Department of Geology and Environmental Science Hartwick College and Department of Earth Sciences State University of New York College at Oneonta Oneonta, New York
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Department of Geology and Environmental Science Hartwick College and Department of Earth Sciences State University of New York College at Oneonta Oneonta, New York ' - ~' NEW YORK STATE GEOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION 75th Annual Meeting September 12-14, 2003 Eric Lee Johnson, Editor FIELD TRIP GUIDEBOOK HOSTED BY: Geology and Environmental Science Department Hartwick College Oneonta, New York 13820 and Department of Earth Sciences State University of New York College at Oneonta Oneonta, New York 13820 PUBLISHED BY THE NEW YORK STATE GEOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION. Additional copies may be obtained from the Association by contacting Dr. William Kelly, c/o New York State Geological Survey, Rm. 3140 CEC Albany, NY 12230. or by visiting http://www.nysgaonline.org/ 11 DEDICATION This guidebook is dedicated to all of those who helped make this meeting possible. Special thanks are given to Dr. Jim Ebert at SUNY Oneonta for his tireless efforts in making the arrangements for the meeting, and to Dr. Harrison Schmitt for coming and ' i helping us celebrate NYSGA's 75th anniversary. Finally, this meeting would not have been possible without the dedication and hard work of all of the field trip leaders who have spent countless hours both in the field and at the keyboard constructing the fabulous array of trips presented on the following pages. The tops of mountains are among the unfinished parts of the globe, whither it is a slight insult to the gods to climb and pry into their secrets, and try their effect on our humanity. Only daring and insolent ones, perchance, go there. Henry David Thoreau Cover photo: Overlooking the Hudson Valley at the Mountain House site: North Lake, Catskill Park. lll Table of Contents Preface and Acknowledgements p.v A-1 Late Middle Devonian Biotic and Sedimentologic Effects in East p. 1-54 Central New York-Tully Formation Clastic Correlative Succession in the Sherburne-Oneonta Area. Gordon Baird, Carlton Brett, and Alexander J. Bartholomew A-2 Coastal Margin Interfluve Paleosols and their Stratigraphic p. 55-101 Relationships with Tidal-Influenced Deltaic Deposits in the Sonyea Group (Frasnian) of Northwest Delaware County, New York Daniel Bishuk Jr., Jon Hairabedian, and James R. Ebert A-3 Glacial Regime and Depositional Environments along the p. 102-140 Retreating Laurentide Ice Sheet, Northeastern Appalachian Plateau, New York P. Jay Fleisher A-4 Karst of the Schoharie Valley, New York p. 141-176 Arthur N. Palmer, Paul A. Rubin, Margaret V. Palmer, Thomas D. Engle, and Brian Morgan A-5 Geology and Geochronology of the Southern Adirondacks p.177-196 James McLelland A-6 Late Ottawan Ductile Shearing and Granitoid Emplacement in Appendix A the Hudson Highlands, NY Matthew Gorring, David Valentino, Alexander Gates, and Gary Solar A-7 Paleontology and Stratigraphy of the Middle Helderberg Group p. 197-204 at Rickard Hill Road, Schoharie, New York James R. Ebert and Nancy A. Elliot 8-1 A Visit to the Land of Gilboa p. 205-212 Robert Titus 8-2 Grabau's "Transition Beds"-- Key Elements in a Radical p. 213-237 Revision of Helderberg Stratigraphy James R. Ebert and Damon K. Matteson 8-3 Examples of Along-Strike Changes in the Fold-Thrust p. 238-266 Architecture; Structural Geology of the Rosendale Natural Cement Region, Ulster County, New York Kurtis C. Burmeister and Stephen Marshak 8-4 Late Middle Devonian Biotic and Sedimentologic Effects in East p. 1-54 Central New York-Tully Formation Clastic Correlative Succession in the Sherburne-Oneonta Area. Gordon Baird, Carlton Brett, and Alexander J. Bartholomew v Preface and Acknowledgements It is a great pleasure to welcome you to the 75th annual meeting of the NYSGA. Hartwick College and the State University of New York College at Oneonta are this year's host institutions and we hope that you take some time to visit both schools a tour our respective Geology Departments. This year's field trips cover a broad array of topics and regions and will take you from the depths of caves to the tops of Catskill and Adirondack peaks. The range of topics is certainly varied including the fields of metamorphic and igneous petrology, structural geology, sedimentolgy, hydrology and paleontology. In honor of the 75th anniversiary of NYSGA, we are fortunate to have Dr. Harrison Schmitt as our keynote speaker. Having walked on the moon, Dr. Schmitt brings a very unique perspective on geology and we look forward to hearing his address. It is fitting that a lunar geologist present at NYSGA, since both the moon and the State of New York have one thing in common; terrific exposures of anorthosite. NYSGA meetings are unique and refreshing in that they focus on learning about geology by going out into the field and seeing it first hand. Because of this focus, NYSGA depends on the many individuals who have dedicated themselves to planning and running field excursions. Their tireless efforts are what make NYSGA meetings so enjoyable and valuable. I thank all of the authors and trip/workshop leaders, for their hard work. I would also like to thank Dr. Jim Ebert for arranging the meeting (as well as being a trip leader and author of multiple field guides) and for his help in making this field guide a realitiy. Jim served as the field guide editor for the 1991 NYSGA meeting held in Oneonta, and his expertise, advice and calming influence helped me immensely. Thanks Jim. In addition, I thank the staff at SUCO and Hartwick College for all of their help and technical support, and finally, I thank my students who make what I do so enjoyable. Eric Lee Johnson, Chair Department of Geology and Environmental Science Hartwick College Oneonta, New York 13820 I . i rfl, I-IAR1WICK Dr. Eric Lee Johnson Dr. James Ebert Field Guide Editor President 2003 Meeting New York State Geological Association New York State Geological Association 1 Trip A-1 LATE MIDDLE DEVONIAN BIOTIC AND SEDIMENTOLOGIC EVENTS IN EAST CENTRAL NEW YORK- TULLY FORMATION CLASTIC CORRELATIVE SUCCESSION IN THE SHERBURNE- ONEONTA AREA. Gordon C. Baird Dept. of Geosciences, S.U.N.Y. Fredonia, Fredonia, NY 14063 Carlton E. Brett Alexander J. Bartholomew Dept. of Geology, University of Cincinnati, H.N. Fisk Laboratory of Sedimentology, 500 Geology/Physics Bldg., Cincinnati, OH 45221-0013. ABSTRACT Terrigenous clastic deposits equivalent to the upper most Moscow Formation and Tully Formation record a number of key sedimentological-paleontological events that occurred during the latest part of the Middle Devonian Givetian Stage. These deposits, last mapped in detail by G. Arthur Cooper and H.S. Williams in the 1930s, have been the subject of extensive stratigraphic mapping work by the present authors over the past five years. Goals of this mapping project are: 1) to identify divisions and boundaries correlative to units identified in the Tully Limestone further west through the classic work of Phillip Heckel in the sixties and seventies; 2) to identify key facies that can be interpreted in the context of onshore-offshore paleoenvironmental models; 3) to reconstruct the faunal succession in this thick interval of strata so as to elucidate in greater detail two key levels of faunal change associated with the global Taghanic Bioevent; and 4) to use stratigraphy and sedimentology to identify structural features that were active or present during deposition of these units. Preliminary results of our work show that most of the lower and medial parts of the Tully Formation clastic correlative succession (here in referred to as "TFCCS") between Sherburne, NY and New Lisbon, NY consist of relatively unfossiliferous strata that record the development of a structural basin (New Berlin Trough) probably centered in what is now the Unadilla Valley. Condensed units overlying regional discontinuities developed at several stratigraphic levels both in the basin and on its western flank; sediment-starvation associated with condensation led to the formation of "oolitic" chamosite under conditions not fully understood. Basin center deposits recorded dysoxic conditions and development of low diversity faunas dominated by auloporid corals and small brachiopods; eastward passage of sparsely fossiliferous deposits near New Berlin to richly fossiliferous equivalent units near Laurens reflects a shoreward basin-to-shelf transition. This contradicts the standard view that the lower and medial Tully record primarily shallow and even lagoonal conditions. Our model does vigorously support (and significantly enhances) Heckel's (1973) view of a "Tully clastic trap" controlled by structure in east-central New York. Herein, we show that typical oxic Hamilton facies ends with onset of dysoxic, highstand conditions associated with deposition of the New Lisbon Member. We exclude the upper, Tully-equivalent part of Cooper and Williams' (1935) "New Lisbon Member", which is separated from our restricted New Lisbon Member by a basal Tully erosion surface. Currently, we believe that the restricted New Lisbon succession is equivalent to the Gage Gully submember of the Windom Member, although this is still uncertain. The TFCCS contains six internal mappable discontinuities; these are, in upward-succession: a, a base-Tully (DeRuyter Bed-equivalent?) contact; b, a sub-"Laurens" contact, possibly 2 equating to the base of the Fabius Bed to the west; c, a sub-Symrna Bed disconformity traceable westward into central New York; d, a top-Smyrna flooding surface contact; e, an erosion surface flooring the West Brook Bed; and f, a diastem (base-Moravia Bed? discontinuity) above the West Brook Bed. The upper Tully, base-West Brook contact marks the greatest lowstand event with development of a prolific Hamilton faunal association characterized by diverse brachiopods, and corals, above the contact. East of Otselic, the Tully Formation contact with the overlying Geneseo Black Shale is conformable. Initial Tully Fauna incursion occurs at the base-Tully (DeRuyter Bed-equivalent?) contact at New Lisbon and Laurens.