IB Research Notes

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

IB Research Notes IB Research Notes Information for the IB research community Volume 2, Issue 2 April 2002 Welcome to IB Research Notes, Volume 2 Issue 2. In this issue This issue’s feature article is by Simon Murray. The Research Notes article considers the global economy from a Theory of Knowledge perspective. Mr Samir Chammaa, head of Ibn ~ Call for Articles Khuldoon School, and Mr Mike Clarke, subject area Feature Article: manager at IBCA, provide responses to the article. The Value(s) of Also included in this issue is an article outlining a Theory of Knowledge longitudinal study relating to Swedish IB Diploma in a Global Economy holders, and details of the research committee and its Simon Murray functions. Study Report: The research unit, in conjunction with the research Longitudinal studies in the committee, is actively developing a research strategy IBO: Swedish Diploma for e-learning as it relates to international schools Holders Research Study and international contexts. We are looking for 1971–1993 individuals and groups who may wish to become Annika Andrae Thelin et al involved in e-learning activities or who may wish to The Research Committee share their work through IB Research Notes. Please contact [email protected] if you would like further Research Noticeboard information. ~ Interpreting International We would also be interested in hearing from prospective Education conference authors of articles related to any field of international ~ Journal of Research in education. They can e-mail [email protected] to discuss their International Education ideas and suggestions for articles. ~ Research committee IB teachers can access IB Research Notes via news and ~ Research literature information on the online curriculum centre. To widen access to our research information, IB Research Notes ~ Research conference will also soon appear on the IBO public web pages, but ~ IBO public web site until such time as this occurs it can also be accessed at ~ Online curriculum centre www.bath.ac.uk/Departments/Education/CEIC/ibru/ index.html. IB Research Notes is published four times a year and is a joint publication of the International Baccalaureate Research Unit (IBRU) and the International Baccalaureate Curriculum and Assessment Centre (IBCA). Contact details: IBRU Department of Education University of Bath a Bath GB BA2 7AY Fax: +44 1225 323 277 E-mail: [email protected] © IBO 2002 2 IB Research Notes Research Notes This publication is intended to communicate the outcomes of small-scale pieces of inquiry and developments relevant to the IB community. The reason for publishing in this electronic form is that we wish to provide timely access to ideas arising from inquiries of current significance to the IB community. The general aims of the publication are to: 1. provide a forum for the publication of research related to the IB and international education 2. present research related to the IB to its community via the online curriculum centre 3. establish a forum for exchange of IB research-related comments and information, by providing a feedback column 4. provide the wider IB community with an outline of some of the current research being undertaken on IB-related topics 5. provide information about recent research articles relevant to the three IB programmes. Call for Articles We encourage anyone involved in any form of research within or on the IB programmes (PYP, MYP, Diploma Programme or all three) to contact IBRU at [email protected] if they wish to submit an article or report for publication. We are particularly interested in hearing from teacher researchers within the IB community. Please note that the IBO reserves the right to edit articles, in consultation with the authors, for length and style (articles should not exceed 2500 words). Should you wish to comment critically on articles published in IB Research Notes, please e-mail [email protected]. © IBO 2002 3 IB Research Notes Feature Article Simon Murray is Head of Sixth Form at St George’s British International School, Rome. He has taught English and Theory of Knowledge (TOK) in schools in Spain and Italy, has been a Middle Years Programme approaches to learning coordinator and Diploma Programme coordinator, and was an associate lecturer in arts and social science for The Open University in Europe. He is also a TOK assessor, and is currently researching the impact of globalization on issues of national and international education. The Value(s) of Theory of Knowledge in a Global Economy Simon Murray Abstract This article considers globalization as primarily a problem of knowledge. It goes on to suggest that the increasing commodification of knowledge is a central part of the operation of globalization that, when joined to an apparent liquidation of the difference between politics and economics, raises issues about a possible economics of epistemology. Finally, it considers the status of the national and the international in the context of the global, and tries to outline possible connections between Theory of Knowledge (TOK) and concepts of internationalism. Introduction Given the wealth, perhaps the surplus wealth, of comment on globalization, a further attempt to understand this phenomenon needs to justify itself. This justification is made easier by the fact that, as far as I am aware, education in general is grossly under-represented in the most influential debates, school education rarely mentioned, and international school education apparently a species currently too exotic to classify. Yet it is the provocation offered by globalization to the teaching of Theory of Knowledge, and its response, that might help establish an agenda which currently seems absent in thinking about the future of education in a global economy. And if I have already extended the apparent scope of this article, that extension is legitimated in part by the special role allocated to the teaching of TOK within the Diploma Programme. TOK is the proper place and space for the Diploma Programme to consider itself. And if globalization in turn asks TOK to reflect upon itself as a discipline and consider its own educational value, then the Diploma Programme is itself implied: the mirror of globalization reflects many faces, and at least the six of the current hexagon. © IBO 2002 4 IB Research Notes What is Globalization? Knowledge is and will be produced in order to be sold, it is and will be consumed in order to be valorized in a new production: in both cases, the goal is exchange. Knowledge ceases to be an end in itself.1 These remarks, made during Lyotard’s 1979 report on knowledge for the government of Quebec, probably exceeded his original brief, which was to assess “the condition of knowledge in the most highly developed countries”.2 But, with remarkable prescience, he described our own times very well indeed, I think. Twenty years before the term became fashionable and ultimately indispensable, Lyotard identified the phenomenon that we have come to know as globalization. That he diagnosed it as essentially a problem of knowledge and not just an issue of sovereignty, market economies, communication technology, time–space compression or social justice (though it is certainly all of these and more), makes it particularly relevant to TOK. Thus, we need to examine the impact of globalization as it ramifies across a variety of ways of knowing, itself a wide-ranging research project.3 More pressingly though, we need to assess where it leaves TOK as an educational discipline, and ask ourselves what is its value and what are its values. If knowledge has ceased or is ceasing to be an end in itself, and is now bound increasingly within a process of commodification, then our students need to reflect on this, and we as teachers need to work out how we cope with this situation.4 Recently, a limited debate has been conducted within the IBO about the significance of globalization.5 Thus, Gautam Sen raises the central question that “[b]y omitting a closer scrutiny of globalisation itself, the [strategic] plan seemed to regard it as a process which the IBO could see itself supporting unproblematically”.6 The subsequent exchange between Sen and Walker, albeit conducted in a limited context, did little to address this question, largely because both seemed to conceive of the globalization debate as working from competing social agendas rather than emerging from the more fundamental problem of knowledge identified by Lyotard. Now, while conceptualizations of globalization are remarkably diverse, they do tend to fall into two broad categories. The first of these is skeptical about presenting the reality of globalization as a genuinely new phenomenon, while the other, more radical, position asserts the need to recognize that the world order, and the relationships that structure it, have fundamentally changed. Then again, these classifications themselves break down, especially on the side of the radicals, according to how urgent is the perceived need to act on this recognition of change, and according to what they recognize as the locus of this change. One person responsible for making the term globalization fashionable and indispensable is Anthony Giddens.7 In the Reith Lecture series Runaway World,8 broadcast from around and to the world by the BBC World Service in 1999, Giddens took it as given that we are all in the grip of globalization. His themed lectures on risk, tradition, the family and democracy were notable for the cautious optimism characteristic of the so-called “tranformationalist” model. At the time I was surprised by the comparatively
Recommended publications
  • Departm-Ents of Instruction
    II DEPARTM-ENTS OF INSTRUCTION COLLEGE OF SCIENCE, LITERATURE, Al';D THE ARTS FACULTY GEORGE EDGAR VINCENT, Ph.D., LL.D., President 1005 5th St. S. E. CYRUS NORTHROP, LL.D., President Emeritus 519 1Cth Ave. S. E. JOHN F. DOWNEY,' M.A., C.E., Dean, Professor of Mathematics, Head of Department of Mathematics 1115 :th St. S. E. *ADA LOUISE COMSTOCK, M.A., Dean of Women, Professor of Rhetoric West Sanford Hall MARGARET SWEENEY, Ph.D., Dean of Women, Professor of Rhetoric WILLIAM W. FOLWELL, LL.D., Emeritus Professor of PoIiti~al Science 1020 5th St. S. F. JOHN G. MOORE, B.A., Professor of German, Head of Department (of German 2810 University Ave. S. E. CHARLES WILLIAM BENTON, Litt.D., Professor of the French Language and Literature, Head of Department of Romance Languages 516 9th Ave. S. E. MARIA L. SANFORD, Emeritus Professor of Rhetoric 1050 13th Ave. S. E. JOHN CORRIN HUTCHINSON, B.A., Professor of Greek, Head of Depart- ment of Greek 3806 Blaisdell Ave. JOHN SINCLAIR CLARK, B.A., Professor of Latin Language and Litera- ture 729 10th Ave. S. E. HENRY F. NACHTRIEB, B.S., Professor of Animal Biology, Head of Department of Animal Biology 905 6th St. S. E. DAVID L. KIEHLE, LL.D., Emeritus Professor of Education 266 25th St. N., Portland, Ore. GEORGE BELL FRANKFORTER, Ph.D., Professor of Chemistry, Head of Department of Chemistry 525 E. River Road *WILLIS MASON WEST, M.A., Professor of History, Head of Department of History 1314 6th St. S. E. FRANCIS P. LEAVENWORTH, M.A., Professor of Astronomy, Head of Department of Astronomy 317 17th Ave.
    [Show full text]
  • Matical Society Was Held at Columbia University on Friday and Saturday, April 25-26, 1947
    THE APRIL MEETING IN NEW YORK The four hundred twenty-fourth meeting of the American Mathe­ matical Society was held at Columbia University on Friday and Saturday, April 25-26, 1947. The attendance was over 300, includ­ ing the following 300 members of the Society: C. R. Adams, C. F. Adler, R. P. Agnew, E.J. Akutowicz, Leonidas Alaoglu, T. W. Anderson, C. B. Allendoerfer, R. G. Archibald, L. A. Aroian, M. C. Ayer, R. A. Bari, Joshua Barlaz, P. T. Bateman, G. E. Bates, M. F. Becker, E. G. Begle, Richard Bellman, Stefan Bergman, Arthur Bernstein, Felix Bernstein, Lipman Bers, D. H. Blackwell, Gertrude Blanch, J. H. Blau, R. P. Boas, H. W. Bode, G. L. Bolton, Samuel Borofsky, J. M. Boyer, A. D. Bradley, H. W. Brinkmann, Paul Brock, A. B. Brown, G. W. Brown, R. H. Brown, E. F. Buck, R. C. Buck, L. H. Bunyan, R. S. Burington, J. C. Burkill, Herbert Busemann, K. A. Bush, Hobart Bushey, J. H. Bushey, K. E. Butcher, Albert Cahn, S. S. Cairns, W. R. Callahan, H. H. Campaigne, K. Chandrasekharan, J. O. Chellevold, Herman Chernoff, Claude Chevalley, Ed­ mund Churchill, J. A. Clarkson, M. D. Clement, R. M. Cohn, I. S. Cohen, Nancy Cole, T. F. Cope, Richard Courant, M. J. Cox, F. G. Critchlow, H. B. Curry, J. H. Curtiss, M. D. Darkow, A. S. Day, S. P. Diliberto, J. L. Doob, C. H. Dowker, Y. N. Dowker, William H. Durf ee, Churchill Eisenhart, Benjamin Epstein, Ky Fan, J.M.Feld, William Feller, F. G. Fender, A. D.
    [Show full text]
  • IB Diploma Programme Handbook 2017-2018
    IB Diploma Programme Handbook 2017-2018 IB Diploma Programme Handbook ___________________________________________________________________ Table of Contents The IB Mission Statement 3 The IB Learner Profile 4 The Curriculum 5 Core Requirements 6 Theory of Knowledge 6 Creativity, Action, Service (CAS) 6 The Extended Essay 6 The Diploma Points Matrix 7 Subjects Offered at Amman National School 8 IB Assessment 9 Academic Honesty 9 Tawjihi Equivalency for the Literary and Scientific Streams 11 Ministry of Education Documents (Arabic) 12 2 IB Diploma Programme Handbook ___________________________________________________________________ The IB Mission Statement The International Baccalaureate aims to develop inquiring, knowledgeable and caring young people who help to create a better and more peaceful world through intercultural understanding and respect. To this end the organization works with schools, governments and international organizations to develop challenging programs of international education and rigorous assessment. These programs encourage students across the world to become active, compassionate and lifelong learners who understand that other people, with their differences, can also be right. 3 IB Diploma Programme Handbook ___________________________________________________________________ The IB learner profile The aim of all IB programmes is to develop internationally minded people who, recognizing their common humanity and shared guardianship of the planet, help to create a better and more peaceful world. As IB learners we strive to be Inquirers We nurture our curiosity, developing skills for inquiry and research. We know how to learn independently and with others. We learn with enthusiasm and sustain our love of learning throughout life. Knowledgeable We develop and use conceptual understanding, exploring knowledge across a range of disciplines. We engage with issues and ideas that have local and global significance.
    [Show full text]
  • International Baccalaureate - Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia International Baccalaureate from Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia
    12/5/13 International Baccalaureate - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia International Baccalaureate From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia The International Baccalaureate (IB), formerly the International Baccalaureate Organization (IBO), is an international educational foundation headquartered in Geneva, Switzerland and founded in 1968.[1][2] IB offers four educational programmes for children aged 3–19.[3] The organization's name and logo were changed in 2007 to reflect a reorganization. Consequently, "IB" can refer to the organization itself, any of the four programmes, or the diploma or certificates awarded at the end of the diploma programme.[4] Contents Logo of the International Baccalaureate. 1 History 2 Diploma Programme curriculum outline 2.1 Extended essay 2.2 Theory of knowledge (TOK) 3 Middle Years Programme curriculum outline 4 Primary Years Programme curriculum outline 5 Organization 6 Governance 7 Reception 8 Allegations of plagiarism 9 See also 10 References 11 External links History Marie-Thérèse Maurette[5] created the framework for what would eventually become the IB Diploma Programme in 1948 when she wrote Is There a Way of Teaching for Peace?, a handbook for United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO).[6] In the mid-1960s, a group of teachers from the International School of Geneva (Ecolint) created the International Schools Examinations Syndicate (ISES), which would later become the International Baccalaureate Organization (IBO).[7] The IB headquarters were officially established in Geneva,
    [Show full text]
  • International Baccalaureate®
    Content Supporting 2019 International Baccalaureate® Highlights Supporting the IB Curriculum Framework Content from the IB and other reputable publishers DP and CP titlewave.com/go/ib Everything IB EDUCATORS Follett is proud to be a trusted provider of materials for International Baccalaureate® schools around the globe. This 2019 Follett IB Catalog presents only a fraction of our comprehensive offering. Start exploring. Inside this catalog, you’ll find books from reputable publishers including Oxford University Press, Hodder Education and Haese Mathematics. Plus, there are expert- selected book suggestions and companion materials for the Diploma and Career- related Programmes, and professional reading resources for the PYP, MYP, DP and CP. “This catalog provides a general overview of the thousands of books and resources Follett What we love. provides to IB schools worldwide. Browse Throughout these pages, you’ll find these pages, but we offer so much more thoughts and hints from our team. Be on on Titlewave.” ® the lookout for Titlewave tips and other NATALIE ZIEMBA helpful information as you browse. Associate International Marketing Manager United States There’s more to the story. We can’t fit all of our great IB resources into just these pages. Be sure you check out our complete selection at titlewave.com/go/ib. Titlewave is the leading online destination for educators. If you don’t already have one, sign up for a free account today and see why more than 10,000 educators log on daily. IB Materials Ordering +1.708.884.5100 | [email protected] | titlewave.com/go/ib FLIP TO PAGE 33 TO LEARN MORE ABOUT ORDERING ON TITLEWAVE.
    [Show full text]
  • The International School of Geneva and the United World Colleges in the Early Years of the International Baccalaureate
    The International School of Geneva and the United World Colleges in the early years of the International Baccalaureate Contents Acknowledgments ............................................................................................. 3 Ecolint and the Origins of the International Baccalaureate Philip Thomas ..................................................................................................... 4 The early Atlantic College and the Birth of the International Baccalaureate David Sutcliffe ................................................................................................... 20 United World Colleges and the International Baccalaureate Andrew Maclehose .............................................................................................. 39 Future Challenge David Sutcliffe ................................................................................................... 47 Biographies of Authors..................................................................................... 60 1 Acknowledgments We, former members of staff of the International School of Geneva and of Atlantic College in the early pioneering days of the IB, have decided to write our memories of the role of these two schools in the realisation of what, for many, was an admirable but almost utopian dream. In part we have done so because these achievements are vital features of each school’s history, in part as a tribute to the numerous gifted colleagues whose dedicated professionalism and untiring enthusiasm ensured success. Many of
    [Show full text]
  • Page I Internationalising the Curriculum in Australian Schools FM Brohier BA
    Page i Internationalising the Curriculum in Australian Schools F. M. Brohier BA (Hons), Dip Ed, M Litt Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Deakin University August, 2011 Contents Page iii Contents Contents ........................................................................................ iii List of Figures ........................................................................................ vi List of Tables ........................................................................................ vi Acknowledgements ....................................................................................... vii Abstract ...................................................................................... viii Abbreviations ........................................................................................ xi Chapter 1 The Phenomenon of International Education 1 1.1 The Background to my Research ........................................................................... 1 My Relationship to the Research Process ................................................................. 3 The Research Participants ......................................................................................... 4 The Schools .......................................................................................... 5 1.2 Unravelling the Narrative and Contextualising the Issue ................................... 5 The Effects of the Implementation Process in Schools ..........................................
    [Show full text]
  • With World Growing Smaller, IB Gets Big
    With World Growing Smaller, IB Gets Big Students take part in a team-building exercise called “Poly Bones” in an 8th grade physical education class at South St. Paul Junior High School. — Scott Cohen for Education Week Amid heightened concern about preparing students for a global economy, the academically demanding International Baccalaureate program is catching on fast in U.S. schools. By Scott J. Cech South St. Paul, Minn. In a large black-and-white photograph hanging in Jane Stassen’s office, 1930s-era construction workers perch on a thin steel beam some 70 stories above New York City, precarious but undaunted as they read newspapers and eat lunch on a break. It’s no accident that Ms. Stassen, the director of curriculum and instruction for the 3,200-student South St. Paul school district, keeps this image on view above her desk. She sees a parallel to the cash-poor district’s plan to become what would apparently be the first public school system in the nation to offer the demanding International Baccalaureate program to all its students by next fall. “We’re going confidently out on a limb,” Ms. Stassen explained. As to why a small community best known for its long-gone meat-packing plants would choose to put itself in the vanguard of education reform, district officials say the driving force was pretty cut and dried: the need to prepare students to compete for 21st-century jobs. “What we want is for all our kids to pursue postsecondary [education],” Ms. Stassen said. “In order to prepare them for that, we need to offer them rigorous, challenging academic experiences, and that’s basically what [IB] is all about.
    [Show full text]
  • East Is East and West Is West George Walker
    IB position paper East is East and West is West George Walker © International Baccalaureate Organization 2010 1 InternationalLanguage A teacher Baccalaureate support materi Organizational: Example interim 2010 objectives Introduction to IB position papers This paper is part of a series of papers commissioned by the IB and written by IB practitioners. Each paper addresses a topic or issue related to the IB’s philosophy or its educational practices. Other papers in the series Hare, J. July 2010. Holistic education: An interpretation for teachers in the IB programmes. Marshman, R. July 2010. Concurrency of learning in the IB Diploma Programme and Middle Years Programme. 2 East is East and West is West What I object to is the artificial arrangement by which this foreign education tends to occupy all the space of our national mind and thus kills, or hampers, the great opportunity for the creation of new thought by a new combination of truths. (Rabindranath Tagore 1961: 222) Abstract This position paper addresses the long-standing criticism that the International Baccalaureate (IB) is too closely associated with Western values and, despite its title, does not enable students to see the world from a truly international perspective. Considering evidence from different authorities, it analyses the IB learner profile and asks how appropriate it is for the cultures of East Asia. The paper concludes that the learner profile does indeed reflect the strong Western humanist foundations of the IB, but accepts that the organization’s successful growth (not least in its Asia- Pacific region) makes sudden change unlikely and undesirable. Instead, it recommends that the learner profile be reviewed regularly and used as a focus for internal debate on this issue.
    [Show full text]
  • Brochure 2021 IB
    Kolding Gymnasium International IB Baccalaureate Why you should choose Kolding Gymnasium When you become a student at Kolding Gymnasium, you’re joining an exciting school community no matter which educational path you choose. At KG we offer you the best of opportunities to take an education that prepares you for the future and equips you both academically and personally for any further education. We have a long and rich tradition for combining the educational and the social sides of school life at KG. After school, or during the breaks, there are plenty of extra- curricular activities on offer (students’ council, sports, committees and much more). “I told myself I never wanted to go to gymnasium, until I heard about IB. Sure IB is hard and stressful sometimes, but you also gain a lot socially. IB is like our own Little America – a huge melting pot where Danish culture meets people from all over the world. IB is one of the best choices I’ve ever made – by far!” INTERNATIONAL MINDEDNESS “The IBO encourages international mindedness in IB students who must firstly develop an understanding of their own cultural and national identity” George Walker Former CEO of the International Baccalaureate Organisation 2 KG is a fantastic place with lots of room for everybody. 3 4 What is IB? The International Baccalaureate When you join the International Baccalaureate Programme at Kolding Gymnasium, you’re not only entering a vibrant and exciting school community at KG, but also becoming a member of a world-wide community of students in 147 countries who are studying in the 3104 schools currently approved to offer the diploma programme.
    [Show full text]
  • Global Citizenship Education in Practice: an Exploration of Teachers in the United World Colleges
    Global Citizenship Education in Practice: An Exploration of Teachers in the United World Colleges Andrew Mahlstedt Monograph International Comparative Education School of Education Stanford University August 2003 i Abstract Increasing globalization calls for new forms to education to respond to emerging concepts of global citizenship. This study explores the question of whether, and if so how, education for the values of global citizenship is possible. Building a definition of global citizenship education from the growing literature, and supplementing these ideas with world society theory and curriculum theory, I examine one example of global citizenship education in practice – the United World Colleges (UWCs). Through document analysis, questionnaires, and interviews, I detail the pedagogical processes by which teachers at the UWCs seek to educate students toward the values of global citizenship, in comparison with theories from the literature. I conclude that the methods used by UWC teachers do indeed work within the theories detailed in the literature, and create a snapshot of global citizenship education in practice. iii Acknowledgements Thank you so much to everyone who has helped me along the way to the completion of this monograph. It is the culmination, in part, of this academic year at Stanford; in part as well though, it is the culmination of a deeply rooted passion for exploring and expanding global citizenship education that began in a yak-dung filled tea house in Namche Bazaar, Nepal, in November, 2000. Thanks to the earth that nurtured the food that fed the yaks that provided the dung for the smoky air of that tea house that germinated a passion that has become a path.
    [Show full text]
  • ECOLINT and the ORIGINS of the INTERNATIONAL BACCALAUREATE ECOLINT and the ORIGINS of the INTERNATIONAL BACCALAUREATE Phil Thomas
    ECOLINT AND THE ORIGINS OF THE INTERNATIONAL BACCALAUREATE ECOLINT AND THE ORIGINS OF THE INTERNATIONAL BACCALAUREATE Phil Thomas 1 ECOLINT AND THE ORIGINS OF THE INTERNATIONAL BACCALAUREATE ECOLINT AND THE ORIGINS OF THE INTERNATIONAL BACCALAUREATE Preface The origins of the IB at the Ecole Internationale de Genève / International School of Geneva (widely known as “Ecolint”) can be explained as both an idealistic venture and as a pragmatic response to the changes that were occurring in the city, the school and the associated communities during the early 1950s and 1960s. The idealism dates back to the school’s founding and reflects Geneva’s role as a major international centre. The city has always had a reputation for educational innovation dating from Jean-Jacques Rousseau, through the Ecole Nouvelle movement to the establishment of the Piaget Institute in 1929. In November 1920, the Permanent Secretariat of the newly formed League of Nations arrived and, as with most other international or inter-governmental organisations, educational provision for the children of staff members soon became an issue. The school was thus founded in 1924 by a group of the League’s staff members who saw it as a pioneering venture which would take advantage of recent educational pilot schemes. From the outset it was to be an international school promoting the League’s ideals of peace and international understanding. The School narrowly survived the Second World War to become the oldest international school in continuous existence in the world. The League was succeeded by the United Nations Office in Europe and by a number of UN agencies and the School was thus well placed to continue its service role and its mission as an innovative institution.
    [Show full text]