DOCSLIB.ORG

Essential Teamwork in Dealing with the Media

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Essential Teamwork in Dealing with the Media Making the world a more just place by educating and inspiring its judiciary SPONSORED BY THE TEXAS MUNICIPAL COURTS EDUCATION CENTER ESSENTIAL TEAMWORK IN DEALING WITH THE MEDIA Professor Benjamin A. Holden OBJECTIVES: After this session you will be able to: 1. Discuss the relationship between the courts and the press; 2. Increase understanding of how the press operates; and 3. Identify methods for achieving effective press coverage. REQUIRED READING: PAGE Benjamin A. Holden, Essential Teamwork in Dealing with the Media – or – How the Third Branch Can Coexist with the Fourth Estate (and Vice Versa) (Jan. 2018) [NJC PowerPoint] .........................................................................................................1 CUSTOM: ESSENTIAL TEAMWORK IN DEALING WITH THE MEDIA FOR THE MB/KZ TEXAS MUNICIPAL COURTS EDUCATION CENTER FEBRUARY 11, 2018 HOUSTON, TX Essential Teamwork In Dealing with the Media -or- How The Third Branch Can Co-Exist with the Fourth Estate (And vice versa) February 11, 2018 Ben Holden, Assistant Professor/Teaching College of Media University of Illinois Media’s Importance to Democracy “Our liberty depends on the freedom of the press, and that cannot be limited without being lost.” ~ Thomas Jefferson I. Who ‘They’ Are Reporters: Young, Scared, Ill-trained Mid-level editors: Targeted for extinction Top editors: Fighting publisher to avoid cuts Publisher: Fighting corporate to avoid cuts All: Multi-tasking like hamsters on a treadmill 1 The Media – Who They Are 40% of journalism jobs lost in past 10 years. U.S. Labor Department – Sept. 2012 Employment of reporters, correspondents, and broadcast news analysts is projected to decline 9% from 2014 to 2024. What is causing the loss of media jobs? Declining advertising revenue IA. The Alternative Bloggers, Tweeters, Texters, specialty website operators, true-crime story hunters, interested party “observers,” disinterested (very focused) “observers,” and various quasi-journalists. “I believe The First Amendment Law of the future will be made by these impecunious individuals…“ -- Floyd Abrams, counsel to New York Times, partner, Cahill, Gordon & Reindel LLP, & RNCCM board member 2 IB. Enlightened Self-Interest BOTTOM LINE: Don't make them sue you. The bad news for democracy is traditional corporate news organizations may not be able/willing to appeal incorrect First Amendment rulings because of corporate pressures...Even if they are right on the law II. Who ‘You’ Are (In Their Eyes) Lawyers: Rich and slavishly dedicated to the status quo Judges: Imperious, aloof and unreachable The Law: Unnecessarily complicated; constructed and administered to serve the wealthy and connected II. What ‘They’ Want and Need Good, clean rulings on: 1. Access to courtrooms 2. Access to court records 3. Open meetings disputes involving other branches of government 4. Judicial rulings including appropriate in- camera transcripts, motions in limine and jury instructions 3 II. What They Want and Need (Cont.) 5. Never ever, ever grant a prior restraint -- unless the paper is trying to disclose troop movements, spy names, bombing-striking targets or bomb making recipes. 6. Unmasking-you may be able to order it. Vol. 1 ISSUE 1 RCMLJ (judges.org) II. What They Want And Need (Cont.) 1. Quickly and decisively dispose of Sheppard v. Maxwell motions on venue and new trials 2. AKA: The 7 Habits of Highly Effective Judges III. An Approach Toward Improved Cooperation 1. M-V-P 2. Meetings to educate 3. (shared) Vocabulary 4. Press Releases on Good News/ Syllabus opinions 4 IV. What’s In It for You? “What distinguishes a truly free society from all others is an independent judiciary and a free press. ” -- Edward R. Murrow, journalist and crusader against the Red Scare and other threats to Democracy IV. What’s In It for You? (Cont.) (Or enlightened self-interest ) Do you really want the replacement refs explaining to the public: Controversial judicial orders (e.g., Exclusionary rule) Complex legal concepts (e.g., ‘Nullification’) Retention elections Judicial compensation Managing The Press 1. Have press management system 2. Know how media are structured 3. Share ‘after-hours’ numbers 5 What’s In It for You? “What distinguishes a truly free society from all others is an independent judiciary and a free press. ” ~ Edward R. Murrow, journalist and crusader against the Red Scare and other threats to Democracy A Judge’s Toolbox 1. On the record 2. Not for attribution 3. Background 4. Deep background A Standard Newspaper Hierarchy (1) EE (2) ME (above 200K circ.) (3) City Editor (4A) Legal Affairs Reporter (4B) General Assignment Reporter 6 Standard Newspaper Hierarchy Executive Editor Managing Editor City Sports Features Copy Desk Editor Editor Editor Chief Legal Affairs General Copy Assignment Reporter Reporter Editor Newspaper Woes May Be Your Opportunity Decline in newspaper FTEs How newspaper people think Tips on working with a depleted press Threshold Issues: • Do you Have a PIO? • Can You “do business” with the EE? • Is the paper connected to a larger group? End of Segment 1 7 Essential Teamwork In Dealing with the Media -or- How The Third Branch Can Co- Exist with the Fourth Estate (And vice versa) Telling The Court’s Story (And Your Own) A. Good Stories About The Judiciary 1. New courtroom openings. 2. Retirements of beloved jurists. 3. “Firsts” among women, minorities, etc. 4. Drug courts and innovative sentencing. 8 Good Stories About The Judiciary 5. Hard Time For Hard Offenders – Judge Rosemarie Aquilina on Larry Nassar. 6. Innovation in Media Relations – Judge Terry Ruckriegle in Kobe Bryant Case. B. Telling The Court’s Good Stories (And Your Own) 1. The press-ready press release. 2. Knowing news deadlines. 3. Knowing your beat reporter. 4. The ‘evergreen’ story. C. Working with the Press to Minimize the Impact of “Bad” Stories (Crisis Communication 101) 9 Working With The Press To Minimize The Impact of ‘Bad’ Stories 1. Draft ‘talking points’ and stick to them. 2. Say only what you want to be quoted saying. 3. Do not be afraid to (calmly) repeat yourself. Working With The Press To Minimize The Impact of ‘Bad’ Stories 4. Tell the truth; never lie. 5. No. 5 does not mean disclosure of everything you know. 6. Build trust: don’t make this the first time you talk to this reporter. Working With The Press To Minimize The Impact of ‘Bad’ Stories 7. Don’t ask a professional journalist to read back a quote; instead try: “I’m happy to help make sure you got that right; I know this may be a little confusing.” 10 End of Segment 2 Essential Teamwork In Dealing with the Media -or- How The Third Branch Can Co- Exist With the Fourth Estate (And vice versa) Mistrial by Mobile – Social Media and Your (Millennial) Jurors 11 Ethical Perils for Attorneys Who Use Social Networking Apr. 2009: Sean Conway, a lawyer, was angry at a judge So he blogged that the judge was an “Evil, unfair witch!” Florida Bar reprimanded and fined him Judicial Ethics and Social Media Do you currently have a professional Facebook account? Judicial Ethics and Social Media Do you currently have a personal Facebook account? 12 Best Social Media Practices & Cautionary Tales for Judges Courts Wrestle with Social Networks In civil fraud lawsuit, boss sent text message to his employee on witness stand during a sidebar conference about employee’s testimony Spectator alerted judge who confronted the boss and employee and read their texts into the record Judge said the texts were “underhanded and calculated to undermine the integrity… of the legal process.” Result: Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Scott Silverman dismissed the lawsuit Judges on Facebook Should a judge be on Facebook? CCPIO’s Report Released August 26, 2010 says 40% of judges have Facebook accounts Most of those are elected judges 13 Williams-Yulee v. The Florida Bar Holding: Florida’s ban on the personal solicitation of campaign funds by candidates for judgeships does not violate the First Amendment. States may prohibit judicial candidates from personally soliciting money. 5 – 4 decision – sharply divided court North Carolina Judge Faces Ethics Problem Judge presided over custody and support hearing “Friended” the attorney for the defendant on Facebook Discussed the case and whether one of the parties had had an affair Used Google to conduct own research on plaintiff Query: The Judge’s Conduct Is … a. Not actionable because he was exercising his First Amendment rights; or b. Requires a public reprimand to educate other judges and the public about appropriate communications; or c. Requires private censure because the judge and public can be educated without publically embarrassing the judge; or d. Requires a suspension; or e. Requires termination? 14 Result in North Carolina North Carolina judge was issued a public reprimand South Carolina Magistrate judge may be Facebook “friends” with law enforcement officers and employees as long as no discussion of anything relating to judge’s position as magistrate judge New York Judge may be a Facebook friend of lawyer on judge’s calendar but Judge must avoid the appearance of impropriety Judge’s conduct must promote public confidence in integrity and impartiality of judiciary 15 Kentucky Being Facebook friends does not “reasonably convey” the impression that the lawyer Facebook friend to a judge is in a special position to influence the judge. Judges should be mindful of whether online connections alone or in combination with other facts rise to the level of “a close social relationship” that should be disclosed and/or requires recusal. Ohio Allegation that judge wrote emails to newspaper about cases pending in her court. Emails came from judge’s account (“lawmiss”) at times when someone was logged into her office computer. Judge denies that she wrote emails and sued newspaper for invasion of privacy. Ohio A judge may be a “friend” on a social networking site with a lawyer who appears as counsel in a case before the judge.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Ethics in Photojournalism: Past, Present, and Future
    Ethics in Photojournalism: Past, Present, and Future By Daniel R. Bersak S.B. Comparative Media Studies & Electrical Engineering/Computer Science Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 2003 SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF COMPARATIVE MEDIA STUDIES IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE IN COMPARATIVE MEDIA STUDIES AT THE MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY SEPTEMBER, 2006 Copyright 2006 Daniel R. Bersak, All Rights Reserved The author hereby grants to MIT permission to reproduce and distribute publicly paper and electronic copies of this thesis document in whole or in part in any medium now known or hereafter created. Signature of Author: _____________________________________________________ Department of Comparative Media Studies, August 11, 2006 Certified By: ___________________________________________________________ Edward Barrett Senior Lecturer, Department of Writing Thesis Supervisor Accepted By: __________________________________________________________ William Uricchio Professor of Comparative Media Studies Director Ethics In Photojournalism: Past, Present, and Future By Daniel R. Bersak Submitted to the Department of Comparative Media Studies, School of Humanities, Arts, and Social Sciences on August 11, 2006, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science in Comparative Media Studies Abstract Like writers and editors, photojournalists are held to a standard of ethics. Each publication has a set of rules, sometimes written, sometimes unwritten, that governs what that publication considers to be a truthful and faithful representation of images to the public. These rules cover a wide range of topics such as how a photographer should act while taking pictures, what he or she can and can’t photograph, and whether and how an image can be altered in the darkroom or on the computer.
    [Show full text]
  • Combatting Fake News
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Southern Methodist University Science and Technology Law Review Volume 20 | Number 2 Article 17 2017 Combatting Fake News: Alternatives to Limiting Social Media Misinformation and Rehabilitating Quality Journalism Dallas Flick Southern Methodist University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholar.smu.edu/scitech Part of the Internet Law Commons Recommended Citation Dallas Flick, Combatting Fake News: Alternatives to Limiting Social Media Misinformation and Rehabilitating Quality Journalism, 20 SMU Sci. & Tech. L. Rev. 375 (2017) https://scholar.smu.edu/scitech/vol20/iss2/17 This Comment is brought to you for free and open access by the Law Journals at SMU Scholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in Science and Technology Law Review by an authorized administrator of SMU Scholar. For more information, please visit http://digitalrepository.smu.edu. Combatting Fake News: Alternatives to Limiting Social Media Misinformation and Rehabilitating Quality Journalism Dallas Flick* I. INTRODUCTION The continued expansion and development of the Internet has generated a malicious side effect: social media intermediaries such as Facebook and Google permit the dispersion of third-party generated fake news and misin- formation. While the term “fake news” tends to shift in definition, it most frequently denotes blatantly false information posted on the Internet intended to sway opinion.1 The social and political implications for
    [Show full text]
  • Through the Network (Of Networks) – the Fifth Estate* By
    Through the Network (of Networks) – the Fifth Estate* by William H. Dutton Professor of Internet Studies Oxford Internet Institute University of Oxford *Prepared for an Inaugural Lecture, Examination Schools, University of Oxford, 15 October 2007. I thank Martin Elton, Linda Frankland, Ellen Helsper, Malcolm Peltu and Juliet Webster for their comments and encouragement to discuss this topic. 1 It is an honour for me to present my inaugural lecture to you, and to do so here in The Examination Schools. This is a special place and – as we all know – place matters. Today, I will focus on how – in Internet time and space – users are able to reconfigure their access to information, people and other resources in new ways that are of major significance for society. The Rise of a Fifth Estate in Internet Time and Space In an earlier era, printing was tied to the rise of the press as a major institution. Its subsequent growing role in conjunction with the development of radio, television and other mass media has created an independent institution in many nations, which has become known as the ‘Fourth Estate’. This has become central to pluralist democratic processes. Today I would like to explain why I believe it would not be an exaggeration to argue that a new form of social accountability is emerging in what I am calling the ‘Fifth Estate’. It is enabled by the growing use of the Internet and related information and communication technologies (ICTs), such as the personal computer and World Wide Web. Essentially, the Internet is enabling people to network with other individuals and with a vast range of information, services and technical resources.
    [Show full text]
  • Jls 725 Editorial Writing
    EDITORIAL JLS 725 WRITING JLS725 EDITORIAL WRITING Course Code JLS725 Course Title Editorial Writing Course Developer/Writer Andrew Asan Ate. Igbinedion University, Okada, Benin City. Course Editor Mr Oloruntola Sunday Department of Mass Communication, University of Lagos, Akoka. Course Coordinator Chidinma H. Onwubere National Open University of Nigeria Victoria Island, Lagos. Programme Leader Christine I. Ofulue , Ph.D National Open University of Nigeria Victoria Island, Lagos. NATIONAL OPEN UNIVERSITY OF NIGERIA ii JLS725 EDITORIAL WRITING National Open University of Nigeria Headquarters 14/16 Ahmadu Bello Way Victoria Island Lagos Abuja Office National Open University of Nigeria 5, Dar Es Salaam Street, Off Aminu Kano Crescent Wuse 11 Abuja, Nigeria. e-mail: [email protected] URL : www.nou.edu.ng Published by: National Open University of Nigeria 2008 First Printed 2008 ISBN: 978-058-748-9 All Rights Reserved iii JLS725 EDITORIAL WRITING CONTETS PAGE Module 1……………………………………………………. 1 Unit 1 Meaning of Editorial and Qualities of Good Editorials……………………………………… 1-6 Unit 2 Public Opinion and Editorials...……………… 7-14 Unit 3 Editorials and other Forms of Writing………... 15-21 Module 2……………………………………………………. 22 Unit 1 Sourcing the Editorial Materials……………… 22-27 Unit 2 Editorial Audience and Qualities of Editorial Writers………………………………………... 28-34 Unit 3 Editorial Board………………..……………… 35-40 Unit 4 Techniques in Editorial Writing…. ………….. 41-48 Module 3……………………………………………………. 49 Unit 1 Determinants of Editorial Subjects …………... 49-53 Unit 2 Classification
    [Show full text]
  • The Trouble with the Fourth Estate
    The Trouble with the Fourth Estate Axel Bruns, ARC Centre of Excellence for Creative Industries and Innovation, QUT [email protected] – http://snurb.info/ – @snurb_dot_info Hello. We’re here tonight to discuss the potential for bloggers to become the new fourth estate – which immediately raises two questions: 1) which bloggers? and 2) what do we mean by fourth estate? Let me start with the first. I think we need to be careful not to overclaim on what the role of bloggers in political discourse is, or can be – and I’ve done my research in this field for the best part of the past decade, and am probably as guilty of overestimating the impact of blogging as the next person. When we’re speaking of bloggers as a potential fourth estate, we’re really mainly speaking of the minority of news and political bloggers, and much less so of the majority of bloggers who cover all manner of other themes, from providing updates on their or their company’s professional activities all the way through individuals blogging on themes like sports, crafts, food, or highly personal matters. From the research that we’ve done in the past few years, in Australia there are probably some 200 bloggers who can be said to deal with news and politics on a regular basis – and that’s already starting to include the so- called ‘bloggers’ on the opinion pages of many newspaper Websites, and the commentary feeds of sites like Crikey and On Line Opinion, which are really far more than simple blogs.
    [Show full text]
  • Our Fourth Estate (H.C
    Our Fourth Estate (H.C. Frisbee and other early editors of local newspapers) By Douglas Shepard / Barker Museum Newsletter (Winter 1997) Over the years in this newsletter we have drawn heavily on material from the Censor as well as from the other newspapers serving our region. But, although we have used these sources, we have never actually focused on them for their own sake. Well, we intend to remedy that grievous lack starting right now. Let us begin, like Alice, at the beginning: the “masthead”. If you are an old-timer here, you are so used to it that you probably do not even hear anything odd when we say the name of our main source, the Censor. But stop for a minute and try and imagine what in the world Mr. Frisbee had in mind when he named it in February, 1821. Was he going to carefully not print what he found objectionable in the news? No. Actually, in naming his paper, he was working within a long and venerable tradition. As the nation states of Europe and the British Isles began to shape themselves – and each other – from the Renaissance period on, the need for information began to grow. Large banking establishments and other important cross-border merchant groups began circulating what we would call newsletters or house organs which quickly became important to others outside the group as well. At the same time, increased literacy and improvements in the printing press encouraged the dissemination of court circulars about the official schedule of the monarch and his/her entourage.
    [Show full text]
  • Media and Mass Disempowerment of Civil Society in Africa
    The African e-Journals Project has digitized full text of articles of eleven social science and humanities journals. This item is from the digital archive maintained by Michigan State University Library. Find more at: http://digital.lib.msu.edu/projects/africanjournals/ Available through a partnership with Scroll down to read the article. The Sleeping Dog Cannot Bark: Media and Mass Disempowerment of Civil Society in Africa By Danladi Musa Abstract The concepts of media as the fourth estate and the society's watchdog are popular among communication scholars. However, a consideration of the actualization of this concept is indicative of the media's failing in playing these roles. Very often, the media marginalise and disempower the masses whose causes they ought to promote. If the media were to truly play the watchdog role as the fourth estate, then both the structure and ownership of the media must be reviewed with a view to redressing the imbalances that make them tools for the disempowerment of civil society in Africa. Dr. Danladi Musa teaches at the Department of English, Communication and Media Studies, University of Zimbabwe. 79 Un Chien Dormant n'Aboit pas: Les Medias et le Passage du Pouvoir a la Societe Civile en Afrique Par Dr Danladi Musa Resume Le concept que les medias constituent le quatrieme quartier et le chien de garde de la societe" n'est rien de nouveau chez les specialistes en communication. On remarque, cependant, que les choses se passent autrement en realite, ce qui revient au meme qu'accuser les medias de ne pas jouer leur role comme il faut.
    [Show full text]
  • The Evolution– and Devolution–
    JULY 1999 Volume 28, Number 7 IMPRIMISBecause Ideas Have Consequences 27th The Evolution– year and Devolution– of Journalistic Ethics Marianne Jennings 845,000 subscribers Professor of Legal and Ethical Studies Arizona State University Journalists are the eyes and ears of society. arianne Jennings is an They gather, sift, and communicate millions of M award-winning newspaper pieces of information. But as Marianne columnist and radio commenta- Jennings warns, some journalists believe that tor, director of the Joan and the facts are less important than a story that David Lincoln Center for Applied “sells” or that promotes a cause. Ethics, and professor of legal Professor Jennings delivered her remarks at and ethical stud- the February 1999 Center for Constructive ies at Arizona State Alternatives seminar, “The Fourth Estate: A University. With undergrad- History of Journalism,” which was co-hosted by uate and law de- Hillsdale’s newly established Herbert H. Dow II grees from Brig- Program in American Journalism. ham Young Univer- sity, Dr. Jennings lawyer by training and a newspaper col- has written six text- umnist by avocation, I teach ethics at a books, and more business school. People tell me that’s than 130 articles. four oxymorons in one sentence. Her column in the AMy unusual career choices have made me Arizona Republic realize that lawyers, businessmen, and journal- has been reprinted ists wrestle with the same ethical concerns. But by the Wall Street Journal, the Chicago Tribune, and other news- journalists face the greatest challenge. They not papers nationwide. A collection of only have to decide whether to follow a code of her essays, Nobody Fixes Real ethics personally but also whether that code Carrot Sticks Anymore, was pub- should apply to the stories and the subjects they lished in 1994.
    [Show full text]
  • The Fourth Estate Is Dead, Long Live the Fourth Estate: a New Military
    G Model PUBREL-965; No. of Pages 6 ARTICLE IN PRESS Public Relations Review xxx (2011) xxx–xxx Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect Public Relations Review The Fourth Estate is dead, long live the Fourth Estate: A new military mindset for a rapidly evolving communication environment a,∗ b Cliff W. Gilmore , Richard R. Osial a 7039 Kings Manor Drive, Alexandria, VA 22315, USA b 15465 Golf Club Drive, Montclair, VA 22025, USA a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t Keywords: The authors identify a need for a shift in the communication mindset of the U.S. Department Change leadership of Defense (DoD) to better account for the speed, ubiquity and mobility of human interaction Communication in the evolving communication environment. The leadership requirement to define a new Communications reality when guiding transition and complex change is identified. Three reality-defining Mindset truths are drawn from the convergence of leadership and communication theories. First, it is Organizational transition Dialogue not possible to lead without communicating. Second, it is not possible to not communicate. Dialogic Third, it is not possible to communicate without influencing others. Analysis of current DoD Monologue lexicon, principles and organizational design related to communication activities reveals a Monologic technical/monologic mindset. This mindset is evaluated based on the three truths, shortfalls of the mindset are identified, and four concrete leadership actions are proposed to guide a transition to a social/dialogic mindset. Proposed actions include defining a new vision and purpose for the military based on preservation of credibility and trust, creation of a new communication lexicon, creation of universal guiding principles, and revision of doctrine and training to incorporate social-communication thought, theory and practice.
    [Show full text]
  • Social Media in the Changing Ecology of News: the Fourth and Fifth Estates in Britain
    International Journal of Internet Science 2012, 7 (1), 6–22 ISSN 1662-5544 IJIS.NET Social Media in the Changing Ecology of News: The Fourth and Fifth Estates in Britain Nic Newman1, William H. Dutton2, Grant Blank2 1Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, University of Oxford, United Kingdom 2Oxford Internet Institute, University of Oxford, United Kingdom Abstract: This paper provides a case study of the changing patterns of news production and consumption in the UK that are being shaped by the Internet and related social media. Theoretically, this focus addresses concern over whether the Internet is undermining the Fourth Estate role of the press in liberal democratic societies. The case study draws from multiple methods, including survey research of individuals in Britain from 2003–2011, analysis of log files of journalistic sites, and interviews with journalists. Survey research shows a step-jump in the use of online news since 2003 but a levelling off since 2009. However, the apparent stability in news consumption masks the growing role of social network sites. The analyses show that the Fourth Estate – the institutional news media – is using social media to enhance their role in news production and dissemination. However, networked individuals have used social media to source and distribute their own information in ways that achieve a growing independence from the Fourth Estate journalism. As more information moves online and individuals become routinely linked to the Internet, an emerging Fifth Estate, built on the activities of networked individuals sourcing and distributing their own information, is developing a synergy with the Fourth Estate as each builds on and responds to the other in this new news ecology.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 the Fifth Estate
    The Fifth Estate: Democratic Social Accountability through the Emerging Network of Networks1 William H. Dutton Professor of Internet Studies, Oxford Internet Institute, University of Oxford Abstract The rise of the press, radio, television and other mass media has enabled the development of an independent institution: the ‘Fourth Estate’, central to pluralist democratic processes. The growing use of the Internet and related digital technologies is creating a space for networking individuals in ways that enable a new source of accountability in government, politics and other sectors. This chapter explains how this emerging ‘Fifth Estate’ is being established and why this could challenge the influence of other more established bases of institutional authority. It discusses approaches to the governance of this new social and political phenomenon that could nurture the Fifth Estate’s potential for supporting the vitality of liberal democratic societies. The Emergence of a New Pluralist Democratic Institution The historical conception of feudal societies being divided into ‘estates of the realm’, as reflected in France, England and Scotland, can be up-dated in a way that is useful for understanding developments in contemporary network 1 Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1167502 societies. In pre-revolutionary France and England, for example, these estates were identified as the clergy, nobility and commons.2 In the 18th Century, as explained by Thomas Carlyle (1905: 349-50), Edmund Burke identified the press as a Fourth Estate: Burke said there were Three Estates in Parliament; but, in the Reporters’ Gallery yonder, there sat a Fourth Estate more important far than they all.
    [Show full text]
  • The First Amendment and the Fifth Estate
    DO NOT DELETE 3/27/2012 4:50 PM ARTICLES THE MEDIA THAT NEED CITIZENS: THE FIRST AMENDMENT AND THE FIFTH ESTATE ADAM COHEN* TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION .................................................................................... 2 II. THE CHANGING MEDIA ECOLOGY—AND THE ELITE RESPONSE ............................................................................................. 7 III. THE FIFTH ESTATE AND FIRST AMENDMENT VALUES ......... 23 A. INFORMATION NEEDED IN A DEMOCRACY ................................. 25 B. CHECKING GOVERNMENT ABUSES ............................................. 30 C. CHECKING THE PRIVATE SECTOR ............................................... 32 D. ENCOURAGING INTEREST GROUP FORMATION ........................... 35 E. PROMOTING SELF-EXPRESSION ................................................... 38 IV. TOWARD A RIGHT TO PARTICIPATE ........................................... 43 A. THE RIGHT OF EQUAL TREATMENT ............................................ 45 B. THE RIGHT OF ACCESS TO GOVERNMENT INFORMATION ........... 59 C. POLICIES OF PARTICIPATION ....................................................... 66 V. AN ARCHITECTURE OF ACCOUNTABILITY ................................ 76 VI. CONCLUSION .................................................................................... 85 * Lecturer in Law and Kauffman Fellow, Yale Law School. Member, New York Times Editorial Board, 2002–2010. A.B. Harvard College, 1984; J.D. Harvard Law School, 1987. I would like to thank Jed Rubenfeld, Jack Balkin, Amy Chua,
    [Show full text]