Answers to Questions Prior to Hearing

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Answers to Questions Prior to Hearing Hon Mike Nahan MLA Treasurer; Minister for Energy; Citizenship and Multicultural Interests Ourref: 48-13528; 48-13527 Hon Ken Travers MLC Chairman Estimates and Financial Operations Committee Parliament House PERTH WA 6000 Attn: Mr Mark Warner Committee Clerk Dear Mr Travers QUESTIONS PRIOR TO 2014-15 ANNUAL REPORT HEARINGS - SYNERGY AND HORIZON POWER In response to the Committee's letter of 20 October 2015, please find attached responses to the questions prior to hearing, in respect of Synergy and Horizon Power's 2014-15 annual report. Yours sincerely DR MIKE NAHAN MLA TREASURER Att. CC: Hon Peter Collier MLC Minister representing the Minister for Energy in the Legislative Council 1 9 NOV 2015 Level 13, Dumas House, 2 Havelock Street, West Perth, Western Australia 6005 Telephone: +61 8 6552 5700 Facsimile: +61 8 6552 5701 Email: [email protected] ESTIMATES AND FINANCIAL OPERATIONS COMMITTEE 2014/15 ANNUAL REPORT HEARINGS QUESTIONS PRIOR TO HEARING Synergy Annual Report 2014/15 Hon Robin Chappie asked: 1) Page 5 under "Our Business," I ask: a) How many people are employed at each of your nine power stations? Answer: Employees (2014-15) Cockbum Power Station 19 Kalgoorlie Gas Turbine Mungarra Gas Turbine 5 Pinjar Power Station Kwinana Power Station (includes Kwinana Gas Turbines) 11 Geraldton Gas Turbine 0 Worsley (South West Co-Generation Joint Venture) 0 (operated by Worsley Alumina) Muja Power Station 337 Collie Power Station 1 FTE + contractors as required. How many people are employed at each of your nine wind farms? Answer: Employees (2014-15) Albany Wind Farm Bremer Bay Wind-Diesel System 4 Esperance Wind Farms Hopetoun Wind-Diesel System Coral Bay Wind-Diesel System 2 Denham Wind-Diesel System 2 Kalbarri Wind Farm 1 Mumbida Wind Farm 6 How many people are employed at your one solar farm? Answer: Employees (2014-15) Greenough River Solar Farm 1.5 2) Page 21 under "Delivering energy" you describe two station transformers failing and a partial cooling tower collapse at Muja Power Station, I ask: a) Have these issues been rectified? Answer: Yes. The collapsed section of the cooling tower has been repaired and is back in service. b) If yes at (a), how much money was spent rectifying these issues? Answer: $6,224,277 c) How much electricity has the units in Muja A and B produced this year? Answer: Total energy sent out from 1 July 2014 to 20 June 2015 (Mwh) Muja G1 14,113.91 Muja G2 46,693.57 Muja G3 55,252.25 Muja G4 99,490.18 d) What is the current value of the Muja Power Station? Answer: This information is not required under accounting and reporting procedures and is not evaluated by Synergy. e) Due to ongoing failures, the extraordinary amount of money that has been spent on this plant in the past five years, and the age of the facility, are options being considered for the selling and/or mothballing of this facility? Answer: No f) If yes to (e), what options are being considered? Answer: N/A g) If no to (e), why not? Answer: The Muja Power Station plays a vital role in providing base load electricity generation within the South West Interconnected System and has proven itself during significant periods of 2015 to be the only generation unit capable of supplying energy to the Great Southern Region of Western Australia. Without Muja AB generating during the periods where Western Power transformers failed, the Great Southern Region would not have had a reliable supply of electricity. 3) Page 31 under "Emissions to air," I ask a) How much C02e has been emitted by each of your power stations, wind farms and solar farm? Answer: Total Emissions (2014-15) C02e tonnes Cockburn Power Station 260,410 Pinjar Power Station 376,980 Kwinana Power Station (includes Kwinana Gas Turbines 602,490 Mungarra Gas Turbine 82,910 Geraldton Gas Turbine 30 Worsley (South West Co-Generation Joint Venture) 623,890 Kalgoorlie Gas Turbine 1,750 Muja Power Station 3,744,290 Collie Power Station 2,024,280 TOTAL 7,717,030 Wind and solar farms do not emit C02e. 4) Page 52, under "Statement of Comprehensive Income," I ask: a) How much money did Synergy spend on fuel for their generation facilities alone? Answer: $368.7 million b) From which companies did Synergy purchase its fuel? Answer: Synergy has long-standing fuel supply contracts with Premier Coal and NorthWest Shelf Gas. c) How much money did Synergy pay to each of these companies? Answer: The terms and conditions relating to volumes and pricing of contracts are commercial in confidence.
Recommended publications
  • Ancillary Service Costs: Spinning Reserve, Load Rejection Reserve and System Restart Costs (Margin Values and Cost LR) for 2021/22 Determination
    Ancillary service costs: Spinning reserve, load rejection reserve and system restart costs (Margin values and Cost_LR) for 2021/22 Determination 31 March 2021 D227225 Economic Regulation Authority Economic Regulation Authority Level 4, Albert Facey House 469 Wellington Street, Perth WA 6000 Telephone 08 6557 7900 Email [email protected] Website www.erawa.com.au This document can also be made available in alternative formats on request. National Relay Service TTY: 13 36 77 © 2021 Economic Regulation Authority. All rights reserved. This material may be reproduced in whole or in part provided the source is acknowledged Ancillary service costs: Spinning reserve, load rejection reserve and system restart costs (Margin values and Cost_LR) for 2021/22 – Determination Economic Regulation Authority Contents Executive summary ............................................................................................................. 2 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................... 6 1.1 Requirements for the ERA’s determination ......................................................... 7 2. What are ancillary services? ....................................................................................... 9 2.1 Spinning reserve service.................................................................................. 9 2.1.1 How the cost of spinning reserve is recovered from the market .............................. 9 2.2 Load rejection reserve service .......................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Environmental Protection Authority ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AUTHORITY
    Environmental Protection Authority ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AUTHORITY ANNUAL REPORT 2002 • 2003 Contents: TRANSMITTAL TO THE MINISTER ..........................................................................I CHAIRMAN’S OVERVIEW .......................................................................................... 1 MEMBERS........................................................................................................................ 4 MAJOR ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES.......................................................................... 8 Sustainability................................................................................................................... 8 Natural Resource Management....................................................................................... 9 State of the Environment Reporting ............................................................................. 11 Broadscale Clearing of Native Vegetation for Agriculture .......................................... 11 Forest Management....................................................................................................... 12 Perth’s Water Resources............................................................................................... 12 Peel-Harvey................................................................................................................... 13 National Water Quality Management Strategy: Australian and New Zealand Guidelines for Fresh and Marine Water Quality (Guideline No 4) and Australian Guidelines for
    [Show full text]
  • GRIFFIN ELECTRICITY PTY LTD Collie B Power Station
    GRIFFIN ELECTRICITY PTY LTD Collie B Power Station (Collie B) Proponent’s Response to Submissions April 2005 Table of Contents 1 SUMMARY OF SUBMISSIONS RECEIVED........................................................ 1 2 NOISE................................................................................................................... 3 3 SURFACE WATER AND GROUNDWATER ....................................................... 7 4 FLORA AND FAUNA ......................................................................................... 12 5 ATMOSPHERIC EMISSIONS ............................................................................ 13 6 GREENHOUSE ISSUES .................................................................................... 29 7 LIQUID AND SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL.......................................................... 38 8 SOCIAL AND HERITAGE ISSUES.................................................................... 51 9 OTHER ISSUES ................................................................................................. 52 10 GLOSSARY........................................................................................................ 56 11 BIBLIOGRAPHY ................................................................................................ 59 Collie B Power Station – Responses to Issues raised in Submissions Page i List of Tables Table 1 – Summary of Noise Levels ...................................................................................3 Table 2 - Collie Power Station Sound Power Level............................................................4
    [Show full text]
  • University of Southern Queensland Facility of Health, Engineering And
    University of Southern Queensland Facility of Health, Engineering and Sciences Low Load Frequency Support Capability - Collie Power Station A dissertation submitted by Alan Christian Cornish In fulfillment of the requirements of ENG4111 and 4112 Research Project towards the degree of Bachelor of Power Engineering (Honours) Submitted: October 2020 Abstract Energy markets around the world are in a transitional phase, where wind and solar generation are penetrating the markets at unforeseen rates. The desire to decarbonise emissions associated with power generation in Australia, is seen as the first step in meeting our commitments to the Paris Climate Change Agreement. This has had a significant effect upon the electricity grid within Western Australia. The high volume of renewable generation is creating grid instability during times of low demand. This is a result of fluctuations in generation due to the variability of wind and solar. Network strength is no longer as robust because of the loss of synchronous inertia that was behind a grid mainly powered by thermal machines. Many coal fired stations are attempting to become more flexible and change from base load to cyclical operation to assist counteract the irregular nature of wind and solar generation. Collie Power Station is one such station, attempting to improve its operational flexibility. One aspect is the desire that the station move from a current minimum load setpoint of 130MW to 105MW (generated) to assist the station remain dispatched at low load rather than desynchronising it from the grid. The aim of this dissertation is to model the frequency support capability at 105MW to determine if the station continues to provide frequency support for the grid.
    [Show full text]
  • 2014-11-25 QWON Power Stations
    LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL C1379 QUESTION WITHOUT NOTICE (Of which some notice has been given) Tuesday, 25 November 2014 Hon Robin Chapple to the Leader ofthe House representing the Minister for Energy. Please provide a summary of all active power stations in Western Australia, including: age; capacity profile; fuel and/or mine type; number of employees; whether it is on or off the grid; and the closure schedule. I thankthe Hon. Member for some notice of this question. I table the attached document. The Public Utilities Office has relied on the Independent Market Operator for data concerning generators on the SWIS and has reported the maximum sent out capacity offered by these facilities into the Balancing Market, as of 25 November 2014. These figures may differ slightly from the number of capacity credits awarded and from facility nameplate capacity owing to factors including parasitic load and ambient temperature. For NWIS and NIS facilities, various sources have been used as there is no single definitive list of facilities. The nature of mining operations has not been investigated. The Public Utilities Office does not have access to data on the number of employees or on the closure schedule of power stations. The expected plant life of power stations is variable, a function of maintenance regimes and commercial considerations. ATTACHMENT TO QWN C1379 . 'I . " ~ -1J&1t~-n i ~,'l;(, : 'C' 4\", lTt ~A','~:'l';"(~.i~ffil!. " l]f,:,gl '~. l) , '. lifP'\1 ~, , •. 'fg~~t:t.: :' (~~.~:~n.', . ~ j - llll' ~!l!i:jliiW~tlilit~r~QJ\l1~~t~ii~Sys:t~m;(~~),~'•.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix E. Energy Price Limits Based on Aero-Derivative Gas Turbines Using Alternative Gas Price Forecast Appendix F
    2015 Review of the Energy Price Limits for the Wholesale Electricity Market IMO Final Report 18 May 2015 Contents 1. Background .................................................................................................................. 3 2. Summary of the draft report ........................................................................................ 3 2.1 Overview ......................................................................................................... 3 2.2 Methods for estimating gas price distributions ............................................... 3 2.3 IMO’s preliminary view .................................................................................... 4 2.4 Results in the draft report ............................................................................... 4 3. Public consultation process ....................................................................................... 5 4. Changes from the draft report .................................................................................... 5 5. Conclusions .................................................................................................................. 6 Document details Report Title: 2015 Review of the Energy Price Limits for the Wholesale Electricity Market – IMO Final Report Release Status: Public Confidentiality Status: Public domain Independent Market Operator Level 17, 197 St Georges Terrace, Perth WA 6000 PO Box 7096, Cloisters Square, Perth WA 6850 Tel. (08) 9254 4300 Fax. (08) 9254 4399 Email: [email protected]
    [Show full text]
  • A Journey Towards Facilitating Multiple-Use of Cockburn Sound and Owen Anchorage Stage One Parts I, II And
    A journey towards facilitating Multiple-use of Cockburn Sound and Owen Anchorage Stage One Parts I, II and III Background paper for the Cockburn Sound Management Council Prepared in consultation with the Multiple-use Support Team 2009 ISBN 1 921094 18 4 A Journey towards Facilitating Multiple-use of Cockburn Sound and Owen Anchorage Stage One Parts I, II and III Background Paper for the Cockburn Sound Management Council Initiated by Barb Green Prepared and developed by Barb Green, Geoff Botting, Dr Tom Rose and Officers of the Cockburn Sound Management Council – Department of Environment and Conservation for the Cockburn Sound Management Council Shop 1/ 15 Railway Terrace Rockingham Beach WA 6168 In consultation with the Cockburn Sound Management Council’s Multiple-use Support Team Dr Tom Rose – Council Coordinator Professor Kateryna Longley – Chair Mr Keith Tocas – Recreational Fishing Representative Mr John Smedley – Recreational Boating Representative Mr Bart Houwen – Community Representative Mr Gino Valenti – Fremantle Ports Representative Mr Andrew Hill – Department of Fisheries Representative Mr Tim Bray (in Andrew Hill’s absence) Mr Ian Briggs – Department of Industry and Resources Representative Dr John Keesing – CSIRO Marine Representative Dr Rod Lukatelich – Kwinana Industries Council Representatives and Mr Milan Vicentic – GIS Coordinator, Department of Environment and Conservation Mr Chris Coffey – Environment Officer, Cockburn Sound Management Council Ms Jessica Davis – Environment Officer, Cockburn Sound Management Council
    [Show full text]
  • Neerabup Preliminary Decommisioning Plan
    PRELIMINARY DECOMMISSIONING PLAN NEWGEN POWER STATION NEERABUP December 2010 330 MW Gas‐Fired Power Station Neerabup Index PRELIMINARY DECOMMISSIONING PLAN ........................................................................ 1 NEWGEN POWER STATION ............................................................................................ 1 NEERABUP 1 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 1 2 Company Information ............................................................................................. 1 3 Need for the Project ................................................................................................ 1 4 Project Information ................................................................................................. 2 4.1 Plant Information .............................................................................................. 2 4.3 Land Description ................................................................................................ 3 4.4 Environmental Approvals .................................................................................. 4 5 Purpose of the Document ........................................................................................ 4 5.1 Rationale for Site Selection ............................................................................... 4 5.1.1 Power Station ................................................................................................ 4 5.1.2 Gas Pipeline
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Planning Report 2020
    Annual Planning Report 2020 Table of contents Section 1 Introduction 3 Section 2 Planning considerations 7 Section 3 Demand forecasts and scenario planning 13 Section 4 Emerging technology 17 Section 5 Key completed projects 23 Section 6 Transmission network issues and developments 27 Section 7 Distribution network issues and developments 49 Section 8 Conclusion 57 Appendix A Estimated maximum short circuit levels for 2019/20 59 Western Power Annual Planning Report 2020 1 2 Western Power Annual Planning Report 2020 1 Introduction Western Power Annual Planning Report 2020 3 Who we are For more than 70 years, We’re already harnessing new technology and are excited about further opportunities to Western Power has evolve with the changing energy needs of our provided Western customers to keep them connected every step of the way. Australians with safe, We build, operate and maintain the reliable and efficient transmission and distribution networks which cover a service area of over 255,000km². electricity. The transmission network is shown in the diagram on page 6. Our vast transmission and distribution network seamlessly connects our homes, businesses The network is inherently dynamic and and essential community infrastructure to an complex. Customers’ needs change and we increasingly renewable energy mix, to build our regularly receive new connection applications. State and meet the changing energy needs You should use the information in this report of Western Australians. We’re powered by only as a guide and we recommend that you community trust and the passion of our people. get in touch with us as early as possible when planning your project.
    [Show full text]
  • Proposed Revisions DBNGP Access Arrangement
    Proposed Revisions DBNGP Access Arrangement 2016 – 2020 Access Arrangement Period Forecast capital expenditure Supporting Submission: 9 PUBLIC Date Submitted: 31/12/2014 Proposed Revisions DBNGP Access Arrangement CONFIDENTIALITY 1.1 This submission is provided to the ERA to assist it in its assessment of the proposed revisions to the DBNGP Access Arrangement. 1.2 Some information contained in the submission is confidential and commercially sensitive. The reasons for DBP's claim of confidentiality are outlined in Appendix B: to this submission. 1.3 A public version of this submission will be provided separately. 1.4 Accordingly, this version of the submission is provided to the ERA on the following conditions: (a) it is to be used by the ERA solely for the purposes of assessing the proposed revisions to the DBNGP Access Arrangement; (b) it is not to be disclosed to any person other than the following without DBP’s prior written approval: (i) those staff of the ERA who are involved in assisting the ERA in its assessment process; and (ii) those of the ERA’s consultants who are involved in assisting the ERA in its assessment process and who have appropriate confidentiality undertakings in place. DBP Transmission (DBP) is the owner and operator of the Dampier to Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline (DBNGP), Western Australia’s most important piece of energy infrastructure. The DBNGP is WA’s key gas transmission pipeline stretching almost 1600 kilometres and linking the gas fields located in the Carnarvon Basin off the Pilbara coast with population centres and industry in the south-west of the State Trent Leach Nick Wills-Johnson Manager Regulatory & Government Policy Manager Economic Regulation P: (08) 9223 4357 P: (08) 9223 4902 M: 0429 045 320 M: 0477 374 246 DBNGP (WA) Transmission Pty Limited ABN 69 081 609 190 Level 6 12-14 The Esplanade PERTH WA 6000 P: +61 8 9223 4300 F: +61 8 9223 4301 Sub 9 forecast capex [PUBLIC]_Final.docx Page i Proposed Revisions DBNGP Access Arrangement Table of Contents 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Carbon Emissions Inventory Major Resource Projects – AGEIS 2012
    FACILITIES CURRENTLY OPERATING Name/Location; Facility name, Operator Scope 1 (Direct) Source of data General activity GHG emissions Point source CO2e TPA emissions total, where stationary energy is accounted for elsewhere (eg Power derived from SWIS) Alkimos Wastewater Treatment Water Corporation Plant Sourced from SWIS 16,000 EPA Bulletins 1238, 1239 Argyle, diamonds Rio Tinto Argyle Diamonds sustainable development 49,000 report 2009 and 2010 Armadale Brick Austral Bricks Data provided by Company giving their (Brickworks Ltd) 42,968 state total emissions Cardup Brick Austral Bricks (Brickworks Ltd) see Armadale Brick Caversham Tile Bristile (Brickworks Ltd) see Armadale Brick Malaga Brick Austral Bricks (Brickworks Ltd) see Armadale Brick Australind; titanium Cristal Global Sourced from SWIS 34,000 Company report (June 2009) Boddington; Mt Saddleback, BHP Billiton - Worsley bauxite Alumina Pty Ltd 243,000 AAC Sustainability report 2009 Bonaparte Basin; Blacktip gas ENI Australia project not known Bonaparte Basin; Puffin, oil AED Oil Ltd (in administration) not known Brockman Syncline 4 Iron Ore Rio Tinto (form. Project Hamersley Iron Pty Limited) 111,800 EPA Bulletin 1214 WA GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS Page 2 Bronzewing - Mt McClure, gold Navigator Resources Ltd not known Burrup; Ammonia Plant, Burrup Burrup Fertilisers Pty NGER Greenhouse and Energy Information Peninsula Ltd 1,484,877 2010-11 Canning Basin; Blina, Lloyd, Buru Energy Ltd Sundown & West Terrace, oil 244 Data provided by Company Cape Preston; Central Block, Sino Iron (CITIC)
    [Show full text]
  • P6252b-6253A Hon Robin Chapple; Hon Peter Collier ENERGY
    Extract from Hansard [COUNCIL — Tuesday, 15 September 2015] p6252b-6253a Hon Robin Chapple; Hon Peter Collier ENERGY — POWER PURCHASE AGREEMENTS 3306. Hon Robin Chapple to the Leader of the House representing the Minister for Energy: (1) Will the Minister provide a list of all of the Power Purchase Agreements signed in the last ten years, detailing which companies were contracted, for what capacity, which fuel was to be used in the electricity generation and what proportion overall is from renewable sources? (2) Will the Minister provide a list of all the coal fired power stations, including the various stages of those plants, in the South West interconnected system and the year that they were built? (3) Will the Minister outline the life expectancy of a coal fired power station? (4) For the coal fired power stations owned by Synergy, will the Minister outline the availability of these plants over the last five years taking into account all downtime due to planned and unplanned maintenance? (5) For the coal fired power stations owned by Synergy, will the Minister outline the expected timeline for the closure of those power stations, given that many of them have exceeded their initial life expectancy? (6) How much has Synergy spent on maintenance, including all refurbishments and upgrades on its coal fired power stations over the last five years? Hon Peter Collier replied: (1) No, this information is commercial in confidence. (2) The table below details all of the coal fired power station units currently operational in the South West Interconnected
    [Show full text]