The Burnt Corral Vegetation Management Plan Collaborative Proposed Action
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Burnt Corral Vegetation Management Plan Collaborative Proposed Action A report to the North Kaibab Ranger District Kaibab National Forest from the Landscape Conservation Initiative Northern Arizona University The Landscape Conservation Initiative at Northern Arizona University forges new solutions to environmental challenges through a three-pronged approach: applied science, collaborative planning, and field-based educational experiences. More information is available online at www.nau.edu/LCI Suggested citation for this report: Sisk, T.D., S.D. Stortz, J.M. Rundall. 2014. The Burnt Corral Vegetation Management Plan: A Collaborative Proposed Action. Landscape Conservation Initiative, Northern Arizona University. Flagstaff, AZ USA. Acknowledgements We are grateful for the contributions of all participants in this collaborative, including the many stakeholder participants and personnel of the North Kaibab Ranger District and Kaibab National Forest. Your time and knowledge were key to making progress on these complex issues. The Lab of Landscape Ecology and Conservation Biology, Kaibab National Forest and Grand Canyon Trust provided spatial data for this project. Dr. Steve Sesnie and former forest planner Bruce Higgins provided important advice on old growth in the project area and references across the plateau. Thanks to the Kaibab National Forest and North Kaibab Ranger District for the opportunity to pursue this collaborative landscape assessment for the Kaibab Plateau; particularly Randall Walker, Dave Vincelette and Ariel Leonard for their leadership, coordination and contributions. This project was funded by the North Kaibab Ranger District, Kaibab National Forest, U.S. Forest Service Region 3, with matching funds from the Landscape Conservation Initiative, Northern Arizona University. i Project Staff Jill M. Rundall Northern Arizona University Thomas D. Sisk, Ph.D. Northern Arizona University Sasha D. Stortz Northern Arizona University Participants Name Organization Sept. 18 Oct. 22-23 Nov. 19 Alicyn Gitlin Sierra Club x x x Ariel Leonard Kaibab National Forest x x x Bill Austin US Fish and Wildlife Service x x Brit Betensen North Kaibab Ranger District x x Byard Kershaw Kane County x x Cassie Hagemann North Kaibab Ranger District x x x Connie Reid North Kaibab Ranger District x x Dave Robinson North Kaibab Ranger District x Dave Vincelette North Kaibab Ranger District x x x David Hercher North Kaibab Ranger District x x Don Martin Mohave Sportsman Club x x Ed Grumbine Grand Canyon Trust x x x Ethan Aumack Grand Canyon Trust x x x Garry Domis North Kaibab Ranger District x x x Geoffory Anderson North Kaibab Ranger District x Jim Koons Private citizen x x x Jim Matson Kane County x x x John Schoppman Forever Resorts x Joseph Varnado North Kaibab Ranger District x x x Katherine Davis Center for Biological Diversity x Katie Sauerbrey North Kaibab Ranger District x Kevin Frandsen K&D Forest Products x Larry Whelan Friends of the Kaibab Squirrel x Luke Thompson Arizona Game and Fish Department x Melissa Robinson North Kaibab Ranger District x Paul Callaway North Kaibab Ranger District x x Randall Walker North Kaibab Ranger District x x x Samantha Flores North Kaibab Ranger District x x Steve Rich Private citizen x Tanner Whetstone North Kaibab Ranger District x Terry Herndon Mule Deer Foundation x Todd Buck Arizona Game and Fish Department x x x Todd Schulke Center for Biological Diversity x i Table of Contents Executive Summary ....................................................................................................................................... 1 Background ................................................................................................................................................... 2 Study Area ..................................................................................................................................................... 3 Approach and Methods ................................................................................................................................ 5 Results ........................................................................................................................................................... 8 Discussion.................................................................................................................................................... 16 References .................................................................................................................................................. 18 Appendices .................................................................................................................................................. 22 ii Executive Summary In July of 2014, the North Kaibab Ranger District (NKRD) launched a collaborative planning process to develop a proposed action for vegetation management in the Burnt Corral project area. The project, focusing on the western Ponderosa Pine belt of the district, is within the area prioritized by the Kaibab Forest Health Focus (KFHF), a collaborative, science- based group that worked from 2008-2009 to guide landscape-level forest restoration efforts across the Kaibab National Forest (KNF). The priorities from the KFHF were subsequently integrated into the Kaibab Forest Plan, and the NKRD drew on the stakeholder-identified priority areas to select the Burnt Corral project boundaries. A collaborative group, consisting of about 32 stakeholders, some involved in the KFHF and some new participants, was convened to carry forward the spirit of the KFHF toward on-the-ground management actions. Specifically, the collaborative process, supported by science and spatial analysis, was an effort to develop a single proposed action, supported by stakeholders and interest groups holding diverse values, for the NRKD to bring forward into scoping under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA). The NKRD contacted the Landscape Conservation Initiative at Northern Arizona University (NAU), including the Lab of Landscape Ecology and Conservation Biology, to facilitate the meetings and support spatial analysis to aid consensus building, and the district committed to take the guidance of the collaborative forward into NEPA planning and implementation. The effort produced a draft proposed action based on a field visit and stakeholder deliberations over the course of several months. Consensus was reached on many pieces of guidance, and the proposed action reflects the will of the group. Where consensus was not reached, the LCI attempted to chart a path forward, or to document the range of opinions and options that emerged. This report presents the approach, outcomes and future recommendations from the Burnt Corral collaborative, and is accompanied by the collaborative proposed action submitted to the NKRD as they move forward with project planning and NEPA analysis. 1 Background The Burnt Corral collaborative vegetation management planning process was convened to develop a proposed action for vegetation treatment in an area of approximately 28,060 acres on the North Kaibab Ranger District (NKRD) of the Kaibab National Forest (KNF), using a collaborative approach supported by spatial analysis and group deliberation. The project represents a significant milestone in several years of work on landscape level prioritization and planning for forest restoration on the Kaibab Plateau. In 2009 the Kaibab Forest Health Focus, a science-based collaborative process to identify priority treatment areas across the Kaibab National Forest, was completed. The effort identified both priority areas and initial treatment guidance across the KNF, by district (Figure 1). The results of the prioritization were integrated into the new Kaibab Forest Plan as priority landscapes for management attention. The Burnt Corral project area is a venture into vegetation management in the area identified as highest priority for management action by stakeholders in the KFHF. It offered the opportunity for stakeholders, both those involved in the KFHF and others interested in forest management on the North Kaibab, to contribute to on-the-ground efforts across this project area, effectively filling in the details of the treatment sketch provided in previous broad-scale assessment work, as the scale of planning and analysis moves toward project-level implementation. This is also the first landscape-scale project on the NKRD that falls under the 2014 Land and Resource Management Plan for the Kaibab National Forest. Figure 1. Priority landscapes (left) and treatment guidance (right) on the North Kaibab Ranger District, as developed by the Kaibab Forest Health Focus The NKRD identified several objectives for the Burnt Corral project. Vegetation management objectives were to improve forest health and vigor, while improving habitat conditions which are more resilient to change in the event of wildfire and/or other climatic condition changes. The goal of 2 convening a collaborative process was to reach consensus, where possible, on a proposed action or guidance to use in a proposed action. The NKRD hoped that thorough and inclusive work “up front” to address stakeholder values and concerns, a civil and science-based process would lead to an efficient NEPA process and support for a practical, implementable proposed action to serve as the foundation for future project-level efforts. Study Area The Burnt Corral project area is about 28,060 acres in size, and lies on the southwest portion of the Kaibab