DOCSLIB.ORG

Comparative Study El

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Comparative Study El Comparative study el lev on the implementation tional of the ECHR at na the national level the t a This comparative analysis deals with the issues of application of the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (ECHR) in national legal systems of ECHR several States Parties to the Convention. the These important issues are dealt with in eight articles of elaborating the application of the ECHR in Croatia, France, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Poland, Russia and Serbia. Countries were tion selected following two criteria: monistic or dualistic systems – in ta order to demonstrate different legal consequences in both systems due to the application of the European Convention, and the commencement of the application of the Convention – presenting the states that have been parties to the Convention implemen since its adoption, as well as those that have become so in the the past two decades, which affects different level of activity of their n courts regarding the implementation of the Convention. o The experience from one country, as shown here, can serve as the inspiration for improving the implementation in another, as study e well as for overcoming certain obstacles and problems tiv identified in the articles. a ompar www.coe.int/nationalimplementation ENG C The Council of Europe is the continent's leading human Alessia Cozzi rights organisation. It comprises 47 member states, 28 of Athanassia Sykiotou which are members of the European Union. All Council of Dagmara Rajska www.coe.int Europe member states have signed up to the European Convention on Human Rights, a treaty designed to protect Ivana Krstic human rights, democracy and the rule of law. The Maria Filatova European Court of Human Rights oversees the Nikolina Katic implementation of the Convention in the member states. Petra Bard – Károly Bárd e Stephanie Bourgeois p o r u E f o l i c n u o C COMPARATIVE STUDY on the Implementation of the ECHR at the National Level Authors Alessia Cozzi, Athanassia Sykiotou, Dagmara Rajska, Ivana Krstic, Maria Filatova, Nikolina Katic, Petra Bard – Károly Bárd, Stephanie Bourgeois This publication has been prepared within the framework of the “Human Rights Friendly Judiciary” project funded by the Human Rights Trust Fund and implemented by the Council of Europe. The opinions expressed in this work are the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy of the Council of Europe. Council of Europe Belgrade 2016 Publisher Council of Europe Office in Belgrade Španskih boraca 3, 11070 Belgrade www.coe.org.rs For the Publisher Tim Cartwright Editor Silvija Panović-Đurić ISBN 978-86-84437-85-5 Circulation 500 Print, layout and cover design Dosije studio, Belgrade Copyright©2016 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be translated, reproduced or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic (CD-Rom, Internet, etc.) or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage or retrieval system, without the prior permission in writing from the Directorate of Communications (F-67075 Strasbourg Cedex or [email protected]) Contents Foreword 5 Stephanie Bourgeois THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS AT THE DOMESTIC LEVEL 7 Alessia Cozzi THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS CASE LAW IN ITALIAN JURISPRUDENCE 29 Athanassia Sykiotou THE RELATION OF GREEK COURTS WITH THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS CASE-LAW 47 Dagmara Rajska NATIONAL IMPLEMENTATION OF THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS – EXAMPLE OF POLAND 67 Ivana Krstic STATUS AND APPLICATION OF THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS IN THE REPUBLIC OF SERBIA 87 Contents 3 Maria Filatova THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE EUROPEAN COURT’S CASE-LAW IN THE RUSSIAN LEGAL ORDER 107 Nikolina Katic IMPLEMENTATION OF THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS ON NATIONAL LEVEL 129 Petra Bard – Károly Bárd THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE HUNGARIAN LEGAL SYSTEM 147 Stephanie Bourgeois IMPLEMENTATION OF THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS IN FRANCE, A PROCESS OF PROGRESSIVE ACCULTURATION 167 Comparative Study 4 Foreword omparative analysis before you is dedicated to the issue of the application of the European Convention on Human Rights in C the national legal framework of several contracting states to the Convention. This issues is of great importance, as the acceptance of the European Convention on Human Rights represents the first step towards its implementation in the national law, while the Convention leaves to the states the freedom to decide on their own how to respond to their commitment to respect and apply its provision. The way the state will do so, depends primarily on a reply to a question whether the European Convention can be applied directly, and on its status in the hierarchy of the national legal norms. Consequently, two legal systems emerged: monistic and dualistic. However, simple incorporation of the European Convention in domestic legal system is not capable of solving all problems emerging in the application of the European Convention, nor it is a guarantee of its complete and efficient application. Therefore, it is even more important to review the role of courts in this process. It is necessary to analyse up to which level national courts can examine conformity of the authorities’ procedures with the provisions of the European Convention, as well as the readiness of judges to apply the principles contained in the European Court of Human Rights jurisprudence, even in the cases when domestic legal framework provides clear basis. Replies to these important issues are provided in the eight articles dealing with the application of the European Convention in Croatia, France, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Poland, Russia and Serbia. The selection of countries was made following two principles: affiliation to the monistic, or dualistic legal system – in order to demonstrate different Foreword 5 legal consequences of both systems in the application of the European Convention; as well as the length of the contractual status, presenting the contracting states since the adoption of the Convention, respectively the states who became contracting stated in the last two decades, on which depends the level of courts’ activity in its implementation. Initially, all articles examine the status of the European Convention in domestic legal system, through the analyses of the hierarchy of legal norms and its direct application. In the second part, the authors point out the application of the European Convention and principles incorporated in the European Court’s jurisprudence by national courts, providing examples from both good and bad practice in the national case law. Finally, all authors give recommendations for improvement of the implementation of the European Convention and further steps that should be taken for the better, more effective and thorough implementation of the principles and standards outlined in the European Court jurisprudence. Experience from one country can serve as an inspiration for the improvement of implementation in another country, as well as a way to overcome some common obstacles and issues identified in the articles. Brief comparative overview of solutions from several states is given at the beginning. We hope that you will find this publication useful for your future professional endeavours. Comparative Study 6 The Implementation of the European Convention on Human Rights at the Domestic Level1 Stephanie Bourgeois Former lawyer at the ECtHR I. The Status of the European Convention on Human Rights in domestic law . 8 A. Preliminary remarks: the legal force of international treaties in the domestic legal order, monism versus dualism. 8 1. The dualistic view . 8 2. The monistic view. 9 B. Constitutional variety in Member States . 10 II. Judicial practices . 13 A. Consistent interpretation. 13 1. Constitutional provisions. 14 2. Legislative provisions . 16 3. Constitutional courts’ case law . 16 B. Judicial disapplication of domestic law . 20 1. Disapplication practice on constitutional bases . 21 2. Disapplication devised by domestic judges . 21 3. Constitutional provisions empowering national judges to disapply national law that conflicts with international treaties . 22 C. The limits to primacy: the counter-limits doctrine . 23 III. Conclusion . 27 1 Initial version of this Article has been prepared within the Council of Europe HELP programme. This version is revised and updated one. Stephanie Bourgeois 7 t is primarily the task of the national authorities of Contracting States to secure the rights and freedoms set forth in the Convention. To I what extent the national courts can play a part in this, by reviewing the acts and omissions of those national authorities, depends mainly on the question of whether the provisions of the Convention are directly applicable in proceedings before those national courts. The answer to this question depends in turn on the effect of the Convention within the national legal system concerned. The Convention does not impose upon the Contracting States the obligation to make the Convention part of domestic law or otherwise to guarantee its national applicability and prevalence over national law. I. The Status of the European Convention on Human Rights in domestic law A. Preliminary remarks: the legal force of international treaties in the domestic legal
Load more

Recommended publications
  • EUROPEAN COMMISSION DG RESEARCH STADIUM D2.1 State
    EUROPEAN COMMISSION DG RESEARCH SEVENTH FRAMEWORK PROGRAMME Theme 7 - Transport Collaborative Project – Grant Agreement Number 234127 STADIUM Smart Transport Applications Designed for large events with Impacts on Urban Mobility D2.1 State-of-the-Art Report Project Start Date and Duration 01 May 2009, 48 months Deliverable no. D2.1 Dissemination level PU Planned submission date 30-November 2009 Actual submission date 30 May 2011 Responsible organization TfL with assistance from IMPACTS WP2-SOTA Report May 2011 1 Document Title: State of the Art Report WP number: 2 Document Version Comments Date Authorized History by Version 0.1 Revised SOTA 23/05/11 IJ Version 0.2 Version 0.3 Number of pages: 81 Number of annexes: 9 Responsible Organization: Principal Author(s): IMPACTS Europe Ian Johnson Contributing Organization(s): Contributing Author(s): Transport for London Tony Haynes Hal Evans Peer Rewiew Partner Date Version 0.1 ISIS 27/05/11 Approval for delivery ISIS Date Version 0.1 Coordination 30/05/11 WP2-SOTA Report May 2011 2 Table of Contents 1.TU UT ReferenceTU DocumentsUT ...................................................................................................... 8 2.TU UT AnnexesTU UT ............................................................................................................................. 9 3.TU UT ExecutiveTU SummaryUT ....................................................................................................... 10 3.1.TU UT ContextTU UT ........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Exhibition Series Turning to Farce?
    14 — THE CITIZEN. Prince George — Friday, May 25, 1984 Exhibition series M ic h a e l turning to farce? F a r b e r TORONTO i CP i - A record 24,768 ning (when the game was tied 4-4),” fans were entertained and the cof­ said Blue Jay infielder Garth Iorg, fers of amateur baseball federations who lined a game-tying double to in Canada swelled, but the annual right in the fifth inning. "Just split MONTREAL — The Soviets’ recent game of Pearson Cup exhibition game be­ the trophy in half and give it to both political football with the Olympic movement tween the Montreal Expos and To­ teams. brings to mind another quieter power play in­ ronto Blue Jays suffered a late-in- "I think playing that long is point­ volving Nadia Comaneci, the recently-retired ning black eye Thursday night. less.” he added. "And half the fans gymnast. With bullpen coach Joe Kerrigan are gone, because the stars are out Comaneci re-invented her sport, bending and on the mound in the 13th inning for of the game. We were just playing it shaping gymnastics the same way she did her Montreal and Toronto catcher Buck out.” 83 pounds eight years ago in those steamy Martinez throwing warmup pitches Having left his starting rotation at nights at the Montreal Forum when she made in the bullpen, the annual affair be­ home and not about to use his bull­ a generation of girls stop wanting to be nurses tween Canada’s major league base­ pen aces.
    [Show full text]
  • The Cord Weekly (February 12, 1976)
    Volume 16, Number 16 the Cord Weekly Thursday, February 12, 1976 WLUSU rounding up the year's business by Jack Williams significantly change existing prac- The Board of Directors of tices. WLUSU met on Monday night to Position descriptions of the vari- discuss several items. ous WLSU student positions were Thefirstitem discussed discussed next. Many ofthem had was sev- approved eral policies covering the opera- been at the previous tions of meeting. One position description, the Turret. The Lounge that Policy Committee recommended of Treasurer, was amended to decrease the amount policies on Special ofHonouraria Admissions, paid $450 Admission Booking from to $350 effective Passes, the February 26. Mike Turret for special Strong, speak- events, services ing on behalf of the amendment and products offered, prices and ar- staff. gued that "the amount.of time needed to fulfill the job of Treas- urer not The Admission policy changes does exceed that of the existing policy on advance tickets. other officers who only get paid $350". The passed. Under the new ruling, only motion WLU Several position students may purchase advance descriptions for tickets the Board of Student Activities on Tuesday, the first day of were also considered. Oneof sales. U of W and must them, others wait marketing Services Coordinator, until Wednesday to purchase their caused acircular discussion. It was tickets; however, a WLU students argued that the position was un- may buy up to three non-WLU tic- necessary because each organiza- kets on Tuesday. tion in the BSA is capable of handl- ing own The Special Admission its advertising and that a Passes central position only create policy also changed existing prac- would more problems.
    [Show full text]
  • Universi^ International
    INFORMATION TO USERS This was produced from a copy of a document sent to us for microfilming. While the most advanced technological means to photograph and reproduce this document have been used, the quality is heavily dependent upon the quality of the material submitted. The following explanation of techniques is provided to help you understand markings or notations which may appear on this reproduction. 1. The sign or “target” for pages apparently lacking from the document photographed is “Missing Page(s)”. If it was possible to obtain the missing page(s) or section, they are spliced into the film along with adjacent pages. This may have necessitated cutting through an image and duplicating adjacent pages to assure you of complete continuity. 2. When an image on the film is obliterated with a round black mark it is an indication that the film inspector noticed either blurred copy because of movement during exposure, or duplicate copy. Unless we meant to delete copyrighted materials that should not have been filmed, you will find a good image of the page in the adjacent frame. 3. When a map, drawing or chart, etc., is part of the material being photo­ graphed the photographer has followed a definite method in “sectioning” the material. It is customary to begin filming at the upper left hand comer of a large sheet and to continue from left to right in equal sections with small overlaps. If necessary, sectioning is continued again-beginning below the first row and continuing on until complete. 4. For any illustrations that cannot be reproduced satisfactorily by xerography, photographic prints can be purchased at additional cost and tipped into your xerographic copy.
    [Show full text]
  • RESULTS WOMEN Individual All - Around
    RESULTS WOMEN Individual all - around Year Location Gold Silver Bronze Elena Teodorescu- 1957 Bucharest Larisa Latynina Sonia Iovan Leustean Elena Teodorescu - 1959 Krakow Natalia Kot Sonia Iovan Leustean Vera Caslavska 1961 Leipzig Larisa Latynina Polina Astakhova Ingrid Fost 1963 Paris Mirjana Bili ć Solveig Egman Eva Rydell 1965 Sofia Vera Caslavska Larisa Latynina Birgit Radochla Mariana 1967 Amsterdam Vera Caslavska Zinaida Druginina Krajcirova Ludmila 1969 Landskrona Karin Janz Olga Karasseva Turischeva Erika Zuchold Tamara Lazakovich 1971 Minsk - Erika Zuchold Ludmila Turischeva Ludmila 1973 London Olga Korbut Kerstin Gerschau Turischeva Nadia 1975 Skien Nelli Kim Annelore Zinke Comaneci Nadia 1977 Prague Elena Mukhina Nelli Kim Comaneci Nadia Natalia 1979 Copenhagen Emilia Eberle Comaneci Shaposhnikova 1981 Madrid Maxi Gnauck Cristina Grigoras Alla Misnik Ecaterina Szabo 1983 Gothenburg Olga Bicherova Lavinia Agache Albina Shishova 1985 Helsinki Elena Maxi Gnauck Oksana Shushunova Omelianchik Diana Dudeva Daniela 1987 Moscow Aleftina Pryakhina Elena Silivas Shushunova Svetlana 1989 Brussels Daniela Silivas Olga Strazheva Boguinskaya Svetlana 1990 Athens Natalia Kalinina Henrietta Onodi Boguinskaya Vanda 1992 Nantes Tatiana Gutsu Gina Gogean Hadarean Svetlana Khorkina 1994 Stockholm Gina Gogean - Dina Kochetkova Lilia Svetlana Lavinia 1996 Birmingham Podkopayeva Boguinskaya Milosovici Saint Svetlana Claudia 1998 Simona Amanar Petersburg Khorkina Presacan Svetlana Elena Viktoria 2000 Paris Khorkina Zamolodchikova Karpenko Svetlana
    [Show full text]
  • 1980 Olympics Moscow, Soviet Union
    USA Gymnastics Online: Results: 1980 Olympics Page 1 of 3 1980 Olympics Moscow, Soviet Union 1. Soviet Union 2. East Germany 3. Hungary Men's All-Around 1. Alexandr Ditiatin Soviet Union 118.650 2. Nikolai Andrianov Soviet Union 118.225 3. Stoyan Delchev Bulgaria 118.000 Men's Floor Exercise 1. Roland Bruckner East Germany 2. Nikolai Andrianov Soviet Union 3. Alexandr Ditiatin Soviet Union Men's Pommel Horse 1. Zoltan Magyar Hungary 2. Alexandr Ditiatin Soviet Union 3. Michael Nikolai East Germany Men's Still Rings 1. Alexandr Ditiatin Soviet Union 2. Alexandr Tkachev Soviet Union 3. Jiri Tabak Czechoslovakia Men's Vault 1. Nikolai Andrianov Soviet Union 2. Alexandr Ditiatin Soviet Union 3. Roland Bruckner East Germany Men's Parallel Bars USA Gymnastics Online: Results: 1980 Olympics Page 2 of 3 1. Alexandr Tkachev Soviet Union 2. Alexandr Ditiatin Soviet Union 3. Roland Bruckner Germ. Dem. Rep. Men's Horizontal Bar 1. Stoyan Delchev Bulgaria 2. Alexandr Ditiatin Soviet Union 3. Nikolai Andrianov Soviet Union Women's Team 1. Soviet Union 2. Romania 3. East Germany Women's All-Around 1. Elena Davydova Soviet Union 79.150 2t. Maxi Gnauck East Germany 79.075 2t. Nadia Comaneci Romania 79.075 Women's Vault 1. Natalia Shaposhnikova Soviet Union 2. Steffi Kraeker East Germany 3. Melita Ruhn Romania Women's Uneven Bars 1. Maxi Gnauck East Germany 2. Emilia Eberle Romania 3t. Maria Filatova Soviet Union 3t. Steffi Kraeker East Germany 3t. Melita Ruhn Romania Women's Balance Beam USA Gymnastics Online: Results: 1980 Olympics Page 3 of 3 1.
    [Show full text]
  • The Impact of Nadia Comaneci on the Sport of Women's Artistic Gymnastics
    87 The Impact of Nadia Comaneci on the Sport of Women's Artistic Gymnastics Roslyn Kerr is currently completing her PhD in sociology at Canterbury University where she is examining elite gymnastics in New Zealand. Her research interests include technology in sport, talent identification and the philosophy of sport. Roslyn has held numerous roles in gymnastics in New Zealand and currently works as a coach and administrator. IN 1976, EXACTLY 30 years ago, gymnast Nadia Comaneci burst onto the stage at the Montreal Olympic Games and changed the sport of women's artistic gymnastics forever. It is indisputable that Comaneci's performance at the 1976 Olympic Games was highly significant in influencing the sport of women's artistic gymnastics. Authors have agreed that Comaneci 'changed the judging standards',1 'introduced fundamental changes',2 'did things in gymnastics that had never been done before',3 and generally 'changed everything about the sport'.4 This article discusses exactly what constituted the changes Comaneci introduced in the sport both technically and stylistically and how these affected the sport in years to come. This article also argues that Comaneci was the most prominent 'advertisement' for a nascent trend towards younger, pre-pubescent gymnasts which had begun in the late 1960s, though not the sole reason for this change as is often believed. This article is part of a larger research project about the history of women's gymnastics since 1952. It utilises not only archival research, but an analysis of the gold medal routines at each Olympic Games since 1952 obtained through video footage, an examination of the rule book, the Code of Points, and interviews with 20 gymnastics experts from around the world.
    [Show full text]
  • January 2 2015 Issue
    BUILDING PERMITS / FORECLOSURES / PUBLIC NOTICES KAY’S COOKING CORNER BELL DEVELOPMENT – REAL ESTATE P7 P10 P11 Volume 102 | No. 1 HAMILTON COUNTY Single Copy 50¢ CHATTANOOGA, HAMILTON COUNTY, TENNESSEE Friday, January 2, 2015 H 100 YEARS AGO Putting change in the hands What was going on in Chattanooga in 1915? Saturday, Jan. 2 of the community Miss Ruth Richmond made By David Laprad her debut Friday night at the Patten Hotel in a brilliant ball A sign near Dr. Valerie Radu’s given by her mother, Mrs. desk serves as a reminder to her- Edward Gould Richmond. self and an invitation to others: Two hundred and fty guests “Write your own life story,” the attended. Mrs. Richmond small placard says. was assisted in receiving by Radu is the executive direc- close friends. tor of the Family Justice Center Wisdom Goree has re- (FJC) in Chattanooga, a federal turned to his home in Atlanta and state government funded after a visit with his cousin, program focused on reducing Brook Brantly, on Missionary relationship violence in Ten- nessee. A child of missionaries, Ridge. she grew up in a family in which Miss Wessie Bowen will service to others was important. leave Monday to return to But as a social scientist, she wants Randolph Macon College in to do more than meet immediate Virginia. needs; she wants to bring about Sunday, Jan. 3 lasting change by using research to develop “best practices.” Mr. and Mrs. Wilson Kerr e words on the placard, announce the engagement therefore, remind her to follow and approaching marriage of not just her heart but also her their daughter, Margaret, to head as she leads the center.
    [Show full text]
  • Into Reverse Twice in the Next Few Weeks
    24 THE MERAU). Tnes., Jahf »W1 Conoco into reverse twice in the next few weeks. policy issues.” ' ■ ■ ' . guideUn^ percent. In the second quarter of cond quarter dropped t)y investment, measured alone, $3.8 billion offer from Joseph E. legal action to block the purchase, Conoco, which competes vigorousls^ IS uncertandies WASHINGTON (UPI) -N fh e Revisions of first quarter figures STAMFORD (UPI) - Conoco and hrmnlly-with Mobil in all phases Mobil had no ImmoiBate coni^ economy abruptly shifted into 1978, prices went up 5.8 pwcent. billion. accelerated downward by 20.8 per­ Inc.'s directors, warning a takeover Seagram & Sons, the U,S. sub­ which would be the largest in U.S. surrounding the Mobil offer,” cent. sent GNP up an additional 2 percent. of the petroleum business, a major ment. When Mobil made its $$0-a- reverse from April through June The GNP, after seasonal adjust­ But the drop was mostly wiped out After adjustment for inflation as by Mobil Oil Corp. could trigger a sidiary of the Canada-based corporate history. share cash and 'stock bid'' laat • Bailey said, “it w u clear to our ment, was $2881 biUion - $2.88 in the final figure because the Exportp decreased by 5.3 percent Seagram liquor concern. Mohil is the nation’s second ridtructuring of the U.S. indust^ is GNP down and the gross national product well as seasonal factors, second “ntajor restructuring” of the U.S. likely to result with substantial Friday, Mobil OiahlHni Ra«Wld> board that cbntimied strong suptot declined 1.9 percent on an annual trillion— the first decline since last ovendnent counted cars held by on an annual basis and government petroleum industry, say the com­ Following the board meeting, largest oR company hdiind Exxon.
    [Show full text]
  • Podium Individual Compus Feminin 1934 - 2011
    Podium individual compus Feminin 1934 - 2011 Year Location Gold Silver Bronze 1934 Budapest Vlasta Dakanova M. Kalcosaly J. Skirklinska Zde ňka 1938 Prague Vlasta Dakanova Matylda Pálfyová Ve řmi řovská 1942 Not held due to World War II 1950 Basel Helena Rakoczy Anna Petersen Gertrude Kolar 1954 Rome Galina Rudiko Eva Bosáková Helena Rakoczy 1958 Moscow Larisa Latynina Eva Bosáková Tamara Manina 1962 Prague Larisa Latynina Věra Čáslavská Irina Pervuschina Natalia 1966 Dortmund Věra Čáslavská Keiko Ikeda Kutchinskaya Ludmila 1970 Ljubljana Erika Zuchold Zinaida Voronina Turicheva Ludmila 1974 Varna Olga Korbut Angelika Hellmann Turicheva Natalia 1978 Strasbourg Elena Mukhina Nellie Kim Shaposhnikova 1979 Fort Worth Nellie Kim Maxi Gnauck Melita Ruhn 1981 Moscow Olga Bicherova Maria Filatova Elena Davydova Natalia Olga 1983 Budapest Ekaterina Szabo Yurchenko Mostepanova Elena Shushunova 1985 Montreal - Dagmar Kersten Oksana Omelianchik Elena 1987 Rotterdam Aurelia Dobre Daniela Siliva ş Shushunova Svetlana Natalia 1989 Stuttgart Olga Strazheva Boguinskaya Lashchenova Svetlana 1991 Kim Zmeskal Cristina Bonta ş Indianapolis Boguinskaya 1992 Paris No all-around event held 1993 Birmingham Shannon Miller Gina Gogean Tatiana Lysenko Lavinia 1994 Brisbane Shannon Miller Dina Kochetkova Milo şovici Lilia Svetlana 1995 Sabae Lavinia Milo şovici Podkopayeva Khorkina 1996 San Juan No all-around event held Svetlana 1997 Lausanne Simona Amânar Elena Produnova Khorkina Viktoria Elena 1999 Tianjin Maria Olaru Karpenko Zamolodchikova Svetlana Natalia 2001 Ghent Andreea R ăducan Khorkina Ziganshina 2002 Debrecen No all-around event held Svetlana 2003 Anaheim Carly Patterson Zhang Nan Khorkina 2005 Melbourne Chellsie Memmel Anastasia Liukin Monette Russo 2006 Aarhus Vanessa Ferrari Jana Bieger Sandra Izba şa Jade Barbosa 2007 Stuttgart Shawn Johnson Steliana Nistor Vanessa Ferrari 2009 London Bridget Sloan Rebecca Bross Koko Tsurumi 2010 Rotterdam Aliya Mustafina Jiang Yuyuan Rebecca Bross 2011 Tokyo Jordyn Wieber Viktoria Komova Yao Jinnan 2013 Antwerp 2014 Nanning 2015 Glasgow .
    [Show full text]
  • Hostage Ihanrltpater
    Hostage iHanrltpater Situation £p r n t u n lUrralJi T - • _______ __________ H I VolV. oXlC. IXXC, IXN,o .N ^o. t—o —Ma MncahnMchtwM, tw(io, ntino.n, nF.r,i dFaryid, aDy«, cD«*mc«bm«rb 7«,r i, • Si•n cSein 1c8eB 1 8•8 12 0•« 2S0i«n gSlien gCloe pCyo •p y1 5•c1 5Hco mHeo mDie Delivered I unceriain^-------------------------Jobless TEHRAN, Iran (UPI) - Iran’s — the only man who can free them — foreign minister said today some of and the militants themselves. the 50 U.S. hostages will be freed In his first personal reaction to the F igu res shortly and others tried as spies, with United Nations resolution calling for possible death penalties. But the release of the hostages. Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini quick- Khomeini denounced it as a "plot by ly jeopardized the promised releases the American Security Council, CIA D ecline with a blistering attack on the United and SAVAK” — the former Iranian States. secret police. Khomeini said Iranians should Khomeini urged all Iranians to go WASHINGTON (UPI) - sever all ties with the United States to the rooftops of their homes this Unemployment edged down to 5.8 and "rub America's snout into the evening and shout "AIlah-Akbar” percent in November, with most of dust.” He dismissed the U.N. Securi- ("God is great” ) and "Death to the the improvement among women and ty Council resolution calling for world-eating American im- blacks, the Labor Department said release of the hostages as an perialism" today. "American plot.” He charged the United States is Militant students, too, denounced hatching plots daily against Iran and The decline, from 6 percent in Oc- Foreign Minister Sadegh Qodb- he is “expecting new bitter tober, came at a time when most zadeh's statement on the release of happenings” soon.
    [Show full text]
  • Soviet Visions and Adaptations to the Rejuvenation of Elite Sports (Second Half of the 20Th Century) Sylvain Dufraisse
    Facing the Involvement of Youths in Competitions: Soviet Visions and Adaptations to the Rejuvenation of Elite Sports (Second Half of the 20th Century) Sylvain Dufraisse To cite this version: Sylvain Dufraisse. Facing the Involvement of Youths in Competitions: Soviet Visions and Adaptations to the Rejuvenation of Elite Sports (Second Half of the 20th Century). Frontiers in Sports and Active Living, Frontiers Media S.A., 2020, 2, 10.3389/fspor.2020.568025. halshs-02973311 HAL Id: halshs-02973311 https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-02973311 Submitted on 24 Nov 2020 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. ORIGINAL RESEARCH published: 21 October 2020 doi: 10.3389/fspor.2020.568025 Facing the Involvement of Youths in Competitions: Soviet Visions and Adaptations to the Rejuvenation of Elite Sports (Second Half of the 20th Century) Sylvain Dufraisse* UMR 6025 CENS, Université de Nantes-CNRS, Nantes, France Edited by: François Vallotton, University of Lausanne, Switzerland This article focuses on Soviet sports authorities’ adaptations to youth involvement Reviewed by: in elite sports during the second half of the 20th century during the Cold War. It Shushu Chen, demonstrates that the quest for performance and success in world competitions University of Birmingham, United Kingdom meant that sportsmen needed to start training at younger ages.
    [Show full text]