Arxiv:1808.01879V3 [Astro-Ph.CO] 26 Dec 2019
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
NORDITA-2018-063, MPP-2018-237 Axion Miniclusters in Modified Cosmological Histories 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, Luca Visinelli ∗ and Javier Redondo y 1Department of Physics and Astronomy, Uppsala University, L¨agerhyddsv¨agen1, 75120 Uppsala, Sweden 2Nordita, KTH Royal Institute of Technology and Stockholm University, Roslagstullsbacken 23, 10691 Stockholm, Sweden 3Gravitation Astroparticle Physics Amsterdam (GRAPPA), Institute for Theoretical Physics Amsterdam and Delta Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of Amsterdam, Science Park 904, 1098 XH Amsterdam, The Netherlands 4Departamento de F´ısica Te´orica, Universidad de Zaragoza. c/ Pedro Cerbuna 12, 50009 Zaragoza, Spain 5Max Planck Institute for Physics, Foehringer Ring 6, 80805 Munich, Germany (Dated: December 30, 2019) If the symmetry breaking leading to the origin of the axion dark matter field occurs after the end of inflation and is never restored, then overdensities in the axion field collapse to form dense objects known in the literature as axion miniclusters. The estimates of the typical minicluster mass and radius strongly depend on the details of the cosmology at which the onset of axion oscillations begin. In this work we study the properties and phenomenology of miniclusters in alternative cosmological histories and find that they can change by many orders of magnitude. Our findings have direct implications on current and future experimental searches and, in the case of discovery, could be used to learn something about the universe expansion prior to Big-Bang-Nucleosynthesis. I. INTRODUCTION The history and the properties of the present axion field strongly depend on the moment at which the break- The nature of the cold dark matter (CDM) remains ing of the PQ symmetry occurs with respect to infla- unknown to date despite the growth of evidence in sup- tion [44{56]. If the PQ symmetry breaking occurs after port of its existence coming, on top of the original mo- inflation, a fraction of the total axions component is ex- tivations [1,2], from gravitational lensing [3], the cos- pected to organize into gravitationally bound structures mic microwave background radiation (CMBR) [4,5], also known as axion \miniclusters" [57{61], prompted by the in combination with Lyman-α and weak lensing [6], the inhomogeneities of the axion field in this scenario. Axion hierarchical structure formation of the observable uni- miniclusters are compact objects with a density of various verse [7], the formation and evolution of galaxies [8{10], orders of magnitude higher than the present local CDM galactic collisions [11, 12], and a plethora of other obser- density. Inside axion miniclusters another type of ex- vational techniques. otic structure, an axion star [62{84], could possibly form. Among the many hypothetical particles that could It has been argued that the first miniclusters that ever compose the CDM is the quantum chromodynamics come into place have a characteristic size of the order of 12 10− solar masses. This scale is much smaller than the (QCD) axion [13, 14]. The axion is the pseudo-Goldstone ∼ boson arising in the spontaneous breaking of a U(1) sym- smallest clump that WIMPs would assemble into in the metry first introduced by Peccei and Quinn (PQ [15, 16]) standard cosmology, because of their much longer free- 1 to address the strong-CP problem [17{20]. The fact that streaming length . Therefore, detecting these clumps axions could solve two distinct problems in physics makes provides a unique discrimination signature among CDM its search particularly appealing. If the axion field ex- candidates. As structure formation evolves, axion mini- ists, it has a very small mass and faint couplings to or- clusters are expected to hierarchically assemble into dark dinary particles. Both happen to be suppressed by a matter halos of galactic size, forming minicluster halos. new energy scale, the axion decay constant fA, which This claim has yet to be addressed numerically, as well as corresponds approximately to the scale of PQ symmetry the possibility that miniclusters might have not survived breaking and which is constrained by axion phenomenol- tidal disruption. Some studies suggest that miniclusters > 7 1 survive hierarchical structure formation to date [86{89], ogy to be fA 10 GeV. In particular, the scale fA− sets arXiv:1808.01879v3 [astro-ph.CO] 26 Dec 2019 the axion coupling∼ to two photons, which opens the pos- claiming that it is possible to constrain the fraction of sibility for axion electrodynamics [21{26] and promising dark matter in halos using micro-lensing data [90, 91] laboratory detection methods [27{32]. In the literature, and femto-lensing in the future [92] (see also [93]). Semi- mixed dark matter models in which the axion makes up a analytic results on the mass function of axion miniclus- fraction of the dark matter while the rest is in the form of ters are available today [94], with refined numerical work weakly interacting massive particles (WIMPs) have also recently reported [95, 96]. been considered [33{35]. See Refs. [36{43] for reviews of Today, the standard axion miniclusters would be grav- the QCD axion. itationally bound clumps of axions with masses of the ∗ Electronic address: [email protected] 1 See Ref. [85] for the effect of a non-standard cosmology on the y Electronic address: [email protected] free-streaming length of WIMPs. 2 order of the largest asteroids like Vesta or Pallas, and dominant contribution to the CDM they become CDM at of size comparable to an astronomical unit. Miniclusters temperatures GeV, precisely when we cannot ascertain could suffer tidal disruption by stars, with the value of the crucial assumption∼ of radiation domination. bound axions diminishing with respect to its early uni- In this paper we want to drop entirely this assumption verse estimate. It is usually expected that a sizeable frac- and study the properties of axion miniclusters in differ- tion of the galactic DM axions is bound into minicluster ent non-standard cosmologies (NSCs) before BBN. The structures, the remaining part forming a relatively ho- mass and the radius of a minicluster depend crucially on mogeneous halo. Despite the large number of clumps the size of the causal horizon at the time when axions expected, the Earth would encounter only a few such become non-relativistic, which in alternative cosmologies objects every galactic year (!). On the other hand, if might differ by various orders of magnitude with respect the fraction of axions bound into miniclusters is close to to the standard scenario. In order to focus the discus- unity, the direct detection of axions in microwave cavity sion on the novel aspects, we assume that axions make searches could be severely affected. A negative search by up the totality of the cold dark matter observed and that a cavity experiment could be an indication that axions essentially all axions fall into miniclusters. Our results, are mostly organised into clumped structures like mini- summarised in TableI are quite spectacular! In fact, clusters. Since axion detection is sensitive to the local the typical minicluster mass and radius can change by CDM energy density, a clumpy axion distribution would many orders of magnitude with respect to the predictions lead to spikes in the axion detection spectrum and be rel- achieved in the standard cosmology. Most importantly, evant for a direct detection technique. The interest in all the time and duration of encounters with the Earth can of the upcoming axion detectors then lies in the present be largely enhanced or suppressed, opening many possi- phase-space distribution of the axion CDM, which is not bilities for the direct detection of axion dark matter. expected to be homogeneous even at the interstellar scale. Previous works have already studied how the axion A reliable detection must take into account the possibil- mass for which the axion explains the totality of the ity of a inhomogeneous CDM distribution either in space observed CDM is modified in several NSCs [107{109] (axion miniclusters and stars) or in momentum (low- but the changes to the properties of miniclusters are dispersion filaments from tidal stripping). Moreover, if presented here for the first time. Moreover, regarding the axion is discovered by a haloscope experiment like the treatment of NSCs and the axion DM mass, we ADMX, HAYSTAC or CULTASK, the energy spectrum improve over previous results by computing the non- will be immediately measured and could be used to do standard cosmologies numerically including the recent galactic astronomy [97]. The spectrum and its variation detailed input from lattice QCD (equation of state and in time (daily and anual modulations) can be used to axion mass) [110] and presenting simple analytical com- identify substructure in the axion DM distribution like parisons with the standard radiation dominated case. tidal streams from dwarf-galaxies [98] or even from axion Note that, in addition to the cold axion population, a miniclusters themselves, obtaining their main properties modified cosmology would alter the yield of thermally with precision [97]. With these techniques, astronomical produced axions [111], as well as of any other light par- quantities like the solar peculiar velocity could be mea- ticle such as neutrinos [112, 113]; however, since for the sured even better than with ordinary astronomy. Several range of masses considered in this work, mA < 10 meV, variations of the haloscope concept allow to measure the the thermal population is a sub-dominant component∼ to axion velocity distribution by enabling directional detec- the total energy density, we do not discuss this contribu- tion [99{101], increasing the precision and decreasing the tion further. required measurement time. Understanding the fraction This paper is organised as follows. Sec.II is a brief re- of axions bound in miniclusters and of the axion phase- view of the production of cosmological axions.