View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE

provided by Elsevier - Publisher Connector Magazine R871

The relationship with Sudhaus event — usually a mutation, or a gene has been enormously important and Quick guide recombination — enables the precursor allowed us to establish a phylogeny for (tail or fin buds in these examples) to a bunch of closely related nematodes continue developing beyond the bud with differently shaped tails. The Atavisms stage, often resulting in a functional phylogeny tells us the direction of structure. Extant horses, for instance, Brian K. Hall the evolutionary changes and shows have a single toe on each foot with a that the same kind of morphologies splint bone on either side. In horses evolved multiple times. Based on a What are atavisms? An atavism with three toes — an atavism reflecting lot of developmental genetics and is the occasional re-appearance in the three toed ancestral condition — the recently, genomics, we now have individual species members of a single additional toes can be fully functional, a pretty good idea of the principal generation of a character — a structure all the necessary muscles and nerves genes involved in C. elegans male or behaviour — that is present in all having developed in response to the tail morphogenesis. Some of these ancestors within the lineage. The presence of the atavistic toes. The genes are indeed the kind that Gould word comes from the Latin atavus three-similar sized toes are clue to imagined — they are responsible for meaning an ancestor further back the process: in larger limb buds, the regulating the timing of particular fates! in time than a great-grandfather’s primordia of the side toes (normally But there are other kinds of genes as grandfather. Atavisms also are known splint bones) developed and grew at a well. The challenges for the future are as evolutionary throwbacks, reversions, similar rate to the middle toe, enabling to figure out how these genes interact or the reappearance of ancient three toes to form. to regulate morphogenesis. Then we characters. Because their appearance can use these genes to see how the is unexpected, atavisms appear to be What causes atavisms? Apart from genetic architecture has been altered new but really are the manifestation of individual environmental disturbances, in the other nematode species. These an old character, the developmental mutations resulting in atavisms are studies may not tell us precisely how and genetic basis of which has been known. Excessive facial and upper body our ancestors’ DNA changed to make retained in ancestors without being hair in humans (hypertrichosis) can be us human. But, along with the exciting expressed as a character. so extreme as to cover almost the entire work of others in the field, we hope it body with hair. The causative mutation will lead to a general model for how How do we identify an atavism? By has been mapped to Xq24-q27.1 in the evolution works with development to definition, atavisms can be identified X chromosome, although the gene has make different forms. only in a lineage for which we know not yet been identified. We see that, the evolutionary history. Thus, when provided the gene regulatory pathway Would you recommend a scientific the patterns of articulation of the wrist is present, a mutation can provide career to a student these days? bones in all the individuals from a single a sufficient signal to reactivate the Science is nothing quite like I had Californian population of the rough- pathway leading to the formation of the envisioned as a kid, of course. I could skinned newt, Taricha granulosa, were atavistic feature. Atavisms tell us that not have foreseen the petty politics, the analyzed, two of the eight patterns were genetic information may be retained frustration of the grant-writing treadmill, found to be atavistic — these patterns but not expressed in the phenotype the difficulties of managing a lab in a few individuals were found in all for many generations. An enormous composed of diverse personalities, the members of an ancestral species. amount of variation is therefore present time drain of committee work and peer to be (re)activated given the appropriate review duties, the endless demands Other examples of atavisms? The signaling event. of students, and the struggle to find occasional presence of a tail on a new- blocks of time just to think about a born human is an atavism because Where can I find out more? Atavisms. Encyclopedia of Evolution (M. Pagel, ed. problem. Fortunately, many interesting human ancestors are known to have in chief), 2002, Volume 1, pp. 86-87. (New York: intellectual challenges still abound. had tails. Likewise, the occasional Oxford University Press.) Reflecting back on that electrically formation of hind fins in whales or Figuera, L.E., Pandolfo, M., Dunne, P.W., Cantu, J.M., and Patel, P.I. (1995). Mapping of the stimulating New Year’s Eve, however, dolphins or of fore- and hind limbs in congenital generalized hypertrichosis locus it is clear that the first motive force snakes can be identified as atavisms to chromosome Xq24-q27.1. Nat. Genet. 10, 202–207. propelling me into science was not because cetaceans and snakes have Hall, B.K. (1984). Developmental mechanisms just intellectual. It was physical and ancestors with fore- and hind limbs. underlying the formation of atavisms. Biol. Rev. emotional, an intense intimacy with Camb. Philos. Soc. 59, 89–124. Hall, B.K. (1995). Atavisms and atavistic mutations: a new phenomenon, like a first love. How do atavisms arise? Implicit evolutionary conservation of genetic and Every once in a while, a surprising new in the identification of a character developmental information. Nat. Genet. 10, 126–127. discovery or a successful experiment as an atavism is that the ancestral Shubin, N.H., Wake, D.B., and Crawford, A.J. will reignite my sense of wonder and developmental and evolutionary basis 1995. Morphological variation in the limbs of joy, or the look of sudden understanding for the character has been sufficiently Taricha granulosa (Caudata: Salamandridae): Evolutionary and phylogenetic implications. will light up a student’s face in the preserved that we can identify the Evolution 49, 874–884. classroom. And then it is all worth it. character as an atavism. Also implicit Zander, R.H. (2010). Taxon mapping exemplifies punctuated equilibrium and atavistic saltation. is that a precursor of the atavism Plant Syst. Evol. 286, 69–90. Department of Biology, New York University, must be present as developmental 100 Washington Square East, New York, programme or rudiment in all individuals Department of Biology, Dalhousie University, NY 10003, USA. but normally not progress far enough Halifax Ns Canada B3H 4J1. E-mail: [email protected] to produce the character. Finally, an E-mail: [email protected]