Of Disability

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Of Disability http://researchcommons.waikato.ac.nz/ Research Commons at the University of Waikato Copyright Statement: The digital copy of this thesis is protected by the Copyright Act 1994 (New Zealand). The thesis may be consulted by you, provided you comply with the provisions of the Act and the following conditions of use: Any use you make of these documents or images must be for research or private study purposes only, and you may not make them available to any other person. Authors control the copyright of their thesis. You will recognise the author’s right to be identified as the author of the thesis, and due acknowledgement will be made to the author where appropriate. You will obtain the author’s permission before publishing any material from the thesis. Disability as an Entanglement: A New Materialist Reimagination of Disability A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Education at The University of Waikato by Ingrid Rose-anne Jones 2019 Abstract: Research and contemporary practice indicate that people labelled as learning disabled remain positioned on the margins of humanity, despite decades of hard work from the disability rights movement, support workers, and families and whānau, among many others (Goodley, 2017). In this thesis, I seek to find some answers as to why this situation persists. I seek further to investigate if this ongoing marginalisation can be challenged through using new materialist theory to reimagine disability. The thesis begins by outlining the big picture of disability oppression in Aotearoa New Zealand and across the globe. Thereafter, literature from disability studies and the humanities more widely is drawn upon to argue that the binary notions of “learning disability” and “normal, ideal humans” are not fixed, indisputable concepts. Instead, they can be viewed as artefacts of the historical, spiritual, political and social structures which have emerged over the past few centuries in the Western world. Learning disability becomes of necessity positioned as inferior within this binary and, it can be argued further, this positioning plays a crucial role in the validation and perpetuation of disability oppression. The key conceptual frameworks shaping policy and practice in Aotearoa New Zealand are examined. This is done with a focus on the ontological underpinning of the ideal human inherent in many of these frameworks, and how this underpinning inhibits challenge to exclusionary structures and practices. The conceptual framework is formed from agential realism (Barad), citational chains and lines of flight (Bergson / Butler, as used by Davies), performativity (Butler), affect (Wetherell), desiring silence (Jackson and Mazzei), and disability pride (Parsons). Datum was generated through a series of nine “hui”, or research meetings. These were held with a co-facilitator and seven participants, all of whom have been assigned the label of learning disabled through diagnostic processes. i The analysis begins with participant responses to the collaborative exploration of ideas related to disability pride and ableism. Whilst there was evidence that participants enjoyed discussions related to ableism, many displayed a powerful adverse reaction to visual displays on pride. In particular, participants’ affective responses to the videos and discussions regarding pride signalled the limitations of the view that the problem is largely discursive. Exploring this challenge using the conceptual framework ultimately enabled me to propose a new means of conceptualising disability: disability as an ongoing series of entanglements. The entanglements which rose to the fore during data generation and analysis were the affective entanglements of disability, the desire for recognition as a viable subject, the silences regarding disability, and the drive to help. This thesis proposes that these entanglements serve to further the inferiorisation of disability and hold it in a static place of “otherness”, and thus foreclose potential for radical transformation to exclusionary structures and practices. However, by drawing upon agential realism I also highlight the ever-present possibility of rupture which lies within each of these entanglements. Based on the findings of this thesis, I conclude that radical potential for change can potentially be found by understanding and reworking these entanglements. ii Acknowledgements: The work in this thesis was made possible thanks to the support of many people. I would first like to thank my supervisory team – Lise Claiborne, Carol Hamilton and Alison Henderson, who provided me with unfailing support throughout the thesis journey. From my “what’s the point of theory?” days, through to the many, many chapter reviews, you were always on-hand to steer me in the right direction, and always made sure I knew that you had my back. I feel incredibly lucky to have had you as my supervisory team. I would like to thank my friends and family whose offerings of love, time, emotional support, finances and food helped me through this journey. I would particularly like to thank my mum, who never failed to make sure I felt supported, had warm clothes and plenty of food (as I write this I have a box of home-made biscuits labelled “PhD Sustenance” sitting next to me), and my partner Matthew, who spent many an hour being an ear to my endless ramblings. Thank you to my participant group. You were such a big help in my research. I really liked how you were honest with me about the things that were hard to talk about. I learnt a lot from the things you told me. I also really liked how keen you were to be a part of the research, to support me, and to laugh and have fun. I also want to say thank you to my co-facilitator, Glen. You did a great job helping me to plan the hui, thinking up ideas for the different activities and resources, and facilitating the hui. Your help made a big difference. I would like to thank the disability community in Aotearoa New Zealand, who have let me in as an honorary member, and who often provided a sounding- board for the project as it was developing. Lastly, I would like to thank the many disabled people and families who have let me into the lives over the years, and who have kept my heart in the disability sector. iii Nō reira, ka nui te mihi ki a koutou katoa (my sincere thanks to all of you), Ingrid Jones November 2018 iv Table of Contents: Abstract: ....................................................................................................................i Acknowledgements: ................................................................................................ iii Table of Contents: .................................................................................................... v Chapter 1: Introduction .......................................................................................... 1 A Note on Writing Style ................................................................................. 2 Disability Oppression - The Big Picture .......................................................... 4 Rethinking the “Problem” of Disability ........................................................ 10 Tools for Rethinking the “Problem” of Disability ............................... 11 Ableism. ......................................................................................... 11 Disability Pride. ............................................................................. 12 Conclusion.................................................................................................... 12 Thesis Structure ........................................................................................... 12 Chapter Outline ........................................................................................... 13 Chapter 2: Conceptualising Learning Disability ................................................... 17 Truth-Claims of Learning Disability .............................................................. 18 Pre-Contemporary Conceptualisations of Learning Disability .................... 22 Learning Disability as an Artefact of Modernity and Capitalism ................. 24 The Modernist Human, Capitalism and the Emergence of Learning Disability ............................................................................................. 24 The Bell Curve and the “Norm” .......................................................... 28 Ableism and the Concept of the Ideal Human ............................................ 33 The Inferior “Other” of the Ableist Binary ......................................... 35 Broader Processes of Othering .................................................................... 37 The Real World Consequences of Inferior Positioning ................................ 39 v Conclusion.................................................................................................... 42 Chapter 3: Learning Disability in Aotearoa New Zealand ..................................... 44 Medicalised Conceptualisations of Learning Disability ............................... 46 Normalisation .............................................................................................. 48 Normalisation and Support Services .................................................. 51 Normalisation, the Ideal Human and Devaluing Difference .............. 53 The Social Model ......................................................................................... 55 Local and International
Recommended publications
  • Seattle Queer Film Festival
    10-20 OCTOBER 2019 seattlequeerfilm.org Isn’t it time you planned your financial future? Photo Credit: Sabel Roizen We are excited to welcome you to the 24th annual Translations: Seattle Transgender Film Festival, Reel Seattle Queer Film Festival! The latest in queer cinema Queer Youth, Three Dollar Bill Outdoor Cinema; special from across the globe is being celebrated right here membership screenings; and, of course, the Seattle in our neighborhood, with 157 films from 28 countries Queer Film Festival. We are able to do this vital work in screening over 11 days. the community thanks to the generous support of our This year, the festival showcases many new voices and members, donors, and patrons. experiences, with films from around the world and right SQFF24 carries through it a message of resistance and here in Seattle, including the Northwest premiere of representation, and reflects the LGBTQ2+ community on Argentina’s Brief Story from the Green Planet, winner of the screen. We are thrilled to share these stories with you. Berlin Film Festival’s Teddy Award; and the world premiere We hope you’ll feel a sense of connection and strength in of No Dominion: The Ian Horvath Story by local filmmaker numbers throughout your viewing experience. Plot your course with someone who understands your needs. and Pacific Northwest Ballet principal soloist Margaret We’ll see you at the movies! Mullin. We also feature programs that give you a chance Financial Advisor Steve Gunn, who has earned the Accredited Domestic to reflect on the last 50 years since the Stonewall Riots, SM SM Partnership Advisor and Chartered Retirement Planning Counselor with films like State of Pride by renowned filmmakers Rob designations, can help you develop a strategy for making informed Epstein and Jeffrey Friedman, a 30th anniversary screening decisions about your financial future.
    [Show full text]
  • Senator D. Rodriguez (A)(S)(E), Senator R
    1 RESOLUTION #3F 2020 FALL SESSION 2 3 Legislative Action: 4 Introduced by: Senator R. Harper (A)(S)(E), Senator D. Rodriguez (A)(S)(E), Senator R. 5 Regalado (A)(S)(E), Senator B. Southern (A)(S)(E), Senator S. Musa (S), Senator T. Mondloch 6 (S), Senator E. Hotz (S)(E) 7 8 1st Reading: 9/2/2020 Referred To: Steering and Rules 9 2nd Reading:_______ Committee Action: 5-0-0-0 10 3rd Reading: _______ Senate Action:___________ 11 12 13 Executive Action: 14 15 __________________________________ _________________________ 16 ASUNM President Date 17 18 WHEREAS, the Associated Students of the University of New Mexico (ASUNM) Government 19 is the representative body of the undergraduate students and promotes student success; and 20 21 WHEREAS, the University of New Mexico (UNM) is a higher education institution that 22 promotes inclusivity and fosters respect for students of all backgrounds, and actively defends the 23 rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (LGBTQ+) faculty and students; and 24 25 WHEREAS, UNM has curated resources, initiatives, and policies dedicated to LGBTQ+ student 26 growth, both personal and academic, including but not limited to the LGBT Collaborative, 27 LGBT Patient-Centered Care Training and Education, Safe Zone Awareness, Safe Zone 28 Training, LGBTQ Resource Center Art Gallery, Cafe Q* Lecture Series, LGBTQ* Library, 29 Universal Restroom Initiative, PRIDE Scholarships, Affirmed/Preferred First Name Initiative, 30 UNM Regents' Policy 2.3, Policy 2720, National Coming Out Day Events, SHAC Gender- 31
    [Show full text]
  • Condorcet and I - a Fictional Conversation Between Condorcet and Me: on the Outlines of an Historical View of the Progress of the Human Mind Michael S
    Rollins College Rollins Scholarship Online Master of Liberal Studies Theses Spring 2015 Condorcet and I - A Fictional Conversation between Condorcet and Me: on the Outlines of an Historical View of the Progress of the Human Mind Michael S. Christopher Rollins College, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.rollins.edu/mls Part of the Fiction Commons Recommended Citation Christopher, Michael S., "Condorcet and I - A Fictional Conversation between Condorcet and Me: on the Outlines of an Historical View of the Progress of the Human Mind" (2015). Master of Liberal Studies Theses. 63. http://scholarship.rollins.edu/mls/63 This Open Access is brought to you for free and open access by Rollins Scholarship Online. It has been accepted for inclusion in Master of Liberal Studies Theses by an authorized administrator of Rollins Scholarship Online. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Condorcet and I A Fictional Conversation between Condorcet and Me on the Outlines of an Historical View of the Progress of the Human Mind A Project Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Liberal Studies by Michael S. Christopher May, 2015 Mentor: Dean, Patrick Powers Reader: Dr. Eric Smaw Rollins College Hamilton Holt School Master of Liberal Studies Program Winter Park, Florida 2 Condorcet and I A Fictional Debate between Condorcet and Me on the Outlines of an Historical View of the Progress of the Human Mind ________________________________________________________________
    [Show full text]
  • PERSPECTIVES PERSPECTIVES 2011 to 2013
    PERSPECTIVES PERSPECTIVES 2011 to 2013 2011 to 2013 INTERNATIONAL GAY AND LESBIANINTERNATIONAL GAY HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION INTERNATIONAL GAY AND LESBIAN HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION 80 Maiden Lane Suite 1505 New York, NY 10038 U.S.A INTERNATIONAL GAY AND LESBIAN iglhrc.org • fb.com/iglhrc • @iglhrc • [email protected] HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION © 2013 PerspectivesCover1120.indd 2-3 11/22/13 11:58 AM PerspectivesCover1120.indd 4-5 11/22/13 11:58 AM INTERNATIONAL GAY AND LESBIAN HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION COMMENTARIES, OP-EDITORIALS AND BLOGS 2011 to 2013 New York 2013 perspectives11232013.indd 1 11/24/13 11:36 PM perspectives11232013.indd 2 11/24/13 11:36 PM Contents INTRODUCTION ......................................I JESSICA STERN AFRICA ...........................................1 As the Flames of Homophobia Burn Around the World ................. 3 DAMIAN UGWU Rape is Rape .......................................... 6 KATE MUWOKI Zambia Shackled by Homophobic Laws .......................... 10 JULIET MPHANDE Malawi’s Constitution Clear on Gay Rights but Politicians Aren’t ............. 13 GIFT TRAPENCE Gay Ugandans: Loud and Proud ............................... 17 VAL KALENDE Zanu-PF Win Holds Bleak Prospects for LGBTI Rights ................... 20 CHESTERFIELD SAMBA ASIA AND THE PACIFIC ISLANDS ..........................25 Indonesian LBT Women Exposed to Backlash ....................... 27 GRACE POORE Stop Bullying .......................................... 29 DOI NAKPOR Wanted: Room for Respect .................................. 31 GING CRISTOBAL An LGBT Centre in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia ......................... 35 OTGONBAATAR TSEDENDEMBEREL AND MUNKHZAYA NERGUI Challenges We Face: Transgender Women in Malaysia .................. 38 NISHA AYUB LATIN AMERICA AND THE CARIBBEAN ......................43 LGBT Pride in Colombia ................................... 45 MARÍA MERCEDES GÓMEZ INTERNATIONAL GAY AND LESBIAN HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION 3 perspectives11232013.indd 3 11/24/13 11:36 PM Is Religion Superior to Human Rights? LBT Women in Chile ..............
    [Show full text]
  • Nikolay Alexeyev RUSSIAN B
    NIKOLAY ALEXEYEV RUSSIAN b. December 23, 1977 ACTIVIST “Without an ideal, nothing is possible.” Nikolay Alexeyev is Russia’s best-known and most quoted LGBT activist and the His leadership founder of Moscow Pride. In 2010 he won the first case on LGBT rights violations in Russia at the European Court of Human Rights. brought international Alexeyev was born and raised in Moscow. He graduated with honors from attention to LGBT Lomonosov Moscow State University, where he pursued postgraduate studies in rights in Russia. constitutional law. In 2001 the university forced him out, refusing to except his thesis on the legal restrictions of LGBT Russians. Claiming discrimination, he filed an appeal, but the Moscow district court denied it. In 2005, after publishing multiple books and legal reports on LGBT discrimination, Alexeyev fully dedicated himself to LGBT activism. He realized “that it wouldn’t be possible to change things in Russia just by writing” and that he should be involved in more direct activism. Despite an official ban on LGBT events, Alexeyev founded and served as the chief organizer of Gay Pride in Moscow. Participants in the Gay Pride parades were attacked and bullied by anti-gay protesters. Police arrested Alexeyev and fellow activists multiple times. Through both illegal public protests and legal appeals, Alexeyev’s uncompromising fight for the right to hold Moscow Pride drew international attention to the issue of LGBT rights in his country. In 2009, alongside Russian, French and Belarusian LGBT activists, Alexeyev organized a protest to denounce the inaction of the European Court in considering the legality of the Moscow Pride bans.
    [Show full text]
  • An Examination of the Emergence of the Queer Figure in North American Culture Using a Queer Marxist Theoretical Framework
    Western University Scholarship@Western Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository 8-12-2016 12:00 AM An Examination of the Emergence of the Queer Figure in North American Culture Using a Queer Marxist Theoretical Framework Jade C.R. Da Costa The University of Western Ontario Supervisor Charles G. Levine The University of Western Ontario Graduate Program in Sociology A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the equirr ements for the degree in Master of Arts © Jade C.R. Da Costa 2016 Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/etd Part of the Gender and Sexuality Commons, and the Inequality and Stratification Commons Recommended Citation Da Costa, Jade C.R., "An Examination of the Emergence of the Queer Figure in North American Culture Using a Queer Marxist Theoretical Framework" (2016). Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository. 3969. https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/etd/3969 This Dissertation/Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by Scholarship@Western. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository by an authorized administrator of Scholarship@Western. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Abstract This thesis develops a new sociological perspective entitled “Queer Marxism,” a neo- Marxist perspective on gender identity, gender expression, and gender oppression that incorporates Judith Butler’s queer perspective of gender performativity. Using this Queer Marxist framework, this thesis will identify an existing tension, due to emerging contradictions within the North American capitalist structure, between the current realities of gendered bodies and the dominant gender binary ideology of North American society. In reflecting on this tension, this project will argue that non-normative genders (and sexualities) are gaining more recognition and validation at a cultural level which, in turn, serves to only further contradict the hegemonic presence of the gender binary ideology that is upheld by the dominant socio-political and economic structures of North America society.
    [Show full text]
  • Queer & Trans Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders (Aapis)
    Queer & Trans Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders (AAPIs) History & Futures Presented by Julia Elting Introduction •Julia Elting •They/them/theirs pronouns •Queer Vision Access Program Coordinator at Asian Counseling and Referral Service Learning Goals •Introduction to LGBTQ history and policies in the US •Introduction to AAPI history in the US •Introduction to some LGBTQ identities within AAPI cultures •Familiarity with AAPI LGBTQ activists and historical figures Content Warning •As the history of the US contains violence against many minority groups, there may be disturbing things that are brought up in parts of this presentation. Please take care of yourself and take breaks as needed. LGBTQIA+ Timeline 2015 – Marriage equality Before 1950 – Anti Gay in all 50 states Legislations in America 1969 – Stonewall Riots 1973 – Homosexuality no longer a mental illness 1970 – First Gay Pride 2016 – 49 killed and 53 Marches wounded at Pulse nightclub; largest mass shooting in LGBTQ 1980’s – Start of history HIV/AIDS epidemic heavily impacting LGBTQ communities Stonewall Inn – June 29, 1969 – New York • Stonewall – gay bar owned by the mafia, where LGBT people can socialize and gather in secret • Police raid of Stonewall • Pointed guns at patrons, arrested people, and hurt people in the bar; patrons fought back against police • There were violent demonstrations and rebellion that went on for 6 days after the police raid • Stonewall was crucial to the Gay Liberation movement during Civil Rights era • Key activist leaders: Storme DeLarverie, Marsha
    [Show full text]
  • International Association of Pride Organizers 2010 Annual Report
    International Association of Pride Organizers 2010 Annual Report Contents InterPride Inc. – International Association of Introduction 3 Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Intersex Pride Organizers Corporate Governance 4 Founded in 1982, InterPride is the world’s largest organization for organizers of Pride events. InterPride is incorporated in the Executive Committee 4 State of Texas in the USA and is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organiza- Regional Directors 4 tion under US law. It is funded by membership dues, sponsor- ship, merchandise sales and donations from individuals and or- Regions and Member Organizations 6 ganizations. InterPride Regions 6 Our Mission Member Organizations 7 It’s InterPride’s mission to promote Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans- gender and Intersex (LGBTI) Pride on an international level and to InterPride Inc. 2010 Annual Report 11 encourage diverse com munities to hold and attend Pride Events. InterPride increases networking, communication and education Summary 11 among Pride Organizations. InterPride works together with Personal notes from the Co-Presidents 12 other LGBTI and Human Rights organizations. InterPride Publications 13 Goals 14 InterPride’s relationship with its member organizations is one of advice, guidance and assistance when requested. We do not Committee Reports 17 have any control over, or take responsibility for the way our member organizations conduct their events. Member Services 17 Conference Structure and Integrity 17 Scholarship 17 www.interpride.org Strategic Planning 18 Fund Development 19 Methods and Standards 19 WorldPride 19 Human Rights 20 Communications 27 Secretary’s Report 27 Finance 29 Regional Director reports contained within this Annual Report Financial Statements 2009/2010 30 are the words, personal accounts and opinions of the authors involved and do not necessarily reflect the views of InterPride Regional Reports 32 as an organization.
    [Show full text]
  • Celebrating Pride Month: a Resource Guide June 2021 Celebrating Pride Month: a Resource Guide
    Celebrating Pride Month: A Resource Guide June 2021 Celebrating Pride Month: A Resource Guide Table of Contents Author IF YOU WANT TO: Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Office Pride Month Subcommittee Listen and learn 1 [email protected] Understand and connect 2 Watch and enjoy 2 Read and absorb 3 Investigate and explore 3 Support and experience 3 Share and cultivate 4 About Commonfund Commonfund was founded in 1971 as an independent asset management firm with a grant from the Ford Foundation. Together with or through its affiliates, Commonfund today manages customized investment programs for endowments, foundations, and public pension funds. Among the pioneers in applying the endowment model of investing to institutional portfolios, we provide extensive investment flexibility using independent investment sub- advisers for discretionary and non-discretionary outsourcing engagements. Investment programs incorporate active and passive strategies in equities and fixed income, hedge funds, real assets, and private capital. All securities are distributed through Commonfund Securities, Inc., a member of FINRA. For additional information about Commonfund, please visit www.commonfund.org. Celebrating Pride Month: A Resource Guide Celebrating Pride Month: A Resource Guide About Pride Month About This Resource Guide Pride month is the promotion of the self-affirmation, Commonfund, in conjunction with our Pride Month dignity, equality and increased visibility of lesbian, subcommittee has created a resource guide to help gay, bisexual, and transgender people (LGBT+) as a us all celebrate the contributions of Americans in the social group. Pride as opposed to shame and social LGBT+ Community. For the purpose of this guide, we stigma, is the predominate outlook that drives most will reference the acronyms LGBT+ or LGBTQ+ which LGBT+ rights movements.[1] LGBT+ is an inclusive stands for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender or way to represent all of the different identities in the Queer, plus other sexual identities in the greater community.
    [Show full text]
  • The Harsa-Carita of Bana
    THE HABSA-CARITA OF BANA. FEINTED BY J. AND C. F. CLAY, AT THE UNIVERSITY PEESS. ORIENTAL TRANSLATION FUND. NEW SERIES. II. THE HABSA-CABITA OF BANA TRANSLATED BY E. B. COWELL, M.A. PROFESSOR OF SANSKRIT AND FELLOW OF CORPUS CHRISTI COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE, AND F. W. THOMAS, M.A. FELLOW OF TRINITY COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE. PRINTED AND PUBLISHED UNDER THE PATRONAGE OF THE ROYAL ASIATIC SOCIETY AND SOLD AT 22, ALBEMARLE STREET, LONDON 1897 TO THE RIGHT HONOURABLE THE EARL OF NORTHBROOK, G.C.S.I. this work is dedicated in sincere gratitude for the kindly sympathy and generous help which he has given to the New Series of the Oriental Translation Fund. To that generosity is due the publication of this translation of Bana's old historical romance. PREFACE. book of which an English translation is now for THEthe first time presented to those who are interested in Hindu literature and antiquities, appears to have been almost forgotten in India. One writer on rhetoric mentions it by name in his Sahityadarpana as an example of the kind of prose composition called Akhyayika, and a verse passage is quoted from it in the older treatise on rhetoric, the few native scholars had seen it for Kavyaprakaga ; yet many years, although rare copies did linger unknown in some native libraries. Professor FitzEdward Hall first introduced it to the knowledge of European Orientalists in the Introduction to his edition of Subandhu's Vasavadatta, published at Cal- cutta in the Bibliotheca Indica in 1859 ; he discovered three MSS. more or less complete. An edition with an excellent Commentary was published at Jatnmu in Kashmir in 1879 (Samvat 1936), and this was reprinted with some variations in Bombay A.
    [Show full text]