CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD MEETING Wednesday, April 14, 2021 – 1:30 P.M

CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD MEETING Wednesday, April 14, 2021 – 1:30 p.m. City Hall, Council Chambers, Vero Beach, Florida - AGENDA

1. CALL TO ORDER

2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIENCE

3. PRELIMINARY MATTERS

A) Adoption of Minutes – March 10, 2021 B) Agenda Additions, Deletions and Adoption

4. UNLICENSED CONTRACTORS/CITATIONS

5. EVIDENTIARY HEARINGS

A) Citation Appeals

1. CASE #21-CE-11496 / 3202M VIOLATOR: Portales De Vero, Inc. / Charles McKinnon, Agent VIOLATION: Eight (8) Palm Trees removed without a permit – Code Sections 72.43; 72.44 VIOLATION ADDRESS: 2855 Ocean Drive, Vero Beach, Florida 32963

2. CASE #21-CE-11503 / 2021000475 / 3209M VIOLATOR: Christopher Dold VIOLATION: Noise violation – Loud music and noise – Code Section 38-61 VIOLATION ADDRESS: 611 East Causeway Boulevard, Vero Beach, Florida 32963

3. CASE #21-CE-11504 / 20211000476 / 3210M VIOLATOR: Christopher Dold VIOLATION: Noise violation – Loud music – Code Section 38-61 VIOLATION ADDRESS: 611 East Causeway Boulevard, Vero Beach, Florida 32963

B) Non-Compliance / Compliance Reports

1. Request for Board Order

a. CASE #19-CE-9526 / 1704T VIOLATOR: Roger A. Jacquelin, Jr. and Maureen K. Jacquelin VIOLATION: Construction without a permit or approvals – Code Sections 22-106 (a); 64.02 (a)(1) VIOLATION ADDRESS: 1715 29th Avenue, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Property found in compliance as of April 25, 2019. The initial civil penalty of $100 has been paid. There are continuing penalties of $100 per day that commenced March 15, 2019 for 41 days x $100 = $4,100 plus costs due to the City)

b. CASE #20-CE-11288 / 3009M VIOLATOR: Paver Overlays, LLC / Atlantic Hardscape Supply, Inc. / Biran C. Herndon, Agent / John L. and Penny C. Eshleman VIOLATION: Failure to obtain Code Compliance Certification / Right-of-Way Agreement for installation of pavers – Code Section 64.05 (9)(a) VIOLATION ADDRESS: 4701 Bethel Creek Drive, Vero Beach, Florida 32963 (Property found in compliance on March 12, 2021. The initial civil penalty of $50 has been paid. There are continuing penalties of $50 per day that commenced on November 20, 2020 for 112 days x $50 = $5,600 plus costs due to the City) c. CASE #20-CE-11287 / 3008M VIOLATOR: Acacia Treasure Coast, LLC / Erol R. Atamer, Agent VIOLATION: Public nuisance; Weeds, grass, or undergrowth at a height of more than 12 inches – Code Section 38-31 (a)(b)(1) VIOLATION ADDRESS: 1110 Royal Palm Boulevard, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Property found in compliance on January 6, 2021. The initial civil penalty of $100 and costs of enforcement of $55.96 have not been paid. There are continuing penalties of $100 per day that commenced on November 20, 2020 for 47 days x $100 = 4,700, plus $155.96, plus costs due to the City)

d. CASE #16-CE-6432 / 0826M VIOLATOR: High Tide Auto Wholesale, Inc. VIOLATION: Repair and sales of vehicles without business tax receipt and site plan approval – Code Sections 70.62 (a)(1)(2)(3); 64.06 (a) VIOLATION ADDRESS: 2626 U.S. Highway 1, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Property found in compliance as of October 17, 2016. The initial civil penalty of $50 has not been paid. There are continuing penalties of $50 per day that commenced on March 22, 2016 for 209 days = $10,450, plus $50, plus costs due to the City) e. CASE #20-CE-11270 / 2995M VIOLATOR: 1616 24th Avenue, LLC / Barbara Hooker, Agent VIOLATON: Fence and brick pavers installed without Code Compliance Certification from the City of Vero Beach Planning and Development Department – Code Sections 64.05 (7); 22-181; 22-106 VIOLATION ADDRESS: 1616 24th Avenue, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Property found in compliance as of March 19, 2021. The initial civil penalty of $50 has not been paid. There are continuing penalties of $50 per day that commenced on November 6, 2020 for 133 days = $6,650, plus $50, plus costs due to the City) f. CASE #20-CE-11301 / 3020M VIOLATOR: Stephen D. Boyles VIOLATION: Front deck constructed without Code Compliance Certification or building permit – Code Sections 64.05 (a)(b)(9)(b); 22-181; 22-106 VIOLATION ADDRESS: 2626 11th Avenue, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Failure to comply) g. CASE #20-CE-11380 / 3096M VIOLATOR: John Desjardins VIOLATION: Shed installed without Code Compliance Certification or building permit – Code Sections 64.05 (a)(b)(9)(b); 22-181; 22-106 VIOLATION ADDRESS: 2675 10th Court, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Failure to comply)

h. CASE #21-CE-11468 / 3174M VIOLATOR: 1901 33rd Avenue, LLC and Sunshine Corporate Filings, LLC VIOLATION: Public nuisance: stagnant swimming pool – Code Section 38-31 (b)(7) VIOLATION ADDRESS: 1901 33rd Avenue, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Failure to comply) i. CASE #21-CE-11441 / 3172M VIOLATIOR: John Martin Monko, Jr. VIOLATION: Failure to obtain a building permit for the enclosed structural wall and the AC mini-split system installed VIOLATION ADDRESS: 442 Conn Way, Vero Beach, Florida 32963 (Failure to comply; Failure to pay $50 civil penalty) j. CASE #21-CE-11490 / 3196M VIOLATOR: Christopher Dean and Jenifer Stepanek VIOLATION: Pine trees removed without a permit – Code Sections 72.41; 72.44 VIOLATION ADDRESS: 2635 Victory Boulevard, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Failure to comply) k. CASE #21-CE-11483 / 3189M VIOLATOR: 827 22nd Street, LLC / Fred Piumelli, Agent VIOLATION: Failure to obtain Code Compliance Certification or building permit – Code Section 64.05 (a)(b)(9)(b)(10)(a) – Repeat violation VIOLATION ADDRESS: 827 22nd Street, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Failure to comply; Failure to pay $100 civil penalty)

l. CASE #21-CE-11491 / 3197M VIOLATOR: Robenson Juste, LLC / Cottrell Tax and Accounting, LLC, Agent VIOLATION: Trees removed without a permit – Code Sections 72.41; 72.44 VIOLATION ADDRESS: 5075 Highway A1A, Vero Beach, Florida 32963 (Failure to comply; Failure to pay $800 civil penalty)

m. CASE #21-CE-11492 / 3198M VIOLATOR: Robenson Juste, LLC / Cottrell Tax and Accounting, LLC / The American Pavers Contractors, Inc. / Elias Mendoza, Agent VIOLATION: Pavers installed without Code Compliance certification from the Vero Beach Planning and Development Department – Code Section 64.05 (11) VIOLATION ADDRESS: 5075 Highway A1A, Vero Beach, Florida 32963 (Failure to comply; Failure to pay $50 civil penalty)

n. CASE #21-CE-11417 / 3131M VIOLATOR: Dan R. Cornell VIOALTION: Sewer use restrictions – Code Section 78-83 (a)(4) VIOLATION ADDRESS: 1802 Ocean Drive, Vero Beach, Florida 32963 (Failure to comply)

o. CASE #21-CE-11506 / 3212M VIOLATOR: Barry Simon VIOLATION: Oak tree removed without a permit – Code Sections 72.41; 42.43; 72.44 VIOLATION ADDRESS: 1655 30th Avenue, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Failure to pay $300 civil penalty)

p. CASE #21-CE-11500 / 3206M VIOLATOR: Ryan C. Scarpa VIOLATION: Driveway installed without Code Compliance Certification from the City of Vero Beach Planning and Development Department or a building permit from the Indian River County Building Department – Code Section 64.06 (a)(22)(d) (Failure to comply)

6. OLD BUSINESS

7. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS

8. CLERK’S MATTERS

A) Code Penalty Information

9. ATTORNEY’S MATTERS

10. CHAIRMAN’S MATTERS

11. MEMBER’S MATTERS 5

12. ADJOURNMENT

This is a Public Meeting. Should any interested party seek to appeal any decision made by the Board with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he will need a record of the proceedings and that, for such purpose he may need to ensure that a record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Anyone who needs a special accommodation for this meeting may contact the City’s Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Coordinator at 978-4920 at least 48 hours in advance of the meeting.

CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD MINUTES Wednesday, March 10, 2021 – 1:30 p.m. City Hall, Council Chambers, Vero Beach, Florida

PRESENT: Chairman, Eric Price; Vice Chairman, Stephen McDonald; Members: Linda Hillman, Christopher Bryant, Frank Pizzichillo and Ken Daige Also Present: Code Enforcement Officer, Melody Sanderson; City Attorney, John Turner and Deputy City Clerk, Sherri Philo

Excused Absence: Richard Kennedy

1. CALL TO ORDER

Today’s meeting was called to order at 1:30 p.m.

2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIENCE

The Chairman led the Board members and the audience in the Pledge of Allegiance to the flag.

The Deputy City Clerk swore in staff and the audience present for today’s meeting en masse.

3. PRELIMINARY MATTERS

A) Adoption of Minutes – February 10, 2021

Mr. Price made a motion to adopt the minutes of the February 10, 2021 Code Enforcement Board meeting. Mr. Pizzichillo seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.

B) Agenda Additions, Deletions and Adoption

Ms. Melody Sanderson, Code Enforcement Officer, pulled Case #21-CE-11421 – Area Rug Gallery, Inc. / Foster’s Accounting Service, LLC, Case #21-CE-11398 – Vero Plaza, LLC / Cutting Edge Salon / Nichole Price and Case #20-CE-11366 – Russell A. Bevard, Jr. from today’s agenda. She reported that they were all in compliance.

Mr. Price made a motion to adopt the agenda as amended. Mr. Daige seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.

4. UNLICENSED CONTRACTORS/CITATIONS

None

5. EVIDENTIARY HEARINGS

A) Citation Appeals

None

1 03/10/21 CEB B) Non-Compliance / Compliance Reports

1. Request for Board Order

a. CASE #21-CE-11421 / 3134M VIOLATOR: Area Rug Gallery, Inc. / Foster’s Accounting Service, LLC, agent VIOLATION: Sign violation - Code Section 38.17 VIOLATION ADDRESS: Right-of-way of 27th Avenue and SR 60, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Failure to pay $50 civil penalty)

This item was pulled from today’s agenda.

b. CASE #21-CE-11398 / 3112M VIOLATOR: Vero Plaza, LLC / Cutting Edge Salon / Nichole Price VIOLATION: Sign violation – Code Section 38.17 (a)(o)(p) VIOLATION ADDRESS: 484 21st Street, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Failure to pay $50 civil penalty)

This item was pulled from today’s agenda.

c. CASE #20-CE-11366 / 3081M VIOLATOR: Russell A. Bevard, Jr. (owner) and Richard Cotton (tenant) VIOLATION: Watercraft violation – Code Section 74-81 (c)(3) VIOLATION ADDRESS: 1903 Robalo Drive, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Failure to pay $50 civil penalty)

This item was pulled from today’s agenda.

d. CASE #21-CE-11428 / 3141M VIOLATOR: James and Bertha Cox, Patricia and Joe Cox VIOLATION: Public nuisance – Code Section 38-31 (a)(b)(5) VIOLATION ADDRESS: 2605 11th Avenue, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Failure to comply)

Ms. Sanderson reported that a citation was issued for public nuisance; garbage, rubbish, trash, debris, dead trees, and other unsightly and unsanitary structures or materials that were not properly enclosed waiting for normal trash pickup. She said this case was initiated based on multiple complaints of the condition of the property. No request for a hearing on the citation was received within the 10-day time frame so a hearing to contest the citation has been waived and the violation is deemed admitted by the violator. She then showed on the screen photographs of the property (on file in the City Clerk’s office). She reported that this case is before the Board to determine if the property is in compliance. 2 03/10/21 CEB Mr. Bryant asked Ms. Sanderson for her recommendation as to if she felt the property was in compliance or not in compliance.

Ms. Sanderson said that she defers to the Board.

Mrs. Patricia A. Cox, who has been sworn in, said the property has been a mess in the past. But, since then her husband and nephew have been working diligently to clean it up. She said they have a memorial for her father-in-law in the front of the property and there are two (2) chairs there.

Mr. Price said that he thinks that is part of the problem.

Mrs. Cox questioned isn’t a memorial allowed.

Mr. Price questioned why are the chairs there.

Mrs. Cox said so they could sit at the memorial.

Mr. Price asked what about everything else that is in the yard.

Mrs. Cox said there is a swing and there are plants that they enjoy. She said they are in the process of cleaning up their back yard so they can store some of these things in the back.

Mr. Price explained that if they are not in compliance the Board is going to charge them a daily fine until they are in compliance.

Mrs. Cox said that she is on disability and her husband is not working.

Mr. Price said they need to clean it up and bring the property into compliance.

Mrs. Cox said they are cleaning it up.

Mr. Price said they have to bring it into compliance with the Code.

Mrs. Cox said these are her things and she is sorry that her neighbors don’t like it.

Mr. Pizzichillo asked Ms. Sanderson when sis she initially inspected the property.

Ms. Sanderson reported that she looked at the property on February 1st and February 2nd and she issued the citation on February 2, 2021, allowing them two (2) weeks to comply.

Mr. Pizzichillo said that is well over a month ago.

Mrs. Cox asked the Board how would they like the yard to be. She asked what would they like them to do, throw their stuff away.

Mr. Price said these items cannot be in the front yard.

Mrs. Cox said they are their things. She is sorry they don’t like them. 3 03/10/21 CEB Mrs. Hillman asked Mrs. Cox, if she had a back yard.

Mrs. Cox said that she does, but she doesn’t want to put her stuff in the back yard. She wants it in her front yard. She said it is her property.

Mrs. Hillman explained that the City Code states that you cannot display items like that.

Mrs. Cox asked what is wrong with …

Mr. Pizzichillo said to answer her question, everything is wrong with it.

Mrs. Cox asked why.

Mr. Pizzichillo said because it is an eyesore and he would not want to be her neighbor looking at that every day. He said it is detrimental to the area.

Mrs. Cox disagreed.

Mr. Daige said that he didn’t think the memorial and the chairs were in question. What is in question is the amount of items that are outside the home and the Code prohibits that. He said this is also a safety hazard. He explained that a storm could blow these things around. He understands that these items belong to her, but the Code does not allow it and the property has to be brought into compliance.

Mrs. Cox said it would be wonderful if Ms. Sanderson could come and tell her exactly what she needs to do and she will do it.

Ms. Sanderson said that she did not think anyone was contesting a few chairs or a memorial, but the excess items that remain outside are the basis of the complaint.

Mrs. Cox said that her husband took stuff to the dump and will be making another dump run with the items that they don’t need.

Ms. Sanderson said improvements have been made and it needs to continue.

Mrs. Hillman said if this was next to her house she would have a huge problem with it.

Mrs. Cox said they are embarrassed and are trying to clean it up. She said they are going to continue cleaning up the property and she wanted the Board to know that they are making progress.

Mr. Pizzichillo said it has been over a month since the Code Officer inspected the property and they could have done something a lot sooner. He said this is deplorable and if he lived next to them he would be making a complaint every day. He said this is detrimental in many ways to the surrounding homes. He felt that they had plenty of time to clean up the property.

Mrs. Cox said that she really does appreciate the Board and she would like to explain if that is okay with them. She said that she had surgery …

4 03/10/21 CEB Mr. Price said that is not necessary. He said the Board is not looking for excuses. He said that he understands that the Code Officer wants the Board to determine whether or not they are in compliance. He asked Ms. Sanderson how would the Board define bringing the property into compliance to Mrs. Cox. He said it might be hard for her to judge what is allowed and what is not allowed.

Ms. Sanderson said it would be nice if she just had the memorial and a couple chairs.

Mr. Bryant asked how much was the fine.

Ms. Sanderson said it was $50, which has been paid.

Mr. Bryant said that she is not in compliance. He said the Board needs to issue an order of some sort to allow 30-days to comply or ….

Ms. Sanderson responded no.

Mr. McDonald said they have already had a month and a half to comply.

Ms. Sanderson requested that the Board finds that there is a violation, that the violation continues, that the Board issues a Board order to correct the violation within seven (7) days of the Board order or continuing civil penalties in the amount of $50 commencing on the original compliance date of February 17, 2021, until corrected.

Mr. Daige said to understand it correctly, the Code Officer is recommending seven (7) days to get this squared away.

Ms. Sanderson clarified that it would be seven (7) days from the date of the Board order, so they would have more than seven (7) days to comply.

Mr. Daige explained to Mrs. Cox that the Code Enforcement Officer is willing to work with her to let her know what is allowed and what is not allowed. He said if it was up to him, he would contact the Code Enforcement Officer in a few days to be sure that she is bringing the property into compliance.

Mr. Bryant suggested that they allow 14-days to come into compliance.

Ms. Sanderson explained that Mrs. Cox would have approximately a week or more in addition to the seven (7) days, depending on when the Board order is prepared and signed.

Mr. John Turner, City Attorney, explained that all the paperwork has to go through his office and has to be signed, which usually takes additional days.

Mrs. Cox said that she has a table and chairs out front, which she uses to sit outside and listens to music.

Ms. Sanderson explained that the table and chairs and the memorial is not the problem. The problem is when the other items stay out front, which is when the complaints come in.

5 03/10/21 CEB Mr. Price moved that the Board finds that there is a violation, that the violation continues, that the Board issues a Board order to correct the violation within seven (7) days from the date of the Board order or continuing civil penalties in the amount of $50 per day shall commence on the original compliance date of February 17, 2020, until corrected and that the initial civil penalty has been paid. Mr. McDonald seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.

Mr. Daige recommended to Mrs. Cox that she call the Code Enforcement Officer in about three (3) days so that she can check the property to make sure that she (Mrs. Cox) is coming into compliance.

e. CASE #20-CE-11171 / 2960M VIOLATOR: Jill Silcox and Shelly Robertson VIOLATION: Weeds, grass, or undergrowth at a height of more than 12 inches throughout the property – Code Section 38-31 (a)(b)(1) VIOLATION ADDRESS: 1941 33rd Avenue, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Property found in compliance on February 16, 2021. There are continuing penalties of $50 per day that commenced on October 2, 2020 for 137 days x $50 = $6,850, plus the initial civil penalty of $50 and the cost of enforcement of $55.96 for a total of $6,955.96, plus costs of recording and City Attorney fees)

*Please note that this item was heard after item 5B) 1f on today’s agenda.

Ms. Sanderson reported that the property was found in compliance on February 16, 2021, and the civil penalty has not been paid. She requested that the Board finds the property in compliance as of February 16, 2021, and cease the continuing penalties as of February 16, 2021, and the violator to pay the accrued continuing penalties and costs.

Mr. Price moved that the Board finds that the property was in compliance as of February 16, 2021, to cease the continuing penalties as of February 16, 2021, and to pay the accrued continuing penalties and costs. Mr. McDonald seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.

Mr. Pizzichillo said in these cases and other cases the Board has discussed with the City Attorney some kind of mechanism for the City to collect from the non-payers. His concern is that some of these people will never pay.

Mr. Turner said there are times when the City is paid when the property is sold. He said their only other options are to foreclose or send them to a collection agency. He noted that a foreclosure would have to be at the direction of the City Council.

Mr. Pizzichillo asked how many of these cases do they have that are of significant nature where they have not paid.

Mr. Turner said a list would be in the City Clerk’s office.

6 03/10/21 CEB Ms. Sherri Philo, Deputy City Clerk, explained that the City Clerk’s office does not really have a list, but she does try to keep track of the cases where the Board orders are recorded and money is due. However, as far as telling them how many cases there are, there are several.

Mr. Daige suggested that the Board receives a list of the Board orders that are recorded and that they see the amount of monies owed to the City so they could look into if there is a course they could take to speed up the process instead of waiting years down the road. He said the Board could get some verbiage from the City Attorney so they could put a package together to send to the City Council for them to see and make a ruling on it.

Mr. Daige suggested that before the Board thinks about making a recommendation to the City Council that they see what is open and on the books.

Ms. Philo explained that there are cases where the property is in compliance, but the penalties were not paid that are recorded; there are cases that have continuing penalties accruing that are recorded; etc.

Mr. Price suggested that they exclude costs that are due to the City and just get a list of the fines themselves.

Ms. Sanderson explained that some fines are continuing daily.

Mr. Pizzichillo said that he is not interested in the $50 penalties. He is interested in the large fines that are owed to the City. He wants to know how many cases there are where there is a significant amount of fines owed to the City that have not been paid.

Mr. Daige said that he understands it is a moving number. What he is looking for is if the City Attorney could recommend a mechanism where the monies could be collected quicker.

Ms. Philo questioned so are they requesting a list of the monies that are owed to the City.

Mr. Pizzichillo said that he doesn’t want any names, he just wants the number.

Mr. Turner said the question is what level does the Board want to pursue foreclosure actions.

Mr. Pizzichillo said there is some number that the City has to move on, not the person who forgot to pay $50.

Mr. Daige said there are properties in the City that have been fined over the years and are still in bad shape. He said if there is a way for the City to square some of this away, he would like to do it.

Mr. McDonald asked Mr. Turner if it would be appropriate for the Board to meet with the City Council and express their concerns.

Mr. Turner said that he would recommend that they do things as a Board and not as an individual. He suggested that they see if the City Clerk’s office can prepare something for the Board to look at and then they can put it before the City Council as an agenda item for them to make a determination if this is something they want staff to pursue. 7 03/10/21 CEB Ms. Philo said that she would research how she could gather this information for the Board as to the fines that are owed and if there are continuing penalties.

f. CASE #20-CE-11119 / 2152T VIOLATOR: PC Investment Properties, LLC / Julie E. Miller, Agent VIOLATION: Trash and debris; dumpster in poor condition and in need of repair – Code Section 38-31 (a)(5) and Section 66-11 (5)(b)(c) VIOLATION ADDRESS: 1876 41st Avenue, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 (Property found in compliance on February 16, 2021. There are continuing penalties of $50 per day that commenced on October 21, 2020 for 118 days x $50 = $5,900, plus costs of recording and City Attorney fees. The initial $50 civil penalty has been paid)

*Please note that this item was heard prior to item 5-B) 1e on today’s agenda.

Ms. Sanderson reported that the property was found in compliance on February 16, 2021, and the civil penalty has been paid. She asked that the Board finds the property in compliance as of February 16, 2021, to cease the continuing penalty as of that date, and to pay the continuing penalties and costs.

Mr. Troy Peterson, Property Manager, who has been sworn in, said that he didn’t realize that he was walking into a hearing. He thought that they were just going to try to get this issue cleared up.

Ms. Sanderson reported that this case is before the Board to find the property in compliance.

Mr. McDonald asked Mr. Peterson if he understood that this was to be brought into compliance last October.

Mr. Peterson answered no. He explained that they took over management of this property in November and they were not aware of the Code violation until December. He reported that the property owner told him that the wrong mailing address was on file and at that time he contacted Ms. Sanderson.

Mr. McDonald asked Ms. Sanderson when she was contacted.

Ms. Sanderson said that Mr. Peterson did reach out to her prior to today’s hearing.

Mr. Peterson said they contracted with Professional Grade Fence before the end of December and they were the ones pulling the permits. He said when he would question the permits he was told that the City’s permit was ready, but they needed a permit from the County, which was the delay. He said that Ms. Sanderson did tell him that the City’s permit was ready and he communicated that with Professional Grade Fence and they told him that they were waiting on the County’s permit. He said that the fence was completed within a week of them receiving the permit from the County. 8 03/10/21 CEB Mr. Daige asked what is the entire amount due.

Mr. McDonald answered $5,900.

Mr. Price said the property owner is the one who has to pay this, not the Property Manager.

Ms. Sanderson reported that she has not had any communication with the property owner.

Mr. McDonald asked if the property owner was notified in October.

Ms. Sanderson answered yes, by the address that is on record.

Mr. Peterson reported that the property owner did tell him that the City had the wrong mailing address.

Mr. Pizzichillo said that he would not have a problem giving them the benefit of the doubt. He said according to the Property Manager, they did not receive notification.

Mr. Tuner reported that there is no indication of any return of the notices in their file so there is no issue as to service.

Ms. Sanderson showed the Board a photograph that was taken of the property on September 8, 2020 at 8:13 a.m. (on file in the City Clerk’s office).

Mr. Daige referred to the photograph. He said there is a lot of debris around the dumpster and that didn’t happen overnight. He said it is the responsibility of the property owner to maintain the property. He said the fence around the dumpster shows that it has been in disrepair for quite a while. He said that he is not in favor of relaxing any of the accumulated fines.

Ms. Sanderson asked Mr. Peterson if there a local property manager, with the owner living in south Florida and him being located in Melbourne.

Mr. Peterson said there was a local property manager before his company took over and the property was seriously mismanaged. He said that his company had a lot of clean up to do in addition to the dumpster. He said there were less than desirable occupants that had to be removed, there was some Police activity that they had to be dealt with, and there was some gang activity on site. He said they cleaned up the property, and did a lot of work since they took it over.

Mr. McDonald moved that the Board finds that there was a violation, that the violation has been corrected, and that the Board issues a Board order to pay the $50 per day effective October 21, 2020, through February 21, 2021.

Ms. Sanderson asked that the Board finds that the property is in compliance and that the penalties stand.

9 03/10/21 CEB Mr. McDonald moved that the property is in compliance and the penalty stands and the Board issues a Board order to pay $50 a day between October 21, 2020 and when it came into compliance on February 21, 2021.

Ms. Sanderson asked that the Board finds that the property is in compliance as of February 16, 2021, and to cease the continuing penalties as of February 6, 2021, and to pay the accrued penalties and costs.

Ms. Philo noted that the correction date was February 16, 2021.

Ms. Sanderson said that is correct.

Mr. McDonald said the motion is that the Board finds the property in compliance as of February 16, 2021, to cease the continuing penalties as of February 16, 2021, and to pay the accrued continuing penalties and costs. Mr. Daige seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.

Mr. Peterson asked that the Board order be mailed to his office at 1103 West Hibiscus Boulevard, #310, Melbourne, Florida 32901. He said this would be settled faster if the Board order is mailed to him.

6. OLD BUSINESS

PUBLIC HEARING A) Code Enforcement Board Case #21-CE-11400, 1413 25th Avenue, Kaleigh Rhea Ann Romine and Notice of Public Nuisance Code Violation, Case #21-CE-11440, 1413 25th Avenue, Kaleigh Rhea Ann Romine and Caliber Home Loans

Ms. Sanderson reported that the City Manager signed off on a public nuisance violation, which was hand delivered to the property owner, it was mailed to the property owner’s grandmother who is also on the mortgage, and was mailed to the bank. She reported that she spoke with the bank twice and the most recent voice mail was that they would remove the trash and garbage, but if the property owner tells them to leave the property they would. She reported that the Public Works Department put in a request to the City Manager to abate and secure the property.

Mr. McDonald questioned in addition to the continuing penalties, the cost of abatement would be added.

Ms. Sanderson said once the City secures the property and the property owner does not have access, then that would cease the $100 per day penalties. The property owner would be billed for the cost of the City to abate the property, the property owner would then have 30- days to pay or appeal, and then the City would move forward with action of a lien.

Mr. Pizzichillo said the property owner would be removed from the property at some point.

Ms. Sanderson said that is correct.

Mr. Daige asked Ms. Sanderson once the property is boarded up that the Police Department 10 03/10/21 CEB keeps an eye on it. The reason is because this property has been used by the homeless and sometimes they get irritated when a property is shut down and they go in and pull off the boards.

Ms. Sanderson reported that this property would be on a “keep watch” by the Police Department.

7. ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS

None

8. CLERK’S MATTERS

None

9. ATTORNEY’S MATTERS

None

10. CHAIRMAN’S MATTERS

None

11. MEMBER’S MATTERS

None

12. ADJOURNMENT

Today’s meeting adjourned at 2:26 p.m.

/sp

11 03/10/21 CEB BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640 S-A) I

CITY OF VERO BEACH

vs. CASE No's.: 21-CE-11496

PORTLES DE VERO, INC./ CHARLES MCKINNON, AGENT Citation No.: 3202M Violator

TO: Portles De Vero. Inc. / Charles McKinnon, Agent NOTICE OF HEARING 3055 Cardinal Drive, Suite 302 Vero Beach, Florida 32963 AND 2855 Ocean Drive Vero Beach, Florida 32963

YOU ARE HERBY NOTIFIED that a hearing is scheduled before the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Vero Beach ("Board") regarding the above-styled code enforcement case as follows:

DATE and TIME: _A_p_r_il______1_41_h__ 2021 at 1 :30 P.M.

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL. COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING:

Appeal of code enforcement citation.

YOUR HEARING RIGHTS: You have the right to be represented at the hearing by an attorney at your own expense if you so choose, however an attorney is not required. You have the right to present witnesses and other evidence on your behalf and to cross-examine witnesses against you. You have the right to testify or not testify on your own behalf.

CITATION APPEALS: Pursuant to COVB Code sec. 2-303, the Board's authority on appeal of a citation is limited to fact-finding only. If your appeal of the citation is to contest the interpretation or application of the Code provision(s) cited as being violated, such appeal must be made in writing to the designated administrative authority of the City as defined in sec. 2-303 or that appeal is waived. If such administrative appeal is taken, it must be finally decided before the Board may hear appeal of the citation.

Page 1 of 2

2020 NOH Appeal Form IF YOU FAIL TO APPEAR: If you do not appear at the hearing in person or by your attorney to defend this matter, you will be deemed to have waived your right to a hearing and the Board may rule against you in your absence and enter an order accordingly. Also, take notice that such waiver of your right to a hearing will be deemed your admission of the violation(s) cited if the hearing is for appeal of the citation.

LATE CORRECTION OF VIOLATION OR LATE PAYMENT: This case may be presented to the Board even if all cited violations have been corrected and civil penalties and costs have been paid prior to the hearing.

HEARING RECORD: This hearing involves non-criminal code enforcement matters. You are responsible for insuring, at your own expense, that a verbatim record of the hearing is made by a Florida certified court reporter should you desire to appeal an adverse decision of the Board to the Circuit Court.

POSTPONEMENTS: No request for postponement of the hearing will be considered unless such request is made in writing, stating good reason for the requested postponement, and received by the board clerk at least five (5) days prior to the date set for the hearing at: City Clerk's Office, City Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960.

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By~ - ~ erriPhilo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true copy of the foregoing Notice of Hearing was provided to the above-named violator by first class U.S. Mail addressed to the above-specified address this 31 st day of March 20 21

em J>hik, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Appeal Form L A M B E R202J MJ'R- 5 Pr1 3: 33 COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE INC.

29 45 20th Street, Vero Beach, Florida Ph one: 772-778-2334

March 5, 2021

City Clerk's Office City Hall 1053 20th Place Vero Beach, FL 32960

RE: Code Enforcement Citation No. 3202M / 21-CE-114976 Portales De Vero Inc 2855 Ocean Drive Request for Hearing

To Whom It May Concern:

As the Property Management Company for Portales De Vero Inc, we request a hearing to contest the citation due to certain circumstances. While someone encroached on the property without permission and vandalized several palm trees, we, as Property Management, and Portales De Vero Inc, were not aware of the cutting of the trees until after they were cut down and hauled off. Once informed of the damages, we contacted Code Enforcement. We are in the process of applying for the After-the-fact permit as per the Citation.

Please give our request expedience so we can try to expedite the replacement of the trees.

Sincerely, _xbmrv (/~~di Simon Senior Property Manager BEFORETHECODEENFORCEMENTBOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: Portales de Vero Case Number:21-CE-11496 Violators 2855 Ocean Drive Violation Address Vero Beach, FL 32963

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-PAYMENT OF CIVIL PENALTY

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has corrected the cited violation by the date given in the citation and the above-named violator has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance ofthe citation. The civii penalty assessed on the citation has not been paid.

------~------~"- Affiant Print Name: Melody Sanderson

Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Affiant, Melody Sanderson, who was duly sworn, and who states that he/she has read the foregoing Affidavit ofNon-Compliance and that the contents are true and correct. v-d l I Sworn to and subscribed before me thisL3 day of C,.. v C.,,.V\. 20 2\ by Melody Sanderson, who is personally known to me OR n/a produced ------as ident1hcahon.

••.. •;;;;·;~••... TRACY FERSCH Print Name: /.f~illf,;\ Notary Public - State of Florid?. Commission No.: 1•: !j-.: • •j Commission # GG 1755t2 \:',; _;_,J_--"'"~/ My Comm. Expires Feb 20 . 2022 My Commission Expires: ··-t::.'..':~-··· Bonded :hrcugh National Nc:ar; Assn . VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3202M / 21-CE-11496

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on Februa(Y. 26, 2021 at 12:59 am

Name: Portales De Vero Inc / Charles McKinnon, Agent 3055 Cardinal Drive, Suite 302 of: Vero Beach, FL 32963 at (violation address): 2855 Ocean Drive in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Palm trees removed without a P-ermit.

Violation of code provision(s): 72.43, 72.44

Facts constituting violation: Eigbt.(8) Palm trees removed without obtaining a Tree Removal Permit. After-the-fact permit must be obtained from the Vero Beach Planning Department and mitigation maY. be reguired. CIVIL PENALTY: R,050.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/16/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 03/16/2021. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 03/02/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: Ci!Y. Clerk's Office, Ci!Y. Hall. 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Your signature below acknowledges receipt of a copy of this citation and is NOT an admission of the violation. Willful refusal to sign and accept this citation is a misdemeanor criminal offense punishable as provided by law.

Date:------Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000225 Certified Mail Receipt: 70182290000036959580

a-1 w JR IGI NA L BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs. CASE No's.: 21-CE-11503

CHRISTOPHER DOLD Citation No.:2021000475 I 3209M Violator

TO: Christopher Dold NOTICE OF HEARING 611 East Causeway Boulevard Vero Beach, Florida 32963

YOU ARE HERBY NOTIFIED that a hearing is scheduled before the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Vero Beach ("Board") regarding the above-styled code enforcement case as follows:

DATE and TIME: _A_p_r_il______14_1_h--~ 2021 at 1 :30 P.M.

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING:

[B Appeal of code enforcement citation.

CITATION APPEALS: Pursuant to COVB Code sec. 2-303, the Board's authority on appeal of a citation is limited to fact-finding only. If your appeal of the citation is to contest the interpretation or application of the Code provision(s) cited as being violated, such appeal must be made in writing to the designated administrative authority of the City as defined in sec. 2-303 or that appeal is waived. If such admin_istrative appeal is taken, it must be finally decided before the Board may hear appeal of the citation.

IF YOU FAIL TO APPEAR: If you do not appear at the hearing in person or by your attorney to defend this matter, you will be deemed to have waived your right to a hearing and the Board may rule against you in your absence and enter an order accordingly. Also, take notice that such Page 1 of 2

2020 NOH Appeal Form waiver of your right to a hearing will be deemed your admission of the violation(s) cited if the hearing is for appeal of the citation.

LA TE CORRECTION OF VIOLATION OR LATE PAYMENT: This case may be presented to the Board even if all cited violations have been corrected and civil penalties and costs have been paid prior to the hearing.

POSTPONEMENTS: No request for postponement of the hearing will be considered unless such request is made in writing, stating good reason for the requested postponement, and received by the board clerk at least five (5) days prior to the date set for the hearing at: Clerk's Office, City Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach. Florida 32960.

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By:~ - - ~~ Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

erriPhilo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Appeal Form °'~"~fW Do\d 2021 MAR I I AM ro: 35 03( II {2.0 2-1 l {).._M. ~tx:-~H7 ~r,~\ ~t. hi\l.,.,,r'J . c~hJ-,"~ , 1) 21 - er- 1(5o'-(

i) t. t - Ct - l\ 5o 3 VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT AMENDED CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3209M / 21-CE-11503

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on March 06, 2021 at 8:30 P-m

Name: Dold, Christopher 611 E Causeway Blvd of: Vero Beach, FL 32963

at (violation address): 611 East Causeway Boulevard in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Noise violation.

Violation of code provision(s): 38-61

Facts constituting violation: Loud music and noise. CIVIL PENALTY: $100.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/23/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: . This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Fonseca Date Issued: 03/06/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: City Clerk's Office, City Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000247 Certified Mail Receipt: HAND DELIVERY

0 ORIGIN AL ----- . ' CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION _! Code Enforcement . th 1053 20 Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 •-·---- - No. ---=-lb_l=---.,fc__D_O_....,Q_q_1_s______STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH, In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on the pf day of ,N14 (? (!, t} 2.£1..lL, at Zf) 30 ( )AM (X) PM I I First Name Middle Last DOB Sex Race of 61 I C: (:.L}v5l.5"w-l}Y 13,___v,.:J v~eo~~~l-f FL- 5l:jC.} rv--,r4= at Street /1\ City State Zip Code Telephone ------L-+------in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the Location of Violation following civil offense: lad) ,.jQI w I/VJ U)I .. in violation of code provision( s ): V8~ro )6C I ] 8-(p I / 3tr Ilt" I Facts constituting violation:______~----- r/crl?O w9 5 /.,I 6/./-f'J:>, r'ee; f Gfr J V tal.d-r} ft)/V, f flA-110

c1v1L PENALTY: $_l___.S""'"'o'-._,,o....o.....___ PAY BY DATE:_0_3_(/_ro...... /Zo_z...... 1_ REPEAT VIOLATION

D WARNING. This is a warning notice and no civil penalty is assessed. If correction of the violation is required, it must be corrected by the date specified below. Failure to correct the violation by the date specified, or a repeat of the same violation, even if the violation occurs at a different location, will result in issuance of a citation assessing civil penalties against you.

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: ______, 2 . This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Date Issued: 6 ~Iott/ ZoZ I Telephone: {J7l) q'/8 "'{[~ 60

';( W~?,:.2,, '"'''''"'' Date J}/o&/zo 7./ V.06-08 WHITE - CLERK YELLOW - VIOLATOR PINK - CLERK GOLD - DEPARTMENT /DIVISION BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: Dold Case Number:21-CE-11503 Violators 611 E Causewav Bv Violalion Address Vero Beach. FL 32963

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-PAYMENT OF CIVIL PENALTY

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson, being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has coJTected the cited violation by the date given in the citation and the above-named violator has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance ofthe citation. The civil penalty assessed on the citation has not been paid.

----~-~______,Affiant Print Name: Melody Sanderson

Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Affiant, Melody Sanderson, who was duly sworn, and who states that he/she has read the foregoing Affidavit of Non-Compliance and that the contents are true and correct. Sworn to and subscribed before ;!JM~f _/JA(J, di 2cl__ by Melody Sanderson, who is ~ sonally Jsriewn to me OR n/a produced ------as identi-fiea-frcJn.--

;\t-RY ds Jennifer De La Rosa J'Cb NOTARY PUBLIC !iSTATE OF FLORIDA ~ ,. ""~ Comm# GG346655 A)J? f ARY~ BLIC ".r1NcF , ri.._c;.· F.xpires 6/19/2023 Pmtt Nan1e: Ca.h1miss\SP No.: 6Mi' Commission Expires: BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Te~phone(772)978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH

vs. CASE No's.: 21-CE-11504

CHRISTOPHER DOLD CitationNo.:2021000476/3210M Violator

TO: Christopher Dold NOTICE OF HEARING 611 East Causeway Boulevard Vero Beach, Florida 32963

YOU ARE HERBY NOTIFIED that a hearing is scheduled before the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Vero Beach ("Board") regarding the above-styled code enforcement case as follows:

DATE and TIME: ---=-A...:,;p:;..;..r;:.;_il______...:,.14...;...1_h___._ 2021 at 1:30 P.M.

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING:

Appeal of code enforcement citation.

2020 NOH Appeal Form waiver of your right to a hearing will be deemed your admission of the violation(s) cited if the hearing is for appeal of the citation.

LA TE CORRECTION OF VIOLATION OR LATE PAYMENT: This case may be presented to the Board even if all cited violations have been corrected and civil penalties and costs have been paid prior to the hearing.

POSTPONEMENTS: No request for postponement of the hearing will be considered unless such request is made in writing, stating good reason for the requested postponement, and received by the board clerk at least five (5) days prior to the date set for the hearing at: City Clerk's Office. City Hall. 1053 20th Place. Vero Beach. Florida 32960.

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 B~ -:~ erriPhilo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Slierri Philo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Appeal Form (1('\"\ofW Do\ J 2021 MAR , 1 nn ro =35 0){ II {2.0 2- I l °'"""' ~v-c~+--7 ~r,e.c.' ~e.. h, \l.,"'r? c~hH -

1) 21 - er- 1(5o'-f

i) '2 l - C€ - ll S'o 3 VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 1,•. CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION ,______AMENDED CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION...... , 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3210M / 21-CE-11504

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on March 06, 2021 at 9:31 Rm

Name: Dold, Christopher 611 E Causeway Blvd of: Vero Beach, FL 32963

at (violation address): 611 East Causeway: Boulevard in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Noise violation.

Violation of code provision(s): 38-61

Facts constituting violation: Loud music. CIVIL PENALTY: $100.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/23/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

Issued by: Fonseca Date Issued: 03/06/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: Ci!y: Clerk's Office, Ci!y: Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1 ,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:------Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000248 Certified Mail Receipt: HAND DELIVERY

:J ORIGI NAL . .' CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION ! Code Enforcement ; th ' 1053 20 Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960 •...... ~.- ' STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH, In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on the pT# day of ;v7/Jr/<<:. /j 2&_, at 2J ( )AM {)<) PM I First Name Middle Last DOB Sex Race of /JI F C 4v5E"v-rqy Jt,vO v~ 1>&1<:~ Fc_ IV/A at Street 'JI City State Zip Code Telephone ______in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the Location of Violation following civil offense: L(jV,t) ,-/(JJ 5£'//VJ(/)J

CIVIL PENALTY:$ lSC>.66 PAY BY DATE: 63/,b/?.t,j I REPEAT VIOLATION

0 CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: ______, 2__ . This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Date Issued: ~/olr' / ?o 2) Telephone: on) q7[i-4hoo

6 6 XS{'hlf~~"'" of lodl,ldoal Date 31 (p ffe Z}

V.06-08 WHITE - CLERK YELLOW - VIOLATOR PINK - CLERK GOLD - DEPARTMENT/DIVISION BEFORETHECODEENFORCEMENTBOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: Dold Case Number:21-CE-11504 Violators 611 E Causeway Bv Violation Address Vero Beach. FL 32963

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-PAYMENT OF CIVIL PENALTY

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has corrected the cited violation by the date given in the citation and the above-named violator has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance ofthe citation. The civil penalty assessed on the citation has not been paid.

,Affiant -P-ri_n_tN_am_e_:..,.M"""'Y{.. e_l_o_d_y_S_an-de-1--s-on___.

Sworn to and subscribed before me t),rrsJZ5day of_+M,.,.,.J!\--".(A_ J ...,,_h__,_____2oJ/ by Melody Sanderson, who is \ per~6n~/known to me OR n/a produced ------as ilien .ficat1on.

u'"RY 4s.P. Jennifer De La Rosa ]){ NOTARY PUBLIC t -/l! .,--F~TATE OF FLORIDA '.r, • · ,,rnnm/1 GG346655 !j'c::1,::~xpires: -,vaf. ' 91~ Expire.s 8/19/2023 BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH

vs. CASE No.: 19-CE-9526

ROGER A. JACQUELIN, JR. AND MAUREEN K. JACQUELIN Citation No.:_1!..!.7..,,_04_,__,T'---- Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: Roger A. Jacquelin, Jr. and Maureen K. Jacquelin 905 Riomar Drive Vero Beach, Florida 32963 AND 1715 29th Avenue Vero Beach, Florida 32960 And [email protected]

YOU ARE HERBY NOTIFIED that a hearing is scheduled before the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Vero Beach ("Board") regarding the above-styled code enforcement case as follows: DATE and TIME: April 14th 2021 at 1:30 P.M.

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: D Failure to Correct Violation(s). Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs.

Other (describe): Request of the Code Enforcement Officer for the Board to find in

compliance, to cease the continuing penalties, to pay all accrued penalties, and all costs due to the City

2020 NOH Form address the Code Enforcement Board pursuant to provisions of City's Code Enforcement Ordinance, you will be deemed to be in default and to have waived your right to appear and the Code Enforcement Board may take necessary and appropriate action in the matter(s) and enter an order(s) accordingly.

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By:~ -K~ SerriPhilo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

' . .,,,,,C:---· Sherri Pllilo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CIT~ TION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 1704T / 19-CE-9526

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on February-12, 2019 at 0928

Name: Jacquelin Roger A Jr & Maureen K 905 Riomar Dr of: Vero Beach, FL 32963

at (violation address): 1715 29th Ave in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Construction without a P-ermit or aP-P-rovals.

Violation of code provision(s): 22-106(9), 64.02(!:!).(1)_

Facts constituting violation: Construction of a new fence without a P-ermit. Please obtain after the fact P-ermitting and aP-P-rovals from both the CltY. Of Vero Beach and the Indian River CountY. Building~partment and remit civil 12fillfil!Y. on/or before 03/15/2019. CIVIL PENALTY: $100.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/15/2019 REPEAT VIOLATION

./ CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 03/15/2019. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: RamseY. Date Issued: 02/13/2019 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 772-978-4551

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: City Clerk's Office, CitY. Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Your signature below acknowledges receipt of a copy of this citation and is NOT an admission of the violation. Willful refusal to sign c!,!!d accept this citation is a misdemeanor criminal offense punishable as provided by law.

Date:______

Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 19-000230 Certified Mail Receipt: 70182290000037022818 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS INSPECTION HISTORY PRINT

PERMITNBR: 2019041056 JOB DESC: ATF 6' WOOD FENCE STATUS: FINAL

JOB LOCATION: 1715 29THAV

SUBDIVISION: 1003 BELMONT PARK SUB NO 2 REPLAT BLOCK: 0050 LOT: 00010.0

MASTER NBR: 2019041056 UNIT: TRACT: TAZ: 81

WATER: SEWER: COA: FLOOD ZONE:

OWNER NAME: JACQUELIN, ROGER A JR & MAUREEN K JOB PHONE: 808-345-0273

CERT NBR: 23765 OBA: SLATINSKI BUILDERS LLC JOB VALUE: $1,000.00

CONTACT NAME: CONTACT PHONE:

SETBACKS FRONT: REAR: LEFT: RIGHT: SPECIAL:

IMPORTANT DATES: EXTENDED APPLICATION APPROVAL ISSUED FINAL CO EXPIRATION CANCEL EXPIRATION 4/17/2019 4/17/2019 4/25/2019 11/11/2019 NOC Form Board Density

DIRECTIONS: ADDTLINFO:

SUBCONTRACTORS

CERTNBR SUB STATUS START DATE END DATE STATUS SUB CLASS OBA

SUB-PERMITS

PERMIT NBR STATUS TYPE CERTNBR OBA JOB DESC 2019041051 FINAL FNM 23765 SLATINSKI BUILDERS LLC ATF 6' WOOD FENCE

FEES

FEE CODE STATUS DESCRIPTION WAIVE AMOUNT DUE ENTER DATE BCAI POSTED BCAI 1.5% SURCHARGE N 2.00 4/17/2019 DBPR POSTED DBPR SURCHARGE 1.0% 7.1.2017 N 2.00 4/17/2019 PERM POSTED PERMIT FEE BUILDING DIVISION N 75.00 4/17/2019 PERM POSTED PERMIT FEE BUILDING DIVISION N 75.00 4/25/2019

CD's...

CONBR STATUS ISSUE DATE OCC CODE TAZ SPECIAL STIPULATIONS

REQ CLASS DESCRIPTION/REMARKS PRI REQ DATE RESULT CODE RES DATE INSPECTOR

999 STR 999 FINAL INSPECTION 0 5/14/2019 99 FINALAPPROVAL 5/14/2019 BLDDI

Indian River County Printed on: 3/11/2021 12: 1O: 11 PM CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT CDPR2036 Page 1 of 1 3120190024976 RECORDED IN THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF JEFFREY R SMITH, CLERK OF COURT INDIAN RIVER COUNTY FL BK: 3202 PG: 1810 Page 1 of 2 4/29/2019 1 :51 PM

BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE , VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960

CITY OF VERO BEACH CASE NO. 19-CE-9526 vs. CITATIONNO.1704T ROGER A. JACQUELIN, JR. AND MAUREEN K. JACQUELIN 905 Riomar Drive Vero Beach, Florida 32963

ORDER FINDING VIOLATION, TO PAY, AND ASSESSING CONTINUING PENALTIES

VIOLATION: City of Vero Beach Code, sections 22-106(a) and 64.02(a)(l)-Construction without a permit or approvals. LOCATION: 1715 29th Avenue, Vero Beach, Florida 32960

The above-styled case having come before the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Vero Beach ("Board") on the 10th day of April, 2019, on request of the Code Officer for a Board Order, and the Board having heard testimony of the Code Enforcement Officer and having reviewed the record in this action, on motion made and approved, found that: 1. The citation and notice of hearing in this case were served as provided by law, and the violators did not appear. 2. The violator did not appeal issuance of the citation and thereby, waived the right to a hearing before the Board to contest the issuance of the citation, which waiver of hearing is deemed an admission of the violation specified in the citation. 3. The violation has not been corrected and the initial civil penalty of $100.00 has been paid. 4. No cost of enforcement was requested. 5. It would be appropriate to allow additional time to come into compliance. 6. The City is entitled pursuant to law to recover the initial civil penalty, costs of enforcement and all costs of recording the Board's orders in the public records and for satisfying and recording releases of the resulting liens upon payment. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED AND ADJUDGED BY THE BOARD THAT: The violator is deemed to have committed the violation as specified above and on the citation. The violator has paid the initial civil penalty of $100.00. There is imposed a continuing penalty in the amount of $100.00 per day for each day the violations have existed and continue to exist as of March 15, 2019, (the date given on the citation for correction) until the date corrected along with all costs of recording the Board's orders in the public records and costs of satisfying and recording release of the resulting lien upon payment. Page 1 of 2 {\ d DONE AND ORDERED at Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida this,;)). day of /i-P r1· I 2019.

ATTEST: CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD:

Slierri Philo Eric Price as Board Clerk as Board Vice Chairman

[Seal]

Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:

Kira C. Honse as Board Attorney

IMPORTANT INFORMATION Correction of Violations: AFTER CORRECTING THE VIOLATIONS YOU MUST NOTIFY THE CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER; by Telephone 772-978-4551 or 772-978-4561, or in person at the Code Enforcement Office, Vero Beach Police Department, 1055 20th Street, Vero Beach, FL 32960 in order to request re-inspection to avoid imposition of additional civil penalties against you. Payment ofCivil Penalties and Costs: You must contact the City Clerk's office at 772-978-4700 for the total amount of civil penalties, enforcement costs, recording and other costs required to satisfy this order and lien. Civil penalties and costs may be paid in person at the City Clerk's office located in City Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960, Monday through Friday between 8:30 a.m. and 5:00 p.m., or by mailing a check or money order to said address, payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! Repeat Violation: Repeat violation of the same Code provision by the violator, even if committed at a different location, can result in the issuance of a code enforcement citation and assessment of increased civil penalties for the repeat offense. Notice o{Right to Appeal Board Decision: An aggrieved party may appeal the Board's order to the Circuit Court in Indian River County, Florida. A written notice of appeal, together with a copy of the order appealed, must be filed with the Clerk of the Code Enforcement Board and with the Clerk of the Circuit Court, together with the applicable court filing fees, within thirty (30) days after the date of this order or the right to appeal is waived. An appeal is limited to appellate review of the record of the proceedings created before the Code Enforcement Board. Ref F. S. 26.012( 1); Florida Rules ofAppellate Procedure, 9.030(c)(l)(C); 9.1 l0(c).

Page 2 of2 BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs . CASE No.: 20-CE-11288

PA VER OVERLAYS /ATLANTIC HARDSCAPE SUPPLY, INC. / Citation No.: 3009M BIRAN C. HERNDON, AGENT/ JOHN L. AND PENNY C. ESHLEMAN Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: Paver Overlays/ Atlantic Hardscape Supply, Inc./ Biran C. Herndon, Agent I John L. and Penny C. Eshleman 976 8th Street AND 6251 N. US Highway 1 Vero Beach, Florid~ 32960 Ft. Pierce, Florida 34946 And 4701 Bethel Creek Drive Vero Beach, Florida 32963

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: D Failure to Correct Violation(s). Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. Other (describe): Request of the Code Enforcement Officer for the Board to find in

compliance, to cease the continuing penalties, to pay all accrued penalties, and all costs due to the City

Page 1 of 2

2020 NOH Form HEARING: You have the right to appear before the Code Enforcement Board on the date and time noted above. Please be informed that failure to appear may result in additional penalties and a lien filed against your properties. If you do not appear at the hearing in person or by your attorney to address the Code Enforcement Board pursuant to provisions of City's Code Enforcement Ordinance, you will be deemed to be in default and to have waived your right to appear and the Code Enforcement Board may take necessary and appropriate action in the matter(s) and enter an order(s) accordingly.

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By~ ~Board-%?~ Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form 3120200078592 RECORDED IN THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF JEFFREY R SMITH, CLERK OF COURT INDIAN RIVER COUNTY FL BK: 3371 PG: 2024 Page 1 of 2 12/28/2020 1: 27 PM

BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA l 053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960

CITY OF VERO BEACH CASE NO. 20-CE-11288 vs. CITATION NO. 3009M PAVER OVERLAYS LLC / ATLANTIC HARDSCAPE SUPPLY, INC. / Biran C. Herndon, Agent / JOHN L. AND PENNY C. ESHLEMAN 976 8th Street 6251 N. US Highway 1 Vero Beach, Florida 32962 Ft. Pierce, Florida 34946 -AND- 4701 Bethel Creek Drive Vero Beach, Florida 32963

ORDER FINDING VIOLATION, ALLOWING ADDITIONAL TIME FOR COMPLIANCE; ASSESSING CONTINUING PENALTIES AND TOPA Y INITIAL CIVIL PENAL TY

VIOLATION: City of Vero Beach Code, section 64.O5(9)(a)- Failure to obtain Code Compliance Certification/ Right-of-Way Agreement for installation ofpavers. LOCATION: 4701 Bethel Creek Drive, Vero Beach, Florida 32963

The above-styled case having come before the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Vero Beach ("Board") on the 9th day of December 2020, on request from the Code Enforcement Officer for a Board order, and the Board having heard testimony of the Code Enforcement Officer and having reviewed the record in this action, on motion made and approved, found that: 1. The citation and notice of hearing issued in this case were served, as provided by law, and the violator did appear. 2. The violator did not appeal issuance of the citation in this case within the time allowed by law and thereby waived the right to a hearing before the Board to contest the issuance of the citation, which waiver ofhearing is deemed an admission ofthe violation specified in the citation. 3. The initial civil penalty of $50.00 has not been paid. 4. It would be appropriate to allow additional time to come into compliance. 5. The City did not request costs of enforcement; however, the City is entitled, pursuant to law, to recovt?r the initial civil penalty, and all costs ofrecording the Board's order in the public records and for satisfying and recording release of resulting lien upon payment. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED AND ADJUDGED BY THE BOARD THAT: The violator is deemed to have committed the violation as specified above and on the citation, and the violation has not been corrected. The violator is to pay to the City Clerk's office, within thirty Page I of2 i • ,I'.

(30) days of the Board order, the initial civil penalty of $50.00. The violator has fifteen (15) days (December 24, 2020) to correct the violation. If the violation is not corrected and the initial civil penalty has not been paid, a continuing penalty will be imposed in the amount of $50.00 per day for each day the violation(s) have existed and continue to exist commencing on November 20, 2020, the date given on the citation for correction, until the date corrected, together with all costs of recording the Board's order in the public records and costs of satisfying and recording release of the resulting lien upon payment. . DONE AND ORDERED at Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida this 1-J -day of@C'-er0J>.er 2020. / ~, ,.,/ ,· /"J / / / ATTEST: conit .E-NFORC:EMEN'r,,)loARD i/ , a Iv 1/1/. / .rl/~ --u _,., ~" / . . .· ... (_,~L-v([__. ( ; vl/4-l-· r vL-<::::L ;_: ,'t.,',,, • (\__-g . I ,, "'1 ;,•,.•·•,.t ' . ,, ,#-?!J d I .• ,...... nda H1'llman .,;.:· slitri-i Philo Ll . .' ~·.- ,..'..·· .•<"--=- /·, !·)· "~:,--:;. .. ~:;; ·'. . as Board Clerk as Board Vice Chairman .._..:· •;. ·:: . ·: .::~::;~, /(.",~) ·:· - . ,... 1"· :-i.. :- ,. ~ "-\· ~, •• ..,· (Seal) - t-11'-' •1S TO CERTIFY THAT. ,t H.1?,. c:i.J.:.··:.J-; ::,_,;; ::;_ ,-,,_;::.-,_ I ;;;J OP" OF~ / ,1- ._' ,.w; :_.;·..1 St-~tl::r-{ i:l.lp_ IO ,/Jf·'_;.:·::,'.\_,; '•..;:,;.'·{ ·.:' '~ ._, . -, . jt:T~ ._:·/·p,(Q.··· .. - <:r;-:-... · .-~ L,' . ;,__.:------. . !_.,I ';,- 1· -.r, ·; .. ,. [),~TE: iMc<-m O-< ,- !.J4-.:icY~ 6 :;_ r: _.-:...... :: as Board Attorney

IMPORTANT INFORMATION Correction ofViolations: AFTER CORRECTING THE VIOLATIONS YOU MUST NOTIFY THE CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER; by Telephone 772-978-4551 or 772-978-4561, or in person at the Code Enforcement Office, Vero Beach Police Department, 105 5 20t11 Street, Vero Beach, FL 32960 in order to request re-inspection to avoid imposition of additional civil penalties against you. Pavment ofCivil Penalties and Costs: You must contact the City Clerk's office at 772-978-4700 for the total amount of civil penalties, enforcement costs, recording and other costs required to satisfy this order and lien. Civil penalties and costs may be paid in person at the City Clerk's office located in City Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960, Monday through Friday between 8:30 a.m. and 5:00 p.m., or by mailing a check or money order to said address, payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! Repeat Violation: Repeat violation of the same Code provision by the violator, even if committed at a different location, can result in the issuance of a code enforcement citation and assessment of increased civil penalties for the repeat offense. Notice ofRight to AppealBoard Decision: An aggrieved party may appeal the Board's order to the Circuit Court in Indian River County, Florida. A written notice of appeal, together with a copy of the order appealed, must be filed with the Clerk of the Code Enforcement Board and with the Clerk of the Circuit Court, together with the applicable court filing fees, within thirty (30) days after the date of this order or the right to appeal is waived. An appeal is limited to appellate review of the record ofthe proceedings created before the Code Enforcement Board. Ref F.S. 26.012(1); Florida Rules of Appellate Procedure, 9.030(c)(l)(C); 9.1 l0(c).

Page 2 of2 VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3009M / 20-CE-11288

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on October 12, 2020 at 9:40 AM

Name: Paver Overlays / Atlantic Hardscape Supply, Inc, Biran Herndon, Agent (John and Penny Eshleman) 916 20th Place of: Vero Beach, FL 32960

at (violation address): 4701 Bethel Creek Drive in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Failure to obtain Code ComP-liance Certification / right-of-way,.J!greement for the P-avers installed.

Violation of code provision(s): 64.05 rnU~)

Facts constituting violation: Failure to obtain Code Comr.11iance Certification I right-of-way_§greement for the Ravers installed. CIVIL PENALTY: j50.00 PAY BY DATE: 11/20/2020 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 11/20/2020. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 11/06/2020 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: Ci:tY. Clerk's Office, Ci:tY. Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:------Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 20-001148 Certified Mail Receipt: 70190140000036353105

J ORIG IN AL BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs. CASE No.: 20-CE-11287

ACACIA TREASURE COAST, LLC / EROL R. A TAMER, AGENT Citation No.: 3008M Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: Acacia Treasure Coast, LLC / Erol R. Atamer, Agent 1165 36th Street Vero Beach, Florida 32960 AND 1110 Royal Palm Boulevard Vero Beach, Florida 32960

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: D Failure to Correct Violation(s). Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs.

Other (describe): Request of the Code Enforcement Officer for the Board to find in

compliance, to cease the continuing penalties, to pay all accrued penalties, initial civil penalty and costs, and all costs due to the City

HEARING: You have the right to appear before the Code Enforcement Board on the date and time noted above. Please be informed that failure to appear may result in additional penalties and a lien filed against your properties. If you do not appear at the hearing in person or by your attorney to address the Code Enforcement Board pursuant to provisions of City's Code Enforcement Ordinance, you will be deemed to be in default and to have waived your right to appear and the Code Page 1 of 2

2020 NOH Form Enforcement Board may take necessary and appropriate action in the matter(s) and enter an order(s) accordingly.

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31. 2021 erriPhilo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form . . 3120200078591 RECORDED IN THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF JEFFREY R SMITH , CLERK OF COURT INDIAN RIVER COUNTY FL M BK: 3371 PG 2022 Page 1 of 2 12/28/2020 127 p

BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960

CITY OF VERO BEACH CASE NO. 20-CE-11287 vs. CITATION NO. 3008M ACACIA TREASURE COAST LLC / Erol R. Atamer, Agent 1165 36th Street Vero Beach, Florida 32960

ORDER FINDING VIOLATION, ALLOWING ADDITIONAL TIME FOR COMPLIANCE; ASSESSING CONTINUING PENALTIES AND TOPA Y INITIAL CIVIL PENALTY

VIOLATION: City of Vero Beach Code, section 38-3 l(a)(b)(l)- Public nuisance; Weeds, grass, or undergrowth at a height of more than 12 inches. LOCATION: 1110 Royal Palm Boulevard, Vero Beach, Florida 32960

The above-styled case having come before the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Vero Beach ("Board") on the 9th day ofDecember 2020, on request from the Code Enforcement Officer for a Board order, and the Board having heard testimony of the Code Enforcement Officer and having reviewed the record in this action, on motion made and approved, found that: 1. The citation and notice of hearing issued in this case were served, as provided by law, and the violator did appear. 2. The violator did not appeal issuance of the citation in this case within the time allowed by law and thereby waived the right to a hearing before the Board to contest the issuance of the citation, which waiver ofhearing is deemed an admission ofthe violation specified in the citation. 3. The initial civil penalty of $100.00 has not been paid. 4. It would be appropriate to allow additional time to come into compliance. 5. There are costs of enforcement in the amount of $55.96. The City is entitled, pursuant to law, to recover the initial civil penalty, and all costs of recording the Board's order in the public records and for satisfying and recording release of resulting lien upon payment. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED AND ADJUDGED BY THE BOARD THAT: The violator is deemed to have committed the violation as specified above and on the citation, and the violation has not been corrected. The violator is to pay to the City Clerk's office, within thirty (30) days ofthe Board order, the initial civil penalty of $100.00, along with costs ofenforcement in the amount of $55.96. The violator has fifteen (15) days (December 24, 2020) to correct the violation. Ifthe violation is not corrected and the initial civil penalty and enforcement costs have not been paid, a continuing penalty will be imposed in the amount of$100.00 per day for each day the violations(s) have existed and continue to exist commencing on November 20, 2020, the date given on the citation for Page 1 of2 .. 1 • ' •

correction, until the date corrected, together with all costs of recording the Board's order in the public records and costs of satisfying and recording release of the resulting lien upon payment. :)4, DONE AND ORDERED at Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida this ./1-J -- day of J2-e C-f!r?1 !J<,/'" 2020.

ATTEST:

Sherri Philo as Board Clerk as Board Vice Chairman (Seal)

Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:

~,4,?7ios.Tumer - as Board Attorney

IMPORTANT INFORMATION Correction of Violations: AFTER CORRECTING THE VIOLATIONS YOU MUST NOTIFY THE CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER; by Telephone 772-978-4551 or 772-978-4561, or in person at the Code Enforcement Office, Vero Beach Police Department, 1055 20th Street, Vero Beach, FL 32960 in order to request re-inspection to avoid imposition of additional civil penalties against you. Payment ofCivil Penalties and Costs: You must contact the City Clerk's office at 772-978-4700 for the total amount of civil penalties, enforcement costs, recording and other costs required to satisfy this order and lien. Civil penalties and costs may be paid in person at the City Clerk's office located in City Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960, Monday through Friday between 8:30 a.m. and 5:00 p.m., or by mailing a check or money order to said address, payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! Repeat Violation: Repeat violation of the same Code provision by the violator, even if committed at a different location, can result in the issuance of a code enforcement citation and assessment of increased civil penalties for the repeat offense. Notice o[Right to Appeal Board Decision: An aggrieved party may appeal the Board's order to the Circuit Court in Indian River County, Florida. A written notice of appeal, together with a copy of the order appealed, must be filed with the Clerk of the Code Enforcement Board and with the Clerk of the Circuit Court, together with the applicable court filing fees, within thirty (30) days after the date of this order or the right to appeal is waived. An appeal is limited to appellate review of the record of the proceedings created before the Code Enforcement Board. Ref F .S. 26.012(1 ); Florida Rules ofAppellate Procedure, 9.030(c)(l)(C); 9.1 IO(c).

Page 2 of2 VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION . CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION I 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3008M / 20-CE-11287

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on November 06, 2020 at 8:11 am

Name: Acacia Treasure Coast LLC / Erol Atamer, Agent 1165 36th Street of: Vero Beach, FL 32960 at (violation address): 1110 Royal Palm Boulevard in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Public nuisances.

Violation of code provision(s): 38-31 {2}_(!;?.}_(1)

Facts constituting violation: Wees,_grass or undergrowth at a height of more than 12 inches. Please cut and maintain the entire RroRer:!Y- at a height of less than 12 inches, Please cover the graffiti on the building.(§).:. CIVIL PENALTY: $100.00 PAY BY DATE: 11/20/2020 REPEAT VIOLATION

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 11/06/2020 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: CitY. Clerk's Office, CitY. Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 20-001147 Certified Mail Receipt: PROPERTY POSTED

ZJ ORIGIN AL BEFORETHECODEENFORCEMENTBOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs.

Acacia Treasure Coast LLC CASE NUMBER: 20-CE-11287

VIOLATORS

AFFIDAVIT OF COSTS STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson, being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a code enforcement or police officer for the City of Vero Beach, Florida and I have personal knowledge of and certify that the City of Vero Beach has incurred the following administrative and prosecution costs in investigation, enforcement, testing or monitoring relating to the above-styled code enforcement case against the named violator and that the City ofVero Beach is entitled to recovery of said fees and costs from the violator pursuant to the code enforcement ordinance:

Officer Activity Date Time Rate Amount MS Total hours 12/9/20-4/14/21 1.02 $ 33.11 $ 33.77 MS Complaint Intake inc MS Initial Investigation me MS Initial inspection inc MS Violator conference n/a MS Telephone conference n/a MS Hearing attendance inc MS Notice of violation preparation inc MS Notice of hearing preparation inc MS Photo/exhibit preparation inc MS Re-inspection inc

Additional Costs and Supplies: n/a Postage n/a Notices (mailed and posted) n/a Long Distance Telephone n/a Photographs inc Vehicle Mileage n/a

Total Costs $ 33.77

Melody Sandersoi' Affiant Officer

Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Affiant, Melody Sanderson, who was duly sworn, and who states that he/she has read the foregoing Affidavit of Costs and that the contents are true and correct. Page 1 of2

C:\Users\msanderson\Desktop\letters and forms\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx Sworn to and subscubefore me this jl_day of Mo)1(__,,a 2o) ( by Melody Sanderson, who is person lly own to me OR __ produced ______as identification.

Jennifer De La Rosa :\r,.RY As.~ NOTARY PUBLIC c:> g- ~STATE OF FLORIDA l)-~ ; Comm# GG346655 ""·.r1NcE ,~-..q; Expires 6/19/2023

Page 2 of2

C:\Users\msanderson\Desktop\letters and fonns\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH

vs. CASE No.: 16-CE-6432

HIGH TIDE AUTO WHOLESALE, INC. Citation No.: 0826M Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: High Tide Auto Wholesale, Inc. 2626 North U.S.1 Vero Beach, Florida 32960 AND c/o Mr. Anthony Gagnon 1801 South Indian River Drive Ft. Pierce, Florida 34950

YOU ARE HERBY NOTIFIED that a hearing is scheduled before the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Vero Beach ("Board") regarding the above-styled code enforcement case as follows:

th DATE and TIME: ----'--A-=p;.;..;ri"--I_ ------'1-=-4______... 2021 at 1:30 P.M.

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: D Failure to Correct Violation(s). Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. [B Other (describe): Request of the Code Enforcement Officer for the Board to find in

compliance, to cease the continuing penalties, to pay all accrued penalties, initial civil penalty and costs, and all costs due to the City

2020 NOH Form you will be deemed to be in default and to have waived your right to appear and the Code Enforcement Board may take necessary and appropriate action in the matter(s) and enter an order(s) accordingly.

POSTPONEMENTS: No request for postponement of the hearing will be considered unless such request is made in writing, stating good reason for the requested postponement, and received by the board clerk at least five ( 5) days prior to the date set for the hearing at: City Clerk's Office, City Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960.

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FORTHECODEENFORCEMENTBOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By:(\-~---f({_ Sfierri Philo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960

CITY OF VERO BEACH CASE NO.16-CE-6432 vs. CITATION NO. 0826M HIGH TIDE AUTO WHOLESALE, INC. 2626 N. U.S. 1 AND c/o Mr. Anthony Gagnon Vero Beach, Florida 32960 1801 S. Indian River Dr. Fort Pierce, FL 34950

ORDER TO CORRECT VIOLATION, IMPOSING CONTINUING CIVIL PENAL TIES, AND TOPA Y PENAL TIES AND COSTS

VIOLATION: City of Vero Beach Code sections 70.62(a)(l), (2), and (3); 64.06(a); Repair and sales of vehicles without business tax receipt and site plan approval. LOCATION: 2626 US!, Vero Beach, Florida 32960

The above-styled case ha~ing come before the Board on the 13 th day of April 2016 on request of the code enforcement officer for an order to correct violation and the Board, having heard report of the code enforcement officer regarding the violation having not been corrected and having reviewed the record in this case, on motion made and approved, found that:

1. The citation and notice of hearing issued in this case were served as provided by law; however the violator has failed to appear in this enforcement action. ·

2. The violator did not appeal issuance of the citation in this case within the time allowed by law and thereby waived the right to a hearing before the Board to contest the issuance of the citation, which waiver of hearing is deemed an admission of the violation specified in the citation.

3. The violations specified in the citation have not been corrected by the violator obtaining site plan approval and a business tax receipt and the initial civil penalty assessed on the citation has not been paid.

4. The City has not requested enforcement costs at this time; however the City is entitled pursuant to law to recover all costs of recording the Board's orders in the public records and for satisfying and recording releases of the resulting liens upon payment.

IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED AND ADJUDGED BY THE BOARD THAT:

The violator is deemed to have committed the violations as specified above and on the citation, which violations have not been corrected and are continuing. The violator shall immediately cause correction of the violations by obtaining site plan approval and business tax receipt, and shall pay to the City Clerk, within thirty (30) days from the date of this Order, the initial civil penalty of $50.00 and a continuing civil penalty of $50.00 per day hereby imposed for each day the violation remained and continues to remain uncorrected after the date

Page 1 of 2 3120160029258 ::"f:CORDEO IN THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF JEFFREY R SMITH, CLERK OF COURT INDIAN RIVER COUNTY FL BK: 2936 PG: 909 Page 1 of 2 5/23/2016 1:23 PM given in the citation for correction (03/21/16), together with all costs of recording the Board's orders in the public records and for preparing and recording release of the resulting liens upon payment. Assessment of enforcement and hearing costs are reserved at this time. sf DONE AND ORDERED at Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida this d / day of 0-f>r< I 2016.

ATTEST: CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Sherri Philo, as Board Clerk Kirk Noonan, Cha~ ----~

[Seal]

Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: (_;r~~i':f1 f? r, rt---,- Way\_J.n'e i3. Coment, as .Board Attorney

IMPORTANT INFORMATION

Correction of Violations: AFTER CORRECTING THE VIOLATIONS YOU MUST NOTIFY THE CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER at Telephone #772-978-4551 or 772-978-4561, or in person at the Code Enforcement Office, Vero Beach Police Department, 1055 20th Street; Vero Beach, FL 32960 in order to request · re~inspection to avoid imposition of additional civil .penalties against you.

Payment of Civil Penalties and Costs: You must contact the City Clerk's Office at 772-978-4700 for the total amount of civil penalties, enforcement costs, recording and other costs required to satisfy this order and lien. Payment may be made in person at the City Clerk's Office located in City Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960, Monday through Friday between 8:30 A.M. and 5:00 P.M., or by mailing a check or money order for the verified amount to said address, payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash!

Notice of Right to Appeal Board Decision: An aggrieved party may appeal the Board's order to the Circuit Court in Indian River County, Florida. A written notice of appeal, together with a copy of the order appealed, must be filed with the Clerk of the Code Enforcement Board and with the Clerk of the Circuit Court, together with the applicable court filing fees, within thirty (30) days after the date of this order or the right to appeal is waived. An appeal is limited to appellate ·review of the record of the proceedings created before the Code Enforcement Board. Ref F.S. 26.012(1); Florida Rules of Appellate Procedure, 9.030(c)(l)(C); 9.1 l0(c).

Page 2 of 2 VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 829M / 16-CE-6432 STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on February 22. 2016 at n/a

Name: High Tide Autos 2626 US Highway 1 of: Vero Beach, FL 32960 at (violation address): 2626 US Highway 1 in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Failure to obtain Business Tax Receipt.

Violation of code provision(s): 70.62 (a) (1,2,3), 64.06 (a)

Facts constituting violation: Repair and sales of vehicles require Business Tax Receipt. Site Plan Approval needed from the Planning Department at City Hall. CIVIL PENALTY: $50.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/21/2016 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 03/21/2016. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 03/03/2016 Department: VBPD/Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: City Clerk's Office, City Hall, 1053 20th Place. Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS {excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 16-000219 Certified Mail Receipt: ·70151730000072948912 DOR}GINAL BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH

vs. CASE No.: 20-CE-11270

1616 24 rn A VENUE, LLC / BARBARA HOOKER, AGENT Citation No.:~2=9_,__95""'"M'-'----- Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: 1616 24th Avenue, LLC / Barbara Hooker, Agent 925 12th Street AND 1616 24th Avenue Vero Beach, Florida 32960 Vero Beach, Florida 32960

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: D Failure to Correct Violation(s). Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. [i} Other (describe): Request of the Code Enforcement Officer for the Board to find in

compliance, to cease the continuing penalties, to pay the initial civil penalty, all accrued penalties, and all costs due to the City

Page 1 of 2

2020 NOH Form Enforcement Board may take necessary and appropriate action in the matter(s) and enter an order(s) accordingly.

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31. 2021 By: ~ «~ SerriPhilo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

= sherri Philo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form 3120210010174 RECORDED IN THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF JEFFREY R SMITH, CLERK OF COURT INDIAN RIVER COUNTY FL BK: 3387 PG: 2479 Page 1 of2 2/15/2021 1: 30 PM

BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960

CITY OF VERO BEACH CASE NO. 20-CE-11270 vs. CITATION NO. 2995M 1616 24TH A VENUE, LLC I BARBARA HOOKER, AGENT 925 12 111 Street Vero Beach, Florida 32960

ORDER FINDING VIOLATION, TO PAY INITIAL CIVIL PENALTY; ALLOWING ADDITIONAL TIME FOR COMPLIANCE AND ASSESSING CONTINUING PENALTIES

VIOLATION: City of Vero Beach Code sections 64.05(7); 22-181; 22-106-Fence and brick pavers installed without Code Compliance Certification from the Vero Beach Planning and Development Department. LOCATION: 1616 24th Avenue, Vero Beach, Florida 32960

The above-styled case having come before the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Vero Beach ("Board") on the 13 th day of January 2021, on request of the Code Enforcement Officer for a Board Order, and the Board having heard testimony ofthe Code Enforcement Officer and having reviewed the record in this action, on motion made and approved, found that: 1. The citation and notice of hearing in this case were served, as provided by law, and the violator did not appear. 2. The violator did not appeal issuance ofthe citation in this case within the time allowed by law and thereby waived the right to a hearing before the Board to contest the issuance of the citation, which waiver of hearing is deemed an admission ofthe violation specified in the citation. 3. The initial civil penalty of $50.00 remains unpaid. 4. It would be appropriate to allow additional time to come into compliance. 5. Costs of enforcement were not requested; however, the City is entitled, pursuant to law, to recover the initial civil penalty, and all costs of recording the Board's order in the public records and for satisfying and recording release ofthe resulting lien upon payment. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED AND AD.TUDGED BY THE BOARD THAT: The violator is deemed to have committed the violation as specified above and on the citation. The violator is to pay to the City Clerk's office, within thirty (30) days from the date of this Order, the initial civil penalty of $50.00 assessed on the citation. The violator has thirty (30) days (February 12, 2021) to correct the violation. If the violation is not corrected and the $50.00 initial civil penalty has not been paid, a continuing penalty will be imposed commencing on November 6, 2020 (original compliance date) in the amount of $50.00 per day the violation has existed and continues to exist until the date corrected, together will all costs ofrecording the Board's order in the public records and costs of satisfying and recording release ofthe resulting lieQ upon payment. .,- fe.b,,~~::- ~ND ~~~RED at Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida this / S ·- day of

( Page 1 of2 . - . '

ATTEST: CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

""-snerri Philo Eric~L- Price as Board Clerk as Board Chairman (Seal)

Approv--"~-d_a_s-to-~~fi--""'~-"•'-'n'-d-=-1-eg_a_l_s_uffi-ICiency:

~.Turner as Board Attorney

Pavment ofCivil Penalties alld Costs: You must contact the City Clerk's office at 772-978-4700 for the total amount of civil penalties, enforcement costs, recording and other costs required to satisfy this order and lien. Civil penalties and costs may be paid in person at the City Clerk's office located in City Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960, Monday through Friday between 8:30 a.m. and 5:00 p.m., or by mailing a check or money order to said address, payable to "City ofVero Beach." Do not mail cash! Repeat Violation: Repeat violation of the same Code provision by the violator, even if committed at a different location, can result in the issuance of a code enforcement citation and assessment of increased civil penalties for the repeat offense. Notice ofRig/zt to AppealBoardDecision: An aggrieved party may appeal the Board's order to the Circuit Court in Indian River County, Florida. A written notice of appeal, together with a copy of the order appealed, must be filed with the Clerk of the Code Enforcement Board and with the Clerk of the Circuit Court, together with the applicable court filing fees, within thirty (30) days after the date of this order or the right to appeal is waived. An appeal is limited to appellate review ofthe record ofthe proceedings created before the Code Enforcement Board. Ref F.S. 26.012(1); Florida Rules of Appellate Procedure, 9.030(c)(l)(C); 9.1 lO(c).

Page2 of2 VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 2995M / 20-CE-11270

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on October 22, 2020 at 8:44 am

Name: 1616 24th Ave LLC / Barbara Hooker, Agent 925 12th Street of: Vero Beach, FL 32960 at (violation address): 1616 24th Avenue in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Fence and brick gavers installed without Code Comgliance Certification.

Violation of code provision(s ): 64.05 (Z)_(~). 22-181, 22-106

Facts constituting violation: Installation of fence and brick Ravers reguires Code ComRliance Certification from the Vero Beach Planning DeRartment. Fence also requires a buildingJJermit from Indian River County Building DeRartment. CIVIL PENALTY: j50.00 PAY BY DATE: 11/06/2020 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 11/06/2020. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 10/23/2020 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: Ci!Y. Clerk's Office, Ci!Y. Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 20-001116 Certified Mail Receipt: PROPERTY POSTED

ZJ ORIGIN AL BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs. CASE No.: 20-CE-11301

STEPHEN D. BOYLES Citation No.: 3020M Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: Stephen D. Boyles 2626 11 th A venue Vero Beach, Florida 32960

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: G Failure to Correct Violation(s). Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. D Other (describe): ______

Page 1 of 2

2020 NOH Form LATE CORRECTION OF VIOLATION OR LATE PAYMENT: This case may be presented to the Board even if all cited violations have been corrected and civil penalties and costs have been paid prior to the hearing.

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 Byi ~ -~4 Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

- Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION .JI 1055 20th Street l!I. Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3020M / ZQ-CE-11301 2 o -df- -)/3D/ STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on November 16, 2020 at 7:38 am

Name: Boyles, Stephen D * 2626 11 Th Ave of: Vero Beach, FL 32960 at (violation address): 2626 11th Avenue in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Front deck constructed without Code Comgliance Certification or building_germit.

Violation of code provision(s): 64,(&(a)(b}(9}(b), 22-181, 22-106

Facts constituting violation: Please obtain after-the-fact Code ComRliance Certification (f!RRlication attached) from the Vero Beach Planning DeRartment. Once aRRroved building_Rermit reguired from IRC Building..QgRartment. CIVIL PENALTY: $50.00 PAY BY DATE: 02/08/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 02/08/2021. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 01/25/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 20-001166 Certified Mail Receipt: PROPERTY POSTED

t) ORIGIN AL BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: Boyles. Stephen Case #: 20-CE-11301 Violntors 2626 11 th A venue

Violation Address Vero Beach. FL 32960

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-COMPLIANCE- CONTINUING VIOLATION

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has not complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has failed to correct the cited violation by the date given in the citation and has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance of the citation.

____L______~,Affiant Print Name: MelodySanderson

Sworn to and subscribed before me t~·Qof-~..,..A,HJa'\-'/4'--'------2,il/_ by Melody Sanderson, who is perso all~~;~ to me OR n/a produced ------as identifi · . BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

CITY OF VERO BEACH

VS.

Boyles CASE NUMBER: 20-CE- I 130 I

VIOLATORS

AFFTDAVIT OF COSTS STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson, being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a code enforcement or police officer for the City of Vero Beach, Florida and I have personal knowledge of and certify that the City of Vero Beach has incurred the following administrative and prosecution costs in investigation, enforcement, testing or monitoring relating to the above-styled code enforcement case against the named violator and that the City ofVero Beach is entitled to recovery ofsaid fees and costs from the violator pursuant to the code enforcement ordinance:

Officer Activity Date Time Rate Amount MS Total hours l l/16/20-4/14/21 2.37 $33.l l $ 78.47 MS Complaint Intake inc MS Initial Investigation inc MS Initial inspection inc MS Violator conference n/a MS Telephone conference n/a MS Hearing attendance inc MS Notice of violation preparation inc MS Notice ofhearing preparation inc MS Photo/exhibit preparation inc MS Re-inspection inc

Additional Costs and Supplies: n/a Postage n/a Notices (mailed and posted) n/a Long Distance Telephone n/a Photographs me Vehicle Mileage n/a

Total Costs \.\ $ 78.47

Melody Sanderso~ Affiant Officer

Page 1 of2

C:\Users\msanderson\Desktop\letters and forms\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx Sworn to and subsc . ed bef9re me this 3 Dday of /l~a I~ 2;;» by Melody Sanderson, who is pers9 ally kn wn to me OR __ produced ______as identification. I

.\~QY As Jennifer De La Rosa NOTARY PUBLIC § .,, ~STATE OF FLORIDA - .~ Comm# GG346655 .i;,~cn'l1'o Expires 6/19/2023

Page 2 of2

C:\Users\msanderson\Desktop\letters and forms\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH

vs. CASE No.: 20-CE-11380

JOHN DESJARDINS Citation No.: 3096M Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: John Desjardins 4165 Apalogen Road AND 2675 10th Court Philadelphia, PA 19129 Vero Beach, Florida 32960

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: Failure to Correct Violation(s).

Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. D Other (describe): ______

Page 1 of 2

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By: ~ . y;;;{c.;?{ SerriPhllo,BoardClerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Sherri Phifo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form BEFORETHECODEENFORCEMENTBOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: DeJardins Case#: 21-CE-11380 Violators 2675 10th Court

Violation Address Vero Beach. FL 32960

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-COMPLIANCE - CONTINUING VIOLATION

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has not complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has failed to correct the cited violation by the date given in the citation and has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance of the citation.

\.. ,Affiant -P-ri_n_t_N_am_e_:_M_e_.,f.,....o-dy_S_a_n_de_r_s_on___

Sworn to and subscribed before mz::hi~ of __,_f_ ,, fM____.,.__...... vcfh~i_____ 2oi.- by Melody Sanderson, who is _per~onal!y .!g).@ful to me OR n/a produced ______as 1dennfi€atron:--

~1>RY 4 Jennifer De La Rosa NOTARY PUBLIC §11:r %STATE OF FLORIDA ,.• ')) r Comm# GG346655 '.r. 'I:," "-1-ce ,~" Expires 6/19/2023 VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEME:NT ~ITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3096M / 20-CE-11380

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on January 07, 2021 at 7:30 am

Name: John Desjardins 4165 Apalogen Road of: Philadelphia, PA 19129

at (violation address): 2675 10th Court in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Shed installed without Code ComP-liance Certification or building_P-ermit.

Violation of code provision(s): ~(a)(b)(9) (b), 22-181, 22-106

Facts constituting violation: After-the-fact Code ComP-liance Certification must be obtained (imP-lication attached). After- the-fact building_P-ermit must be obtained from the IRC Building DeP-artment. CIVIL PENALTY: $150.00 PAY BY DATE: 01/21/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 01/21/2021. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 01/07/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: Ci!Y. Clerk's Office, Ci!Y. Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000029 Certified Mail Receipt: 70191640000214454145

__;-) ORIGIN AL VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT DMSION CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION 1055 20th Street I Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 1430M / 18-CE-8642 STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on June 20, 2018 at 8:12 am

Name: John Desjardins 4165 Apalogen Road of: Philadelphia, PA 19129 at (violation address): 2675 10th Court in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: New roof without a P-ermit.

Violation of code provision(s): 22-181, 22-106 (§.)

Facts constituting violation: New roof installed without Rermit. Permit has since been issued. CIVIL PENALTY: $100.00 PAY BY DATE: 07/17/2018 rA REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 07/17/2018. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 07/03/2018 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

Date:------Signature of Individual

VIOLATOR COPY - 18-000822 Certified Mail Receipt: 70163010000017872513 BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs. Desjardins CASE NUMBER: 20-CE- 11380

VIOLATORS

AFFIDAVlT OF COSTS STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson, being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and infonnation, depose and state that I am a code enforcement or police officer for the City of Vero Beach, Florida and I have personal knowledge of and certify that the City of Vero Beach has incurred the following administrative and prosecution costs in investigation, enforcement, testing or monitoring relating to the above-styled code enforcement case against the named violator and that the City of Vero Beach is entitled to recovery ofsaid fees and costs from the violator pursuant to the code enforcement ordinance:

Officer Activity Date Time Rate Amount MS Total hours 1/7/21-4/14/21 1.69 $ 33.11 $ 55.95 MS Complaint Intake inc MS Initial Investigation inc MS Initial inspection inc MS Violator conference n/a MS Telephone conference n/a MS Hearing attendance inc MS Notice of violation preparation inc MS Notice ofhearing preparation inc MS Photo/exhibit preparation inc MS Re-inspection inc

Additional Costs and Supplies: n/a Postage n/a Notices (mailed and posted) $7.05 Long Distance Telephone n/a Photographs inc Vehicle Mileage n/a

Total Costs $ 63.00

Melody Sanderson, ' Affiant Officer

Page 1 of 2

C:\Users\msanderson\Desktop\letters and forms\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx Sworn to and subscijbed bef

,._lli~RY& Jennifer De La Rosa - s: NOTARY PUBLIC ../1! 5STATE OF FLORIDA "Ji. ~·~c Dmm# GG346655 1 Wee 1~ Expires 6/19/2023

Page 2 of2

C:\Userslmsanderson\Desktop\letters and forms\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs. CASE No.: 21-CE-11468

1901 33Ro AVENUE, LLC / SUNSHINE CORPORATE FILINGS, LLC Citation No.: ------3174M Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: 1901 33 rd Avenue, LLC / Sunshine Corporate Filings, LLC 1215 Castaway Boulevard AND 1901 3yd Avenue Vero Beach, Florida 32963 Vero Beach, Florida 32960 AND 7901 4th Street, Suite 300 St. Petersburg, Florida 33702 YOU ARE HERBY NOTIFIED that a hearing is scheduled before the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Vero Beach ("Board") regarding the above-styled code enforcement case as follows: DATE and TIME: April 14th 2021 at 1 :30 P.M.

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: Failure to Correct Violation(s).

Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. D Other (describe): ______

Page 1 of 2

2020 NOH Form Enforcement Board may take necessary and appropriate action in the matter(s) and enter an order(s) accordingly.

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By:~ ·~ erriPhilo, lfoardclerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form BEFORETHECODEENFORCEMENTBOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: 1901 33rd Avenue LLC Case#: 21-CE-11468 Violators 1901 33 rd Avenue

Violation Address Vero Beach, FL 32963

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-COMPLIANCE -CONTINUING VIOLATION

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has not complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has failed to correct the cited violation by the date given in the citation and has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance ofthe citation.·

----~-"-=-..~______,,,Affiant Print Name: Melo~anderson

Sworn to and subscribed before me th&·~ - da of_ _,~~.....=\/.,..J_,,__,_____ 2oJ../_ by Melody Sanderson, who is person lly kno to me OR n/a produced ------as identifica ·

n Expires: VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3174M / 21-CE-11468

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on February: 05, 2021 at 7:25 am

Name: 1901 33rd Ave LLC 1215 Castaway Bv of: Vero Beach, FL 32963 at (violation address): 1901 33rd Avenue in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Public nuisance: stagnant swimmingJ~ool.

Violation of code provision(s): 38-31 (QL(Z)

Facts constituting violation: Pool needs to be chemicallY. treated and continuous filtration P-rovided to restore water claritY. or water removed and P-OOI covered. CIVIL PENALTY: $50.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/02/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 03/02/2021. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 02/16/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: Ci!Y. Clerk's Office, CitY. Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000180 Certified Mail Receipt: 70182290000036959528

Q OR ~GI NAl VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3174M / 21-CE-11468

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on Februa[Y. 05, 2021 at 7:25 am

Name: 1901 33rd Ave LLC / Sunshine Corporate Filings LLC 7901 4th Street, Suite 300 of: St Petersburg, FL 33702 at (violation address): 1901 33rd Avenue in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Public nuisance: stagnant swimmingJ~ool.

Violation of code provision(s): 38-31 (Q)_{Z)

Facts constituting violation: Pool needs to be chemicallY. treated and continuous filtration Rrovided to restore water claritY. or water removed and ROOI covered. CIVIL PENALTY: $50.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/02/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 02/16/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: Ci!Y. Clerk's Office, Ci!Y. Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING 15 WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000180 Certified Mail Receipt: 70182290000036959528

[] ORIGINAL BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH

vs. CASE No.: 21-CE-11441

JOHN MARTIN MONKO, JR. Citation No.: 3172M Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: John Martin Monko, Jr. 456 Holly Road AND 422 Conn Way Vero Beach, Florida 32963 Vero Beach, Florida 32963

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: []I Failure to Correct Violation(s). Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. D Other (describe): ______

Page 1 of 2

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By: Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3172M / 21-CE-11441

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on November 05, 2020 at n/a

Name: Monko, John Martin Jr 456 Holly Road of: Vero Beach, FL 32963

at (violation address): 442 Conn Way_ in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Permit reguired.

Violation of code provision(s): 22-181, 22-106

Facts constituting violation: Failure to obtain building_Rermit for the enclosed structural wall and the AC mini-SRlit sy_stem installed. CIVIL PENALTY: $50.00 PAY BY DATE: 02/26/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 02/26/2021. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 02/15/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: Ci!y_ Clerk's Office, Ci!y_ Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000151 Certified Mail Receipt: PROPERTY POSTED

[J ORIGIN AL BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: Monko Case#: 21-CE-11441 Violators 442 Conn Way

Violation Address Vero Beach. FL 32963

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-COMPLIANCE - CONTINUING VIOLATION

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has not complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has failed to correct the cited violation by the date given in the citation and has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance of the citation.

______,Affiant Print Name: Melody Sanderson

Sworn to and subscribed before m<:)l1-4 day of _Ma._._a_...... 2ci1l_ by Melody Sanderson, who is p~rsona1yn6wn to me£Y-"------OR n/a produced ------as ideirtilk~t10n.

;\IIRY 4 Jennifer De La Rosa NOTARY PUBLIC '00~STATE OF FLORIDA ~--"l! · Comm# GG346655 'tr. 'b' 14-ce ,g1 Expires 6/19/2023 BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs.

Monko CASE NUMBER: 21-CE-11441

VIOLATORS

AFFIDAVIT OF COSTS STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson, being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a code enforcement or police officer for the City of Vero Beach, Florida and I have personal knowledge of and certify that the City of Vero Beach has incurred the following administrative and prosecution costs in investigation, enforcement, testing or monitoring relating to the above-styled code enforcement case against the named violator and that the City ofVero Beach is entitled to recovery ofsaid fees and costs from the violator pursuant to the code enforcement ordinance:

Officer Activity Date Time Rate Amount MS Total hours 2/11/2 J-4/14/21 1.3 5 $ 33. I I $ 44.70 MS Complaint Intake inc MS Initial Investigation inc MS Initial inspection inc MS Violator conference n/a MS Telephone conference n/a MS Hearing attendance inc MS Notice ofviolation preparation inc MS Notice ofhearing preparation inc MS Photo/exhibit preparation me MS Re-inspection inc

Additional Costs and Supplies: n/a Postage n/a Notices (mailed and posted) n/a Long Distance Telephone n/a Photographs inc Vehicle Mileage n/a

Total Con $ 44.70

Melody Sanderson, Affiant Officer

Page I of2

C:\Users\msanderson\Desktoplletters and forms\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx Sworn to and s~-rI6edbefpre me this3Q_ day of ~l{o v<-M. 2ci}j_ by Melody Sanderson, who is pers nally kn

N Pr . C ion })Jo: .\~YAs Jennifer De La Rosa M mis o Expires: NOTARY PUBLIC -!lj~STATE OF FLORIDA i ....,-)! •- Comm# GG346655 ·.r. 'b 114-ce ,~"' Expires 6/19/2023

Page 2 of2

C:\Userslmsanderson\Desktop\letters and fonns\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx INDIAN RIVER COUNTY/CITY OF VERO BEACH BUILDING DIVISION 1801 27 th Street, Vero Beach, FL 32960 772 226-1260

2017 6th Edition FBC, IRC Ordinance Chapter 403, CVB Ordinance Chapter 22 NOTICE OF VIOLATION

Notice Date: 11/5/2020 To: MONKO JOHN MARTIN JR 456 HOLLY ROAD VERO BEACH FL 32963 Address of building or structure: 442 CONN WAY VERO BEACH, FL Tax I.D: 32403200005016000010.0

NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the above referenced building or structure is hereby declared UNDER NOTICE OF VIOLATION by the undersigned Building Official.

THE FOLLOWING LISTED CONDITIONS have been documented and determined to have rendered the building or structure IN VIOLATION of the provisions of the Florida Building Code, and/or the Code of Ordinances of Indian River County or the City of Vero Beach: 1. Alterations & mechanical installation completed outside scope of permit # 2020091184 2. AC mini-split system installation without a permit. 3. Front entry enclosed without a permit

THE FOLLOWING ACTION IS REQUIRED and ordered by the Building Official and must be commenced within or completed by the time specified: 1. Apply for an after the fact permit through the Indian River County Building Department. Permit must be issued, posted on jobsite, and inspected. Work must be complete by licensed contractors.

BUILDING DEPARTMENT REQUIREMENTS: EITHER: Correct the violation: All required permits must be secured and the repair work commenced within (30) days from the date you receive this notice and continue to completion with all violation conditions completely corrected and the building or structure brought into full compliance with the above referenced codes within 180 days; OR: Demolish the building or structure: All required permits must be secured and the demolition work commenced within (30) days from the date you receive this notice and continue to completion with the property brought into full compliance with the above referenced codes within 60 days. IF YOU FAIL TO TAKE THE REQUIRED ACTION within the time stated, the Building Official may cause demolition to be done by Indian River County or the City of Vero Beach and all costs incurred will be charged against the property and the owner of record. Such costs of demolition shall be a special assessment lien against the subject property, which lien may be foreclosed and the subject property sold at public sale to satisfy the lien. NOTICE OF RIGHT TO APPEAL: Any person or entity having any legal interest in the subject property may appeal this Notice and Order to the Indian River County Construction Board of Adjustments and Appeals or the City of Vero Beach Board of Building Appeals. Such appeal shall be in writing and filed with the Building Official within thirty (30) days from the date of service of this notice and must contain the following information: (l) Identification of the building or structure concerned by street address or legal description; (2) A statement identifying the legal interest of each appellant; (3) A statement identifying the specific order or section being appealed; (4) A statement detailing the issues on which the appellant desires to be heard; and (5) The legal signature of all appellants and their official mailing address. FAILURE TO APPEAL IN THE TIME SPECIFIED WILL CONSTITUTE A WAIVER OF ALL RIGHTS TO AN ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING.

Further information regarding this Notice and Order may be obtained by contacting the undersigned Building Official at 772-226-1260 or at the Building Department Office in the Indian River County Administration Building, 1801 27th Street, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. By Investigator: Scott McAdam, CBO, MCP David Checchi Building Official

BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs. CASE No.: 21-CE-11490

CHRISTOPHER DEAN AND JENNIFER STEPANEK Citation No.:_3_1_96~M~-- Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: Christopher Dean and Jennifer Stepanek 2635 Victory Boulevard Vero Beach, Florida 32960

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: Failure to Correct Violation(s).

Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. D Other (describe): ______

Page 1 of 2

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3196M / 21-CE-11490

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on February: 22, 2021 at 8:15 am

Name: Stepanek, Christopher Dean & Jennifer 2635 Victory Blvd of: Vero Beach, FL 32960 at (violation address}: 2635 Victory: Boulevard in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Trees removed without a P-ermit.

Violation of code provision(s ): 72.41, 72.44

Facts constituting violation: Pine trees removed without germit from the Vero Beach Planning Degartment. Mitigation maY. be reguired, CIVIL PENALTY: $550.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/10/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 03/10/2021. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 02/24/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: Ci!Y. Clerk's Office, Ci!Y. Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:------Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000211 Certified Mail Receipt: 70182290000036959559

ZJ ORIGI NAL BEFORETHECODEENFORCEMENTBOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: Stepanek Case #: 21-CE-11490 Violators 2635 Victory Bv

Violation Address Vero Beach, FL 32960

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-COMPLIANCE- CONTINIDNG VIOLATION

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has not complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has failed to correct the cited violation by the date given in the citation and has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance ofthe citation.

Print Name:

Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Affiant, Melody Sanderson, who was duly sworn, and who states that he/she has read the foregoing Affidavit ofNon-Compliance and that the contents are true and correct. Sworn to and subscribed before me~_IB---'.~f{u t1_ d 2(1:)/ by Melody Sanderson, who is . per~ al~y kno tci me OR n/a produced ------as 1dent1 a ..

e: i sion No.: mmission Expires: BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs. Stepanek CASE NUMBER: 2 L-CE-11490

VIOLATORS

AFFIDAVIT OF COSTS STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson, being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a code enforcement or police officer for the City of Vero Beach, Florida and I have personal knowledge of and certify that the City of Vero Beach has incurred the following administrative and prosecution costs in investigation, enforcement, testing or monitoring relating to the above-styled code enforcement case against the named violator and that the City ofVero Beach is entitled to recovery ofsaid fees and costs from the violator pursuant to the code enforcement ordinance:

Officer Activity Date Time Rate Amount MS Total hours 2/24/21-4/ I 4/21 1.35 $ 33.1 l $ 44.70 MS Complaint Intake inc MS Initial Investigation inc MS Initial inspection inc MS Violator conference n/a MS Telephone conference n/a MS Hearing attendance inc MS Notice ofviolation preparation inc MS Notice ofhearing preparation inc MS Photo/exhibit preparation inc MS Re-inspection inc

Additional Costs and Supplies: n/a Postage $6.96 Notices (mailed and posted) n/a Long Distance Telephone n/a Photographs inc Vehicle Mileage n/a

Total Costs ' $51.66 Melody Sanderson, ' Affiant Officer

Page I of2

C:\Users\msanderson\Desktop\letters and forms\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx Sworn to and subs~ore me this 5'vday of / /CNvci< _ 2rJJ../ by Melody Sanderson, who is personcilly lqlown to me OR __ producedi ______as identification. ~ /

N c;1r-R Y& Jennifer De La Rosa p . V c:> NOTARY PUBLIC ~ml£_., { ~STATE OF FLORIDA C ion o.: "':.r. .~ Comm# GG346655 7 9140 7/ion Expires: 4-cE ' Expires 6/19/2023

Page 2 of2

C:\Users\msanderson\Desktop\letters and forms\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARf\ OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs. CASE No.: 21-CE-11483

827 22ND STREET, LLC / FRED PIUMELLI, AGENT Citation No.:_3~1~89~M~-- Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: 827 22nd Street, LLC / Fred Piumelli, Agent 2300 5th A venue, Ste 100 AND 827 22nd Street Vero Beach, Florida 32960 Vero Beach, Florida 32960

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: G Failure to Correct Violation(s). Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. D Other (describe): ______

Page 1 of 2

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By~ ~ tlerriPhilo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3189M / 21-CE-11483

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on February: 23, 2021 at 7:20 am

Name: 827 22nd Street LLC / Fred Piumelli, Agent 2300 5th Ave Ste 100 of: Vero Beach, FL 32960 at (violation address): 827 22nd Street in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Failure to obtain Code ComP-liance Certification or building_P-ermit.

Violation of code provision(s): ~(a)(b)(9) (b), (10) (a)

Facts constituting violation: New Raver driveways and walkways and fence reguire Code ComRliance Certification from the Planning DeRartment (9RRlication attached). Fence reguires Rermit from the Indian River County Building DeRartment. ComRleted Code ComRliance aRRlication and fee can be droRRed off at the Utility DeP-artment drive through. CIVIL PENALTY: $100.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/09/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 03/09/2021. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 02/23/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: CitY. Clerk's Office, CitY. Hall. 1053 20th Place. Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays. Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000203 Certified Mail Receipt: PROPERTY POSTED

J ORIGI NAL VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 2978M / 20-CE-11246

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on SeP-tember 22. 2020 at 8:08 am

Name: 183514Th Avenue LLC 2300 5th Avenue of: Vero Beach, FL 32960

at (violation address): 2207 7th Avenue in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Permits reguired.

Violation of code provision(s): 38.04, 72.04

Facts constituting violation: Signs installed without a P-ermit and trees removed at 2545 Indian River Bv installed without a P-ermit. CIVIL PENALTY: $50.00 PAY BY DATE: 10/23/2020 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 10/16/2020. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 10/09/2020 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: CitY. Clerk's Office, CitY. Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays. Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:------Signature of Individual

VIOLATOR COPY - 20-001052 Certified Mail Receipt: 70182290000036973425 BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: 827 22nd St LLC / Fred Piumelli. Agent Case#: 21-CE-11483 Violators 827 22nd Street

Violation Address Vero Beach. FL 32960

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-COMPLIANCE - CONTINUING VIOLATION

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and infonnation, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has not complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has failed to correct the cited violation by the date given in the citation and has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance of the citation.

------~ Affiant Print Name: Melody Sanderson

Sworn to and subscribed before met~ ~ - of ~Attvd\ 2~/ by Melody Sanderson, who is ~er~nal~y kn to me OR n/a produced ------as entificat n. 1

~0,~RY A& Jennifer De La Rosa NOTARY PUBLIC 3 ,--0! _, §STATE OF FLORIDA ":..t;:

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs.

837 22nd St LLC / Fred Piumelli. Agent CASE NUMBER: 2 l-CE-11483

VIOLATORS

AFFIDAVIT OF COSTS STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson, being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a code enforcement or police officer for the City of Vero Beach, Florida and I have personal knowledge of and certify that the City of Vero Beach has incurred the following administrative and prosecution costs in investigation, enforcement, testing or monitoring relating to the above-styled code enforcement case against the named violator and that the City of Vero Beach is entitled to recovery of said fees and costs from the violator pursuant to the code enforcement ordinance:

Officer Activity Date Time Rate Amount MS Total hours 2/23/21-4/14/21 1.86 $ 33.11 $ 61.58 MS Complaint Intake inc MS Initial Investigation inc MS Initial inspection inc MS Violator conference n/a MS Telephone conference n/a MS Hearing attendance inc MS Notice ofviolation preparation inc MS Notice of hearing preparation inc MS Photo/exhibit preparation inc MS Re-inspection inc

Additional Costs and Supplies: n/a Postage n/a Notices (mailed and posted) n/a Long Distance Telephone n/a Photographs inc Vehicle Mileage n/a

$ 61.58

Melody Affiant Officer

Page 1 of2

C:\Userslmsanderson\Desktop\letters and forms\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx Sworn to and subsc~fo~e me this 30 day of {V/a v-Jr 2riJ:./ by Melody Sanderson, who is person¥Jy knm-~n to me OR __ produced ______as identification. (__/

l),~RY -4,r Jennifer De La Rosa

Q-~ - NOTARY PUBLIC ;STATE OF FLORIDA --·.: c- .~ Comm# GG346655 .s;~ce 19"1-o Expires 6/19/2023

Page 2 of2

C:\Userslmsanderson\Oesktop\letters and fonns\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH

vs. CASE No.: 21-CE-11491

JUSTE ROBENSON, LLC / COTTRELL TAX & ACCOUNTING, LLC, AGENT Citation No.: 3197M THE AMERICAN PAVERS CONTRACTORS. INC./ ELIAS MENDOZA AGENT Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: Juste Robenson, LLC / Cottrell Ta & Accounting, LLC, Agent/ The American Pavers Contractors, Inc. / Elias Mendoza, Agent 5147 Castello Drive AND 5075 Highway AlA Naples, Florida 34103 Vero Beach, Florida 32963 AND 9355 W. Maiden Court Vero Beach, Florida 32963

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: G Failure to Correct Violation(s). Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. D Other (describe): ______

Page 1 of 2

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By: ~ . Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3197M / 21-CE-11491

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on Februarv~, 2021 at 6:53 am

Name: Robenson Juste LLC / Cottrell Tax & Accounting LLC, Agent 5147 Castello Drive of: Naples, FL 34103 at (violation address): 5075 Highwav. A1A in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Trees removed without a P-ermit.

Violation of code provision(s): 72.41, 72.44

Facts constituting violation: Palm trees rn_) removed without Rermit from the Vero Beach Planning DeRartment. Mitigation may: be reguired. CIVIL PENALTY: $800.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/10/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 02/24/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: Ci!Y. Clerk's Office, Ci!Y. Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:.______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000212 Certified Mail Receipt: 70182290000036959566

DORIGIN AL BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of Robeson Juste LLC /Cotrell Tax and Accounting LLC. Agent and The American Pavers Contractors Inc/ Elias Mendoza. Agent Case#: 21-CE-11491 Violators 5075 Highway AlA

Violation Address Vero Beach. FL 32963

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-COMPLIANCE - CONTINUING VIOLATION

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF lNDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has not complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has failed to correct the cited violation by the date given in the citation and has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance of the citation.

------'------"------'Affiant Print Name: Melody Sanderson

Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Affiant, Melody Sanderson, who was duly sworn, and who states that he/she has read the foregoing Affidavit ofNon-Cornpliance and that the contents are true and correct. . /; Sworn to and subsc1ibed before ;e-tlus)!.'~fJiv1 vlfi,_ 2ocx( by Melody San1erson, who is pe; sonally ~A'Vll to me OR n/a produced -----~~------as iden i.f.icati.o~

Printfy me: Comn!lission No.: My Commission Expires: BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH

vs. CASE No.: 21-CE-11492

JUSTE ROBENSON, LLC / COTTRELL TAX & ACCOUNTING, LLC, AGENT Citation No.: 3198M THE AMERICAN PAVERS CONTRACTORS, INC. / ELIAS MENDOZA AGENT Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: Juste Robenson, LLC / Cottrell Ta & Accounting, LLC, Agent I The American Pavers Contractors. Inc. / Elias Mendoza, Agent 5147 Castello Drive AND 5075 Highway Al A Naples, Florida 34103 Vero Beach, Florida 32963 AND 9355 W. Maiden Court Vero Beach, Florida 32963

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: G Failure to Correct Violation(s). G Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. D Other (describe): ______

Page 1 of 2

2020 NOH Form Enforcement Board may take necessary and appropriate action in the matter(s) and enter an order(s) accordingly.

POSTPONEMENTS: No request for postponement of the hearing will be considered unless such request is made in writing, stating good reason for the requested postponement, and received by the board clerk at least five (5) days prior to the date set for the hearing at City Clerk's Office, City Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960.

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By: ~ , Elf:'?[5 Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3198M / 21-CE-11492

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on February~, 2021 at 6:53 am

N Robenson Juste LLC / Cottrell Tax & Accounting LLC and The American Pavers Contractors ame: Inc / Elias Mendoza, Agent 5147 Castello Drive of: Naples, FL 34103

at (violation address): 5075 HighwaY-A1A in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Pavers installed without Code ComP-liance Certification from the Vero Beach Planning DeP-artment.

Violation of code provision(s): 64.05 (11).

Facts constituting violation: After-the-fact Code ComRliance Certification must be obtained from the Vero Beach Planning DeRartment. CIVIL PENALTY: $50.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/10/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 02/24/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: Cit}! Clerk's Office, CitY- Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:------Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000213 Certified Mail Receipt: 70182290000036959573

;J ORIGI NAL BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: Robeson Juste LLC /Cotrell Tax and Accounting LLC Agent and The American Pavers Contractors Inc / Elias Mendoza, Agent Case #: 2 l-CE-11492 Violators 5075 Highway AlA

Violation Address Vero Beach, FL 32963

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-COMPLIANCE-CONTINUING VIOLATION

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has not complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has failed to correct the cited violation by the date given in the citation and has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance of the citation.

~-';-::.-----~'Affiant ___Print Nan1e:::::L__ Melody Sanderson

Sworn to and subscribed before me this ~ , of Jtt vc.f. 20 c:J/ by Melody Sanderson, who is pe~;~ _,_to....,._,.~m-e--0-Rtl ___n/_a_ produced

, ;;;;:identihca 10n.

, m rune: l~-? ;.~1ss10n· No.: 'J Commission Expires: BEFORETHECODEENFORCEMENTBOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

CITY OF VERO BEACH vs. ROBENSON JUSTE LLC CASE NUMBER: 2 l-CE-11492

VIOLATORS

AFFIDAVIT OF COSTS STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson, being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and infonnation, depose and state that I am a code enforcement or police officer for the City of Vero Beach, Florida and I have personal knowledge of and certify that the City of Vero Beach has incurred the following administrative and prosecution costs in investigation, enforcement, testing or monitoring relating to the above-styled code enforcement case against the named violator and that the City ofVero Beach is entitled to recovery of said fees and costs from the violator pursuant to the code enforcement ordinance:

Officer Activity Date Time Rate Amount MS Total hours 2/24/21-4/14/21 1.86 $ 33.11 $ 61.58 MS Complaint Intake inc MS Initial Investigation inc MS Initial inspection inc MS Violator conference n/a MS Telephone conference n/a MS Hearing attendance inc MS Notice ofviolation preparation inc MS Notice of hearing preparation inc MS Photo/exhibit preparation inc MS Re-inspection inc

Additional Costs and Supplies: n/a Postage $6.96 Notices ( mailed and posted) n/a Long Distance Telephone n/a Photographs inc Vehicle Mileage n/a

Total Co'-_ $ 68.54

Melody Sande'rson, Affiant Officer

C:\Userslmsanderson\Desktop\letters and forms\Affidavits\Costs 2018.docx Sworn to and subse·~efore me this ..3!_ day of IVla.xt~ 2cd:..i by Melody Sanderson, who is perso Hy nown to me OR __ produced ______as identification.

;\!>.RY -4 Jennifer De La Rosa NOTARY PUBLIC -oo~STATE OF FLORIDA i Comm# GG346655 .~Nee ,cfi~· Expires 6/19/2023

Page 2 of2

CITY OF VERO BEACH

vs. CASE No.: 21-CE-11417

DAN R. CORNELL Citation No.:----'3"-'-1-=--31-'-'-M:.:,____ Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: Dan R Cornell 1802 Ocean Drive Vero Beach, ,Florida 32963

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: Failure to Correct Violation(s).

Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. D Other (describe): ______

Page 1 of 2

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FORTHECODEENFORCEMENTBOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By: ~ - - ~ Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3131M / 21-CE-11417

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on JanuafY. 26, 2021 at 3:19 P-m

Name: Cornell Dan R 1802 Ocean Drive of: Vero Beach, FL 32963

at (violation address): 1802 Ocean Drive in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Sewer use restrictions.

Violation of code provision(s): 78-83 (2)_(1,)

Facts constituting violation: Commencing January_j_, 2016, each owner of a Rrivate wastewater disRosal SY.Stem shall cause the RUmR out of the SY.Stem on a regular freguencY. not to exceed eveni: five Y.ears. In addition to the RUmR out, the owner shall have a licensed seRtic tank contractor Rerform an insRection of the private wastewater disRosal SY.stem. For each such insRection the seRtic tank contractor shall comRlete a seRtic tank P.UmRing insRection reRort in the form .imecified bY. the director and file such regort with the ci!Y. within ten business daY.s. Please have the necessa[Y. insRection comRleted. The insRection form is available for download from www.covb.org. Please contact the Water and Sewer Degartment at 772 978 5220 if Y.OU have any_guestions. CIVIL PENALTY: $50.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/10/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 01/26/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: CiW. Clerk's Office, CiW. Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000088 Certified Mail Receipt: 70182290000036959542 [J ORIGIN AL BEFORETHECODEENFORCEMENTBOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: Cornell Case#: 21-CE-11417 Violators 1802 Ocean Drive

Violation Address Vero Beach, FL 32963

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-COMPLIANCE - CONTINUING VIOLATION

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge of and certify that the above-named violator has not complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has failed to correct the cited violation by the date given in the citation and has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance of the citation.

------~-----~Affiant Print Name: Melody Sanderson

Sworn to and subscribed before me this ~=3" 1 ay of _ f'v_ lO_ lf_C._h____ 20~ by Melody Sanderson, who is personally known to me OR n/a produced ------as identification. BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOAR[' OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 2orH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH

vs. CASE No.: 21-CE-11506

BARRY SIMON Citation No.:---'3"-'1-=-31.:....:.M:..;____ Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: Barry Simon 1665 30th A venue Vero Beach, Florida 32960

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: D Failure to Correct Violation(s). [!j Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. D Other (describe): ______

Page 1 of 2

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 By: ~~ Sherri Philo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3212M / 21-CE-11506

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on March 08, 2021 at 8:38 am

Name: Barry Simon 1665 30th Avenue of: Vero Beach, FL 32960

at (violation address): 1655 30th Avenue in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Oak tree removed without a uermit.

Violation of code provision(s): 72.41, 72.43, 72.44

Facts constituting violation: After-the-fact tree Rermit must be obtained (f!RRlication attached). Mitigation maY. be reguired. CIVIL PENALTY: $300.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/23/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 03/23/2021. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 03/09/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

RIGHT TO HEARING OR TO PAY REDUCED PENALTY: You must either file a written request for a hearing to contest this citation OR pay the reduced civil penalty specified above at: CitY. Clerk's Office, Cit}! Hall, 1053 20th Place, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS (excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays) OR YOUR RIGHT TO A HEARING IS WAIVED AND DEEMED YOUR ADMISSION OF THE VIOLATION. Make checks payable to "City of Vero Beach." Do not mail cash! If correction of the violation is required above, the timely filing of a request for a hearing will toll the accrual of continuing violation penalties pending outcome of the hearing. Your right to pay the reduced penalty specified above is waived if you elect to contest the citation and, if after the hearing you are found to be responsible for the violation, a civil penalty of up to $500 ($1,000 for contracting violations) may be assessed against you for each day of violation, plus administrative and enforcement costs.

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000250 Certified Mail Receipt: 70182290000036959634

ZJ ORIGINAL BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: Simon Case Number:21-CE-11506 Violators 1665 30th Avenue Violation Address Vero Beach, FL 32960

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-PAYMENT OF CIVIL PENALTY

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and infommtion, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has complied with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has corrected the cited violation by the date given in the citation and the above-named violator has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance ofthe citation. The civil penalty assessed on the citation has not been paid.

,Affiant -P-ri_n_tN_a_m_e_:_M_e~l-o.._.cfy_S_an_d_e_r_so_n___

Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Aftiant, Melody Sanderson, who was duly sworn, and who states that he/she has read the foregoing Affidavit ofNon-Compliance and that the contents are true and correct.

Sworn to and subscribed before me this i~1'---day of_~D1Ah~~cb.,_=··~---20d-{ by Melody Sanderson, who is _personally known to me OR n/a produced ------as identification.

Julianne Poteat NfARY PUBLIC NOTARY PUBLIC Print Name: -~,o-.JN-...e_ R,-k-~-t "" STATE OF FLORIDA Comm# GG350726 Commission No.: ~-3so·7~(., • E Expires 7/19/2023 My Commission Expires: •Ii'l I2...°? BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 1053 20TH PLACE VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960 Telephone (772) 978-4640

CITY OF VERO BEACH

vs. CASE No.: 21-CE-11500

RYAN C. SCARPA Citation No.:--'3=2=-06=-M'-'---- Violator

NOTICE OF HEARING

TO: Ryan C. Scarpa 1512 E. Camino Del Rio Vero Beach, Florida 32963

LOCATION OF HEARING: VERO BEACH CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 1053 20th PLACE, VERO BEACH, FL

PURPOSE OF HEARING: Failure to Correct Violation(s).

Failure to Pay Civil Penalty and/or Costs. D Other (describe): ______

Page 1 of 2

PLEASE GOVERN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.

FOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD

Date: March 31, 2021 s~·7 ~ SerriPhilo, Board Clerk

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Page 2 of 2

2020 NOH Form VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 1055 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 No. 3206M / 21-CE-11500

STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF VERO BEACH,

In the name of the City of Vero Beach, Florida: The undersigned officer certifies that he/she has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that on March 04, 2021 at 9:25 am

Name: Scarpa, Ryan C 1512 E Camino Del Rio of: Vero Beach, FL 32963

at (violation address): 1512 East Camino Del Rio in the City of Vero Beach, Florida committed the following civil offense: Drivewav. installed without Code ComP-liance Certification or building_P-ermit.

Violation of code provision(s): 64.06 (g_)_(2_)_(g.)

Facts constituting violation: After-the fact Code ComQliance Certification must be obtained from the Vero Beach Planning DeQartment. Once that has been obtained a building_1:1ermit must be obtained from the Indian River Coun!y Building DeQartment. CIVIL PENALTY: $50.00 PAY BY DATE: 03/19/2021 REPEAT VIOLATION

CORRECTION REQUIRED BY: 03/19/2021. This is a correctable violation and must be corrected by the date specified. Each day that the violation remains uncorrected after the date specified is a separate violation and additional civil penalties and costs may be assessed against you without issuance of additional citations. You must contact the issuing officer and request re-inspection once the violation is corrected or if you need additional time to correct the violation. If you do not correct the violation by the date specified the City may also take action to correct the violation and assess the costs of correction plus administrative fees as a lien against the property on which the violation was corrected in addition to any lien for civil penalties or costs.

Issued by: Sanderson Date Issued: 03/05/2021 Department: VBPD Code Enforcement Telephone: 7729784561

Date:______Signature of Individual

CLERK COPY - 21-000241 Certified Mail Receipt: 70182290000036959597

J OAIGl r •Al BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH, FLORIDA

In the Matter of: Scarpa Case #: 21-CE-11500 Violalors 1512 E Camino Del Rio

Violation Address Vero Beach. FL 32963

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-COMPLIANCE - CONTINUING VIOLATION

STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF JNDIAN RIVER

I, Melody Sanderson , being first duly sworn, upon personal knowledge and information, depose and state that I am a Code Enforcement Officer for the Vero Beach Police Department Code Enforcement Division and I have personal knowledge ofand certify that the above-named violator has not complied ·with the code enforcement citation served in this case in that the violator has failed to correct the cited violation by the date given in the citation and has not filed a request for a hearing to contest the issuance ofthe citation.

------~ Affiant Print Name: Melody Sanderson

Sworn to and subsc1ibed before me this J.5t1-day of __N'\~_f-1~·=e-b~--- 20...:;}:L by Melody Sanderson, who is personally known to me OR n/a produced ------as identification.

Julianne Poteat NOTARY PUBLIC Print Name: GU-\n.L Pc-kd iii STATE OF FLORIDA Commission No.: G--G· 350 7:;,...(., Comm# GG350726 • E Expires 7/19/2023 My Commission Expires: , J 1e; J.)..3, f Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case 118-CE-9533 1825 14th Avenue $250 No 13/27/19 I I n 2 19-CE-9417 615 Catalina Street $1,000 owed to Building No 3/27/19 YES Dept. owes City costs of recording and attorney fees 3 18-CE-9253 CASE CLOSED 2300 5th Avenue $34.48 No 2/22/19 7/15/19 YES - CASE CLOSED 2019 2019 4 18-CE-9288 7 /31/19 PAID 2300 5th Avenue $34.48 No 2/22/19 7/15/19 7/31/19 PAID SATISFACTION SATISFACTION AND AND RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED 7/31/19 / CASE CLOSED 7/31/19 / CASE CLOSED 5 18-CE-9289 7 /31/19 PAID 2300 5th Avenue $34.48 No 2/22/19 7/15/19 7/31/19 PAID SATISFACTION SATISFACTION AND AND RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED 7/31/19 / CASE CLOSED 7/31/19 / CASE CLOSED 6 18-CE-9319 1941 33rd Avenue $250 No 3/27/19 7 18-CE-9345 / Found in 700 22nd Place, Suite 2C $75.53 yes 3/27/19 7/29/19 COMPLIED AND PAID PRIOR compliance, COMPLIED TO ORDER BEING RECORDED AND PAID PRIOR TO / CASE CLOSED Release of lien ORDER BEING RECORDED / CASE CLOSED- Release of lien 8 18-CE-9137 Satisfaction 1103 21st Street $150 / Paid penalty only on Yes/ $50 x 7 days = $350 12/20/19 yes Satisfaction and release and release of Code 1/14/19, owes continuing owed to the City, plus costs of Code Enforcement Lien Enforcement Lien issued penalties and costs issued November, 2019 - November, 2019 - CASE CASE CLOSED CLOSED 9 18-CE-9154 615 Catalina Street $1,000 owed to Building No 1/22/19 12/17/19 YES Dept. owes City costs of I Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case recording and attorney fees - Paid County $1,000 - STILL OWES CITY $112 (recording & atty fees) 10 18-CE-9216 7/31/19 PAID 2300 5th Avenue $34.48 No 2/22/19 7/15/19 7/31/19 PAID SATISFACTION SATISFACTION AND AND RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED 7/31/19 / CASE CLOSED 7/31/19 / CASE CLOSED 11 18-CE-8919 Release of 736 21st Street $50 No 11/19/18 3/24/20 Yes - recorded on 4/13/20 Lien issued 4/13/20 - Case closed 12 18-CE-8938 1825 14th Avenue $150 No 12/28/18 13 18-CE-8964 Release of 736 21st Street $50 No 12/28/18 3/24/20 Yes - recorded on 4/13/20 lien issued - Case closed 14 18-CE-8976 - PAID/ CASE 2312 Vero Beach $50 plus $112.62 No 1/22/19 1/26/21 Yes - Recorded on 2/5/21 CLOSED Avenue Enforcement Costs= $162.62 15 18-CE-9035 901 21st Street $50 No 12/28/18 16 18-CE-9050 901 21st Street $50 YES 1/22/19 17 18-CE-9067 - Satisfaction 1103 21st Street $100 No 12/28/18 Nov. 2019 YES -Satisfaction and release and release of Code of Code Enforcement Lien Enforcement Lien issued issued November, 2019 - November, 2019 - CASE CASE CLOSED CLOSED 18 18-CE-8839 Release of 736 21st Street $50 No 11/13/18 3/24/20 Yes - recorded on 4/13/20 Lien issued - Case Closed Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case 19 18-CE-8697 Release of 1740 21st Street $50 No 10/29/18 7/22/19 YES - CASE CLOSED 2019 Lien issued - Case closed 20 18-CE-8702 3766 Ocean Drive $50 No 10/29/18 SATISFACTION AND RELEASE SATISFACTION AND OF LIEN ISSUED 2019 - CASE RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED CLOSED - Case filed in CEB 2019 - CASE CLOSED - cabinet 21 18-CE-8775 /PAID/ CASE 3766 Ocean Drive $500 YES 10/29/18 8/13/19 YES, AUGUST, 2019 - CASE CLOSED - CLOSED - Filed in CEB cabinet I 22 18-CE-8789 / PAID 2208 Buena Vista $2,050 No 12/28/18 1/04/21 PAID SATISFACTION AND SATISFACTION AND Boulevard RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED 1/19/21 - Case filed back in 1/19/21 CEB cabinet 23 18-CE-8400 2201 Bonita Avenue $SO YES 10/12/18 24 18-CE-8420 - complied - 1806 24th Avenue $0 No/ Board Order was 11/27/18 No fee to be Case closed recorded because of no charged confirmation of compliance / No Fee for recording or Attorney/ case closed - see folder 04/09/19 25 18-CE-8255 414116th Street, $500 owed to Building No 4/23/18 YES Building 12, Units 1205, Dept. owes City costs of 1209, and 1210 recording and attorney fees 26 17-CE-7966 524 21st Street $SO Paid Penalty only/ No longer continuing/ 1/29/18 owes continuing penalties Owes $37,250 plus costs and costs - complied on 1/3/20 per Code Officer - $37,250 Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case 27 17-CE-8014 17th Street and USl / $50 No Not recorded / 1015 Commerce Avenue Mr. Pickard is (address for homeless Homeless shelter) 28 17-CE-8071 524 21st Street I $50 No 2/26/18 29 17-CE-7840 1265 Olde Doubloon $500 owed to Building No 12/28/17 YES Drive Dept. owes City costs of recording and attorney fees 30 17-CE-7630 1991 34th Avenue $500 owed to Building No 8/11/17 YES Dept. owes City costs of recording and attorney fees 31 17-CE-7330 - PAID - CASE 3766 Ocean Drive $500 + $448.91 YES - PAID AND COMPLIED - 8/18/17 9/1/20 9/1/20 - MONEY WAS WIRED CLOSED - FILED IN CEB Enforcement costs CASE CLOSED TO ACCOUNTING - SEE EMAIL CABINET- SATISFACTION IN FOLDER/ PAID AND RELEASE OF LIEN - $440,562.26 - FILED IN CEB 9/1/20 CABINET - SATISFACTION AND RELEASE OF LIEN - 9/1/20 32 17-CE-7535 1260 29th Street $11,650 No 5/18/18 33 16-CE-7158 1941 33rd Avenue $100 No 8/11/17 34 16-CE-7189 - COMPLIED 2628 USl $21,050 - $paid 11,180.50 No 4/1/19 February, 2020 and Yes AND PAID - CASE CLOSED and did $10,000 in capital paid in capital improvements {21,180.50} - improvements/ (costs) CASE CLOSED/ SEE FILE 35 16-CE-6914 17th Street and USl $SO No 10/21/16 36 19-CE-9650 PAID 2208 Buena Vista $50 + $27.81 Enforcement ORDER FINDING 9/20/19 1/4/21 PAID SATISFACTION AND SATISFACTION AND Boulevard I Cost CORRECTION AND CEASING RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED CONTINUING PENALTIES 1/19/21 - Case filed back in 1/19/21 - Case filed back AND TO PAY CEB cabinet in CEB cabinet 37 19-CE-9548 2716 Laurel Drive $8,175.81 plus costs 5/3/19 38 19-CE-9649 / PAID 2208 Buena Vista $50 + $40.24 Enforcement Yes 5/3/19 1/4/21 PAID SATISFACTION AND SATISFACTION AND Boulevard Cost RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED 1/19/21 - Case filed back in 1/19/21 CEB cabinet 39 19-CE-9526 1715 29th Avenue $100 Yes 4/29/19 40 18-CE-8936 Release 2706 Atlantic Boulevard, $7,433.54 - paid in full No 4/29/19 yes - Release recorded on recorded on June 17, #31 June 17, 2020 - CASE CLOSED 2020 - CASE CLOSED 41 16-CE-6513 1962 14th Avenue $50 No 5/23/16 42 16-CE-6432 - Going back 2626 US1 $50 Yes 5/23/16 before the Board in April, 2021 43 16-CE-6651 1405 14th Avenue $100 & $59.10 cost of Yes 10/26/16 enforcement 44 16-CE-6842 1506 14th Court $50 Yes 10/26/16 45 16-CE-6138 2076 Nevarra Avenue $750 & cost of enforcement No 3/7/16 $141.38 46 15-CE-5971 1844 26th Avenue $50 & cost of enforcement Yes 12/14/15 RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED - $62.02 RECORDED ON 6/2/20 - FORECLOSURE - CASE FILED BACK IN CEB FILES 47 15-CE-6011 223418th Avenue $50 & continuing penalties No 1/29/16 of $6,700 Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case 48 15-CE-000678 1631 Camino Del Rio $1,500 owed to Building No 7/31/15 YES Dept. owes City costs of recording and attorney fees I 49 15-CE-5554 2245 27th Avenue $50 No 6/22/15 so 15-CE-5637 1531 32nd Avenue $50 & cost of enforcement Yes 1/5/17 $61.77 51 14-CE-4871 SR 60 / between 35th $50 & cost of enforcement Yes 11/17/14 Avenue and 36th $26.53 Avenue/ 2520 Buena Vista Boulevard 52 14-CE-5148 3405 21st Street $50 & cost of enforcement No 12/22/14 $34.83 53 13-CE-4238 826 22nd Street $50 & cost of enforcement No 2/17/14 $62 .70 54 13-CE-4441 1146 21st Street, Suite B $50 No 3/20/14 55 13-CE-4457 1415 38th Avenue $500 & cost of enforcement No 7/17/14 $45.99 56 14-CE-2805 2103 17th Street $50 & cost of enforcement No 3/20/14 $95.24 57 13-CE-3632 414116th Street, Unit $500 owed to Building No 3/21/13 YES 307 I 2735 6th Street Dept. owes City costs of recording and attorney fees 58 13-CE-3630 414116th Street, Unit $500 owed to Building No 3/21/13 YES 102 / 14000 101st Dept. owes City costs of Street, Fellsmere recording and attorney fees 59 13-CE-3719 NE, SW, and NW $50 & cost of enforcement No 6/20/13 quadrants of 17th Street $63 .87 Code Penalties I Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case and USl / 1790 SW 119th Terrace, Miramar, Florida 60 13-CE-3978 2326 Bonita Avenue $50 + cost of enforcement No 4/25/14 and 11/04/19 Yes - Satisfaction and release $77.74 + $8,450 of Release recorded of Code Enforcement Lien continued penalties on 11/27/19 issued November, 2019 - CASE CLOSED 61 13-CE-4027 1146 21st Street $50 & cost of enforcemeont No 10/24/13 $50.34 62 13-CE-3984 3405 21st Street $50 No 11/22/13 63 12-CE-3330 2604 19th Place $3,600 & cost of No 4/19/13 enforcement $89.95 64 12-CE-3557 414116th Street, Unit $500 owed to Building No 2/20/13 YES 1204 Dept. owes City costs of recording and attorney fees 65 12-CE-3523 414116th Street, Unit $88.21 cost of enforcement No 4/19/13 105 66 12-CE-3507 414116th Street, Unit $84.82 No 4/19/13 1601 67 Resolution 2008-29 - 1925 22nd Avenue $11,066.81 + Interest No 10/9/08 68 Contract 4688 / Nuisance 1925 22nd Avenue $371.03 + Interest No 11/16/12 Abatement Lien - t I 69 15-CE-6145 1925 22nd Avenue $5,648.68 (was reduced No 12/28/17 from $56,468.25) 70 09-CE-455 1925 22nd Avenue $3,611.14 No 12/15/09 71 07-CE-799 1925 22nd Avenue $6,750 & $251 cost of No 2/22/08 enforcement Code Penalties Bldg I ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case 72 14-CE-4695 PAID 2208 Buena Vista $5,150 & $92.53 cost of No 4/30/15 1/4/21 PAID SATISFACTION AND SATISFACTION AND Boulevard enforcement RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED 1/19/21 - Case filed back in 1/19/21 - Case filed back CEB cabinet in CEB cabinet 73 Contract 4565 / Nuisance 2208 Buena Vista $2,295.58 + Interest No 9/19/14 11/12/20 PAID SATISFACTION AND Abatement Lien File on Boulevard RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED top of File Cabinet 11/24/20 75 15-CE-5698 Filed back in 2208 Buena Vista $50 No Was not recorded 6/1/15 Not needed - Order was not Code Enforcement Folder Boulevard / paid penalty recorded / case closed 76 16-CE-6398 703 Holly Road Fine Reduced by the City No 1/29/18 Council from $194,451.03 to $32,478.68 for ALL CASES 77 13-CE-3789 703 Holly Road Fine Reduced by the City No 5/30/14 Council from $194,451.03 to $32,478.68 for ALL CASES 78 12-CE-3110 703 Holly Road Fine Reduced by the City No 9/24/12 Council from $194,451.03 to $32,478.68 for ALL CASES 79 16-CE-6393 703 Holly Road Fine Reduced by the City No 2/26/18 Council from $194,451.03 to $32,478.68 for ALL CASES 80 13-CE-4007 703 Holly Road Fine Reduced by the City No 3/25/14 Council from $194,451.03 to $32,478.68 for ALL CASES 81 11-CE-3010 2035 18th Street $50 No 3/9/12 (violation address) (Home address 1808 Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case 21st Avenue) - Animal at I large 82 11-CE-2978 2101 Indian River $150 No 2/29/12 Boulevard, Suite 105 83 12-CE-3242 1995 U.S.1 $50 No 11/9/12 I 84 12-CE-3203 2625 34th Avenue $50 + $114.50 cost of No 9/24/12 enforcement I 85 12-CE-3202 2625 34th Avenue $50 + $88.42 cost of No 9/24/12 enforcement 86 Contract 4363 Nuisance 1966 27th Avenue $1889.47 + Interest No 6/13/12 abatement lien/ In vault 87 11-CE-2743 1966 27th Avenue $3250 No 4/4/12 88 19-CE-9499 Case closed 2032 US Highway 1 $50 No 5/22/19 Yes Yes/ Case closed 89 11-CE-2409 1825 31st Avenue $50 + $9,750 continued No 8/22/12 penalty+ $169.81 cost of enforcement 90 10-CE-1461 PAID 2136 34th Avenue $30,691.58 (Council denied No 4/28/11 YES - Release recorded on $30,691.58 / Release of request for lien reduction 7/15/19 / CASE CLOSED Lien issued / CASE 11/16/18) This is the total CLOSED amount due including attorney fees and recording costs 91 10-CE-1250 2602 19th Place $50 + $4,900 continued No 2/7/12 penalty +361.97 cost of enforcement Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case 92 09-CE-919 2038 18th Street $110.28 cost of No 6/17/10 enforcement (was $160.28 - $50 that was paid) 93 09-CE-669 CASE CLOSED 2022 USl (1735 6th $500 owed to Building No 10/27/09 paid per Bldg. Dept. YES August, 2019 / CASE YES Avenue, Apt. #2) Dept. owes City costs of on 7/30/19 CLOSED recording and attorney fees 94 09-CE-038 827 19th Place $50 No 5/22/09 95 07-CE-245 1426 43rd Avenue $249 No 1/16/08 I I 96j07-CE-114 j2166 33rd Avenue II $178 jNo js/7/07 97 06-CE-631 511 Bay Drive (location $500 No 1/4/07 YES of violation) violator address 500 Farmers Market Road, Bay 15, Ft. Pierce, Florida 98 06-CE-704 827 19th Place $2,000 + $424.26 cost of No 12/6/07 enforcement 99 06-CE-744 1228 24th Street $50 continuing (failed to yes 03/09/11 comply with compliance agreement and Board assessed continuing penalties as of January 1, 2011 100 05-CE-894 1926 40th Avenue $5,000 No 7/13/06 I 101 19-CE-9737- Satisfaction 1103 21st Street $250 + $48.86 cost of No 6/17/19 Nov. 2019 yes - Satisfaction and release and release of Code enforcement of Code Enforcement Lien Enforcement Lien issued issued November, 2019 - CASE CLOSED Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case November, 2019 - CASE CLOSED 102 18-CE-8800 1228 24th Street, #10 $2,450 No 6/17/19 103 19-CE-9601 - paid & 958 20th Place Cost of Enforcement $45.86 No 5/22/19 7/29/19 paid & release of lien issued - release of lien issued - case closed - case closed 104 19-CE-9743 paid & 958 20th Place Cost of Enforcement $45.86 No 6/21/19 7/29/19 paid & release of lien issued - release of lien issued - case closed - case closed - 105 19-CE-9782 paid & 958 20th Place Cost of Enforcement $40.24 No 6/21/19 7/29/19 paid & release of lien issued - release of lien issued - case closed - case closed - 106 18-CE-9357 Satisfaction 1103 21st Street $250 plus cost of No 3/27/19 Nov. 2019 Satisfaction and release of and release of Code enforcement $40.08 Code Enforcement Lien Enforcement Lien issued issued November, 2019 - November, 2019 - CASE CASE CLOSED CLOSED 107 98-CE-02 517 Camelia Lane $1,000 No 3/2/98 YES 108 99-CE-173 1085 Andrella Way, $1,000 No 1/25/00 YES Wave 6, Castaway Cove 109 99-CE-189 1916 Ocean Drive and $1,500 No 1/25/00 YES 1926 Ocean Drive 110 99-CE-190 790 Bougainvillea Lane $1,000 No 1/25/00 YES 111 19-CE-9814 1825 14th Avenue $500 No 8/5/19 112 19-CE-10171 Satisfaction 2020 Delmar Avenue Recording costs and City No 9/20/19 PAID COSTS $112 Satisfaction and Release of and Release of Lien Attorney fees ON 1/21/20 / Lien issued / case closed 2/4/20 / filed in CEB cases Code Penalties I Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case issued / case closed / PREPARING RELEASE I filed in CEB cases I OF LIEN I 113 19-CE-10137 601 Flamevine Lane $1,500 ($500 each No 9/20/19 YES violation) 114 19-CE-9097 97 Royal Palm Pointe $100 YES - CASE COMPLIED AND 9/27/19 yes - Release recorded on PAID REDUCED CIVIL June 17, 2020 - CASE FILED PENALTY OF $112 BACK IN CEB DRAWER 115 19-CE-9549 2716 Laurel Drive $76,558.60 plus costs 116 19-CE-10327 1346 16th Avenue $50 No 12/10/19 117 19-CE-10281 772 21st Street $50 No 12/10/19 118 19-CE-10260 816 Cypress Road $50 No 12/10/19 119 19-CE-10359 686 21st Street $SO No 12/10/19 120 19-CE-10363 686 21st Street $50 No 12/10/19 121 19-CE-10360 686 21st Street $50 Yes 12/10/19 122 19-CE-10390 812 Dahlia Lane $150 No 12/27/19 123 19-CE-10428 2716 Laurel Drive $50 & costs $55.96 No 12/27/19 124 19-CE-10415 1260 29th Street costs $34.61 Yes $100 per day 12/27/19 125 19-CE-10409 1546 14th Court $50 No 12/27/19 126 19-CE-10111 2726 22nd Street Paid $50 penalty and costs, Yes 1/3/20 however has not complied - $50 per day continuing penalties 127 19-CE-10417 2512 Atlantic Boulevard $100 penalty, $61.58 costs Yes 2/10/20 and continuing penalties of $100 per day Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case 128 19-CE-10470 - PAID CASE 524 21st Street $4,900 - PAID - CASE No Not recorded yet 3/2/20 CLOSED - FILED BACK IN CLOSED - order ceasing CEB DRAWER cont. penalties to be recorded on 3/18/20 129 19-CE-10511 2716 Laurel Drive $100, $33.44 costs No 3/4/20 130 19-CE-10413 1305 29th Street $90.23 costs and continuing Yes 4/29/20 penalties of $SO per day 131 18-CE-8789 City 2208 Buena Vista $2,440.73 No No Contract or 11/12/20 PAID SATISFACTION AND abatement bill filed in Boulevard Resolution/ just RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED this case file the bill for 1/19/21 abatement so this was not recorded 132 98-CE-01 635 Live Oak Road and $500 No 3/19/98 189 Huber Drive, Ft. Pierce, Florida 34957 133 20-CE-10760 Homeless - Living at the $50 No Not recorded per Source /1015 Commerce City Attorney in Avenue - violation that this occurred at McDonalds / gentleman is 1925 USl homeless 134 20-CE-10764 3655 Flamingo Drive $50 YES 6/25/20 135 20-CE-10614 2716 Laurel Drive $100 and $46.35 No 6/30/20 136 20-C E-10696 1956 34th Avenue $50 No 6/30/20 137 20-CE-10674 1015 Commerce Avenue $50 No 6/30/20 Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# :, Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case 138 20-CE-10641 766 Fiddlewood Road $50 YES - SHERRI HAS FILE -- 7/23/20 SATISFACTION & RELEASE OF PAID $10,650.00 /PAID LIEN ISSUED - RECORDED ON $10,650.00 / PAID 62.00 DECEMBER 12, 2020 BALANCE -SEE FILE/ SATISFACTION & RELEASE OF LIEN ISSUED 139 20-CE-10826 2716 Laurel Drive $50 Yes 8/25/20 140 20-CE-10780 CASE 1433 and 1435 24th Initial penalty of $100 paid - No - complied prior to 9/10/20 NO MONEY OWED YES - RECORDED 3/9/21 CLOSED - CASE FILED IN Street continuing penalties continuing penalties - CASE CEB FILE commenced on 05/22/20 CLOSED 141 20-CE-10779 CASE 2354 and 2356 15th Initial penalty of $100 paid - No - complied prior to 9/10/20 NO MONEY OWED YES - RECORDED 3/9/21 CLOSED - CASE FILED IN Avenue continuing penalties continuing penalties - CASE CEB FILE commenced on 05/22/20 CLOSED 142 20-CE-10742 CASE 1443 and 1445 24th Initial penalty of $50 paid - No - compied prior to 9/10/20 NO MONEY OWED YES - RECORDED 3/9/21 CLOSED - CASE FILED IN Street continuing penalties continuing penalties - CASE CEB FILE commenced on 04/30/20 CLOSED 143 19-CE-10543 15 Bonanza Lane Initial penalty of $50 paid - Yes 9/10/20 continuing penalties commenced on 01/01/20 144 19-CE-10557 19 Malibu Drive Initial penalty of $50 paid - Yes 9/10/20 continuing penalties commenced on 01/03/20 145 20-CE-10548 5 Aero Lane Initial civil penalty of $50.00 Yes 9/21/20 - continuing penalties commenced on December 31,2019 146 20-CE-10628 - RELEASE 525 Banyan Road lnnitial civil penalty of $50 - Yes 9/21/20 12/11/20 Yes - CASE CLOSED OF LIEN ISSUED, CASE continuing penalties Code Penalties

II Bldg ID Case# ,, Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid II Release of Lien Issued Dept Case CLOSED AND FILED IN commenced on May 18, CEB FILE CABINET 2020 147 20-CE-10967 3500 Ocean Drive Initial $50 civil penalty paid Yes - ceased as of October 10/13/20 2/25/21 - Still owes Paid 5,050 Still owes ca fees - Has continuing penalties 31, 2020 - penalties ran recording and ca and recording that began on July 22, 2020 from 7/22/20 through fees 10/30/20 - owes $5.050 plus recording - Paid 5,050 still owes recording 148 20-CE-11076 2715 Laurel Drive Initial $50 civil penalty - Yes 11/13/20 $58.60 enforcement costs - continuing penalties of $50 per day commenced on September 26, 2020 149 20-CE-11065 - Complied 2050 11th Avenue Cost of recording and No 11/23/20 on 12/17/21- Still owes Attorney fees $18.50 Order costs I $75 City Attorney and $18.50 to record release once all is paid in full 150 20-CE-11086 4407 Sunset Drive $50 No 11/30/20 151 20-CE-11123 - PAID/ 2312 Vero Beach $50 plus $34.61 No 11/30/20 1/26/21 Yes - 2/3/21 / Recorded on CASE CLOSED Avenue 2/25/21 152 20-CE-10955 1314 20th Street Paid initial civil penalty - Yes 12/10/20 However, not in compliance and continuing civil penalties are accruing from August 11, 2020 153 20-CE-10950 2665 12th Avenue Paid initial civil penalty - Yes 12/10/20 However, not in compliance Code Penalties Bldg ,, ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case and continuing civil penalties are accruing from August 11, 2020 154 20-CE-10951 2665 12th Avenue Paid initial civil penalty - Yes 12/10/20 However, not in compliance and continuing civil penalties are accruing from July 28, 2020 155 20-CE-11287 - Going to 1110 Royal Palm $100 inicial civil penalty and Yes 12/28/20 Board in April to find in Boulevard costs and continuing civil compliance - Sherri has penalties are accruing from file Nobember 20, 2020 156 20-CE-11288 - sherri has 4701 Bethel Creek Drive, $50 initial civil penalty, Yes 12/28/20 Paid $50 initial file - going before the 32963 costs ,and civil penalties are penalty only on Board in April to find in accruing from November 2/4/21 compliance and to cease 20, 2020 - Paid initial civil continuing penalties penalty of $50 ONLY on 2/4/21 157 20-CE-11103 6 Lamplighter Lane $50 initial civil penalty, cost Yes 1/8/21 of enforcement of $72.51 and continuing penalties began on October 8, 2020 158 20-CE-11171 1941 33rd Avenue $50 initial civil penalty, cost ceased 1/8/21 of enforcement of $55.96 and continuing penalties began on October 2, 2020 - ceased 2/16/21 - Code Penalties Bldg

ID Case# 11 Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case 159 20-CE-11169 1941 33rd Avenue $50 initial civil penalty, cost Yes 1/13/21 of enforcement of $50.32 and continuing penalties began on October 1, 2020 160 20-CE-11198 2406 19th avenue $50 plus costs No 1/20/21 n 161 20-CE-11282 23 Fleetwood Drive $50 plus cost of No 1/20/21 enforcement of $61.25 and costs 162 20-CE-11119 1876 41st Avenue Continuing penalties of $SO Ceased on 2/16/21 1/25/21 per day began on October 21, 2020 - Ceased on 2/16/21 / $5.900 163 20-CE-11306 2716 Laural Drive $150 initial civil penalty - Yes 2/5/21 continuing penalties of $150 per day began on December 3, 2020 164 20-CE-11255 1545 20th Avenue $50 plus continuing Yes 2/15/21 penalties of $50 per day that began on November 27,2020 165 20-CE-11270 1616 24th Avenue $50 plus continuing Yes 2/15/21 penalties of $50 per day that began on November 6, 2020 166 20-CE-11278 1901 33rd Avenue $50 plus cost of $44.70 plus Yes 2/15/21 continuing penalties of $50 per day began on November 17, 2020 Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid :1 Release of Lien Issued Dept Case

1168 20-CE-11256 1836 31st Avenue $89.40 costs plus fees due No 3/2/21 to the City 169 20-CE-11305 2716 Laurel Drive $50 penalty plus fees due to No 3/2/21

the City I 170 20-CE-11258 1413 25th Avenue $50 penalty, $44.70 costs No 3/2/21 plus fees due to the City I 171 20-CE-11310 1935 5th Avenue $50 penalty, $57.22 costs, Yes 3/2/21 continuing penalties of $50 per day commenced on December 4, 2020 and fees due to the City 172 20-CE-11324 2716 Laurel Drive $50 penalty plus fees due to No 3/2/21 the City I 173 20-CE-11297 2665 12th Avenue $100 penalty, $62.90 costs No 3/2/21 and fees due to the City I 174 20-CE-11377 1346 16th Avenue $150 and fees due to the Yes 3/9/21 City 175 20-CE-11290 1933 23rd Avenue $50 and feees due to the Yes 3/9/21 City I 176 20-CE-11350 725 Royal Palm $50.32 costs and fees due Yes 3/22/21 Boulevard to the City 177 20-CE-11359 Right of way/ 21st $100 and fees due to the No 3/22/21 Street and 6th Avenue/ City violator's address - 1401 Highway AlA 178 20-CE-11360 right of way of Ocean $100 and fees due to the No 3/22/21 Drive and Beachland City Code Penalties Bldg ID Case# Address Amount Due Plus Costs Continuing Penalties Date Recorded Date Paid Release of Lien Issued Dept Case Boulevard / violator's address - 1401 Highway I AlA 179 21-CE-11400 1413 25th Avenue Board did not request initial Yes/ $100 per day 3/2/21 (Please note that case $100 penalty 21-CE-11440 is an abatement for this property and is filed with case 21-CE-11400)