HYPATIA A JOURNAL OF FEMINIST PHILOSOPHY

VOLUME 35 NUMBER 4 FALL 2020 Editorial Team (Co-Editors) Editors Emeritae Bonnie Mann, University of Oregon Ann Garry (Co-Editor 2017-2018) Erin McKenna, University of Oregon California State University, Los Angeles Camisha Russel, University of Oregon Serene J. Khader (Co-Editor 2017-2018) Rocio Zambrana, Emory University Brooklyn College and CUNY Graduate Center Hypatia Reviews Online Editors Alison Stone (Co-Editor 2017-2018) Clara Fisher, University College, Dublin Lancaster University Erin McKenna, University of Oregon Sally Scholz (Editor 2013-2017) Villanova University Managing Editors Ann Cudd (Co-Editor 2010-2013) Sarah LaChance Adams, University of North Boston University Florida (Hypatia) Caroline R. Lundquist, University of Oregon Linda Martín Alcoff (Co-Editor 2010-2013) (Hypatia) Hunter College, CUNY Graduate Center Bjørn Kristensen, University of Oregon Alison Wylie (Co-Editor 2008-2013) (Hypatia Reviews Online) University of British Columbia Lori Gruen (Co-Editor 2008-2010) Social Media Editor/ Wesleyan University Managing Editor Assistant Brooke Burns, University of Oregon Hilde Lindemann (Editor 2003-2008) Michigan State University Associate Editors Laurie Shrage (Co-Editor 1998-2003) Maria del Rosario Acosta-López, University of California State Polytechnic University California-Riverside Nancy Tuana (Co-Editor 1998-2003) Saray Ayala-López, California State University- Pennsylvania State University Sacramento Talia Mae Bettcher, University of California- Cheryl Hall (Co-Editor 1995-1998) Los Angeles University of South Florida Ann Cudd, University of Pittsburgh Joanne Waugh (Co-Editor 1995-1998) Vrinda Dalmiya, University of Hawaii-Manoa University of South Florida Verónica Gago, Universidad de Buenos Aires/ Linda López McAlister (Editor 1990-1995, Universidad Nacional de San Martín Co-Editor 1995-1998) Dilek Huseyinzadegan, Emory University University of South Florida Qrescent Mali Mason, Haverford College Krushil Watene, Massey University Margaret A. Simons (Editor 1986-1990) Yolonda Wilson, Howard University Southern University of Illinois at Edwardsville Robin Zheng, Yale-NUS College Azizah al-Hibri (Founding Editor 1982-1984) University of Richmond Law School Nonprofi t Board Linda Martín Alcoff, (Former Editor) Hypatia Reviews Online Editors Emeritae Hunter College, CUNY Graduate Center E. Simon Ruchti (Co-Editor 2017-2018) Talia Mae Bettcher West Chester University California State University, Los Angeles Shelley Wilcox (Editor 2013-2017) Ann Garry (Interim Editor) San Francisco State University California State University, Los Angeles Sharyn Clough (Editor 2008-2013) Helen Longino Oregon State University Stanford University Jacqueline Scott (Secretary) Loyola University Chicago Nancy Tuana (Treasurer) Pennsylvania State University Hypatia Volume 35 | Number 4 | Fall 2020

Articles Constance Awinpoka Akurugu 549 Performing Power in a Mystical Context: Implications for Theorizing Women’s Agency Mattias Gunnemyr 567 Why the Social Connection Model Fails: Participation is Neither Necessary nor Sufficient for Political Responsibility Natalie Helberg 587 Insubordinate Plasticity: Judith Butler and Catherine Malabou Michelle Panchuk 607 Distorting Concepts, Obscured Experiences: Hermeneutical Injustice in Religious Trauma and Spiritual Violence Leonhard Riep 626 The Production of the Muselmann and the Singularity of Auschwitz: A Critique of Adriana Cavarero’s Account of the “Auschwitz Event” Obdulia Torres González 646 The Data on Gender Inequality in Philosophy: The Spanish Case

Cluster On Gaslighting and Epistemic Injustice Alison Bailey 667 On Gaslighting and Epistemic Injustice: Editor’s Introduction Gaile Pohlhaus, Jr. 674 Gaslighting and Echoing, or Why Collective Epistemic Resistance is not a “Witch Hunt” Elena Ruíz 687 Cultural Gaslighting Christine Wieseler 714 Epistemic Oppression and Ableism in Bioethics Nora Berenstain 733 White Feminist Gaslighting