DOCSLIB.ORG

Measuring the Levels of Athletic Identity and Identity Foreclosure

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Measuring the Levels of Athletic Identity and Identity Foreclosure Measuring the Levels of Athletic Identity and Identity Foreclosure among Student Athletes at a National Junior College Athletic Association (NJCAA) College by Deborah L. Borak A dissertation submitted to the faculty of Wilmington University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Business Administration Wilmington University 2018 i Measuring the Levels of Athletic Identity and Identity Foreclosure among Student Athletes at a National Junior College Athletic Association (NJCAA) College by Deborah L. Borak I certify that I have read this dissertation and that in my opinion it meets the academic and professional standards required by Wilmington University as a dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Business Administration Signed_______________________________________________________________ Amy L. Danley, Ed.D, Dissertation Committee Chair Signed_______________________________________________________________ Ruth T. Norman, Ph.D., Dissertation Committee Member Signed_______________________________________________________________ John L. Sparco, Ph.D., Dissertation Committee Member ii Dedication This dissertation is dedicated to my father, Max Borak. This work is for you Dad; this is your accomplishment, for being the best father, for teaching me how to be a parent (my most important role), and for believing in me. Because you believed in me, I learned to believe in myself. I know how proud you are Dad……I can see your smile….I only wish that you were here to share this with me. Your daughter, Deborah Leah (smiling………….Dr. Borak). iii Acknowledgements After three years and one month, I am happy for this day: giving thanks as this journey culminates in the writing of my dissertation. The doctoral journey has been a journey of discovery for me, not just in my area of research, but also in my quest for self-actualization. So, while I am here today, having achieved a lifelong dream, I know that I was not alone on this journey; there are many who supported and encouraged me along the way, and I wish to express my sincere appreciation. I would first like to thank my dissertation committee chair, Dr. Danley and committee members Dr. Norman and Dr. Sparco. Your unwavering dedication and support guided me such that what I had perceived to be insurmountable came to be quite doable. I wrote a chapter, you responded with your feedback; we did it again and again, and finally, after many months of hard work, we accomplished what we’d set out to…….. and I am Dr. Borak! I cannot thank you enough. To the entire Wilmington University School of Business faculty, you have enriched my life immensely. You have taught me, encouraged me, mentored me, and lifted my spirit when times were tough. I will always remember and cherish the doctoral journey that we shared. To my Dad, you gave me the greatest gift that anyone could ever bestow upon another…..you believed in me…….I love you Dad. To my daughter, Sarah, the love of my life, thank you for understanding the commitment that I had made to complete this degree. You are my driving force and I hope that I have taught you to believe in yourself as my Dad taught me. You have iv grown into an accomplished, kind, compassionate woman and I could not be more proud of you! To my brother Keith and his beautiful family, wife Michele, and children Sydney and Max (the second), I thank you for your support and encouragement in good times and in bad, for always being there for me, and for sharing this accomplishment. To Sydney, I am so happy that you came to the dissertation defense. With the grace of God, I will be at yours. To my friend Loris (Dr. Crawford), we started, travelled, and completed this journey together, and during this time, I learned what friendship is. To the College, thank you for your support during this journey, for allowing me to conduct research, and for giving me your time, your encouragement, and guidance. I so very much appreciate all you have done and I hope that the information derived from this study will provide benefit to the institution. And last, but certainly not least, cohort 16; we laughed, cried, lamented, and rejoiced together. It was an incredible experience. I wish you all the very best. To every one of you who supported me along this journey and to those I met along the way, hopefully our paths will cross again someday. God bless. v Abstract A major task of adolescence is the development of an identity, a sense of self, making the college years a critical time for identity formation. For student athletes, development is strongly influenced by athletic participation, which has been shown to manifest into a strong and dominant athletic identity, often at the detriment of the student identity, therefore impeding educational attainment. The purpose of this cross-sectional quantitative study was to gain an understanding of the levels of athletic identity and identity foreclosure among student athletes at a National Junior College Athletic Association (NJCAA) college. The study also sought to understand if significant differences existed in athletic identity and identity foreclosure based on selected independent variables of race, gender, ethnicity, and sport played. Finally, the study sought to determine if a relationship existed between athletic identity and identity foreclosure and if so, the direction and strength of that relationship. Athletic identity was found to be high for the sample and identity foreclosure to be low to moderate. Additionally, results of the study identified significant differences in identity foreclosure scores based on gender and on sport played. Finally, the study revealed a positive relationship between athletic identity and identity foreclosure. Keywords: Athletic identity, identity foreclosure, identity development, student athlete, National Junior College Athletic Association, NJCAA, National Collegiate Athletic Association, NCAA, academic athletic advising, NACADA. vi Table of Contents Dedication ..................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................... iii Abstract ......................................................................................................................... v Table of Contents ......................................................................................................... vi List of Tables ............................................................................................................. viii List of Figures .............................................................................................................. ix Chapter 1: Introduction ................................................................................................. 1 Background to the Problem ....................................................................................... 3 Problem Statement ..................................................................................................... 9 Significance of the Study ......................................................................................... 11 Research Questions and Hypotheses ....................................................................... 11 Framework and Working Model ............................................................................. 14 Definitions of Key Terms ........................................................................................ 14 Summary .................................................................................................................. 15 Chapter 2: Literature Review ...................................................................................... 17 Issues Associated with Intercollegiate Sport ........................................................... 17 Identity Development .............................................................................................. 20 Identity Salience and Athletic Identity ................................................................. 22 Identity Foreclosure.............................................................................................. 24 Effects of Intercollegiate Sport Participation .......................................................... 25 Research on Athletic Identity and Identity Foreclosure .......................................... 31 Athletic Academic Advising of the Foreclosed Student ......................................... 36 Intervention Strategies.......................................................................................... 38 Summary .................................................................................................................. 44 Chapter 3: Methodology ............................................................................................. 45 Purpose of the Study ................................................................................................ 45 Research Questions and Hypotheses ....................................................................... 45 Research Design ...................................................................................................... 47 Study Population...................................................................................................... 48 Ethical and Human Subjects’ Consideration ........................................................... 51 Data Collection Procedures and Instruments ..........................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • THE NCAA NEWS/January I,1987 3 Top Six
    8lsf annual Convention January 1,1987, Volume 24 Number 1 Official Publication oft ational Collegiate Athletic Association L&a Ice Jon Louis Cheryl Miller John Moflet Dub Myers Megan Neyer Top Six award winners to be honored by’87 Convention Three Olympians, NCAA cham- nastics; Cheryl Miller, University of nounced in the December 17, 1986, have excelled in athletics and acade- school records for season hitting per- pions in gymnastics and track, and a Southern California, basketball; John issue of the News. mics while demonstrating leadership centage and career digs. She was finalist for the Broderick Award in Moffet, Stanford University, swim- The awards will be presented at the abilities and performing community named the most valuable player at volleyball comprise the group of stu- ming; Dub Myers, University of Ore- 22nd annual NCAA honors luncheon, service. two tournaments this season and was dent-athletes combining athletics gon, track and field, and Megan to be held January 7, 1987, in con- honored as the Greater San Jose prowess, academic achievement and Neyer, University of Florida, diving. junction with the NCAA Conveniion. Lisa Ice Sports Association athlete of the year. community service who have been These current student-athletes join The Theodore Roosevelt Award, the A finalist for the 1986-87 Broderick She played on the gold-medal team at named recipients of the Association’s six former varsity letter-winners who highest honor the NCAA confers on, Award in volleyball, Ice has been a the 1983 National Sports Festival. Today’s Top Six awards. will receive Silver Anniversary awards an individual, also is presented at the four-year starter at San Jose State.
    [Show full text]
  • NCAA Show Me the Money
    2010-11 Association-Wide Grants, Programs and Services: “Show Me the Money” Cost/Amount of Opportunity Description Deadline Grant Achieving Coaching Excellence (ACE) The Achieving Coaches Excellence Program (ACE) is a collaborative effort of the Cost: The BCA NCAA and the Black Coaches and Administrators (BCA) to further the mission will provide and vision of the advancement of minority men and women in intercollegiate hotel Contact: Stephanie Thorburn athletics. The ACE program is designed to assist an already talented group to accommodations, become the next generation of intercollegiate head basketball coaches. Activities meals, meeting for the four-day, intensive program are divided into “on-court” and “off-court” materials and instructions. Completion of the ACE program will advance coaches skills and travel stipend to marketability of advancement of ethnic minorities. It will also assist with all selected developing the total coach in the areas of communications, budget planning, X’s participants and O’s and program development. The ACE program is administered by the BCA and supported by the student-athlete affairs and leadership development group of the NCAA national office. The BCA also works closely with the National Association of Basketball Coaches (NABC) and Women’s Basketball Coaches Association (WBCA). The BCA also relies on its member coaches and administrators to conduct the programs. APPLE Conference The APPLE conference provides a weekend strategic training opportunity to an October Institutions have “athletics prevention team” (student-athletes and administrators) on the APPLE to pay a $250 model, a comprehensive design for promoting student-athlete wellness and registration fee, Contact: Mary Wilfert substance abuse prevention programming and policies in the athletics department.
    [Show full text]
  • Investigating the Academic Motivations of NCAA Gymnasts in and out of Season
    Journal of Higher Education Athletics & Innovation Volume 1, Issue 6 Investigating the Academic Motivations of NCAA Gymnasts In and Out of Season Amanda L. Paule-Koba, Ph.D. Bowling Green State University Maggie Dunn, M.S. Florida State University Abstract: As National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) athlete exploitation has become a growing concern, it has become increasingly more important to examine the nature of how athletes are spending their time. The purpose of this study was to examine whether motivations change when Division I athletes are in season compared to out of season. A survey was distributed to Division I women’s gymnastics teams from the Mid-American Conference (MAC). Results were assessed based on the factors of academic motivation and their differences during the varying times of the academic year. In this study, individuals from five MAC schools participated. It was concluded that, while academic motivations in season and out of season differed, there was not one season that was more academically demanding than the other. Participants reported feeling busier when in season, although being busy was not found to concretely impact their academics in negative ways. Participants were found to be motivated year-round by their own high expectations and wanting to decrease stress but were more motivated when in season to get ahead on academics to avoid having to focus on academics while traveling to away competitions. The findings are of note to the NCAA, athletic administrators, and academic advisors and should be considered when allocating resources to provide all athletes with academic support if the athlete, even high achieving athletes, feel it is needed to assist in attaining their academic goals.
    [Show full text]
  • Planning Guide for the College-Bound Student-Athlete
    PLANNING GUIDE FOR THE COLLEGE BOUND STUDENT ATHLETE TABLE OF CONTENTS • INTRODUCTION LETTER P. 1 • THE BEGINNING P. 2 – 3 • THE GAME PLAN P. 4 – 5 • YOUR CHECK LIST P. 6 • THE NCAA CLEARINGHOUSE P. 7 • DIFFERENCES BETWEEN DIVISION I, II, III P. 8 • NUMBERS GAME p. 9 – 13 (The facts about competing in college athletics) • NCAA SUMMARY OF RECRUITING P. 14 – 15 RULES FOR EACH SPORT, BY DIVISION • QUESTIONS TO ASK YOURSELF P. 16 – 17 • SAMPLE RESUME P. 18 • SAMPLE COVER LETTER P. 19 • RECRUITING SERVICES P.20 • ACKNOWLEDGMENTS P. 21 This packet has been created for your convenience to help guide you through an important time in your life. Continuing your academic and athletic career in college requires a tremendous amount of work. While The Planning Guide for the Student Athlete can assist you through the college recruiting & admission process, you are the generating force to assure that the necessary tasks get accomplished. The guidance counselors, coaches and teachers here at St. Ignatius College Prep are here to help. The success of this process also depends upon realistic evaluations of your ability, both in the classroom and in the sports arena. Please use this information to help further your athlete’s opportunities beyond high school. There are many people to assist you along the way. Do not hesitate to ask for help. Sincerely, The SI Counseling Department 1 Each year thousands of student athletes and parents market themselves to college coaches. Some are very successful, some are not. It's not a difficult process if you have a road map and the basic resources to give your student athlete the best possible advantage.
    [Show full text]
  • By Receipt of This Document Via Email, I Acknowledge I Have Received the 2020 - 2021 University of Illinois Student-Athlete Handbook
    By receipt of this document via email, I acknowledge I have received the 2020 - 2021 University of Illinois Student-Athlete Handbook. I understand I am responsible for reading, understanding, and adhering to the information contained within this handbook pertaining to rules, regulations, policies, and procedures. UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS DIVISION OF INTERCOLLEGIATE ATHLETICS STUDENT-ATHLETE HANDBOOK August 2020 Dear Fighting Illini Student-Athletes: It gives me great pleasure to welcome you to campus for the 2020-2021 year! A special greeting to our new arrivals; it is our expectation that your years at the University of Illinois will transform your lives and position you for success and happiness following graduation. To all of you, newcomers and returners alike, I challenge you to embrace the opportunity in front of you. Leave your mark on the unique and storied tradition of Fighting Illini Athletics. Seize the moment to contribute to our athletic program’s rich history. We are all part of the Fighting Illini Family. Together, let’s do something special. The intercollegiate athletics program at the University of Illinois serves many purposes to a variety of different stakeholders, including student-athletes, staff, the campus, our community, our state, University alumni, fans and ticketholders, donors, business partners, and many others. In service to all these people and organizations, we have developed a concise mission statement, which defines, in broad terms, our reason for being. This mission statement is as powerful in its simplicity and scope as it is straightforward in its recital: Unify. Develop. Inspire. Achieve. It is a privilege, and not a right, to be associated with our program.
    [Show full text]
  • 2019 Pre-Championship Manual
    NCAA General Administrative Guidelines Contents Section 1 • Introduction 2 Section 1•1 Definitions 2 Section 2 • Championship Core Statement 2 Section 3 • Concussion Management 3 Section 4 • Conduct 3 Section 4•1 Certification of Eligibility/Availability 3 Section 4•2 Drug Testing 4 Section 4•3 Honesty and Sportsmanship 4 Section 4•4 Misconduct/Failure to Adhere to Policies 4 Section 4•5 Sports Wagering Policy 4 Section 4•6 Student-Athlete Experience Survey 5 Section 5 • Elite 90 Award 5 Section 6 • Fan Travel 5 Section 7 • Logo Policy 5 Section 8 • Research 6 Section 9 • Religious Conflicts 6 THE NATIONAL COLLEGIATE ATHLETIC ASSOCIATION P.O. Box 6222 Indianapolis, Indiana 46206-6222 317-917-6222 www.ncaa.org October 2018 NCAA, NCAA logo, National Collegiate Athletic Association and Elite 90 are registered marks of the Association and use in any manner is prohibited unless prior approval is obtained from the Association. NCAA PRE-CHAMPIONSHIP MANUAL 1 GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE GUIDELINES Section 1 • Introduction During the 2018-19 academic year, the Association will sponsor 90 national championships – 42 for men, 45 for women, and three for both men and women. Of the men’s championships, three are National Collegiate Championships, 13 are Division I championships, 12 are Division II championships and 14 are Division III championships. Of the women’s championships, six are National Collegiate Championships, 12 are Division I championships, 13 are Division II championships and 14 are Division III championships. The combined men’s and women’s championships are National Collegiate Championships. The Pre-Championship Manual will serve as a resource for institutions to prepare for the championship.
    [Show full text]
  • 2020-21 Pre-Championships Manual
    2020-21 MANUAL NCAA General Administrative Guidelines Contents Section 1 • Introduction 2 Section 1•1 Definitions 2 Section 2 • Championship Core Statement 2 Section 3 • Concussion Management 3 Section 4 • Conduct 3 Section 4•1 Certification of Eligibility/Availability 3 Section 4•2 Drug Testing 4 Section 4•3 Honesty and Sportsmanship 4 Section 4•4 Misconduct/Failure to Adhere to Policies 4 Section 4•5 Sports Wagering Policy 4 Section 4•6 Student-Athlete Experience Survey 5 ™ Section 5 • Elite 90 Award 5 Section 6 • Fan Travel 5 Section 7 • Logo Policy 5 Section 8 • Research 6 Section 9 • Division I 6 Section 9•1 Religious Conflicts 6 THE NATIONAL COLLEGIATE ATHLETIC ASSOCIATION P.O. Box 6222 Indianapolis, Indiana 46206-6222 317-917-6222 ncaa.org November 2020 NCAA, NCAA logo, National Collegiate Athletic Association and Elite 90 are registered marks of the Association and use in any manner is prohibited unless prior approval is obtained from the Association. NCAA PRE-CHAMPIONSHIPS MANUAL 1 GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE GUIDELINES Section 1 • Introduction The Pre-Championship Manual will serve as a resource for institutions to prepare for the championship. This manual is divided into three sections: General Administrative Guidelines, Sport-Specific Information, and Appendixes. Sections one through eight apply to policies applicable to all 90 championships, while the remaining sections are sport specific. Section 1•1 Definitions Pre-championship Manual. Resource for institutions to prepare for the championship. Administrative Meeting. Pre-championship meeting for coaches and/or administrators. Appendixes. Any supplemental documents to be provided and distributed through the various resources. Championship Manager.
    [Show full text]
  • 2017-2018 University of Virginia Student-Athlete Handbook
    2017-2018 University of Virginia Student-Athlete Handbook The University of Virginia does not discriminate in any of its programs, procedures or practices against any person on the basis of age, citizenship, color, handicap, national origin, political affiliation, race, religion, sex, sexual orientation, or status as a disabled veteran or veteran of the Vietnam era. The University operates equal opportunity and affirmative action programs for faculty, staff, and students. The University of Virginia is an Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Employer. Table of Contents INTRODUCTION 5 Athletics Department Mission 5 Athletics Department 10-Year Goals 5 Institutional Purpose 5 Traditions and Expectations 6 STUDENT-ATHLETE WELL BEING 7 ADVISORY COUNCILS 7 Athletics Advisory Council 7 Student-Athlete Advisory Committee (SAAC) 7 Student-Athlete Mentor Program (SAM) 8 GENERAL INFORMATION 8 Code of Ethics 8 Student-Athlete Responsibilities 9 Change of Address 9 Urgent Communication Policy 9 Resolving Issues Between Student-Athletes and Coaches 10 Team Meeting 11 Team Rules 12 Policy for the Announcement of Student-Athlete Suspensions 13 Exit Interviews 14 Student-Athlete Online Survey 14 Sport Psychology Services 14 Sports Nutrition 16 Strength Training and Conditioning 18 Equipment Rooms 20 Athletics Media Relations Office 21 Life Skills 23 Career Development 23 Personal Development 23 Community Service 24 Social Media, Networking, and Websites 24 Tickets to UVA Athletics Events 26 Amplified Music 26 Playing Schedules 26 Varsity Lettering 27
    [Show full text]
  • Mcneese State University Intercollegiate Athletics
    MCNEESE STATE UNIVERSITY INTERCOLLEGIATE ATHLETICS POLICIES AND PROCEDURES 2010-2011 TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 1 PHILOSOPHY AND ORGANIZATION 101 - Athletics Department Mission Statement ....................................................... 101-1 102 - Principles ........................................................................................................ 102-1 Objectives ................................................................................................. 102-2 103 - Athletic Advisory Committee and Faculty Athletics Representative Departmental Organization ....................................................................... 104-1 Athletics Organizational Chart .................................................................. 104-2 Annual Performance Evaluation ............................................................... 104-3 Graduate Assistant Coach ........................................................................ 104-4 Undergraduate Assistant .......................................................................... 104-4 Termination of Service .............................................................................. 104-4 Nepotism .................................................................................................. 104-4 CHAPTER 2 STUDENT AFFAIRS 201 - Code of Conduct/Discipline ............................................................................. 201-1 Standards of Conduct ............................................................................... 201-2 Disciplinary
    [Show full text]
  • NCAA Myles Brand Building Grand Opening Celebration
    NCAA Myles Brand Building Grand Opening Celebration [00:00:03] Ladies and gentlemen, please welcome the president of the NCAA, Mark ​ Emmert. Mark Emmert [00:00:13] Thank you. Thank you. Could I get all of those who sort of ​ ​ know they have reserved seats to please move forward and have a seat. It got so quiet in here. And you all have wine too. Well, yeah, please come forward. Thank you. Well, first of all, let me on behalf of all of the NCAA, welcome all of you here. We have such a wonderful group of honorees here today, and we're going to get to thank them for their contributions to collegiate athletics and to honor them with this wonderful new facility. We've got our wonderful Governor- no President I'm sorry, Mitch Daniels. President elect, I'm sorry, Governor. Thank you. Mayor Ballard here, we'll get to hear from both of them in just a few minutes, and and this is a a moment that's been a long time in coming since this building has been in the planning stage and the construction stage. We relocated people from all around the country here, moving the eligibility center here from Iowa City, when was that gym three, four years ago? We now get everybody in one one place here. We can bring all of our meetings to this facility so we can pump up all of the all the hotels and all of the restaurants Mayor, and we can we can continue to build the strength of Indianapolis and Indiana as a home for amateur athletics, and for us, that's just fabulous.
    [Show full text]
  • Assessing the Academic Motivations of NCAA Division I Mid American Conference Gymnasts When in and out of Season
    Bowling Green State University ScholarWorks@BGSU Masters of Education in Human Movement, Sport, and Leisure Studies Graduate Projects Human Movement, Sport, and Leisure Studies 2018 Assessing the Academic Motivations of NCAA Division I Mid American Conference Gymnasts When In and Out of Season Maggie Dunn Bowling Green State University Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.bgsu.edu/hmsls_mastersprojects Repository Citation Dunn, Maggie, "Assessing the Academic Motivations of NCAA Division I Mid American Conference Gymnasts When In and Out of Season" (2018). Masters of Education in Human Movement, Sport, and Leisure Studies Graduate Projects. 57. https://scholarworks.bgsu.edu/hmsls_mastersprojects/57 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Human Movement, Sport, and Leisure Studies at ScholarWorks@BGSU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Masters of Education in Human Movement, Sport, and Leisure Studies Graduate Projects by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@BGSU. Assessing the Academic Motivations of NCAA Division I Mid American Conference Gymnasts When In and Out of Season Maggie Dunn Bowling Green State University 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT .........................................................................................................................3 INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................. 4 Research Questions ................................................................................................10
    [Show full text]
  • Student Is a Nice Name for Free Labor
    Santa Clara Law Review Volume 61 Number 2 Article 4 6-4-2021 Student is a Nice Name for Free Labor Anderson, Jenna M. Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.scu.edu/lawreview Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation Jenna M. Anderson, Student is a Nice Name for Free Labor, 61 SANTA CLARA L. REV. 589 (2021). This Case Note is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at Santa Clara Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Santa Clara Law Review by an authorized editor of Santa Clara Law Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. STUDENT IS A NICE NAME FOR FREE LABOR Jenna M. Anderson* The National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) contends that the principle of amateurism protects student-athletes and ensures that their number one priority is education. Although this may have been true when the NCAA was formed, the commercialization of college sports and accompanying monetary incentives have enticed the NCAA to enforce rules that exploit student-athletes at the detriment of their education. The NCAA’s impure motives are no longer going unnoticed. The public is disgusted by what it sees in the media. Student-athletes are rebelling by suing the NCAA for violating federal antitrust laws. The states are passing laws that give the NCAA no choice but to make a change. Courts are chipping away at the principle of amateurism one case at a time. The NCAA must be held accountable. This note proposes a three- part, student-centered solution to reform the current state of affairs.
    [Show full text]