Russia's East Asia Policy: New Opportunities and Challenges*

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Russia's East Asia Policy: New Opportunities and Challenges* Russia’s East Asia Policy: New Opportunities and Challenges* Anna KIREEVA** Abstract Since the demise of the Soviet Union, Russia’s corresponds with Russia’s course on intensifying foreign policy has evolved from a Western- cooperation with East Asian countries in order oriented one to a multi-dimensional one, with to facilitate the development of Siberia and the substantial focus on East Asia. Russia’s East Russian Far East. Asian policy is stimulated by its bid for great power status in the region. Russian-Chinese relations have been the axis of Russia’s East Asian Key Words foreign policy, though the relations have not been without their challenges. Overdependence on China threatens Russia’s independent policy Russia, East Asia, Foreign Policy, Security. in the region and encourages Russia to search for ways to diversify its ties. The rise of China and the US counter-offensive have resulted in a Introduction changing strategic environment in East Asia. A need for balancing between the US and China Asia has every reason to view Russia has brought about ASEAN countries’ desire to as a crucial element of military welcome Russia as a “balancer” in the region. It and political stability as well as of sustainable development.… We may effectively contribute to solving the * The article is prepared with the support of region’s energy, transport, scientific, Russian Foundation for Humanities (grant technological and environmental project № 12-03-00538а). I would like to problems, and our partners are well express my gratitude to Professor Alexei D. Voskiressenski and Associate Professor aware of that. Regional military and Ekaterina V. Koldunova for their comments on political stability, collective efforts a draft of this article, and to Associate Professor to counter international terrorism, Natalia V. Rodoman for giving me a tool of emergency response cooperation, or English political vocabulary to write it. dialogue between civilizations are unimaginable without Russia.… We ** Anna Kireeva is a PhD candidate at MGIMO- accord priority to the development of University, the MFA of Russia. She is a Coordinator of the MA degree programme economic cooperation focusing on the in World Regional Studies and International areas where we have distinct advantages. Relations, “Politics and Economics of World I am primarily referring to the energy Regions”, and a Lecturer in Asian and African sector, including atomic energy, 1 Studies at MGIMO-University, the MFA of transport and space exploration. Russia. Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov 49 PERCEPTIONS, Winter 2012, Volume XVII, Number 4, pp. 49-78. Anna Kireeva influenced by both the West and the A need for balancing between East, in domestic discourse there has the US and China brings about never been clarity about what kind ASEAN’s desire to welcome of a country Russia actually is. One Russia as a “balancer” in the school of thought believes that Russia region. is a European power, and President Medvedev described Russia as one of As incumbent Russia’s Foreign the three main pillars of the European Minister Sergey Lavrov noted, Russia civilisation, alongside the European is not a newcomer in East Asia. Russia Union and the United States. As two has enjoyed contacts with the countries thirds of its territory lies in Asia and one there since the 17th century, and played third in Europe, Russia throughout its an important role in international history has been under the influence of relations in the region in the 19th and both Eastern and Western civilisations. 20th centuries. Although it might be a The Russian political system has differed disputed point, one cannot deny the role considerably from those in Europe, while of the Soviet Union in the victory of the Russian culture has been notably distinct national liberation movements in Asia.2 from Asian ones. Hence, according to Not to be overlooked is the fact that another long-standing tradition, Russia though a vast Russian empire was made is often regarded as both a Western and up of numerous peripheral territories Eastern country, a Eurasian one, whereas situated in Asia, including Siberia, the outside it is mostly perceived as neither Far East and Central Asia, they cannot a Western country nor an Eastern one. be regarded as classical colonies for There is a school of thought that holds a number of reasons. Firstly, Russia’s that Russia is an Asian power, although expansion was supported, or at least not this point of view is mostly rejected by opposed, by the local elites. Secondly, the majority of the Russians. The 2000s witnessed an attempt to overcome this Russia’s periphery, which was integrated dilemma of Russia’s ambivalence. A into the empire, was not plundered, newly emerging concept of Russian as in classical colonial model, but on geopolitical positioning being discussed the contrary subsidised. Thirdly, the at the moment argues that Russia is peripheral elites were not discriminated a Euro-Pacific power, which means it against, but incorporated into the has both European and Asia-Pacific national elite.3 dimensions in geographical terms, but in Since Russia has never been a classical terms of its political characteristics is a colonial power and has been significantly European power.4 50 Russia’s East Asia Policy The existence of so many contradictory a desirable model of development for perceptions makes Russian foreign policy Russia.5 very complicated. Moreover, the Soviet However, before exploring the nature legacy has imposed certain limitations of Russia’s East Asia policy, it is necessary upon it. The Soviet bloc, which also to establish some conceptual clarity in included many Asian and African the use of the key concept, namely that countries, served as a self-contained of a “great power”. The meaning of this military, political and economic system. concept in Russia’s foreign policymaking After the collapse of the Soviet Union the cannot be underestimated, because main foreign policy goal of the Russian aspiring to a great power status has elite was to gain recognition and support been a unifying theme for the Russian from the developed Western world. The ruling elite from Yeltsin to Putin and to logic of this strategic course was quite Medvedev.6 There have been a number justified: with the collapse of the bipolar of studies concerning great powers in system the basic aim of those which “had history, but for the aims of this article lost” was to join the “winners” in order only the term itself and its criteria are to become a part of the international of actual importance, and it is worth political and economic system. However, dwelling on the approaches to define practical implementation of this Western- a great power. Paul Kennedy defines oriented policy in the mid-1990s clearly a great power as a state which is able demonstrated its imbalances and to stand up to any other state in war.7 contributed to re-launching the Eastern Robert Gilpin characterises great powers dimension of Russia’s foreign policy. as countries that are able to establish and Although such regions as the Middle enforce the basic rules that influence East, North and South Africa and others their behaviour and that of inferior states are of great importance to Russian in the system hierarchy.8 Kenneth Waltz foreign policy, its primary focus has been lays down five criteria for being a great on East Asia. Dwelling on the reasons power: population and territory, resource for such a decision, it could be argued endowment, economic capability, that a number of East Asian countries, political stability and competence, and including Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, military strength.9 Singapore and others, which are now perceived as sources of economic growth, Barry Buzan and Ole Weaver offer have quite successfully managed to a more coherent definition for and integrate Eastern and Western political criteria of a great power, which can be and economic models and represent explained by the fact that their regional 51 Anna Kireeva security complex theory (RSCT)10 has Yeltsin to Putin and to Medvedev, with constructivist roots and is quite operable special reference to competing visions on both in the realist and liberal perspectives. Russia’s strategic goals within the political According to them, classifying any actor elite. The second part concentrates on as a great power requires a combination the achievements and blemishes of the of material capability (as understood by Russian-Chinese strategic partnership as Waltz), formal recognition of that status well as Russian relations with other East by others, and a response by the other Asian states and Russia’s accession to great powers on the basis of system- regional multilateral organisations. The level calculations about the present and third part is devoted to the analysis of the future distribution of power in world Russia’s new bid for great power status in politics. The last criterion is behavioural the East Asia region-the impediments to, in nature and means that great powers and prospects of-its implementation. are taken into consideration not only when dealing with the countries of the An Evolution of Russia’s East region they belong to, but also when Asian Policy from Yeltsin to operating in different regions and on the global political system level.11 This Putin and Medvedev understanding of a great power concept After the demise of the Soviet Union will serve as the methodological basis of and the emergence of a democratic but the article. considerably weaker Russian Federation a new foreign policy course was During the early 1990s the proclaimed by the political elite. In the primary direction of Russian early 1990s this course was put forward foreign policy was the Western by the Russian President Boris Yeltsin’s one, and the Eastern was (1991-1999) first team, which had little subordinate to the former.
Recommended publications
  • Abstract Book.Pdf
    Executive Committee Motoyuki Suzuki, International EMECS Center, Japan Toshizo Ido, International EMECS Center, Governor of Hyogo Prefecture, Japan Leonid Zhindarev, Working Group “Sea Coasts” RAS, Russia Valery Mikheev, Russian State Hydrometeorological University, Russia Masataka Watanabe, International EMECS Center, Japan Robert Nigmatullin, P.P. Shirshov Institute of Oceanology RAS, Russia Oleg Petrov, A.P. Karpinsky Russian Geological Research Institute, Russia Scientific Programme Committee Ruben Kosyan, Southern Branch of the P.P. Shirshov Institute of Oceanology RAS, Russia – Chair Masataka Watanabe, Chuo University, International EMECS Center, Japan – Co-Chair Petr Brovko, Far Eastern Federal University, Russia Zhongyuan Chen, East China Normal University, China Jean-Paul Ducrotoy, Institute of Estuarine and Coastal Studies, University of Hull, France George Gogoberidze, Russian State Hydrometeorological University, Russia Sergey Dobrolyubov, Academic Council of the Russian Geographical Society, M.V. Lomonosov Moscow State University, Russia Evgeny Ignatov, M.V. Lomonosov Moscow State University, Russia Nikolay Kasimov, Russian Geographical Society, Technological platform “Technologies for Sustainable Ecological Development” Igor Leontyev, P.P. Shirshov Institute of Oceanology RAS, Russia Svetlana Lukyanova, M.V. Lomonosov Moscow State University, Russia Menasveta Piamsak, Royal Institute, Thailand Erdal Ozhan, MEDCOAST Foundation, Turkey Daria Ryabchuk, A.P. Karpinsky Russian Geological Research Institute, Russia Mikhail Spiridonov,
    [Show full text]
  • Coleoptera Carabidae
    Biodiversity Journal , 2012, 3 (4): 479-486 Preliminary notice on the genus Carabus Linnaeus, 1758 (Co - leoptera Carabidae) of the islands of Peter the Great Gulf in the far East of Russia, Primorski province, Vladivostok area with description of a new subspecies Ivan Rapuzzi Via Cialla, 47 - 33040 Prepotto, Udine, Italy; e-mail: [email protected] ABSTRACT In the present paper the Fauna of Carabus Linnaeus, 1758 of some islands of the Peter the Great Gulf in the Far East of Russia (Vladivostok area) is investigated. After the study of large series of Carabus specimens from the islands and the mainland a new subspecies, Carabus (Morphocarabus) hummeli putyatini n. ssp., is described and figured; moreover, comparative notes with the closest taxa are provided. KEY WORDS Carabus ; new subspecies; Peter the Great Gulf; Vladivostok; Russia. Received 12.05.2012; accepted 24.06.2012; printed 30.12.2012 Proceedings of the 1 st International Congress “Insularity and Biodiversity”, May 11 th -13 th , 2012 - Palermo (Italy) INTRODUCTION The first notice for the genus Carabus for the Is - lands of Peter the Great Gulf was the paper dated The Peter the Great Gulf is the largest gulf of the 1932 by Semenov and Znojko with the description Sea of Japan adjoining the cost of Primorski Krai of C. (Aulonocarabus) praedo Semenov & Znojko, (Fig. 1). The Muravyov-Amursky Peninsula and a 1932 now considered a mere synonym of C. (Aulo - chain of outlying islands divide the gulf of about nocarabus) careniger careniger Chaudoir, 1863 by 6,000 km 2 into the Amur Bay and the Ussuri Bay.
    [Show full text]
  • Russian Federation As Central Planner: Case Study of Investments Into the Russian Far East in Anticipation of the 2012 Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Conference
    Russian Federation as Central Planner: Case Study of Investments into the Russian Far East in Anticipation of the 2012 Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Conference Anne Thorsteinson A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in International Studies: Russia, East Europe and Central Asia University of Washington 2012 Committee: Judith Thornton, Chair Craig ZumBrunnen Program Authorized to Offer Degree: Jackson School of International Studies TABLE OF CONTENTS Page List of Figures ii List of Tables iii Introduction 1 Chapter 1: An Economic History of the Russian Far East 6 Chapter 2: Primorsky Krai Today 24 Chapter 3: The Current Federal Reform Program 30 Chapter 4: Economic Indicators in Primorsky Krai 43 Chapter 5: Conclusion 54 Bibliography 64 LIST OF FIGURES Page 1. Primorsky Krai: Sown Area of Crops 21 2. Far East Federal Region: Sown Area of Crops 21 3. Primorye Agricultural Output 21 4. Russian Federal Fisheries Production 22 5. Vladivostok: Share of Total Exports by Type, 2010 24 6. Vladivostok: Share of Total Imports by Type, 2010 24 7. Cost of a Fixed Basket of Consumer Goods and Services as a Percentage of the All Russian Average 43 8. Cost of a Fixed Basked of Consumer Goods and Services 44 9. Per Capita Monthly Income 45 10. Per Capita Income in Primorsky Krai as a Percentage of the All Russian Average 45 11. Foreign Direct Investment in Primorsky Krai 46 12. Unemployed Proportion of Economically Active Population in Primorsky Krai 48 13. Students in State Institutions of Post-secondary Education in Primorsky Krai 51 14.
    [Show full text]
  • The European Fortifications on the Coast of the Pacific Ocean
    Scientific Journal of Latvia University of Agriculture Landscape Architecture and Art, Volume 10, Number 10 The European fortifications on the coast of the Pacific Ocean Nikolay Kasyanov, Research Institute of Theory and History of Architecture and Urban Planning of the Russian Academy of Architecture and Construction Sciences, Moscow, Russia Abstract. In the Russian Empire during XIX and early XX centuries, fortresses were built and strengthened along the frontiers. We studied the architecture of the Far Eastern Russian cities-fortresses using as examples Nikolaevsk-on-Amur, Port Arthur (now Luishun) and mainly Vladivostok. Coastal fortresses significantly influenced the urban development of the Far Eastern cities. The architectural peculiarity of the fortress architecture at that period was associated with the transition from the brick and stone fortifications to the complex systems of monolithic reinforced concrete. In 1860, a military post with the expressive and geopolitically ambitious name "Vladivostok" ("Possess the East") was established. By the beginning of the XX century, Vladivostok became a rapidly growing city of the European culture and one of the most powerful marine fortresses in the world. The Vladivostok Fortress was an innovative project in early XX century and has distinctive features of the modern style (Art Nouveau), partly of the Russian and classical style in architecture, as well as an organic unity with the surrounding landscape. Plastic architectural masses with their non-linear shape are typical of the fortifications of Vladivostok. Vast and branching internal communication spaces link fort buildings, scattered on the surface and remote from each other. Huge, monumental forts located on the tops of mountains and fitted perfectly in the landscape are successful examples of landscape architecture.
    [Show full text]
  • Russia 2020 Human Rights Report
    RUSSIA 2020 HUMAN RIGHTS REPORT EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Russian Federation has a highly centralized, authoritarian political system dominated by President Vladimir Putin. The bicameral Federal Assembly consists of a directly elected lower house (State Duma) and an appointed upper house (Federation Council), both of which lack independence from the executive. The 2016 State Duma elections and the 2018 presidential election were marked by accusations of government interference and manipulation of the electoral process, including the exclusion of meaningful opposition candidates. On July 1, a national vote held on constitutional amendments did not meet internationally recognized electoral standards. The Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Federal Security Service, the Investigative Committee, the Office of the Prosecutor General, and the National Guard are responsible for law enforcement. The Federal Security Service is responsible for state security, counterintelligence, and counterterrorism, as well as for fighting organized crime and corruption. The national police force, under the Ministry of Internal Affairs, is responsible for combating all crime. The National Guard assists the Federal Security Service’s Border Guard Service in securing borders, administers gun control, combats terrorism and organized crime, protects public order, and guards important state facilities. The National Guard also participates in armed defense of the country’s territory in coordination with Ministry of Defense forces. Except in rare cases, security forces generally report to civilian authorities. National-level civilian authorities have, at best, limited control over security forces in the Republic of Chechnya, which are accountable only to the head of Chechnya, Ramzan Kadyrov. Members of the Russian security forces committed numerous human rights abuses.
    [Show full text]
  • Russky Island Case Study
    Russky Island • Case Study Extreme desalination Waterco filters key component for new desalination plant in Eastern Russia Russky Island off the coast of Vladivostok in Russia is well known for its extreme climate – in fact the seas around the island are frozen for six months over winter. So when the Russian Central Government made the decision to construct a desalination plant there, it needed to be purpose designed for the extreme weather conditions. Located in the northern Sea of Japan in Eastern Russia, Russky Island was for many years a closed area, home to numerous military units, but there were never any industrial, construction or other facilities on the island. That is until 2007, when Russky Island was chosen as the site for the 2012 Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Leaders’ Week (APEC) – and large-scale construction was launched. An integral part of this major development was the construction of a new 10,000 m3/d seawater reverse-osmosis (SWRO) desalination plant to support the drinking and process needs of local residents and the new Far Eastern Federal University, a unique dual-purpose facility: an international-grade university campus and the site of the APEC 2012 Leaders Summit. Global water solutions provider Aqua-Chem Inc was contracted to provide the turnkey design/build desalination project, which purifies 10,000 m3/d seawater reverse-osmosis (SWRO) over 2.6 million gallons of seawater per day. desalination plant to support the drinking and process needs of local residents and the new Far Eastern Federal University. The Russian Central Government recognised our expertise in “ extreme-weather SWRO facilities based upon our long history of making potable water for the Canadian government’s Arctic research teams and the Antarctic research facilities at McMurdo, Palmer and South Pole stations, ” says Aqua-Chem president and CEO David Gensterblum.
    [Show full text]
  • Fefu: a Territory of Events
    FEFU: A TERRITORY OF EVENTS FEFU: A TERRITORY OF EVENTS Dear Friends, I am excited to welcome you at the Far Eastern Federal University, the largest university of the Russian Far East. As we preserve the longstanding traditions of scholarship and as we track the most novel trends in education, we plan to join the ranks of the best centers of education and research in the Asia Pacific. Besides teaching students, Far Eastern Federal University also aims to become a major international center of MICE industry, a forum for discussions and expertise of an international level. We have all preconditions for that, as the campus of the Far Eastern Federal University is not only considered to be the best one in Russia, but also one of the finest campuses of the world. It is located on the Pacific coast in the pristine area of the Russky Island not so far away from the mainland Vladivostok. Our University has extensive capacities for holding events of even the highest level. We have already held over two hundred meetings, symposia, congresses, sports competitions and summits of both the Russian and the international levels. Among our major accomplishments are the 21st session of The Asia Pacific Parliamentary Forum, the annual meeting of the university rectors of The Association of Pacific Rim Universities, the First Far Eastern Media Summit, Russian National Student Spring Festival, Russia’s Championship on Powerlifting, and many others. Dear partners, exhibitions participants, event organizers, leaders of business and government, we are always happy to see you at our hospitable campus! At your disposal are the best technologies and equipment along with the hotel accommodation with all of the facilities that you might need.
    [Show full text]
  • Siberia & the Russian Far East
    SIBERIA & THE RUSSIAN FAR EAST JULY 14-31, 2021 TOUR LEADER: DR MATTHEW DAL SANTO SIBERIA & Overview THE RUSSIAN FAR EAST Embark on the tour of a lifetime to one of the world's last great travel Tour dates: July 14-31, 2021 frontiers. This 18-day tour reveals the cultural and geographical wonders of Siberia and the Russian Far East. Tour leader: Dr Matthew Dal Santo We begin in Irkutsk, a former Cossack settlement forever linked to the Tour Price: $18,975 per person, twin share memory of the immortal ‘Decembrists’ – public-minded nobles who, exiled to Siberia for their part in an 1825 rebellion against the Tsar, recreated Single Supplement: $1,900 for sole use of with their wives the cultural and artistic life of St Petersburg for the benefit double room of Siberia’s rough frontiersmen. From Irkutsk we then travel to beautiful Lake Baikal, the world’s largest, oldest and deepest lake to spend two Booking deposit: $1,000 per person nights on Olkhon Island, which, widely regarded as the “jewel” of Baikal, is Recommended airline: Korean Airlines sacred to the indigenous Buryat people. Maximum places: 20 Taking the legendary Trans-Siberian Railway along Baikal’s southern shore, we arrive in Ulan Ude, capital of the Buryat Autonomous Republic Itinerary: Irkutsk (3 nights), Olkhon Island, and centre of Russian Buddhism, with centuries of close links with Tibet. Lake Baikal (2 nights), Irkutsk (1 night), The valleys of the surrounding steppe are also a stronghold of the so- Ulan Ude (3 nights), Khabarovsk (2 nights), called ‘Old Believers’, a long-persecuted Orthodox sect who have Petropavlovk-Kamchatsky, Kamchatka (4 nights) preserved in Siberia’s remote wooded valleys a centuries-old culture that Vladivostok (2 nights) includes a rich repertoire of songs of exile.
    [Show full text]
  • Investment Opportunities in the Russian Far East
    1 INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES IN THE RUSSIAN FAR EAST 1 2 INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES IN THE RUSSIAN FAR EAST Chukotka Petrochemical industry AAutonomous Area Mining Power industry Kamchatka Territory Agriculture Republic of Sakha Fishery and aquaculture (Yakutia) Magadan Region Wood harvesting and processing Khabarovsk Territory Machine building Sakhalin Region Real estate and tourism Transport and logistics Amur Region Jewish Autonomous Region Primorsky Territory Healthcare 2 3 INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES IN THE RUSSIAN FAR EAST Petrochemical Chukotka Petrochemical industry AAutonomous industry Area Mining Power industry Kamchatka Territory Agriculture Republic of Sakha Fishery and aquaculture (Yakutia) Magadan Projects underway Region Wood harvesting and NGL field Khabarovsk processing Territory Processing facility Machine building LNG plant Investment Opportunities Real estate and tourism Oil and gas field Sakhalin Region Transport and logistics Amur Processing facility Region Jewish Autonomous Region Primorsky LNG plant Territory Healthcare 3 4 INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES IN THE RUSSIAN FAR EAST Sector Potential Petrochemical industry Attraction Factors State Support Mining Unique business environment ▪ Significant reserves (27% of gas and 17% of oil of the APR), estimated reserves – over USD 1.0 trillion. ▪ The Russian Far East offers unparalleled preferences to businesses – special legal treatment in the Advanced Special Economic Zones ▪ Industry majors are engaged in the sector (Gazprom, SIBUR, Power industry (ASEZ) and Free Port of Vladivostok
    [Show full text]
  • APEC 2012 Russia CEO Summit Coalition Activities As of 9.7.2012
    APEC 2012 Russia CEO Summit Coalition Activities As of 9.7.2012 __ = new additions __ = changes Thursday, September 6 12-12:30pm Awarding of the 2012 ASPIRE Prize & Dialogue on Regional Scientific Collaboration Location: Schooner Bar on Deck 4, Legend of the Seas Cruise Ship docked at the Vladivostok Sea Terminal, 1 Nizhneportovaya Str. Speakers: Dr. Sergey Ivanets, President, Far Eastern Federal University, Russian Federation Dr. Brad Fenwick, Jefferson Science Fellow, U.S. Department of State Mr. Myron Brilliant, Senior Vice President for Intl Affairs, U.S. Chamber of Commerce Honoree: Dr. Rossa Chiu, The Chinese University of Hong Kong NOTE: If traveling from Russky Island to Vladivostok for this event, please leave by 10:45am on one of the shuttles that leaves every 30 minutes in order to make it in time. 1-3pm National Center for APEC Annual Lunch Location: Romeo and Juliet Restaurant on Deck 4, Legend of the Seas Cruise Ship docked at the Vladivostok Sea Terminal, 1 Nizhneportovaya Str. Speakers: The Honorable Gita Irawan Wirjawan, Minister of Trade, The Republic of Indonesia Ambassador Demetrios Marantis, Deputy U.S. Trade Representative Vijay Vaitheeswaran, China’s Business Editor, The Economist and author of Need, Speed and Greed 4-6pm Reception co-hosted by the American Chamber of Commerce in Russia and the US APEC Business Coalition Location: Restaurant on Floor -2, APEC CEO Summit Conference Center (Building 12), Russky Island 5:15-5:45pm Coalition Meeting – Ambassador Michael Punke, Deputy US Trade Representative Location: Room 10 (2/12 on the map), Floor 2, APEC CEO Summit Conference Center (Building 12) 6-6:30pm Coalition Meeting – Ambassador Demetrios Marantis, Deputy US Trade Representative Location: Room 10 (2/12 on the map), APEC CEO Summit Conference Center (Building 12) Friday, September 7 9-10am Coalition Meeting – Minister Bark Taeho, Minister for Trade, Republic of Korea Location: Room 10 (2/12 on the map), APEC CEO Summit Conference Center (Building 12) 10:15-10:45am Coalition Meeting – Robert D.
    [Show full text]
  • Variability and Quasi-Decadal Changes in the Methane Budget Over The
    Atmos. Chem. Phys. Discuss., doi:10.5194/acp-2017-296, 2017 Manuscript under review for journal Atmos. Chem. Phys. Discussion started: 18 April 2017 c Author(s) 2017. CC-BY 3.0 License. Variability and quasi-decadal changes in the methane budget over the period 2000-2012 Marielle Saunois1, Philippe Bousquet1, Ben Poulter2, Anna Peregon1, Philippe Ciais1, Josep G. Canadell3, Edward J. Dlugokencky4, Giuseppe Etiope5,6, David Bastviken7, Sander Houweling8,9, Greet 10 11 12,13,14 15 5 Janssens-Maenhout , Francesco N. Tubiello , Simona Castaldi , Robert B. Jackson , Mihai Alexe10, Vivek K. Arora16, David J. Beerling17, Peter Bergamaschi10, Donald R. Blake18, Gordon Brailsford19, Lori Bruhwiler4, Cyril Crevoisier20, Patrick Crill21, Kristofer Covey22, Christian Frankenberg23,24, Nicola Gedney25, Lena Höglund-Isaksson26, Misa Ishizawa27, Akihiko Ito27, Fortunat Joos28, Heon-Sook Kim27, Thomas Kleinen29, Paul Krummel30, Jean-François Lamarque31, Ray 30 1 27 27 32 10 Langenfelds , Robin Locatelli , Toshinobu Machida , Shamil Maksyutov , Joe R. Melton , Isamu Morino33 Vaishali Naik34, Simon O’Doherty35, Frans-Jan W. Parmentier36, Prabir K. Patra37, Changhui Peng38,39, Shushi Peng1,40, Glen P. Peters41, Isabelle Pison1, Ronald Prinn42, Michel Ramonet1, William J. Riley43, Makoto Saito27, Monia Santini14, Ronny Schroeder44, Isobel J. Simpson18, Renato Spahni28, Atsushi Takizawa45, Brett F. Thornton22, Hanqin Tian46, Yasunori Tohjima27, Nicolas Viovy1, 47 48 17 49 50 15 Apostolos Voulgarakis , Ray Weiss , David J. Wilton , Andy Wiltshire , Doug Worthy
    [Show full text]
  • Variability and Quasi-Decadal Changes in the Methane Budget Over the Period 2000–2012
    Atmos. Chem. Phys., 17, 11135–11161, 2017 https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-17-11135-2017 © Author(s) 2017. This work is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License. Variability and quasi-decadal changes in the methane budget over the period 2000–2012 Marielle Saunois1, Philippe Bousquet1, Ben Poulter2, Anna Peregon1, Philippe Ciais1, Josep G. Canadell3, Edward J. Dlugokencky4, Giuseppe Etiope5,6, David Bastviken7, Sander Houweling8,9, Greet Janssens-Maenhout10, Francesco N. Tubiello11, Simona Castaldi12,13,14, Robert B. Jackson15, Mihai Alexe10, Vivek K. Arora16, David J. Beerling17, Peter Bergamaschi10, Donald R. Blake18, Gordon Brailsford19, Lori Bruhwiler4, Cyril Crevoisier20, Patrick Crill21, Kristofer Covey22, Christian Frankenberg23,24, Nicola Gedney25, Lena Höglund-Isaksson26, Misa Ishizawa27, Akihiko Ito27, Fortunat Joos28, Heon-Sook Kim27, Thomas Kleinen29, Paul Krummel30, Jean-François Lamarque31, Ray Langenfelds30, Robin Locatelli1, Toshinobu Machida27, Shamil Maksyutov27, Joe R. Melton32, Isamu Morino27, Vaishali Naik33, Simon O’Doherty34, Frans-Jan W. Parmentier35, Prabir K. Patra36, Changhui Peng37,38, Shushi Peng1,39, Glen P. Peters40, Isabelle Pison1, Ronald Prinn41, Michel Ramonet1, William J. Riley42, Makoto Saito27, Monia Santini13,14, Ronny Schroeder43, Isobel J. Simpson18, Renato Spahni28, Atsushi Takizawa44, Brett F. Thornton21, Hanqin Tian45, Yasunori Tohjima27, Nicolas Viovy1, Apostolos Voulgarakis46, Ray Weiss47, David J. Wilton17, Andy Wiltshire48, Doug Worthy49, Debra Wunch50, Xiyan Xu42,51, Yukio Yoshida27, Bowen Zhang45, Zhen Zhang2,52, and Qiuan Zhu38 1Laboratoire des Sciences du Climat et de l’Environnement, LSCE-IPSL (CEA-CNRS-UVSQ), Université Paris-Saclay, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France 2NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Biospheric Sciences Laboratory, Greenbelt, MD 20771, USA 3Global Carbon Project, CSIRO Oceans and Atmosphere, Canberra, ACT 2601, Australia 4NOAA ESRL, 325 Broadway, Boulder, CO 80305, USA 5Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia, Sezione Roma 2, via V.
    [Show full text]