INSIGHTS FROM EURASIA GROUP politics and the perspectives markets OCTOBER 2007

China’s financial sector reforms gain momentum by Jason Kindopp Director, Asia

he acceleration of financial sector reforms reflects policymakers’ desire to diversify capital allocation in the Chinese economy. The most significant initiatives seek to expandT opportunities for firms to raise equity capital and strengthen onshore stock markets. The government is actively fostering private equity and venture capital industries, and has signaled it is close to launching a new growth equity market (GEM). These measures, along with a recent liberalization in corporate bond issuance, Global Political are in turn pressuring China’s commercial banks to accel- Risk Index erate reform. The GPRI, which is produced by Eurasia Plans to broaden and deepen onshore equity mar- Group, measures a country’s ability to kets are emerging at a furious pace. Consistent with absorb political shocks. The higher the number, the more stable the country. Communist Party directives to cultivate domestic tech- nological innovation, as well as to support small and HUNGARY 78 SOUTH KOREA 76 medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), authorities are intent POLAND 73 on building up domestic private equity and venture BULGARIA 70 capital industries. In August 2007, the National Devel- TURKEY 68 opment and Reform Commission (NDRC) and the MEXICO 67 Ministry of Finance jointly launched a program to fund BRAZIL 66 CHINA 65 venture capital funds in nine sectors, including the IT, SOUTH AFRICA 64 telecom, energy and pharmaceutical industries. Similarly, 63 the government is combining its plan to foster indig- ARGENTINA 62 enous technological innovation with its support for the INDIA 61 THAILAND 61 Tianjin Binhai New Area special economic zone—part EGYPT 60 of a program to revitalize China’s northeast region—by ALGERIA 58 authorizing the establishment of up to 10 venture capital PHILIPPINES 58 funds to invest in innovative start-ups and technology COLOMBIA 57 UKRAINE 57 companies. Beijing is also overcoming its aversion to pri- government SAUDI ARABIA 57 vate equity funds. In addition to launching state-owned INDONESIA 56 society private equity firms, regulators lifted on September 11 the VENEZUELA 53 security government’s ban on domestic brokerages making private IRAN 51 equity investments by authorizing China International NIGERIA 50 economy PAKISTAN 44

Courtesy of Citi Private Bank Capital Corporation and Citic Securities Co. to make direct investments. CLOSE-UP: Russia Chinese authorities have ambitious Reshuffle prolongs succession speculation plans to deepen domestic stock markets, not only by increasing the number of stability Spotlight The recent government reshuffle, in which initial and secondary public offerings but the largely unknown Viktor Zubkov was named also by creating exit opportunities for prime minister, prolongs the uncertainty sur- direct investments in mainland firms. A 63 rounding President ’s succession. major trend this year has been for large The reshuffle demonstrates Putin’s firm control state-owned enterprises (SOEs) that rating forecast of Russian political life, and suggests that he have listed abroad to make secondary will not become a lame-duck president. First placements on domestic exchanges. On Deputy Prime Ministers and Dmitri August 22, the State Council approved Medvedev remain the leading potential successors, draft regulations to establish a new but Zubkov is now a leading contender as well. GEM, which is expected to launch in He is one of Putin’s old associates, and while his early 2008. The melding of direct equity political stripes are indistinct, he has some ties to investments in growth firms with a public the silovik clan among the Russian political elite. listing exit strategy on a newly established Zubkov’s relative anonymity and age (66) have GEM market could trigger capital flows fueled speculation that Putin could be planning into broad swaths of China’s economy. to groom Zubkov as a placeholder president, until At the same time, authorities are try- Viktor Zubkov, Russia’s newly he can return in 2012. If Zubkov’s public profile ing to strengthen mainland brokerages named prime minister, is a dramatically rises at home and abroad in the coming leading contender to succeed and expand the institutional investment months, this scenario might appear more likely. Vladimir Putin. industry. Regulators are poised to autho- The composition of the new cabinet, rize IPOs for as many as 10 domestic announced September 24, is positive for markets. Economy Minister brokerages that meet performance criteria. German Gref, Health Minister Mikhail Zurabov and Regional Authorities have also been quickly approv- Development Minister Vladimir Yakovlev were dismissed. They were ing new fund management companies. replaced by figures from the more liberal, reform-oriented wing of the Institutional investors were virtually non- Russian elite. Finance Minister kept his post, and was existent a few years ago, and now more elevated to deputy prime minister, reflecting the Kremlin’s commitment than 60 fund management companies in to fiscal discipline and broad macroeconomic stability. The appointment China manage approximately $250bn. of Putin’s North Caucasus envoy Dmitri Kozak to the post of regional Increasing the vehicles for capital development minister places another succession contender, and a allocation is escalating pressure on China’s liberal technocrat, in charge of an important ministry with broad commercial banks to accelerate reforms. national reach. Corporate debt issuance is poised to increase opportunities for firms to raise capital. Calls for deepening bank reform have come from the top of the political RUSSIA SUCCESSION WATCH hierarchy, most recently in an August If presidential elections were held next Sunday, public statement by President Hu Jin- how would you vote? tao, who pledged to build a “modern banking system.” China’s banks also face 85% of respondents had not mounting pressures from foreign banks Potential Succesors Poll Data heard of Zubkov before his that have incorporated locally. Annual Viktor Zubkov 4% revenue growth in mainland operations, appointment as prime minister, Vladimir Zhirinovsky 11% among the best-positioned foreign banks and 39% of Russians already such as Standard Chartered and HSBC, Gennady Zyuganov 15% consider him Putin’s successor. has reached up to 80%. These pressures 30% will compel China’s banks to broaden their loan portfolios beyond traditional Sergei Ivanov 34% state-owned enterprises and increase fee- Source: Levada Center poll, 14–18 September, 1,600 respondents, 49 regions.

based revenues. ➪ Legend: Positive change Negative change No rating ➪

2 politics and the markets I nside the Index In the following briefs, Eurasia Group analysts highlight the connections between stability and key political issues in important emerging markets.

LEGEND POLAND

government

society Iraq security

economy Mexico Saudi Arabia

Saudi Arabia GPRI 57

Stock market opens Saudi Arabia’s decision to open its stock market South africa to investors from the rest of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) nations on the ground, and the Iraqi South Africa from events the party more likely illustrates the kingdom’s government will likely face in global financial markets. to participate in future move toward more eco- new challenges, including a But South Africa’s cur- negotiations, despite nomic liberalization. high risk of implosion. rent account deficit, which opposition from party However, Saudi Arabia’s Meanwhile, tensions dropped to 6.5% of GDP leader and losing presi- decision stems from between the central gov- in the second quarter of dential candidate Andres broader geopolitical con- ernment in Baghdad and 2007 from a peak of 7.8% Manuel Lopez Obrador. siderations and is unlikely the Kurdish Regional Gov- in the fourth quarter of to stimulate the local index, ernment could flare up. 2006, remains a source Poland which has been down for Kurdish leaders are likely to of vulnerability, particu- GPRI 73 almost two years. The blame Prime Minister Nouri larly if commodity prices desire to implement equal- al Maliki for the expected drop rapidly. Elections uncertain ity among nationals of the postponement of the refer- As 21 October national GCC in holding and trading endum on the status of the Mexico: elections approach, it is stocks is intended to dem- oil-rich city of Kirkuk. onstrate the kingdom’s GPRI 67 still too early to call the commitment to regional winner. Law and Justice South Africa: Reforms likely integration—something it (PiS) and Civic Platform to pass had previously not deemed GPRI 64 (PO) parties are about even a high priority. Other GCC The congressional in the polls. Both PO and Foreign exchange states decided to open approval of both fiscal and the Left and Democrats reserves increase their respective stock mar- electoral reforms confirms party (LiD) are pro-market; kets in 2002. The Reserve Bank’s Sep- Calderon’s pragmatic their win would be most tember review showed strategy and reinserts favorable for capital market Iraq that international reserves, the Mexican left into the participants and investors. before reserve-related legislative process. Both If PiS returns to power, the GPRI NA loans, increased from reforms are highly likely to outlook is cloudier; in the $28.3 billion at the end of pass in state legislatures. event of an economic slow- Challenges continue June to $29.8 billion at the The modest fiscal reform down, fiscal policy could US decisions based on end of August. This should shows Calderon’s willing- become a problem because General David Petraeus’s strengthen the bank’s abil- ness to reach political PiS would be unwilling to progress report in Septem- ity to deal with financial compromises, improving make politically unpopular ber to the US Congress are market turmoil. Minister of the prospect for future decisions regarding not likely to affect the evo- Finance Trevor Manuel said reform negotiations. fiscal consolidation. lution of the situation in in early September that The approval of electoral Iraq. Sectarian politics will the government was build- reform strengthens the remain the dominant factor ing a cushion to protect PRD moderates and makes

Legend: Positive change Negative change No change

politics and the markets 3 The Outlook Key issues and possible outcomes for the coming month. country GPRI* outlook what to watch for Algeria 58 The president’s poor health and Ramadan will keep Algeria in a holding pattern for October. Argentina 62 Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner will win the October 28 presidential election in the first round. Brazil 66 The government will move toward securing renewal in full of financial transactions tax, which expires in December. Bulgaria 70 Parties prepare for local elections, but few major developments expected until after the late October polls. China 65 Hu will emerge from October’s Communist Party Congress with increased power. Colombia 57 Local elections in October will be marred by allegations of paramilitary intimidation and violence. Egypt 60 The government’s harsh response to media rumors about Mubarak’s alleged ill health shows uncertainty about succession. Hungary 78 Expected street protests against the government have occured but have been underwhelming. India 61 The UPA is likely to become a minority government following the Left Front’s withdrawal of support. Indonesia 56 The government’s weak response to successive earthquakes will likely generate criticism. Iran 51 Domestic divisions will persist, but international pressure will mitigate the regime’s instability. Mexico 67 Congressional negotiations create momentum that is likely to improve chances of future reforms. Nigeria 50 A tussle over monetary policy will raise concerns about the central bank’s independence. Pakistan 44 As Musharraf’s reelection approaches, opposition parties challenge his political future in courts. Philippines 58 Controversy surrounding an overpriced infrastructure project could implicate the president’s key allies. Poland 73 Outcomes of the elections are still unclear and another weak coalition government could emerge. Russia 63 Leading contenders to succeed Putin seek endorsement of ruling party at preelection congress. Saudi Arabia 57 The kingdom will remain stable in the short term, but tensions within the royal family are likely to erupt in the medium term. South Africa 64 The ruling ANC will begin to nominate candidates for the party elections in December. South Korea 76 Fanfare will accompany the Korean summit, but a substantive peace agreement is uncertain. Thailand 61 The junta will extend its reach into the next government by appointing a new army chief with three years before retirement. Turkey 68 Turkey’s bid for EU membership is expected to be revived after the new government takes office. Ukraine 57 Parliamentary elections will not yield a majority winner, prompting lengthy coalition negotiations. Venezuela 53 The government will ramp up spending to build support before a vote on constitutional amendments.

Legend: Positive outlook Negative outlook Neutral outlook *The GPRI, which is produced by Eurasia Group, measures a country’s ability to absorb political shocks. The higher the number, the more stable the country.

Citi Private Bank has retained Eurasia Group to offer political analysis and insight. The opinions expressed in this report are solely those of Eurasia Group and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Citi Private Bank or other business units of Citigroup Inc. Eurasia Group developed the first qualitative comparative political-and-economic-stability index, which Citi Private Bank has licensed, called the Global Political Risk Index, or GPRI. The index is designed to measure a country’s ability to absorb external or internal political shocks. Although the timing of such events cannot be predicted, the GPRI is meant to gauge how well particular nations would be able to withstand them.

All expressions of opinion are subject to change without notice and are not intended to be a guarantee of future events. This document is for information only and does not constitute a solicitation to buy or sell securities. Opinions expressed herein may differ from the opinions expressed by other businesses of Citigroup. Although information in this document has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, Citigroup Inc. and its affiliates do not warrant its accuracy or completeness and accept no liability for any direct or consequential losses arising from its use. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Throughout this publication where charts indicate that a third party (parties) is the source, please note that the source references the raw data received from such parties. The charts are designed by Citi Private Bank. Investors cannot invest directly in an index. Citi Private Bank provides private banking clients access to a broad array of products and services available through bank and non-bank affiliates of Citigroup Inc. Not all products and services are provided by all affiliates or are available in all locations, and not all investments are suitable for all investors. Investments are offered to Citi Private Bank clients in the US region through Citigroup Global Markets Inc. (CGMI), member SIPC. CGMI is an affiliate of Citigroup Inc. In the UK, certain services are available through Citibank, N.A. (“Citibank”) and Citibank International PLC, 33 Canada Square, Canary Wharf, London E14 5LB, which is autho- rized and regulated by the Financial Services Authority for the conduct of investment business in the UK and is a subsidiary of Citigroup Inc., USA. There are additional risks associated with international investments, including foreign political, currency and economic factors to consider.

Investment Products: Not FDIC Insured • No Bank Guarantee • May Lose Value

Copyright 2007, Citigroup Inc. All rights reserved. (1669)