Analysing TCP Performance When Link Experiencing Packet Loss

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Analysing TCP Performance When Link Experiencing Packet Loss Analysing TCP performance when link experiencing packet loss Master of Science Thesis [in the Programme Networks and Distributed System] SHAHRIN CHOWDHURY KANIZ FATEMA Chalmers University of Technology University of Gothenburg Department of Computer Science and Engineering Göteborg, Sweden, October 2013 The Author grants to Chalmers University of Technology and University of Gothenburg the non-exclusive right to publish the Work electronically and in a non-commercial purpose make it accessible on the Internet. The Author warrants that he/she is the author to the Work, and warrants that the Work does not contain text, pictures or other material that violates copyright law. The Author shall, when transferring the rights of the Work to a third party (for example a publisher or a company), acknowledge the third party about this agreement. If the Author has signed a copyright agreement with a third party regarding the Work, the Author warrants hereby that he/she has obtained any necessary permission from this third party to let Chalmers University of Technology and University of Gothenburg store the Work electronically and make it accessible on the Internet. Analysing TCP performance when link experiencing packet loss SHAHRIN CHOWDHURY, KANIZ FATEMA © SHAHRIN CHOWDHURY, October 2013. © KANIZ FATEMA, October 2013. Examiner: TOMAS OLOVSSON Chalmers University of Technology University of Gothenburg Department of Computer Science and Engineering SE-412 96 Göteborg Sweden Telephone + 46 (0)31-772 1000 Department of Computer Science and Engineering Göteborg, Sweden October 2013 Acknowledgement We are grateful to our supervisor and examiner Tomas Olovsson for his valuable time and assistance in compilation for this thesis. We would like to pay our gratitude to CHALMERS for providing us necessary equipment. We would also like to thank the Department of Networks and Distributed Systems for giving us the opportunity to perform our thesis in the department. Last but not the least we are grateful to our parents for encouraging us to achieve our goal. Abstract TCP is a reliable protocol which is capable of handling retransmission and packet loss. In TCP, packet loss is not expected to have a noticeable impact on bandwidth. However, performance was affected even at low packet loss rates (1%) and with an increased rate of packet loss, a drastic drop was observed. To uncover the cause of this unexpected behavior of TCP, a deep analysis of TCP has been accomplished. In this paper we have done a comparison between three different congestion control algorithms (Cubic, Reno and H_TCP) and a deeper analysis of Reno by means of several experimental tests in when the link experiences Data loss and ACK loss. Initially different TCP congestion control algorithms were used to observe their influence on bandwidth rate. Subsequently the TCP variables i.e. advanced window scaling, ECN value, window scaling, TCP no-metric-save value were changed to examine their role in obtaining adequate bandwidth rate with respect to packet drop. In addition to our experimental results, we also include some possible reasons behind the drastic drop in performance rate which was observed. Moreover, experimental results show that the congestion control algorithm H-TCP performed better than Cubic and Reno while link was experiencing packet loss. However, ACK loss didn‟t affect performance that much, and up to 50% loss of ACKs could be tolerated with almost no performance degradation. Keywords: TCP congestion control algorithms, TCP variables, Data loss, ACK loss, Packet loss, Bandwidth rate etc. Table of Content Chapter 1: Introduction ....................................................................... 12 1.1 Background..............................................................................................................12 1.2 Outline of the paper .............................................................................................12 Chapter 2: Problem description ........................................................ 13 2.1 Detected problem in TCP performance........................................................13 2.2 Related work ...........................................................................................................14 Chapter 3: TCP Concepts ...................................................................... 17 3.1 TCP congestion avoidance algorithms ........................................................17 3.2 TCP variables ..........................................................................................................18 Chapter 4: Testing TCP performance............................................... 20 4.1 Description of measurement tools ................................................................20 4.1.1 Wireshark........................................................................................................... 20 4.1.2 Linux Network Traffic control (tc)............................................................. 20 4.1.3 IPERF .................................................................................................................... 21 4.1.4 Netcat ................................................................................................................... 21 4.2 Setting up the network........................................................................................22 4.3 Measuring the impact of TCP drops ..............................................................24 4.3.1 Experiment when Data link experiencing Data Drop ......................... 24 4.3.2 Experiment when Data link experiencing ACK drop........................... 25 4.3.3 Tests with CUBIC when experiencing Data Drop .................................. 26 4.3.4 Tests with CUBIC when experiencing ACK drop ................................... 27 4.3.5 Tests with Reno when experiencing Data drop .................................... 28 4.3.6 Tests with Reno when experiencing ACK drop ..................................... 28 Chapter 5: Tests with more algorithms and TCP variables ....... 30 5.1 Experiments with different congestion avoidance algorithms for data loss ...............................................................................................................................30 5.1.1 CUBIC.................................................................................................................... 31 5.1.2 RENO..................................................................................................................... 31 5.1.3 H-TCP ................................................................................................................... 32 5.1.4 Tests with different TCP variables: tcp_window_scaling ................... 33 5.1.5 Tests with different TCP variables: tcp_adv_win_scale....................... 34 5.1.6 Tests with different TCP variables: tcp_ecn............................................ 35 5.1.7 Tests with different TCP variables: tcp_no_metrics_save value ...... 35 5.2 Experiments with different congestion avoidance algorithms for ACK loss.................................................................................................................................36 5.2.1 CUBIC/RENO/H_TCP ....................................................................................... 36 5.2.2 Tests with different TCP variables: tcp_window_scaling ................... 37 5.2.3 Tests with different TCP variables: tcp_adv_win_scale....................... 38 5.2.4 Tests with different TCP variables: tcp_ecn............................................ 39 5.2.5 Tests with different TCP variables: tcp_no_metric_save value ........ 39 Chapter 6: Discussion ............................................................................ 41 6.1 Outcome from the experiments when link experiencing Data loss ....... 41 6.2 Outcome from the experiments when link experiencing ACK loss........ 42 6.3 Possible reason behind the drastic drop when link experiencing Data loss in RENO ........................................................................................................... 45 Chapter 7: Conclusion ............................................................................ 47 Chapter 8: Future Work ........................................................................ 49 References ................................................................................................. 50 Appendix .................................................................................................... 52 1. Tests with different TCP variables in CUBIC for Data loss ................... 52 1.2 tcp_adv_win_scale ............................................................................................ 52 1.3 tcp_ecn ................................................................................................................. 53 1.4 tcp_no_metric_save.......................................................................................... 53 2 Tests with different TCP variables in CUBIC for ACK loss ..................... 54 2.1 tcp_window_scaling........................................................................................ 54 2.2 tcp_adv_win_scale ............................................................................................ 54 2.3 tcp_ecn ................................................................................................................. 55 2.4 tcp_ no_metric_save ........................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Modeling and Performance Evaluation of LTE Networks with Different TCP Variants Ghassan A
    World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology International Journal of Electronics and Communication Engineering Vol:5, No:3, 2011 Modeling and Performance Evaluation of LTE Networks with Different TCP Variants Ghassan A. Abed, Mahamod Ismail, and Kasmiran Jumari Abstract—Long Term Evolution (LTE) is a 4G wireless Comparing the performance of 3G and its evolution to LTE, broadband technology developed by the Third Generation LTE does not offer anything unique to improve spectral Partnership Project (3GPP) release 8, and it's represent the efficiency, i.e. bps/Hz. LTE improves system performance by competitiveness of Universal Mobile Telecommunications System using wider bandwidths if the spectrum is available [2]. (UMTS) for the next 10 years and beyond. The concepts for LTE systems have been introduced in 3GPP release 8, with objective of Universal Terrestrial Radio Access Network Long-Term high-data-rate, low-latency and packet-optimized radio access Evolution (UTRAN LTE), also known as Evolved UTRAN technology. In this paper, performance of different TCP variants (EUTRAN) is a new radio access technology proposed by the during LTE network investigated. The performance of TCP over 3GPP to provide a very smooth migration towards fourth LTE is affected mostly by the links of the wired network and total generation (4G) network [3]. EUTRAN is a system currently bandwidth available at the serving base station. This paper describes under development within 3GPP. LTE systems is under an NS-2 based simulation analysis of TCP-Vegas, TCP-Tahoe, TCP- Reno, TCP-Newreno, TCP-SACK, and TCP-FACK, with full developments now, and the TCP protocol is the most widely modeling of all traffics of LTE system.
    [Show full text]
  • Traffic Management in Multi-Service Access Networks
    MARKETING REPORT MR-404 Traffic Management in Multi-Service Access Networks Issue: 01 Issue Date: September 2017 © The Broadband Forum. All rights reserved. Traffic Management in Multi-Service Access Networks MR-404 Issue History Issue Approval date Publication Date Issue Editor Changes Number 01 4 September 2017 13 October 2017 Christele Bouchat, Original Nokia Comments or questions about this Broadband Forum Marketing Draft should be directed to [email protected] Editors Francois Fredricx Nokia [email protected] Florian Damas Nokia [email protected] Ing-Jyh Tsang Nokia [email protected] Innovation Christele Bouchat Nokia [email protected] Leadership Mauro Tilocca Telecom Italia [email protected] September 2017 © The Broadband Forum. All rights reserved 2 of 16 Traffic Management in Multi-Service Access Networks MR-404 Executive Summary Traffic Management is a widespread industry practice for ensuring that networks operate efficiently, including mechanisms such as queueing, routing, restricting or rationing certain traffic on a network, and/or giving priority to some types of traffic under certain network conditions, or at all times. The goal is to minimize the impact of congestion in networks on the traffic’s Quality of Service. It can be used to achieve certain performance goals, and its careful application can ultimately improve the quality of an end user's experience in a technically and economically sound way, without detracting from the experience of others. Several Traffic Management mechanisms are vital for a functioning Internet carrying all sorts of Over-the-Top (OTT) applications in “Best Effort” mode. Another set of Traffic Management mechanisms is also used in networks involved in a multi-service context, to provide differentiated treatment of various services (e.g.
    [Show full text]
  • Latency and Throughput Optimization in Modern Networks: a Comprehensive Survey Amir Mirzaeinnia, Mehdi Mirzaeinia, and Abdelmounaam Rezgui
    READY TO SUBMIT TO IEEE COMMUNICATIONS SURVEYS & TUTORIALS JOURNAL 1 Latency and Throughput Optimization in Modern Networks: A Comprehensive Survey Amir Mirzaeinnia, Mehdi Mirzaeinia, and Abdelmounaam Rezgui Abstract—Modern applications are highly sensitive to com- On one hand every user likes to send and receive their munication delays and throughput. This paper surveys major data as quickly as possible. On the other hand the network attempts on reducing latency and increasing the throughput. infrastructure that connects users has limited capacities and These methods are surveyed on different networks and surrond- ings such as wired networks, wireless networks, application layer these are usually shared among users. There are some tech- transport control, Remote Direct Memory Access, and machine nologies that dedicate their resources to some users but they learning based transport control, are not very much commonly used. The reason is that although Index Terms—Rate and Congestion Control , Internet, Data dedicated resources are more secure they are more expensive Center, 5G, Cellular Networks, Remote Direct Memory Access, to implement. Sharing a physical channel among multiple Named Data Network, Machine Learning transmitters needs a technique to control their rate in proper time. The very first congestion network collapse was observed and reported by Van Jacobson in 1986. This caused about a I. INTRODUCTION thousand time rate reduction from 32kbps to 40bps [3] which Recent applications such as Virtual Reality (VR), au- is about a thousand times rate reduction. Since then very tonomous cars or aerial vehicles, and telehealth need high different variations of the Transport Control Protocol (TCP) throughput and low latency communication.
    [Show full text]
  • Lab 6: Understanding Traditional TCP Congestion Control (HTCP, Cubic, Reno)
    NETWORK TOOLS AND PROTOCOLS Lab 6: Understanding Traditional TCP Congestion Control (HTCP, Cubic, Reno) Document Version: 06-14-2019 Award 1829698 “CyberTraining CIP: Cyberinfrastructure Expertise on High-throughput Networks for Big Science Data Transfers” Lab 6: Understanding Traditional TCP Congestion Control Contents Overview ............................................................................................................................. 3 Objectives............................................................................................................................ 3 Lab settings ......................................................................................................................... 3 Lab roadmap ....................................................................................................................... 3 1 Introduction to TCP ..................................................................................................... 3 1.1 TCP review ............................................................................................................ 4 1.2 TCP throughput .................................................................................................... 4 1.3 TCP packet loss event ........................................................................................... 5 1.4 Impact of packet loss in high-latency networks ................................................... 6 2 Lab topology...............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Adaptive Method for Packet Loss Types in Iot: an Naive Bayes Distinguisher
    electronics Article Adaptive Method for Packet Loss Types in IoT: An Naive Bayes Distinguisher Yating Chen , Lingyun Lu *, Xiaohan Yu * and Xiang Li School of Computer and Information Technology, Beijing Jiaotong University, Beijing 100044, China; [email protected] (Y.C.); [email protected] (X.L.) * Correspondence: [email protected] (L.L.); [email protected] (X.Y.) Received: 31 December 2018; Accepted: 23 January 2019; Published: 28 January 2019 Abstract: With the rapid development of IoT (Internet of Things), massive data is delivered through trillions of interconnected smart devices. The heterogeneous networks trigger frequently the congestion and influence indirectly the application of IoT. The traditional TCP will highly possible to be reformed supporting the IoT. In this paper, we find the different characteristics of packet loss in hybrid wireless and wired channels, and develop a novel congestion control called NB-TCP (Naive Bayesian) in IoT. NB-TCP constructs a Naive Bayesian distinguisher model, which can capture the packet loss state and effectively classify the packet loss types from the wireless or the wired. More importantly, it cannot cause too much load on the network, but has fast classification speed, high accuracy and stability. Simulation results using NS2 show that NB-TCP achieves up to 0.95 classification accuracy and achieves good throughput, fairness and friendliness in the hybrid network. Keywords: Internet of Things; wired/wireless hybrid network; TCP; naive bayesian model 1. Introduction The Internet of Things (IoT) is a new network industry based on Internet, mobile communication networks and other technologies, which has wide applications in industrial production, intelligent transportation, environmental monitoring and smart homes.
    [Show full text]
  • A Comparison of Voip Performance on Ipv6 and Ipv4 Networks
    A Comparison of VoIP Performance on IPv6 and IPv4 Networks Roman Yasinovskyy, Alexander L. Wijesinha, Ramesh K. Karne, and Gholam Khaksari Towson University increasingly used on the Internet today. The increase Abstract—We compare VoIP performance on IPv6 in IPv6 packet size due to the larger addresses is and IPv4 LANs in the presence of varying levels of partly offset by a streamlined header with optional background UDP traffic. A conventional softphone is extension headers (the header fields in IPv4 for used to make calls and a bare PC (operating system- fragmentation support and checksum are eliminated less) softphone is used as a control to determine the impact of system overhead. The performance measures in IPv6). are maximum and mean delta (the time between the As the growing popularity of VoIP will make it a arrival of voice packets), maximum and mean jitter, significant component of traffic in the future Internet, packet loss, MOS (Mean Opinion Score), and it is of interest to compare VoIP performance over throughput. We also determine the relative frequency IPv6 and IPv4. The results would help to determine if distribution for delta. It is found that mean values of there are any differences in VoIP performance over delta for IPv4 and IPv6 are similar although maximum values are much higher than the mean and show more IPv6 compared to IPv4 due to overhead resulting variability at higher levels of background traffic. The from the larger IPv6 header (and packet size). We maximum jitter for IPv6 is slightly higher than for IPv4 focus on comparing VoIP performance with IPv6 and but mean jitter values are approximately the same.
    [Show full text]
  • The Effects of Different Congestion Control Algorithms Over Multipath Fast Ethernet Ipv4/Ipv6 Environments
    Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Applied Informatics Eger, Hungary, January 29–31, 2020, published at http://ceur-ws.org The Effects of Different Congestion Control Algorithms over Multipath Fast Ethernet IPv4/IPv6 Environments Szabolcs Szilágyi, Imre Bordán Faculty of Informatics, University of Debrecen, Hungary [email protected] [email protected] Abstract The TCP has been in use since the seventies and has later become the predominant protocol of the internet for reliable data transfer. Numerous TCP versions has seen the light of day (e.g. TCP Cubic, Highspeed, Illinois, Reno, Scalable, Vegas, Veno, etc.), which in effect differ from each other in the algorithms used for detecting network congestion. On the other hand, the development of multipath communication tech- nologies is one today’s relevant research fields. What better proof of this, than that of the MPTCP (Multipath TCP) being integrated into multiple operating systems shortly after its standardization. The MPTCP proves to be very effective for multipath TCP-based data transfer; however, its main drawback is the lack of support for multipath com- munication over UDP, which can be important when forwarding multimedia traffic. The MPT-GRE software developed at the Faculty of Informatics, University of Debrecen, supports operation over both transfer protocols. In this paper, we examine the effects of different TCP congestion control mechanisms on the MPTCP and the MPT-GRE multipath communication technologies. Keywords: congestion control, multipath communication, MPTCP, MPT- GRE, transport protocols. 1. Introduction In 1974, the TCP was defined in RFC 675 under the Transmission Control Pro- gram name. Later, the Transmission Control Program was split into two modular Copyright © 2020 for this paper by its authors.
    [Show full text]
  • Impact of Packet Losses on the Quality of Video Streaming
    Master Thesis Electrical Engineering Thesis no: MEE10:44 June 2010 Impact of Packet Losses on the Quality of Video Streaming JOHN Samson Mwela & OYEKANLU Emmanuel Adebomi School of Computing Internet : www.bth.se/com School of Computing Blekinge Institute of Technology Phone : +46 457 38 50 00 Blekinge Institute of Technology Box 520 Fax : + 46 457 271 25 Box 520 i SE – 371 79Karlskrona SE – 372 25 Ronneby Sweden Sweden This thesis is submitted to the School of Computing at Blekinge Institute of Technology in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science in Electrical Engineering. The thesis is equivalent to 20 weeks of full time studies. Contact Information: Author(s): JOHN Samson Mwela Blekinge Institute of Technology E-mail: [email protected] OYEKANLU Emmanuel Adebomi Blekinge Institute of Technology E-mail: [email protected] Supervisor Tahir Nawaz Minhas School of Computing Examiner Dr. Patrik Arlos, PhD School of Computing School of Computing Blekinge Institute of Technology Box 520 SE – 371 79 Karlskrona Sweden i ABSTRACT In this thesis, the impact of packet losses on the quality of received videos sent across a network that exhibit normal network perturbations such as jitters, delays, packet drops etc has been examined. Dynamic behavior of a normal network has been simulated using Linux and the Network Emulator (NetEm). Peoples’ perceptions on the quality of the received video were used in rating the qualities of several videos with differing speeds. In accordance with ITU’s guideline of using Mean Opinion Scores (MOS), the effects of packet drops were analyzed. Excel and Matlab were used as tools in analyzing the peoples’ opinions which indicates the impacts that different loss rates has on the transmitted videos.
    [Show full text]
  • What Causes Packet Loss IP Networks
    What Causes Packet Loss IP Networks (Rev 1.1) Computer Modules, Inc. DVEO Division 11409 West Bernardo Court San Diego, CA 92127, USA Telephone: +1 858 613 1818 Fax: +1 858 613 1815 www.dveo.com Copyright © 2016 Computer Modules, Inc. All Rights Reserved. DVEO, DOZERbox, DOZER Racks and DOZER ARQ are trademarks of Computer Modules, Inc. Specifications and product availability are subject to change without notice. Packet Loss and Reasons Introduction This Document To stream high quality video, i.e. to transmit real-time video streams, over IP networks is a demanding endeavor and, depending on network conditions, may result in packets being dropped or “lost” for a variety of reasons, thus negatively impacting the quality of user experience (QoE). This document looks at typical reasons and causes for what is generally referred to as “packet loss” across various types of IP networks, whether of the managed and conditioned type with a defined Quality of Service (QoS), or the “unmanaged” kind such as the vast variety of individual and interconnected networks across the globe that collectively constitute the public Internet (“the Internet”). The purpose of this document is to encourage operators and enterprises that wish to overcome streaming video quality problems to explore potential solutions. Proven technology exists that enables transmission of real-time video error-free over all types of IP networks, and to perform live broadcasting of studio quality content over the “unmanaged” Internet! Core Protocols of the Internet Protocol Suite The Internet Protocol (IP) is the foundation on which the Internet was built and, by extension, the World Wide Web, by enabling global internetworking.
    [Show full text]
  • The Impact of Qos Changes Towards Network Performance
    International Journal of Computer Networks and Communications Security VOL. 3, NO. 2, FEBRUARY 2015, 48–53 Available online at: www.ijcncs.org E-ISSN 2308-9830 (Online) / ISSN 2410-0595 (Print) The Impact of QoS Changes towards Network Performance WINARNO SUGENG1, JAZI EKO ISTIYANTO2, KHABIB MUSTOFA3 and AHMAD ASHARI4 1Itenas, Informatics Engineering Department, BANDUNG, INDONESIA 2, 3, 4 UGM, Computer Science Program, YOGYAKARTA, INDONESIA E-mail: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] ABSTRACT Degrading or declining network performance in an installed computer network system is the most undesirable condition. There are several factors contribute to the decline of network performance, which their indications can be observed from quality changes in Quality of Service (QoS) parameters measurement result. This research proposes recommendations in improving network performance towards the changes of QoS parameters quality. Keywords: Network Performance, Quality Parameters, QoS Changes, Network Recommendation. 1 INTRODUCTION very sensitive issue because there is no system that is safe while they are made by human hands, the At the time talked about the Reliability of a system can be improved security built only from system supporting network devices (network one level to another level . infrastructure). The main factors that influence it is Once a network is built, the next job more Availability, Performance and Security, the difficult it is to maintain the network still works as relationship of these factors are as shown in Figure it should, in this case maintain network stability. If 1 [6]. a device does not work then it will affect the work of the overall network.
    [Show full text]
  • Computer Networks ICS
    Computer Networks ICS 651 ● congestion collapse ● congestion control: TCP Reno ● congestion control: TCP Vegas ● other ways of detecting congestion ● addressing congestion ● router intervention ● Internet Explicit Congestion Notification ● FIFO queueing ● fair queueing Router Congestion • assume a fast router • two gigabit-ethernet links receiving lots of outgoing data • one (relatively) slow internet link (10 Mb/s uplink speed) sending the outgoing data • if the two links send more than a combined 10 Mb/s over an extended period, the router buffers will fill up • eventually the router will have to discard data due to congestion: more data being sent than the line can carry Congestion Collapse • assume a fixed timeout • if I have n bytes/second to send, I send them • if they get dropped, I retransmit them (total 2n bytes/second, 3n bytes/second, ...) • when there is congestion, packets get dropped • if everybody retransmits with fixed timeout, the amount of data sent grows, increasing congestion • so some congestion (enough to drop packets) causes more congestion!!!! • eventually, very little data gets through, most is discarded • the network is (nearly) down TCP Reno • exponential backoff: if retransmit timer was t before retransmission, it becomes 2t after retransmission • careful RTT measurements give retransmission as soon as possible, but no sooner • keep a congestion window: • effective window is lesser of: (1) flow control window, and (2) congestion window • congestion window is kept only on the sender, and never communicated between
    [Show full text]
  • Packet Loss Burstiness: Measurements and Implications for Distributed Applications
    Packet Loss Burstiness: Measurements and Implications for Distributed Applications David X. Wei1,PeiCao2,StevenH.Low1 1Division of Engineering and Applied Science 2Department of Computer Science California Institute of Technology Stanford University Pasadena, CA 91125 USA Stanford, CA 94305 USA {weixl,slow}@cs.caltech.edu [email protected] Abstract sources. The most commonly used control protocol for re- liable data transmission is Transmission Control Protocol Many modern massively distributed systems deploy thou- (TCP) [18], with a variety of congestion control algorithms sands of nodes to cooperate on a computation task. Net- (Reno [5], NewReno [11], etc.), and implementations (e.g. work congestions occur in these systems. Most applications TCP Pacing [16, 14]). The most commonly used control rely on congestion control protocols such as TCP to protect protocol for unreliable data transmission is TCP Friendly the systems from congestion collapse. Most TCP conges- Rate Control (TFRC) [10]. These algorithms all use packet tion control algorithms use packet loss as signal to detect loss as the congestion signal. In designs of these protocols, congestion. it is assumed that the packet loss process provides signals In this paper, we study the packet loss process in sub- that can be detected by every flow sharing the network and round-trip-time (sub-RTT) timescale and its impact on the hence the protocols can achieve fair share of the network loss-based congestion control algorithms. Our study sug- resource and, at the same time, avoid congestion collapse. gests that the packet loss in sub-RTT timescale is very bursty. This burstiness leads to two effects.
    [Show full text]