Iris H. W. Engstrand and Molly McClain. USD’s commitment to this joint venture with the Society offers readers all that they have come to expect from a scholarly chronicle and, more, the insightful and creative influence of academics who are themselves invested in preserving and celebrating our region’s vitality. Mary E. Lyons, PhD President University of San Diego Degheri Alumni Center Courtyard v THE JOURNAL OF SAN DIEGO HISTORY Hazel Wood Waterman ©SDHS #88:16649-9 Waterman Family Collection UNA CASA DEL PUEBLO UNA CASA DEL PUEBLO — A TOWN HOUSE OF OLD SAN DIEGO ■ Winner of the 2004 Institute of History Mary Ward Award Victor A. Walsh “The Spanish Dons, rather than the Mexican paisanos, became the symbols of the Spanish past.” — Carey McWilliams, Southern California, An Island on the Land, 1946 ll around the empty plaza stood the crumbling adobes and roofless walls of another time. One of them, the Casa de Estudillo on the southeast side of the Aplaza in Old Town San Diego State Historic Park, had been bought in 1906 by the sugar magnate and investor John D. Spreckels. Hoping to capitalize on Old Town’s tourist potential, he extended his streetcar line up Calhoun Street to the plaza. Two years later his vice president and managing director, William Clayton, hired a 43-year old widow recently turned designer to research and restore the historic ruin. Her name was Hazel Wood Waterman, the daughter-in-law of former Governor Robert Whitney Waterman and then employee of noted San Diego architect Irving Gill.1 Completed in 1910, the restoration launched one of California’s first historic tourist attractions and in the process helped to inspire a nostalgic fetish, an antiquari- an enthusiasm for the state’s Spanish heritage. An estimated 125,000 people visited the Casa de Estudillo in 1915, the same year that the Panama-California Exposition opened in Balboa Park.2 San Diego had been “discovered” by the outside world, but what was the appeal of this restored adobe in a backwater village on the outskirts of the modern city? To unravel the knot of this question requires an investigation into the power and interplay of myth and history. What was the history of the casa and the Estudillo fam- ily who lived there until 1887? How accurate is Waterman’s restoration in terms of design, use of materials, construction methods, landscape, and furnishings? What was her research approach? Her source(s) of information and inspiration? What did the Casa de Estudillo signify to early twentieth-century California society? How did myth and history as popularized in literature, film, and art shape or alter the historic mem- ory of the visiting public? History of a House and a Family Built between 1827-1829 by Lieutenant José Antonio Estudillo, this adobe town Victor A. Walsh is a historian with California State Parks in San Diego. He earned a Ph. D. in American history, with a focus on 19th-century ethnicity and race, from the University of Pittsburgh in 1984. He taught as a lecturer at San Francisco State University, the University of San Francisco, and College of San Mateo. In 1991, he won the Carlton C. Qualey Award for an article published in the Journal of American Ethnic History on Irish drinking customs and Catholic total abstinence. 1 THE JOURNAL OF SAN DIEGO HISTORY house would become the social and ecclesiastical center of Old Town San Diego dur- ing the Mexican and early American periods.3 Born in 1803 at Monterey, José Antonio was the sixth child of José María, the Spanish-born comandante of the San Diego Presidio. His mother was María Gertrudis Horcasitas, a native of Tlayacopa, Mexico.4 Educated, proud, and handsome, José Antonio embodied the bearing of a Spanish gentleman. But he was not a pureblood Spaniard, nor did he support contin- ued Spanish colonial rule. Influenced by Mexico’s struggle for independence from Spain, he became a steadfast advocate of republican self-rule. In 1833, he and five other adult male citizens drafted a petition, urging the governor to establish a civil government in place of continued military rule by the presidio’s comandante.5 Tw o years later the governor declared Old Town San Diego as an official pueblo to be gov- erned by an elected town council. During Mexican rule, Estudillo played an influen- tial role in the town’s nascent political life, serving as treasurer, tax collector, juez de paz (justice of the peace), and finally as alcalde (mayor) in 1837-38. In 1850, under American rule, he served as treasurer, tax collector, and county assessor. José Antonio Estudillo also supported the breakup of the mission system in the early 1830s. Not only did it embody the last vestige of feudal Spanish rule in California, but its monopoly of land and Indian labor had inhibited development. Under the supposed enlightened leadership of rancheros like himself, secularization would reverse this trend. Estudillo had extensive landholdings, with grants to Rancho Temecula (1823), Rancho Janal (1829), and later Rancho San Jacinto Viejo (1845).