Examination of Passenger Assaults
On Bus Transit Systems
FDOT Task Work Order #943-26
University Master Agreement BDV25
FINAL REPORT
December 2015
PREPARED FOR
Florida Department of Transportation
Office of Freight, Logistics and Passenger Operations
Examination of Passenger Assaults
On Bus Transit Systems
Final Report
Funded By:
FDOT Project Manager:
Victor Wiley, Transit Safety Programs Manager
Florida Department of Transportation
605 Suwannee Street, MS-26 Tallahassee, FL 32399-0450
Prepared By:
USF Center for Urban Transportation Research
Lisa Staes, Program Director – Transit Safety and Workforce Development
Jan Davis, Deputy Director – Transportation Finance, Management and Administration
Contributor: Jodi Godfrey, Research Associate
December 2015
- Final Report
- i
Disclaimer
The contents of this report reflect the views of the authors, who are responsible for the facts and the accuracy of the information presented herein. This document is disseminated under the sponsorship of the Florida Department of Transportation, in the interest of information exchange. The Florida Department of Transportation assumes no liability for the contents or use thereof.
The opinions, findings, and conclusions expressed in this publication are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the Florida Department of Transportation.
- Final Report
- ii
Technical Documentation Page
- 1. Report No.
- 2. Government Accession No.
- 3. Recipient's Catalog No.
4. Title and Subtitle:
Examination of Passenger Assaults on Bus Transit Systems
5. Report Date December 2015
6. Performing Organization Code
7. Author(s) Lisa Staes, Jan Davis, Jodi Godfrey
8. Performing Organization Report No. BDV25 Task Work Order #943-26
9. Performing Organization Name and Address National Center for Transit Research
10. Work Unit No. (TRAIS)
Center for Urban Transportation Research University of South Florida
11. Contract or Grant No. FDOT BDV25-943-26
4202 E Fowler Avenue, CUT 100, Tampa, FL 33620-5375
12. Sponsoring Agency Name and Address Florida Department of Transportation 605 Suwannee Street, MS-30
13. Type of Report and Period Covered Research Report September 2014 – December 2015
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0450
14. Sponsoring Agency Code
N/A
15. Supplementary Notes 16. Abstract This research provides a status report on the state of the industry and current conditions under which Florida public transportation systems are operating, and the type, severity, and prevalence of passenger assaults on these systems. The project team will review the time of day assaults are most prevalent; type of services on which they occur most frequently (i.e., paratransit, fixed-route, commuter/express route; and location (i.e., on board, transfer locations, bus stops).
The goals of this research effort are to:
1. Identify the prevalence of assaults on bus transit passengers. 2. Identify the time of day within which the assaults are occurring 3. Identify the locations where assaults are occurring (i.e., on board, transfer stations, bus stops) 4. Identify any other environmental factors which may contribute to an increased occurrence of assaults 5. Identify any mitigation measures transit agencies have employed to reduce the incidence rate of these assaults
6. Identify any mitigation measures that may not be currently utilized by Florida’s public transportation agencies that may be deemed relevant and successful in curtailing assaults on transit passengers.
- 17. Key Words
- 18. Distribution Statement
public transit, passenger assault, bus driver assaults, bus operator training, transit safety
- 19. Security Classification (of this report) 20. Security Classification (of this page) 21. No. of
- 22. Price
Pages
- Unclassified
- Unclassified
115
- Final Report
- iii
Metric Conversion
SI* Modern Metric Conversion Factors as provided by the Department of Transportation, Federal Highway Administration http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/aaa/metricp.htm
LENGTH
- SYMBOL
- WHEN YOU
- MULTIPLY BY
- TO FIND
- SYMBOL
- in
- Inches
Feet
- 25.4
- millimeters
meters mm
- m
- ft
- 0.305
0.914 1.61 yd mi
Yards Miles
- meters
- m
- kilometers
- km
AREA
SYMBOL
in2 ft2 yd2
WHEN YOU
square inches square feet square yard Acres
MULTIPLY BY
645.2
- TO FIND
- SYMBOL
square millimeters mm2
- 0.093
- square meters
square meters hectares m2 m2 ha
0.836
- ac
- 0.405
- mi2
- square miles
- 2.59
- square kilometers km2
LENGTH
- SYMBOL
- WHEN YOU
- MULTIPLY
- TO FIND
- SYMBOL
mm mmillimeters meters
0.039 3.28 inches feet in ft
- m
- meters
- 1.09
- yards
miles yd
- mi
- km
- kilometers
- 0.621
AREA
SYMBOL
mm2 m2
- WHEN YOU
- MULTIPLY BY
- TO FIND
- SYMBOL
in2 ft2
- square millimeters 0.0016
- square inches
square feet square yards acres square meters square meters hectares
10.764 1.195 2.47
- m2
- yd2
- ha
- ac
- km2
- square kilometers 0.386
- square miles
- mi2
*SI is the symbol for the International System of Units. Appropriate rounding should be made to comply with Section 4 of ASTM E380.
- Final Report
- iv
Acknowledgements
This research report was prepared by the Center for Urban Transportation Research for the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT), Office of Freight, Logistics, and Passenger Operations.
The Research Team would like to express our appreciation to FDOT Project Manager, Victor Wiley for his oversight, management, and support of this research effort. We would also like
to recognize and offer our thanks to the members of Florida’s Transit Safety Network who
provided valuable input in the scoping of this project and review of information and data collected for this research. Finally, we would like to express our appreciation and gratitude to the many public transit agencies that graciously responded to our inquiries and provided input and data for this effort, including:
Broward County Transit (BCT) Charlotte County Transit Division (CCTD) Collier Area Transit (CAT) Gainesville Regional Transit System (RTS) Good Wheels, Inc. Hillsborough Area Regional Transit Authority (HART) Jacksonville Transportation Authority (JTA) Lakeland Area Mass Transit District (Citrus Connection) Lee County Transit (Lee Tran) Central Florida Regional Transportation Authority, dba, LYNX Manatee County Area Transit (MCAT) Miami Dade Transit (MDT) Palm Beach County Board of County Commissioners (Palm Tran) Pasco County Public Transportation (PCPT) Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority (PSTA) Polk County Transit Services Division (PCTS) Sarasota County Area Transit (SCAT) City of Tallahassee (Star Metro) Transdev (Hardee, Highlands, Okeechobee, and Desoto counties) Volusia County Transit System (VOTRAN)
- Final Report
- v
Table of Contents
List of Tables .......................................................................................................... viii Acronyms.................................................................................................................ix Executive Summary...................................................................................................xi Chapter 1 – Trends in Passenger Assaults .....................................................................1
Background and Scope.............................................................................................1 Literature Review ....................................................................................................4 Research Process ....................................................................................................4 Assault-related Fatalities and Injuries ........................................................................5 Nationwide & Florida Trends – National Transit Database, 2008-2015 ............................5
Florida Trends – Aggregated Agency Incident Data ...................................................9
Chapter 2 – Florida Transit Agency Procedures and Practices.........................................13
Profiled Florida Transit Agencies – Site Visits and Interviews.......................................13
Broward County Transit, Pompano Beach, FL .........................................................14
Central Florida Regional Transportation Authority, dba, “LYNX,” Orlando, FL ..............16
Charlotte County Transit, Punta Gorda, FL .............................................................18 Collier Area Transit, Naples, FL.............................................................................21 Gainesville Regional Transit System, Gainesville, FL................................................23 Good Wheels, Inc. Fort Myers, FL .........................................................................26 Hillsborough Area Regional Transit Authority, Tampa, FL .........................................29 Jacksonville Transportation Authority, Jacksonville, FL.............................................32 Lakeland Area Mass Transit District, d.b.a., Citrus Connection, Lakeland, FL ..............36 Lee Tran, Ft. Myers, FL........................................................................................39 Manatee County Area Transit, Bradenton, FL..........................................................42 Miami-Dade Transit, Miami, FL .............................................................................44 Palm Tran, West Palm Beach, FL...........................................................................47 Pasco County Public Transportation, Port Richey, FL................................................50 Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority, St. Petersburg, FL ............................................53 Polk County Transit Services Division, Bartow, FL ...................................................55 Sarasota County Area Transit, Sarasota, FL ...........................................................57 Star Metro, Tallahassee, FL..................................................................................60 Transdev, Sebring, FL .........................................................................................63 Votran, South Daytona, FL...................................................................................65
- Final Report
- vi
Chapter 3 – Summary of Highlighted Practices.............................................................68
Training ...............................................................................................................68 Customer Service..................................................................................................69 Incident Response & Investigations .........................................................................70 Corrective Actions .................................................................................................70 Safety Campaigns .................................................................................................70
Chapter 4 – Conclusions and Recommendations...........................................................72
Conclusions ..........................................................................................................72 Recommendations.................................................................................................73
References ..............................................................................................................74 Appendix A – Literature Review .................................................................................77 Appendix B – Passenger and Operator Incidents & Assaults Transit System Questionnaire.87
- Final Report
- vii
List of Tables
Table 1. Assault-related Fatalities and Injuries, 2008-2015..............................................2 Table 2. Florida Assault-related Fatalities and Injuries, 2008-2015 ...................................2 Table 3. Percentage of Assault-related Fatalities/Injuries.................................................3 Table 4. Percentage of Florida Assault-related Injuries by Category of Injured, Florida Agencies, 2008-2014..................................................................................................3
Table 5. Assault-related Fatalities and Injuries, 2008-2015, All Agencies...........................6 Table 6. Assault-related Fatalities and Injuries, 2008-2015, Florida ..................................6 Table 7. Type of Assault-related Injuries by Location, 2008-2015, All Agencies..................6 Table 8.Type of Assaulted-related injury by Location, 2008-2015, Florida..........................7 Table 9. On-vehicle Assault-related Injuries, 2008-2015, All Agencies ..............................7 Table 10. On-vehicle Assault-related Injuries, 2008-2015, Florida ....................................7 Table 11. Assault-related Injuries by Day of Week & Location, 2008-2015, All Agencies......8 Table 12. Assault-related Injuries by Day of Week & Location, 2008-2015, Florida .............8 Table 13. On-vehicle Assault-related Injuries by Day of Week, 2008-2015 ........................9 Table 14. Conduct-related Incidents, 2013-2015..........................................................10 Table 15. Conduct-related Incidents by Month, 2013-2015............................................10 Table 16. Conduct-related Incidents by Day of Week, 2013-2015...................................11 Table 17. Conduct-related Incidents by Time of Day, 2013-2015....................................12
- Final Report
- viii
Acronyms
ADA APTA ATU AVL BCT
Americans with Disabilities Act American Public Transportation Association Amalgamated Transit Union Automatic Vehicle Location Broward County Transit
CAD CAP
Computer Aided Dispatch Corrective Action Plan
- CAT
- Collier Area Transit
CBA CBT
Collective Bargaining Agreement Computer Based Training
CCTD CDL CEO
Charlotte County Transit Division
Commercial Driver’s License
Chief Executive Officer
- CFO
- Chief Financial Officer
CFRPC CMV CTC CUTR DHS EAP
Central Florida Regional Planning Council Commercial Motor Vehicle Community Transportation Coordinator Center for Urban Transportation Research Department of Homeland Security Employee Assistance Program
- Executive Summary
- ES
- FAC
- Florida Administrative Code
Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University Florida Department of Transportation Florida Highway Patrol
FAMU FDOT FHP FON FS
Florida Operation Network Florida Statutes
- FSU
- Florida State University
FTA FTE
Federal Transit Administration Full Time Equivalent
FTSN GPS
Florida Transit Safety Network Global Positioning System
- GM
- General Manager
HART JSO JTA LAMTD LCB
Hillsborough Area Regional Transit Authority
Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office
Jacksonville Transportation Authority Lakeland Area Mass Transit District Local Coordinating Board
LEETRAN MCAT MDC MDT MVR NCTR NSC NTD PALM TRAN PBC
Lee County Transit Manatee County Area Transit Miami Dade County Miami Dade Transit Motor Vehicle Records National Center for Transit Research National Safety Council National Transit Database Palm Beach County Surface Transportation Palm Beach County
PCPT PSTA
Pasco County Public Transportation Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority