Effects of Anthropogenic Disturbance on Plant Composition, Plant Diversity and Soil Properties in Oak Forests, Iran
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
JOURNAL OF FOREST SCIENCE, 64, 2018 (8): 358–370 https://doi.org/10.17221/13/2018-JFS Effects of anthropogenic disturbance on plant composition, plant diversity and soil properties in oak forests, Iran Javad ESHAGHI RAD 1*, Gelare VALADI 1, Osman SALEHZADEH 1, Hosein MAROOFI 2 1Department of Forestry, Faculty of Natural Resources, Urmia University, Urmia, Iran 2Agricultural and Natural Resources Research Center, Sanandaj, Iran *Corresponding author: [email protected] Abstract Eshaghi Rad J., Valadi G., Salehzadeh O., Maroofi H. (2018): Effects of anthropogenic disturbance on plant composition, plant diversity and soil properties in oak forests, Iran. J. For. Sci., 64: 358–370. Three sites including “less disturbed”, “moderately disturbed” and “severely disturbed” were selected in Zagros forests in Kurdistan province (Iran). Three forest stands with similar physiographic conditions of each site were selected and three 400 m2 plots were assessed in each stand to record the floristic information and soil sample (0–30 cm). Different diversity indices were calculated for each sample. Cluster analysis and to collect soil samples detrended correspond- ence analysis were applied to categorize and investigate the vegetation trend. Indicator species analysis was used to determine the characteristic species. Tukey test was used to compare the variables amongst sites. The results showed that 47, 25, 15 species were exclusively observed in less disturbed, moderately disturbed and severely disturbed sites, respectively. Furthermore, cluster analysis illustrated the distinction amongst sites and detrended correspondence analysis result showed that the vegetation of the regions was ordinated by disturbance gradient. 21, 5, 7 characteristic species were respectively indicated in less disturbed, moderately disturbed and severely disturbed sites. In general, plant composition, plant diversity and soil quality were decreased dramatically along the disturbance gradient. Keywords: Quercus brantii; richness; understory species; Zagros forests; canopy cover Politic and scientific sensitivities on the biodi- forest ecosystem were directly affected by human versity issue have increased since the remarkable activities. In this context, Bell et al. (2016) stated enhancement of the extinction rate of species that the effects of silvicultural disturbances on because of human activities (Ehrlich, Wilson species richness in northern temperate and boreal 1991) and ecologists and natural resources manag- forests were independent of climate and soil prop- ers have shown great attention to the relationship erties. The effect of anthropogenic disturbance on between anthropogenic disturbance and species plant composition and plant diversity was inves- diversity (Robert, Gilliam 1995). The exact un- tigated in many studies all over the world. More- derstating of the relationship between biotic and over, Mishra et al. (2004) studied the influence abiotic sections of forest ecosystems and human of human based disturbance on three subtropi- influences on plants’ biodiversity is crucial for for- cal mountainous forest stands and showed that est managerial and protective activities. Scott et the more the disturbance intensity increased the al. (1998) emphasized the impact of improper use more the species richness and diversity of trees and land use change on decline of species diversity and shrubs decreased. Mligo (2011) illustrated and ecosystem destruction. Also, Ruprecht et al. that pole cutting and fuel wood cutting had sig- (2009) stated that structure and biodiversity of the nificant influences on decreasing the biomass, 358 J. FOR. SCI., 64, 2018 (8): 358–370 plant diversity and changing the species distribu- toria Olivier, but in some regions it is combined tion pattern. Blanko and Pereira (2015) evalu- with Quercus libani Olivier and Quercus brantii ated the anthropogenic disturbance on natural Lindley, while the southern part is just covered by vegetation in fragmented forests and showed that Q. brantii (Fattahi 1995). From the past to pres- protection of woodland habitats were necessary ent, these forests have been inhabited by residents for conservation of plant richness in the remain- and nomads who have caused deforestation in ing stands. Shaheen et al. (2001) investigated the some parts and severe damages in others. In these effects of human exploitation on structural diver- forests, people follow a classical form of managing sity and community composition in the subtropi- the forest in which forage for feeding their animals cal forests of India and demonstrated that density, and wood for fuel were collected (Ghazanfari basal area and the number of species were less than 2004). Unfortunately, due to social problems and those in similar undisturbed stands. Furthermore, lack of proper and comprehensive management, they mentioned that this destruction caused much these forests have been heavily disturbed and have pressure on Quercus ilex Linnaeus, Quercus dila- lost their productivity potential which endangers tata Lindley ex de Candolle, Pinus wallichiana the future of the forests (Fattahi 1995). Accord- A.B. Jackson, and Pinus roxburghii Sargent spe- ing to the increasing destruction of oak forests in cies. Despite abovementioned studies, Linares et Zagros forest in Iran, it is necessary to investigate al. (2011) stated that the species diversity of those the influence of human disturbance with various stands that experienced low human intervention intensities on species diversity and soil proper- was five times more than species diversity in pro- ties. Oak stands in Zagros forests are loaded with tected areas. Moreover Shrestha et al. (2012) a complex of disturbance regimes including fuel evaluated the effects of human-made disturbance wood cutting, local people use and livestock graz- on the vascular plant diversity in oak forests in Ne- ing. The local people use and fuel wood cutting pal and illustrated that all diversity indices were and livestock grazing may have distinct effects on enhanced where forest disturbance was at inter- the herbaceous plant diversity. This study, how- mediate level. On the other hand, the soil proper- ever, does not distinguish the disturbance types ties of forest can be affected by human activities but only their intensity levels. The spatial extent (Gömöryová et al. 2008). In the forest ecosystems and frequency of disturbances in the region show tree and herb species could influence soil proper- that these disturbances impact on all areas simul- ties and also there is an interaction between trees taneously but with different intensity. Therefore, and soil, in other words, growth and production of the current study aims to compare the woody and trees depend on the soil fertility. In addition, the herbaceous species diversity and soil properties in amount of mineralization and nitrification of or- less disturbed (LD), moderately disturbed (MD) ganic matter in soil is associated with species rich- and severely disturbed (SD) areas of oak forests in ness (Augusto et al. 2002). Moreno et al. (2007) Zagros forests. stated that harvesting of trees resulted in reduction of organic matter and soil quality; therefore, dis- turbance caused by human activities could change MATERIAL AND METHODS the composition, quality and quantity situation of tree species and as a result affect the soil properties Study area. The research area is located in the in forest ecosystems. Latty et al. (2004) evaluated Kurdistan province (Iran), latitude 35°45' to 36°15'N the influences of land-use history on soil charac- and longitude 45°30'E to 46°15'E. Nine patches of teristics and nutrient dynamics in northern hard- oak forests (Q. brantii) were selected which were wood forests of the Adirondack Mountains. The situated on north-facing sites with similar slope results showed that anthropogenic disturbance and altitude conditions. The altitude is 1,550 m and decreased the soil carbon and nitrogen pools com- the percentage of slope is between 15 and 23°. The pared to old-growth. Also, Borrelli et al. (2017) mean annual temperature is 13.8°C and the mean demonstrated that 45.3% of soil loss is caused by annual rainfall is 658 mm. The soil type is belongs water erosion in the logged forests in Italy. to the Entisol order developed on calcareous sub- Zagros forest is the largest forest land in Iran in strate (Pourbabaei, Navgran 2011). which oak genus is the main woody species. These Sampling methods. We observed a complex of forests are divided into northern and southern disturbance regimes including livestock grazing, parts based on oak species occurrence. The north- local people use and fuel wood cutting in the re- ern part is the specific habitat of Quercus infec- gion. The frequency and spatial extent of distur- J. FOR. SCI., 64, 2018 (8): 358–370 359 s bances in the studied region showed that many H'i1 ppii ln (1) areas would be impacted by these disturbances at the same time but with different intensity which where: resulted in different canopy openness. We catego- s – number of species, th rized the disturbance intensity by specifying the pi – relative cover of i species. canopy openness classes and defining the live- H ' stock grazing and traditional wood cutting levels. E = (2) H ma' x At first, from the oak forests of the region, three where: different sites were selected. The first one was the H' = ln(SR). LD area with more than 50% canopy cover (maxi- max mum canopy cover was 70%), little impact from In addition, rarefaction method