CONTRIBUTIONS FROM THE hlUSEUM OF PALEONTOLOGY

THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN

VOL.23, NO.22, p. 349-33'5 (1 text-fig.) SEPTEMBER17, 1971

HERPETOFAUNA OF THE SANDAHL LOCAL FAUNA (PLEISTOCENE: ILLINOIAN) OF KANSAS

BY J. ALAN HOLMAN Museum, Michigan State University

MUSEUM OF PALEONTOLOGY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN .4NN ARBOR CONTKIBU'TIONS FROJI THE lIUSE;U?tl OF I'ALEOXTOLOGY

Director: ROBERT'Cr. KESLING

The series of contributions from the Museum of Paleontology is a medium for the publication of papers based chiefly upon the collection in the Museum. When the number of pages issued is sufficient to make a volume, a title page and a table of contents will be sent to libraries on the mailing list, and to individuals upon request. A list of the separate papers may also be obtained. Correspondence should be directed to the Museum of Paleontology, The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48104. VOLS.2-22. Parts of volumes may be obtained if available. Price lists available upon inquiry.

VOLUME23 1. The rodents from the Hagerman local fauna, Upper Pliocene of Idaho, by Richard J. Zakrzewski. Pages 1-36, with 13 text-figures. 2. .I new brittle-star from the Middle Devonian Arkona Shale of Ontario, by Robert V. Kesling. Pages 37-51, with 6 plates and 2 text-figures. 3. Phyllocarid crustaceans from the Middle Devonian Silica Shale of northwestern Ohio and southeastern Michigan, by Erwin C. Stumm and Ruth B. Chilman. Pages 53-71, with 7 plates and 4 text-figures. 4. Drepanaster wrighti, a new of brittle-star from the Middle Devonian Arkona Shale of Ontario, by Robert V. Kesling. Pages 73-79, with 2 plates. 5. CoraIs of the Traverse Group of Michigan. Part 13, Hexagonaria, by Erwin C. Stumm. Pages 81-91, with 4 plates. 6. The Pliocene rodent Microtoscoptes disjunctus (Wilson) from Idaho and Wyoming, by Claude W. Hibbard. Pages 95-98, with 2 text-figures. 7. A new microtine rodent from the Upper Pliocene of Kansas, by Claude W. Hibbard. Pages 99-103, with 1 plate and 1 text-figure. 8. Evolution of the fern family Osmundaceae based on anatomical studies, by Charles N. Miller, Jr. Pages 105-169, with 2 plates and 10 text-figures. 9. The insectivores of the Hagerman local fauna, Upper Pliocene of Idaho, by Claude W. Hibbard anrl Philip R. Bjork. Pages 171-180, with 4 text-figures. 10. Antiqzraster naagrzlmi, a new unusual brittle-star from the Middle Devonian Silica Forma- tion of northwestern Ohio, by Robert V. Kesling. Pages 181-191, with 4 plates and l text- figure. 11. Arms of Decadocrinus hughwingi Kesling, by Robert V. Kesling. Pages 193-199, with 3 plates. 12. Dolatocrinzls kz~tasii,a new crinoid from the Middle Devonian Bell Shale of Michigan, by Robert V. Kesling. Pages 201-211, with 5 plates and 1 text-figure. 13. Logocrinus brandoni, a new inadunate crinoid from the Middle Devonian Silica Shale of Ohio, by Jzlmes P. Sigler, Donald White, and Robert V. KesIing. Pages 213-220, with 2 plates and 2 text-figures. 14. Agostocrinzis and Acolocrinus, two new Ordovician crinoids with peculiar ray and respira- tory structures, by Robert V. Kesling and Christopher R. C. Paul. Pages 221-237, with 7 plates and 5 text-figures. 15. Fossil amphibians from the Egelhoff local fauna in north-central Nebraska, by Charles J. Chantell. Pages 239-246, with 1 plate. 16. Michigunaster inexpectatus, a new many-armed s~arfish from the Middle Devonian Rogers City Limestone of Michigan, by Robert V. Kesling. Pages 247-262, with 3 plates and 5 text-figures. 17. Pollen and spores from the Pre-Verne cyclical formation of the Saginaw Group, Grand Ledge, Michigan, U.S.A , by B. S Venkatachala and S. K. Salujha. Pages 263-281, with 7 plates. 18. Two new crinoids of the famiiy Scytalocrinidae from the Middle Devonian Silica Forma- tion of northwestern Ohio, by Robert V. Kesling. Pages 283-289, with l plate and 1 text-figure. 19. Ez~taxocrinuswideneri, a new flexible crinoid from the Middle Devonian Silica Formation of northwestern Ohio, by Robert V. Kesling and Harrell L. Strimple. Pages 291-303, with 6 plates and 2 texl-figures. 20. Strataster ohioensis, a new Early Mississippian brittle-star, and the paleoecology of its community, by Robert V. Kesling and Douglas Le Vasseur. Pages 305-341, with 13 plates and 9 text-figures. 21. Proctothylacocrinus berryorurn, e r,ew crinoid from the Middle Devonian Arkona Shale of Ontario, by Robert V. Kesling. Pages 343-347, with 2 plates. HERPETOFAUNA OF THE SANDAHL LOCAL FAUNA (PLEISTOCEKE: ILLINOIAN) OF KANSAS

BY J. ALAN HOLMAN Museum, Michigan State University

ABSTRACT-T~~herpetofauna of the Sandahl local fauna of McPherson County, Kansas, includes two turtles, a salamander, five anurans, three lizards, and six . None of these are extinct, and all represent forms that live in or near the area today. The presence of a permanent stream community, a stream border community, a gallery forest community, and grasslands, as indicated by the fish fauna and the mammal fauna, is supportcd by the herpetofauna. But the mammal fauna differs from the fish fauna and thc herpetofauna in that it has extralimital species of rodents with western affinities. Based on a comparison of areas of sympatry of extant fishes, amphibians, , and mammals in the Sandahl local fauna, it is tentatively suggested that the climate of the area in the Pleistocene was similar to that of northeastern Nebraska today, and that the two extralimital species of western rodents may have been relicts of more xeric times.

INTRODUCTION Hammann gravel pit.-NW H SE % sec. THESANDAHL LOCAL FAUNA consists of several 31, T 18 S, R 4 W, property of L. W. Ham- local faunules from the McPherson Formation, mann. McPherson County, Kansas, elevation 1420 Sandahl gravel pit.-SE SW % sec. 29, feet, that represent the Illinoian glacial stage T 18 S, R 4 W, property of Sandahl and Son's of the Pleistocene (Semken, 1966; Hibbard, Dairy. 1970). Semken detailed the mammalian ele- The specimens were collected by Dr. C. W. ments of the Sandahl local fauna; mentioned Hibbard and party of The University of Michi- the occurrence of mollusks, fishes, amphibians, gan Museum of Paleontology, summer of 1963, reptiles, and birds; redefined the age of the and Dr. Holmes A. Semken, Jr., now of the deposits; and made comments about the strati- University of Iowa De~artmentof Geology, graphic relationships and paleoecology. Other summer of 1964, under NSF project G 19458. less comprehensive references to faunal studies I should here like to thank these gentlemen for of the Sandahl local fauna are Cope (1889), the privilege of studying fossils collected and Harnly (1934), Hibbard ( 1952, 1970), Lille- curated by them. graven ( 1966), Lindahl ( 189 1) , Miller ( 1970), Nininger ( 1928), and Semken & Griggs (1965). Numbers used in the following report are With the exception of two turtles identified to those of the Vertebrate Collections of The Uni- , the herpetofauna has heretofore remained versity of Michigan Museum of Paleontology unstudied. Thus, the object of the present paper (UMMP V). All measurements are in milli- is to detail the herpetofauna of the Sandahl meters unless otherwise designated. Data for local fauna in order to fit the amphibians and Recent ranges and of Kansas amphib- reptiles into the paleoecological picture. ians and reptiles are from H. Smith ( 1956). Amphibians and reptiles discussed in this re- Following is a checklist of the amphibians port come from four localities (local faunules) and reptiles of the Sandahl local fauna as to in northwestern McPherson County, Kansas, their occurrence in the four localities (local designated as follows. faunules). The turtles were identified by Holmes Anderson gravel pit.-SW % NE % sec. 19, A. Semken, Jr. T 17 S, R 5 W, property of J. E. Anderson. Flohr gravel pit.-NE% SiV % sec. 7, T ANDERSONGRAVEL PIT 18 S, R 4 W, property of Miss Frances Flohr. Trionyx sp. Softshell turtle 3 50 J. ALAN HOLMAN

FLOHRGRAVEL PIT .-Today, breeding adults are found A mbystoma tigrinum Tiger salamander in temporary ponds and pools. Non-breeding Scaphiopus bombifrons Plains spadefoot adults are found hiding under material near Bufo woodhousei woodhousei Rocky Mountain ponds or pools, or they may be at some distance toad from the water in the holes of mammals or of Rana pipiens Leopard frog crayfish. ?Pseudemys Slider turtle Eumeces sp. Striped skink Order SALIENTIA Heterodon cf. H. platyrhinos Eastern hognose Family PELOBATIDAE SCAPHIOPUSBOMBIFRONS Cope lineatum Lined snake Material.-Flohr gravel pit: UMMP V- indet. Indeterminate natricine snakes 603 16, one right ilium. Sandahl gravel pit: HAMMANNGRAVEL PIT UMMP V-5 1817, one sphenethmoid ; V-5 18 18, three sphenethmoids; V-5 1819, two spheneth- ?Pseudemys Slider turtle moids; V-5 1820-5 1829, 10 sphenethmoids: V- SANDAHLGRAVEL PIT 5 1879, one sphenethmoid; V-5 1880, two sphe- A mbystoma tigrinum Tiger salamander nethmoids; V-51910, one left and one right Scaphiopus bombifrons Plains spadefoot ilium; V-5 1912, seven left and three right ilia; Bufo cognatus Great Plains toad V-5 1883, one sacrococcyx; V-5 1884, six sacro- Bufo woodhousei woodhousei Rocky Mountain coccyges. toad Remarks.--Tihen ( 1960) and Holman Bzlfo sp. indet. Indeterminate toad ( 1970) have discussed characters (sacrococ- Pseudacris triseriata Chorus frog cyges, Tihen; sphenethmoids, Holman) for the Rana pipiens Leopard frog identification of Scaphiopus bombifrons. This Sceloporinae indet. Indeterminate sceloporine species occurs in the Recent fauna of McPher- lizard son County. Eumeces sp. Striped skink Habitat.-At present, this species is found Cnemidophorus cf. C. sexlineatus Six-lined race- in fairly arid regions on loose or sandy soil, and runner it is normally associated with grasslands rather Heterodo~zcf. H. platyrhinos Eastern hognose than with flood plains or woodlands. snake Family BUFONIDAE Coluber or Masticophis Racer or Coachwhip Colubrinae indet. Indeterminate colubrine BUFO COGNATUS Say snakes Material.-Sandahl gravel pit: UMMP V- Natrix sipedon Common water snake 5 1919, one right ilium; V-51913, one left ilium; Thanznophis sp. Garter snake V-51897, one sacrum; V-51901, two sacra. Tropidoclonion lineatum Lined snake Remarks.-These two large Bufo ilia differ Natricinae indet. Indeterminate natricine snakes from those of Recent B. americanus, B. debilis, Crotalzls cf. C. viridis Western rattlesnake B. punctatus, and B. woodhousei and are similar to Recent B. cognatus and B. speciosus in hav- SYSTEMATIC PALEONTOLOGY ing a very high, rather than a moderately high Class AMPHIBIA to low ilial prominence. But I am unable to Order CAUDATA separate the latter two species on ilial characters Family AMBYSTOMATIDAE (Holman, 1964 and 1969). Nevertheless, the sacral vertebrae of B. cognatus appear to be AMBYSTOMATIGRINUM (Green) separable from those of both B. speciosus and Material.-Flohr gravel pit: UMMP V- B. w. woodhousei on the basis that, in dorsal 60315, one vertebra. Sandahl gravel pit: view, the condyles end only slightly posterior UMMP V-51882, 14 vertebrae, one left and to the posterior border of the neural arch in B. one right femur, one humerus; UMMP V- cognatus, whereas in B. speciosus and B. W. 5 1893, one vertebra. woodhousei the condyles project well posterior Remarks.-Tihen ( 1958 ) and Holman to the posterior border of the neural arch. This ( 1969) have discussed the identification of ver- character holds in two B, cognatus, nine B. tebrae of Anzbystoma tigrinum. The above fos- speciosus, and seven B. w. woodhousei. The sils represent small adult tiger salamanders. The fossil sacra resemble B. cognatus in this char- species occurs in the area today although there acter. Bufo cognatus occurs from the Middle are no specific locality records for McPherson Pliocene to the Recent (Tihen, 1962). Bufo County. cognatus is found in the Recent fauna of the HERPETOFAUNA 351 area today, although there are no specific local- tailed study of the osteology of Pseudacris. ity records for McPherson County. Based on characters of the ventral acetabular Habitat.-Today, this species is said to be expansion (Chantell, 1968, p. 386, fig. 3, and most common in the long grass and the mixed p. 388) all of the Sandahl ilia appear to repre- grass prairies, and to be less common in the sent the species P. triseriata. None of the eight short grass areas where it tends to be restricted fossil humeri have a reduced secondary ventral to the vicinity of streams. It is said to be rare crest as is said to occur in Recent P. t. triseriata in woodlands except as carried accidentally (Chantell, 1968), but have only a shallow chan- downstream into them. neling in this area as in Recent P. t. feriarum, P. t. maculata, and P. brimleyi. There is some BUFOWOODHOUSEI WOODHOUSEI Girard variation in characters in the five sacra (con- Material.-Flohr gravel pit: UMMP V- dyles widely separated in two, narrowly sep- 60317, one right ilium. Sandahl gravel pit: arated in three; prezygapophyses truncated in UMMP V-60318, one left and five right ilia; three, rounded in two), but this kind of vari- V-603 19, one left ilium; V-51920, one left and ation was common in a series of 31 skeletons of five right ilia; V-51900, three sacral vertebrae. Recent P. triseriata. The P. t. triseri- Remarks.-The ilial prominences of these ata is found near McPherson County, Kansas, fossils are higher than in Bufo americanus, B. today, but based on the humeral character noted debilis, B. punctatus, and B. woodhousei fowl- above the fossils may represent another sub- eri, but they are lower than in B. cognatus and species. According to the mammalian fauna B. speciosus, and are most similar to B. w. (Semken, 1966), which contains Wyoming woodhousei. The sacral vertebrae have the con- species that do not enter Kansas today, the pos- dyles projecting well posterior to the posterior sibility exists that the subspecies represented is border of the neural arch. It is interesting to P. t. maculata, a form that occurs just to the note that the subspecies B. w. woodhousei and northwest of Kansas in northeastern Colorado B. w. fowleri may be consistently separated on and southwestern Nebraska. There is a broad the basis of the higher ilial prominence of B. w. zone of intergradation between P. t. triseriata woodhousei. This has been reported by Tihen and P. t. maculata throughout most of eastern ( 1962). According to Tihen, the earliest veri- and central Nebraska. The status of the humeral fiable occurrence of B. w. woodhousei is the character in the intergrade populations is un- Jinglebob fauna of Meade County, Kansas, known. which is of Sangamon or early Wisconsin age. Habitat.-The habitat of the chorus frog The Sandahl record thus extends the range of today is swampy and marshy places, and in this subspecies back in time to the Illinoian. flood plains. Recent B. w. woodhousei occurs in the area to- day, but there are no specific locality records Family RANIDAE for McPherson County. RANAPIPIENS Schreber Habitat.-At present, these toads are said Material.-Flohr gravel pit: UMMP V- to be most abundant in long grass and mixed grass prairies, where they inhabit a large vari- 60321, one right and one left ilium. Sandahl ety of situations, and they are likely to enter gravel pit: UMMP V-60322, six left and six wooded areas. right ilia; V-603 23, five left and five right ilia; V-5 1899, three sacral vertebrae. BUFO sp. indet. Remarks.-The ilia of Rana pipiens are easily separated from those of Rana catesbeiana Material.-Sandahl gravel pit: UMMP V- on the basis of having a much more gentle, less 5 1898, one fragmentary sacrum. precipitous slope of the posterodorsal border of Renzarks.-A sacrum of a large toad is too the ilial crest into the dorsal acetabular expan- fragmentary for specific determination. sion. The ilia of R. pipiens may be separated from those of areolata on the basis that in Family HYLIDAE R. R. areolata (R. a. areolata three; R. a. circu- PSEUDACRISTRISERIATA (Wied) losa three, R. a. aesophus one) the vastus Material.-Sandahl gravel pit: UMMP V- prominence (Holman, 1965b) is narrower, more 60320, one left ilium; V-60452, one left ilium; rounded, and less flattened than in R. pipiens. V-51914, 12 right and four left ilia; V-51892, Moreover, in most specimens of R. pipiens the three left and five right humeri; V-5 1902, five posterodorsal border of the ilial crest slopes sacra; V-5 1903, two sacra. more gently into the dorsal acetabular expan- Remarks.-Chantell ( 1968) provided a de- sion in R. areolata than in R. pipiens. Rana 352 J. ALAN HOLMAN pipiens has been recorded from the Recent fauna Family of McPherson County. HETERODONcf. HETERODONPLATYRHINOS Habitat.-At present, Rana pipiens is a Latreille ubiquitous anuran that is said to frequent about any aquatic situation during the breeding sea- Material.-Flohr gravel pit: UMMP V- son, but during much of the year individuals 50485, one vertebra. Sandahl gravel pit: UMMP may reside in damp places rather far from water. V-50451, 13 vertebrae. Remarks.-Based on the flatter anterior Class REPTILIA borders of their prezygapophyseal faces (Hol- Order CHELONIA man, 1963) I tentatively assign these vertebrae to H. platyrhinos rather than to H. nasicus; Two turtles, Trionyx sp. (softshell turtle) although based on a greater number of Recent and ?Pseudemys sp. (slider turtle) were re- skeletal specimens than were available in 1963, ported from the Sandahl local fauna by Sem- there is some overlap in this character, as one ken (1966, p. 138). of 19 H. platyrhinos has the rounded condition, and there are some intermediate conditions in Family IGUANIDAE three of 13 H. platyrhinos and one of three H. SCELOPORINAEsp. indet. nasicus. Heterodon platyrhinos is found in the Material.-Sandahl gravel pit: UMMP V- Recent fauna of the area today, but there are 51878, two fragmentary right maxillae. no specific locality records for McPherson Remarks.-The more fragmentary of the County. two bones has more distinctly tricuspid teeth Habitat.-At present, this species prefers than the more complete bone. The small scelo- dry areas where ample sunlight reaches the porine lizards, Sceloporus undulatus and Hol- ground. These snakes are to be found in dry brookia maculata, are recorded from the Recent woods, or sandy river shores, in sand dunes; fauna of McPherson County, Kansas. but they are seldom found in moist or heavily wooded areas. Family SCINCIDAE COLUBERor MASTICOPHISsp. indet. EUMECESsp. indet. Material.-Sandahl gravel pit: UMMP V- Material.-Flohr gravel pit: UMMP V- 603 26, six fragmentary vertebrae. 60324, one partial left dentary. Sandahl gravel Remarks.-These fragmentary vertebrae pit: UhlMP V-51881, one left dentary. represent either Coluber or Masticophis, but I Remarks.-The dentary is smaller and has have not been able to carry the identification more slender teeth than in adult Eunzeces abso- any farther. Coluber constrictor and Mastico- letus, but I am unable to carry the identifica- phis flagellum are found in the area today, al- tion to species. Small lizards of the genus Eu- though specific locality records are not avail- meces that occur in or near the area today are able for McPherson County. E. anthracinus, E. fasciatus, and E, septen- trionalis. COLUBRINAEsp. indet. Family TE~IDAE Material.-Sandahl gravel pit: UMMP V- CNEMIDOPHORUScf . CNEMIDOPHORUS 6032 7, 11 fragmentary vertebrae. SEXLINEATUS (Linnaeus) Remarks.-These vertebrae represent snakes of the subfamily Colubrinae, but the bones are Material.-Sandahl gravel pit: UMMP V- so worn and fragmentary that I cannot identify 60325, a partial left dentary. any of them to the generic level. Remarks.-The dentary represents a small Cnemidophorus that is very similar to Recent NATRIXSIPEDON (Linnaeus) C. sexlineatus. The bone represents the anterior part of a dentary, and it contains nine teeth Material.-Flohr gravel pit: UMMP V- and two empty alveoli. The two anteriormost 60328, three vertebrae. Sandahl gravel pit: teeth are unicuspid, but the next seven are UMMP V-60329, 48 vertebrae. bicuspid. Cnemidophorus sexlineatus is re- Remarks.-These relatively large natricine corded from the Recent fauna of McPherson vertebrae (see Brattstrom, 1967, p. 189) are County. assigned to the genus Natrix rather than to Habitat.-Today, the habitat is in relative- Thamnophis. Some of these vertebrae are com- ly dry areas where there is sandy or other loose plete enough to compare at the specific level. soil and where there is short grass or other These complete fossils resemble Recent Na- kinds of low vegetation. trix sipedon and differ from Recent N. erythro- HERPETOFAUNA 3 53

gaster and N. rhombifera in having much lower Remarks.-These vertebrae are too frag- neural spines. They resemble N. sipedon and mentary, are too worn, or are from such parts differ from Regina (Natrix) grahami in having of the vertebral column that they cannot be as- the tips of the hypapophyses pointed or nar- signed to the generic level. rowly rounded rather than truncated. This spe- cies occurs in the Recent fauna of the area Family CROTALIDAE today, but there are no specific locality records CROTALUScf. CROTALUSVIRIDIS (Rafinesque) for McPherson County. Material.-Sandahl gravel pit: UMMP Habitat.-This snake is presently found V- 60334, two vertebrae. near streams, rivers, marshes, permanent ponds, Remarks.-These vertebrae are rather frag- and lakes. It is said to wander several hundred feet from water at times. mentary, but they are very similar to Recent Crotalus viridis vertebrae. The largest fossil THAMNOPHISsp. indet. represents an about 10 cm long based Material.-Sandahl gravel pit: UMMP V- on a Recent skeleton at hand. Crotalus viridis 60453, 12 vertebrae. is found in the Recent fauna of the area today, Remarks.-These relatively large, elongate but specific locality records are lacking from natricine vertebrae (see Brattstrom, 1967, p. McPherson County. 189) are assigned to the genus Thamnophis. Habitat.-At present, this species is said to Most of them are incomplete, but one large ver- be commonly found in prairies, prairie canyons, tebra that is almost comglete is more similar and other grasslands. to Recent Thamnophis marcianus and T. radix DISCUSSION than to T. sirtalis and T. proximus in that the posterior part of the neural spine has a well- hllken (1966) outlined five major ecologi- developed overhanging portion, rather than hav- cal communities indicated by the fossil fishes ing its posterior edge straight or gently curved and mammals of the Sandahl local fauna. The as in the latter two species. But this fossil is herpetofauna fits well into this picture (table 1). larger than any T. marcianus or T. radix 1 have on the other hand, the regional ~aleoecologic~l seen (10 T. radix and seven T. marcianus picture is puzzling, for the area of sympatry tons). Measurements of the nearly complete (the area where all of the extant species could fossil are: length through zygapophyses 6.2, be living together today) of the extant width through posterior zygapophyses 5.5, mammals of the Sandahl local fauna lies to the height through neural spine and hypapophyses the area sympatry the l1 extant 5.8. Thamnophis marcianus occurs to the west amphibians and repti1es and southwest of McPherson County, Kansas, Ecolo~icalc~rnmunities. - The ecological today, the closest locality record being in Bar- communities indicated by the fishes and mam- ber County to the southwest. Thamnophis radix: mals of the hldahl local fauna (Semken, 1966) has been recorded from the Recent fauna of are a permanent stream McPherson County. munity, (2) a stream border community, (3) a gallery forest community, (4) a lowland TROPIDOCLONIONLINEATUM (Hallowell) meadow-savanna community, and (5) an up- Material.-Flohr gravel pit: UMMP V- land prairie 60330, two vertebrae. Sandahl gravel pit: Herpetofaunal members of the permanent UMMP V-6033 1, 45 vertebrae. stream community would include Trionj~x(the Remarks.-All of the very small natricine softshell turtle) and Pseudemys (the slider vertebrae are easily assignable to the species turtle). These animals are characteristic of the Tropidoclonion lineatum based on characters parts permanent streams. detailed in Holman (196sa, p. 103). hi^ spe- Natrix sipedon (the common water snake) and cies occurs in the area today, but there are no Rana Pipiens (the leopard frog) would enter specific locality records for McPherson County. the water time time, the water snake Habitat.-Today, these snakes hide under to search for food, the frog to escape predators. stones, logs, rock fences, and other cover on the The stream be surface of the ground, presumably in grassland inhabited Natrix sipedon (the regions. water snake), Pseudacris triseriata (the chorus frog), Rana pipiens (the leopard frog), and NATRICINAEindet. Heterodon cf. platyrhinos (the hognose snake), 1Material.-Flohr gravel pit: UMMP V- on ssndy banks. Occasionally, herpetofaunal 60332, 10 vertebrae. Sandahl gravel pit: UMMP members of the gallery forest might come into V-60333, 156 vertebrae. the stream border community looking for food. J. ALAN HOLMAN

Permanent Stream Gallery Grasslands Minimum Total Stream Border Forest Number of Number of Communitv Communitv Communitv Individuals Vertebrae Ambystoma tigrinum Scaphiopus bombifrons Bufo cognatus Bufo w. woodhousei Pseztdacris triseriata Rana pipiens Trionyx sp. Pseudemys sp. Eumeces sp. Cnemidophorm cf. sexlineatus Heterodon cf. platyrhinos Coluber or Masticophis Colubrinae indet. Natrix sipedon Thamnophis sp. Tropidoclonion lineatum Natricinae indet. Crotalzcs cf. viridis TOTALS 2 4 3 7 65 3 09

The gallery forest community would have skink) , Cnemidophorus cf. sexlineatus (the six- been inhabited by Ambystoma tigrinum (the lined racerunner), Coluber or Masticophus (the tiger salamander), Bufo w. woodhousei (the racer or coachwhip), Tropidoclonion lineatum Rocky Mountain toad), and probably Tham- (the lined snake), and Crotalus cf. viridis (the lzophis (the garter snake). western rattlesnake). The remainder of the herpetofauna could Regional paleoeco1ogy.-It is important to be found either in the lowland meadow-savanna note that if the Sandahl local fauna vertebrate community or in the upland prairie community. fauna is taken as a whole, there is no one area These communities have been combined under in the United States today where all of the the term "grasslands" in table 1 of this paper. extant species can be found living together. Grassland forms include: Scaphiopus bombi- If the area of sympatry of the 11 extant frons (the Plains spadefoot), Bufo cognatus mammals, as plotted by Semken (1966) is (the Great Plains toad), Eumeces sp. (the compared with the area of sympatry of the 11 extant amphibians and reptiles as plotted in this paper (text-fig. 1) the mammalian area covers southeastern Wyoming and north central / SOUTH DAKOTA Colorado, whereas the herpetofaunal area cov- I ers extreme southeastern South Dakota, eastern Nebraska, central Kansas, and barely touches NEBRASKA north central Oklahoma. The fish fauna also shows eastern and northern affinities, with Perca flavescens (the yellow perch) extending south- ward only to northeastern Nebraska (Smith, 1963) and Stizostedion vitreum (the walleye) extending southward only to northeastern Kan- sas. Both fishes were identified in the Sandahl locality by Semken (1966). This is a puzzling situation that I find diffi- cult to interpret. One can account for mixing of OKLAHOMA NEW MEXICO TEXAS northern and southern elements in Pleistocene faunas by envisioning a more moderate climate, TEXT-FIG. 1.-Present area of sympatry of Sandahl with cooler summers and milder winters. But it local fauna extant mammals (solid area) and of is difficult to imagine differences in annual Sandahl local fauna extant amphibian spe- cies (unshaded area). The star indicates the San- moisture that would allow for such a mixing of dahl localities in McPherson County, Kansas. eastern and western species. HERPE'I

Nevertheless, if one removed Citellus rich- , 1964, Pleistocene amphibians and reptiles from ardsoni (Richardson's ground squirrel) and Texas: Herpetologica, v. 20, p. 73-83. , 1965a, Pleistocene snakes from the Seymour Cytnomys cf. gunnisoni (the whitetail prairie Formation of Texas: Copeia, 1965, p. 102-104. dog) from the fauna, the areas of sympatry of , 1965b, Early Miocene anurans from Florida: the mammalian fauna and the herpetofauna Quart. Jour. Florida Acad. Sci., v. 28, p. 68-82. would overlap in eastern Nebraska (see Sem- , 1969, Herpetofauna of the Pleistocene Slaton local fauna of Texas: Southwestern Naturalist, ken, 1966, fig. 7, light bars, and text-fig. 1, this v. 14, no. 2, p. 203-212. paper). Both the herpetofaunal and the mam- , 1970, A Pleistocene herpetofauna from Eddy malian areas of sympatry would probably over- County, New Mexico: Texas Jour. Sci., v. 22, lap those of (the yellow perch) p. 29-39. Perca jlavescens LILLEGRAVEN,J. A., 1966, Bison crassicornis and the a.nd Stizostedion vitreum (the walleye) in north- ground sloth Megalonyx jeffersoni in the Kansas eastern Nebraska. Therefore, considering the Pleistocene: Trans. Kansas Acad. Sci., v. 69, p. entire vertebrate fauna, perhaps it is best to 294-300. LINDAHL,J., 1891, Description of a skull of Megalonyx tentatively postulate a climate similar to north- leidyi n. sp.: Trans. American Philos. Soc., v. 17, eastern Nebraska today, and to consider that p. 1-10. the two western rodent species were relicts of MILLER, B. B., 1970, The Sandahl molluscan fauna (Illinoian) from McPherson County, Kansas: Ohio more xeric times. Jour. Sci., v. 70, p. 39-50. NININGER,H. H., 1928, Pleistocene fossils from Mc- LITERATURE CITED Pherson County, Kansas: Trans. Kansas Acad. Sci., v. 31, p. 96, 97. BRATTSTROM,B. H., 1967, A succession of Pliocene and SEMKEN,H. A., JR., 1966, Stratigraphy and paleontol- Pleistocene snake faunas from the High Plains of ogy of the McPherson Equus beds (Sandahl local the United States: Copeia, 1967, p. 188-202. fauna), McPherson County, Kansas: Contrib. Mus. CHANTELL,C. J., 1968, The osteology of Pseudacris Paleontology, Univ. Michigan, v. 20, p. 121-178. (Amphibia:Hylidae) : American Midl. Naturalist, , & GRIGGS,C. D., 1965, The long-nosed peccary, V. 80, p. 381-391. Mylohyus nasutus, from McPherson County, Kan- COPE, E. D., 1889, The Edentata of North America: sas: Papers Michigan Acad. Sci., Arts, Letters, v. American Naturalist, v. 23, no. 272, p. 651-664. 50, p. 267-274. HIBBARD,C. W., 1952, Vertebrate fossils from Late SMITH, G. R., 1963, A late Illinoian fish fauna from Cenozoic deposits of central Kansas: Univ. Kansas southwestern Kansas and its climatic significance: Paleontol. Contrib., Vertebrata, art. 2, p. 1-14. Copeia, 1963, p. 278-285. , 1970, Pleistocene mammalian local faunas SMITH, H. M., 1956, Handbook of amphibians and rep- from the Great Plains and Central Lowland prov- tiles of Kansas: Univ. Kansas Mus. Nat. History inces of the United States. In, Pleistocene and Misc. Publ. 9, 2d ed., p. 1-356. Recent environments of the Central Great Plains: TIHEN, J. A,, 1958, Comments on the osteology and Dept. Geol. Univ. Kansas Sp. Publ. 3, p. 395-433. phylogeny of ambystomatid salamanders: Bull. HARNLY,H. J., 1934, Vertebrate fossils from McPher- Florida State Mus., v. 3, p. 1-50. son Equus beds: Trans. Kansas Acad. Sci., v. 37, , 1960, On Neoscaphzopus and other Pliocene p. 151. pelobatid frogs: Copeia, 1960, p. 89-94. HOLMAN,J. A., 1963, Late Pleistocene amphibians and , 1962, A review of New World fossil bufonids: reptiles of the Clear Creek and Ben Franklin local American Midl. Naturalist, v. 68, p. 1-50. faunas of Texas: Jour. Grad. Research Center, So. Methodist Univ., v. 31, p. 152-167.