DOCSLIB.ORG

Turnbull Blasts SMH Editor-In-Chief Over Anti-Semitic Cartoon

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Turnbull Blasts SMH Editor-In-Chief Over Anti-Semitic Cartoon Turnbull blasts SMH editor-in-chief over anti-Semitic cartoon THE AUSTRALIAN AUGUST 04, 2014 12:00AM Sharri Markson Media Editor Sydney Darren Davidson Business Media Writer Sydney An illustration from Nazi propaganda newspaper Der Sturmer in 1934. Source: Supplied COMMUNICATIONS Minister Malcolm Turnbull rang The Sydney Morning Herald’s editor-in-chief , Darren Goodsir, to lambast him for running an anti-Semitic cartoon. And Attorney-General George Brandis likened the cartoon to images from Germany in the 1930s. The Australian can reveal that Mr Turnbull phoned Goodsir during the week to tell him the cartoon was in poor taste. The cartoon, which ran in The Sydney Morning Herald on July 26, shows a Jew with a hooked nose casually destroying Gaza while reclining on a chair. The image, created by illustrator Glen Le Lievre, was complete with a Star of David and also ran on The Age’s website and has not been taken down from online. Mr Turnbull told Goodsir the cartoon had a disturbing similarity with a long and deplorable tradition of anti-Semitic caricatures. It is understood that Mr Turnbull said the cartoon had caused great offence to many of his constituents and that it went well beyond the criticism of Israeli policy in the column by Mike Carlton which the cartoon illustrated. The phone call, made in Mr Turnbull’s capacity as federal member for Wentworth in Sydney’s eastern suburbs, which has a large Jewish population, came as the Heraldwas flooded with complaints from readers about the cartoon and coverage on the conflict in the Middle East. Prominent Australians have stopped buying Fairfax Media’s The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age over their bias against Israel in the Middle East conflict. One of Australia’s leading immunologists, highly regarded professor Ron Penny, and his wife, Naomi, said they stopped their subscription last week after a life spent reading The Sydney Morning Herald. “We’ve been married 54 years and we’ve had the Herald on our kitchen table all those years, and before that my parents bought it,” Ms Penny said. “It’s 75 years of receivingThe Sydney Morning Herald daily six days a week. “After reading the Mike Carlton article and seeing that cartoon, we decided that whatever happens we cannot possibly subscribe to a publication that could print anything as totally ignorant and odious as that. “Thank god we can live without that horrible publication.” Professor Penny said as soon as they had cancelled the Herald, they immediately subscribed to The Australian. “We’re very pleased that your source exists, otherwise where would we have the opportunity to be comfortable that we’re reading information that is unbiased and not as disgusting as at Fairfax and the ABC?’’ he said. Former Fairfax board director and businessman Jonathan Pinshaw has also cancelled the Herald subscription he had held for more than 30 years. He wrote to Fairfax as a subscriber explaining that his reason for cancelling was the unrelenting bias against Israel. The Australian understands he quit his subscription because of the tone and bias in Fairfax’s coverage on the Gaza conflict generally, not the cartoon specifically. Melbourne business leader and Pratt Foundation chief executive Sam Lipski had already cancelled his subscription to The Age, eight years ago, but he said yesterday: “It is of course utterly disgusting and the worst kind of anti- Semitic cartoon.” While Mr Turnbull declined to comment, Senator Brandis, who is a strong supporter of free speech, said, in his view, coverage in Fairfax newspapers had been “overtly anti-Semitic”. “I thought the cartoon was deplorable,” he said. “I think that critics of Israel’s foreign policy of course have every right to express their views. But I would have thought that a responsible media organisation would have a very good look at itself when it publishes cartoons (of) the kind we haven’t seen since Germany in the 1930s.” Asked if the cartoon amounted to racial vilification and could encourage or incites others to hate Jewish people, Senator Brandis said: “It certainly constitutes a racial form of stereotyping. “I think The Sydney Morning Herald and Fairfax Media in general ought to be very careful about the almost overtly anti-Semitic tone some of their commentary, including their editorial cartoon, have adopted.” Fairfax and Goodsir declined to respond to numerous questions from The Australian. However, today’s edition of the Herald contains an editorial “unreservedly’’ apologising “for this lapse, and the distress that has been caused’’. Members of the community have lodged separate complaints with the Australian Press Council and under 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act, which Senator Brandis has argued should be repealed. A senior member of the community said an official course of action was still being determined. “The organised community is still getting legal advice and looking closely at its options,” he said. Possibilities include state-based complaints in both NSW and Victoria under section 20C of the Racial Discrimination Act, which relates to the inciting of racial hatred. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The ACMA Has Dismissed Two Complaints from the Australian
    Investigations 3195 and 3224 File no. ACMA2014/273 and ACMA2014/446 Broadcaster Australian Broadcasting Corporation Station ABC1 Type of service ABC television Name of program Media Watch Dates of broadcast 17 February 2014 and 24 February 2014 Relevant code Standards 2.1, 2.2, 3.1 and 5.3, and Section III of the ABC Code of Practice 2011 (revised in 2014) Date finalised 24 September 2014 Decision The Australian Broadcasting Corporation: did not breach standard 2.1 did not breach standard 2.2 did not breach standard 3.1 did not breach standard 5.3 complied with Section III of the ABC Code of Practice 2011 (revised in 2014) ACMA Report into investigations 3195 and 3244 – Media Watch broadcast by ABC1 on 17 and 24 February 2014 The complaints On 31 March 2014, the ACMA commenced an investigation into an episode of the program, Media Watch, broadcast by the ABC on 17 February 2014 (the first broadcast). The ACMA commenced its investigation following receipt of a complaint that the ABC breached standards 2.1, 3.1 and 5.3 of the ABC Code of Practice 2011 (revised in 2014) (the Code) in respect of the statement in the first broadcast (the statement) that: Insiders tell Media Watch that The Australian is losing $40 million to $50 million a year. On 5 June 2014, the ACMA commenced an investigation into an episode of Media Watch broadcast by the ABC on 24 February 2014 (the second broadcast). The ACMA commenced its further investigation following receipt of a complaint that the second broadcast ‘present[ed] facts in a misleading way’ and ‘did not correct errors in an appropriate way’.
    [Show full text]
  • KENNEDY AWARDS Excellence in Australian Journalism
    KENNEDY AWARDS Excellence in Australian Journalism 10th Anniversary Sponsorship Prospectus DIMITY CLANCEY AND LAURA MANGHAM OF A CURRENT AFFAIR WIN THE 2020 MIKE WILLESEE AWARD FOR OUTSTANDING NIGHTLY CURRENT AFFAIRS THE HISTORY OF THE KENNEDY AWARDS NAMED after the trailblazing indigenous journalist Les Kennedy, the Kennedy Awards were initially conceived in 2011 to recognise excellence in New South Wales journalism. Almost immediately the Kennedys were shaped by the nature of the entrants - attracting journalists from the likes of Four Corners, 60 Minutes, The Australian, A Current Affair, 730 Report, SBS and the Financial Review to become a truly independent, national celebration of Australian journalism. The awards were created by journalists for journalists - open to all-comers with no agendas or historical obligation to affiliation. A decade later the Kennedys have become the Australian media's night of nights - celebrated for their inclusiveness, independence, respect for the past and the value of fostering the next generation of the nation's finest journalists. SANDRA SALLY (RIGHT) PRESENTS THE HARRY POTTER AWARD FOR OUTSTANDING TV NEWS REPORTING J U N E 2 0 2 0 . Les Kennedy THE INSPIRATION OF THE KENNEDY AWARDS Les Kennedy was never in the officers' mess of journalism - and nor did he want to be. He loved nothing better than excelling on the road as a leader of other "shoe leather" journalists. Proud of his indigenous heritage, Les' awareness of his past and the pride he took in it were the twin chambers of a big, generous heart. It was his fabled generosity that fuelled a selfless devotion to a long list of protégés.
    [Show full text]
  • Pushback Journalism: Twitter, User Engagement and Journalism Students’ Responses to the Australian Penny O’Donnell and Jonathon Hutchinson
    Pushback journalism: Twitter, user engagement and journalism students’ responses to The Australian Penny O’Donnell and Jonathon Hutchinson Abstract This article examines journalism students’ responses to claims in The Australian, made in October 2014, alleging some of Australia’s top uni- versities were indoctrinating rather than educating future journalists. It reports the findings of a case study of user engagement with the story, including social media network and sentiment analysis of the resulting Twitter conversation. We found evidence of what we term “pushback journalism”, a new type of user engagement by younger people. Jour- nalism students and other interested users converged to “rewrite” the indoctrination story – using wit, irony and humour as well as argu- ment – with the aim of setting the record straight from their perspec- tives. In contrast to Australian social media research on adversarial relationships between professional and amateur journalists, we argue “pushback journalism” provides evidence of contiguous but critical re- lationships between the current generation of professional journalists and upcoming journalists-in-training, based on different if overlapping ideas about, and experiences of, journalism education, media careers and the future of news. Introduction News media interest in young people who aspire to become journalists peaked in October 2014 following controversial claims published in The Australian by Media editor Sharri Markson alleging that some of Australia’s “most prestigious universities” were “indoctrinating students, not educating them” (Markson, 2014a). AJR 37(1) 105 Most of the mainstream media discussion of these allegations did not canvass what students had to say about their media degrees; instead they focused on the increasingly prickly relationship between journalists and academics over the best preparation for journalistic work (Henningham, 2014; McNair, 2014; Davey, 2014).
    [Show full text]
  • Stop Lifting Or We'll
    News warns Mail: stop lifting or we’ll sue THE AUSTRALIAN JUNE 09, 2014 12:00AM Sharri Markson Media Editor Sydney Look familiar? How the Daily Mail treated a story previously featured in the Daily Telegraph. THE Daily Mail Online’s Australian arm could face a lawsuit if it does not stop blatantly lifting content from News Corp Australia newspapers. News Corp Australia’s lawyers sent Mail Online’s owner, Associated Newspapers, its directors and its immediate publisher Martin Clarke a legal letter on Friday, threatening to sue for breach of copyright and intellectual property rights unless it provided a legal undertaking by Thursday this week to cease and desist from copying original content produced by News Corp journalists. The British Daily Mail newspaper’s editor-in-chief, Paul Dacre, was copied into the legal letter, along with Mail Online’s Australian editor, Luke McIlveen, The letter included about 10 specific and representative examples of Mail Online, which launched in Australia in January, appropriating articles from newspapers such as Sydney’s The Daily Telegraph and The Sunday Telegraph, Brisbane’s The Courier-Mail and Adelaide’s The Advertiser . In most cases, Daily Mail Online, which is a partnership between Nine’s digital arm Mi9 and the Daily Mail Trust, provided only a single attribution before large parts of the story, and in some cases the accompanying graphics were reproduced on the website under another journalist’s byline. On June 1, The Daily Telegraph’s sports editor-at-large, Phil Rothfield, exclusively revealed that former Olympic swimming champion Ian Thorpe was out of rehabilitation and would be a commentator at the Commonwealth Games.
    [Show full text]
  • The AFRB and China's Subnational Diplomacy in Australia
    Analysis Paper 17 November 2020 A House Divided: The AFRB and China’s Subnational Diplomacy in Australia Salvatore Babones A House Divided: The AFRB and China's Subnational Diplomacy in Australia Salvatore Babones Analysis Paper 17 Contents Executive summary ...............................................................................................1 Introduction: China, Victoria, and the AFRB ..............................................................2 China's global subnational diplomacy .......................................................................4 Victoria's journey onto the 'Belt and Road' ................................................................6 When educational and scientific cooperation become collaboration ...............................8 Conclusions and policy recommendations ................................................................ 10 Endnotes ............................................................................................................ 13 iv Executive Summary Australia is an open society awash in Chinese foreign influence activities that are in any way covert, influence operations, which at times may cross the coercive or corrupt. That is the line that separates lines to constitute foreign interference in Australia’s legitimate influence from unacceptable interference”.2 domestic politics. Some of the most nefarious of these The Attorney-General’s Department actually praises operations take the form of ‘subnational diplomacy’: foreign influence operations that are “conducted in
    [Show full text]
  • S Pacific Step up Be an Aid Budget Step Back?
    Published on November 9, 2018 Scott Morrison and PNG PM Peter O’Neill in Sydney last week. Dan Himbrechts/AAP Will ScoMo’s Pacific step up be an aid budget step back? By Ashlee Betteridge and Matthew Dornan Scott Morrison has broken his Prime Ministerial silence on aid this week, in an ‘exclusive’ interview with the Daily Telegraph and a significant speech on the Pacific. On Wednesday, Morrison spoke to the Tele’s Sharri Markson about his vision for the aid program, which is decidedly anti-multilateral but pro-sports. “Why do we want to be in a race to spend lots of money badly?” he asked Link: https://devpolicy.org/will-scomos-pacific-step-up-be-an-aid-budget-step-back-20181109/ Page 1 of 5 Date downloaded: September 26, 2021 Published on November 9, 2018 rhetorically in the interview, slighting the NGO sector and seemingly forgetting that the aid budget is now at historic lows as a percentage of Gross National Income. The article confirmed there would be no increases to aid under his government. It’s worth remembering that Morrison’s maiden speech in Parliament in 2008 sung the praises of aid and called for its increase, noting that addressing global poverty was “a moral crisis that eclipses all other.” His tone in the Tele couldn’t have been more different. The story did however suggest that more aid would be allocated to “sports diplomacy”: a pursuit of questionable development utility – at least insofar as poverty alleviation is concerned – and one to which Australia’s profitable sports codes could surely make some sort of financial contribution.
    [Show full text]
  • Australia's Democracy
    AUSTRALIA’S DEMOCRACY A STRATEGIC ROADMAP FOR RENEWAL Dr Mark Triffitt University of Melbourne Introduced by: Glenn Barnes & Verity Firth Co-Chairs, Citizens for Democratic Renewal AN INITIATIVE BY THE CITIZENS FOR DEMOCRATIC RENEWAL PART A A PART A B INTRODUCTION In Australia today, we citizens enjoy a of Social and Political Sciences at the University stable governance structure gifted to us by our farsighted forebears – citizens understanding of the serious systemic challenges of Melbourne – seeks to inform and improve from all walks of life, not just the Australia faces in our governance structures and practices, while bringing together a number of powerful and privileged. They strived possible remedies into a potential roadmap for for near 30 years to piece our Federation democratic renewal. together, based on a liberal democratic ‘representative government’ model, and In bringing these matters to your attention, we to gain popular support for it. public awareness of the issues involved and the It is now time for this generation of imperativeare seeking for to enlistcommunity your involvement wide engagement, in building Australians to put in a similar effort for discussion and consideration of how we can the benefit of today’s citizens and for name on a list of citizens supporting us, we need future generations. taxmake deductible our democracy donations work and better. we need We need public your During the nineteenth century the system commentary to help build broad awareness of of representative democracy evolved to the the need and opportunity for this project. antecedent of the current forms in use. The system All details are at democraticrenewal.org.au aimed to address the perennial challenge for Our end objective is to stimulate the establishment societies characterised by competing ideas and of our whole community, to determine how we ‘common interest’ decisions that the vast majority canof an regenerate Australian and citizens’ strengthen assembly, our thatdemocracy, is reflective caninterests accept.
    [Show full text]
  • AJR 2015 Pushback Journalism
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Sydney eScholarship Pushback journalism: Twitter, user engagement and journalism students’ responses to The Australian Penny O’Donnell and Jonathon Hutchinson Abstract This article examines journalism students’ responses to claims in The Australian, made in October 2014, alleging some of Australia’s top universities were indoctrinating rather than educating future journalists. It reports the findings of a case study of user engagement with the story, including social media network and sentiment analysis of the resulting Twitter conversation. We found evidence of what we term “pushback journalism”, a new type of user engagement by younger people. Journalism students and other interested users converged to “rewrite” the indoctrination story – using wit, irony and humour as well as argument – with the aim of setting the record straight from their perspectives. In contrast to Australian social media research on adversarial relationships between professional and amateur journalists, we argue “pushback journalism” provides evidence of contiguous but critical relationships between the current generation of professional journalists and upcoming journalists-in- training, based on different if overlapping ideas about, and experiences of, journalism education, media careers and the future of news. Introduction News media interest in young people who aspire to become journalists peaked in October 2014 following controversial claims published in The Australian by Media editor Sharri Markson alleging that some of Australia’s “most prestigious universities” were “indoctrinating students, not educating them” (Markson, 2014a). Most of the mainstream media discussion of these allegations did not canvass what students had to say about their media degrees; instead they focused on the increasingly prickly relationship between journalists and academics over the best preparation for journalistic work (Henningham, 2014; McNair, 2014; Davey, 2014).
    [Show full text]
  • Dear ACCC, I Was Unaware at the Time I Prepared This Submission to the Royal Commission Into Natural Disasters That You Were Co
    From: bill jen To: Water Inquiry Subject: A National Water Authority (concept paper) Date: Wednesday, 30 September 2020 1:46:13 PM Attachments: WATER - FINAL.docx Dear ACCC, I was unaware at the time I prepared this submission to the Royal Commission into Natural Disasters that you were conducting an enquiry into water trading on the Murray-Darling Basin. I see you have released an interim report which implies a final report is in progress. I submit my paper to you because I hold strong views (like many others) about the imbroglio concerning the MDB Scheme and how water generally is not treated wisely, equitably or, particularly, with an eye to the future in the face of advancing climate change. I notice it is reported (Weekly Times, 5/08/20) that your organisation has said “... there are scant rules to guard against the emergence of conduct aimed at manipulating market prices and no particular body to monitor the trading activities of market participants.” This is just one element contributing to a complete fracturing of water availability across this continent; trading water is a concept with which I totally disagree. I hope someone there will read my paper, consider the reasons behind the argument and acknowledge my transmission of it to you. Yours sincerely, Bill Robertson. National Water Authority A Concept W.H.G..ROBERTSON MARCH, 2020. 1 ‘All great questions will be dealt with in a broad light with a view to the interests of the whole of the country.’ Sir Henry Parkes Tenterfield, 1889 2 Contents Introduction 5 Drought 5 Floods 6 Primary Water Sources 9 o Water Disharmony 9 Water Rights/Entitlement 11 Foreign Investment 13 o Cubbie Station 13 o Senate Estimates Hearing 14 o Weilong Grape Wine Company 16 o Webster Ltd.
    [Show full text]
  • Israeli Politics Have Been People Infected with Coronavirus As Reconfigured Into Pro-Netanyahu and Anti-Netanyahu Groupings
    AUSTRALIA/ISRAEL REVIEW VOLUME 46 No. 3 MARCH 2021 AUSTRALIA/ISRAEL & JEWISH AFFAIRS COUNCIL AN ELECTION LIKE NO OTHER The unprecedented politics of Israel’s March 23 pandemic-era poll CONSPIRACIES FOR KIDS A GAME OF JAKARTA’S HISTORY OR HIS NUCLEAR CHICKEN JIHADISM PROBLEM STORY? An exclusive exposé of children’s books Iran sets itself on a Islamist extremism Former US Presi- that promote hate and extremism PAGE 21 collision course with following the dent Obama’s the Biden Adminis- release of Abu Bakar misleading Mideast tration ..........PAGE 24 Bashir ..........PAGE 28 claims ........... PAGE 31 NAME OF SECTION WITH COMPLIMENTS AND BEST WISHES FROM GANDEL GROUP CHADSTONE SHOPPING CENTRE 1341 DANDENONG ROAD CHADSTONE VIC 3148 TEL: (03) 8564 1222 FAX: (03) 8564 1333 With Compliments from P O BOX 400 SOUTH MELBOURNE, 3205, AUSTRALIA TELEPHONE: (03) 9695 8700 2 AIR – March 2021 AUSTRALIA/ISRAEL VOLUME 46 No. 3 REVIEW MARCH 2021 EDITOR’S NOTE NAME OF SECTION he March edition of the AIR focusses on analysing Israel’s unusually complex ON THE COVER Telection campaign in the lead up to the fourth national vote in two years on A worker from the Central Election March 23. Commission in Israel wearing a full Amotz Asa El explains why this election is looking very challenging for long- protective suit during a media demon- serving incumbent PM Binyamin Netanyahu, while Times of Israel Editor David stration of special polling stations for Horovitz explores how traditional left/right blocs in Israeli politics have been people infected with coronavirus as reconfigured into pro-Netanyahu and anti-Netanyahu groupings.
    [Show full text]
  • The-Viral-World.Pdf
    © 2020 Observer Research Foundation and Global Policy Journal. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical or photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher. Observer Research Foundation 20 Rouse Avenue, Institutional Area New Delhi, India 110002 [email protected] www.orfonline.org ORF provides non-partisan, independent analyses on matters of security, strategy, economy, development, energy and global governance to diverse decision-makers including governments, business communities, academia and civil society. ORF’s mandate is to conduct in-depth research, provide inclusive platforms, and invest in tomorrow’s thought leaders today. Design and Layout: simijaisondesigns Graphs: Rahil Shaikh Language Editing: Preeti Lourdes John Citation: Maya Mirchandani, Shoba Suri and Laetitia Bruce Warjri, eds., The Viral World (New Delhi: ORF and Global Policy Journal, 2020). Cover Image Source: da kuk/Coronavirus outbreak on a world map/Getty/Royalty Free https://www.gettyimages.in/detail/photo/coronavirus-outbreak-on-a-world-map-royalty-free- image/1213355637?adppopup=true ISBN: 978-93-90159-27-7 THE VIRAL WORLD Edited by Maya Mirchandani Shoba Suri Laetitia Bruce Warjri Contents Editors’ Note ........................................................................................................................................................ 6 Pandemics Strike,Communities Respond ............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • How China's Long Reach of Repression
    HUMAN “They Don’t Understand RIGHTS the Fear We Have” WATCH How China’s Long Reach of Repression Undermines Academic Freedom at Australia’s Universities “They Don’t Understand the Fear We Have” How China’s Long Reach of Repression Undermines Academic Freedom at Australia’s Universities Copyright © 2021 Human Rights Watch All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America ISBN: 978-1-62313-916-2 Cover design by Rafael Jimenez Human Rights Watch defends the rights of people worldwide. We scrupulously investigate abuses, expose the facts widely, and pressure those with power to respect rights and secure justice. Human Rights Watch is an independent, international organization that works as part of a vibrant movement to uphold human dignity and advance the cause of human rights for all. Human Rights Watch is an international organization with staff in more than 40 countries, and offices in Amsterdam, Beirut, Berlin, Brussels, Chicago, Geneva, Goma, Johannesburg, London, Los Angeles, Moscow, Nairobi, New York, Paris, San Francisco, Sydney, Tokyo, Toronto, Tunis, Washington DC, and Zurich. For more information, please visit our website: http://www.hrw.org JUNE 2021 ISBN: 978-1-62313-916-2 “They Don’t Understand the Fear We Have” How China’s Long Reach of Repression Undermines Academic Freedom at Australia’s Universities Glossary .............................................................................................................................. i Summary ..........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]