POLAR RECORD A Journal of Arctic and Antarctic Research Journal of the Scott Polar Research Institute, University of Cambridge

Editor: IAN R. STONE Deputy Editor: Nikolas Sellheim Book Reviews Editor: Hanna Lempinen

Editorial Advisors: Dr Liisa Holmberg, Sámi Education Institute, Finland Dr Patrick Arnaud, Vachères, France Dr Julia Jabour, University of Tasmania, Australia Dr Susan Barr, Oslo, Norway Priv. Doz. Dr Cornelia Lüdecke, Munich, Germany Mobile Prof Robert Barletta, University of Southern Alabama, Dr R.I.G. Morrison, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada Go USA. Dr Maria Nakhshina, University of Aberdeen Prof William Barr, Calgary, Alberta, Canada Prof Mark Nuttall, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada Dr Peter Carey, Christchurch, New Zealand Dr Beau Riffenburgh, Llanarthne, Carmarthen, UK Dr Janice Cavell, Ottawa, Canada Dr Shiv M. Singh, National Centre for Antarctic and Prof Klaus J. Dodds, London, UK Ocean Research, India CJO Mobile (CJOm) is a streamlined Prof Julian Dowdeswell, Cambridge, UK Prof Valdon Smith, Matieland, South Africa Dr Damian Gore, Sydney, Australia Dr Erki Tammiksaar, Tartu, Estonia Dr Anna Stammler-Gossman, University of Lapland, Prof David W.H. Walton, Cambridge, UK Cambridge Journals Online (CJO) Finland Prof Oran R. Young, Santa Barbara, CA, USA for smartphones and other © Cambridge University Press 2015. Copying Polar Record is registered with the Copyright Clearance Polar Record (ISSN 0032-2474) is published six times Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. small mobile devices yearly — in January, March, May, July, September, Organizations in the USA that are also registered with the November — the six issues making a volume. First pub- CCC may copy material (beyond limits permitted by lished in January 1931, Polar Record appeared twice sections 107 and 108 of US copyright law) subject to yearly until July 1954, three times yearly until September payment to CCC of the per copy fee of $16. This consent 1987 and four times yearly until 2014. Scholarly contri- does not extend to multiple copies for promotional butions are invited on virtually all subjects of polar interest. or commercial purposes. Code 0032-2474/2014.  Use CJOm to access all journal Organizations authorized by the Copyright Licensing FirstView Contributions Agency may also copy material subject to the usual content including All authors who would like to submit contributions for pub- conditions. For all other use, permission should be sought articles which are published lication in Polar Record must send the Editor an electron- from the Cambridge or the American Branch of ic copy of the manuscript together with a covering letter. Cambridge University Press (addresses below). online ahead of print The submission must be saved in .doc or .rtf format, and should be sent via email to: Advertising Access quickly and easily thanks [email protected] Details of advertising in Polar Record may be obtained  from the publisher. to simplified design and low Subscriptions Orders, which must be accompanied by payment, should CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS resolution images be sent to any bookseller or subscription agent, or direct Published by the Press Syndicate of the University of to the publisher: Cambridge  Register for content alerts or University Printing House, Cambridge CB2 8BS, United Cambridge University Press, Journals Fulfillment Kingdom save searches and articles – Department, UPH, Shaftesbury Road, Cambridge CB2 32 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10013-2473, 8BS, UK USA they will be available on both or 477 Williamstown Road, Port Melbourne, Victoria 3207, CJO and CJOm Cambridge University Press, Journals Fulfillment Australia Department, 100 Brook Hill Drive, West Nyack, New York C/Orense, 4, Planta 13, 28020 Madrid, Spain 10994–2133, USA. Lower Ground Floor, Nautica Building, The Water Club,  Your device will be detected and Beach Road, Granger Bay, 8005 Cape Town, South The subscription price of volume 51, 2015, for electronic Africa automatically directed to CJOm access, is: for individuals, £111.00 (US$213.00 in USA, via: journals.cambridge.org Canada, and Mexico), for institutions £320.00 (US$590.00 in USA, Canada, and Mexico). EU subscribers (outside the UK) who are not registered for VAT should add VAT at their country’s rate. VAT registered subscribers should provide their VAT registration number. Japanese prices for institutions are available from Kinokuniya Company Ltd, PO Box 55, Chitose, Tokyo 156, Japan. Information about Polar Record and all other Cambridge journals can be accessed via http:// www.cambridge.org/.

000322474_51-4.indd0322474_51-4.indd 2 66/25/15/25/15 110:220:22 PMPM M P

2 2 : 0 1

5 1 / 5 2 / 66/25/15 10:22 PM A Journal of Arctic and Antarctic Research A Journal and Antarctic of Arctic 2015 51 NUMBER 259 JULY VOLUME POLAR RECORD

POLAR RECORD VOLUME 51 NUMBER 259 JULY 2015 ,

p 465 p 458 Reviewed Reviewed by Nikolas Reviewed by Beau p 457 p 460 Reviewed by Philip Sidney. Reviewed by Philip Sidney. Reviewed by Nikolas Sellheim, p 460 Reviewed by Ian R. Stone. Reviewed by Eleanor Darlington in Wellington c.9 February 1917. Canterbury Museum, Middleton collec- in Wellington Reviewed by Ian R. Stone. Aurora p 456 Janet M. Hartley.

p 462 p 463 . p 464 1 by Sebastian Knecht. Riffenburgh Sellheim Einar Lund Jensen, Kristine Raahauge and Hans Christian Gulløv. Einar Lund Jensen, Kristine Raahauge and Hans Reviewed by Malgorzata Smieszek. Megan R. Balks and Jerónimo López-Martínez p 444 Megan R. Balks and Jerónimo López-Martínez Maria Ackrén p 404 422 Berkes p and Fikret John-Erik Kocho-Schellenberg

d tion. See the article by D. Harrowfield in the present issue. in the present tion. See the article by D. Harrowfield The arctic climate system. Mark Serreze and Roger Barry. and Roger Barry. climate system. Mark Serreze The arctic Murray and Anita Dey Nuttall. understanding policy and governance. Robert W. International and the arctic: relations Antarctica and the arctic circle: a geographic encyclopedia of the earth’s polar regions. Andrew J. Hund. Andrew polar regions. a geographic encyclopedia of the earth’s circle: and the arctic Antarctica The arctic in the anthropocene. Emerging research questions. Henry P. Huntington and Stephanie Pfirman. Huntington questions. Henry P. research Emerging in the anthropocene. The arctic Hoosh: roast penguin, scurvy day, and other stories of antarctic cuisine. Jason C. Anthony. and other stories of antarctic penguin, scurvy day, Hoosh: roast COVER PHOTO A. K. (Keith) Jack with Sir Ernest Shackleton on Cultural encounters at Cape Farewell: the east Greenlandic immigrants and the German Moravian mission in the 19th century. in the 19th century. immigrants and the German Moravian mission the east Greenlandic Cultural encounters at Cape Farewell: Lashipa. History of large scale resource exploitation in polar areas. Louwrens Hacquebord. Louwrens exploitation in polar areas. scale resource Lashipa. History of large Siberia: a history of the people. Media and the politics of arctic climate change. When the ice breaks. Miyase Christensen, Annika E. Nilsson, Nina Wormbs. climate change. When the ice breaks. Media and the politics of arctic BOOK REVIEWS CONTENTS ARTICLES p 343 David L. Harrowfield and country’: the Ross Sea party 1914–1917. ‘For the sake of science Barr p 366 expeditions, 1909 and 1912. William Swiss Greenland de Quervain’s Alfred Lewis p 386 May and George Karen to Ben Macintyre. the media: a response Scott and Shackleton in p 392 Tunsjø Ingrid Lundestad and Øystein China in the Arctic. The United States and perspectives. and future as a self-governing past, current sub-national territory in internationalGreenland relations: p 413 and Anatoly Alekseyev Piers Vitebsky northeast Siberia. Indigenous perspectives from What is a reindeer? the Canadian Arctic. from using network analysis in a case the development of co-management: Tracking image. Pat Millar p 432 polar explorer-hero of photography in the making of his role A. Cook: the Frederick A. O’Neill and track usage. Tanya properties between soil physiochemical relationships walking tracks: Ross Island recreational POLAR RECORD POLAR Research and Antarctic A Journal Arctic of of Cambridge University Institute, Journal Polar Research of the Scott 2015 259 JULY 51 NUMBER VOLUME d n i . 4 - 1 5 _ 4 7 4 2 2 3 0 000322474_51-4.indd 1