22

Moscow’s Red Square, St. Basil’s and the Kremlin—seat of power in from the czars, to the Soviets to the current strongman, . Wikimedia, Alex Zelenko photo Solving the Riddle of Russia: Who Blinks First? Anthony Wilson-Smith

Not only have the West’s post-Soviet dreams of a liberal, quarter century ago, as the So- democratic Russia dissolved in a morass of corruption viet Union lurched toward dis- A solution, one of the people and autocracy; Vladimir Putin’s expansionism and chronicling its fall was Russian journal- tanking oil prices have made Russia a prime candidate ist Artyom Borovik. His television show for next basket case of Europe. Former Maclean’s Vzglyad—which mocked Mikhail Gor- bachev’s government—was watched by Bureau Chief Anthony Wilson-Smith looks as many as 100 million people a week. at the geopolitical state of play, and sees hope in an Fluent in English, the result of a child- upcoming Arctic Council meeting in Iqaluit. hood in New York with his Soviet dip- lomat father, he also had a large follow- ing in the West. Artyom was energetic, engaging, crusading in his beliefs—and despairing about his country’s future even as he applauded ongoing changes. “Russians,” he once said, “talk about

Policy 23 how we like democracy, but we really History shows that Russia—as both a stand-alone like a strongman who tells everyone nation and centrepiece of the old — what to do—and makes the rest of the world pay attention.” tends to become more bellicose in the face of challenges at Within a decade, Vladimir Putin had home. Successive Communist rulers spent heavily on the become leader of a reconstituted Rus- military at the expense of a steadily worsening economy. sia, and was on his way to providing evidence of that observation. Artyom had little chance for I-told-you-so: leaders had given up trying to hide try’s bankers to play a high-stakes he died in March, 2000, shortly af- the reality of chronic food and hous- game of yo-yo with interest rates in ter Putin came to power, in a plane ing shortages, factories producing attempts to prop up both the ruble crash that many believe was caused nothing of use, rural villages still and the banks. Six weeks after inter- by sabotage. (Artyom made powerful without electricity, and a currency est rates were increased from 10.5 enemies almost as easily as he made of nonsensical value. Because the ru- per cent to 17 per cent to prop up friends). And 15 years later, Russia ble did not trade freely on currency the ruble, the central bank chopped continues to evoke bafflement, anger exchanges, its value was pegged ab- the rate back to 15 per cent because and concern abroad—all the more so surdly high. By the late 1980s, a ruble of pressures on the overall financial as its internal troubles deepen. formally worth $2 Canadian could be system. In the same period, the gov- It’s tempting at times for Western bought for about 10 cents by foreign- ernment said it would commit $23 countries to wish Russia ill. Some ers living in Moscow who were will- billion to bail out troubled banks. efforts in that direction are fully de- ing to chance going na lyeva (trading served, such as Canada’s suspension on the black market.) Russia is now at of almost all diplomatic discussions, Today, the problems are clear to all. roughly the halfway along with economic sanctions that The global fall in oil prices of more point of a modernization European Union countries placed on than 50 per cent in the last year has Russia because of its annexation of driven a deep hole into the middle of program focusing on fighter Crimea and actions in Ukraine. But Russia’s economy. The measures the aircraft, air defense, no one should wish on Russia an government has undertaken amount submarines, ships, strategic economic collapse of the scale that mostly to efforts to buy time in the nuclear weapons and some analysts now forecast because hope that oil prices rise again. Steps of falling prices for the country’s recently introduced by Finance Min- intelligence. prime export, oil. For one, Morgan ister Anton Siluanov include spend- Stanley recently revised its econom- ing $22 billion (US) to prop up banks ic forecast for Russia, calling for a and major state companies, $2.7 bil- downgrade in the already-suffering lion to keep pensions in line with ut one area where Russia economy from 1.7 per cent shrink- the spiralling inflation rate, and continues to spend—and age to negative 5.6 per cent. It also $700 million for agricultural aid. B build—is its military. After forecast that, instead of a mild re- As it taps into $385 billion in gov- neglect in the 1990s, Russia has been covery in 2016, the Russian econo- ernment reserves, the government overhauling its armed forces. Its mili- my will shrink even further. is gambling that oil prices will rise tary budget two years ago was $90 before it exhausts that money. Since billion—which puts it behind only istory shows that Russia—as December, the reserve has dwindled China ($188 billion) and the US both a stand-alone nation by $36 billion. Last month, the gov- ($640 billion), according to the Stock- H and centrepiece of the old ernor of Russia’s Central Bank said holm International Peace Research Soviet Union—tends to become more that the country has lost about $160 Institute. That represents more than bellicose in the face of challenges at billion in annual revenue because of double the amount it spent a decade home. Successive Communist rulers the decline. previously. Russia is now at roughly spent heavily on the military at the the halfway point of a modernization Despite stop-gap measures, the ef- expense of a steadily worsening econ- program focusing on fighter aircraft, fects of falling oil and mounting in- omy. When Gorbachev took power, air defense, submarines, ships, strate- flation are clear. The New York Times gic nuclear weapons and intelligence. and introduced widespread reforms recently reported that last year food in an attempt to reverse course, he prices rose more than 15 per cent. For all that, Russian military might is was lionized in the West, but detested Some staples, like sugar, rose up to only a shadow of what it was in the at home because he was seen as hav- 40 per cent. The overall inflation rate peak days of the Soviet Union. But it ing diminished his country’s place in was 11.4 per cent and expected to be is enough to concern neighbours, as the world. at least as high this year. Those chal- well as a reminder of Russia’s legiti- By the end of the Soviet Union, its lenges have led Putin and the coun- mate worries about rising ethnic ten-

March/April 2015 24 sions within its own borders and just beyond. Westerners often make the mistake of thinking of Russians as homogenous. In fact, based on the 2010 census, the country includes more than 190 ethnic groups and al- most one in every four people—22.3 per cent—is of a background other than ethnic Russian. Moscow con- tinues to fret over tensions in former Soviet republics to its south, espe- cially in the North Caucasus region as well as in Afghanistan. At the same time on the economic front, the Morgan Stanley forecast identifies three serious short-term

risks: President Reagan and Vice President and President-elect George Bush meeting with General • A further weakening of the ruble Secretary Gorbachev on Governor's Island in the shadow of the Statue of Liberty on and increase in inflation if Mos- December 7, 1988. National Archives and Records Administration cow makes “special deals to help particular banks and companies.” military force to preserve what it sees All of which shows that even as more as its traditional sphere of influence. attention is focused on the Middle • The introduction of capital East and the growth of radical Is- controls. Overall, Putin’s track lamist terrorist groups, Cold War ten- • The imposing of further sanctions record—and that of sions persist. For Russia, ironically, on Russia that could “trigger rat- his country—suggests that the way out of its present econom- ing downgrades and index exclu- ic fix could lie in the Middle East. sion.” That would cause the ruble Russia will continue a foreign Saudi Arabia, which holds a fifth of to fall even more and inflation to policy built on truculence— the world’s oil reserves, has given rise further. and, potentially—as it has in some indications it might be ready Looking ahead, the question is who Ukraine—the use of military to reduce the flow of oil and thus see blinks first? Logic says that Western force to preserve what it sees prices increase if Putin were prepared countries, including Canada, the to abandon support for Syria’s Presi- and members of the as its traditional sphere of dent Bashar-al-Assad. Under Putin, European Union, need to see some influence. Russia has positioned itself as a key sort of concession from Putin be- player in the Middle East—and sees fore they lift existing sanctions that Syria’s Assad as a key figure in the are part of Russia’s problem. Some fight against Islamic State (ISIS) and would argue that came in February, ne indicator of the direc- Al Qaeda-backed groups. with the announcement of an agree- tion in which things are ment between the leaders of France, O heading will come in April, The irony is that on this key issue, Germany, Ukraine and Russia aimed when Russia attends a meeting of Western countries, including Cana- at ending ongoing fighting in east- the eight-member Arctic Council in da and the United States, share the ern Ukraine between forces of that Iqaluit hosted by Canada and includ- goal of keeping ISIS and Al Qaeda country and Russian-backed separat- ing Nordic countries and the United in check. By that measure, the Arab ists. But even as that raised hopes, States. Canada, Denmark and Russia aphorism that ‘the enemy of my en- it is a fragile accord—and one that all lay claim to overlapping sectors of emy is my friend’ should bring Russia carries over it the shadow of Wash- the Far North—including ownership and the West closer. But there is little ington’s willingness to send weapons of the North Pole. Russia’s newly- indication that will happen. As Putin to Ukraine to provide support against minted ambassador to Canada, Al- once said, “Sometimes it is necessary the separatist forces. (Canada also ex- exander Darchiev, has taken a con- to be lonely in order to prove that pressed willingness to consider some ciliatory approach to the meeting, you are right.” He may not be in the form of enhanced support.) saying it will provide an opportunity right, but Putin and his country are increasingly lonely. Overall, Putin’s track record—and to “compromise” in discussing ap- that of his country—suggests that proaches to the region. But Russia Contributing Writer Anthony Wilson- Russia will continue a foreign policy has also been rebuilding some old Smith, a former editor of Maclean’s, built on truculence—and, potential- Soviet air bases in the region and de- was the magazine’s first Moscow bureau ly—as it has in Ukraine—the use of ploying more aircraft and navy. chief. [email protected]

Policy