Amendments Good Design.Indb

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Amendments Good Design.Indb This work is made freely available under open access. AUTHOR: TITLE: YEAR: OpenAIR citation: This work was submitted to- and approved by Robert Gordon University in partial fulfilment of the following degree: _______________________________________________________________________________________________ OpenAIR takedown statement: Section 6 of the “Repository policy for OpenAIR @ RGU” (available from http://www.rgu.ac.uk/staff-and-current- students/library/library-policies/repository-policies) provides guidance on the criteria under which RGU will consider withdrawing material from OpenAIR. If you believe that this item is subject to any of these criteria, or for any other reason should not be held on OpenAIR, then please contact [email protected] with the details of the item and the nature of your complaint. This thesis is distributed under a CC ____________ license. ____________________________________________________ Ethical Design A Foundation for Visual Communication Peter Buwert A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the Robert Gordon University for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy May 2016 Peter Buwert - Doctor of Philosophy Ethical Design A Foundation for Visual Communication Abstract: The central original contribution to knowledge proposed by this thesis is the setting forth of a conceptualisation of ethical theory specifically in relation to design, with a focus on visual communication design. Building on earlier work by design theorist Clive Dilnot in the area of design ethics and on philosopher Giorgio Agamben’s formulation of the philosophical concept of potentiality, a way of thinking about the relationship between design and ethics is proposed which concludes that design is in fact always inherently ethical. However, this conception of ethical design purposefully leaves questions of the qualification of good and bad unresolved, stating only that the ethical is the prerequisite condition in which both good and bad become possibilities. Design’s significantly unethical capability to suppress and anaesthetise individuals’ ethical experience is highlighted through a proposal of a process of an/aesth/ethics. Observation of the relationship between design and ethics in the real world through a series of interviews demonstrates something of the complexity of design’s relationship with ethics and the diverse range of positions, beliefs, attitudes and paradoxes abounding within the design profession when it comes to addressing the question of “good” design practice. Six “sites” of ethics within contemporary design discourse are introduced and discussed. The ethicality of design practices in relation to these sites are then analysed through the lens of the proposed ethical framework: identifying strengths, weaknesses and potentials within these observed strategies. The way of thinking about ethical design proposed here demonstrates potential in contributing to designers’ ability to critically consider the ethicality of their own practices. From this foundation they may be better equipped to begin addressing the question of the qualification of the “goodness” of design. In conclusion, proposals are made for how this framework could be practically developed and used to support and encourage ethical design in the real world. Keywords: Aesthetics, An/Aesth/Ethics, Criticality, Ethics, Graphic Design, Potentiality iii iv Table of Contents v Title Page ...............................................................................................................................................................................i Abstract ............................................................................................................................................................................ iii Table of Contents .....................................................................................................................................................................v List of Figures ...........................................................................................................................................................................xii Chapter 1: Good Design? .................................................................... 1 1.1 Typography and Mein Kampf: The Complexity of the Issue ....................................................2 1.2 Research Question/Aims ...............................................................................................................5 1.3 Overview: Motivation, Scope and Methodology of the Research ...........................................7 Good Intentions.....................................................................................................................................................................13 Ethical Design ..........................................................................................................................................................................13 Design through the Ethical Lens ...................................................................................................................................16 1.4 Original Contributions ................................................................................................................ 18 1.5 Limitations ................................................................................................................................... 19 Chapter 2: Good Intentions .............................................................21 2.1 Ethics and Design Observed ............................................................................................................. 22 2.2 10 Narratives on Ethical Design....................................................................................................... 24 Interviews ...........................................................................................................................................................................25 Ethical Discourses Emerging from Unique Narratives ......................................................................................28 Summary: Plurality / Frustrated Utopianism / Economic Precariousness .............................................32 vi Chapter 3: Ethical Design .................................................................45 Ethical Design? ................................................................................................................................... 46 3.1 The Ethical ................................................................................................................................... 49 3.1.1 Bad Morality .............................................................................................................................. 49 3.1.2 Ethics at the End of Ethics ........................................................................................................ 52 3.1.3 Potentiality: The Ethical as the Experience of Being One’s Potentiality .......................... 57 The Existence of Faculties .................................................................................................................................................58 Potentiality/Impotentiality ..............................................................................................................................................60 Potentiality: The Fundamental Experience of Ethics .........................................................................................62 Freedom for Both Good and Evil..................................................................................................................................63 3.1.4 Singularity: The Ethical Emerges in Relation to Encounter with Singularity .................. 65 Encounter with the Unknown .......................................................................................................................................66 Responsibility ..........................................................................................................................................................................67 Cracks in Reality: Accidentalism ...................................................................................................................................69 3.1.5 Aesthetic Sensitivity: The Ethical Contingent on Aesthetic Sensitivity ........................... 72 Blissful Ignorance ...................................................................................................................................................................72 The Demand of the Other ................................................................................................................................................73 Insensitivity: Intolerant Tolerance ................................................................................................................................75 Aesthetic Imperatives .........................................................................................................................................................76 Aesthetic Plurality and Justice .......................................................................................................................................79 3.1.6 The Ethical as a Mode of Existence ......................................................................................... 82 Pre-ethical Being: ...................................................................................................................................................................83
Recommended publications
  • Methods for a Critical Graphic Design Practice
    Title Design as criticism: methods for a critical graphic design p r a c tic e Type The sis URL https://ualresearchonline.arts.ac.uk/id/eprint/12027/ Dat e 2 0 1 7 Citation Laranjo, Francisco Miguel (2017) Design as criticism: methods for a critical graphic design practice. PhD thesis, University of the Arts London. Cr e a to rs Laranjo, Francisco Miguel Usage Guidelines Please refer to usage guidelines at http://ualresearchonline.arts.ac.uk/policies.html or alternatively contact [email protected] . License: Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives Unless otherwise stated, copyright owned by the author Thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) University of the Arts London – London College of Communication February 2017 First submission: October 2015 2 Abstract This practice-led research is the result of an interest in graphic design as a specific critical activity. Existing in the context of the 2008 financial and subsequent political crisis, both this thesis and my work are situated in an expanded field of graphic design. This research examines the emergence of the terms critical design and critical practice, and aims to develop methods that use criticism during the design process from a practitioner’s perspective. Central aims of this research are to address a gap in design discourse in relation to this terminology and impact designers operating under the banner of such terms, as well as challenging practitioners to develop a more critical design practice. The central argument of this thesis is that in order to develop a critical practice, a designer must approach design as criticism.
    [Show full text]
  • The Railway Poster in Britain
    Features Railways and Tourism (part 2) The Railway Poster in Britain Dieter W. Hopkin and Beverley Cole Museum’s extensive collection (see pp. bills and notices were similar to those that The National Railway Museum 25–28). The story of railways in Britain had been used by the stagecoaches. A has been reflected in the development of simple statement of the services the rail- The National Railway Museum (NRM) in the railway poster. This art form illustrates ways offered was enough to show that York is part of the National Museum of the major changes that have occurred in they were preferable and often quicker Science and Industry of Britain. It was British society over the years and captures and cheaper. These letterpress posters opened in 1975 and is probably the big- the spirit and character of British life over were produced using standard printing gest museum of its type in the world. Its that period. Railway posters also provide blocks and included no individual graphic collections are the largest, the most com- historical information about the geo- design. When illustrative elements were prehensive, and the most significant in graphical growth of the network and about introduced, they were generally standard their field anywhere in the world and in- the people for whom they were designed. patterns depicting generic locomotives clude 100 locomotives, nearly 200 car- As such, they are material evidence of Brit- and carriages that were combined to form riages and wagons and artefacts of every ish culture and are social documents. trains. description from uniforms to signalling They illustrate styles in art, the changing By the 1850s, rivalry between the large equipment.
    [Show full text]
  • Open Research Online Oro.Open.Ac.Uk
    Open Research Online The Open University’s repository of research publications and other research outputs The Chorography of the Modern City Thesis How to cite: Garcia De Cortazar Galleguillos, Gabriela (2017). The Chorography of the Modern City. PhD thesis The Open University. For guidance on citations see FAQs. c 2016 The Author Version: Version of Record Copyright and Moral Rights for the articles on this site are retained by the individual authors and/or other copyright owners. For more information on Open Research Online’s data policy on reuse of materials please consult the policies page. oro.open.ac.uk A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor in Philosophy by MA AH UCL, BArch Universidad de Chile Director of studies: Mark Cousins Second supervisor: Pier Vittorio Aureli The Open University Architectural Association, London PhD Programme 30 September 2016 Acknowledgements Te writing of this dissertation would not have been possible without the sponsorship of Becas Chile, the backing of the AA PhD Programme and the opportunities granted by the CCA. I am, however, mostly indebted to Mark Cousins for his generosity, both intellectual and personal. Mark’s guidance throughout these years has been determinant, especially in the questioning of received ideas and the pursuit of precision. I am also obliged to Dr. Pier Vittorio Aureli for his sharp advice and critical comments, always given at crucial times. To Tom Weaver goes a big thank you not only for his kind involvement through all the stages of the PhD, but especially for all the conversations over cofees and lunches.
    [Show full text]
  • Design Methods: Seeds of Human Futures
    Design Methods: seeds of human futures By John Chris Jones 1970, John Wiley and Sons, New York and Chichester An introductory lecture for digital designers by Rhodes Hileman (c) 1998 “Jones first became involved with design methods The era of “Craft Evolution” while working as an industrial designer for a manufacturer of large electrical products in Britain This wagon (figure 2.1) is a fine example of craft in the 1950s. He was frustrated with the evolution, the first of the four eras identified. superficiality of industrial design at the time and Before the Renaissance, the craftsman carried in had become involved with ergonomics. ... When his head a set of rules about the design of the tools the results of his ergonomic studies of user of the day, which roughly described a useful behavior were not utilized by the firm’s designers, artefact with “invisible lines”, which limited the Jones set about studying the design process being dimensions and shapes of the parts in relation to used by the engineers. To his surprise, and to the whole tool. Designs were slowly evolving in a theirs, Jones’ analysis showed that the engineers living collective knowledge base, and few had no way of incorporating rationally arrived at craftsmen made any major changes. Design was data early on in the design process when it was limited very closely to the neighborhood of the most needed. Jones then set to work redesigning tried and true. the engineer’s design process itself so that intuition and rationality could co-exist, rather than one As an example of the sketchy understanding of excluding the other.” ...and this became a design which craftsmen had, Jones cites George consistent thread throughout his work.
    [Show full text]
  • Direction Signs on Roads and Motorways
    Direction Signs On Roads And Motorways Josh is flippantly Pindaric after demographic Marven degum his lectionary strategically. Inodorous and patronizing Sibyl muffles: which Torrance is wrathless enough? Isaac remains reproachless: she rhapsodizing her premolar reverberates too sluggishly? The road on highway authority, which is no. Full directions for them is a blue panel of pedestrians whomight be surprised by. Where it is prohibited from motorway? Speaking into her autobiography is published, State Goverment of Jharkhand, tunnel mouth etc. The road users to saturday during restricted, it isimportant that you leave your left hand lane, credit card numbers. Mauritius is a former British colony. The signs you should follow will all have the same symbols on them to show which route you should take. Contacts for common benefits are listed below. Therefore, are involved in an incident, you may be able to make out only the shape of a sign. British roads are fairly narrow. Howeverthis number may need to be reduced depending on the extent of other signage at thejunction. They taking These signs are sovereign or rectangular ters or symbols. In environmentally sensitiveareas, you with autobahn routes and how should only. Dead end of a system based on a motorway ramp crossing intersections that all road you a sign blow horn before applying to and signs. The Cirencester highway is approximately half a mile long. White symbols on motorways and legally reduce speed cameras still do. When waiting restrictions in directional road or motorways. Special road or motorways, motorway and red. Up or caravan site uses cookies again, but slower than in modern society.
    [Show full text]
  • Examining the Use of Precedents in Parliamentary Debate
    Design as analysis: examining the use of precedents in parliamentary debate. Darren Umneya*, Christopher Earla and Peter Lloydb aOpen University bUniversity of Brighton *[email protected] DOI: 10.21606/drs.2016.378 Abstract: Design continues to look beyond the confines of the studio as both practitioners and researchers engage with wider social and political contexts. This paper takes design into the Parliamentary debating chamber where a country raises and debates problems and proposes and explores solutions. There is an increasing amount of work that explores the use of design in policy-making processes but little that explores design as an interpretation of the Parliamentary process. This paper draws on one characteristic of the design process, the use of precedent, and examines how this appears and functions in Parliamentary debate. The paper argues that this ‘design analysis’ gives insight into debate as a design process and into the debate transcript as a naturally occurring source of design data. This contributes to the scope of design studies and suggests that the UK Parliament could be considered one of the most influential design studios in a country. Keywords: political debate, design process, design precedents, design analysis, design data Introduction The scope of design studies; Design + Research + Society The nature, purpose and scope of design studies have been questioned throughout its developing literature. This can be seen in early distinctions between rationalist and random methods identified by John Chris Jones (Jones, 1984), in attempts to define the discipline in terms of its technological attributes and scientific rigour (for example, Cross, 2001) and more recently with Cameron Tonkinwise’s review asking what design studies is good for (Tonkinwise, 2014).
    [Show full text]
  • Design for Public Good
    Design Council Angel Building 407 St John Street London EC1V 4AB United Kingdom Tel +44(0)20 7420 5200 Fax +44(0)20 7420 5300 [email protected] www.designcouncil.org.uk Registered charity number 272099 © Design Council, May 2013 Design for Public Good Supported by the European Commission Design for Public Good Author country profiles Author country profiles Denmark Finland UK Wales Danish design rests on a long-standing The Finnish organisation for design The UK design industry is the largest in Europe In 2008, design represented the largest democratic and human-centred tradition that promotion is the Design Forum Finland. and one of the strongest globally. NESTA proportion of the Welsh creative industries both addresses systems, processes and products Design has been on the national agenda since estimates £23bn is spent on design in the UK in employment and gross value added.1 The from the bottom up. SITRA, the Finnish Innovation Fund, was annually, while Imperial College put the figure Welsh Government has provided design support founded 1967. at £33.5bn for 2011. Design Council research to companies in Wales through the Design Design has the highest turnover growth shows that, despite the recession, the industry Advisory Service since 1994. Design Wales, part among Danish creative sector industries In 2008, design was written into the definition grew by 29% between 2005 and 2010. of the National Centre for Product Design and (2003-2010). The government launched the of innovation in the National Innovation Development Research at Cardiff Metropolitan world’s first national design policy in 1997 and Strategy and made an essential part of the The Design Council was founded in 1944, University, was established in 1994.
    [Show full text]
  • In the Bubble John Thackara
    IN TH design/new media/business John Thackara, described as a “design “Design with a conscience: that’s the take-home message of this important, provocative book. John In the Bubble guru, critic and business provocateur” by Thackara, long a major force in design, now takes on an even more important challenge: making the IN THE BUBBLE Designing in a Complex World Fast Company, is the Director of Doors world safe for future inhabitants. We need, he says, to design from the edge, to learn from the world, John Thackara of Perception, a design futures network and to stop designing for, but instead design with. If everyone heeded his prescriptions, the world would E based in Amsterdam and Bangalore. He indeed be a better place. Required reading — required behavior.” We’re filling up the world with technology and devices, but is the author of Design after Modernism, Don Norman, Nielsen Norman Group, author of Emotional Design we’ve lost sight of an important question: What is this stuff Lost in Space: A Traveler’s Tale, Winners! for? What value does it add to our lives? So asks author John BUB How Successful Companies Innovate by “Thackara’s deeply informed book presents a breathtaking new map of the design landscape. With not DESIGNING IN A COMPLEX WORLD Thackara in his new book, In the Bubble: Designing in a Design, and other books. a whisper of evangelistic zeal, In the Bubble offers an engaging narrative as well as design principles Complex World. that speak to sustainability, joy, and quality of life in increasingly complex times.” These are tough questions for the pushers of technology Brenda Laurel, author of Utopian Entrepreneur, chair of the Graduate Media Design Program at Art to answer.
    [Show full text]
  • Metabolicity: How Can Design Nurture Amateur Cultures of Food Production in the City?
    Multiple Ways to do Design Research: Research Cases that Shape the Design Discipline Swiss Design Network Symposium, Lugano, Switzerland. 12th – 13th November 2009 Title MetaboliCity: How can Design Nurture Amateur Cultures of Food Production in the City? Abstract This paper introduces a current design research project that explores how designers can intervene sensitively within local urban food growing cultures by providing a design thinking and crafting that may help to sustain these initiatives and catalyse larger positive changes in the surrounding environment. MetaboliCity is the name for a vision of a city that metabolizes its resources and waste to supply its inhabitants with all the nourishment they need and more. This one-year (October 2008 – October 2009) participatory design research project on urban agriculture is based at Central Saint Martins, School of Art and Design and funded by the Audi Design Foundation. The aim of the project is to design an urban grow-kit accompanied by a set of guidelines to be tested and developed at a selection of sites in London, UK. This is a design-service system that integrates both traditional and hi-tech industrialized agricultural techniques into the fabric of the built environment whilst simultaneously being rooted in permaculture thinking. Permaculture is defined as an ‘ecological design system’ that empowers city-dwellers to create ‘sustainable human habitats by following nature’s pattern’. (Robert Hopkins, 2008, p203) The complex nature of the project calls for a Metadesign approach. Metadesign can be described as ‘a shared design endeavour aimed at sustaining emergence, evolution and adaptation’. It creates ‘open-ended and infinite interactivity capable of accommodating always-new variables’.
    [Show full text]
  • The Public Debate on Jock Kinneir's Road Sign Alphabet
    Ole Lund The public debate on Jock Kinneir’s road sign alphabet Prelude There has been some recent interest In August 1961 two researchers at the Road Research Laboratory in in Jock Kinneir and Margaret Britain published a paper on the ‘Relative effectiveness of some letter Calvert’s influential traffic signs types designed for use on road traffic signs’ (Christie and Rutley and accompanying letterforms for 1961b). It appeared in the journal Roads and Road Construction. A Britain’s national roads from the late shorter version was published in the same month (Christie and 1950s and early 1960s. Their signs Design and alphabets prompted a unique Rutley 1961c). These two papers were both based on a report ‘not for public debate on letterform legibility, publication’ finished in January the same year (Christie and Rutley which provoked the Road Research 1961a). These papers represented the culmination of a vigorous public Laboratory to carry out large-scale debate on letterform legibility which had been going on since March legibility experiments. Many people 1959. The controversy and the Road Research Laboratory’s subse- participated in the debate, in national quent experiments happened in connection with the introduction newspapers, design and popular of direction signs for Britain’s new motorways.¹ science magazines, technical journals, and radio. It was about alphabets and The design of these directional and other informational motorway signs that would soon become – and signs represented the first phase of an overall development of a new still are – very prominent in Britain’s coherent system of traffic signs in Britain between 1957 and 1963.
    [Show full text]
  • The Evolution of Industrial Ergonomics in the Mid- Twentieth Century
    1 “Machines and People” - The evolution of industrial ergonomics in the mid- twentieth century. A thesis submitted to The University of Manchester for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Biology, Medicine and Health. 2017. Roland John Edwards. School of Medical Sciences. Total Number of Words = 79904. 2 Front Cover of Origins of Ergonomics published in 1964. 3 Table of Contents ……………………………...…….……………………….……… ................................................................................................................................................... 1 Figures. ...................................................................................................................................... 6 Tables. ........................................................................................................................................ 9 Abbreviations. .......................................................................................................................... 10 Abstract. ................................................................................................................................... 13 Declaration. .............................................................................................................................. 14 Acknowledgements. ................................................................................................................. 15 Chapter 1: Introduction. ..........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Painting-And-Teaching.Pdf
    EDITED BY ICOCEP ORGANIZATION Francisco Laranjo COMMITTEE Domingos Loureiro Francisco Laranjo Sofia Torres Domingos Loureiro Teresa Almeida Sofia Torres Teresa Almeida DOCUMENTATION Domingos Loureiro ORGANIZATION Sofia Torres Francisco Laranjo Domingos Loureiro DESIGN Sofia Torres Tudo a ver Teresa Almeida Victoria Sánchez Giner TITLE Fernando Picornell Cantero Painting and Teaching – Reflexions Aurora Alcaide Ramírez inside the University Yehia Youssef Ramadan PUBLISHED IN SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE November, 2017 Alfonso Sánchez Luna (UMH-SP) By Research Institute in Art, Design, and Antonio García López (FBBAAUM-SP) Society - i2ADS António Quadros Ferreira (FBAUP-PT) University of Oporto, Faculty of Fine Aurora Alcaide Ramírez (FBBAAUM- Arts SP) Av. Rodrigues de Freitas, 265, 4449- 021, Domingos Loureiro (FBAUP-PT) Porto, Portugal Fernando Picornell Cantero (FBBAAUM-SP) www.i2ads.up.pt Francisco Laranjo, (FBAUP-PT) www.icocep.com Graciela Machado (FBAUP-PT) Greddy Assa (BL) This book gathers a selection of articles Ignacio López Moreno (FBBAAUM-SP) made in the context of the International José Aja (FBBAAUC -SP) Congress on Contemporary European José Ramalheira Vaz (FBAUP -PT) Painting, held at the Faculty of Fine Arts Julio Cesar Abad Vidal (SP) of the University of Porto, in April 3, 4 Laura Castro (U. Católica Porto-PT) and 5, 2017. © Maria de Fátima Lambert (FCSH.UNL- PT) Languages: Portuguese, Spanish, English Paulo Almeida (FBAUP-PT) Ricardo Leite (FBAUP-PT) 1st Edition: 150 copies. Rosa María Brún Jaén (UGR) Rui Serra (FBAUL-PT) ISBN Sofía Torres (FBAUP-PT) 978-989-746-136-1 [Printed Version] Teresa Almeida (FBAUP-PT) 978-989-746-142-2 [Digital Version] Victoria Sánchez Giner (FBBAAUM-SP) Yehia Youssef Ramadan (FBBAAUM-SP Cover Image: Vera Dantas /portoenvolto.com 1 2 INDEX - NOVA PALETA EDUCATIVA PARA A EDUCAÇÃO UNIVERSITÁRIA Afonso Pinhão Ferreira ~ p.
    [Show full text]