DOCSLIB.ORG

Biopolitics and Subjectivity: the Case of Autism Spectrum

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Biopolitics and Subjectivity: the Case of Autism Spectrum BIOPOLITICS AND SUBJECTIVITY: THE CASE OF AUTISM SPECTRUM CONDITIONS IN ITALY By M. ARIEL CASCIO Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Anthropology CASE WESTERN RESERVE UNIVERSITY May, 2015 2 CASE WESTERN RESERVE UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES We hereby approve the thesis/dissertation of M. Ariel Cascio candidate for the degree of Ph.D.*. Committee Chair Atwood D. Gaines Committee Member Eileen Anderson-Fye Committee Member Lee Hoffer Committee Member Anastasia Dimitropoulos Date of Defense March 6, 2015 * We also certify that written approval has been obtained for any proprietary material contained therein. 3 Table of Contents List of Tables ...................................................................................................................... 7 List of Figures ..................................................................................................................... 8 Preface................................................................................................................................. 9 Acknowledgments............................................................................................................. 11 List of Acronyms .............................................................................................................. 13 Abstract ............................................................................................................................. 11 Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 16 The Autism Concept...................................................................................................... 16 Experiences along the Autism Spectrum ...................................................................... 16 The Research Questions ................................................................................................ 22 Dissertation Overview by Chapter ................................................................................ 25 Chapter 1: Literature Review ........................................................................................ 29 Chapter Overview ....................................................................................................... 29 Section 1: The Anthropology of Biomedicine ........................................................... 32 Section 2: The Anthropology of Autism .................................................................... 41 Critical Autism Studies ............................................................................................. 42 Cross-Cultural Studies of Autism ............................................................................ 49 Section 3: New Biopolitical Theory............................................................................ 52 Overview of New Biopolitical Theory ...................................................................... 54 Molecularization ....................................................................................................... 58 Somatic Expertise ..................................................................................................... 60 Illness Identities ........................................................................................................ 64 Collective Identities and Biosocialities .................................................................... 65 Cross-Cultural Studies of New Biopolitical Theory ................................................ 66 Section 4: The Anthropology of Youth ...................................................................... 69 Rites of Passage ........................................................................................................ 72 Identity....................................................................................................................... 73 Peer Relationships .................................................................................................... 75 Sexuality .................................................................................................................... 79 Transition to Adulthood ........................................................................................... 81 Conclusion .................................................................................................................... 83 Chapter 2: Background .................................................................................................. 85 Chapter Overview ....................................................................................................... 85 4 Section 1: History of Autism ...................................................................................... 85 Section 2: History of Italian Autism Services ........................................................... 90 Section 3: Management of Italian Autism Services................................................ 100 Chapter 3: Research Design ......................................................................................... 116 Section 1: Conceptual Framework .......................................................................... 116 Section 2: Methods .................................................................................................... 119 Participant-observation .......................................................................................... 119 Staff and Other Professionals ................................................................................ 120 Parents/Guardians .................................................................................................. 121 Youth with Autism ................................................................................................... 125 Data Analysis .......................................................................................................... 127 Dissemination of Results ........................................................................................ 130 Limitations .............................................................................................................. 130 Section 3: Description of Fieldsites .......................................................................... 132 Day Center 1 ........................................................................................................... 133 Day Center 2 ........................................................................................................... 136 Day Center 3 ........................................................................................................... 139 Residential Center 1 ................................................................................................ 142 Residential Center 2 ................................................................................................ 145 Social/Recreational Group 1 .................................................................................. 147 Social/Recreational Group 2 .................................................................................. 152 Results Overview ....................................................................................................... 156 Chapter 4: Professional Conceptualization of Autism ............................................... 157 Chapter Overview ..................................................................................................... 157 Section 1: What is Autism? ....................................................................................... 158 Autism, Asperger’s Syndrome, and Intellectual Disability ................................... 166 What Causes Autism ............................................................................................... 172 Section 2: How Should Autism be Managed? ......................................................... 174 Psicoanalitica .......................................................................................................... 176 Psicologico .............................................................................................................. 177 Ufficiale ................................................................................................................... 178 Psicoeducativo......................................................................................................... 183 Cognitivo-Comportamentale .................................................................................. 184 Relazionale .............................................................................................................. 187 5 Ecologico ................................................................................................................. 188 Psicomotricità ......................................................................................................... 189 Auto-Mutuo-Aiuto .................................................................................................. 190 Specific Approaches................................................................................................ 191 Life Cycle ................................................................................................................ 209 Conclusion .................................................................................................................. 215 Chapter 5: Parents’ Perspectives ...............................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Editorial: Pride and Autism Spectrum Disorder
    EDITORIAL: PRIDE AND AUTISM SPECTRUM DISORDER June 14, 2019 Tuesday June 18 is Autistic Pride Day and every April, thanks to National Autism Awareness Month, there’s a renewed sense of support for people living with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and those who’ve worked tirelessly to foster environments of inclusion and self-determination for all. Yet, when Autism Awareness Month comes to an end, so too does much of the focus on autism from the general public. As a society, we’ve made positive strides, but it’s important to remember that the conversations about acceptance, inclusion and support for people with ASD need to happen year-round. Today Autistic Pride Day is about celebrating differences in the autism community and realizing people’s infinite possibilities and potential. People with autism have hopes, dreams, aspirations, and a right to participate in the working world. Unfortunately, people with ASD are not afforded the same opportunities as the rest of us when it comes to employment. While the majority of Americans are enjoying a low unemployment rate and strong economy, the unemployment rate for adults with developmental disabilities remains high. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, only 29 percent of Americans ages 16 to 64 with a disability were employed as of June 2018, compared with nearly 75 percent of those without a disability. The unemployment rate for people with disabilities who are actively seeking work is 9.2 percent — more than twice as high as for those without a disability (4.2 percent). Employers’ lack of understanding and lasting stigmas are partly to blame for this discrepancy.
    [Show full text]
  • Autism Society History
    Feature | Autism Society History Where We’ve Been and Where We’re Going The Autism Society’s Proud History s the nation’s oldest grassroots autism organization, the Autism Society has Abeen working to improve the lives of all affected by autism for 46 years. When the organization was founded in 1965, the autism community was very different than it is today: the term “autism” was not widely known, and doctors often blamed the condition on “refrigerator mothers,” or parents who were cold and unloving to their children – a theory that we now know to be completely false. Perhaps even more discouraging than the blame and guilt placed upon parents of children with autism at this time was the complete lack of treatment options. Parents were often told that their child would never improve, and that he or she should be institutionalized. “All practitioners we saw had one characteristic in common – none of them was able to undertake treatment,” wrote Rosalind Oppenheim, mother to a then-6-year-old son with autism, in an article in the June 17, 1961, Saturday Evening Post. “‘When will you stop running?’ one well-meaning guidance counselor asked us along the way. When indeed? After eighteen costly, heartbreaking months we felt that we had exhausted all the local medical resources.” Oppenheim’s article garnered many letters from other parents of children with autism who had had similar experiences. She sent them on to Dr. Bernard Rimland, another parent of a child with autism who was also a psychologist. Not long after, Dr. Rimland published the landmark book Infantile Autism, the first work to argue for a physical, not psychological, cause of autism.
    [Show full text]
  • Autism and New Media: Disability Between Technology and Society
    1 Autism and new media: Disability between technology and society Amit Pinchevski (lead author) Department of Communication and Journalism, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel John Durham Peters Department of Communication Studies, University of Iowa, USA Abstract This paper explores the elective affinities between autism and new media. Autistic Spectrum Disorder (ASD) provides a uniquely apt case for considering the conceptual link between mental disability and media technology. Tracing the history of the disorder through its various media connections and connotations, we propose a narrative of the transition from impaired sociability in person to fluent social media by network. New media introduce new affordances for people with ASD: The Internet provides habitat free of the burdens of face-to-face encounters; high-tech industry fares well with the purported special abilities of those with Asperger’s syndrome; and digital technology offers a rich metaphorical depository for the condition as a whole. Running throughout is a gender bias that brings communication and technology into the fray of biology versus culture. Autism invites us to rethink our assumptions about communication in the digital age, accounting for both the pains and possibilities it entails. 2 Keywords: Autism (ASD), Asperger’s Syndrome, new media, disability studies, interaction and technology, computer-mediated communication, gender and technology Authors’ bios Amit Pinchevski is a senior lecturer in the Department of Communication and Journalism at the Hebrew University, Israel. He is the author of By Way of Interruption: Levinas and the Ethics of Communication (2005) and co-editor of Media Witnessing: Testimony in the Age of Mass Communication (with Paul Frosh, 2009) and Ethics of Media (with Nick Couldry and Mirca Madianou, 2013).
    [Show full text]
  • Committee Business
    IACC Committee Business IACC Full Committee Meeting April 19, 2018 Susan A. Daniels, Ph.D. Director, Office of Autism Research Coordination Executive Secretary, IACC National Institute of Mental Health Thanks to OARC Staff Susan Daniels, Ph.D. Director Oni Celestin, Ph.D. Julianna Rava, M.P.H. Science Policy Analyst Science Policy Analyst Rebecca Martin, M.P.H Matthew Vilnit, B.S. Public Health Analyst Operations Coordinator Angelice Mitrakas, B.A. Jeff Wiegand, B.S. Management Analyst Web Development Manager Karen Mowrer, Ph.D. Science Policy Analyst April is National Autism Awareness Month NIMH Special Event for Autism Awareness Month The Story Behind Julia, Sesame Street’s Muppet with Autism April 9, 2018 • Panel presentation featuring speakers from Sesame Workshop, the nonprofit educational organization behind Sesame Street • Meet-and-greet with a costumed Julia character Archived video available: https://iacc.hhs.gov/meetings/autism- events/2018/april9/sesame- street.shtml#video Autism Awareness Month News • 2018 Presidential Proclamation: President Donald J. Trump Proclaims April 2, 2018, World Autism Awareness Day • 2018 UN Secretary-General Message: António Guterres' Message on World Autism Awareness Day Autism Awareness Month Events • Autism Awareness Interagency Roundtable Indian Health Service April 2, 2018; Bethesda, MD • Empowering Women and Girls with Autism United Nations April 5, 2018; New York, NY Event page: https://www.un.org/en/events/autismday/ Archived video available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tyhm7p8Gr2A
    [Show full text]
  • Becoming Autistic: How Do Late Diagnosed Autistic People
    Becoming Autistic: How do Late Diagnosed Autistic People Assigned Female at Birth Understand, Discuss and Create their Gender Identity through the Discourses of Autism? Emily Violet Maddox Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Master of Philosophy The University of Leeds School of Sociology and Social Policy September 2019 1 Table of Contents ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ................................................................................................................................... 5 ABSTRACT ....................................................................................................................................................... 6 ABBREVIATIONS ............................................................................................................................................. 7 CHAPTER ONE ................................................................................................................................................. 8 INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................................................. 8 1.1 RESEARCH OBJECTIVES ........................................................................................................................................ 8 1.2 TERMINOLOGY ................................................................................................................................................ 14 1.3 OUTLINE OF CHAPTERS ....................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Inclusive Practices for Neurodevelopmental Research
    Current Developmental Disorders Reports https://doi.org/10.1007/s40474-021-00227-z AUTISM SPECTRUM (A RICHDALE AND LH LAWSON, SECTION EDITORS) Inclusive Practices for Neurodevelopmental Research Sue Fletcher-Watson1 & Kabie Brook2 & Sonny Hallett3 & Fergus Murray3 & Catherine J. Crompton4 Accepted: 9 March 2021 # The Author(s) 2021 Abstract Purpose of Review Inclusive research practice is both a moral obligation and a practical imperative. Here we review its relevance to the study of neurodevelopmental diversity in particular, briefly describing a range of inclusive research models and justifying their use. The review itself is inclusively co-authored with three autistic collaborators and community leaders who all have extensive experience of research involvement. Recent Findings Drawing on theoretical arguments and specific exemplar projects, we describe six key considerations in the delivery of inclusive research. These are the following: taking the first steps towards inclusive practice; setting expectations; community-specific inclusion measures; inclusion and intersectionality; the role of empowerment; and knowledge exchange for inclusion. Together, these sections provide an illustrated guide to the principles and process of inclusive research. Summary Inclusive research practice is both beneficial to and a requirement of excellence in neurodevelopmental research. We call for greater engagement in this participatory research agenda from grant-awarding bodies to facilitate not just inclusive but also emancipatory research. Keywords Participatory research . Inclusion . Neurodiversity . Patient and public involvement . Participation Introduction for its use. We then illustrate six key facets of inclusive re- search in neurodevelopment, drawing on our own experiences What Is Inclusive Research Practice? and including illustrative examples from the literature. Arnstein’s ladder of participation [4•] provides a rudimentary Inclusive research takes place with members of the relevant model for thinking about inclusive research practice.
    [Show full text]
  • Best Kept Secret a Film by Samantha Buck
    POV Community Engagement & Education Discussion GuiDe Best Kept Secret A Film by Samantha Buck www.pbs.org/pov LETTER FROM THE FILMMAKER The first question i get about Best Kept Secret is usually “What is your personal relation - ship to autism?” until making this film, i always thought the answer was “none.” What i learned is that we are all connected to it. Autism is part of who we are as a society. Across the country, young adults who turn 21 are pushed out of the school system. They often end up with nowhere to go; they simply disappear from productive society. This is what edu - cators call “falling off the cliff.” While i was on the festival circuit with my last feature documentary, 21 Below , i saw many films about young children with autism. These films were moving and important, but they only spoke of a limited population—predominately caucasians from financially stable fam - ilies. But what happens to children with autism who grow up in other circumstances? i began to research public schools in inner-city areas all over the united states, and the best kind of accident of fate brought me to JFK in newark, n.J. and Janet Mino—a force of na - ture who changed my life. she has been a constant reminder to have faith, value every member of society and believe in people’s potential. Best Kept Secret on the surface could seem like a straightforward vérité film, but we tried to accomplish something different—a subtle and layered story that takes on issues of race, class, poverty and disability through a different lens than the one to which many people are accustomed.
    [Show full text]
  • Real-Time 3D Graphic Augmentation of Therapeutic Music Sessions for People on the Autism Spectrum
    Real-time 3D Graphic Augmentation of Therapeutic Music Sessions for People on the Autism Spectrum John Joseph McGowan Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of Edinburgh Napier University for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy October 2018 Declaration I, John McGowan, declare that the work contained within this thesis has not been submitted for any other degree or professional qualification. Furthermore, the thesis is the result of the student’s own independent work. Published material associated with the thesis is detailed within the section on Associate Publications. Signed: Date: 12th October 2019 J J McGowan Abstract i Abstract This thesis looks at the requirements analysis, design, development and evaluation of an application, CymaSense, as a means of improving the communicative behaviours of autistic participants through therapeutic music sessions, via the addition of a visual modality. Autism spectrum condition (ASC) is a lifelong neurodevelopmental disorder that can affect people in a number of ways, commonly through difficulties in communication. Interactive audio-visual feedback can be an effective way to enhance music therapy for people on the autism spectrum. A multi-sensory approach encourages musical engagement within clients, increasing levels of communication and social interaction beyond the sessions. Cymatics describes a resultant visualised geometry of vibration through a variety of mediums, typically through salt on a brass plate or via water. The research reported in this thesis focuses on how an interactive audio-visual application, based on Cymatics, might improve communication for people on the autism spectrum. A requirements analysis was conducted through interviews with four therapeutic music practitioners, aimed at identifying working practices with autistic clients.
    [Show full text]
  • The National Autism Project: Aims and Objectives
    The National Autism Project: aims and objectives The National Autism Project: Address for correspondence aims and objectives E-mail: ian@ nationalautismproject. org.uk C Ian Ragan, London Editorial comment Dr Ian Ragan is the director of the National Autism Project (NAP), launched in April 2015 and funded by The Shirley Foundation. In this paper, he describes the key aims of the project and the advisers and organisations who are contributing to this work. He makes the case that the spending on autism, relative to other conditions, is very low and that this has limited the progress on identifying the most effective interven- tions. It is hoped that data will be gathered on the cost-benefit of different services and strategies which can then be used strategically to inform future practice in health, education and social care and the voluntary sector. Readers of the GAP Journal who would like to read more about NAP or contribute to its work can visit the website www.nationalautismproject.org.uk. Note: The term autism is used throughout this paper to denote all individuals on the autism spectrum, including those with Asperger syndrome. Introduction All charities face the issue of deciding how best to spend for young people and adults? Can we be sure that ‘ben- their money and to justify their existence to their donors, efits’, as normally defined by the neurotypical majority, supporters and beneficiaries. They can augment their are really meeting the needs of the autistic minority? in-house expertise with the opinions of independent It was to try and find answers to such questions that experts but every organisation still needs to develop Dame Stephanie (Steve) Shirley with others developed its own strategy, its future direction, and its goals and the idea of the National Autism Project (NAP) which was ambitions.
    [Show full text]
  • Autism: a Generation at Threat Review Article
    April 2009 JIMA:38486-IMANA.qxd 4/27/2009 10:10 AM Page 28 Review Article Autism: A Generation at Threat Sabeeha Rehman, MPS, FACHE President and Founding Member of National Autism Association New York Metro Chapter New York, New York Fellow of American College of Healthcare Executives Abstract A generation of children is at risk as the incidence of autism increases. No consensus exists on the causes of autism or its treatment. A wide range of poten- tial factors such as genetics, vaccines, and environmental toxins is being explored. Some clinicians offer a combination of behavioral, educational, and pharmaceutical treatments, whereas allied health professionals stress diet, bio- medical interventions, and chelation. With a lack of an organized approach to diagnosis and treatment and a lack of trained professionals, children are not receiving timely interventions. Curing autism has to be made a national priori- ty. National programs should conduct research, standardize treatments, and offer public and professional education. Key words: Autism, autism spectrum disorders, health planning. Purpose impact the normal development of the brain in the he incidence of autism spectrum disorders areas of social interaction, communication skills, and (ASD) is becoming an epidemic. This phenome - cognitive function. Individuals with ASD typically non, not unique to the United States or Europe, have difficulties in verbal and nonverbal communi - Tis fast emerging as a worldwide problem. This paper cation, social interactions, and leisure or play activi - reviews the gains made and obstacles faced in the ties. Individuals with ASD often suffer from numer - diagnosis and treatment of ASD and proposes a com - ous physical ailments, which may include, in part, prehensive plan to deal with this phenomenon.
    [Show full text]
  • The Cerebral Subject and the Challenge of Neurodiversity
    BioSocieties (2009), 4, 425–445 ª London School of Economics and Political Science doi:10.1017/S1745855209990287 The Cerebral Subject and the Challenge of Neurodiversity Francisco Ortega Institute for Social Medicine, State University of Rio de Janeiro, Rua Saˇ o Francisco Xavier 524, Rio de Janeiro CEP 20550-900, Brazil E-mail: [email protected] Abstract The neurodiversity movement has so far been dominated by autistic people who believe their condition is not a disease to be treated and, if possible, cured, but rather a human specificity (like sex or race) that must be equally respected. Autistic self-advocates largely oppose groups of parents of autistic children and professionals searching for a cure for autism. This article discusses the posi- tions of the pro-cure and anti-cure groups. It also addresses the emergence of autistic cultures and various issues concerning autistic identities. It shows how identity issues are frequently linked to a ‘neurological self-awareness’ and a rejection of psychological interpretations. It argues that the preference for cerebral explanations cannot be reduced to an aversion to psychoanalysis or psychological culture. Instead, such preference must be understood within the context of the dif- fusion of neuroscientific claims beyond the laboratory and their penetration in different domains of life in contemporary biomedicalized societies. Within this framework, neuroscientific theories, prac- tices, technologies and therapies are influencing the ways we think about ourselves and relate to others, favoring forms of neurological or cerebral subjectivation. The article shows how neuroscien- tific claims are taken up in the formation of identities, as well as social and community networks.
    [Show full text]
  • Autistica Action Briefing: Adult Mental Health
    Autistica Action Briefing: Adult Mental Health Harper G, Smith E, Simonoff E, Hill L, Johnson S, Davidson I. March 2019 Autistica is the UK’s autism research charity. This briefing summarises the most important scientific findings about mental health in autistic adults. It was developed in collaboration with leading researchers and autistic people with experience of the topic as an insight into the latest evidence. We strongly urge the Department of Health and Social Care, NHS policy-makers, commissioners, services and public research funders to act on this information. The evidence about mental health in autistic adults has moved on; services and policies to improve mental health must now do so as well. www.autistica.org.uk/AutismStrategy “If a neurotypical person was afraid to leave the house, that wouldn’t be seen as normal or okay. But if you’re 1 autistic you should just accept that that is the way your life is going to be.” What we know “The main problem with mental health services is that no one seems to want the responsibility 1 of putting him on their books… He keeps getting passed around departments” ▪ Almost 8 in 10 autistic adults experience a mental health problem.2 Autism is not a mental health condition itself, but mental health problems are one of the most common and serious challenges experienced by people across the spectrum. ▪ Up to 10% of adults in inpatient mental health settings are autistic,3 even though only 1% of the population is on the spectrum.4 ▪ Autistic people are often unable to access community mental health
    [Show full text]