IN THE SUPREME COURT OF OHIO
Charles E. Wilson et al.,
Relators, Case No. 2012-0019
V.
Governor John Kasich et al.,
Respondents.
EXHIBITS TO DEPOSITIONS OF
RAYMOND DiROSSI AND HEATHER MANN
JAN 17 2012
;,.ctt<<,it !;JM ,^F4fiFi^E ^OURI iJF OMpO CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
A copy of the foregoing was served via e-mail and regular U.S. Mail this 17v' day of
January 2012, upon the following:
Aaron Epstein Richard Coglianese Pearl Chin Jeannine R. Lesperance Assistant Attomeys General Constitutional Offices Ohio Attorney General 30 East Broad Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 aaron epsteingohioattorneygeneral.eov Jeannine LesperancegOhioAttomeyGeneral.gov richard coglianesena ohioattomeygeneral.gov pearl. chinna ohioattorneygeneral. gov
Counsel for State Respondents
Mark Braden Robert Tucker Baker Hostetler 65 E. State Street, Suite 2100 Coiumbus, Ohio 43215 mbradengbakerlaw. corn rtuckerna bakerlaw.com
Special Counsel for State Respondents
Lloyd Pierre-Louis (Bar # 0068086) Wesp/Barwell/Pierre-Louis Co., LLC
Counsel for Relators
2 From: Rench, Karrie To: Carle. Mattr cc: Wickham, lohni Subject: Meet Gov at 15th Floor Date: Thursday, June 02, 2011 9:01:54 AM Attachments: image001.png
Matt -
Beth wanted to know if you would meet the Governor at the 15th floor this morning. The Governor is attending Mark Braden's presentation on redistricting at 10 am. Since this is his first appointment, he wi!I go straight to the 15th floor. Wickham should know when is ETA is.
Thanks!
Karrie Rench Assistant to the Chief of Staff Office of Ohio Governor John R. Kasich 614-644-0941 Karrie Rench(tDzovernor.ohio:aov www eovernor.ohio.¢ov
may be publicly This message and any response to it may constitute a public record and thus available to anyone who requests it.
tE Mann, Heather
From: Hansen, Beth [[email protected]] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 11:12 AM To: Mann, Heather; Rench, Karrie; Carle, Matt Cc: Grodhaus, Michael Subject: Re: redistricting meetings
The Governor is out of town next week. But Mike Grodhaus, Matt Car!e and I would like to met with Braden and Morgan. Thursday is best
Weekly meetings on Monday are best in the afternoon. 3?
Finally, I'd love to grab coffee - week after next is best!
Thanks Heather
From: Mann, Heather [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, June 30, 2011 02:47 PM To: Hansen, Beth Subject: redistricting meetings
Dear Beth:
I am following up on a conversation Troy had with you about a planned Ohio visit from Mark Braden and John Morgari, the consultant on the data/technical end of redistricting. They will be in Columbus Thursday, July 7 and Friday, July 8. We would like to make them available for an individual meeting with the Governor (as well as the other apportionment board members) those days. Right now they are blocked off for staff training that Thursday afternoon and Friday morning, but of course we can move those around. Please advise if there is a time that might work.
Additionally, I spoke with Matt Schuler and Troy Judy about setting up a weekly staff meeting on redistricting starting in the next two weeks, at which you or your designee could be present. Is there a regular time that would work for your schedule? I was thinking perhaps sometime on Mondays?
Finally, not that you have any spare time, but would you like to grab coffee or lunch sometime in the next two weeks?
Thank you, Heather Mann
Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather mann(c)ohr.state.oh.us
CONFIDENTIALITY4 NOTICE
)S,J U
Redistricting Presentation -Republican National Committee May 2010 Presenter: John Morgan Consultant to Ohio Republican Redistricting Task Force Attended by Michael Lenzo, Ohio House Majority Legal Counsel I-7 Aaaortionment Board timeline Need to finalize data Need to standardize political index and other theses Need to determine who is Joint Republican and Joint Democratic appointment Need to determine who is Secretary GOV call meeting 2 weeks before the 15t Meeting
August 15t 4th orSth 15t Apportionment Board Meeting
Late August (maybe week of August 22"d) Apportionment Board Road Show
Friday September 23rd-Date of Plan submission to Board September 28`h or September 291h = AB Vote October 151- hold for possible date for emergency hearing
EXHIBIT
73 coneressional redistrictine timeline Wednesday, Juty 20, 2011 9AM - 12PM Coiumbus / Ohio Statehouse - Senate Finance Room 3PM - 6PM Zanesville / Ohio University - Zanesville Campus
Thursday, July 21, 2011 Cleveland State University Maxine Goodman Levin 9AM - 12PM Cleveland / College of Urban Affairs - Atrium
Tuesday, August 2, 2011 9AM - 12PM Lima The Ohio State University at Lima & Rhodes State College Life & Physical Sciences Building 3:30PM-6PM Cincinnati / University of Cincinnati MainStreet Cinema
August 19th - Target date to get a bill equivalency file to LSC
Hold it "in the can" until legislature comes back in September (13`h / 14tn^ House might come back eariy and do committee work to get bill moving
If that doesn't work - must get done by end of October
EXHIBIT I CONSULTING AGREEMENT
This consulting agreement ("the Agreement") is made as of the I"day of August 2011, between the Republican Members of the Legislative Task Force on Redistricting, Reapportionment, and Demographic Research ("The Task Force") and Capital Advantage, LLC, 5732 Springbum Drive, Dublin, OH 43017 ("Capital Advantage").
WHEREAS, the Task Force is an entity which was created by R.C. 103.51 for the purpose, among other things, of engaging in such research studies and other activities deemed necessary or appropriate in the preparation and formulation of a plan for the next apportionment of the Ohio General Assembly and a plan for the establishment of districts for election of representatives to the United States Congress; and,
WHEREAS, pursuant to R.C. 103.51(D), Task Force is empowered to engage such experts and technical advisors and fix their compensation, and to obtain such services as are necessary for the Task Force to perform its duties under R.C. 103.51; and,
WHEREAS, the Republican members of the Task Force desire to retain the services of Capital Advantage to aid them in carrying out their duties under RC 103.51(D) including but not limited to, the preparation and formulation of a plan for the next apportionment of the Ohio General Assembly, and a plan for the establishment of districts for election of representatives to the United States Congress, and Capital Advantage agrees to render such services to the Republican Members of the Task Force, on the terms and conditions set forth herein.
The Task Force and Capital Advantage mutually agree as follows:
1. Consulting Services. During the term of this agreement, Capital Advantage shall make available Raymond E. DiRossi to render such consulting services as may be needed or requested by the Republican Members of the Task Force to cany out their duties under R.C. 103.51.
2. Term. The term of this agreement will commence on August 1, 2011, and shall expire on December 31, 2011, unless tetminated in accordance with the provisions of Section 8 of this agreement or extended by the Task Force by agreement with Capital Advantage.
3. Consulting Payments. In consideration of the services to be performed by Capital Advantage pursuant to this agreement, The Task Force agrees to pay Capital Advantage the total sum of seventy-five thousand dollars ($75,000.00) payable as follows forty thousand dollars ($40,000) on August 22, 2011, and thirty-five thousand dollars ($35,000) payable on October 17, 2011. Further, should litigation be commenced challenging the redistricting plan passed by the General Assembly, the reapportionment plan adopted by the Apportionment Board, or any similar litigation pertaining to the duties in this contract, Capital Advantage shall be paid an additional thirty thousand dollars ($30,000)_
4. Expense Reimbursement. During the tenn of this agreement, Capital Advantage shall be entitled to reimbursement of all reasonable and necessary travel and lodging expenses incurred by Capital Advantage in connection with Capital Advantage's performance of the consulting expenses hereunder, provided that Capital Advantage submits to the Task Force EXHIBIT Nr ^ ^ I invoices or other documentary verifications of such expenses. The determination of whether any such expenses submitted by Capital Advantage are reasonable and necessary shall be within the sole discretion of the Task Force; provided, however, that the Task Force shall not deny reimbursing Capital Advantage for any properly verifed expenses that the Task Force approved in advance of such reimbursement. The Task Force shall provide parking access to Capital Advantage, the use of which shall be limited to the purpose of benefiting the Task Force in the perfomzance of statutory duties.
5. Other contractual obliflations. Commencing on August 1, 2011, and continuing through October 31, 2011, Capital Advantage shall not engage or hold any other contracts for consulting services related to the General Assembly in the state of Ohio.
6. Independent Contractor. The Task Force and Capital Advantage expressly acknowledge and agree that the consulting services to be provided by Capital Advantage under this agreement shall be performed as an independent contractor and not as an agent or employee to the Task Force or the Republican Members of the Task Force. The parties expressly acknowledge and agree with respect to any payments made to Capital Advantage hereunder, Task Force will not: (i) withhold any federal F.I.C.A. or other federal, state or local taxes; or (ii) contribute to any applicable workers' compensation, unemployment or any other state or federal programs. Further, Capital Advantage agrees that it has no right to bind the Task Force, or the Republican Members, to any legal commitments to third parties.
7. Indemnification. The Task Force shall indemnify and hold harmless Capital Advantage including Raymond E. DiRossi, against any and all liability insofar as such liability arises out of or is based upon any plan for apportionment of the Ohio General Assembly or the establishment of districts for election of representatives to the United States Congress, or the formutation or creation of any such plan or for any such matter that the Republican Members of the Task Force use the services of Capital Advantage. For this purpose, liability shall mean any: (i) judgments, damages, costs, charges, expenses, or other liabilities imposed by any court, administrative agency, or other govemmental authority in any executive, legislative, judicial, regulatory, or administrative action, suit, or other proceeding, including any appeals, (ii) costs, charges, and expenses (including, but not limited to, attomeys fees, filing fees, posting of bond, etc.) reasonably incurred in connection of the defense against any such liabilities, in any such action, suit, or other proceeding; and (iii) costs, charges, and expenses (including, but not limited to, attomeys fees) reasonably incurred in connection with investigation or defense of any claim made or threatened (whether or not made or resulting in any action, suit, or other proceeding.) The indemnification from liability as discussed in this section shall continue in full beyond the end of this Agreement on December 31, 2011.
3. Termination. The engagement of Capital Advantage by the Task Force under this agreement shall terminate automatically upon and in the event of death, disability, termination or employment, or other removal or separation of Raymond E. DiRossi as a representative of Capital Advantage during the term hereof. In the event of termination of Capital Advantage's engagement, prior to the expiration of the term of this Agreement, Capital Advantage's compensation shall be prorated to the dateof such termination and no fterther compensation or expense reimbursements shall be due or paid, but Capital Advantage will still have right to indemnification in Section 7.
YL 9. Assignment. Without the written consent of the Republican Members of the Task Force, Capital Advantage shall have no right to assign or otherwise transfer any rights created under this Agreement. This Agreement shall be binding upon, and shall inure to the benefit of, Task Force and Capital Advantage and their respective successors, personal representatives, executors, administrators and assigns.
10. State Prooertv. Atl equipment, documents, and data purchased or created with Task Force funds shall remain the joint property of the House and Senate Republican Caucuses upon completion of the term of this contract, and shall be transferred to the custody of the House or Senate Republican Caucus upon approval of the Republican Members of the Task Force.
11. Conf'identialitv. Capital Advantage shall not disclose or use, without appropriate authorization by the Republican Members of the Task Force, any information acquired by Capital Advantage in the course of its contractual duties with the Task Force that is confidential because of statutory provisions, or tbat has been clearly designated to Capital Advantage as confidential when that confidential designation is warranted because of the status of the proceedings orihe circumstances under which the information was received and preserving its confidentiality is necessary to the proper conduct of govemment business.
12. Entire Aereement. This Agreement, together with any attachments hereto, constitutes the entire agreement between the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof and supersedes any and all written or oral prior agreements and understandings between the parties. IN WITNESS THEREOF, the parties agree to the above terms and warrant that they have the authority to bind the parties.
Legislative Task Force on Redistricting, Reapportionment, and Demographic Research
ti Ma ew T. Schuler Oh(o Senate Chief of Staff
Troy Judy House of Rehtesentatives Chief of Staff
y DiRossi Capital Advantage, LLC
t(3 Page 1 of 1 Casemaker - Browse
Ohio Administrative Code
011. Apportionment Board
Chapter 011-1. Meetings 2011 Updated for atl rules flnal filed and adopted through November 21,
011-1-03. Open meatings Ali meetings and public hearings of the 2011 apportionment board shall be held in accordance with the Sunshine Law, section 121.22 of the Revised Code and pursuant to rule 011-1A1 of the Administrative Code, as amended.
History. Effective: 08l15I2011 Promuigated Under: 111.15 Statutory Authoritv: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution Art. Xi, Sec. 1, Revised Code 121.22 Prior Elfecfive Dates: 9!7l91, 8/1i101
EXHIBIT
http://www.lawriter.net/NLL3UvII,/getcode.asp?statecd=OH&codesec--011-... 12/8/2011 `o INITIAL APPORTIONPIENT BOARD MEETING SCRIPT
1. Call to Order
KASICH: Pursuant to Article 11, Section I of the Ohio Constitution, I hereby call GOVERNOR to order this meeting of the 2011 Board ofApportioning Persons. There is a quorum of members present, but for the record, would each member of the Board please indicate their presence by stating their name.
[Members state names and titles) This meeting is called pursuant to Article B, Section 1 of the Ohio Constitution, which requires that after each decennial census, the Ohio Board of Apportioning persons - including the Governor, Secretary of State, Auditor of State, and two persons selected by the leadership of the General Assembly convenes between August I and October I of the year the census figures are released to establish the district lines of the Ohio General Assembly- Article 11 of the Constitution governs the procedures for this apportionment, and we will therefore proceed under its provisions.
Appointment IL Present Indicia of OfSce and Letters of
with a copy of the proposed agenda for GOVERNOR KASICH: Members have been provided item of business is for the members of this meeting, which was distributed in advance. The first their membership on the Board by presenting their letters of appointment, in the Board to verify the case of legislative apportioning persons, and oaths of office in the case of other members.
We will now receive these documents. 3 would like to indicate for the record that I have the Auditor David Yost, and myself as Govemor. certificates of office for Secretary of State Husted, 1 also have a letters from House Speaker Bill Batchelder, Senate President Tom Niehaus, Senate and House Minority Leader Armond Budish, choosing and Minority Leader Capri Cafaro, appointing Leader Budish and President Niehaus to serve on this Board.
from each member, and it all appears to be We now have received the appropriate documentation in order.
III. Election of Chair of the Apportionment Board
GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is the selection of a chair.
SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Govemor, I move that Governor Kasich be named chair of the EXHIBIT i' (46 Apportionment Board.
GOVERNOR KASICH: We have a motion. Is there a second?
AUDITOR YOST: I second the motion.
GOVERNOR KASICH: Auditor Yost seconds. The nomination has been made and seconded. Those Are there any other nominations? If not, afl if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. opposed? Motion is carried, I will serve as chair.
IV. Selection of Secretary of the Apportionment Board
on the agenda is for the selection of a secretary to the GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item Board of Apportioning persons. The Secretary will keep the minutes, call the roll, and record all votes and maintain custody of all the records of the Apportiotunent Board, including the proposed plan to be filed with the Board. I will now entertain a motion for secretary.
be named Secretary of the SECRETARY IIUSTED: Mr. Chairman, I move that [name] Apportionment Board.
GOVERNOR KASICH: We have a motion. Is there a second?
AUDITOR YOST: I second the motion. seconds the motion. The nomination has been made and GOVERNOR KASICH: Auditor Yost seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If not, Those opposed? Motion is carried, [name] will all if favor signify by saying aye [all say crye]• the custodian of the records, the documentation serve as Secretary. I will now give [name], provided to me.
V. Election of Vice Chair of the Apportionment Board
next item on the agenda is the selection of a vice chair to the Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The of Apportioning persons_ I nontinate Auditor Yost to serve as vice chair of the 2011 Apportionment Board. Is there a second?
SECRETARY HUSTED: I second the motion.
GOVE"RNOR KASICH: Secretary Husted seconds the motion. The nomination has been made and seconded. Are there any other nominations7 Is there any discussion of the nomination? If Those opposed? If not, will the Secretary not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. I please call the role. 2 lW-? SECRETARY: For the selection of Auditor Yost as Vice Chair of the Apportionment Board, [calls rolfl. Auditor Yost is selected Vice Chair of the Apportionment Board by a vote of X-X.
VI. Announcement of Attorney Representation
GOVERNOR KASICH: Historically, the Attomey General has represented the Board and all persons serving on the Board. Attorney General Mike DeWine has appointed Mark Braden to be here today to be available to the Board. I would like to ask Mr. Braden to identify himself on the record. MARK BRADEN: Mr. Chairman, Members of the Board, I am Mark Braden, Counsel to the Board.
GOVF.RNOR KASICH: Thank you, and welcome.
VII. Appointment of Official Court Reporter
GOVERNOR KASICH: At this point, given the official and historic nature of our proceedings, we need to appoint an official court reporter for the proceedings of the Apportionment Board. For the record, I'd like to ask our court reporter, who is here from the finn of Armstrong & Okey to please identify herself.
REPORTER: My name is Karen Gibson, court reporter with Armstrong & Okey.
GOVERNOR KASICH: Accordingly, I will now entertain a motion to appoint an official court reporter for these proceedings.
SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Cbairman, I move that the lirm of Armstrong & Okey be the official court reporter for the 2011 Apportionment Board and that said court reporter please transcript of each of our meetings. prepare and provide each member of the Board a copy of the
AUDITOR YOST: I second the motion.
GOVERNOR KASICH: Auditor Yost seconds the motion. The nomination has been made and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If not, Those opposed? If not, will the Secretary please all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. call the roll.
SECRETARY: For the appointment of Armstrong and Okey as official court reporter for the 2011 Apportionment Board, [calls roln. The motion carries X-X.
3 rW GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you.
VIII, Adoption of Rules and Procedures
GOVERNOR KASICH: This brings us to our next agenda item, which is the adoption of the rules of the 2011 Apportionment Board. All the members should have a copy of the proposed rules which I provided to each of you in advance of today's meeting. These proposed rules are, Apportionment Board which are on file with in essence, a revised version of the rules of the 2011 the Legislative Service Commission. Our intention is to vote on the rules as a block unless there is an amendment. At this time I would entertain a motion regarding the rules.
as a block] [If there is n motion to adopt the proposed rules Chairman, I move that we vote to adopt Rules 1-12. SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr.
AUDITOR YOST: Second. The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the GOVERNOR KASICH: Secretary will call the roll. [calls roll]. The motion carries X-X. SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt Rules 1-12
proposed rules] [If there is a motlon to amend the motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? GOVERNOR KASICH: The
MEMBER: Move to amend. moves to amend. Please describe your amendment. GOVERNOR KASICH: [name]
Member proceeds to describe amendment.
GOVERNOR KASICH: The amendment has been moved.
MEMBER: Second. motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary will call the roll.
SECRETARY: [calls roll]. The motion to amend passes X-X.
GOVERNOR KASICH: Is there finther discussion on the proposed rules as amended? If not, will the secretary please call the roll on the motion to adopt the proposed rules.
4 lYs ------SECRETARY: [calls rollJ. The motion to adopt rules 1-12 as amended passes X-X.
GOVERNOR KASICH: The rules have been adopted. I instruct the Secretary of the Board to certify and file these rules forthwith as prescribed by the Ohio Revised Code.
]X. Adoption of Public Hearing Schedule
rules we have just adopted provide for a series of public hearings GOVERNOR KASICH: The around the state to receive public input and comment on the apportiomnent plan. At this point I would entertain a motion to establish a schedule of these public hearings.
Mr. Chairman, a proposed schedule had earlier been distributed stating SECRETARY HUSTED: the times and places for eleven public hearings to be held in various locations around the state move that we adopt the proposed schedule as the from August 22 to August 26, 2011. I would schedule of public hearings as required by our rules.
GOVERNOR KASICH: Is there a second?
AUDITOR YOST: Second.
GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary wi11 call the roll. [calls rollj. The motion SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt the public schedule of hearings, carries X-X.
GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary is instructed to make the schedule available to the press and the public.
X. Adoption of public records policy
GOVERNOR KASICH: The rules also call for the Apportionment Board to adopt a public records pursuant to Ohio Revised Code 149.43. A proposed public records policy was distributed to members earlier and is in your folders. Do I have a motion on the proposed policy? SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairman, I move that the Board adopt the proposed public records policy.
AUDITORA YOST: Second. . Any discussion? If none, the GOVERNOR KASICH The motion has been made and seconded 5
(';0 Secretary will call the roll. [calls roll]. The motion carries SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt the public records policy, X-X. The Secretary is instructed to make the records policy available to the GOVERNOR KASICH: public and the press.
XL Designation of place for public review of proposed apportionrnent plan
time, I would like to ask Secretary Husted to provide us with an GOVERNOR KASICH: At this overview of the Secretary 's redistricting website.
SECRETARY HUSTED: [discusses website]. rules call for the apportiotunent board to designate a place or places GOVERNOR KASICH: The where the public may review the plans of apportionment that are filed with the Board. Is there a motion on the designation of a place for public review of submitted plans?
Chairman, I move that the Board designate a website with the SECRETARY HUSTED:1vIr. address of www resapeohio.or and a physical space adjacent to the Ohio House of 43215 where the public may ltepresentatives Chambers, 2"d Floor Statehouse, Columbus Ohio review the plans that were submitted to the Board.
AUDITORA YOST: Second. motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary will call the roll. motion to designate the place where the public may view apportionment SECRETARY: On the plans, [calls roll]. The motion carries X-X. Secretary is instructed to make the location and website as the GOVF.RNOR KASICH: The designated places for public review of plans available to the press.
RII. Establishing time, date, and place of next meeting
this time I will entertain a motion to establish the date and place of GOVERNOR KASICH: At . the next meeting of the 2011 Apportionment Board I move that the next meetin of the Board be set for SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairman, 6 )SI Monday, Sept. 26, 2011 at 9AM in the Ohio Senate Finance Hearing Room.
AUDITORYOST: Second. motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the (',OVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary will call the roll. On the motion to set the date and location of the next Apportionment Board SECRBTARY: meeting for Monday, Sept. 26, 2011 at 9AM in the Ohio Senate Finance Hearing Room. The motion carries X-X.
XIII. Adjourn
further business to come before the 2011 Apportionment Board? GOVERNOR KASICH: Any If not, I will entertain a motion to recess the Board until Monday, Sept. 26, 2011 at 9AM.
SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chainnan, so moved.
AUDITOR YOST: Second. and seconded. All in favor? Opposed? GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made Thank you, the 2011 Apportiorunent Board is adjourned.
7 ISZ HeatherAAann
From: Vaughn Flasher [vaughnigcapitolstrategiesgrp.com] Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2D11 5:32 PM To: Ray DiRossi; [email protected]; Jody (-iCursi Cc: Heather N. Mann - gmail; MaU Schuler; Troy Judy Subject: Rer Time sensitive issue for OHROCfRSCC - Apportionment data
This will be the first in the string of emails. I have copied 7ody so please copy her going forward on the indexing issue, since she does our indexing. ------original Message------From: Ray DiRossi To: yohoQohiohousepoo.cem To: Vaughn Flasher Cc; Heather N. Mann - gmail Cc: Matt Schuler Cc: Troy 7udy Subject: Time sensitive issue for OHROC/RSCC - Apportionment data Sent: 7u1 5, 2011 5:27 PM
Ben / vaughn
I hope this email does not prompt a massive string of emails but if further detailed conversations are warranted/needed - please advise.
Heather and I had a conference call today to discuss data issues and one of the most pressing issues that we have identified is standardizing political indexes for the upcoming Apportionment of house and senate districts.
As the respective Chiefs of Staff and other principals (Speaker and President) get into evaluating districts - we all need to be on the same page with regards to what statewide non judicial races comprise our "political index." Can you both provide the quick list of what races you used to "index" districts leading up to the November 2010 races? Also - are there any 2010 statewide that you feel should be added to make a more precise index?
We can use just about any race from the last decade. We would recommend not using any judicial races, congressional races or state legislative that you races for the statewide indexes. Some possible contests that have been suggested might already be using.
2010 Kasich/Strickland 2008 Obama/McCain 2006 Taylor/Sykes 2006 Dann/Montgomery 2004 Bush/Kerry
Please advise what races you currently use or would like to see used..
One last thing... by way of example - in 2000 we used the following 4 races averaged 1996 Clinton/Dole statewide 1998 Taft/Fisher statewide 1998 Deters/Donofrio statewide (minus Summit and Hamilton counties) 2000 Bush/Gore statewide
Ray I EXHIBIT
a -1 Heather Mann
From: [email protected] Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2091 5:41 PM To: Uaughn Flasher; Ray DiRossi; yobo®ohiohousegop.com Cc: Heather N. Mann - gmail; Matt Schuler; Troy Judy Subject: Re: Time sensitive issue for OHROClRSCC - Apportionment data
For the 2010 elections, we used the elections listed below for our indexes;
2008 Obama/McCain 2006 Taylor/Sykes 2006 Dann/Montgomery 2004 Bush/Kerry
-Original Message----- From: "Vaughn Flasher"
This will be the first in the string of emails. I have copied lody so please copy her going forward on the indexing issue, since she does our indexing. ------Original Message------From: Ray DiRossi To: XohoFdohiohouseROp.com To: Vaughn Flasher Cc: Heather N. Mann - gmail Cc: Matt Schuler Cc: Troy Judy subject: Time sensitive issue for OHROC/RSCC - Apportionment data Sent: Jul 5, 2011 5:27 PM
Ben / vaughn I hope this email does not prompt a massive string of emails but if further detailed conversations are warranted/needed - please advise.
Heather and I had a conference call today to discuss data issues and one of the most pressing issues that we have identified is standardizing political indexes for the upcoming Apportionment of house and senate districts.
As the respective Chiefs of Staff and other principals (Speaker and President) get into evaluating districts - we all need to be on the same page with regards to what statewide non judicial races comprise our "political index." Can you both provide the quick list of what races you used to "index" districts leading up to the November 2010 races? Also - are there any 2010 statewide that you feel should be added to make a more precise index?
We can use just about any race from the last decade. EXHIBIT l0 or state legislative We would recommend not using any judicial races, congressional races have been suggested that you races for the statewide indexes. Some possible contests that might already be using.
2010 Kasich/Strickland 2008 obama/McCain 2006 Tayior/Sykes 2006 Dann/Montgomery 2004 Bush/Kerry see used.. Please advise what races you currently use or would like to
used the following 4 races averaged One last thing... by way of example - in 2000 we 1996 Clinton/Dole statewide 1998 Taft/Fisher statewide 2000 Bush/Gore statewide 1998 Deters/Donofrio statewide (minus Summit and Hamilton counties)
Ray Heather Mann [email protected]] Fron:: Gtark 9ensenlPOLIDATA Sent: Sunday, July 10, 2011 4:44 PM To: 'Ray DiRoss4'; 'Heather N- Mann - gmail'; 'Troy J.'; 'Matt Schuler sbc emaif; 'Benjamin Yoho'; Vaughn Flasher : [email protected];'Michael Lenzo' Cc: 'Braden, E. Mark' Subject: RE: Ohio Apportionment and Redistricting poiiticai data
Ra}=, A good start... T}U,nks. clark
POLIDATA (0 Demographic and Political Guides j w-vvev.Rolidata.ns POLIDATA (R) Political Data Analysis j vrcvtiv nolidatanra POLIDATA *-at CatePress j www cafettress e:o^olidata I'OLIDATA 0 at Lulu j wmtiv lulu com/twlidata
Clark Bensen j POLIDATA LLC I Tel: 703-690-4066 Vermont Oftice: 1303 Hayward Road I P.O. Box 530 ; Corinth, VT 05039 Virginia Office: 3112 Cave Court j Lake Ridge, VA 22192 efax: 202-318-0793 j email: clark a?nuli^
From: Ray DlRossi[mailto•ravdirossjpcimai{ coml Sent: Sunday, July 10, 20114:22 PM To: Heather N. Mann - gmail; Troy J.; Matt Schuler sbc email; Benjamin Yoho; Vaughn Flasher; Jod(^a caoitofstratea esgro cor2Michael Lenzo Ce: Braden, E. Mark; dark Bensen - polidata Subject: Ohio Apportionment and Redistrittfng political data Based on previous emails, we seem to have agreement on using the 5 races listed below (equally weighted) to comprise our index number for apportionment and redistricting. In races where there are tninor party candidates - Ihave excluded those minor party candidates and weighted the 2 majors to 1000/o. If there are no objections to these 5 races, I have ca'd Clark Bensen and counsel on this email so that they can make sure we have these races in our political data to be used with Maptitude.
Using these 5 races -- the Statewide Republican Index by my calculation is 49.56%
Ray
2004 Presidential Busb(Kerry Bush won 50.81 to 48.70 Using only 2 Major parties - Bush won 51.05 to 48.94
2006 Auditor T'aylorlSykes Taylor won 50.64 to 4936 2006 AG nnnnlNtonigomery Dann won 52.61 to 47.39
2008 Presidential ObamalMcCain Obama won 51.30 to 46.91 Using only 2 Major parties - C}batna won 52.33 to 47.66
2010 Kasich/Strickland Kasich won 49.04 to 47.04 Using only 2 Major parties - Kasich won 5 1.04 to 48.96 Heather Mann From: Ray DiRossi [[email protected] Sent: Monday, July 11, 2011 1:52 PM To: Heather Mann Su bject: Re: GeoCode etforts ok t}tats fine On Mon, Jul 11, 2011 at 1:28 PM, Heather Mann
*sx Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Oltio 43206 (514) 352-5$19 lreathenunannC Pmail,rnm
--Original Message----- Prom: Ray DiRossi [mailto:ratdirosSiCmgma.il.coml Sent: Sunday, July 10, 2011 9:39 AM 'fo: Heather N. Mann - gmail Cc: Troy J. Subject: Re: GeoCode efforts
Are you also communicating with Ben Yoho on adding to the database past and future opponents of current republican s-tate reps
Ray
On Sun, Jul 10, 2011 at 9:34 AM, Ray DiRossi
Dear Ben:
Attached is an updated incumbent home address tist, which may be subject to change further given appointments and anticipated vacancies in the House. We will need to get addresses for likely candidates and opponents to add to this database for the larger redistricting database
Ray - I had already pulled the Senate and Congressional addresses a few months ago, but this list has not been verified against the Cierks' data.
-Heather Mann 1 Con ss R ublican 2 Con ss Auslria Steve 2537 Obetz Drive Republican 3 Congress Boehner John 7371 Charter Cup Ln. Democrat 4 Con ress Fudge Marcia 269 10 Em • Rd. Republican 5 Congress Gibbs Robert 6992 TR 466 Re ublican 6 Con ss Jolmson Bill 3755 Hunters Aill Republican 7 Con s Jordan Jim 1709 State Route 560 Soudt Democrat 8 Congress ICa tur _ Marcy 1841 DoriRd. Deinocrat 9 Con ess Kueinich Dennis 12217 Milan Ave. Republican 10 Co ess LaTourette Steven 7082 Oak St. Re ublican 11 Congress Latta Robert 1528 Muirfield Dr. Re ublican 12 Congress Renacci Jim 521 LeedsGatesLn_ RuWican 13 Congress Ryan Tim 1504 Taft Ave. Re ublican 14 Co ss Schmidt Jean 771 Wards Comer Road Re utilicait 15 Con ress Szivers Steve 372 W. 2nd Avenue Deinocrat 16 Con ress Sutton Bei 3825 Royal Rock Rd. Re ublican 17 Coneress Tiberi Pat 6830 Mahogany Dr. Re ublican 1S Congress 'furner Michael 5815 Stone Lake Dr. Re ublican 1 I House Newbold Craig 347 E. State Ri 14 Republican 2 House Brenner Andrew 8824 Clearview Lake Court rrail Re ublican 3 House Amstutz Ron 4456 Wood Lake " Re ublican 4 House Huffman Matthew__ 2220 Merit Drive Re ublican 5 Aouse Stebetton Geraid 536 East Allen Street R^ ublican 6 House Gardner Randy 409 S. Mitchell Road Democrat 7 House Yuko Kenn 479 Pierson Dr. Demacrat ^ 8 House Budish Armond 6 Kenwood Court Democrat 9 House Boyd Barbara 34L8 Washi onBlvd. rDemocrat 10 House Patmou Bill 867 East Blvd Democrat 11 House Williams Sandra 12518 Fairhill Road Democrat ^ 12 House Bames John 4467 Lee Road, Apt. 303 Democra# 13 House Antonio Nickie 1305BetleAve. Democrat 14, Honse Fole Michaet 3525 Catnnunn Ave. Democrat 15 House DeGeeter Timothy 2700 Tuxedo Drive R ubliean 16 House Baker Nan 4477 Mallard Circle Re ublican 17 House Anielski Marlene 17150 Alexander Road Re ublican IS House Dovilla Michael 62Hama Street Republican 19 House Gonzales Anne 335 Wildwood Drive Democrat 20 House Garland Nancy 4983 Mead Way Drive Re ublicaa 21 House Duff Mike 645 Farrin an Drive Democrat 22 House Carney John 357 E. Torrence Rd. Republican 23 Huuse Grossman Cheryl 3143 Park Street 1230 Oakland Avenue Democrat 24 House Celeste Ted Demoarat 25 }iouse Stinziano Michael 1128 Highland Stred Democrat 26 House Heard Tracy 1732 Cole St. Democrat 27 House Weddington Carleton 75N.OhioAve. Democrat 28 Flouse Pillich Connie 9910 Forestglen Drive Re ubhcau 29 House Btessin Louis 3153 McGill Lane Re ublican 30 House Meeklenbor Bob 6648 Powner Famt Dr. 4990 Rellennt Ave. Democrat 31 House Driehaus Denise Democrat 32 House Mallo Date 917 Dayton St, A t. 2 Dentocrat 33 House Reece Alieia 2081 Seymour Ave. Re ublican 34 House Stautber Peter 7571 A ers Road Republican 35 liouse Maa Ron 2075 S. Siate Route 123 Republican 36 House Henne Michaet 844 7 Diamond Mill Road 401 Devereaux Drive 7 House Butler Jim 1 Re ubiican 3 280 Grand Vista Drive lican 9 8 ouse lair e 1 Luckie Clayton 69 Horace St. ocrat 39 House 3636 . ocrat 40 Flouse Wlnburn Roland 527 Chesles Dr 4t Eiouse Slab blican L Z222 East Strcetsboro Road hlican 42 House Roe ner Kristina 57 erwood Forest Drive 43 House MeKenne Todd 06 Sh Republican ^ I33 Furnace Run Rd. ocrat 44 House S kes Vernon 2055Cramer Ave. 45 House Milkovich 7ack crat 3050 B. wick West #113 blioan 46 House Sears Barbara 2054 Belvedere ocrat 47 House Fedor Teresa 2910 Collin aod Blvd. 48 House Astiford Michael ocrat 1660 Grand Ba Drive 49 House Szollo.si Matt ocrat 117Marlboro Ave. NE 50 House Ha n Christina blican 1817 Devonshire Drive NW 51 Housc Schurin Kirk blican briar S. NE House Slesnick Ste en ocrat 52 d Millvit{e Road 53 House Derickson Timoth blicao 1846 New LondonRd. 54 House Combs Courffiey ublican 6959 Rock Sprins Drive 55 House Conditt Mar aret ublican 1828 W. 38thSt. ocrat ^ 56 House Ranios Dan 338 Olive Street House Luod Matt ocrat 5054 State Route 601 House Boose Terry Iubliublican 2940 Wliis erui Pines Dr. Democtat House Gerber Ron 562 Madera Ave. House Hagan Robett Democrat 460 Antigua Rd. SW ttouse Oke Mark Democrat 372 E. 328th St. House Fende L.orraine Deritocrat 6893 Mildon Drive House Young Ron Rublican 4061TodAve.NW 64 1[ouse Letson Tom Democrat V 7450 Northview Drive 65 House dBrien Sean Democrat 2981ndianview Drive 66 House Uecker Joe Republican 7234 Abilene Tmil 67 House Beck Peter Re ublicau 646 Ada Street 68 House CI e Kathleen Democrat 435 East Smith 69 House Batchelder Bill Re ublican 2098 Fairknoll Drive 70 House Martin VJ7atTod Re ublican 894 Jonathan Lane 71 House Hoitin er R ublican 38 W. Hi h Street #3B 72 House McGre or Re ublieen 6l7 Holida Drive 73 House Go al Democrat 11932 Harris Road 74 House Goodwin R ublican SSOEuclidAvenue TS House Wachtmann Rub)ican 830 S. Maio Street 76 House r ue Re ublican 281 Do wood Court 77 House Buch R ublican 1509 Bon Air Circle Re ublican 78 Fiouse Adams John 1075 Flilicrest Drive Re ubliean 79 House Adams Riehard 80 House Murra Dennis 2035 Cedar Point Dr. Democrat 1014 Birchard Avenm: 81 House Damschroder Rex Republican 555 SunsetDrive House McClain Jeffr Re ublican 82 860 Wedewood Drive Re ublican 83 Iiouse Burke David 2050 Palouse Drive 84 House [-Iackett Robert Re lican 5564 Grassy Brranch Road 85 House Peterson Bob Re ublican 7027 State Route 350 West Re ublican 86 House Rosenbe er Cliff 238 McGee Lane 87 [-louse Care John Re ublican 307 N. Market Street . 88 House Bubp Dantt R ublican 74-A McDaniel Road 89 House Johnson Terrv Re ublican 3 Swin le Avenue 90 House Ruhl Mar et Re publiran 58 Corbin Drive N. R ublican 91 House H es Bill 46HudsonAve. Democrat [ Philli s Debbie 92 Tho on '^^^' Re ublian 2945 Dresdent Road e bfican Baldetson Troy 4(rt0 Scioto Dr., V^EiIIADUSC Gentife Lou Democrat 4570 Hacrold Street N W Re ublian ndis Al 368 E. Jaon Street R ublican Fta11 Dave Hoitin^ton Ricbard Rublican 5718Noiih RichmondRoad Kozlowski Casey R ublican 2714WesttnoorRauad Senate Hite Cliff Republican I 3331 PelhamRd. 2 Senate W oner Mark Re ublican 5325 Ponderosa Drive 3 Semts Bacon Kevin Re ublican 8265Che LaurelDr_ 4 Senate Col William Reublican 604 Revelstoke Court 5 Senate Bea te Bill Republican 533LockerbieLn- 6 Senate Lelmer Pe (Mar erite) Re ublican 800 Valle.View Pt. 7 Senate Jones Shannon Re ublican 2097 Beech Grove Dr. R ublican 8 Senate Seitz Bill 3 Lenox Ln. 9 Senate Kearne Eric Democrat 4887 Peacock Rd. 10 Senate Widener Chris Re ublican 2461 WarrenSt. I I Senate Brown Edna Democrat 7025 Dibble Rd. 12 Senate Faber Keith Republican 5360 Barton Rd. Republican 13 Senate Mannin Ga le 1131 L.ittleandian Creek 14 Senate Niebaus Tom Re ublican 1237 Medford Rd. I S Senate Tavares Charleta Democrat 4319 Fairoaks Dr. Rublican 16 Senate Hughes 7im 440 North Street 17 Senate Daniels David Re ublican 7413 Tattersall Street 18 Senate Grendell Tim Re ubGcan 161 StonebendDr. 19 Senate Jordan Kris Republican 42995. School Lot Road 20 Senate Stswart Jimm R ublican 13901 Woodworth Ave. 21 Senate Smith Shirl Democrat 5206 Crown Pointe Dr. 22 Senate -ObhoF Larry Re ublican 16800 Delaware Ave. 23 Senate Skindell Michael Re oblican 17157 Rabbit RunDrive 24 Senate Patton Tom Re ubliean 16204 Sunn Gten Ave. Senate Turner Nina Democrat 25 514 Hed ate North Court 26 Senate Gillmor Karen Re ublican 3800 Rosemont Blvd, f 09-C 27 Senate LaRose Frank Re ublican 1298 N. Howard St. 28 Senate Sa er Tom Democrat 1585 Yorksh've Trace Ave. 29 Senate Oelsl er Scott Re ubtiran 149 Homestead Drive 30 Senate Wilson Jason Democrat 1173 Stone Run Ct_ 31 Senat.e Schaffer Tim R ublican 600WaznerRd. 32 Senate Cafaro Ca ri Democrat 3765 Mercedes Pl. Democrat 33 Senate Schiavoni Joe ^ Beavercreek Ohio 45434 WestCltester Ohio 45069 Warrensville Hts. Ohio 44128 L,akevilte OH 44639 Poland Ohio 44514 Urbana Ohio 43078 43615 Toledo Ohio Cleveland Ohio 44111 BainhPid c Ohio 44094 Bowlin Green Ohio 43402 Wadsworth Ohio 44281 44446 Niles Ohio Loveland Ohio 45140-9049 Columbus Ohio 4 3201-33 1 2 Co le Ohio 44024 Galena Ohio 43021 Centcrville Ohio 45429 44408 COLUMBIANA VIL D 044 Columbiana Ohio 01807 Ohio 43065 POWELLCITYH Powell 0028 Ohio 44691 WOOSTERCITY3C Wooster 0020 Ohio 45805 LIMA4A Lima LAN 3B Lancaster Ohio 43130 LANCASTER CITY 3 B 43402 Bowling Green Ohio Ohio 44143 RICHMOND HEIGHTS 03 B RIHT03B Richmond Hei hts BCHWD00H Dhio 44122-7501 BEACHWOOD 00 H Beachwood CLHT03F Cleveland Hts. Ohia 44 1 18-2 5 4 3 CLEVELAND HEIGHTS 03 P CLEVEOSI Cleveland Ohio 44t08 CLEVELAND O8I Ohio 44120-1018 CLEVELAND06 R CLEVE06R Cleveland CLEVEOIH Cleveland Ohio 44128-2957 CLEVELAND01 H Ohio 44I07-2679 LAKEWOOD 03 B LAKWD03B Lakewood CLEVEI9R Ohio 441 1 1-2912 CLEVELAND 19 R Cleveland PARMA04D Ohio 44134 PARMA 04 D Parma WLKV06B Ohio 44145-6303 WESTLAKE06 B Westlake WALTNOOA Ohio 44 14 6-5 023 WALTON HIL.1.S 00 A Walton Hilts BEREA05C Ohio 44 01 7-244 0 BEREA 05 C Berea 03201E Westerville Ohio 43o81-5729 WESTERVILLE I E 01082G New Albany Ohio 43054-9697 COLS 82 G 18201B Worthin on Ohio 43085-353I WORTH I B Columbus Ohio 43214-3837 I B 09101B Grove Ci . Ohio 43123-3225 GROVE CITY 07000B GrandviewHeights Ohio 43212-3317 GRANDVIEWB Ohio 43201 Columbus 01005A Columbus Obio 43205 COLS OS A COLS 07 B 010078 0100711 Columbus Ohio 43203-1950 Ohio 45242 MONTGOMERY C 1003 Mont me 59 3 Obio 45251-3111 COLERAIN C Cincinnati 7313 Obio 45248-2972 GREEN M Cincinnati 2505 Ohio 45238-3806 CINCINNATI 25 E Cincinnati 1801 Ohio 45214 CINCINNATI 18 A Cincinnati 0703 4 523 7-47 5 7 CINCINNATI7 C Cincinnati Ohio 5605 Ohio 45255-3914 ANDERSON E Cincinnati 0069 Oh10 45036-8941 0069 SAL T W Lebanon 0353 Clsyton _ _ Ohio 45315-9665 CLAY B Da ton Ohio 45419 Ohio 45458 Centerville 0092 Ohio 45402 DAYTON 7 B Dayton 0394 Ohio 45405-t845 HARRISON ) Da ton 4420 Copley, Ohio 44321-3096 COPLEY TWP F Ohio 44236-3413 HUDSON 3 E 2970 }ludson 3204 Ohio 44319-4257 NEW FRANKLIN 2 B Akron 0480 Ohio 44307-2259 AKRON 3 N Akron 1600 A}ron Ohio 44312 AKRON 10 A 05006 Maumee ]Ohio 43537-9738 MONCLOVA 6 O107 D Toledo ^ Ohio 43614-3003 TOLEDO 7D Ohio 43610-1449 TOLEDOIOD O110D Toledo 07001 Ore on Ohto 43616-1152 OREGON I Ohio 44601 Ailiance 173 Canion Ohio 44708-1907 JACKSON TWP 5 Canton Ohio 44714-1137 Oxford Ohio 45056 Hamilton Ohio 45013 Lib Tw . Ohio 45011 Lorain Ohio 44053 Elyria Ohio 44035 Norwalk Ohio 44857 Canfield Ohio 44406 Youngstown Ohio 44504 Catrollton Ohio 44615 Willowick Ohio 44095-3308 Painesville Ohio 44077 Warren Ohio 44485 BrookBeld Ohio 44403-9644 MiamiTownsh' Ohio 45140 Mason Ohio 45040 Kcnt Ohlo 44240 Medina Oh[o 44256 Dayton Obio 45431 Newark Ohio 43055 S rin eld Ohio 45502 Mansfield Ohio 44904-1820 Defiance Ohio 43512 Napoleon Ohio 43545 Findla Ohio 45840 Greenvi8e Ohio 45331 Sidne Ohio 45365 Troy Ohio 45373 Sandusky Ohio 44870 Fremont Ohio 43420 U erSandus Ohio 43351 M sville Ohio 43040 London Oluo 43140 Sabina Ohio 45169 Clarksville Ohio 45113 1Vellston Olrio 45692 West Union Ohio 45693 McDermott Ohio 45652 Mount Vemou Ohio 43050 Granville Ohio 43023 Athens Ohio 5701 Marietta Ohio 45750 Zanesville Ohio 43701 Steubenville Ohio 43953 Dover Ohio 44622 Millersbur Ohio 44654 fluntin Valle jOhio 44022 Pie nt Ohio 44082 Ohio 45840 Findla 09001 Ottawa Hills Ohio 43606-2469. OTTAWA HILLS 1 Columbus Ohio . 43231.-4033 45069 Middletown Ohio Ohio 45371-2761 Ti Ci 0632 Ohio 45429 KETTERiNG 3 O Ketteffn 0162 Oluo 45056 0162 CLC T MA S rin boro 7323 Cincinnati Ohio 45233 GREEN W Cincinttati Ohio 45229 S rin freld Ohio 45502-8718 0108 F Toledo Ohio 43620-1325 TOLEDO 8F Ohio 45822-2814 .. Celina 1540 Ohio 44039 N RIDGEVILLE 41 C NorthRid evil[e 0106 NewRichmond Ohio 45157 OHIOTOWNSt-1fB 432092840 01028D Columbus Ohio COLS 28 D ^Ohio 43214 ^ COLS 22 A 01022A Columbus 01 Greenfield Ohio^ 45123-1338 GREENFIELD 111 E Ohio 4^f026-2036 Chesterland 02101 Ohio ^ 43065 ORANOE TWP B Powell 05 Alban Ohio ^ 45710-8980^ COLUMBIA Cleveland Ohio 44112-1919 Medina Ohio. ^ Lakewood Ohio 44107 Stron sville Ohio 44136-6243 . Cleveland Ohio 44128-3771 44883 •rifrn Ohio 44333 Fairlawn Ohio 44310 Akron Ohio North Canton Ohio 44709-4855 Columbiana Ohio 44408-9559 Lancas[er Ohio 43130 Hubbard Ohio 44035 44406 Canfield Ohio r
Heather Mann
From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, JuN 31. 2011 10:21 PM To: 'Benjamin Yoho' Attachments: house 4 chb.xlsx
This is what should be updated with candidates, opponents, and persons of interest.
.rx Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 {614} 352-5819 heathernmann ail.com
t v a E Z ^ N m ° H^ m 1^ ^ n n V o N W p 1D o Op .^-1 n N ul o^^ ^m N i^ Q^ry ^G o1 01 .i 1^ v{ tp ^ IN4 n p T N m Qy p N sa N.-[ 1^ N Ol .-( ^O Of M O Ul OV d' CO Q ^V O eiO1 t0 N^ N ^l N v1 Ti ^-1 1`^ N f^l tO R Ol N h( .i ^.^ rct N V e-[ ^D M O^D m m N I*pl a^D ^ N umi V V^n [p^1 W(V
6 2 oC ¢ K 1' ¢ ^ O O 0 ^ Q ^ ^ O 6¢ K¢ ^¢ ^ K 0 ^ Q ^ ^ ¢ 6 ^ O ^¢¢ 2¢¢ 0
N . J, m_ d O. d N . m c
E S°i QZ^ °ur^ruu..smoo¢n.rt^^r^7 u.v4¢°^t7aYa`mm
C O ^ ^ W E L N C O C^ O Y N N 0 C T m N Y IY V' O L ^ Y t O V L h0 c N r_ Y Z.O C Y^^ 9 O^'O E^ C r N C7 Y d'J ^ N^ E. O^ C y N u E! d^^ N^ R N3^ N d m q d ry C O O^6 3 1p N'u ^ZtDQ2v^t7T ^O(00. ^ MQu^. ^tL Qo (7C7^tJt7tJN23'am^o ^¢ v^^ sm m^
01 ^ U) N N N Y) ^ N N O V1 V^1 N N N v^i U) 0) N JI N N C) d N N Ul O! UI N Ol d UI N G) G) N„ O O ' o'o o o 0 0 00 0 Oo a o o 0 0 o H30 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o O o o ' O o o b^,. ' O _,*_=O o 0 0x= 2= x= x 2 x x S 2 x x x T 2 S S x x x x 2 2= 2 x= x x x x 2 2
' g ry y M p N^P !^ a0 w ^ ^^ ^.^, ^^.Ny N^ ^.mx N N N M N N N N N N m m m M M M M M M M
L
N 0 oU d' o N o N m*a ^^^^ m G^i rn m.r+ m N m m o n m v^ a w^n r rn^o rn m O T^/1 a m QU O V N N l0 V N^ ^^^ ^ N^ O vt N N a r r ^y
r
M r N O M^/t N N^^C h M N O Q Yl N ^6 N N r M O O O Of ^n +y cu r r oo ci co m ul N ^n .-1 N M N N H ci M Q N M 1D ei
cC O a[ c K [L o K K K K K K 0 K K 2 p 0 K ^ O b cC K O K K cc O ^¢ O O 4 0 cc Q 0 tG
R > ^ c C y a c '^ m y c iO H L La o^ C^°-° C c" L c a^ ^ c E rv a`i :c Q ^ c^ s u C !D ¢ ^ z[ 1^- 7 rJ m t^ ^`G U ]G VI I- U G a^L }a- K 0 G J K H N ^ 2
C q N c R c ^ b m m ^ E w w c >p ^'w c ^ u^e ^^ 4 > R u`^ c `^. w cn c m`v y t ^ c°-' `m v^ m L^' E E - c Ay Y ar ^[ r`o v°- o m^ w" E c E c ^ L m 0i a^ N W R C o 0 o Q^'O n `p UO Y- ^.- R^ t yD R^ LO N Gl' kO RN pR O YO at 3 m K^ N ^ VI ^- Q 4) 2 N V1 D OC J 0`U x 0 LL Y J O^ m f} ¢] G 2.^ l7 l7 ^ VI m Q Q
N VI ul N N R N N N n R ^ h N R N N YI ^ N N N N N N N0 v R M M N V1 M 0 R N R N VI 'o O'a 'o 'o o'o a o 0 o a'o 'a o o'o 'o o'o 0 0 0' 'a 'o xo xo xo 2o xao x or xa xoo x 0x x0 x0O x x' x x z z x x s x x x x x 2 x x x 2 x x x x x x x x r-r n GO n 7 m m eG m N^ O^ N m N d' N fl O^ N N N d' N it ^ m n r m N N^a N N M O N O N ap ^^N O N r+! n N s! ^ v3
O CC ¢ ^ aG K LK [C O K tC oC IK 2 K!Y K a a tt
^ `v X0 = a c^ - o^?;ow m^^ ozmu a^^ or-^moar.^a
a pp c G c._ 0 o a a w
nE cz Co > m^^ ro Yu o m` a^^^ s .ac m v c m o a `L O^ m S a oc U m aC x n r m t7 `-+° S S x
m ar m w m w m w w w m w w a ai v m w ui ^ N N M N N vl W h!n N VI N N VI wl N D 0 O O O O D 4 O 0 O OO a O O a a a O S 2 x T S S S x T T S S S S S S x T x T ... a O r-^ N m 7 N t0 (^ m'O^ e.•• c.. . ..^ .•. 00a .-1oU WN mC'ao cn N ca tD oo f^ w W°Gf vw a¢ m t5^ m T rn drn m as m rn S o o o 0 o 0 o o 0 o o 0 0 0 00 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 L L t L L L L L L L L L t t L L L L L L L tii L L wooooo0000000000000000000000000000000000m L L L L L L L L L .G L L L.C
n L L ar av ^ H ro o = m v ro S a S ^ $ l7 c o c c c c°o y x ^ .a .^ ^ V S s n' a' o c ^ c c c c o c c> c ,p -^v, ,^ m o 3 m m ^ m ° m ro m o ro ro q s E u. a E E E°«Q c c c c c c $ o a; o E v m.5 E ^ w v a w y ar ^^«,^ v ,"„ 3 C o ' o N > > > > > 3? o i c c c c^O m^ w m m N m-Y ^o o p E j ^ v ro m3'Sm3z^i- i7c7io V fl va3v ^ v vvm `^°uav
^ ^ p p > U > > > d > O a
< "^^ a w vi °C .^ o 4 7`^Ynv m c u a^i 6'^ 6 y mLL a vi ¢,ooca o'_^,j^ _ y E c o°C :=. o°1O'. > °C v ^ aci t p o Ym >_ z rv s^ o tc vm m°° 3 a ^^F a c ^ a% o:° 6 - o¢ a ro ve R m,n c= o E ^ ro E w c'°_ °=m Z°o-« ¢ 0?c °L m s OC v^ N- X^ a F.° ^ s ^ dr o K ro 31 N d .m v-y m> m a m m o o2 d^^ u16i O cW^n ^ d o m^ IY ^ Q ^n Q vi ^ a U x y ^j (j G W Vf 0. Y^ W u J m V F^ a x ^^^L W Y- O S V 2 O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O L L L L L t t L S G L t L L L L 00000000000000000000000000000t.C .G L .C .C .C t t L L L L 00000000000
n ^
3 o c ae °-' "a o wO m o m c w pcp
O m .IC m o^ m^ N^ p3j d N N N^^ a y ^ n ^O o o^ N N y W -,5 - x N.R9 Q} o N o N O au° z a a aM^-^° o ¢ u u o x^ ^, z u> u 3 LL 3 m^ f^^ Q z o z LL t^ ^
3 9 m z W O N 0 K Q a` W R Z C ^' NN dR N) ' > N a O C ^y ^- W N d N 3 R N > 00 ^ 61 p iT =^ Q l0 C N.. = 7^ C] O R _ N`I >'O C` U `_ O^ O 1' `? C^ m j E Y J C U LL C R> a Q Q r ^ R- a ^ in m 3^ Q K^^ p Z w. ' ^^ o K 4.'^a ^ o m O a^ii- aRi • O c`n Q O> N a0 u O
J N m m a^ a' ^ m ry a'q 's m m m'x .` m x-°_ . N ^^ ^'m c? o aCi o` N" R ^ IY ^- N R +^. ^ m L R^ M^ ^ o C^ W'N i o R^ o o- R L ry d z W O W L^ h z Q Q LL 3 x x W N O m Q V D Z aC 3 O VI ^i ^ S ^j [} ypj y'Ci LL U tll fll U 0 6 0 0 0 0 0 o p d ^ ^ o o o o o o 0 0 L L.C .C t t L L.C L.t L L t L L L00666000000000000000 L.L L
y C p^ ^ C ^ G ^ m N C v ^ 4 6 d N 7 _ C ,=p 40 Z>y d ^ C O Y N O^^ N V 41 y C N^ OI j d d H Q m^^ O ^ ^ O m L G j d ^ E d m C 3l N d 9^ pU O (7 Q g N vf p G = 6 J +A U ^ ^ ^G' ^.
^ 0 3 m o
p ^ ^ d s n °.' o^ v v ¢ w in i E C'1 5 O' V N 3 N^^ Q 3 Q OI 2' : V^ c^ j .O Q Q^. [] m ^ J y`y d 6 C d G U^ ^ ^. ([ L N N O^ ^ N d^ 3 ^ d C tCn N 4 O O^ C L 0 ip -• O O V^ N^ 6{`J N rL Z^ N U 2 t0 p N S w U Z Heather'IV[ann
From: Heather Mann [heathernmannQgmail.com] Sent: Manday, August 01, 2011 12:59 PM To: 'Benjamin Yoho';'Troy J: Attachments: house_4_chb.xlsx
Ben,
Attached the updated database format for House incumbents, P01s, and challengers. I need any candidate or other names added to this as soon as you have time so we can get them up on the screen-
-Heather Mann r+a Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614] 352-5819 heathernmann(ftmail.com
EXHIBfT ^ ^1`^ a E 2 O m o .+ .. .n h .+ co m - m-m °^^ m h m h h V o N d h N u`^i rv^o Oi ai ea t^ -1 !^ Of n^ tO V' O^ N h N m N^ N V m V N M O h V lD .-1N Q R n1ei I^'1 ^1 N,c^ .h-^ N T R^p T N1 rt r'^ ^h V1 m m^ N N V^^ M^
p O O 0 O K 4K G.1 Q[] a a K a C C• oC a a ^ C D OC ^ a rc y' rG rY a O 0 O O 0 O ^ O O a
N C y C
Z Ql L'C] T T 0 N ^ ^ y ^ ^ L Qf Li N C^ r l.i = C^ A C^ V^ C!^ ` N uu°^m°ooaaz°^^^u
= co
N ry O AV C ^
'ac^ o v m^- c`- Z n°c ^^ Em mv o'-"A v E_ ^ V' Y > v- m v- m^ m ro v a 1O 3 ^ Z m ¢= v^ i9 i m m° ^a- m 1O Q u.Ca O vm m d Oc o[7 ot7 m 0 Uo +nm v-x 1 O. m cG 0 g a V! ^G Y m
0+ N C^ W N N N a^ m N W v N 0^ N 0W y N Oi N m vOi udi O^ u0i N N d N^1 VI N N Jl N N N Vl N ^i udi N^ N N N^ N N 0 O O b DO O D O O O O O O O O O O O O O O ^ O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 2 S 2 S 2 2 x 2 S x Y Y 2 x x S x Y S S 2 Y S S Y Y 2 S x F= x x= x Y x 2 x= O*"^ N M O N^O h m m ei N M d' ^^ r` p^ 4 ti N m V' ^/1 t0 h mOf iC rl N hl V^ m h m 01 O ^„^ ^y ^„f ^y ^y ^..{ N H ai N N N N N N N N N N f^l M lyl M m M M M m M
0 o ap R^D J1 OD V o0 r N o o^" O) Yl pp H o N O rv m e+ mrnm M-am^nm coon mwa mmnpW^ ^o^na^mv m O Ot N<1' M iD 'OQ n N n lD V N M YI ^ M W N^ O N N .-1
n ^p N^p u^ O d' O O 00 P u1 O^D O^ GO m!^ N O m N v1 N N ^o Y^ Ta N O V N N M N N 111 e^ N m N N N 'i r-1 ^' N m l0 ^
^orcz^oo^o^ooccouac^aocx^rxozrc^eoczoc oer.zaoc^^ooo^
W v c .-. c a a a ^ m a ^ a °.x n a a^^ n o 3 m c« a c^-^c 'o c E ^„ .a ^ u U m^ "i a E D D m^ o`r o 0 1O o 0 o a D a m"-'°. -`° a°c `-° m ^ 6' ^ ^ ic ^ C,+•
c a o c '° pp m
3 c C ^ o•o con y y" ^ s^ ° v uai .L3 m^. 9 C o a`a .z Q^" ^ c•YJ i. o^ m u m m W 0) ?^ o D V D D D 2 3'D G.C N V Y y m V N O N V W d O ^ m j O m m Y N O 4Yi m ^ V^ K TL N^ N li Q N 2 N eA O U lJ (L .^ m l7 T O u. T..+ O^[C U G] g 2^ U^ l7 ? m m Q Q
a a N a a a a a a a a N N N N a a N N N N a N N N N a NN aN N a. N a a N Gl a a a a 3 3a N N N VI N M M N ^ J"J S 3'J ^I 3 J 3 3 3 J 3.'i N t/ VI N N 1 3 3^ 3 3 3 3^ 3.3 J.^J ^'J .3 'S ^J O3^ O 3O 3O 3^O D J D 3 O O O O O O O O O O O D D D O D O O D D D O D O O O D D D D D D D 2 S S 2 S T= S S 2 S S 2 2 S S 2 S 2 S 2 2 S S 2 2 2 2 S S 2 2 2 2 S S 2 2 S 2 O N N m V Ilf ^^^^'^ n n^ n n n^ ^ On1 i+ ED Gl O rl N M V N' lp I^ CU 01 . x ^. rl f•F' M C` ITt lG' Ul Uf ^D ^O W^O N N R V d' V V d' O V V V^11 ^ t!] 1^1 N N N ^) ^n V Ul YI O^ t^ OO h V M OD W 01 O O CO N GD m.r^na ^nmrvmon .n v rv^^.$u~ imnn o^O^nnryNOrvM ^vav N^n
K O K¢ n: m' O+L K aC K K aC C rtC t[ ra C ^ n'
r « ^ a ^ c ^ .o C m t m b a aoc^oxmuW V^ ^ O O O^ o^-gmoam'^ao'z`v ^"^ W^- d G m O m u
m ro
0 N M - :J
ts`U' y N^ n^ L m.'c .OC ^^ m^ mzx o ^c 0 `L o a^°cm -o2=n riV'
w N N+^q N N N N N N K^ M N N N N N a N O D^O OO O O O O O O O O D O O O O O O = x S S 2 S S S S S S S S S S 2 S S S S
o°oma^o^ro^^e`°oorumc°c^ moi`o+mwmmmrn^rn o o 0 o o o 0 o o o o o 0 o o o o o o o o 0 o o o o o o o o o 0 o o o o o o o L L L L L t L.C L L L L.C H000000000000000000000000000000000000000L L t L L L.G L.G L L t L .C t t t t L.E L L L L.C' .G
L m OG
IO N.L ^ .T. ^ 41 C i }?s N N a 61
A m m m o m ^ m o ^ a 4 t E m-^a EEEE E c c c c c c oc o o aZi o > i> i.y >£ > ? 3 0`^ `^c 3 s ^ oa m m ai 0-6 o m ' s? o c c c c c c^ m m w m -"^ u a^^ ^ m^ m ^= u ^ 9 ^ a$ 3 m 3 z 3 ° ^ t^v °^S^ u u o u u u°^ u o u o
J f^l N ry ^ O
>^ i.a 3 ai > O p. «¢ i^ m iy w q > m a W O 3 m ? Nw O ` p^ K y W 0` E W `1 ^ N N N ^ . V p N Q Q^ y ^ Ta T^ ^ '^ N > G C > = Q O^ X q .
d w ^ p=^q.o. L Na 6 C> ^ m>^w`[ a`m 0 'O c^° ^ pp 3 O^^a i o w `, m'°G C' O 00 ^ d E C 0^ N ^ N a U o t i^ in :c c a_oe « E^„"S E`v c m
LL w 6 O x V Z LL^G A 0.' 0 N Q Vl O ^ l7 S N W V^^ w tri O_ Y^ W u_ !ll U i- ^ a x 3^ 0 0 0 0 0 o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 p o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o LO o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 o Oo O D O O o o O O
N C ^ 3 6 c m a o ^ a o o ?^ m v ^ v c c c n^ 7- c y2 w^^ > m^ ~ co c o m` `^u N m p- y w o;^^p c c c E^ a° m c L o n v c T n -o 0 0^ m a^ v m ^_° Cm y V, a}i ¢ 1O Wm c^' v Q O^ o m Dy m`m o Um Um`x O= m J a W^L p> V T U 3 4^ m^ G^^^ Z N^ 0 Z 4- F7 V1 ^ ^ u S 4¢ ¢ g l°- t^ 0¢
«o«° ^ -a > z>w m°'ovco ° Z z -o= ,i 3pD^j >. mm a, ^v Am .c3 ai >3oo`.q s>j i ya ^^^ ^> 'o NLL c ^ v0`> ^v°i'S c^ m m°'^ d Z'^ Zp d E! O> N Q U a . x W a o^C ^ Y 4 O m O `' N 43 ^W a° a m d ^n ^ in 3 m a, c o x m ^.a'.. "' a- v_ C - ^a `^ Nu g m c._ EE y. c- > v•o- 3 u > R c m^*^ o o ^.o a W m W o`m ° o o- i 2 2 w v5 o m S 1O s m.c ^ a. 0i D ^^6 x z^ 3 D v^ ^i g Q w^ F- ^ d 4 u. 7 ^S U w^n LL U m m U U' ^ Oo l9 o a o 0 0 0 0 o P o 0 0 0 o P o a o 0 0 2 000000000000 4 O O 4 4 O 0700
s c v ^ C v ^= c w ar 0 o a^ w- m s^'^ s c `> o j E>w «'N w 'N c n 3 0^ y O^^ _ ai c> c a^ D y y a. E w^u O'° t m ro N p= j ai re d a^ O m m N
U N N a W o a m r . v c o vo Q
p` c a m ^ m y m C Z at o, 0 ca t^= N i ry i^+ C H K j] j (tl a` ^^ C L a 0 2 9^" d m K J s ^ P O^ i V^ 9 a^- ^
'O ^ G Ol ^ R m^ ^^ G D.8 L^ D v0 ^ O P Heather Mann
From: Ray DiRossi [raydirossiQgmail.comj Sent: Sunday. July 31, 2011 1:57 PM To: Benjamin Yoho Cc: Troy J.; Heather N. Mann - gmaY; Michael Lenzo Subject_ House Seats by Index... Attachments: House - seats by index.xls
Ben
Here is a document that I am using and thought you and others may want
Its all 99 house seats ranked according to our unified index on their current districts ironically there are 59 seats on the unified index that are 50% or better for republicans
We hold 6 of their seats that are indexed below 50%
They hold 6 of our 50%+ seats at least they do now......
Ray
EXHIBIT
g ^_ 74_06%j 72.63%; 1.es%; u-fs7b 69_01%1 67.19% 4.60%: 1.84% 68.23%' 64.96% 1.384/0; 1.41% 67.89%^ 64 28% 286% 1.88% ------66.00% 61.92%'_ ._.__. 7.97%,l 4.01% 65.33%: 67_.11%, 0_35%i 0.85% 65.00%j 62 31% 1.91% 0.96% 64.88% i _ 64.23%! 1.67% 0:92% r ... ---`--- 64.549'al 59.28% 3.24%I 1,68% 64.23%1 6183% 115%1 254% 64.16%1 64 96°^6f 156%1 0 94% 63.42% 63.60%, 0.60%-- -- 1._.._..'---0 59% _ 63.15%1 61.79%T 0.46%i 3.74% 61.66%60.94%1 3.30% 1.26% . __..--- 61.40% 60.23%' 0.81%, 0.88% 61.34%7 59.44% 057%0.78% .._.--- - 61.01% 57.90°/n 3.42% 1.85% 60.89%I _ 5957%I 11.07%, 1.92% 60.84% 60.40% 4.251yo! 109% 60.84%1 58.58%1, 8.84%1 4.38% 60.53%: 57.43%1 8.68%j 1.95% 60.15%f 59.08%1 7.66%! 1.27% 60.149'uI 57.79%s 533% 1.36% 5924%1 56.28%I 1.46%I 1.28% - ----.. -.._ , 59.13%'_ 59.76%1.58%^ 0.70% 59.03%1 53.75%: 4.18%! 4.06% 58.69%^ 55.61%13.73%1 1.18% 58.51% 55.39%, 2.24%j4.96% 0_97%1.86% 5$ 33% 55 97°0; 58 25%I 5141%8.20%l 1.71% 57 95%: 52 91%' 22.15% 1.41% 5716%', 53 59% 1.01% 5.33% - ---- = __ 5657%; -54.55%' 4.04Y°I 1.53% --- --^ - ---, _ 55 89%] 53 09% 1.22%1 1.29% - -{ - - __ _ : 55.71% 56.36% 6.32%^ 0.98% 55.49% 55.35% 0.89% 54.36% 54.15% 10.93%i 1.21% ^^-54.22%j 59.05%"^ ^1.27%0.63% 47.49%1 18.12%I 2.49% 53.63% 1 52_72°/d ... ^1.09% , 0.81% 53.42% 48.36% 1.41% 2.21% 53.30W 51.98% 2.95% 0.54% 52.949449.21%) 3:98%2.36% 52 88% 44 51% 4 45% 1.33% 52.61% 49 20%1 2 39%- .1.79% 52 58%^ - 49 76%1 3 08% 3.15% 52.05% 47.74% 2 40%; 5.39% 51.84%1 48.57% 2.42%1 1.13% _ 5148% 4835%1 2.68%1 193% 5121°i6, 4914%----- .._.-__315%, 1.03% ---- 51.19%i 45.60% 2 51%] 3.62% 96% 44 74%( 24 85°G 3.97% 28 (ConniePdlich-D-(2-016) 50. A3 97%^ 6 04%3.59% 22 lohnCarney-D-(2016) - _50 81% - ^-- - 3.97% 2.47% 57 Matt Lundy -D- (2014) 50.65%! 4710%' 50.54% 50.50%; 2.51%( 1.35% . _. . > ...__ . ^ ----- . .... 50.47%i _ 47.67%1 6.27%4 1.22% 50.44%, 47.13%t 8.36%1.06% - -- -- °-^^ -...---- . 50.32%1 53.05%',^ S.i6%, ----- 0.51% 50.23%' 42.94% 6.52%; 4.59%
49.59%' 49.75%1 1.45% 0.73% 48.38%` 52.78%1 2.41% 1 1.16% ^-- 48.27%j_- 46.82%1 10.54%1 2.61%_ 48.14%j 48.39%1 2.53% 0.81% 61 tMark0key-D-(2014) _ 47.95%T, 41.21%; 19.33%1 3.68% 20 1 NancyGadand-D-(2016) - 47.62W 39.69%' 20.68%1 5.92% 22% 2.62% 0.74% 47A6%'...... 53 ... - --- - 43.28% 5.73%1 2_86% ! 80^Dennis Murray -D- (2016) . _....__-, 45.68%'_ - 42.61%4.68% 1_23% 68 1 Kathleen Clyde -D- (2018) - -- , 4481% 42.90%i 3.54%, 2_389'° - ....,.___ .- _-. - I 36.22%; 33.17%1 3.10% 1 Demse Driehaus -D- (2016)_ _ 44.269'°': ------42.25%1 2.25%, 3.24% - 15 Tim_DeGeeter-D-(2012) 43.79% , ...... ,. __ _ -- - --. . _ 43.25% j _ _43.55%^ -2.31.00% 92 ) Debbie Phillips-D- (2016) ------25 iMiehael5tinziano-D-(2018) 42.27%{ 39.02%__ 12.04% 4.31% 4D.52%; 46.61% 4.14%j 0.75% 95 Lou Gentde-D-(2018) 38.74% 42.339'^ 3.77%1 1.89% 59 Ron Gerberry -D- (2016) ._ 38 03%^ 33.80%) 6.10%1 4.42% 49 !Matt Szollosi -D- (2014) gA,6 z; Ti%( 9.91%, 7.65% 14: Mike Foley-D- (2014) . __ . _-... ._. ^ - - . . _ - . 36 93%_.. 35.059.1 11.78%1 1.19% 45 12ach Milkovich -D- (2018) 36 41%^ 32.61%! 16.63%1 1.77% 52 (StephenSlesnick D-(2016) ^ 37.60%i 11.88%1.08% 64 , To m Letson -D- (2014)- 35.68% 35.23%1 29.120% 15.8796' 8.269' . 47 Teresa_Fedor-D-(2018) 32.48%36.75%, 3.98%0.99% 65 Sean O'Rrien -D- (2018) --32.47%,... -28.03%' 43.21%^, 1.58% 40 jRoland Winburn-D-(2016) 3i.17%1 26.75%1 13.76% 14.15 _ % 56 ;Dan Ramos-D-(2018) .,._,. . _.. ._.-...... -_-._.. . 31.16%; 25.03%! 13.46%^ 10.929'0 13 Nickie Antonia -D- (2018) _ 56%( 47 92%j 213% 33 Ahcia Reece-D-(2018) ^ J 28R19'o 22 48 25% 140% 7 Kenny Yuko -D- (2012) i 26 92% 2118% I 39% 1814%; 42.79% 2 43% I 32 Dale MaUorv -D- (2014) 25. 23 40%• 18.73% 44.31%+ 2 85% 39 1 CI_ayton Luckie -D (2014) _44 V_ernon Sykes -D- (2014) 2211%. 16.99%' 42.38%^ 2 32% 21 86%^ 16.48%1 50.37%1 4 05% ! - 26 ^Tracy Maxwell Heard -D- (2014) 14.45% 47.77%1 4 44% 48 j Michael Ashford -D- (2018) 20 27%' --- 19.62%f 14.45%, 53.15% 4.82% 11 ;Sandra Williams -D- (2014) _ 13 97%! 56.51%I 1549'0 ^ 8 !Armond Budish -D- (2014). 19 54%! 19 19%[ 20 04%i 31.48% 7 46% 60 RobertHagan-D-(2014),____ G 18 79% 13.63561 46.23% 12.80% 30 iBill Patmon -D- (2018) 18 7TYo 14.21%! 40.52%i 3 40% 27 '_Carlton Weddington -D- (2016) ------^ - 1779%i 12.56%' 52.82%^ 1-65% 9 IBarbara!__._.._ Boyd -D(2014) 12 John Barnes -D- (2018) 15.56%, 10.85%], 68.87%^ 113% Mann, Heather
From: [email protected] Sent: Thursday, August 04, 2011 2=11 PM To: Clint Morefield; Mann, Heather; [email protected] Cc- Jon Cook Subject: Re: Plotter
Clint hearing is We are at the actual hearing at 230 in senate finance_ We will be back at bunker later today. After the over.
Let's try and get it over there later today
Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry
From: Clint Morefield
EXHIBIT 510 t1 Gmail - Tuesday at redistricting office Page 1 of I
Ray DiRossl
Tuesday at redistricting office 7 message
Ray DiRossi 3s" https://mail.google.com/mail/?ui=2&ik=2cd7e552a7&view=pt&search=sent&th=131 d2d... 10/25/2011 Gmail - Re: Senator Manning update Page 1 of I Ray DiRossi Re: Senator Manning update I message Wed, Sep 21, 2011 at 1:29 PM Ray DiRossi ok.. FYI - i will have to keep it to less than 30 minutes Ray On Wed, Sep 21, 2011 at 1:23 PM, Vaughn Flasher From: Ray DiRossi FYI 1 am mee6ng with Senator Manning at the bunker at 3:30 p.m. today if Senate session is over Please join if you can... Ray 36 https://mail.googte_com/maiU?ui=2&ik=2cd7e5 52a7&view=pt&search=sent&th=1328cff... 10/25/2011 Page I of 3 Gmail - house seat in the 13th district house seat in the 13th district 4 messages Gayle Manning Hi Ray, I know they are iookir.g for Republicans in Lorain COunty for Boose and I had discussed with Matt there were some in Lorain - people that live there but their kids attend Amherst School District. I have the names of the street - listed below -if that would help. We walked there a couple of times - good response from the people. I believe Heather Mann is working on the House but I do not have her e-mail address. Deerfield Estates: Antler Crossing, Black walnut Trace, Buckhom Blvd., Buckskin Ln, Deer Valley trail, Doe Crossing, Fallow Way, Golden Rod Ln, Kyra Ln, Mantil Ln. Six Point LN, White Tail LN, Winter Foe Trail. Apple Orchard- Cooper Foster: Appleseed Dr., Baldwin Bivd, Bayberry Rd, Belmont Dr, Oberlin to Broadway, Rte 58 to Linn North Side, Dannie Dr., Debra Dr., Dorwood Dr., Fiesta Ct, Lemonwood Ct, Orchard Hill Blvd., Jaeger Rd.: Blush Dr, Camden Bivd, Courtyard Dr, Crossing Trail, Fields Way, Meadow Way, Quincy Adams Ct, Randolph, Salem Cr. Camden Ridge: Jenee Dr, Kingsbury Ct, Rosemount Ct, Santina Way, Viewcrest, Yorktown Ct, Pill Hill: Greenbriar Ln, Hiilgrove Dr, Laura Ln, Longbrook Rd, Marlboro Ave, Normandy Dr, Rosecliff Dr, S. Park Dr, Yorktown Rd. Oak Point Rd.: Colony Ct, Eagle's Nest Dr, Fox Run, Hidden Creek Dr, Mallard Creek, Manhatten Dr, Mayflowerbr, Oak Point Estates, Oak Tree Dr, Providence Ct, Roe Ln, Squirrel Nest Dr, Staghorn Ln, Velvet Horn Williamsburg: Duxbury PI, Emerald Dr, Gargasz Dr, Gettysburg Dr, Glouchester Dr, Independence Dr, Jamestown PI, Nantucket Dr, Urban Cir, Narranggnsett Bive, revere PI, Seven Pines Dr, Timberview Dr Kolbe Rd: Oakcrest Dr, Oakhill Blvd, Spalding Ct N. Pointe Pkwy-Cooper Foster: Belifower Dr, Boxwood Dr Middte Ridge (east of 58), Old Lake Rd, Park Square Dr, Plymouth Dr, reserve Cr, W. Erie to Beaver Creek, Oakhills, Beavercrest Dr, Hidden Creek I hope this helps. i am sure that matt spoke to you about splitting North Ridgeville. Feel free to call anytime. Thanks, Gayle Ray DiRossi Senator Thanks for sending I know you put a lot of tfine into this Very helpful I am continuing to work on this issue.. Ray iQuoled text hiddeni Ray DiRossi https: //mai l. google.comlmaiU?ui=2&ik=2cd7e552a7&vievv=pt&search=sent&th=13273d... 10/2 5/201 I t'i1g0 I nI 1 Vmt11i - (ri0 subJCCtj Ray DHtossi (no subject) 1 message Thu, Aug 78, 2011 at 5:47 PM Rav DiRossi ^ 2011-08 Regional Hearings Script.docx ^ 20K EXHIBIT 0 hrtpsahnail.google.com/ntYti tl7ui =2& i k=2cd7e552a7&view=pt&search=sent& th- 13 1 ded... 16f251201 I APYORTIONMENT BOARD REGIONAL FIEARiNGS SCRIPT 1. Call to Order &[ntrodnction of Panel SECRETARY: We now call to order the [name lacationj regional hearing of the Ohio Apportionment Board. As people arrive who would like to testify, we would ask that you please fill out a witness slip on the table and provide them to the Lisa or Kyle [indicate .staf,}]• 'I'he 2011 Appottionment Board, which is responsible for drawing districts for the Ohio Senate and the Ohio House of Kepresentatives, held its initial meeting on August 4, 2011 _ At the meeting, the Board adopted rides which require a series of public hearings throughout the state to gather public input and comment and appointed [Heather,b/anniRay DiRossi] and I as Joint Secretaries of the Board. Seeing that the Vice Chair of the Apportionment Board (State Auditor Dave Yost) is here with us today - I will ask if Auditor Yost wonld preside over this regional hearing. [Hands gavel to Auditor] H. Opening Statement ^ AUAITOR YOST: Thank you. Will the Secretary please call the mll, and during this attendance roll call would each member please state their name and which office they represent, if they are present as a designee. [Secretary calls the roll] We wonld first like to thank [univer-sity name and contact.sj for hosting us today, as well as Lisa Griffin who coordiuated arrangements for these hearings. I would like to -emind everyone that the purpose of the hearing is to gather inforniation. cotnnients, and input regarding the upcoming reconfiguration of the House and Senate district lities. T7te Apportionment Board and tlie panel before you is not responsible for re-drawing Ohio's congressional districts. New congressional districts will be established by the state tegislature as a bill that will be voted upon by the members of tlte Ohio House of Representatives and the Oitio Senate. Tltat bill then wordd have to be signed or vetocs b,v the Governor. We would ask all of the witnesses limit their comments and testimony to the matter before the Apportionment Board-that being the Ohio fiouse and Ohio Senate districts. 1 We're here to listen today. We're not here to debate you; we're not here to debate one another. We're here to get input from Ohioans on the apportionment process and how it impacts your communities and your representation in the Ohio General Assembly. 1'oclay - vve have a limited amount of time for the hearing (if applicahle -- we are crlso schedaded to have a hecn•ing later todav in (iruert location), and we want to give ever}rone a liall opportunitv to offer their input. We are scheduled here for iwo hours, and we may ask witnesses to limit their testimony in the interest of tinie and out of courtesy for other persons who wish to address the panel. In Ohio, as in most states, legislative reapportionment occurs in the years ending in "1", which are also tlie years in which the federal census figures are released by the U.S. Department of Comanerce. T'he censtts Ggures released this year indicate that Ohio has a population of 11,536,504 people. 7'hat means that ideally each of the 99 House districts should contain 116,530 people, and each of the 33 Senate districts should contain 349,590 peopte. Anyone who has researched, or uadertaken the actually drawing of legislative districts, knows that this process involves far more than somebody putting roughly the sante number of people in each district- In Ohio. the General Assemblv districts must conform to traditional redistricting principles and other requirements that are embodied in Article XI of the Ohio Constitution. Article XI contains specific rules governing the cottstruction of these districts, incltiding severat lay'ers of sometimes complex requirements. In addition to the Ohio Constitution; the Board niust also comply with all applicable federal Eaws, ntost notably the Voting Rights Act. Because these hearings are being held for the purpose of receiving your input in the process, we are not going to go over the details of the law. However, copies of Article XI of the Ohio Constitution, as well as other information such as population eha.nges, the apportionment process, and how the public may submit plans are available for you at the table. We encourage vou to pick these up and review them as they are the same guidelines the board has to follow as it draws legislative districts. A iaw other items before we begin: these proceedings witl be transcribed by a court reporter so that the Board in its deliberations may consider things that are said here today - so please speak clearly and loud enough for the panel and the audience members and our court reporter to hear. If vou have written testimony, please submit it to our staff so that it nray be included in the ofticial record of the proceeding. We will make sure that all testimony received at the hearing is I available on the Secretary of State's website at www.reshaneohio.ora. As the Secretary; Secretary's designee is here wiilt us today, I would ask for a brief overview of the website at this time. ------ I11. Witnesses _ _ ..------°_--_-_------__--- --^ ------^ Ai1Dt'I'OR: We will now beLin with our fit^st witness here today, Mr.tT9rs, i name l . Please state I _. __°____.------ 2 rautl spell }rour name for ttte record. [Ifitness offersdestimony] AUDI'r(1R: "I'hank you for yoar testintoaiy. Are there atty questions for the witness? Secing none, I will now call Mr./Mrs. [nameJ to offer testimony. [41'itne.rs ofl'ers testirnony, etc.] IV. Adjourn ALIDIOR: Are there any other witnesses present to offer testimony? Seeing none, is there any further business to comc befott this regional h€aring of the 2011 lpportionment Board? If not. we stand adjourned until our next regional hearinx at fitime, dale. foccdion]. Heather Mann ,,- ^^" From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent: Saturday, August 20, 2011 8:07 PM To: 'Schuler, Matt' Cc: 'Troy Judy; 'Matthew T. Schuler'; 'raydirossi@gmai!.com' Subject: RE: Meetings Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Great! Troy is as well. I've blocked off both days in case we don't get through everything on Saturday O Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 [email protected] From: Schuler, Matt fmai!to:Matt.Schu!erCa)senate.state.oh.usl Sent: Saturday, August 20, 2011 7:53 PM To: Heather Mann Cc: Troy Judy; Matthew T. Schuler; ravdirossiCalomai!.com Subject: Re: Meetings i can be available both days. On Aug 20, 2011, at 11:24 AM, "Heather Mann" Dear Matt and Troy: Ray and I would like to set up a "decision tree" and timeframe within to get specific direction on the various plans and options upon which we have worked. Each of you have had an initial walk-through on mostly the same areas, but we would like to reserve several hours of your time to jointly lay out the options with the other areas of the state and review slight modifications we have been making based on feedback. Based on these meetings, we can generate a list of decision points upon which we need further direction in order to move forward. Trying to get the four of us during the work week will become increasingly difficult. Therefore, would either or both oY tl3e foliowing tiines wn rk for you • Saturday, August 27`h - lOAM to 2PM • Sunday, August 28th - lOAM to 2PM EXHIBIT 3 Also, we would like to know how you envision getting feedback from Speaker Batchelder and President Niehaus. Do you see us doing further presentations to them jointly, relaying through you to them the need/information on final decisions, or a combination on both? In either event, should we calendar some times for meetings with them? Thank you, Heather & Ray *m• Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 [email protected] 4 Heather Mann From: Chad Hawley [[email protected][ Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2011 3d)7 PM [email protected] Subject: Re: Fwd: On behalf of TROY.JUDY aQOHR.STATE.OH.US: My Ohio House Districtsfrom Empty PIan1 nope On Tue, Aug 23, 2011 at 2:49 PM, Heather Mann From: Chad Hawley Heather, Homework assignment. Find what to do with the exeess part of Medina County, Thank you, chad -°------Forwarded message ------From: 0 % aae ag ag_ ag * cast p^ pres pres pres ag_ ag ag_ a^ cong cong cang cong gov gov gov gov d rep r ^^ 08 m08 de r08 -rep d 08 dem 08 rep d 08 -dem -r08 rep cast d de p_rpe m08 08 08 08 08 08 m m em ep e .1 2,46 1,79 ^ 1,86 47 1,75 45. 1'79 5,71 2,64 .2 2186 43.1 3 90 46. 46 50. 1 1'43 33.7 2 720 5 0,60 5,83 04 3,26 6'43 g6,13 2 4^550.95 4,55 6 5,05 2 0,88 47.59 6,75 77 03 7'39 08 8,370 1 2 4 6 1 1 4 1 1 3 36. 24,0 53. 1 61 ,4 27,03 33,3 54.2 25,9 42.2 25,5 41.6 31,37 24,9 40.5 45,1 16,2 35. 25,9 57. 16,2 4C00 5 51 .06 6 09 16 95 19 46 84 10 17 24 6 47 7 57 9 60 5 80 3 24 EXHIBIT / . W Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2011 6:27 AM To: 'Chad HaMey My Ohio House Districts from Empty Subject: RE: On behalf of [email protected]: Plani Who did this? Troy already knows that there are only two ways to draw Medina_ Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heat hernman n(ftma il. com From: Chad Hawley rmailto•chad hawlev(ionmall.mml Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 20112:45 PM To: Heather Mann My Ohio House Districts from Finpty PIan1 Subject: Fwd; On behalf of TR0v 7UDY@OHR STATE.OH.US: Heather, Homework assignment. Find what to do with the excess part of Medina County. Thank you, chad --- Forwarded message ------From: Error! Filename not specified. ® 1 % %r^ a % a cong cottg g gov ag_ v cong gov ag ag ag ast res em -re re de d rep _r -Ae S p d S dem r$ 08 d 08 r08 ^08 cast _d^ -dm ^ c 08 m08 Pde p r^ d p n' em ep mos 08 08 e .1 3,90 1,79 1,86 1,75 1,74 8 571 2 912 2,64 2186 1,93 2,46 39 46. 46.2 5,05 501 0,88 33.7 2,720 47.59 6,75 43.1 0,60 5,83 46 3,26 47" 6,43 45 7, 7 6,13 415 50.95 4,55 6 6 2 1 8370 1 5 4 1 04 1 77 3 03 1 08 2 4 57. 16,2 36. 24,0 53. 54.2 25,9 42.2 25,5 41.6 31,37 51.06 24,9 40.5 45,1 16,2 35. 25,9 1 61,4 27,03 44.00 33,3 6 09 16 95 19 46 84 10 17 24 6 47 7 57 9 60 5 80 3 5 24 3 ^ + pres pres agL ag cong cong gov 8 cast de pres rep pr^ g°^,e gov ^ ag ag` ag _ dem ag- rep ag- dem cOng rep eong cast de gov 08 m48 _dc - Q8 rep 08 dem . rep- 08 -dem - 08 rep -m de - re d rep r e m08 08 08 08 08 08 m Pp D1 em ep- ,1 4 Heather Mann From: Chad Hawley [[email protected]] Sent Wednesday, August 24, 2017 6:27 AM To: . Heather Mann Subject: Re: On behalf [email protected]: My Ohio House Districts from Empty Plani Troy and 1. On Aug 24, 2011, at 6:26 AM, Heather Mann Who did this? Troy already knows that there are only two ways to draw Medina. RYk Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt_ B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernman nCdamail.cam From: Chad Hawley (mailto:chad hawley(aomail Coml Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2011 2:45 PM To: Heather Mann Subject: Fwd: On behalf of TROY 7UDY nOHRo STATE OH US: My Ohio House Distrjcts from Empty Planl Heather, Homework assignment. Find what to do with the excess part of Medina County. 'Phank you, 5 1 EXHIBIT ^ 'll chad ------Forwarded message ------From: Error! Fiiename not specitied. % g [1 % % ag- colig gov p 8+ cast pres pres ^^ pres ae^ ag ag ae cong c^^p cong cast d e gde g - 0$ rep p- mre g dre adrep ae- I Al1 08 de _de OB _Yep 08 dem 08 rep - 08 -dem pt m08 m08 08 08 08 08 08 m p em ^ he rJ 5 571 2,64 2,86 1,93 2,46 43.1 3,901,79 1,86 1,75 1,79 2.8 2,912 462 SO.I 33.7 2 720 46113 50.95 4,55 5,05 0,88 47.59 6,75 0,60 5,83 404 3,26 47 6,43 03 7,39 9 7 2,415 4 6 6 2 1 8,370 1 5 4 1 I 3 1 35. 25,9 57. 16,2 36. 24,0 9 1.1 61,4 27,03 4400 33,3 54.2 25,9 42.2 25,5 41.6 31,37 51.06 24,9 40.5 45,1 16,2 7 6 47 7 57 9 60 5 80 3 5 24 6 09 16 95 19 46 84 10 17 6 Heather Mann From: raydirossi@gmai!.com Sent: Monday, August 29, 2011 11:36 PM To: Heather Mann Subject: Re: Meeting with Ray & Heather Are we going through it all again? I did it with vaughn in 36 minutes.------Original Message------From: Heather Mann To: Ray DiRossi Rep].yTo: Heather Mann Subject: Re: Meeting with Ray & Heather Sent: Aug 29, 2011 11:34 PM Don't text and drive. Look how long it took to go through this stuff with the chiefs! ------original Message------From: Ray DiRossi To: Heather Noelle Mann ReplyTo: Ray DiRossi Subject: Re: Meeting with Ray & Heather Sent: Aug 29, 2011 11:32 PM 3 hours??? Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry -----Driginal Message----- From: "Heather Mann" Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry EXHIBIT 3 11 22- Gmail - Weekly Redistricting Meeting Page 1 of 1 Ray DiRossi Weekly Redistricting Meeting 1 message Mann, Heather EXHIBIT https:!/mail.google.com/mail/?ui=2&ik=2cd7e552a7&vie^r-pt&cat=Redistricting%20Em... 10/14/2011 tZ Gmail - F W :12-0901-0130-map0.pdf Page 1 of I FW: 12-0901-0130-map0.pdf 2 messages Sep 1, 2011 at 4:42 PM Heather Mann FYI, attached is one of the displays that Mark Braden wants to show the principals in the meeting tomorrow. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, 4pt- B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmann(rDamail com From: Braden, E. Mark [mailto:MBraden(a2bakerlaw.coml Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2011 3:16 PM To: Nuven, Rosemarie Cc: 'Heather Mann' Subject: FW: 12-0901-0130-map0.pdf can you print in colorforrne -„) 12-0901-0130-mapD.pdf 618K Ray DiRossi this is exactly what i said I DIDNT want to do not the content but external maps iQuoted lexl hidden) EXHIBIT tiq 27 https://niail.google.com/mail/?ui=2&ik=2cd7e552a7&viev.=pt&search=sent&th=13226b... 10/25/2011 » ro °= Qf° n £ N . ^ ^ N ^ J O T T `n L W W D J W w N O^ W ^] N N v ^ Gc N ao ^n Q b O W W O^ 01 ^D O M ^> U O^ T T C C G C ./ N b^C:n 1i .G. w io w w w W N ^ a n u o w w w EXHIBIT gxnm ao^ ry N ^ W N N J ^ P -- A U W W W A O+ a J w A W C N N N Oc w N GO ^E W .. R W A ^! N 0 o c r r r °_°^`^ ^c."wau °^^Aw vwi O w,p T^A 0 0 0 " -n -n rrr a q°i^° n aTaa 9fa a Dla^^ a D>a aia aaaapaaaaaaaaa>raa a. q q a;a^l^a^ ^ aisl^f^ a q q q Fi' a! N N;N'N ql nln po n n ninp nln, n r nnnnln c c c °^,°cIG'c°lo F CIO^ O^COO92 C° 2,C•z'^°^ olco'DC,° ° F04C C G' q E O ^ 0 6 q ^p q 3^3 y q a° o 0 0.5'S 5.0 5 a^ -FS = V f 7•2^<2 I•2•2 ^2',^.2..7-7.2,^.2 7.?'2.2ti7^2R2 .^t E ^m^-'^c>O.'.?.^s' ^n f.^•--ro ^ O7?7M m 3 (> O Q^."^nI }s'' ^^ I ^ •^^. Y'^.^ o °s 7 0 °^ Q H ^ O° 0g o y 411^.a c°,Z-^^3 q.-µ,_^ o'a''^ 5_'^.a -I I^ p N; ^ . q '6'.•6^A ^° '6aA ^'6 _Si^A^'O ^!'O fwry:fc ^ .^ ^^^ A j ^ b' a'^ J 6 n0 H 0 oi y' . GC W•VJ t Ap^J wIN R Li^IJI R J W N^^X' -^ W R d) O•D ^•^I^^tJ^Y O IJ .D l O•- N J•:41'^ G1 OIA .l ^,iN^ J W ta,. ^D Vi NIs.',GC O OIR.R Oo.^^^o O O - S L IJ W U;^1 140 A OIJ O-'`D^R cn N" n ^^- OIRI + -I- n m SJ NL- R Wy^R p^ W^p [ J IJ N O O:O --1IR O W^^^W O O.N W ^ y.J.p A AUIW^+iIONO NIt AIOIP 66 .I 3i N ^lVp ^.O'L1'GC O F w•^ w >.,t w O w J_O;T `J N w.NlO. '+, .^„°` . LI JI _^^-A L C1 N.OO!WIN N.1.3. W I".^.. -° .. '. . a,^D J bIGC ^O a. ^c .o ^o ^^q ^o .o^.^lvJl^° b^^i^ ^ w^^a ^ ^ a^ol^lrn a ^•^^ b 9p J J tn J R R.•O I OO 00 ^I ° U O G^0 W y'!b Wp MIW W J N'v'J R L. u tT W L-.^J 'h ^ IJI`..h''R G^ ^.W t.N ^O.IJR IJv^ > O, p N CO O Gp -,JO A AIJIV O A R J i'-..R 3• O oIWI p R \\ ^1 GC w V,' o ^.J A w O` K e \ \ \.'e_e \ c',o`^\ e .- A^ ^l t N'h •-` O N .> - O tJ.lAi.^lOlb Op iJ.N^IRI^ - W W^^6^tn O^A'b ^D:w^.W:--1 .•A O O O O O O'^.C^O^.,O o 0 O OO O:O 010,0-0 O O O -^V,'O:O10^^0 W^O GO O - N O '.UI LJ,O -IJ- O O 3, ^--^^ O-w O O: V.. N 0^ ^1 OIp -I^J^A la A' .,.('i w - O PNa10 '.Rl•^^'.P:R A - 06 OC l'^° O o .e te e a,e o o^a\^> ^_...... o co a IC ^^'\-1 t > - . _ I O`. IJIhJ V.IJO.'+!'-!A 0 O 41-'^o^-•'N,OO^O-0i.. -.y. . O O O^O O-.C,O O.O'O;O O O.O o^.C:oi3 O^O'O^C O^O;O O N rnO O^O OO^O^O^O O O J O^- -.O O- O^:O o O-•-.O O^ 'oI PJ O NIO I`J N IJn ^D AN ^ J•lo u'^-O ^IIL^+iJ 0 .O ^-'C R o.^^0 O^o^ et-.v, oc Cc w gi1+ ^:,i.Ji oc alA^^^'^ e \ e ^o Ie \ \^ °.^i ^c..c o ...... ^.. i 1 . 1' . c, A - iW m;x vi:u ^D:N A •c W -I ^O^P31J^ ^l^l..I^ N OiiJ_ A .J `DI"^, ^tJ•£.e.tJ.3 -'O^V. W O U'fN O'O O s.W'.`DiJ'w to 0 0 0 0p o o. --^ - c^ aoif O _ ^ ^ ^ N IN b O^ O^' IJ.^ w .N.O'J R N W 1.10 J• L^ JiW-OI^ R lJ.L. e O O O^ lA i ^l G1 P t+.O Ri-• O : no tJ a \''..\.\ \ \. G I`C\ \ C ^ ^ 0`IO O O ,, b o ,a o` c o o a^o.:o 0 0 ^_ o :D ' a a a a'>'Y 2:;a'nk a a a Y^y ^ a.a Y`DIY.N.^ >> YI^yI.w a IN'N N.N N s'rs ^ y c'1.>^.-a s^ ^. :'^ 1-,1•') ( c.^ s^-Is , S ^'^^is _s s, .^ _ ^ m m m n r 3 c a ^^nnn,n^nn;rn^n L 6 d C:C 6 C C.C G. G. ¢.,C d C CiC CIC C.C CCP.C Rc O o o O,OIO^C o O i;J nnnln'nnnnnnnnnnn^n^nn^^nnn^nnno olo c olo;o o:c o a,o c o o'oo 0 0 00G 0 C 0 C 0;0 C" CIC C:c IC.C F-G GIc c Es ` ^'31 ^ '^' o .o ^. a-oF o n:7 ° 5^' ^ y o o: .?^:5 ;-7 ^ '_.? ;4 J ^ i+e ^3 7 .'^ i3 :^2 .7 7 s,2 ' ^ j.e (•< ti -v '3. 2 ^2 ^^ ^. 9u .^,d3.i --1 .<-+nq- - 5'io<.-'.n:5 ^ n^jaI a.;7 ^Io' ^.f:^'ov. t,g•^''''1 . w1 ." , j 'o°.' ^`^=od- 1-y ^^ ^. 3 vivj 1" , rrd-I . i ^^m . . . ^ , .. . ^. I ,^^ . ^ . ^. . .. ,..IIJ thl .. ^ ....__ ... •.. 4,itO L J^V.G 'T N^J `-N N NjW!l. ^6• ' W NJA -N.O W NN pa ^W,^•O .O'JJ O'w OC!IJ.•O:W s'h"U Q. NIN O> T W W-0o0. ^ A JiU VC .- U N)4. 4) ^V, J Q' I,'UJ,L 0 O J c0 ,..^^ G^v^.O W J-^ 'h^G] P C< tJ.U^N W^J.+n O T i O C O O^- O O O'.C O C O O G OOO C.O O ° .O O^ IO>Ci0i0^0 O.O N W `W O{a ^t N^ I^L`,N 'fJ O. O N O •-- IJ N V ^ tJ OitJ N iO a-• N a^ ,[o' w i w 1. rn I a O PaJ d O^._ t. C N^Q O C J^'a ^^ e'P^ eP ,c o .o e o °. \ \ \ o I^ ^. ^fp; . _. ,. . . __ ^. ._ h c.o- ° 9 c 'c o o- o o o lojc -- o o^+^ola P.N b . % O 1' u-NN w W IJ..O. [h O^ T 1> A O^ ^! V u' o t'^ \_O ^IO o A +1al : ^ a,^^VI.h A v7 °.O a, 1 >!> >q DY y^Y:y >»njy yIL ssss' sf 1^s s^sslsl^la!_ss^. ssc i sss:ss^+ E c w 6-'5 S'i c m c^5'+ n w m'^ w r1 w E yrwl^,1^ w m C G G . C.IG I C G I G ^ C C C', C I C S C. ^ l a G P GiC IP i GIG I ^ G`CGICIG CC G I P .pfiJiw^w^5P`1n CIN w wIW C.w w IG w.C C6 E. IC ta^^'-i9.^JiCIiW w Y1.1f^` n ^} n'n n n r,.n'n n n n n•:n n n!n n nln nn n no n n^c) nnin I^In C G'.tI^IOICI C° C I°e ..G C°° L C C-C C CIC'°iCIC ° y^:7G^ aa'a'^I^^ i G^.^3> >'>> >ay M ^ ^ < t < ^c ^2 . . , €. ? 1^2 ^2 2 , 2 ^< I,e f < •1 ^e ^^ Q ^2 ..c ^ e I't `g ^'? 1•^ h• ^. i f ^ o i I I .-r .n v v^.'dtvlv p'ZI^ r T^, ISfS c C^^^'^ O,.n'nIn Dl„ D,n 2 no a^y ^I^i^ir^-^^ m.'c•°!nhe rvI31oR n' oIo G: £ ^'a.;c^`o ^•^' e I.-io!G,^ lo :Y•t rv.yf lo.°'^ra "'^#- FE °o <^1^ In _7I^ ,^!^I fnl^^ol i^"^'ro^qfs ^pYro OVI^;olnr,ytta;.n n ^s n ^lo i^^y ?I o fo l^I y l A lo' $ i s ^ ^l^ o o ..I a ! 0 ^ ^s.F ',,^ o `6^.. ^3 oc v ^I ^-? -o .o°oI a Z '. t w .. ro' p,) ^ I V^ ^' . IJ : ^J ' 1J . O I IJ I y Ls:.LIJ'W v. 6+IC m:'Vlm ^ni.Dr.`b • pC UIOIPIP A P GC.GG b V' IJ ^!D _•r po.lhi0^ U "D .D'AiA:A -0 V^'^D.LIUI W A!.-'N AI`-irA'4I C L U.. W Oo 0o OiL) P O ..-',O.P P^ J^,J c0 PiQ`I- L UIJ ^IW ^'O'A-V^I'J.an C +q ^`O WIJ tC -41C ! ., I. 1 < A N OC C:IQJ. ' J1 1Jp ^ `^ :. J J ^ r ^ !L_ y^^ ^ O ^ ^O V L^ j^i IT I C^P r.Cp l d P N'4i T^ +^l^.w U^^^.t1^:4^^^.].J 0^0 J GC^ J J:J A s b'^C. .^ G A^`^DJ:^I;^^+^1 SD` tOir P PoIT V P ^ y W tPi. m ^ v' C_ . b i.AO W .O +wl +I T 'IJ^.oPO C oc ^:.C[^ ^ I. . . ^ . . . . ., o n i\I:c°. }.in I I ^ W y ^` J tA NI ._.L IJ ^iW-^ IJ IJ L' L.-N P ' Q A a v^ fC COly_b w l. IJ-^ C c ^^II^+^^ D^^^ tJ `WO iJIC1 vfOia` 01 J^-^^-] Q JIW"An_O^ O` ^D_OIQ I„J`OI^ N .C ICi1J^0 I r O CIOIOC O lJ,+f Q^I)c ^ O^' ^D !-..1' ^6 J J W'^DIIJ .D P'P J'tJ J ^ J10_ o. V y) W..y^j- V^^ P^J. N J V..IJ .nIC va - p^ A tn oo1V^ '^ A.tn - lo^ (\ ' a o e o^ 2` \ c o 17^ o \ \ o ^" Aie ^fo i e. --{- f-I I 1 t ^I ^ ' ^ 0 a I fJO . - W V C W_:IJI9o u I A60'-T GiUlrn .Z A.U LI'+ 1, ^ - IJ^L JaJly J I _^ iJ^IJ 1 ^ I I I^ '.^ I c c- o ooC C c o^o.c o c o-.o c c;clo C C'CICI^C O C C ^^^ O O O10 N y t^l l W'i IJ G IJ 4 I^l I I I A' V^ J V . ^n P. U.. CO 3 ^.1 W' Ce. P J tJ N^l J Ce` t`^. Y`G O_ . . ° I `^f . . . _._ _ ^_°^ . VL^O•(o 'e ^^lo .A ^!e_ a o*^'B__o I -_ ' r A f I I i i1J PW ^:w ^ q¢C ^ J ^.^ C J O,A.OCf9o IJJ- ^ -IJ.mfan P A tJ b'V ^ IJ P IJIIJ.J c. C:rh''tn C P :^AI ^ O Q'.^I •- O C O OI f0 J O.C O O Oo v p. A ^ 4).N J O. J'^N C.Ov C 0o tJ ^W J^. j J C lm A J^ 0!W .O C O^tn A V C_ ^(j tb Q..J V. 0 J C.A . "\:e L tO U a e o n`16^-e e le p- .p 1C o ^'0 7 - r,a^a a:aia a a;a > a>:a!^ r.a:a alay > a.v a'a > a a;^ a a:>ly > > > N a ^'s' W '^'.r *'r l ^-B-a -"i !ai-^,r sry '^s^p : pp;-- s s _sy s ^ '. c c s ^i4 s^-rsCv s;sia' s -"s ^s.' . o 1 Nit0 'n Ii i^ NI^ N ^. O' S I ^ ^ 'J n I^ y N ya ^ N N N ^ . Ni C C i CIC C S N me j. qj' V'. '1.:, 0 , 0 ; o olo.o 0 0 oI?,Io. o o:o °.o 0 0l00 c 01010 0 0; = A n n n n = . g 7;9'9 r 5!9 § y " ^2 I.^ ,.7 .e ..2 ^7 .2 nr G c .7 'n< .^ v .^ :.7 .t < :a^ ,.^ r 7 ^•< ,'2 O . 2 r1 :^2 yJ^i9^oi'^' n i, 427^.na'noi?',CPa r "rs w ro;^l N n c w.ro .cy rik' °, ^ °- <. ^ .i} ro^m r G ^ '^ .N f ^ R ,..y'a'ml jo ' -t Tb ^..i U.^^ ro i^, ^''^ 3< Y I ^ ! . ^ , i. A. ^. N w^^ '^ ^ { '^l {I JIN N A'- "lJ.t .W -. 'O -• IJ ^ ^ GGIp OIm ^ ;. ^ IJ !J P J^ NW W^ I!.O ^ I ^ J I ^ I P.p W ^ AImI P I N d'. mCJ ^l >(^`I o O :. J P^.^ rID I I t p}a ^ L^CIw Ni' m.N I 4 V'6 w^A C N ^ V A!WV^ O rn N- Oa, ^Iw - w'02- !+'^''.m ^l N N w 4 `.I w.^ •O O rn C` m P'GO W m h N-^9' i^M P'. Uim w'iAIN J:IJ:p^ O Nm W W - rh N +a-A ^.1 4 0^ P^l N O^° U ^O P w bY P'P i A ; U ' - ^ 0 ,^- . . OC'O..^C n ^CiO w. 0 , 0^^1-J'A m.N . . ^ . - ^•_- _ - -_ '. n m^G W ^ •Db ^°Ir° •° ^O p ^O^rp^D^•G 'V V' 4 W L ^ ^D ^ m '.°^.DI^O al>C m ^° 2 v^ ^C .D "^i .° ' C3+ ^° P m A P `J N P '°l I J J m^F JP m P' ^-1 P Oo P Oo W tn ^1 J ^ U' O. ^-3 A ^ O' ^ 8 • m1A ^O -I oo m ->O U w ^^ IN P+-1K' L O L m:^G O-P L4 l P O P w a Vm P m..aa A O'^{y O ,'. o¢ OoIJ P P.Q:be ` \.e ,.c ol^j^.^^ e'\^tJ ^ a. % ^ a^ ^ { ^y C >.. i . ( s , . I 1 ^ ^ . • 1 1 . . . ^O J m ro"V t.l mJ w"^P A d m ' m NIC1^ lw R ^. IJ"^D Jr I V lr ^ - ^ J t^-l ^6' 4 v ^ { C Z ' 1J ^ 0 O^t^.w t. v ^ O C O A w OI,J O CO AOC O >^ w-' ^ h, 0 Wip>^OIIJ O O O t- O 1 0 N1J'O + b ^ N Oo.twir pA. A „ ^ W W P w ^iC O^ S ONt) r P IJ A^Q^?^. t^ ^O s. e^Vr-N N^m.i vni b^G m`U W ^ ^ ^: v o e o lo e! , ^ ^eo l I A A Wf W O O(W O;AIO.•s N P •° w W.W.N w v^^P-,h mOI^^^OI C ^l ^ ^ i L ^ G ^ - N C^N o O^l O ^ I I ! i ^ 1 Nj0!Oi0 O^O ^^ O O O C O O,O OIOIO^O O P L O O O O Od O C^C O O Oi h Q,b O ^ l W O ; A ^n I N O! O IJ A P Ni^ w OIO OiQJ N O10 O^l .C^r Oe O Jr N^L t ^ N ^ w:N I IJ \ O A O I yl. 6- O g 8 W\ P\^^^a O o ii ^^ c ao e. me.l e-. :-. e " .` ^ VN i^' I ^ w•d - Ni . m.-^.N O' -- A w A O; i mim:y'N NI--^^m tJ WN!^ ^T ^. P T 9 _ t . W.._ S P.A,,h.,A ^.l O.l P 41i0 tn ^ C IA^mI°^:O.F^ ^ ._. ; , I I . . i ^ ^ 10 O O ^'w ^. O OIOO N iJ - C OO^ O N- C w p •- O O N.0 N. .° o N J Wm , N O^ _l J N N,PIOOi N V• ^ tn C,^!O P.'^1106 ap 00 p i w . C y J^ o O O WIO. V] Ca. o 7 Ie o P c I xa•o . e Ie e!e ' > 'CO U11 b7 W 6W CO.. W U7 QI W I G1 W (> f+^N (D n in n N^ f^ m m rv N. 3 Y1^ 9 '3 ^ 33 3 lca o..o 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 f5^h Ct !^ f)^h CJ n-:(l c^ (A ^) n 1^.7 ^I^^? n J N N sD a.s W.^b Wov^ G po:N N CI cnI^^CIWI^I.P J d'^O.J^ N CIW 'sT.v7.4NN^^ A '.p^I Vi ^D ^D v7 m O (+. ^ I W ^O ^O ^D ilC P J GG J P V' W Vt ^l ^l J .F^o C^ i0 N GJ O.C V7P:CT ^ .cc tn - F C T W U N \'v O^N-.O O .C' IO 4J I ^ ICy-^ !C. `D ^° N Oc W.C P P-OION N O A' .O C -J ^ T C \ N CO W ^ OIPI V ^ Wt IJC V y GO W iJ V^ . by--) Va-Cit- ^O O O' I\ 9 \^C 1i6 I^. ^e \ O e t•,q WW:'W^q W q-W^,W b qq WW W W qW W W q'.W W Wtq:. h W.IE l9 N ft([..rv R R-r.^f4'r.h,f0 ^ IGd q q q.Wiqq WIW^yWlq;q O:rt h=.h.Nh N ^ NN •_ o O O oo O O OO C O O I4 O O Oa I O o OOO O O O O^ y 3 ^ ,I'S J ^ - Y - F OiO.C ^IC O OiDIC'O C) o'^n ^1i^!nl^nnn^.'nnnn nnn`) rnn r` rs ^ ^..o^ q ^ ^ ^.,^.a '1-^.7v x7^Z ^ < 7 r2 `<^;^i•` v .t •7 ':.7 ^ 7 ^e •< ;•2 •7 . v .^e ^t ^ 7 4 v t •2 ^^ s7 r',' .^ cr ^ s:^' o ^z ^^{' r x^n ^n -n W q,W q WIW'q{•GI.• ^ w n fl s^n 7'^ < a vo:nl^ l,y a ru r^ <^^' < ^.o I ^ < < ,^ < ft ftl hl ^ ^ C 4 Y a•':.JLIC J W:^D:wI .'^D 4,O tn ^OIF^ ^^'.e^P.-' C^W p._^t J'.J JICGN w0^ l^. V• O'.P 'A O.WI^JIy) '.3.Ji-- -^G P J y. W J< G'3',.OI P J II P^ W"D ^1 ;^I O' .b. C L. < x ao '.I.. O.WI^ILWrY!--Wj{b!6 1ni a^ ` o ^ J Qt^ls) -^W^a1sJ^^V• V^ O J'^A --IO Q'-•O O.O O O Q, w IJ L.,tn'b..N-Q. .n^J 1J ^n ^pICC^J `-^.P^43'J W .L..A N. 5 . _!-^.^.._ . NItJ - o c olo a o' ololob c vA, A1wW o..°o a^. o c^e o ' o ` e-^e ^c c c•o^ N . _ ^ V^ ^ : ' ^ . ^t• ) I tJ - ^p o w'oI+O;^1,,b iJ!w U.O^o:'^n-b P O IJ.w 13. .t I<: C.J^^.^O NI00'6a. ^...,. c-w -. ml^. _ V',-.C>_IJ'Oa. _ __ _ p a o o^lo^oo o C c^ - c^, a a a o.oo 0 00 0 o O10'QIO O^O O O^ ,^` C N.OpIU'JIN'IJ-^D P A`D A IJ P ,b31^ N JS.^ O IJ.'J In TIjI^! tJ J.U Oi P J 0 •OIW O 0.` O N O• P IJ"•DIJ O riC JIS i P J F J'IJOIJ O OW ^!O ^V' 1J C^ e°^WryI^ I oa O`. pl^'a lo o'o"o I^ eo baw^WabbW^WIW,c^cG W^W W^m^clmmW OS'WiWiWoEa!alopQg$oooF'a£,a^ W W.:A:W^C. b WW'W-W W 9_W f+,n`A nR n !] C] (]^C]C7in nnin G GO C p O^ ac O C O( O OG ?^O O p O a l0 ^ p C O C D O O;C C C'C'C F ^ F C GC G c V 3 E' , ^ ^ ( n.^ ^v 7 .2 A •<• 7 ^7+7^Z:7. 7 x = ^K ^}y m o o p i u. 9 a n ouc^xA i 3^ o - a jJ o..<•.<,^1°t.t^ (],•-1:^ io:_]^0^^ pn A n ar°I{p. ' ? I d 1' f7 d lr75 +-p N -s^,ti7I ^^n¢ ^a v,-' t7la I^; la 7"vv v-s .m f^ , r all ^I • I i^, . D: N V.O A^p` ^ hJ W^U;+) J•'%'J:W'GO.^J IJ ' A pp:^v'l W:S al'v^ vi .p AIIJ'OG w'A wlv ln •J^I•"-'^^'^-oo!•^ A.rn•o u N ai- v^ ,p A V.'J_..J,t;w^o al;r^^-J,rp •^.d,CO.•s£„R,^:.a O.A^a+.O.U' . . I ' I f w A ,aiW N o.nw OW01GU ^ IJ 0o NW^^ r:N U t W ^^•J.'r- U N W,F U^- U M A'F N W W J L- ! IJOOUN.AO+b+NJN^OA ^ N'.J t .6 -1 W V+ (J A1'J^ I^Q. IJ ^W`W O O J U_. W O. U.GC a^ N I IJ. J O] O GO - ^p O W_T 1. J. p. p^( Oc t.atNN .A>3'yl]o S._ . ..I -.. _ .. t I I ^C ^'J v 1^ v71 O V^1 •O v: ^^O ^n .D .p A M'D^aMIV' W.U' -L W GOIJ m d3 .b J^ y'AIC.O i^ G. tp{^p .p N^.t Gop.'p^ GC U.C P^ A ^.ae C 00 . 00 J ).l P- ^I A J'J ^%.A ^ Q% 6+ J• J O ItJ1-IU J a^ NI W A W:N G1 iT O:A ao J p• O O. O O A o0 W W O^N A Oo O^ Nwl^ Ni^ iJ pp IJI^- ^! A A'-- J J.p ^ Al^laa. a y, . m'. > O Op3^ .n U Oa U.n^0Q \ o,N e Ne A:..^ .e O e 10 0 8 O a e. A' i^eIW -^A^tJ'NflOI^I^^O N'b O O^ ba^0 tAw ^t tJ A IJA J','nIOJiO ialP[O A O,OGw N P.N'.J. O .,C O A O C o0 O' oI-• O W O O OsC NIO^OI O O O a•h w C O,eIJ.IJ ^t N^O N Oo^OC u c o 3J^ ^`_ o oI I^ oI ^ A^: A UA 09 O J^• 1. .C N WI•C+N IJ J I .p` J A'O.A At^..p W O9 0^ JIf-1AI^ W'^ ^^ J e V^ ^o^ -! - n ^e e le, o e,a t e °= (, I 00, N . 't 'I o O a'+ Lo NtW ^. w Co Iw w Oeo ^nI- •^:v oi -:A;^pItJ ^. Oi0;0 e. _N OimO. I•' ^._. N O r•O-•^ ^^+-J ^JI ^ OO w'.6,J J O. OIJ 3 O O N;N e+o-c o c+c,oa.o,e o u o o a .'a+o^010•clo'A + l. ^ .o Io OOA > t^ O O'.O .S'O -J^C+ v^ O A o.•,i.q..0 A tJ "` ^` uc ^. A'^ w P 0OI ^ b G O- a J O O^JIG WW ^ \ OkeJ w vn^F wIJ1N O O.o.w o ^., n I$^ \ o e ^a c io ie GP e'•^ o e 1 ._ . II -. ( ' . - . 1 W IJ L . v ^. I I O A ^ A^ J j ^ IJ N W',p ^.p^,a ..A N A A^S vr wIA'^.r.n p ^: C wIp I •D.tJ.W w Oe A 3 tJI^^IJ^J b O^utL .W A'.^U V. i.J^J i . t 4' o 0 ol+oio^oll-^-o^.o -'.o 0 o^'Io 0 c O IJ' OI ` .o o tJ olOwO ^J w O T N s `^ ^. O U't,T.J O lo U C. N •O N N ^! •s IWIJ v p^IW. JIU ^J ^tI`Oc ^1 w S W O U o O wIT O-3Iw.6 ln n :.N .n p^IN o tn L) C YJ ^O N AIL' O Oe.J tA J w^N IJ a^ Na o ^ o ^ J J c a o e I\,o_a o o°' e\\°+\°-\j I"I\i\°I\^^ \I\ e' o o c^^ I I fA M I { _ I.J'_ WI ^L.lI^ :^ r Vr I^yild ^OI P^w;o ^^t^a!^II.b W.O -^ A O.O^:^D i6^I^.1^N1.nfA^MO. _ {.-. J,. _'7^lo. - oIp O O.C 4 OIO ol0 o OjOlOlp O p,0 oio N ^D 4^ ^N^b EEI 1Wi'.p IJ^N ^ '^ A cg U. p^V^ :b O^ O O v^^- M T O fJ- O.'-"^ { { I I^ I I^ ^ I .^ O O^ ^_. O T Oi1Jl^1 ^plW^pTj^ fJ W W tA W^O1 O. W^IiL M^ IJI pw.© ^l ^ A^. cn A^t C N WIp O oi,Cl oP o nllTn r n n n n.n n:g ^n^CT''s 5cn.^ s o s l nn 7nn^_nnng nnnOO:nln Q:^ s^alm• SI ^a 3: . m ir , @ w'^ 3^ ^ ^.Y'^ T q V^ O5 45 'D ^9 ^J b 'O YO aC m 'O2 (,u_ ,lm Id ^. ' a.^ m n'°-^• ^vm.l w, e. 0 0 o'^oo 0 oloio'o 0 oj=l^Ic Er` ^^^.;^m a Im. ^ p is a ^ a I R ^a ^I` . I ! t^^2 ^i^.7:I•?^? I 2•2Z ?e :il <..2'7 o ^ o oo.oo o o 0 0 0 o i clo Y oola'^o 71a ^ ^ a I c'F 71§ B 51^ ^ ,^^2 < . Z•7:^ Z t l ^Q '.^I<,elr:^:^< v'<^•< e 101 ^ d ¢^.^ o c ' io.c 3 ^ .m 6 ^ ^•} o '^1`p,o ^ -? P^' E c'a'^rv l n N ^5. _ C C'm ^'? ...t^Slre n ^^< $^-d a f^ ^.^! H'".3 c o v o 4 H .. ^ a ^ I ^ '-^• I^s^ Y !U^ < ^.'C3 o (rv c "hI -j ' w rn__.f f ^ . --'A !J IJItJIJ W lJ W ^ ^ ^r•^ 'w^ot^ wINNN w'N J^a IJ P. w tA^ R.A W AI :NIN O'!PJ JIJ'+1^'V^V^ ^.]IF tn IJIG^-0 W^ IJ O_^-W •f'i IJ ^ J W G.,^D^Ir p^O^W^^ G -1J^P IJ O A WIW'N'LJ.U'IX::OIG G'4lIJ wrw ^ p N W_N N IJ tJ b^ r^ Y W ^. tn W^W;^IV w.^ rJ PIa` T•V J A A!R NI b ^n^N30 PiO^A'rJ A.VAi ^• P A J'^-O• OOOGO 00Ai0 A ^ ppw' IA^ •D v^10_O +IV^ ^O G w^G W;w PIJ J.UP^P IJItJi^ OOiO:,^ ^ NI^Im ini.^a : . 4 C ^b .o O OI 'J ^, O w •O ^V• Y^p .p ol OG 'J A w^ .Dlw w .C ^J `r ^O ^C r ^o -0^^[){•O -0'A O^,ap:.p J N V J n^R R O;J R'1 J J^) J P J-J w w .w'A h J J A G^11Q`{^ Q'II`)I W w J w R{J^I ^AIOY J O^ i>.w A'h'w N AI.P - J ^O O^t+ 3) A V^ q^r Oo It^ N^^dJ x W N G aiw n:n WIIyJ A R J G JJi1J A^ v' ORtf Wr OI- h tJ.OG "1 g GIv ^ ^za {_^p , ^ ° , l.I I - -' ; • 1; ti o- pp O .^^ O P:w Q- a N-IA W.IJ'OOIwiW!PiJI'-0 A 3 rJ A:s A p ^W AY^.` ^.. ^ f ! ^- o,o ?^ o r+, c a'cN c--.AI ^ oop. oio^oQ- O'IJ Oc I O^4lIJ G O 7W O J:w'^YA,W^P w Ffi "W R "!O 4hltJ GI;.A"J. OwC w G Io^,w!L G a: Q c^i7'y p W_A L.P N^6rwIw iJ W tnA tn'N n to e '.e e ^_e e V-_ilti a:A. °;e ^e . e r ! I r w:0 c:^ O^J O ^_'wI , .. • O O G O O O O OG'6 C Op G O O O' O O O O O a'..pO O O O'O O O OG G O A d jCYR A k- IJ ! '.O tJ O ^`{O P OYO p rJIO w1AIJ o,O w aIO a O IJ .^ b O tn R R w a a : o W O O v!IJ tnr ^.A:'R 1.) A^:Vd's ^) \^• o^'I. ^ia^.;o . o a e o 6` ^ L• 4 i Iw r.py N IJ - A W.J -^. d.N ^;W =^ p, IcJ. w s I o v =1- -.'.wrR..-- w A.w..O.R.O ^)'^b:OC ^I•w I I I p .p G O'O p O CO O C W N O 4 IOI .- O N- C.+1 ^p-W J w w Rlv. lA •O J!V O ItoR W RIh'.WIG O I ^O'p 4 G^ OG N^'N U W W'IJ G W p bl b V Itp pIJ R J'^6 A J J-0 G IJ C ^O O. \ 1 ^G\ o Cl O ^ r, ^,•^,rrnn;rg^nn nn^,nnn^nr^r^cnn.n;n^^',^^nc^c^n^n^n l4 rn-mis rt^n rzi rt n mI ^ ^ ^.^.^,:? [o r 2 o m m ru n CI 'rc •^i x.^Y Y^"f1EE^F''.T 0^9 ^ ^oc oylj v 5 ^^^lo o ^nnc^^,^n!nnn'c^ ^ g EEElF l^F cg Sa^C G^o o^o o clnclIo o^o^o 0 o:c a •e '< '^ Ic •^ •<'.^ ''7 Q ^ !'< o^o aloloio o^o aoF a C C- G 1 C ^ ;3E; ^ £ F C p p ^t < C .c ^ I ^ C} 3 b;O hq 0^3!.^^^. C: 5 a C o^ a i.Z a f^ •7 .2 ,e ^ 17 < < ^ ', ^e •^ •2 t2 "Z `^ ^2 i o"r+'^^4 S n^ ;W!>^ w4 0 0 ^_o:,l„a^jl^^e+^^^^ m^-io01- o^'^o N T[5. lo +svl'21rt G- I^;G1°'I rc ^:-fo'n -1'o r- n--.li° ^° yiw p'I.r rm ^^ _C --IWO r^G^.' -1r11G;6^'1^ -1 tm Q'!l^ w len t^^CS? n r lo ^a CI<^~',I^^C^ GaG f7^, tv ,, i ., U; F l ( C Y _ W W,- A V AiNIT ^D N LlV .1 O.IO^^• u.N L^W P CG P Go"L •O N-• Y^J J G]•IIJ A w GO.La^-S':.p^{J CpIA:Y F G CG,C^ -^iP N•^0^.^^^^tJtP P J.^J4 ^':C Oo O W-_). V^ W LO ^P tsl^ '^ nlOO^P -.J C a0'.tJ GO O W^^ C'J^ co^O J...... , .^ . _. 1 A W N N _ NIN . ^ I 1 . P' I! EN`- A J^ AIJ w"J v.Iw^V^ W Px Co 1'VJ O O..rJ N W pNiW Oa':-A-• N F N A N w VI ^..OiA N.O P*S W tJ"^a) O. -^L^l N:.W J W O A W,A N^^iy'alil^ j^F^j'^pwpl^ h P^JC A U m^^l.0i sloNe 'J ^VOi sN. N'JG1 m^l_^^ aO- J> U y N:p JNA PIO A N.P ^^•D J O^O^ wt^/.^O^oI^!'.m AIw O^o1TPI'^^1 t^+"J^:^ ^•^^' CCI^p N'..la IN-U ^p p O^O J_IT 0 A^4^• ^^q Vr w e^1 A J^'P O-G t^).P O O ce tn J IA p y) A G> P N O JVi oo;IJ N b W.Vlha 'b.^ JO1IQ J N pp N N:4+ IJ - e M.^.V' ta W fJ U r.G^6) O^'N IJ E W £.^._. W^.P ^O ^O C:4b:W'Qa^•O r ^p^^`:p^O^p -^:O^G•-'o^0 til^.'--^^J W O• ^F.0;.0.1'J•'U.^A q.0>'Q : -e'\. ^ > e e ^ A. tJ ._.. W N. V. 'L'•^ _. V^ tJ J^^^UIU-^ N U •-' O^,-.O p^0.0^116'C G C^OIy b^FJ J V^ ^ W V^ iJ La c:L) ! NI I i GO •- y ^^ lw'_..w.oe O +^ 0a A^O;N O A IJ eh --.A tJ -•^'p' d'^.09. ^J^1.. ^.. . a_.._. J ^ w^^(!^ V w JIIJ J> O•-' O P fJ _.^.__. ._...... :'^ ^, ^ I i ^ iWi^A^G S, ^I N O O O O -C O ^ C + tJ O -IGN O;OIO. JIJ yIG^ O J'w O+ C ..4'L+ IJ A U' J.^ 100 J . N U '.aD C> oe J.1 O P o^ = e C o> .> o al ^^p ,^^^Ia o 0 0 o a f11cn r n n;r nnn'n r nr.(`,r-n r r r nlf n n^'^ ^ZI7 crj` n , n n q 0 0 0 o^, E' q o o i'o_" o 1> :_ 5'^ o 0'^'5 >>^'a, >-'^^ g e: a,^ ^,^I'' 0 c o 0 0 ^ = ^^ ^ rr l ^n n r nnr. ; n'rr'rrrrn.nr nnnn ^ c ' ` ^^I^ m f o;o ,a co o c-olo 0 oIcl^Ic c o^o o^ o°° Lo on ^ a^ rin^nnno o c;o c aa w m m o!g^^ F^ Fs 55 I ^^ ^ nlnn ^Z <'2w•^.z.2 ..27i :I 2 ^.v.`< tv {'7•21,^^:? y'^ ^ ! Oin n D I J.nIO^Z^'z,^ls' s . .v3 ^,t c ? o w roe .h ^ ! ^ h m Jly ^ ^^I < o, l rmr p ^'^. ^1o> S1 o-^^3 ^ ,^.'^> ^>''-1^o n 5.I^ ...o_ an, ^'-' 03^ 13 1 ^ .. cp 1 S I^I y u^ ^^1ry m O 7J m ^ ^ ^ C ^ ^^ n ^a <. ^ .K ^G .._ .i% o• ^ ^ i^'a> -l I'^'>.`..I..-' ' p; n -3 ' -' ° e o:-l^-i ^ lm OclO s --114 .op^ml^ItslllCG .^>ly^>y°.^.^>^:S^31d.d icw ry ^ I^! I 1 . 1 ^ , ^ e^ a N J^N J N WIA:A F tJ LJtNi 'h h ^ IV IJ - IV Zt^. .Ml+^' J O . P W V . N Ni . . .' p b F v 'O p 'J. OI •F C J WV. tJ'V'V ^-3^ ^•L` O A IJ I^ GC rD `G'tx O tJ ,-J.A 'N^+ W P W^tn hI1JIN,W A Vr P I Js. L d I J W.'V W'J ^' P^- J N P,4 C; ^-' i C^WIA^tJ IJ O s w N"^ y'.. I ri0h^ IJAIA^F P+-/' UN- WIN^^.W,U O O^ OVJ .n w A J^ w t.+J U TA . III 4 i I __1 I - rt ^ ' _ w. 4 i ( I ^O a+'.NIA N^ lw;A A ^^ Cl A ^ N IJ IJ'Li •s- 1U:N,-' IJ d P N -' IJ p ^Q '-NJ A J^P.^- MS O^a,^F O^! G Pt^D u^'.P Q^ ^' j GO '3 ^ A I I N U^ ^ rC. ^ ^ ^° '^I P W_•D ^I WiW.•.• O> J Gc l bOl•D P^D7 W i^ ^',+.^' . J^A .n N tn m F _ P ^" A 9 A:O^.P ^^.W D^ O`C, O b`D T I W ^ AIWIJi IJ , ' S ^ ^ `O b - ! ^ca mrc 'w vo^.o •o w^ol'o vc '^ ^ol^o ^D d •o.^o ^o ^D v^ n ,c w ^a •o^.^Ew .c G u'rc •c J P J^S^J Le J J ^l °-• q 'J.`J flG P ` +J' ^ ^, ^JOV !^ OC P UIP'O,la•l"^ w tJ P U ^8 ^O O Jr Cc 'U'!n O'a P^'-' . mICW^DP.^FG . :. , .,...... ( , r ^y.^v ! . . . . . I . M. ^. N 19 ^J A ^0.1 '^S P N. ,1J V. C.a O`O A:.W C OC T'1 . I^I..J J OC F _ . ^^-.°^N Vr ^ al tJ W C.:w T.^^: I ^ ^ N^^ O C O.^-' O^IJ O'-' +' N C C C P C'Ol'^ - O C C C O OIO G ,p, Ilj .T O C N ^ A A ,C.P OIO `Gw F- '.nI+T L N^J A 6^ N P(-+ION 1"l A O^ G O w GG A V-` oC x ^G w 7 O w10 GO F P +D OotO •D cn O^V'D ^j^- N U O/3' C: tJ '^C IJ . O+ UI \ . \ c I f,^ ^\ ^ ^ i'0^ t G1 W aN P tA. I O _ > ^` 9\^.j.IC i\^"..a o\\ i ic o\ 4z \'e \^o .c \\, pd \ e '.. ..i ..- 1 ^^. .__ . . . .i ^ . . I s , I . _ . ^ . . -. I ^ I . ^ O -N ^ ^ : N ^'_ ^ G P 1'•V J ^ tJ O:'k' 'b0'A. w I I . .^'i_ W,^ ^ A .OiN'.lJ ^J;-IJ •L Ln W W IJ L IJ C „hit-. I . . ' ^•..1_ '- AJ O^CO N ? W IJ A O O i C-.O d CIO ''CJ I O.C I d ' DIC I O ^ t.J ^ O IGiCIC^d C 7 p.0 i 0 O. C C C,Ci^ ,Cp C O I 1 N:F fj t. N 6'w O Y^IP 'V J ^•^ ^1- ^(J.r'o i^^AIW UI^ Ih IJl.pl^ Ft(^'QFi N N"N ^..^ ^ L Ci^J ^^ ^G!T,.^ 0 . ^ W . t V° V° ,^_a ° \lel° AI A ,o _ C\e o,a 9"^,'j^V° .o-'> o e^c'elA^V^o'a^°..AAIcle I 1 U IJ - C^ .w' "F -.1 A ^ f3 W w W'IJ I IIJI IJ WiW^ IJ^IJJtI - i F i m l C i I ^ i J ^ N Z^ 1J i. N'Id ^ PI P 4w IJ F '9 A.N P .P _ iA yC 4 c.3 J C W C'^''J d^ ^- J^ II _ w .O IJ17, I' 1 '^ IJ G O G IJ O CO O N^G,O O G '^ IOI?^^^ C 'F C J"'J i A C IJ , P C C ' 'J^ P ^l N.U J' I.•-.^+t O^ O•G..A IJ Ji'. 'J L\D p IJ J w J•OO P IJIU,'Jpf^ J O C J^Q C C- O O P.G^I,D ^J A I G_':h o C4lFlzwO Oo pc ^O+ o^T O ^io^A ' o . o ^o d lo :a ^^-\'a id`-c e e e ^ e o.3,e lo o-o o a 'e\'e. ^ e' ^ o o e c e c^:a^:a lc Nor' c y 0 0 o o nuo N c 0 io n. o'.o^a o I o yort' n ' W N .h . VI G n.n'in no:,^ ^ onionon';^l^lon'^',oc^p^ N ^^V ..II o 0 oloolo 0 0^o 0 o c o a'a o 0 0 0 0 o n^'R oo l oolo;o^o^ol s, 0 oIOGy p r nl^^2^^I^I^ .^s ^ ['q'! ^! C 00 '0. 0 0I ^17 j C 1 3 ° 5. ^ C^ a 3 !g^>:3 > >,° y o o Ooolo 0 o e c o oio^o 0 o'oco Q n^ o o olo-o(o ^ ^ C G o o Oo 0ol o ^0 o ^000 • C C C C F G C C C C^ C G I6 ^ Y. O I :i^G'v^SKj2{ = ^i .. , , . . . . . . W _.. ., , ^ _-... . . _._ vi ` • ^ O , . . lW IJ an ^p N M N^ ^ V J ^°•Ch [^ I I^_IN ^.l U W'(^ o J ' V^IA lh `D p^ ^'J P O A "J G W W J J^. lW4 W. - Q^ A' W^V 4^+ N.A ^•. W N L^ 'V ..^ £ tn:w^.G. A. N-.^C P^D P'L w-'NJ'N3 :.) `..' - . W P^D Y , N Do I A:..^C OC - 'J V ^ N P^^iO O J^" a P:P w A O V^ N V^ A-IN J.-.OfP J I O O A O P o- . _ I . I! a C - ! I I I .OIN ^J In:O V+ J Ot) ^ A ' J A P ' G\ A A t! .n 1 ^G CIOIP A U:fJ P ^ 6l4IW J Vi op.^DJ P S.w O w0 09 AP l`^+PO O ^ ^ R i , N'N VJ ^ l a^`.iW1O^.nitsNi'wIP I oolVr:v: U o^°o Jt. N^ _.VF.O ^ J ^ OO O ^ A+ '.. bi^Olv' +:^ .° ^D ^O ^ a',O ^D P+A'^D ^D .O O 'aloo p o n l c la .c •C ^D I y . ^ q ^D b-'U `0 ^° 'v mP ^a^DGO tn ^D U Ci^ MIO J o] J-ln.N J C ^.l ^O J fA C.CT. 'AIO^^JIJ ^D M.u J J JIP O^ `t.^D LC I IV^IA Ji ^ ^ - e,J ^ 4 ^OC^ e Oa t^ , p wl.. .I.a o G b : u C' N ^ ^ I J.Ql PIPncI P^^ r . b ^ 1 0 w ^ ^ w N J I eio . a'<< I oe.l e= aaa^^a ^^a'a `°-i° i l ola=^> ^o=^^ ^^ ^ _ L_ ^ ^ 1-. , . , I_ , . m^. ^.) ` N JIO ; O ; ^ V^ N iJ N U.O }^ k w J A J IO^^fOlF4:PO( A w - G i A I W CGlwl O_p ^ O A O l I I O ^ O O O^OIO Oi0 O OIO O O O1' O O C a O O OIO O,O O O^p O.O. P wO IA^A J A.OIO tn U Oa: n N O J O O P^O ^ ^^ L O'O P^- pP VO OOiA a p IJ NO!4 O .O ^ W J='a'CI V P J.L.OI^ V' V Ie V ^ \° ^• ^ I ^ ay m .w D' . .^IN._. p,p_N J A J OOIN.-I ^ .O O N O W Y -. La ^ I w ^IQ^tJ IJ 0 0_O ^OIO,OI O: V• ^ C3 Ji - 0'^ ^. OlOtO ' O p 0 0'00 0'0 00 0 000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 010 0 O O O O O I O I O'O Op L p L> w IJ .- i O O +^- IJ A A'. ^- O ^ A O ^ W O N w ' P .n' -G^ G O . J^ Cb ^o ^ O: O I w A Ge IJ Q^ A:W O O. . J A^ o O^ -.1 OC 0' ^ b O t- O. O'. O I N i . I I I I .^r h! ! , , _ ^ A ae> -- iJ J,^V^.N ^ s- bl-' 0 ^I^.N W L V OIOjOIJ O-'.O Cn `O O B.!9 a O P^ tn O P.P.A J.- I - _ _. , I ^ I •. o'ol o-o 0 o:p o 0 o:c G la o o ^^_ A^ ! o I 'o^l o, o 0 0- ^ J °, °+ ^N N^.p V Jo Ooo O p O w Oitn O^V, O^'J 1.,W.P ^O O"1iw tJ L .O tnlh ^ ^. tn J . ^•wV ]w..DAJP.tc W IeVo NppIJ PW OC6. 0! IOI \ 10OWO^OOAI N' c ^ `^ o e c c'2•,^ oo -o o^ o I c" ^ c o^ ^°.Io^ o^ c a> o ^= la d^o a a c-2` oioio o!o oo 0 0 o'o{c^olo'c ^•m ST.^`^^',^•^'^ ^:'-'"'^0 o o.o 0 ° o 0 0°0 0o 0 ?10000o!a ^. ^ ^'^ aa aifl"lain^o.'a^n.Iala^cla n!»a.la'. wtro+room m m r^+.m .wwwd^wwwNq m m m m'm.w m m. . f;Anil3'if3:nt7.A!]'(]jn^C)n!,o0 0 0 . 0 Ic crgIe cClcij ° ',c ° c o o!o clc^c'e o c o o'.o ooo^o I 7 0 0 l ' a o c 6 o S a^ 5l^i b> >. la o c ( uf Fi o z N o"po.^^^^^t6IRPamvb ^r^ts;x.F `rR°fUr.7 N aFri p ' c io ^ so c•, o o--] c ^.^..7 nl^ ^'^^' n'n X dl,x m Irv ^'^' 'S <,y G C m^'^ p ro p a b^ T p ^ It7l^jlm ^3 2 < < p,slf]^ ca'o m-N It^^oiY C]rv a- c-tF,c -i-i ,.^.-t. o rv25 ^ 2 ra n `_ h ^m,I .1 iIII ^ - - ^V O> - b OiW. U N N..D ,n U-.t O ce: JW A^•.P W V WW;NIA^R^U-. .N 4C 'J ^b O'P - W'.P Oo1W^ Iw tA Lv PP -.1'OC 4> O OG - J 1J 'p P^ L W U N "L A N O A O'n U N N 'p: IJ I O tJ: J L^O N. O W'V O P'J.W, ! ^ P! IJ J ^O ^ N W....^^ItJ ^_R'W S. O.R U W WII`J^A^ WiU A N . ^IJ'O Q N.J'J V• ^G.P ^ R UOiN W.AIa O J Ib ^'O!U R A'CC;O V. P A;J:N ; 0^ s^,^ O VQi IJ J A O A N^O R O . cu P ti O W:.^ ^p .- y J O 1N _Oc:0ol0lA ' ^j.^ J'P ^a. vWiO;3 V7 00.0.0^0 :O tJ ^J I ^O A y'N'^+) JR < W Q RO^O{ '^JICA J A W'.W U IJ •'V• a W.•^'D WIY'rIPIQ^I '.OSiA 0` J bi^0 U^P P U P.C.oo J J'+ oo Q,O^la ^ OPI^GI^ `^ p . O O en"v P A O N,O ^JA \ooo 0 e \ `y^ I\ \ \° \ J\ a c '^ o _ o' o , I I . .... ,, . , ' I UjA N^^N N A P' cc:J:O^^ R'O R W`G '.s1.N O I JA . it7 + UNI IN R O R'. W 0.^. O ^t ^ [n P P'xi^`p R!4" p_y=1e [\Ie \ \ \a 1 , -^ tJ, Ja O -J 'W'^. NN^ -^ Wil-I pi..- O•- Oa A A^U'P N O I II •- WIN W'N NI IO^J O 1 ^ >^A pAA A A \ i .RiIt i ^'W .y^ .NiNtN^NI N{ I W.fTlU:^O:^ W •^'NjIJ N O I I'^^ P O O. po v b IN'^-- A rNiR bi -O 1 I N^ ^O_. O O^ C OiC I^ 1` i O . ^ 4 c7'N o `I^O^ N OO N O^ IJ p- l p -Q ,^r J AR N a0 4 p ^ tJl A W lJ ^i^ N, .n Q l ,/. N R J Oo 'J' V V S V. 4. . P O P W IJ' W W 4 p^ ^O ^ N A 1NI^- IJ O^ N i^ \ !^- \ \ \ ^ \ f ^' \° \ \ \ \° \ e o I o- e . o e o ! o p. ^\Io e o^ •''d•3lTI a ' o I e : ._ ^ n . n n n n^ n nin,n:nin'n;^ n n ^ n n'n;n nIr' n n n C` n n:n fC` CS,nln n n n. CAC yy lKjS v ^ c yC3 N I 5f ^ C C v^IYn'o`^^ y''vOf1010O L Z ZZ^ ^i s r ( ro m ^+ w o o a o mb ^m „ ,^ry.v-^r o+ ^'c o- rz^ < rv ^ ^^IC) ^313 ^^a a ^ s n.^ ^q'r ^,u ^: r^``n ^O'^x rv .^ . a c's T v rv cl^ -•) r d^.' o a m s c 1 m r m , G Flnlo'w m o Ia o'^ ylc S^n &^.`r° a a ^*t.'d . s i c l^ rv 7 1<"^'^'.n.lrv. ^ . T^ < n m.T ? ^ `?ryl ^r. mn 'H^cI,^^^< cron 'rc v. ra T :rv ^° y ^IC C l y !N I r io ^ s = rv Icl << ^rr_ ^- I ¢s Irv . ^ ^h^ tn I n_ . ^ ,.^ ^ iC^" ^G i nNSA , ^ 7 : a ^t'! rvl^'I °' I?> ^^ ^ n I It,< +,tirvE't^ l' m a < ^a [^ ^ .I^v n GiC s' I . .f'^1, ^ I`r^ ^r^^°'it rm^n-•7 r?I ^^'^. [nA i 1 n- ! i ' ( { Ll y I4fI+ t.! N - .-. W IJ I"AJ U^ J: G`^ a A^a W^„U' 4> W O ^'N IJ W.yr^D W > A N.J y- W.p NCG A'V GG'. P Ca N'. ^J 0 a O O^^nf^ w N W^- V rn^ o-J . :o:-- pp,W A N JIA N^NI A I talYatNytn,.a^J c^ ^,o ^p O,n WO.•aIP Ciw160 IV 1^+lIlJ 1 ^ FI, Tr ^1 ^ - tJ' 4> N'R.r w P^Nr .n P I J .Ni-AIy IJ J A.J ln 'yIV. Cc'y N^',W N OPc O .^'n'^A I-.yW .( I Nb W1._y V t< P A^OC..Py.^ ..J IJ W .D -'J i r J^ J ^OOI--'I d J •O:yi4 } v^ P CY-^yIVO tJ tJ N^P:Ov --!A y4 N.'-"Ay ^ -O^• w J' N^P ,`J A I I -•RLa'.P.-I w pp'.p Op po NI•altn O O O NI"VJ J _ tn O y^NIOC O IN .] y'O^V^jl y P961 V^.J F^ _ ^ -v ,. I i -I I v^ LIJ ^ qA0'O^ bI^J',A Ai0 AIO'^ Z 50 -:O O^-t^O^hIJ O^+1G^i w O^I N-G .P ^! A^ O J--^1 N ^G P A A.OJ G adlJi4^ .^. If^ P A <-.Ca OL• ^ tJ ^^U^^IO'N tn N-^ Op w WW F^^ A!•6 P^a P J+J .! a R ^ a^' a° o^ e`e -^ ^ o Io-. _ ^ 1 Y 1 1 ^-' ^J',.^. iA y P w a4 OIJ. Wi M`J -iIJ N4y^WIn ' CIIAI•- I lJ.iAWGO^ P - N •a i A aa A t^JtJ v^ J^OI^a O.•n' 00 t+ . D> A^JIIJitA A L.'^G Ct'^>:oe1-^ W xl^l tJ J W W+•O A- y.'n O v>.lS. AI-'CII ^^I Ci,`C 4.N.00-UIJ p' hJ '.] N: tJ'La 6^ -1 P CIO A:-iWi, 'CI^'P•,iJ P A W?ItJ J tJ A,C ?A P A'OO^ ^ eIL > N o N,PI-^IJ'ae^OlA! ^•> o A.w'ln a a"o ^ o•'o e o^-.c o.lo ^e t6^ a'e ^e^o o e^ a,o ' III I i iJ^N^IJ ^O -^ ^I A. IysIN W ^a 4 Iw - J ppl {U.: ^^ ^I41 1^+>..W'µ'•D"^ xi J A W N A^. NIP.y - V. m R 6i N v^ O'a O t^ ii. ^.> CI^D V y^lJ ^ O^J N W'^I'^tJIw,.LIO^IN ^.I(O ^IT^wO ^+S4JIW WP' P A L J_ a+ O^D•C J O. ^-IG G.A,- OO - A A N A'y b Ll. -ItJ! a.>^_. N OIA',n^-.1^y OI^I.I. O^> J IJ I O^ LJ '.^ y O I^D ^I^ !`J! J CO ^ tj W[JIAINIwI^:^t n A y' W. A O y y IJ ^a •D %, y U .n IJ - P I A I.n I^^'g I x ^^ m c^ o i I ( I IJ f , I j I^j ^ I 1J ' ,- P y J- ,C• y a y n- iJ C..J W:P . ly>I^-W A J^-.4'^ - L 'J^ ^i AI'J.ILaI4J^V+ JIJ 40 O14`. 9 I+Q^ J'^l':.^DIC• A_O• N ^J^O^ "••O J f^. IJ I . I t I - IJ w lI •- CA v' O y N IJ - J ^ A I W N b O . 'nO^NIn'PIAL :LJONy^ W C'tJP >'OtDIJ eCJ O. A P iJ'^>'W -lRfA^n`n oJla^. W n.a O^ >O J O> O. A, o e. ^° ^i yp - W A R IJ ^ l ^x a,O p tJ a 'a A> W Jo a: e o > e °^ e a= e a nnn^n;nnn:nnh^nn:n^nninnnnhnnnnnhnnn nn o^ o 0 0^ c 1 o c^ o 0 0 o to o 0 o i o c a c^: c 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 .^"^{'v w m n w^n° w w^c' ()^ m o'`^° v v m:ro m°^m mE^^w w t^a'twd v m^`m^a' °w° ^m w m^ ^°i`t' _ O O O O^ DO CO O C OCO O^O ^O^OVOIOIOo n^ C C C O O^^O^O 'OVOVO^o 'J' _ =7 3 = =-^1 1,9 " .7 ^= O = _ = tl 7 Z } '^1 = z Ci'. 0 ^='^.9.:=^.^J'R S ^ I ".Z' 2 ^ ^•2 .<^ +7 p2 ^2 •7 F i7 ^^Q ^ 7 ? =•Z n nnnnmmwwvm^'^"wm^xlsrF£rt l w >.= 4 oc, r rq S Sy ^w o.aO c w oQ+J k? iQ o 4 rop V o: tt : c^ m1 aa w, o to a w .< .,^ S= c 7 n i Y ^ X ^°r °x o.: ^fF ^S . c`°+ ! o o ! 3 t ^, a . < o vl'c ^m F^ 5^w F t0 n o-ih^o ..^:5^^,y <^ '< ^^(+t^ica^<^ I5 F= o<.` ^^r.h. 2I^ I eo n^^; Idr c n rc:R t<:^1^'• I^-m ro^ .n,^ < rv ., t, ^^ ^C] 7 Y<<'W ^^^ ^ <^wiwl V w I.h^ jd WWW^ iVe b _ ^ w-A IJ N t^ ^ ' I^ O'^J ^p C o ut IJ W Ni,N L A.N^w Ot^Qt D^^O , . .t^ 'IJI^I W .1+^ WIR W V,' ... w D^JGO CO m W:T W - - D ^ , I 7 N^ ^N A J b NL-,p tNW D . 1 ^ G ' IJ I Q^I IJ zi u v.0^^ t ^N^+1 u . IJ ^q 01+1 A AIT"`t b^ W C O IJ -.N W A.,ol1.tD - O y. pp,U tJ V. Jt:- l41 G> A. W T^•LI\O t,Ui U^M^^.^ u•L•I j^^IJjaIWIOION. VWi Li A FWjl-^O ts .^^ptN'.p U O Ot0 tJ .CN-ay Ay'0 ; I '^i ^ ^ ^ ' I I ^ u.+ 0.;^0 -J b DI J .1^IY ^IIO:.bI^l^ ^.DO 4J ^`t.llbl60 wlDlb b J O^o ^ b,V 1 O P a NI-D U ^+'tT GW pp O--'.ut yU;W W N O O+ L^D LI Oo J N ^D U U A o^^D pplOO;F^^'..^.Oo W b fo OI+OI p L •p N.^D b I .. .. . 3 . . . . . ; : . .. . . , - IJ - wD w. W.A U- a W W^^O Ut:.LJ. Vt. ^ A lA LC.-• w Oo p 4, O( C p UIpJ u P C.Og O^ C O D W^ U tJi '++ O tJ W 0 W..\ y\ W`YD C A^•6 O^O A t^ p^ NI o^ N O^ 3.FuE^ J A A in 1^ O^ C 2. O a'Q^^^ , b a',a: - - ^== LJ. w ` y ti^D .N' ^ IA w tv W' 1^0 J Li O N A l O j J L^ W' ^pp1 W: . W b•O Ob J U:. A O t Oo:P'J':wiW Ot. W N^5^0 ^O O;J t/ C• t0: C^WI _...... _._.-_. _ _.__ _ . . ; ^ . . I . . I ' I , I N' _ V' T LJ: :VtIJ N IJ N, W:^ L-^^A w _1 P V'.+1"_' .D. .p I^^O>' Wu. N utrbJ, J^' t.P A N^yl^ P^^A O^ N'W^th^bi O^ i1 LT tJ.P'A -i " , . W L'^i^l'^p'C P^O.w:T VhOib ^ t N.O N WIN C-^IJ.IJ,N - ^ti Aj_'^W N - N L O ,Dp^C L NtO,- O b>LIONO• OCO1Jw:oCGP.'S.I^UqW^WAiJO^NCFd^O1wWNUW6.DiOI^L^ ^^.I., -e I \\° 1 I ^'o ninnn.nnnnnnn;nnnnnnnnlnn,i:n.nin,nn d, Cnj .t lwi'idi P4^w wlo. w I^'1`^la' ^'Ir'Jf^ rclaS 0 Q0p 7° rm° irK 6 m u9o ^n° !{c ^2 rf kn NI°-. tl^Q, 'i1p ;°c p^^ r°1p r°n uaa o^c u°o ^ IM IM pp^m•b`m w L^Im^w w w pw'w m m nnnnnnnnln:nlninnb w'w'..m wIN wwlm'm.w b. nnnn:nln=n;r,nnnnn'nn p '^ o o O o OIo1C OF 0 o C G O C Ci^ CC G co CIOrC C G C gig ^ i ^ I^ ^ 4 1 2 ? 7 -5 < 7 ,7 = 7 7 ^ ? 2 I^ ? 6^ O ^'.o..,^ < m•I^ o ^^gln a'S•e ^a.^e ro mlm.vo <.-^ -' rt cro.c m <^a.a = 0';y..c c''^< .y`n ^,.rt^.n 2 x^ v,jylo• xK .^ w (G n•`°'' ^pc° n^^, i ^ ''n - ,^!"^_ m' N) ^ . ....I y IJ NIL^IJS-^N b W^i O Q U O .D W O i J N_b)IN ^B i WW - IJ N J IJ -' '++ Fd -N 1^u+ ^p W d N^IJ Orl.JI1J^A h'^J o ro FJ'P-^ n olo'A Iti A d~;,.61N rOJ OP+ t^ N d P,tJ h J^ P,w J N.^ A W I J`O I ^. JI q N.A,06 3.1.> N^^DiOD OC AW ^T 'V O°:-iW_^i A^l C° J'O P J^ OjGc ^10) N WI^ N W G41,_. 1 .^^ I ( • ^ ^ . '. ' '. I I 1 , 1 1 • L L^^^. apINIVN^W^Y^ IJ^W -'W iO....^N G'JAIb^.A n tpi IJ^.^ O IJ CO N.- IJ CV^:hN.N-•Ve 'w.+SYu'.A W^- -i-rJI^o^A.O'^ N ^p tn 00'1^ P;OI IJ C O 'v iV 'Vi-^^d pp P a Q x a I+P)^Oo O N d N O n^) N P ao .I-^d:-J W-^d;L^W O P N 4 _INI^D _n^l! GC .DiA ppl.p:'.O J•O t v'1 ^n .i to •O ao D;^J Npp^P )d?OGCN'^^D OC 1 ^ N ^^ p ^ J N^A^VA^T J V J Co o. U C^O }.. A N- '. o O O^ a IJ P -- O• P^1 J e A O A W W^N .C s P^ F^ I L P A ^ > IJ W o o^.^ ?^ O1 °. s e e a o c^ ^ e° , o, 1 1 ^• ' ^ ^PJi j 'N IJyi ^Gh N O' -. . r NI•0! N '^J L N IJ J'W 'Ji W AI-lU)'w^L°i'J'^IJjN N^l •O1WI s7.Ow Oe --l 00 aold. 11A Oe A W L'^ N 06. W A J J,A P'-' ^I O•'DINI'JO TI[Jlwiyl l)I.OP!O^ (L"_.1 W V_N'A U1 r.r W P V^ Q.A.•-• p P,^,''m pp C.bJ+^-IAO'C^LO :AP,rJIJ A IA!-`P AIw^ io^N W. G 1% J^'A lJ ^Id P . LC C OC L^l'_I F CC)O.A d'S.^'Oiv^ 4 Id°t^) O A .,O O J,- P P' . , 0 oc.ac'O_ • e o ^^-o o °`'e' 1---" I^I II _ -' iJ.- OE -• Oe W NItJ ).W1A P W:^" iW b! W OO n n W w,_ O O J J Uw^C Pii« O P!^P IJ ) 'LI:A JiW Qw 1^P` i1'S•,1G .G d .-^ _ .. . . . ' 'i I I ^ L O O O.NtA OILIN iAiJl' +^ /^ OIJ N^C!G Id NI- P W=h J^ O^ O ,J ^ I p J^ G.d b A O 00 V IJ J J IJ L^O^ vpqlU i oei.^.iN ^ n J W^'P C r N w^^ UI ^ h o a o le e Im,c Ie^ ° I I ' , ° j ., ' .^ . I.._._..^_. . . _._I .. __. ' I I ^ rJ W J b,^^ O ,IJI_, ,n IJjcn PIM Oo,^01 N w. J JIP^,^)I 1^•D.P wI'n N_= ^^w t J^a U P W P W!J IJ J P LIN 1 1 1 ^ t { y.'w ^ N IJ - 47 ^ 3 N. ^ IJ N'^ UIJ -O IN IJ N rJ - . _ p ' O AION O O A ^I Q a P^D U d.1 i,Al.'^ w"A IJ A IJ U.% J.JIiW PA a NiG^O ^Ib.A ^ O +Ilte J P •O'P OI o, o.o. p,. o b c^ Ille, a.lo.io,le.lo o°`" -'o 0 6 C7'^JlC• OIdC',OkQ^Qi^a^4CJ4,dC3'ae'yC.dCy^yCio,ctiCi.p'C> _'w ^d '^i^ i'fr^etard m n na ^ ^A'ml^lrv^m^xy-n mr^in^ ^m,m t^k'n ^^^Irt^n 9Ia.^ ,a C m A mlFe^£^o ^ `enn r enb ^': .'n O'CIOIO^C^O!Olo O^CG;G c o o bOo'A G o O O-a Do:O O G O^OIO ^ 5 ^ K ^^a . a' a a a , n^.^,^;.^p^^•<^.7 3,^s w o a 7.•7, 7 9 •7 ry z .r < r 7^ ^r: ^aOi^z-/ !i i rC.C^ n ca m^> >^< F,F g^<.-1.z d z x^i.^^ c^ crR'O^ s t F anil^l'r ' W1--3^ f r m a u, a a Q ^'^ '^o c -im^i^^P' sr^m ^u° <^"^ ^ o-< t s^ ' ml ot^C f° n w' m M r^ t . ° ^ Is !v : ^ ( :T -3 i +I N v^ A"N^r/^A^O Oa-w^^.NIJ +1 Np^l CP'h'NN W^- N IJI- Oa fJ '" WIC'^V^ A 991 .W Jr^O O II^D O W G014 W'W J-tA `LI O^O 1J:3J tAO'1 Q A GOh +1^00' VIPINP cn,w P olw O K:i'J tn V^ W,J.'•IO.WlJI.WI[nJ40+lATiA'^_lJ^ oo:v^ w o^^o ^y,kJiV^^^.^+.•• I ^ G J W-..^^O^G ` tl^OIf^A W O-VJ `O W T+^1..1 J O Cq"OU Ip ^ C>;J .^ tnl^T OC^^D ^J^lo^o L^C W Q 000.^+ -a y J^Oe .l^.I ^D 4 O'.J IN Gc -I,P,-i P O pp GC La C^ 'V.pc J.q ^D O J.v^ ^h.'^ JJN N^ C^i o^^^ Q. O O D O^ P w w A J C O'N W C a y o e o e ^^-^ o e e\lo Id-^o '^ d'-ad e\ _• 0^_3_ . . `- . ..__.._ O N^. "- y N C^I O IJ w - .G' IJ tn W: aro rJI,O.J,.P^^n.O C:O O^C'N^P O -^.Ji-- --lo c o^o c,o y. o'p -.p o c p'o.c^o 0 0;0 o c o;, C tJ - O w 0 0 0 o"olw o Q O A C O p OC F^ O^O IJ- O tJ'tJD « O J kJ ^ p G G p w, 0` O J IJ C O O O O.O -1o O A W oO O O a,_ ^ O 0.02 C OIn.^ O A PO - a;v. OyO,IJ^ A.O C O Oiw - O^ N O-- A V'O O'O P O I „OOC CO'O OO*O1O O OO O O O O-'O O O O O O C CO.O O O Ory , O.OI ln ln .O OI' N N W O O C O: O O ^, J O ^-1'.O p O O F O O O A OO'O O '^OO +1O O^ 'k"np.Qr- C g O O G. OI p'C O.O O A ^ e'_ ` c C d3 _ a ^ ' r \° '` o e- o^ o o\' ao 0 0'` >- 3_` , . . . . , . ' . ',. . , , I '. I Y _J C^.V...... P 9^VIIJ ^O'-^^ b O a.IJ^ -•':O.C. A C +1'^'^9 el^ W IJ' `C r^ ° ^ O O' O P OOO O^O w O O G O: , c O O O C^O' O O O O O L+1^GO W'W - W O Ai^ W O^C O - b'^ w l. O^Gc O'O, O O P m',1. O w tJ P CA P P o p ^IJo c \ O!J O Io g O O tJ"O'n O Ix kJ OO c le e a o ^ e o ^ o °o oo-e a'.. '. 1:^ p- pp Op O p p p pipp 0 0^ Iw O i^7ip p p(p^p-O p -7^7 p o rs ^ ts ro ro ts ro n r T n io I rop^3^pip m ro n «;rs^n ro rc'.co,rzl.Fhror^lp.pr rl -,,^ -Z -t- _ £ ^ ^ S - '7 ^ > > el< we^^^(L mjsaFF w(^ &wro s < ^ E Flt m. r n.n n n n £ w d`^ '1m a`m n a mn.^neI ^+ n n.iirt n:mn^ a r r ^.m m ^ r, IP,' .^`' nr rzrv-mmnnln+onmmmrt.rt.rzmlmlrtrzrv't^1fl 4 Ik'^p''IE''^^''I^'I61i^^I^;F° l '3t^nn(';•CiC^!^fZ.•'^")n.f7 0 oo o Oo. r] o o O 0 . q DtOIOO G C C9'I CC tCr G CIC C 0O O O 6 O t p tv , cy^C Ca ClC royC ^ yt y 31J .'^ ' ^J,^ O(c 4 G c c, 10 ICC q a q 3 I _ EiEs I;^C ^ q .V p vTl.<^.<^eI^GI 1Y.. a r rr'.v,j ^p v Oi [' 'F t x^C4i0 O nn tP m^;> ^ Z^-;i^ IF "^IAjo II^ ^'S >:^I K ip'j r . y I4'i'y y. te a^+ os 5o m ScO 2 0_ n' .^ a n F y.v tm ^(G w(^ o Id (n o luoi EL r°^ s ti°o'alJlw- ^ ^G^p^ ot OI rtq:-ICI-3'-i'ol-1` o ^ ^ -i,o Frc: t^ otn^y nlmlri.nl'o'I ( -7 ( `e O.r a o c$ - - ^ WW, ro(^ o y 1G1= itF o^E E iCl o f^ m o '. iG ro< ( E a F I 'v. 7^^I^i515^'^IF 0^ C1( .j ? , f p ^ ^ ^ W I( :altn bi0 ^ ^N ro o ,G Fvur^sist s^^^ •o's.G•^ s-a ^!iw "^ivla(°^ ^-.', Ittl's I^ ` I, o t 'WA ^ 4 IIJ' IJ N w X ^ P P'N w a t- N A N j ^ Frcew'L. A ab'^° u °`O'w GC CG'^^.^IL^N WIQ..OC J V^ •^ V' ^•.1.•J. X j ^^ A J N O Q+ ^^CG N .p V^e^IL3 ; O t W^^= 1J T W W IJtJ 3 ;-. aJ NI . ^ IJ' )^N W.C L3,tJ GO^w ^- V.^N W L - ^ N Q, ^Io^^^Olv. oC C oo^.IJ•,N. Cc^a: tJ OIw ^ o `p:^N^"^ N C'L^O W L:OT^P OIX^^O O^ ^ O ..3 .,3 -J•W.X OM GG PJ. ^O C NN ^'.-l.-V P Aw ^^A,i O 00O'O IUO'J^; N:IJ C ^ OIZ9 C•.`.1 iM L L^ IJ Ce W.OjN OC LA R!.W^. C P W-:P Is .CC.O^ct."'i jJ ^O^cI1JIL > wo l ^^C O^.^Cw w O 4 \ \ \!^ D OI=^^ \ \'c^ o > ` d'e a ee .. c p^ ^c ` e e\' o a lo o a e o ^c ^_ \ ^', _ . , 1 t E- .-A tr•^.'N,^ O•^,N V.:V^iV^. w G G 6 V OC ^ IJ O-C^' L 1J IJ.P O iJ'O Cv^ O'•^- ^N^C C C C'X O O,CA ^ w Giw tn L A P 3^ ^ V^'C M J IJ'X Ut Oi p--ICC'^D J/rA ^ 6^ a +J N:^K' P tJ '. J viN ^IIJ t+'O L OIg !J I^J, O g o^ IJipIJF c D O'. \\ G C O p po Ia }e O;O a O.O .O .O _ D_ 9 e o\n ! 9 ' L' .C FItPJ O -.J NO . M O X C O O O O CC CIC'C C ' Otw G N O Lt , ^' OA w^0 O O C 43'C G ^ OO:^ C Cf O p^ w bs J NG.^.GQO U F p^_Olw A t^`DNtL AJ',viTtJO:NIV ^f.,PWIwi JOIOe+^.'i'.OC^O^:O:^pO C ..C O a ID _c G.8\. \°^ \°^o ^3^.\ o"i a >'a c a \ ...e^`\tc . ^-o,(\,\ \.,c^Io O a^'O a A•..• tl^. -t u^ O` Q^ A N.N.w N J CI J L J,^ 1.3 `Y^C:CtJ A^tJ `o G'o. A:^, ww w cn t,.'t;a> N-.4^^..w _. 1.- t t. ®..p^ n •.t^.0 . O oo^,C,^I O J ^ A V^ A "J IJ C J^!iF' - J^ ^-. rr J r i : ( __.._.. J ^ N A A v^ A L w V Gc N w.V• IiJ C ..0^ OtOIOI IJIO - IJ tJl- J L^I " V^ J w':tn C ^.OC tJ ^J ^d O•P ?L'N A A d^^ P AI^-^C l N J P'OC P i.d ^^OI`-t AIJ V^ 'J ?` A A^, O 3• `D O10 (,• I /^ N';O IJ J OGiiJIA t I O o o e o' c^ e^ o^O e e^'e9'c\ O e' c \\ o_ o e e o I,o'o e\'\'^e v o to Ic o e a a _ ALCU IJ ^- ^ UI Oi-.NIw (q J ^a^^O^i`J `^1 IJ IJ'a `:^ 4 P:F .tl ^ V• V^ w,F-F •D C O'^O ^ D'^IJ`^,IJ IJ L> A IJ N'^U IJ W N^-^^O• IJJ.^J N 4 _- , ^-- - - f ^ • . . . ',, . I . . . .^ _ I' t^.^ N W ^ V• J W 10J W.A •J• IJ [T^^^1'C W LO, ^^ P• P:A a^ O. J O aD•D"C Oa .IJ N^U J.O L.PiIJIU •O . W N U .P C V.IJCGW'P•^'PJ_.+ IJIJ+DNW.V^W__ JU'wUF P OC W ^0^.•D •D^W^^^•O O •O"A J ^ ^ O.•D •D .o J •O.•O O ^ ^O'^ v •D v7 O ^ 'J J V^.N AlrniJ yI0 > C;J p ^D •O^Jb..C u^:^O•ViV1 J O O J J P 00 P• J GG O• C.{, N J C^1 90 a P 'J P a O P. J C W W ON JO- t'u A AN..IJ C y O IJ V'IJ W O h F FF . N.r. W [A:ti1'O ^'tOl O ^.p J o -I^ ^Dp p eIJIJe'w <\I=\ e. Go.c6__^^ .Q , ^ ^ ( ^ Q\ I G ♦^^ ^^ O\.a A IJ U. -IJ^^ W.JIO b>Iy C C W'W y N ^- v^^.IJ.C'tJ'W^Nfa 1 ' 'it c^cICo c^b Jo'.olwlo w J iJ O C 4"P O N A^+> O t ^WU JIW IJ OO,O ^^ JV> C JOly al o e •a o ^o \_\ e e \ ^'o \ \ \ p . I . . iN . ', ^ W a-^D:.-. VV^ W L11J., O^I J- a^.-^^ •^IwI m W V^^ A W'vro O'W-O O d#'Sd V• l^ . W, "^ ^ OI•^/••J, ,IJ A ^- Nty^l+ .• O^CIN N- IJ - N N ^J O` W N ^J OO O WIN IJIWIN.J A OlF.a Oi •C^ - O IN - IJIp..^1 O^ W.N J.OIA^A^^IIC l^J U F ^ 4°.°I oEy .c ^. e o ol^ !g o o^Jc .^Iw oe a^w <^.O o^.. o a ^^^ie 2^°! ^'ti T1I T ^,' r ^^ rl ^i 'Tl { 'ry T f j -[t "n 'YI T TI''tl `1 'TJ I'TS 'TI T' "11 "^l "R1d.W "'1 T .'Md.d,W '^l l'TI Cdld.lw^^wld 'ii '. "1 W Ct W,G{W FId.W G W d W IW W W d: W G W^W W,W^ rt< 'a a =:' 3 _ ? ? 3 .'-1?a m n te m, m, ro m n Irv"m m° m.. mm m^ m o-m o m m n m m I m_ rt n r ^ m o m m m O O. G;Q' 6 G°.'6 2 4. O. 6'1^6IO.^G O. d.,4.. a o. c. q. a n a^°`. a a ac.a a°.^a a c nrnnr,nnlnnnlnn'n,n,nl^^^n^n^n.nnnnnnnnnnnnnlnr.Inc 4.OIC0a_^ C O,.C O^IO10^,OiO I OF ° O 0 0 OO O O ,Oc O O{O O^O^O O q q 13 5 "y1 5 . q > ^ ^ S q ^ P . a 3 . I ? Fs 3 ^ 9, ^ 3 ^ G G 6 > > W > >^. >I II.?- 7 '.t .7 d ? `^2 ^2 •2 .^ .7 ,7 .7 .2 % 'Z S^ G` .-3^ 0 m a w e a ^ ep -.p ,^^N Gl Oc w11J O^ J^9o Fn ^O:F m'A rJ J ' 'p'J NN-'P V' oo FI^L V m A 00'- O'^'L:JI°^ °^ .,.Ci, P W.O T F C IJ tJ ^ F U A:A:G J^ tJIWIL W N G1.FIN ,A,.CT J CA min. I I ^ FO{^I W^F:A'tD U G1 W"V'O G'^ J^^ el,lA ^r^'^ ^I^^{^ J w U*U-O'.J IVlIL'J^w i O ^D.O..J,CYI^O-F,'l. ca O' O 9a.A_:.F J.:'W -.N {FI'n W 4'..+_°nIJ ^-^ oo:mw m w^tJ . . . . : . " .. . ^, . . ":D ^fi L a O m 'C 'n : ^O K'i O 0 .O. ^ p' r•0 00 'D. L^, v .D .c 'h .O O o O ^D ^° ^O W O J-J' F J:+^ 0? '^.'-1 mp .p CJ:U O m FU J D. 1+>.P F O{^c.J-C^ V F pmJ J W O IpJ O C.; J m'UOQ..U- v IJ tVn aJC'^o J OIm'-FJ^ !^ p0 m^ W J J m f OJCJFmIA \ t^ ^ ° 4" V". f : e'\ e,.m.d+'.2 e ce^; < a^ ee e eAA° e e 2 ot°I. o,. s2 _^.-^ .__ .. _ . . _ . . E _ . " _ _ _ . _ ^ • _ _ -^ { ^ w T A { _ N w VI' . 3 N pC^IJ w L N.ww i» OF W m N.,V.m.=^ ^ w_-^15 ^F ^D O P O',O OCOOV-1-FImFN ^ W. V 1n 000 -- w 0 A G^ O O ^ p O O N' O 1`l p w- O O A? IJ O C p O O O' O .D w J. O 00 w w.V, m O NIJ^D tJ IJ-IJ O N A J O C+ N wlw A •+ < O O O d' O'. p IJ O GC.J l'J ^ O m. m- IJ wD' IJ m N J p O C O-V .O ^O W+ F'tJ w^ e a Ic a^ a•.'e°°^o^^o-^o o.^ ^ ^ b aana.a ^,e > I ! I I IJ b .m. ^ '^ U b:'v._W ^]h O ICiC^OII.! Jlw o 10 L^b ^- G'A ^- b O Oj'h'OI ._ b Jw,w . J .4J F.. F'G0,-IU jitj . ^ : . O O N O.O O O C.C C 0+ CG C'O O C ^I...IO N OItJ'OIp O O.O w O O v O.O h O N Oi. T F t ^4 J^ F N'O W i<',^IpI1 D 4 ^DIO wL Y O J '^ p O -J Jlmlif tJ C^+ o J^ O p - O O m^:F O> D p J OpIO S e "''+ O JIJ C^ J O 0 ^ bI I^ A. I ''^A {y ee \ o^ o e o u: O . c 3`.le` a n. ^ e"lo oe o ^e^. ^N 0 a= °. tJ O 0 0 C'O -IO ^ O s C OIO p-?O O OI ^ O IJ N+-^O J. G O 0 0 0 . J D Gc JC L ^1 J FfIJIJ m ^e F O.w',O^:m O-! COO F'h V '.+ h `J J.w F AO:`D O m O,\. ^°' bt^l e O -J `Ol,i,.e I\Ic e e O.. .^,CIa F. Ca.P W a\ w.w^;b OO , o eVe,l^ e "ri .. T "'^1 '*I ^'it 'Pr ^1- T Y, 'rt ^ T Zt 'lt -.y I Yt Y T YI ^1 ° ro ^^r°••._<^S"°'4^+ olNi_J'q°^o:z° ^'1b».7 O.nl5 ^I`JI3 sIo, ^ o a5 !n^^ {o ,^ ^ m f3 ^ o..-i n t° 0, ^ ^^iv^<3,^ „•. ro.3 .^ _^,^ . 3^ { ^° c . ^ ( , n . . ^ . . O 7; rc rtfn FC' i y'4-r . W^ A I ^ ^!A w ^ N ^n w O O Ge P O Vr^O A N^^DI'+> )O..-.P Wl)'n rfY -Y ^ lin .p -C. N VIJ W i NIO1O b pe . I '. p W w 00 ^Ci wG9 A N J A > C ^ ^1 1 p ^> !O P W"YPIt3Ip b"TIJ LINIV{rDI^.,N W A W^r^N W U.T`N P U_N ^ piW 'L IJ OC G P J.N I b^o ^^O{J .. . '_-1 . IJ ^ b OO -.ll J U q0o N IJ N ^I; P'N ' I ^ N w W N N OIW-J OICNn^^tlUlOa 'T W,,w W oo A.4Y WIpGIN C1'J A 1' A V. U17+-.) CT IT W^U O OI^' W W O^ tT J O W A w{O V^{U A J OIU!^O O-- N^G P U O'NI-- N{ _ U LT p LJ PIW;oAO-'.n LLJIA -1.OIWIb Qp-G^IO J^Y'O+ - C vN W -; Ilr I!' i I b.ob^^ ml^al,.o a^^ b pp ^^olro, ^ ^o 00 ^ vo-'a ^o u Gc J.'^ O+II OG W P J W^00 GG bIW OoI^ A A UtJOa Oa ec W-U 41 N G^IT . .n a^, +1 +.Y w^D: tJ A N.O O+T A^b N^U Oa ^r InIU N 1J U NU ^I U P^.W `^'b ^^O o C w-.^ A^IP j.^ ^IA rJiy rai, h'IO UIUI,O A^l ^O ^O O O ^G A G^ ^U N^l OO e e ^^e'2^\!c13^ c a-__ r D e 3° 2^f``t^ e ^cee^ o o a^'o . I : . . ._ . . I '. N {OV^P VJ. ^^4n'vr W wtGoo, C)`J^co OP.- e":^J., ^n ^Y w -^r NA N v^ tJ i+D V^ ^i^^!W N^.IJIO O n w w j^ ^^^ O^D v. N!J C N O-) tJlOO O W IIJJ N U.w.Ge N O ^-^^+) P:^D U 2Y^ oe OV b'p oa ^)IW^^.^G ^> 4e.GOIN vr^ C w x^0^^ o O O o0^.0',c^ p,0' ^^^3.^ e o .3 \ \ > ^bIU e e U :,n O A^^.> V.^ r^ fl' _ ^>:w r0 IJ 'n OIPIN pa .t.J ^Y ,O W A w ..'.O W A_O -- O tn O ee O N P rJU lv7^tf. Oa - W'O --^0 O O CO O O,O^O C'J O.O O.pjOIO 3.'NIA-NI ^ ^ ^I ^ IpIV W N r- O' GG y O ,p Oa -'O O^)..^1'P A O-6^ O IJ O- ,1.AO4 tn.DO tlO^o y i' 0 J bLlw ^rY ,OC^OC'00 U Cc e0o v. Y zD ^e ^ I C N I .. ^ ..N ^ ( II I u tNi, ^ N T ,UIJ ^- ^D N W^ ^ y'WIA.WIP^ tJ ^J'.O ^I+^ O w J. PjJlO_+1 A W.'/^ O^PJiCI-' (p!w_IJj-^. A A_ O I.^.O -.0 T O i-- A.^IN IOIO ^ (IJItYI NN N )^ b^'^ Y'^I°' V^ oc'De P w.^p -.> v M O P J O b A^D A PN p ^ A J^ON 'C^ Oo11J^T'J,^w.N'v1 A O^G O .eo ^p1O O^ t, w W 'O^ . `J. e i . op l W U O^! Y . P - V Or oo O.I1JI e, o e ' o o=B-a 3. o c a e e -e le o e` o e^`lo ^^e` 'i'I `R T Tt `I ^TI "'I T ^TI Yt ^ h1 T TI ^'ti T -'tl 'tS 'Tl T -rl TI f -+'t•`1'1 "^t TI Y"h `+1 YI T, hlj^Il ^{ _^a '+i Zi TI a ? .^^s^.^^^N' ^ j'^g^p7 ^3 ,,6 FFSCX'F^'ac'.^^IT•T' r _ , =XT . TF.T;F T 1x' %' ' T TS'TI^ 0.3 r'J J 'J' J 3 a! ^3 S;b P"J 3I"J 'J 3,'3 ^J."J^3^3 3i3.3.3 3 7`J.:S 3I:`JIu^3 n^n^nnnn.nnn'nr^nnrnn ^nnnn:nr nn'.nnln`nnrnnnnnnnF C O G O'6^ C C C O O D O O 4 G G G ; O C I G O Oc O O . C ^ F C C C G O C'O G p O 0c 4 O q O ^13^ 3 . ^.^. 3 O 6:? ^ .^"^"^ µ3 1^ ^'J^.^ 5 ^ 3 ^".^I^ ^ ^- I{ !^c-r^x ^ x X^CY C^'' ^ ^ Ci c'{.i d (t n w co wl ^i SFIC '1 7 i O i ^<1^ ^ V^I(<' rt T` f^J 1 ro^^ . M•^N ^^^^mi a ^^' C ia^ I ^ ^^1^^ V^ V P V V^; ( - W IW ^f ^'alJl j21^Y^b^OC. pGOi,'API^, ..I^I^Vr•^ IV'JIIV'thf.)^ O.`h'4•!L' W w V^ IJ^I^IiJ^ U O^ IJ ^ W'tT J t^ViWi J^J W^N p^V ^ ^ Vl ^ I b ..1^4^Ji IJ^xIG.O •'J^IJVO^j^u1 t J^W1__ ^ " , . . ,_ ^_ . J^ . I . -.... - _.. , _. - a o.v.^- oo+l N O V,• ' L1'++d'W ^d. 1. > -A TV GC,W P PI 4^'N tn W. lK' +1 - U IJ 1J Y YI^ +1. 0^^'S0 ^J•-•I-.1 P W 00 ^ A Y 0. W !W Oo'.O D'.L Oa Y PN Oc Y. .O ^l'O I ! -- < ol. V..P NiJ L p0 ^^ CJ^O^^O^N'tJ J.PD O^ J O^o J J^J M1^. J IwJI^ '+ tn:P W0i^ w P b ^'w M J 6..U^y v ^JTid tel^ o D. o W a LIO'V IL.^ ^ w^ O J..m .^O Cd n.o = v' . s e o^< o`. o'• _= ^ ^e^a >. b N IP, P ^.1 ,q W' .qIJ N^W ,N'D^W V ^II2? Pi- J^2^ WpIW G4 tb Y !O ^.IIG4 II JIP :N -- Y^^w d JF-}^ ^l .O iJ-1JIl+, "CIM`O `O'^C'b N -IV^ 3tJNOM.•O.dw O^^L.t.O'f OI^^GW ^ / UID P'fJIO^b N"^'+ ( N,p fplVl.tn 6 O W"^f W.P O O O@I13 OV IJ OtJ IJ. ^ O^ V IOI.O c1w^^^,JO .O P, o ou o°u° ^^^ ^ :x.^o z°y tJ IyJeI°^^o 0 0 ^ c^ ^ 00 ^ 0 .9 i g . . . i ^ -_- . • '- i I ' : . I I " 1! U ._.A O 1^'JJ^tJ`P tLJ:G A^.^ V w..P_oJC OifJ• •D^^.,C:^G^Vi1J'f6Jlv GJC CWpl^+i•O < • _ 3 I^j w y^10y ^ , - O ? IJ w^ O tJ Y io'IJ a '-I+`.^1N "J - I p Up ^i F b^^ IJ YP(M. •O .O D v!O O b'J O10 LO' J Oo P QIO Oo1^GIN PJ;O C IQJiJ'L L b^,fP.'. a ^' I ! : . .i ! ^•-.,y P tn IJ IJ J In.^' U O IJ -- -U:D.% 1.iCCOU SD"SI.^ J'..^O,.IJ .J.,P ^I_w;,p'^,•^l.v,W ^tdlP O:N^N^^ibs IJ OIJ NIU IJ^- O.Y G W-•D ^ W J t] ! WI Iy^.' I I I O O W ,G 1a.o O.V ^ w1U.p. ^ ^ ^ ^:o0 C {d •e S Za .h. H N Q p p ,R,n I6 ^r^. ^ C < _ b l pg R p '-1 "') O J I0; ^4 a nFQO rtq'. OF = p F H o „^ o a. d,^-1^'--3 CT.n G w w C ,. d l y. -I ^,o o s o pno''i Rv. opF S^oCH^p a. n'p ('i 'w^.'6'^ N?N13.^ Y'iE ^.T ^ t : Q $ ?pIR' q P b103t ^n: .T6-ri S `p ^y R,- ,. !'t-' S^ ^a. y Ti s: ^r . IU^;, ., `°; a v"v. v n 'y ,, c !1 I y: ^ . I • -. . b ^ . , . v . . _ _ . !. . w P m +^ ^ D^^!^ N ¢$ti. W - w A P S IIJ T W '- ^ _ ^ ^. V. - v ^ 4 N '.O +^ "ro. tu W IJ Oe: ^O. N P OO C A A P f^^^ ^^ c°. A d U c 1 A W ., ^ ^ d C^O I 10_ W N 4',M P N^Qr ,. O• P!J '.. N C A O• T•O N O IJ J 4IIJIC Gcd,N w, W,'3" U P A. C.p p^ ^ hIP I A J W-- P. A , Va , J I ^ ^ _ _ _ • " . ^ . ^ I . ^ b'l__. I I I. LlvC 1 P by ffii N P•J• N L: ^IC ^ AIOC:N •G R d_µ ^ P 00 W ^^ w N "" "^ J A NiPIM!v o-N" .... W W O^ - s p ^0'W^-IC JI - i W O . J C O N O W p• W A ^ LZ , N 01 J^C .Ii OC W;^ ^ u% hlw LCW^V•IQ O O ^^^tJN^^N °^7` ` P^A I IJ i ._- _^W W: Q• .p •p W O N A tJj O 1 I M . ^C 3J•C ^C^-0iy I.p ^G.. v^ J -0 .p ^c ^ `C 'a V-0-^D ` J• U W P ^c b •DI.O •C •Olb •C 4D ^R^-0^-0 v'^ ` d A PIC'3• P J J v N P p•,. .p •D P C.tJ J .A I ^G U N Ce W P _ 01Id:W J W: d 3^ P TIIX'^CIQ°. O. QN ' A ^ 1 •G..{..C° J' ^ L^1 oj P o . 'e ^ . IV• p GC P -0:N^tJ ,p1 N Do'W I JIm^ W IJI ^I s^.iW l , p e a n\ O O\ \i °•^C ^ OJ^^ \ q1 'o O Ie ^ Ic I I-! ^ I 1 I I (^ 1 a I _. W J 00 lE N 0.^ W I 3N'^.3. O.O^ 1^ WI^ P. N ,N V. ` . A.w^.O C- N b C W `# •• ^ 7 V rb J w.G N C GI ^4 i . Plf v •D w•.n^O^ G^ W d!C ^IN'T^I O1CI C^O C C.C C C C C,O10 O O C A '1 ; 1 ^ N ^ L O C- N C O C . O./• A:OO -^C -- 'p, ^ C^ ^. O ' O tJ. IJ'^• 4 tJ CC A W ^:n'oo a a• oo C -.1 w t ^^ m P wlo, v I O oe.^ J C J 4 b>^A ^ " O ^pp w A 't e ^ o O-0 O ^ ^I^I a ^^. ^ a . e o ° e io - e o^ e o -Fo' , o ! . . . _ : -, 1__^-1 ^ ' - ^ -. _ e .. ^ I • _... . . i ' I I ; ^ L Aq'e .' . II ^' l I LE' O'. I ^ ^pp W ^ = O O C A y, O ^ IJ - Q• x b 4^P -^:•- FIAIp^OI^iw^- ^, i I ^: O O xn - O C . N O J -... . -. . I ^ ol o c Olo ° a ^ o o C o- o 0 0 0 0.0 0° o ololo o c o,C c c o c o'o 0 o y P o l c o c -4 0 ^A LO 4 D^o'O WI I^cI^ w o A P o'®10 C C A IJ O1^ O w ^ U O C_ c• OC J ^. .n CIUTA AIWI °!C^^ p C• s e N I A W.O•IO p C \ : ' ^:° J .Q N .v^+ I`E I \ , ._ °^^^ •J D D. fl ^^0^ .\ 16 _o , ^ ; I j I q .1+.. CII el. ^i ^ U IJ A--^ 00 P. J OC FJ U^JO^^ ^ w A.A y,V•^A 1 U A N [y.^ .t+ e^'.so O I L IN IJ w'IJ N tJ i.^ U;^! IIJ pl YJ w J'.O.. ,^ y .A 4: . ;. .,. . -.- -I - ;. DI,O^W.W1W C V w.P ^'A.'J^ •D GO A d Y p ^• . O^ w 4 ^V N 4 AIU O• A 4 w A'O! A n^O N ItJ O - O . O . ,^ A ^ Or7 C O'O C O O 1.,1 00 ^ fii U A tJ C 4 IJ v A mlz w'P. W .n J^ C> O IJJ P'.0^ IIC^OaiJ^A.A Ni a W-^ PAO A v AI W N P-tn ^ A Nl ^ N P 4 . C W \° iy W:N le e^ Ia. O o° o, c Ic o e o o \ j l a o'- I ' Io' o ^ a^. o^" " o• e eo N N ^ W d 4v P' C> . J O . C'n N IE.R:R N ^N^N f.I N:N RIN N R'• n n^ n C C ry: A .l. R f^N^, N'N ' Wtd^d d d ^^+1 ^ d d d'd d ^- ^iZ [4 r WIW:d m d d W d {J W d;W d!tl W C^` d'A^tl d d L+ ^^"^^ C^ CIC C'.C,C C^C^C-C GjC C C C'(pCIC C^ C^.C C U(/O IIC A^C.C:^J LL UL iRC OC 04 UG '3 W ^O: Fa ^ Fry' UC UC (lC UC Ti r^ . d W ^ d d b b Utl0 W W d C1 n n n nin n n ^ K R d i d d W 95 N d 6 Q` _ d W W d^ W W O C Fj p p ,v.T I ° C I O O^ O^ 6 1 G O C^ O "J C O. O O EJ E, CJ G C C C O ^ C O=Q 6^ C 6 C, 6 D O cr2.1r^,7. e a1c c c'.c c e '.c^c c9 9 5 E ^ `i V`< .^ rv^ . L '..t .'^ `^ ^ ^{ 'G ',`< 1 `f 1`! "^!v kC ;•^ : , ^ v, 'fJO: 0 R ^' N N^ 1 ^T• ,^ ^ ti v^ C , - • . . . . ^ I 3 I O I I ^ g_ , E . , I t 1 . : ? O, TiW IJ N s^ W IJ N W U L U 01' ^A NI4 ^ X w O^',L V F'^- P W ^. w . N^OO^.^ °I F-1.- O.^.. N ^ in A^^W.1+. La A -• Jr -- A^ILII W 00 N lto' U P i! F PiQ` - P T3 IO W JI 00 U^ PJ.`D `O ^i J ' Jir A ^.V^ +l ^• bl- tJ t r^'TIA O^P.^.•yiWiw _ ,.a ^ O^.tUn Urm N tbi. W V N^O^c •-. w N :.- N w o ^ A, a - m OI^^ b N+r.a U IS J^.._ N i...- ^ "S ^: bTIJ O+';-IL'.XpIA t'a W JIN^^J Oi0 W A`^O i- ONi JWi!.^ h O NIN Q` P O-N.O ^ Q b I -- OD IOIP W`D OD W O N ,J - .,_ p^ pp iP W F t ".-^ w^D W P W W 1J m N 1 00 _W_W__W X 6 ^ A J J m J tJiU A_ O h J N •O P ..C'UIOIU:LJ^ ^ p01A.U W Fl At^ O ^_ , • ,. ', p ^ . 4 . ,. ^ I O 'J.•D^'V V^-b"^p^tii V ^L`.. IX.' `D 'J5 `O •D `D CD IJ `On'U J' ^p `O' ^J •O ^O ^^^.p `p^'`DIb^^D .G'D J' OCbI b a J•.I P.J N^P ^"p CO P v J^a ^)'a `t +^1 Oc `^IIG^IbIa J ^ ^.1 Oc P I `^'` • s W Qrv ^-l N UiW ^J ++ m^^J .N A^ J:N O I W - IJ ^fi b OC^U `D4CIIJ^'T P 00 4s t^ N o ^ \ p a ^ DD ^.^ lA U WI--IU6o.A OS `L!m J L J. ^`p W.°' a`p N O¢ 'O'i. 6 IJ:^priJ •L.O J A e ^\ a n ' e ^^3 o^ . a:^2 $• e^ - ^e^'- : D\: a 2°, o\ . ._ ^ w.p i .o c' • ' e cD ° ^^', c ^i • . . . , , o 14 V: ^ m P^' p^ m tn. N`N w N A P^A F X IJ ^-1 .n O^-•_•- ~1 ^. N OC'- N I^ N'A^..• U ^:A:.^ tJ m r- Q.^ N>.co a } ^a C 4 0 - O o 6'C OI C o O o OI6 ^010 o O A ` N ^ b O^ O NIW m.. 4 CC m^f ^.in o U IJ^W N' IU.m `D U OC cDio < F.n^: d oo ^O P ^' bO O -J W O^P J Ja ^u ^ N^e3 O F.^O^a OIU ^ 4 N J C I X W O J ^ IJ `a W i ^O ^ " ` P ^. J.rO 4 ,^ 5 .Q I ^` ^ O O O D _G e e^ D",^ O^ c L . O . , - O .A \. ^. D , p.:. D D . _. . ' ^ . . . \ 7' C . . _ - . . . -.._ . - 1. ^ , - - a ; VUi w .. d •. o J. _ W..J^.w ,N^ F tn. Iw A '.•^I,- tJ 'a W w.-- GO tn J O^V.^O 'J A CIO O P OtA-- ^ O .p ya Vr A:UiO O A b+;P N C^C'^. W . F N m P J ._ .. .i ^ ^l WIU P -- O77 W _ _ ...... _. ... P .. a I I ^ ^ C p'O C O OiO Q^ 0^0^o c o o alo 0 0 4 0 o C o 0 0'^0 o c:o^o ' o 0 l o N W ^ .c U P N tJIV O W A IJiT -i O` Fqa m P o.. P g .o`O .. o \ O.O o J p\ O 5 a`p `J p^P W OOI°` A N^ m P p GC 1 ^ ' , OF °• ' ^ P^O I J 4 m^L-^N.L C C 1v+ ^ 'r rq N. I^ .- ^ N. w I C y, O C X i - J:m `Di w J F W," ' J ^I J W'PI FJ'W P 4 . _ o a^ {JAP •,I J'^•w_ao a^o _'l/`^ cn mI- . , _ . , i. i i O O -J A J.m A.O O^ 3. G A W O o ^ G Q' J. N N al^l^p^ ylA^ ai^'V!O OiO WI1J Q^^QI _m O O a!+^.w G^ U Oc IJ:O 1 N --O W A W.. a, ^ O,-^ ^-^IJiOIA^VN I N t . Y^ ^ o'- . P ^^ D IJ^OtIJ P ^ c cA. e o o^ a ^O'^O N Ia":O ^^a'_ e I^ 1 0 kC \ n i ^0 i0 O. C^ n,n n n n G^'C1 n n nin n.n n n n,n'n n njn .n n n n n! n;n 7 o ie (' ^1•.n m mI^E eu'mmI nr7. ^'. ^.^i ia n R.rt^N ,^^-. M1 i m.m^m,.o mim^n m h n ^ m,m;m ^.^ a ro ii..et• a a.r,a r. rc tC h `^m..,^ laO^M1.fGjm N^^^N N^N^I2yh N f^9'.rt f=Y m^ NN •- t4:m M1 N^R a h l^F 2 R 2 2 nnnnnnnn'n tir,nnnnnnc 3 0o c o n c nnnn!nnip^n o c o o-o o^^o c o c o cc.o, c o oo 9 E ?99 S ^,.9,. .^ o , ! tn tJ•-V.J n,n W:^ nitn T• _:.'TIiC)^!t C) d W d X':X '"'^• I7 ^ T.;2 n^^19,j1^ o. Ei^^h..cld 1o!f, ^ !n m^n^7; m_'^ ^C'-.c -iX•i^S{F -q,7 {O (G: ^-cf21•' ^^'1,dn.I ua IA^ f 1n :,.a ^ ,^n Y v, ,.y,' . _.' y .`^ ^y ( 5.'^'7 (]:¢.V- . I .li`ol ; • ^ Gi U 'Cj!tn'.^^.I'JI'J•;^1^L!N /,'-•iOj^ Alp ly N LI^^GCi0i3P0^0iJiA ^^^]^W.a c^aim^o W --_. -i ! ^ . • _ . ,. ^ . N L^ ^ tJ I..t hJ o:A J IJ.w'. tJ W` '-' J• 'P^^ ^:IJ O F; IJ - +1 W'.J^w 6, P C.N.C w 'J'.n w? J=1tJ N NIA -- A.G9 A- W`O IJ O. :O C ti^ ^J.p IJ C.W 1^ tOi•••^lr^^ GC ^^ J•'^D'P.'C a, n.tn .J !IJ.P O^ ^l.P C^l ^.N_tJ' Cc Go' C N . . L' .p I w u.W •C GR t^i,J J tJl^.> j C J^I,G^e ^` OJe N^IJ^-^.l `OJ w n ^.^C J O^LJ O+ Q•d..tCJ wl'J^i tJO o^o W^ W N O WIIJ O t ^ n F I T e, nO'^. .e^e O c . e" ^ ee ^^ O_> \ --G,O .G ^ e`^d e O .\ O e - - i 0 -^ o .s-• m ,nA: N 11 1'o^fl.>.w..[^va•o..JOO:n c J a v. Oe.....C^_O'____'G,_^..__ ...... _ . x' I w - ! -^. C I^J^,O C fJ tJv^ JfGC W^C IJ'O w L C- C G U^ N'C N O' 'N A^ A J IJ' IJ `.S N' ^ J O O tJ P tJ L', ^D .F N P^ ^ V' w tJ tJ C1 N I V, ' Lia'-'JIJ^-II^O JO^G J,'-A LPCJIOC'o^AJV''WCIJCIdJC e C -^ -^o^^^^:w^.-O L O C C o^-^^C o^.th!^O^o^IN'C c^,,C!C^^ ^-.C C^'oilJ• O_i ^ p;^ A^ A:•w ^n m m.w 6^'u JO J"J ^.l •^.41^,^'tn Oo O.O LItJ.O.A ^.ae ^'ooea.. ^.\a=\-' - ^I pp t.. pC:pci N J-` IJ IJ'`A. C A^L+ .'p^,-l^P J^^ L^OIP W O W C:C"II J J LIN.T --• C.t.. O N P.M^IJ^O J?O o C'w C'-- - O Co NP...G A O O:N IJ IJ P tJ'T IJJ, O O J L IJ'O`fF 00 N^cn o, W W 1^C ^ N- O^ QO^G^P`,n^OalOa L IJ N n; 6^ w^Cs. .t. y vp' Ie Oc • L 00 N.` ^ J.A P^IJ - A Oo Oo..n:0 Ce G`a:.4:•-• \° o' o" le !e ^ N _ C N N N Q^ O),^:CIL^'^ O1N ^j tn tJ-'O^'L'^J N L 00 Q^.a^.VY- Otd Pd+i.w_P ouiJ:v^ W :IJ^,^FV `O'L!J LIJ { ^OiNF-Ji^O^n'L'ryl.,^-y^ L L! A IJI-(O^ V„NIIJ P r J'J ^y IJ t3 L-A'NINjJ .l'.-'.F.L.P PiWiC.^ rr N^'^V-VLFWVL C^OCiiVa OIJ •.n J Oo.G+i .^-^ ,P plOFL->',JIC / S V_W IeJd (J "^J' VU OOCr ^ J.s;J P^^ O^A P pp ,G / I- VO ^O ^C ` W C O L'tn . 'UF V tJ PF'O N N IJ ^V. L I pp V W ' .O I O l d^ a0 . J^° 'v' 'J' .O tD O^ C^ C^ N'J - ^^C 01Vo OL^.1 O 4^ 00W'J.C 06 ^C `CI LJ ^L Jo^ O N^D,IJ L. W 09 O O tJ I\'1 n3. ^ o e V\ \ e \ a` a a\ a o\ a\ ^\ 0\ \° \ F,^ \ \ ^a*°Io \l0 3- e\ o a J^I °' . , u-P N_ _OIN^NIN^.W N I-D^L!L".q WL ^IP ^^^ .,0 ^^ y_^ t C.b ^O_ N C N^C. C.C. tJ ^.C . . 1 I ! L' ''w c Ic o^o c c^ N W co ^ciol loo 0 0 0 OL A VI P N ^C :^ CA L. J P L r P L ^ Q C O^O^O P O IJ w- ^C wiN C'C^ s >^ L w tJ We .l LDIG\ =n:L N O+ Oo N J• J - ^G y !J O O.» ^0:00'O'P ^,. G+:UI + V o rn hw oe >G .. oa L;LT °I^I oic°lol V^A^V>i .^'^°. a> aa ^\a ° a_a a ,a a I _a`al ^\I; ^ai.a < I T L J O^ IW^Vr C Q' ^ N C IJ '.n N.._ . ^'^^ L^ t^ J IW N C C IJ O-GtC I i F O L O^'---^ .O C p p NC O O C O O^O CIG'C CO O C C C C ICIO OI WIV O w L Oe^v P LI^OIO ^ O O L N O O O O IJ ^ N C -^ G O L i^I -' ^n GI{oJ'Q ° O^.Oo N O'^.O Pol J^ O J\-.O O\ NIJIL V^:o L p J L Y^ PI^.1 h L c, e:. \\o ^ a o\ e\i {o o e-a c\iq o.d 1-^ . . _. _ . -,, ,, . ,I _^ • _ '. .-1_ ...... __ 1J : O^Wi O. .J, T . N i ( ^ o^ 6jali,-, ^- o p c c cl=` ^C NI IN^IJ IJ O;^ O W C ^ VpoL'J,OJ-L•^GO +]P.N W O. ^ yy O N1oo ^ OO .O ^^ I ^ 1T W LJ° V+1-O W J L oJ P' W \1\.° \ -\ \ ^p: ^` O a °\I\^C a \ O\!^F\^\ \ °\ ° ^ -^ ^LEW :W^ViIJM ^r= ,p^V^ -'w^.0 a w^oe V!w .nIJ-^! NIlm f NI-^ ^O .L L+1 PO ' .bN^N P^' P4^' J.lltn^^J d L.O i w ^ L 9 O.P;J J P.W WI^ ^ O.N.. i ; , . I 121 IJIC-- IJ W-- C J N^ ^J IJ V..^ V ^ .W O O N'J AO^ NO-- f IJIn O W 00- W A tIJ J W^O. J^m.^C ViOO A''C ^ P O^w - v''O J: NJ V^ I\ 9J Goo V O V> O;`o t^J lr ^D^i•1^0 W W'•^ P VD Pfb bo \O O^I^D V^ .^IL -- N J ,^.L p \I o , a' o o e ='e o'^ o 0 0 o e x x T2 •T' S 2 2 S=Y.^ ^"5.2-2 S 2 Z' T'2^1',T^ 2'.Y! -•".- x ^ x Y S. ^.' = S."".C.S ^g'wl3l^.f^^ q q q 0 o c o'erEO c^o^3•0 0l0`^0^0,.^ 7^.o^b 0 o Eli6 ^.oGlolol^ 0 0'0.^ o^S 5,^7.0 g O o^o^o a'.O oic^^l'c^ 5^'5 o^c.o^oa ! rsl q nn q ^ o v. q n n n f^ n^n n n nln nIn r]^n n n n!7 ^.!n n^n n n n n n n nn nlf` '"^ ^'^ n-^'i G G,G G^ = C O G^^C^ F G CIG cIV O O O'O O I O,pG OC IO^O O IO:O O C c L G KC 9 6 g Ig:6 'J I '^J ^IP Q CCII y!cj .Y "^J'*Z «' ^ '< •2 4< ^'2 ^.7 re .^7 •2 ..t ..^ ,'J .i . ^v tQ''...7 < :7 `7 k < - - !.^ .%!.'Ff IM1f ^2 ^_ e 2 2 ,^. y ! -n.^^ n `n ^n.[n [e ['t D•O C7 Cl OID D D nn n n ri!n^^ ^Im ca .t" t- 7C!',x x'S C1^OIG^:G] 7 G.c w.< ( r''.a m a o^ f^^'?,^ w 7. ^ ro+ e°s ^°o ^!.g ^ r3 r7 ^ o ^ m e^ rs, rt. 7^ a o ^i ^'J ^ G I^' n s m nFi R I< n} c l^^ oa o 3 O G.i ic m r"i "1;F £ cT w 7^'F 3 7 •v a O OI310 ` m,¢ ,^o o£< SI o e.I2^.<;^yl^.<..y^e n^'c:c G c.qv.^^ o..dl^!^^y,xw w.'P.rIGl51 nJo..n q ^IT'°'() :^nr^' ^,o Cnic^r^^n^ <•vGOinan,^ $n['•^s^3^wi i'] ^•Z^<^c ;^ =w!a'^a< ^<'n^ w W T -•--I•D P'w^^ w N w!OI^ IJI -^,N tJ. -'._^i N WIO^w UIU!.'J^iW ^^ E' A^' - lo> OJC:d^'.LOtooltNi+iW L^ J w A^1 J^1 OIA A N A UY/+ ^^[^T A O^ ^!'.!+UiIN A .^O^ilm'U. y W W A W U Oa U dIA A p^ l Oe W.OI.O W. ^ T U: I - ^ N.A!`^1IOIYl4^ J^00^0•D O^ ^ J , . . •DIPI^ A'W ^l Oe^'Jr ^ U ^n U.NIO I (•I I O• NsW Ts - I , WI.O A^Y .+ IJ ^ r.m N A A L.[ U. ^.'R Vr WII V w O^I'b V N OP^ OIN OT tJ ^[ { A W i ^ijT OC T W L!• A^1 Oo I A ,. w 't U O[.^D,^^iW o^IWIJ U.- LI^ GUiO-:O^ OItp.PO^O I ^U y W •J-•'.OVr ^D U twi•w P^O tn,1O N 'J^ N^O^ ^! A . OI'-_ • ^ . , -_ V L .- ^ - • AO^c'y0 O^O O^o^._L Iw,A ^.N O^ ^+W f OOi6. ^ 9^0 .^P V~iIP A r A.ipJ^.^-J^VA.Ia^o ylL^^lUI^itNa. T O O vlti ^-.P!OI^ v!^ v LIA^KW a C.N A^Q JI^^^IO{CI^^'^ N-V^ OJitVJr A'W ^ R O^ A e. -a o.o o e w,\^e le -_ o o o \!o c a c o__ \\°'^ o o le e Io o^e Ien-^ ^ . ! . , , ` W . .'. ( P^ i N,^__al^ W q J tJ^DIA^^N^NIU^^ ^-^ O^'^O TIO NIP•^V V^w L^^J_O O•D •G'^O N W w.U ^G ,P.;O •Olil'_C^__ {.. . - . _ ._, L ', _ ., . . . . I I! , I a '' ^, _ O•'O J^ {--IA W^ Ni6+ A^OpIOIOIA W [J A J-- O O 4-J A O.N Jr T IA O L.^n 00 ^.O V.O -L! m'O OIO^b,NIW.N,Ip ti. w N NIU !O-Wlr'OAOf ST. Ala ^^l^i+ •^O O.A.^ O alo.o \\-\ e`\\' __° \^aeo >, o .^ ^\\__:°_ \ !...:elvy^^\I^E F i ! 1! ! f NIN O OA G'OIO{ C- O w O^OO O^O U^N OC'.w..[ O W Ji-ao J O.O J A O9'tn 'V OI'J^O W T r'^ V^" b N 7 C U^t P^IO J'O IJ O N C IJA-V O`JrIO^ IA a\ t;i^ o Io o\^\ a a e'a ^ o.. 0 - o I\ ^Ia^\ c`le ..-^ ^, ' . { . • , r 1 I ^ _ _ ! ^ •.•1fJ.N IW^'• I^ A, N IJ .b U'A -:N:IJ J P. t^ u A O.J ^ ',T P. p ^A-^'IJP^1 W.oe'^ P^.`D U-JA ae OolO+I1J t NIAC''N 1. oC.UONI+DI•D ...6^ ^D .-'G !J r•..•IL v7 O oo'.O^t-••I [Jlr•O I i0"•D •_ ( . A O N U.A N O{ -• PI-' O Olw'N O, ^O O O V N NNI tJIO'^ w.^! O'. J J^GIO^O ^ OIQ^'^i^0 \\^\,^^ 9G0^ AI\I\!v'j \.O e AI\iOI^ 4^qiJ Lll^-fWjti ^ \ \ \ \\ .'a. ^ e o o 'c 'C o2 0 ^\'+^ 27a: S TTIS^212 SS S 2 2.2 S Zi2'Tm aS.T am S.S a S waa2 S.T Sm'm .J- -^ i+ -I^ rj ym -wm w ww mlw i3S3i' J^g'3 0 o o ' ^ 3 3 ^ . 7 > > > , > >I3i3 3 3 9 3 . ^ 7 7 ^ , ^ 3 31000 p . p In O(O On O O'O O OIOO ° O O O O:O OO OO O°O OO O^ OO °O n C O O OO O j0 O O OO O F c C G C C C G C C_C C^ C^^^ y Fj^ 3 C C p C'> >^.S 5j.^5o^l G,c^g--c^:>>>>.> F3 G2 < ;•2 < •2 •< :•? 7 ..; ^c ^e 'Z ^r < r2 < ,< .^ v •7 ^t < « v . ?<' < r ^e .. f t i I 7jz z z z z z.z'Z 31r z:5 5t^ 3 3.^ ^°a ' v v'in n^ .n ri:',.v: v .v X'.^ v v'-3 m r ;-m'^ot j v x ^^>Iw O ra m roln ' .^I^l ol° ° . o ° °' F• m }}}'m r<£ IS^SI Cc3^c I -^P5' : n^'°'a. ^Ijl3 3 W 9 3 5-myi^i^ <^Qiw ntrCp°j^IWi^^°^clol° a^° .t.,a1mICIIa^ ^^Ia ^n"^q ^2a m ^ ^ Oi<2^ a 1JSa' "' al v I •,. A ^ ro0 ^:^ ^ { I roI nk l O nI^ . a ^ lo -n ^ . [71O (^1ro x^a <1o ^?.t^ iw l ro (m in SI12. ^. IZ ^ ^"ts^^ 'Q i7°c n!Gr i (.) l o Iti :n ^^j ^°.Ih ^ _ FIfJ rv m Y ,ty{C7 C'7C7:a I I !^I 1 ^`^I • ' pn, ^ I ` In l , ^' f° G ty! I I (^I t n I j . j I ^ I i Ia' •oi L w o0..^ ^ v^ v' •DIC wl ^n w P c.- - w A I W ' ^:^C a Y, J I ^ Y JthIA^. ^l1J N.l lOt^ta a tA p P N.O^IJ ^p^ !J WIWIN^W'W tT `ll'.Q^^ a6 V. U.O^^aO O J^F.O^{tn J.9^.OJ..a^P '^C^V^ Y't^ tr W O P t^i.P OD b{M..O Oo V^ A ...... ! , W W W 1 J N^IN W A:J P CC^P^^^O] iJ Ih;PP.OG:.wW iJ 3 U iCiIJ . ^ a NINII,i r J•:bla L^11} C IJ " W'N J JO IJ P atN^C1A C._W 6^L0 IJ 4C.V• - VIC.^ ^.W C bIW N P!lnW +] 0.•^ WW{^ V• V^ O tJ IJ.A J N A WfVIjA J J W J^J U IJGe ^ y .- ^I .J .. . V O.- tJ.y A A p^ J.J- a^'J L^ l..C h a Jr J w.'.° ^O `-^''a •DVJ ^ b Y. O .p '.J{L JJI•°Jj.,^,Ipp Oc o6.m'U A W.O P^.*xi s'd A J'eJ Ot d'tJ C^ P P J Y W n A vriG^ w .n C^ O^'n O P-J^ tn 'J^ ^..•r ^D.P '^ P^J lJ.03 •D AI O6 I JIA^^-' F'°.^ O J^..^ VI W^jJ'IJIy ^A j^ WT ^ as'c,°81o No^{ 2A^^ c f saI` ^\ ° Ae j^ o`AAio Aoa.^j> . . .. _ .^_ II^I^ i I{I^ y Wlja.^.A ^CV PI^ JWJW ANW^i NC.N.J f I .,p•3.iJ NftJ. IL^ WjWI^J. W J !J J W N V^ 3IJIA,•N - o,a.niC N C'A'tJ U.a AIC C^: I J.tItl^p .iJ ^y'"JiP•OIC ^C^'h 6'IJIAiU^Ca 3'IO W A-_Vr J'^ P Yi' I t I IA an. ' IL{IJI A w w IJ ^D ^ O•nCj^J•- V I+^O 0-1^C'A N C J^PIC.^^JICOtJ O d N IJPW C C- NIp^OIN -' '> FJ v.^ P..3. P.{Op v S^P Gc L V^ 'L Pv^ A L O.alv. t.11°PiN rn O6 q: ^. u m A rn^wioao °^°:'p1rJ^ o\o Q.^.r^ w^I:e I.°81^R ^ a a^,o oe x o ^.. oo c e o ntc i o• t_- { i - Iw{^Lj.NP3< A - °• N ^p J ottn N ' Y P 1 L a o .n _J o W ^b.A a: IO^I.L{w A:wiC WI;niLw o 01. __o Y_.o._ ol c -. w L - N •s p c ^o_otc+iw1 . .a{^ v..^ J.:C L 1 p N^ IO^O O OI-IC- C- O C O Vi - C C.-•IN C Ai- O OIC C I IJ 00 .J f-jJ - N O w C ^ W^n -IG O^ O t .1 O. J in ' C^^ ' D ^ V.OC W1O N N C CI^^C^C •C. ^ O J.I^IIJ ^ O OJo V O L V ^o P Cai,i JidJ A,L I^ .QO o la o o ^l o ^ta•;c . . . ° ;°-t¢\ '^:..`_... ' J'^•p N.J .-LJ. C^Y P-^ 3^ a C IJ.IJ;AI^ W.V`t0 J.Oi1J J"3^ '^J C^^J^O4 A ' IJ tJ C N - O C V^C -^ 1 C. 3 NN.O O V^1 t+1^ ^ O1 OIt11 J IC WtIJ p^th. C.^ 1. J a O N+ J GC p W-A V•IN IV_AIOaa:^m V^ViICLba.T.P .,1 P u N^i^I^jW.^>wJ,WJ a .^ > L . eo' NhJ^p.60A1JL^Jb'Lte o 0 0 o_I-. a . . ^r2 _ ^- mx5-SxTs.^sx l3..^i q ^I^ ^^^ 3^'1' ^!^ ' o.n n n n n nln n'olo^9 n n?I O.n.ICIOIn^nlnlo n^c- n n=n n n .^ _^_^ 0^>i(^) o an nooo 0 o.e c o 0 oIO ^Ic o.o'o 0 0;0 0 o a'^ o oo o a ^ n n n . n n x'.x^^ XIxiT'Y^F Y^x^X }nr ^C ^ C.; 7:> .YlA' ^CcFI . ! I I (^,n,^ l,i[7(7iC]-n 0,0 10 0 a O q ^7 '^ 0j0 OG10 0 OOEO1OIO OIOO 0100;0'O C G plGl^ O OO O O O010, '^ c. ^ G c10 ICIGiC ^ b ^ yC bI 10O G 3P D ^t1 ^17Iy ^ c 9 10 9 !9 y `'^ .g ^^7 4` , 22^Q2L^7i2^^2^2 C22?G7^2^ ^ lv,7^gl iE I _ A { fii^y I ^i g`'^ On oR 1 2^Glg I ^^5 ^^. 0.h2It 5B!a I^ Ic 3'sp ^'r^o ^va o ^'o m SH ^nO'a:y 3^. o. n e..<$ & ` I ,t^ • 'r.,4 CR) , " -° •o IO g ra I^I A Ir I ' I ^7- N 6WWW tA ft.IJ N- NI U - i :p ^ p.','p i^a J`o0P.0 U o'.IJ^ ^ A 9 V: J A N O^J^tJ tn A P'Oi O W^^^^^DIIJIO ^N W rb N.^p ..T^^O W U rV^wN" W:DJG K^,A.OV*N^V:^wIWlT AwNocAJDV:_^' r^_ " - wt 1 I I - "' - N CG J^ . o. A:n.N NI4p^0 ^IO tn^v^i:000.W'WO .C N A10^ N W w''rJ wIa-^CIU ANi^ W1-.l^tp p W P~ ^D .N w JVi N^ (T 6V AIO:GaIAINIJ ^D'.^ '-- ^O Oa N GC'CO'0.1.1 •+ 4A O - JI T^p'J J V^ C^ W b P: J tJ.^ .D ^D vh O 'D `^ `^^^D D ^G V.9 'V N ^U ^D 6 ^O .O'^D. ^D ^D^^OI'V v v V ^D ^J 'J G+ JIVV.^tIOa J A.J IWI t:P 6^.ti1 00 ^O <'^ ^^ p^ .I.p G Opcp J Oo T'N^l 'J^N ChC rJ0'A'O A A GO w +ht'^ N.N ^^ Fw olt^i: iiiA tPA:^-^ w^^ i}iw.w .VD:W A^OAiINI^ o ^ a e o pi'Im -o o- o '\ \"\ l e Ie ^\ e . a ^a o e a-o-e a> e ro ,e 4 ' ^ _._._.._ , _ ' , I __ • I _ 0 N^O ^ -• O O O:O O^" N'iN- - ^ -- O _ I' I :_ . e.L N!NINAV'Jlv^ ^ -- LL". J^C V: A t . RI a GO ^A O.O.- 1. \^ ^\\ip^ol\\^'o\\O_ I I J 41 ^ v 1M:t.:i.^ P 'A .N W .w A O-^G ^ aolA'^Dtn-.P :AV. J J t.: Q+ A ^ I .. . ( I ^ ^ I . I 1 N w O s' ^ N O' N+J a-- N^ O A ^O N!W O J.[A.... N O.W nl .- Jt - O'• .i(ll.l'L> A BO.U Ot A N ^ C'^ A t.+ wD'N W 1h.J0 ^"t A c w.0 l+ JN l^.DO AItJ pI^LIO OIA J J P^liOl^W N V^ N L !J O N AIO^IV^ ^ a^ J A IJ .A N,A-V: 9 o;O6 e OO' o ' :O' C o e.e \ Ip • o o'p^ o ac \ o 0 o a e C c^ op O ^.O >\ ^"'O 'c () ^.. S' 2ix -)• 2 2 Y2 Y^' "'2 Y S S Z'{ ^S T Y 2 212 Si'^ S T'.T' : . ^S YI•T'!x' x ^ 2` ^d d M d^>IY C'd ^ d N I L+ I i , d N t0:d;^ 5 T v ^..aldi^ Yld ^^d d^^..•dv ^,d d ^^I^ 19 ^ E _ ¢ G nVG{G^¢ ylO , •^ N ^ _ ', ¢ G 6 G 6¢ G ^ G 6: 6._ C G¢V6 G 6¢IG j D 5 3 O O ^ O ={ q ='y Ci = '> =I= O .>,C ' O^nIn^A ^,r ^ A'nlr t^^A I^ A A n A AiA n n n r) A o I O aO 100 0 O O O O O 0 1 0 O C O O OO O VO O { , C{ ^ ^j AA L^ r (^S 0 AA A ^ C^ CC Cc F F G K 1 F C C G Gc C. C F Op O O O 0 0 O 0 6 G = 1 ==1= ==!=V , 2 ^^^•^ e. "G ^`Z.ic_,__^ ^7 ^=4^7•G^^{ ^ =Ir^'i'^Id°r` d^^t!c{.,>,4p o.^^In2 ^ Ir, h pry•^^'.rEL {, : ^ 19I^ °=7^c!^' ao rz;ca- ^ ^rt d -.ry ^lo ^ I Q r1^i^N l4 If ('j <^ G^ _ =.^'i^^ •"}yV > J ^^ 0 ,= P, x y.o..y H lI =IJ^I .<.. o^^ r:•^o.= Y:^. ^ E SV.?_ S-.yITS^^.b g^2^^rq I . ` { I I ( . Q fIt . pp U^ mSN ^] tV . .^ ,J N^ M" w, O.w Q^ ^C N- P s IJ L.00 m ^SJ,V /: W ' x` w.• J O•n. ^F F P.V^ -JIA.- OC *MIJ O•P.U w O• N w tJ o P°Q^ J L l]t s . N Ni'^ , k. P.-+1 N^ o ^^^' y^iV) ^^'n ^ ^ p:a W^o ^ ^+ p.mc • N- - N C C N'O - O oo O . tJ-IJ IC J w.pp ..,t ^r V, w.O;tn v L P^: J-- . _,_^ . . ,. .._...... ro . _ 'W . N JI V^^ ''D9 IJ . J IJ N ppD N IJ. w. P L^ O p• P W W^J V• . N.In W ^ im t.3 ^ G •J ^ 6^'m . OG. P U OOi00ID O V' ^U Lt.) ^`p^ : C O O O^W P . tp .O {q^W,p l1 O'P O O P^'JMInS''D;IJ.IJwPL'.^D P'•./•'IJ P O -]'.- .^ O_, Ov m;^O-_. O _I NmIP^W.A'JJP-- _ I . pn a a .c,o .G a p.^ 'J .C al'.o^c .o v .o 0 ; di.o `CI ^ .O n ,c .7^.p^c^^D a i m , m a m nc . J a x o . a.^o %,q n :c.•a :,t. w .o ^. aw oecy .o a, v o•. .c m P m J J w J --, J a . y co ^ o- m ^C^ {J O O^.IJ'O^W O IJ L'N J W,.W O^ AIW .O Vt'.a L^ry ^ w " J^O AP pp D^N^ d •C VN,V O , mP N W':6♦o W Y t. N6 A O.Ip Q Lo ' A O-{m N11^5'f? . . . y. - N . . , . m L O,^N:P w N N'Q•'N O^ m^C N :^O •8 -.w.- P ln •O,'^ {^ .. ^^ 4. IcC O eA "-' U O A C A '. ^'^^OOCCO'C 0,-60COOCC' OOC'OOO.O C.C COIOOOOOJO- 1J C m D IJ . J L. O N N ) ^^J . O J IJ L^ C J O P Pl ^'^ w NO C O N^O - U p o qOtCJ L+,w VC^+A N ^w-^ O VmGCF• m POU"V:Q^CIOwO^ O a 7 ,• n e O I . O C O'^ C .< i C .. _.. S , OG o' OOO '.o o^ o O C^ _^. ^.^ '. . ...^. . . __ .. ._ ^, 1 1 (5 ^ . . . , ...... ^.:^'. q. N N 11 IS'. O P JS ) > ^j 'w G:- l+OtnG ^D C_O NSpI.- CIN -O O N.-.Q w I N !:U O L O^-_w C 'GG O O C CC ,C O ^'" O O O OG'O'C C O O 0 C C CIC O.O C OO - O O p^0''C O A . o U^ J ^ r O O:IJ -Q ''.W W C Q ^ N b 0 Oc FJ 51iN O J. P QG W C P p N Olw'-•N O w O p A O m'OI, ^O^ 4^ p ^^ o ..^ .e e ^ e^ a e o c , . ! i .. . . . ' . _ . . - _ _, ` '. . _ . , ,,., _ _^• .O y.- O N 1J N- O^ O O' 1 •D O , w J ^ •.n L O O w ! O W w G'.C.tJ P P ww V - U I , ^ w ^ ,p ^i P^^m - C ^- ^C w cn e•', CI^ N O N- C O - C O tJ'-0 O O O O O O C QOIO OIC O.O O Q tn L O P N C•+ 1• In LN CACF N N J: J O W Uw ^ N P^ O L O !V• N \:D',P iJ ^l NID LO Ioe P I) C3`!w. ^.O O O^ \.o - ^ a p ^ e a^ e^o J 0 x.Y:2 S!.^-: Sr..Y:2 Y Y S'. !T^T S 2 . R ry tYG N^ N t'^r lxD /Y4 N - f2'/ n t_^D 1 l^9 ' A ro n RN l^C R^.. lTJ 1 +>^ O.aI'^ a 9 al'3^. a^ ^°( ^2^^^`^>a7a'a^z,^a z^^`'.^.^a•'z^zi^ 0 0 oj" oi°lo o',o .na3 0 ^'a0 0^0'0l0 ala aia ala a^aala a,a o ^^n•n^n^nnrc^nn.n^n;n I ^lo oicfo 0 0(0^040 0'0y 0 ^9191^^30 0 0 0'0 01o0E A^ 0 0 0 0!0 0 0-00 0 ^0!0,,0100 0;^ €j^•^ry^^ clal'^Ir^ r 7^?i^^717 ZaI?i . zIv 77 ^h2 ^lo ^ ^i^a ^ oCo Fyl ^ ! I. 1 I ^ L-- Ibz! w2 RK b o s.^^ a^,^ ra) ^ o s,r^ .a tw Iw < ! D:a u < a •^ < ^ ^ }^^c i-'^ f` : ^. <^oz a^ < w m^ v m ^'v s.^ ^ ^w^^^ y°^i°`'^^^^o 'T) - ^ t.j6i t+o ^ ag ^3 $ ^ 3^ ^31'• a ro ^^I^I^^'^^i^ .^ 3 m 5-v°^''^^ ^ ro°I I NI I N T A o A'W 00 J T x O O^ W IJ -N'.n'NI`O - "U1`+ W C w;N N tJ^o^7-- O•ur ^, !1 IJ^'h -.IAI W^M.O o;.;b UIO N N Vr d. tn +t W A o 1; oIA^N `y0 y-O 0 ^"^ N G O.ty). W W;N y(JI^O!O w A W V_: r W_r- . . I I W^:O `D^b^`D^o b10 `DJ'^ `D C ^^ O b v, v^ ' Y^ G O D' `D O JJ v b P J.`D--1 A .l G4 ^ppC ^p ce y o4 `O `C `O Yi' `D U ^p y `O vl 'J 3 P,N Jt O q-.,. b w^0` tJ0 O O°` 'J ^^ iJ ^' °' ^' J t^l J O b+ W 4^ O vr ^ A 1 ^„ ^ O J+l `D. Q^ .I J ^ O ;J NI N." oo Vrx ^ w O+ 0°.^i rn piN 6:^ `G O O"xW J J P' A A A A IA tJJ v W A w 00 L . I v„ o \ s' ^a°,o \'^.o c \< \lo v,vI ^lo v _^o ; ' v o_ 5 y. r^tJ O d] N O J O O- tJ oc o.0 O'OjW-O IJ U N.^tJ.,C^•Vr'NfOi-•:N -^'J.N^.O tJ'O w ^ -J __ _ __y_ I_ _ . . . . • ^ ^^ ^ ^ : O^O^0.010 O O'^ O O^0.010^0 OIO^OIO O AC C 4 N^OOo^.OiOlO ^.^ •W O a0.^10 N W N O,O O e'.^ O-'.°IA O^ ^o ^vr g.^' O W A:O O.W,vwi ..^^ ^ N J vr twir x xIVrW W O°.OC0 0 \ \ ' • I 1 °.".J\ \= ^ ^o ^OI C 610 a \-\ pA.p A A1\^e a ^o ^e o wl I '. ^ _ . I tJ':wla^i4+,y+ AI W I.JjN10._'^ - 6 ! I I ! I I O O-o'o•O^O C O-N O C OIOIo C^OI^ ololo'o;o o c o^ o oo^o^oja o 0 0 o^ot? wlolo^olo^w c v w oblo 0 0 o w y WIA - ^O AL' O IJ ArtJ^N '^ w A- ^w "^IO.OO O tJ OO `o WW C^ O O O-O^ e \ICOI\°. o'a\ol^lo e ^ g^ oIo'e e.^.^o ^ o i` ^.-1 ' _.. _. ., I .: ._ - . .. I i 1J -. ^:UA aJ W C^ O ^^^I^^ol^ rt[J a o ^'.O^c o AInIJN 1 ?^O^O O OG O OO O^c.O o C' O O^O A w HJ ^ L- ^ 'w'cn w A^r-oo -a:w^-,tw ^CN rn`O t.) I •^. o.-!o -^.ic o o.oo.o 0 0o ca':'c^ O O b IJ C tJ oc V`° Ar^ x x:P -P `O O w S^ A o v.. C . A '. b:^Dl c u+ U O l^J W W J. ^D' y'. O^ r w W W O` '.^. ^^O ^.-',n a 'SSSI S2'SS't•.+..ST^ -^'S''YT2'S.^' n ISIJ. X S'.S S S S._ 3fte!<1^o,qus`-^i^,^^i_^msi^s'^'^"I!^^tTS:^ ^'^c!PSi^'s^T^^4jVS^^?;^s°-r.2^•^ FiF F .'r T'IF T^ C' m y ro '.M v .J w mq ^'^^'o N M7,d ^^.3 v x73 mo- ^i^o.n;n yj t co^^^ ^,^'i.^'^O,-,U,:do'^^'^5 d G16 ^i^i^^'!sjo d d.dldt0- p-s'^. d 6.0. d d didld d 6 2 dIGIC. R LI^ C fi p0 0'J! !IC nln,n nn n'n,n n'nin ninin n.nr.,n.n r n n nn n n,n ^Nn n c IC^OIU OG O Oi= O F O O O'A;^ CO 0-0101° O (°a0 °OUIUI G O O O OLG O 3^^^'^ G OI^ G^^ ^ P ^77v'•r•? `'^•%+^t ^ {,^I,^J^J a' , , i . I u ^G O .i,..P.: (y) W b ? ^I^^o;.^h MIO tJtA ^ JCC 4J'. O'^-.W Ua ^I^t^`O 3 A;w: J. J N A J•h.•^ b N b 3r CJs..-0IIJ -,W s)i'O,^UIV•I^I^L N N.A'O .G%.^.^W^O Ll^f V GI^1S+: N ` ^^1 IA!w w-_G'^..^1 wIA oO:O ^A y.0^'T C:h W-^A w °.,-•., U. w;.A^tJ 9 3 3 wyA `:P O s^Q'...C A w l^i. N^A-1 IJ.W^J Cf;; -1. A oc W^^.wi. ILJIW ^J^'^ ^ O^NI7!OLD wiw O.^'..m O^0 O^aI i ^n: • { I ^'. .° ^o^^o .c v7 e ^o G'^ tG .G ^^•c w ^G^..nI^cl^fa .c .c^:^ •°!•c,.e v^ ^ v^ .o .u a^v'!J^W •o.^c J Oo ^) '^'IAI{`-1 ^ q 04 ^1 r10e 09 06 ^I.J 00 ^-t^00-'J 41 N^J..O ^ ^l J"1 O.{ LD ^OIOO:^.I O A W N C O'J^0'V.A 31 DffOC O IJ Oo G^^: IJ^ W OLv-U,L^1'+QO I.Ji W^oC .Li. a.QJi^.0^0 w a^o OD^O^,a O ev oa7 oo 0 o i g,oXl o I^ie -^ -r A Ij jw -^IJ.;Ge-,w'.fi W IJ^- U^'OjN.G'^AI•i.^A A G:^G C O'.L> O NaJ^.•- ^ . i I . c o^G,•^ o ^o;G^c^. v. c.ci-^G;o^o1 o!p c G o o A oIG o G'^;o p w'.^.^ N O IJ V.' N N V. i% W ) O t.n O> C J C f{ L O O. IJ J L J' J ^.cn10o^J^J W^6i d' O.G ;O OIw J' V O p AV ^ o j ! 7 . ._ . . . '. ^ ^ - , , • ^ ^. . I i ! I -.,.r,7 N W p O-"t A.GI•D^-•^G'AiN ^^^ ^-1_O O^NrWIAIIJ L- ^^ O N:GIO _IwI O -Li•.0.0 O O O'0 O O Oi0I0'O^O 7^ O O O OO'G O^G O O G O O O O C•.`^. ^ 'O OIO O O O a pLG O. ^O O^' O O J O.O- q^O W Ol^OIO^ OIG^IO W J O O OaIN'J O ^ G.J Ca WIp^..O e.. p e C N Ic b d. •J^O^C.OICIO I^a .D ^ C^JIV O- N J C.'G;N J;N J peINIAI.,: tA . . . . _... ^-._ ._I I _ . . , :. I , I i I _ 1 p p^G G^ olG o G o G G o'o 0 ow v. O'O!c;olG O o G;? 'o pi^l o N G^c^G c ^! aIL:,A 'W \^.p O. O:{ ^IIO ^p'P..N 3 iJlw •D ^10'i. A.^ °.IP.GI:N J-°. J C.O O+ G:GjOOIV' '^.de+G J i^.iJ J^•L ^ ;^I . IJ tJ ^^! a^\I^I^^a ^IJ'\I.. ^ °\ p, e.Io : : e- e_ io O`.e O`:C e IG o o o!olo 0 0'0l0'.0',.010'0 0.0 0 0.0.0`0 oao^o!ol n n n o^n r n n:n n n n^ln i ^ ^ s aF 3^^ r:s^.s: F r r.ac'rl'Flrir s-:', H ^'w°:nowo^a rcm .aG c.la^am^o ^v, b^' rw ^^+. o x;er o 7•^'?r .'w .;3 wI c m jt n m 6 a ^roig^^. v ! W w L. ,^IJ! Wtr !wi :U .F NI ! J ^y;.^ ^ ^ yr tn w^tJ Q^^WI IU IJ.tA W^W WIAiW;GIwtJIJi1wJ^!.D Oi p^^IJ^^D IJJ IJ r.W -^- ....^_ _1 ._..._^. t 1 ^ P _ N ! w:R IJ w ta', 4) sl'--^ tn.Ai..^ ppI ^`. .O yU W N GG .IJt 1. Ipp^W^tJIEC O. .06^IJ 4 IJ O `U'. IO ^pIL^O.^ ^Ip^p N_w J w 0^6 W y^p •c'v.lv7=-'.T Pix OO-..baY`. J O J,CO_WIO! -^u+'O:.^DIP .Jt^'^'iG1i1JIJIU P^1^ ._'P $-i1JiPidf^IJ:O , ^ ^o'.o!.alw ^o .o .ow o o w •o-^c ^c v^^^al.o^,ofa U G O+ ^^I'1I^'.`•l 7 1 M `O ^0 W ^C °.G^ D J WIR O W Ib^J m J J'W p n,^, bI.pIW!'3 ^1 ^W A^L ..9 O W(T L^IIJ'W: J O U.A'. w L'J W L P'a P^'^ P' P W.O ^c Y.'^ n J .GI,DI.n'^J eY'.e o. O''- i^'^.^ o wl i I k i i o.o o,o a o o c a,o n. o 0 0,,. C O O O CIC OIO IJ C OC O OO O O O O O OO ^ O IJ J O w C J -d C!r OI 3• O C - 4 L+ r J 0 0 1J 0 N O O iO 4.n P C'.O N GC OT O O-J: W ^ Cs. N -O pIU J CaIOC •J. W P+. N J A N a A A' A O A pA a'^ `^c ^e'o c-°•o o'^a,a i !o a' ^ p A ^ ° a .e C c o ^OO V, ^I WIO!a'tn!NiNIT --!C.'%^CIQiI ._-.^IJ P. O L. .NiC w w.IJ Sa I ^ I I ^ O O O 'IC c IO^p!O.O C^O Cj0 CIO^OIOIOIO,O C C O O O'O O O O C C O O O O N V- IJ NIOO N ^J O IJ O^O IJ .aP O fJ O O C^ NO IJ10 tn N O y N O O J!M ^l ^p;O;O!^ p I\ O^J,IQ^ ( N^.J L'J O.A W.t/^ 4 o U V W L-.O i i 1 ^ w !y v^0 P s^N!-^O Iplpi',p':J:6d . i . ., ! . . . . 0 0. o oi^'N oioio otojol^ o c NIv^ o oloiololo oocl 'O c^c o oIc o!o J o w J +. L ">.J J' L '.b GO [J^"14)1w d)^ V J G^ P^ 0^ OA ^IWIJC PN'w'0:^1 OOi /' Jlla IJ ,n iAiL+ O LN IGCIO L IJ n.P RI-n L.OO+ o W.POD^'J A O P J a w..[a:4 e v o.VV`\ °olo^^'o 66.71% 65.40% 61.30% 5.07% 1.82% 64.54% 63.90% 64.11% 4.11% 1.21% 64.26% 61.20% 57.05% 16.05% 2.01% 64.03% 63.04% 60.62% 6.67% 3.20% 61.74% 62.00% 59.05% 0.89% 3.86% 61.14% 60.60% 61.05% 1.53% 0.93% 59.38% 59.92% 57.34% 5.33% 1.66% 57.95% 58.34% 54.92% 2.77% 2.64% 57.38% 57.38% 55.52% 7.72% 1.85% 57.22% 61.30% 58.32% 4.56% 1.30% 56.96% 53.45% 46.85% 5.56% 4.07% 56.89% 58.529'0 55.95% 1.08% 1.12% 56.34% 58.40% 56.33% 3.37% 1.08% 56.2995 48.83% 49.35% 2.16% 0.69% 3.149'o 0.77% 56.22% 3?tf# baS E bia'rfi1g Ct ^2(tS$) 56.53% 55.41% 44.63% 7.46% 1.12%. 54.67% 2'Iil? '^rank E,^7^afe f^ (2.Di8), ^' 47.68% 52.80% 52.10% 48.34% 3.41% 1.73% 52.69% 53.79% 51.12% 2.69% 2.00% 50_18% 43.10% 19.28% 3.90% 52.02% 51.54% 50.43% 46.209'0 4.00% 2.95% 49.05% 46.27% 6.88% 1.29% 48.68% 43.76% 39.94% 2739% 1.71% 46.81% 45.59% 45.87% 42.12% 6.65% 6.23% 1.10'Yu 44.58% 30th Jason Wilson -D- (2016) 46.51% 49.90% 3.00% 6.37% 1.5095 38.67% 32nd Capri Cafaro -D- (2016) 37.29% 38.95% 7.11% 38.28% 23rd Mike Skindell -D- (2018) 38.049'0 34.25% 8.30% 1.37% 37.50% 28th Tom Sawyer -D- (2016) 41.09% 38.42% 14.40% 11.40% 3.13% 37.43% 33rd Joe Schavoni -D- (2018) 36.60% 38.19% 5.67% 33.76% 11th Edna Brown -D- (2018) 31.43% 25.92% 23.07% 2.54% 32.83% 9th Eric Kearny -D- (2014) 31.93% 24.96% 41.53% 6.41% 29.59% 21st Shirley Smith -D- (2014) 18.55% 13.44% 50.71% 3.92% 26.23% 15th Charletta Tavares -D- (2018) 27.75% 22.98% 33.63% 1.36% 19.33% 25th Nina Turner-D-(2014) 20.48% 15.29% 57.66% 1.31% 64.05% 0.64% -0.06yn 60.47% 3.06% 3.42% 61.73% 0.99% 1.11% 0-2E-r.°r'o 61.36%0 0.54% 0.31% 56.62% -0.515, 54.72% LD.39',5 q XJ 55.52% 0.00% 0.00% -4.iIL% 50.21% "^^ 3.51% 3.36% 55.34% -1-63% -G.6?Sa -2.06% 54.92% 7.46% 5.57% -i3.31% 6.99% 49.00% 0.70% 0.66% 50.06% ':.10% .U a 1.84% 47.15% r'X^^ 1.11% 0.95% -0.s79A 3.05% -028% 47.93% 40.14% 1.38% 1.19% 0.24% 34.63% 3.59% 0.83% 2.33% 0.90% 11.04% .5s9'. 1=-15% e e^_, e S e C e e e e o' < e e e e= e e e°'^ "^ O ^ C rn M N N^O ": ^ P P `T n^' V h "! P . M"x O CC O O " N T^° m 1' O 1^ N'- O".C ^ 1.= try O Q^ '. h N P'- . . e e e^ o e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e o e e M1'+ °^ ^ N^ ^n N C^ P P M P M °. O M h h Q N^/1 ^ Q ^p c0 -+ 00 ^G O rn N eG - N oo O m m Um O^^O Q t^ O oo O ^ N[^i P P Q Q h ^ M'' ? N . m! O O^ O°+ P!G cl O Q O^° ^': M^° ^O - V a O? O O O v^ -" N- v^ C '- O- O N P'c ^^^ ^ P M ^° ^+ ^^^ ^C M^D "• 3 y x e e e e e e e e o e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e^p ^ L- M I^ N M M M O^ O b W[^ b l^ Q N V^ N I^ N^^° W P M O - ^° M1^ N f'M O^ 9 m O^n O m P vt a0 N N^D ^D V^n M Q ^D O^ V) O^ 1^ t^ GC N O^ P tm YP O CO GO M1 N Q oo ^D co O O O lV M(V N^G I^ -- i0 O v^ [V ^O ^/i '- ^ N L Y Y N p N ^ tj. Q^ m ^ OO O^ ^^^ M ^_^ ^ ^O [^ °^ O N N N^ (J N N N N^ F' tN'1 ^m'1 N h P P N ^ N N Y U Z O o e e e e e e e e° e e° e e e e e e e e e e o 0 0 o e e_ e e c o e o-Q e Q 6 0.^ b N T M b a h b^ ^^ P b N N(N`l r C b QN. vOt O vPi m O O P P r^ P^ M1^ N W ,^ a--- -+ + -r m ^ ^-N R^ O 1^ M N --- N m^n M V P P m M- O M N x ^ ^ a1 G e e r e c y^ ^ N M y^ 1'^D e o o e o N M CO e e e P P N yl yl e f^ Ot N o o a ^ 00 P^ M^• !^ O^ ^ M^D Q W N O M M W O0 ^ 1^ O^ O ^° ^O ^O C p PP^O NO P M^ MN h a0v^ N . °^ N P N M O ^1 ^^D N 00 `O T Q,' ^G tV oG^D oom M oo O^ O cV O O 7 N^^'i tV [^ pp N^ P N M-- h N P h v^ P v^ ^D .. T N-^O N^.-. O P D .-. ^n P N N m Q P W T o e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e o e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e o L W M m M1°^ O O- 1^ 1^ ^et vl m P ^l T O^ P V^G O^ P O Vi W N CO -^1 N N U P N ^O O^ O^ G 1^ N-^n t^ ^n N O^n V^ P GC O P N N^° - M-- ^n CC ^O CO f^ P O 1^ C^ b N O^n ^n N O M O G N O^ ^D OP v^ - P N M K O v^ m lV o0 1^ T t^ ^ O^ M M N 00 ^D P P N N^G 00 N-- P O^ h ^n v1 3^ v^ vi P N ^ ^ N M P P Q Q Q P n P vi P m-^ P b M1 m- N ^n ^O M b ` V M e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e o a o e e e e e e e e_ e e Y^ m I^ N b f^l ^D ^ O^ U M tD iO y W M^'/t m m N^`O 1^ b 1'^ P M1 b^° O^ W O^ CO N q M M1 M O Q P^ ^ M1 b Q^ M1 '^ `°. P G^ ^D GO O h[ N 00 M1^ 1^ O N M M-- O-^ '/1 r" p y M P O^ ^ O^ b P I^ M O^ Vl ^ 1^ M M O N m M1 1^ O P O N f' W O i^ P P b^^^ O OO o-. (y. P^D ^/1 ^O b^n N -"- - -- M eh P'n ^n v1 '!t P Q^h ^n Vt P N"- vl N 1^ P N N N b^O b _ ^ b _ O ^ op ^_ ^ O .NNbO_vN^^Oao^N"'WNVO'^ ^N_v^^DNC' 9piOrHv^O^10`^..-.Nr. ^'-vO `JV ryO vOv^D 0 v N N vOpNVOvO^.FY.i NNu.'^Opi yO xfYiv a^v^ ^ p^ v 0.'•-Q G^,r ^ p^Odc .d ^a4ao L^ hQ EC] o cQ.rtvW'. 000 euN Y`N' ° Y .o O^y p ^1 Y^' O'° T _ C Y R,r°'Y ^'t6 N T. C 9 V.OA m^^ Y Y CC :6^^i n R 3 a'g aa -° d^^ 4^ (D y Y.y.J ^.. g{O . ^ a ' Y - N o o: a Y F^ y o ^. '^v Cta^oa^amd o W Y^ Y C ^ p'm^ a oz2 i=z^^^FY^-u uaappawx^:, -+ N M P h^D t^ DO Q^ O y N M P ^n ^M1^,, cC Q+ O -- N m P^n b 1^ aG O. O- N M C vf. +O M1 --^ '- „-,^. N N N N N N N N N N- M M m M rn M m M 113 •sM4VH e `=_oe='e==eee eee^`ee=eee eeeee^ee^eee ^/1 ', P h- °• P ry Q P tn VVt tn mO ^ P m N "C M M b M N^ Q Q d m M N T O m Vl ^: ^O ^" ^ M M ,-• M 1D .• .^d vl ^ -,. On P r.-+ O m^O ... ^ b N b N h N`•^ ` ! cM p- m m O t^ P^ M OC O O O Oc O^ V N ^ Q N i d- O m O ^' ^.^ O l4 .- v^ " ;- M e e e e e e o e o e e e e e o e e e e e e e o e e e o e e e e e e o o e e e ^m m O m^ ^ h^D M^O O O-^^/1 ^^O ^/1 P O- P- M M W Q O m 00 M M^ V b P O Q ID vl M vl [^ m. o0. NID . h. v^ . - m. P QIOy. . v^. . M. d. h. b. T-. . b. a. d^n. . P b b O P^O ^ d N l^ d h^' Q V1 V d N M^/1 M^"' VN1 a M b vmi ^p M d vOi R N Q vNi M rhi b b d vdi Vmi vdi Q v^i v^ vmi b^ e^ e o^'; e^'V e o p O _O'-• ^O_ O • O O D O O O O O O O O e P V: h P N^.., b.O Q O V^ h^" R`^ O^ N'f; ^ NO ; ^ N T tQn ^=.r I^ V M a d W C•:• N ^ ^ N^ N N ^' M 1^ O O C= = f'1 4 R N j M - O C- O e e e^g e o 0 e e e o O o e o e e e o 0 o p e e e e a o e p o e o m^n d 1^ - N l^ S N M N O O Q P M N OO m N O^O O O. O[^ M Q h N O^n O-^n m M- N. b .P Q. O^. .M^^O . . .--M . t^. .- m. M. t^. .h .O . N-N-'/^ . . . . . h-. 00. MID. . m . 1- ^D. . O. M. N . 1^ . ^n. O. 1^. O. b N d vNi vi V N<+bl vbi V^ vdi VNi M b b b nMi ^ vdi V N Q vMi tbn NMf b^^ vht ^O vmi ^ vMi b i0 ^ b O 9 a N P M m h b Q vt h ^D d d O GG P M- N^O ^n h P W Ep O^ d rm v^ N^n P M^ O^ N N- M Q Q M Q CI M M M M Q d Q^" h Q Q^n vt Vl Vl vl V^ V] V^ t^D ^O ^D \O ^O ^G h ^C 1^ h h m m W m W E V N N U) 0 0 o e a o e o e e e o e e e e e e° e e e e e e e o 0 o e o 0 0 0 0_ e a o e c ^ oMO vm1 O-M+ r rNi - M N V^ m rMt Ih^ N^ O `: V^ W Vb' m O T O P Q^ N N P^D N m n vdi ab0 - N-^^ O N^ N m Q d O---^ V a N M^ t^ O-'- rf - O--^^ - ^ N ^ M M N O e o e e e e e ^ e ° e e e° e e e° e e e°^ e e e e e e^^ e e e e N f;.N b Nn M h m m h O ^T v^ O d l^ r h m h ^ tn vm^ oG m O m N m M^^^ O b'^ d . M d d P - O Q . M m P . P O 1^ ^l - O P MD D ND I^ . O Q'- M en p^ oo N-+ ^^ Cl ,^_, ^fJ V b r^ ao 1^ M +t M m^(4 rt N ^ M-- Q Q^ oo '1 ^^ r• O^ O e e e e e e^ e e e o e e e e e a e e e e e e e e o e e e e e e e e e o e e O^ vt -J M 1^ h Q. m- m d O N- O 1^ Q N^n O ^D M V m M^O f^ v) ^O P-' P Q m N^n ^O P N m Q 1^. Q^ . - vl. 1^ .O. O. N. ^ d. m. h vl. b. m^D . P. h-+. [^. 1+1. O .(•'1 . CI .Vl h. O. . ^^O . O. Q .Vl m-. Vl. h m O h m t^ h m P^D ^1 P O^ Q M N P N O m^^D !^ P N O m P m 1^ ^D Q h N M h^n ^O d N ^- h Y^ ^ N d d Q'- M V N^ M v^ d M b v^ ^D N d d d N d d d M M^O ^D d v^ in vi Q^n ^D D ^O o C e e e e e e O o o O e o 0 0 0 0 0 e O o e o o e aa e o a_ e o e e o e e o Q^. Q. Q. r'1 . m. vl. ^. O^ . h. N. N. P. ^/1 . .P Q^O. . .r m. O^O. . .m .m .P .O .N .Q .Vl .Q . N .O .t^ .P .Vl . h .N .N .b h. Vl. t^. b N ^ h N^ N m vNi ^ N th'1 h vNi M b b b M vOi ^ rmi ^ V^n v^ m M b b V vMi b^^ vQi vhi b b b ^D a0 OQ ^ - w^ d .. ^9 ! p . . @ N ., d0 OOV^W^ppN^©mV.^b.O`O ....bQ ^ 00. m"'bON Ov0 1^NVO^OO ONb, ONN.pp^^OOOVN60V r"w..OO N N^`-. bOv N Q L1 S c4 CG 44: a44 , ..Ni v N N v N L^ N N N. N O 04 C4 N O^ 9^ 0 F ^` °• o^. .c 0.,'0•On ^ u .p ^ OO a N W'aC T`oN ',.^. °^. m fA .r/39c Lr c^ i ro m r/Ni m °a mS] Wom O c o-.ro] O v 4d- v re 6^ e-^ >i ^` a 'x k P ° x U .'°^' A FA ^ ^ 'c° g E a c m!" o S,' m 'A • `° .`d du.^ oro. ^ ro ar o o'do oo v°' dro^ ^^' o T^ ^ o ^5 > rlFGkv- W' P; ^.-t d+ F 4 0. X W n ti iz' fL 1 G: M P O'+. N M Q ^n ^aO^h oo P O ^"^ N"iHf Q^n ^O f^ ro3 P O- N M V^n b l^ m P O+- N M d'^' b h .. M d Q V Q Q Q'Q...Q d d'/1 Ul• v^:v^ N..sy^ vl v^-v1 ^/1 D ^D b^D ^D ^D ^`Q }O ^G ^p h h 1^ t^ R+' 1^ h C 1 (`t O O O^; c C Oo O ^ Q N Q ^(v ^^ O O t'Q^ Z r W`p ^. 7 1^_ °' v^ ';^ O O O> ?^ Y O O O^ --^ O O C O 0 o e e e o e e e o e o e e e a o o e o e o 0 0 0 0 0 0 GC ^O M C^ ^ O M1 O^ V^ N N O Q C^O vl Q vl V Q O Q T t`M-- CG O N^O -r ^0 h h O; Q^`^ ^^^ h^ h M O^ ^° N O W M O V N b c^ M CO CO t^ W Yl Q^ Q^ M M O^ Vl M M N^D O V1 v1 Q O ^/) O W N Q b^C Q Q v^ vl v^ v^ vl ^fl ^D v^ v^ V^ Q ^f v^ Q v^ ^n v^ Q Q V v^ N M v^ ^o .c o o c ?"^ _^ `• e e e^_^ e e'_ o=c o_ a- c p n T-. G^ C-- N O`^ O O C' M`^ N o e e e e e o e e e e o e e o 0 o e e o 0 o e o e o 0 M M o v^ O M- N^O M N h O V`D t^ O N U N N T^ M O ^n M T ^D ^ O^ h O Nl 00 M°^ --' N^-^ O N ^D ^ a ^ O rt W M Q ^^ O^ M f't M Vt ^O ^O V^/) ^O ^D ^D h V1 Vl ^O V ^D Vl V O V1 d' ^ Vl Vl V Q Vl yl GMG c00 W W chG W r a T a^^ b r P P T°b. T^^ T r N N M^ h e e a o 0 o e o o a o e e o e o e o o c o a d' N^D °^ M^O O^ 00 O M O^ 0 aC b O ^ Q ^/1 ^^ 1^ 00 O^ T CO M Vl P O Q^ h b vl h WlD p ^l h M1 M l^ °^ M O O N^n - O-' O O O OO G O O- O O O ^ O O N o e e e e e e o o e o N e e e o e o e e e o ^O l^ M O t ^n N oO h O N-- U 1^ ^D h a M1 V d' v^ ^° h V O O^ N M ^/1 N ^D `C m OO M - T - ^l ^n N ^l .^ _.. v^ ry R - V ^C ^ - O N O O[V - N ^ N O fV M o e o o e e e a e a e e o e e 1^ ^O v1 O^O M b Vl O W O M V P M h O b O N M^1 O O^ ^C ^ Q b^ Ybi ^°^9 v^i b h b Vbl R vMi v1 V^ vPi v^i R e e o a e o e o a e e o e e e N ^ ^ N C V h^D M O M V`O ^- 00 h Q b O^O ^D O a N M ^O ^/) M 1^ vi P Q ri [^ .-. vi M O M O C^ OD Q ^n v^ v^ ^O a^D v^ V v^ v^ < v^ ^° v^ Q . . .^ ^ ^,0^. ..- ' "^ - ^• ^ N ^ 7- Z 7- -^ ^+rvNp O"^ ^,- ^ " U - t o ^ -^, y °p ^ f^ ^. o ^ Q °; . ^•' ^ ° o 0 0 ° °' Q5 T T C v. 0.° U T^'^s ^+0 °^ „^ C) ^E° ^Osf a6u y ^ C NN 4Y p a ° °sv^^K^i^F1-a!°A[) '46 `a^ ' LEI a0 Ge O^+ N,M Q, v^ ^D.C ac O^ hcc hO^ m.eoO-+ c,o N coM ocV^n uo b00 c+ 0o co uo orn o^ m°^ a rn o. o.-o^°. J 15, ae' o }2°I^I a° aY^^ a'^Ria° a e zgJ a a°I 3E 3°^ o tp ( ap .-1 .i tll 00 N lp n • l0 r Vf , e ^G m ^ V ut N ^O '^ ^O O T OG ., I^c ^e 6 ^° \ ° 00 N t rf 00 m N 1.-r . m .-^ o tn O .-^ ao N 7 01 M N^I M tD l Tta J W O C O tn Ol n N M^O ^ ^t(1 Oti1 W i nQ1 Oi GO O; O tD M 06 h N ^.-a i I Vl h I KiMr ]Cm O rl O ^ -a-1 -_ N M Yf r1 "i rl N 1I R IZRI dz m ZR 9 a9 Zg DO Q^ rn M t0 , Q, N o O ti a W st !. 9^ Ofa N n Q N' O t/1i .1 N m.`i fll l0 Of) ^D 01 ! C1 n 01 N I M a c O VI 1^ W N tr1 rv M ti oi ! vi r m O oi ni v5 vi oi rri o o; o 0 ou .+ . . oi co r a- t^ ^ d ^ o O ^ui m i m m m N^ oo mm afv ^i v ^.N '^a (I' ^ o°\^ ^ r n^ w ! ^ ^ co! . , m v o ^q n Ln v a n tn ,^ m m^ o 1+1 h n M ti O t/1 ^ M M NV1 ( Or O GU ' O C 0 C N n M eT p ei N cD O Vl tp 31 -. t0 .. to ^ lD tp t!S tll 1fl R VI IA V ^ ^ tp tp 1t0 lD O N M^ lD I, +J Ci, Im y a^.^ eY ^. N O 1a Yf m O O O 00 Ol rtlI aDI H d Of N O N w .ti n O t0 ♦ N p^ "^ L'] I.^ d E ei O `. k .ti m tn in ^Dn inM V ^^ ma M C^ r rr p O e0 tn L t M rn cr M . N 00 n'i , `A N ^/: m .-1 rv^ O O r ^ M 'i V.I^ (3yl [V ._C- ft `^ F m N "'_ ^ . [f , 'i. '-1 t0 V ^-1 '7 et m ^^n p^ o ,.i .o r. r^ ^ n . o d E d a^ uf ^ N m co o I^n ^-, ^•: ^o Q O `0 N m M S .^ u't i '7 n V O m V I`^:N C^ '+ I 00 . . . 1 ti t0 O+ ry n't G ti : a V- oi ^ N . CJ N I e° 10 M ^ei O ^ ' m m f•` m ^ r1 M e.1 a 00 a+ h- ev O vt O^: cv m llf O M ^ In m11 o0 ^o c 'w m c o^ rv c, m N m cp o q N ^n r, ep tn W ^ ^ O ' M , V ^ m t o^ N n ^.n-r mI^ I ^ r i^pl a m I ni r I O ^ ^ n ^ f^ II T Eel^^o m o o\ .s^ u a M tTel ` pE c^MIS Y T V` ^C C Ml ti.uyl V V!^^ a = 4 91 cf ai m oo m l0-^ ° ^ °n mo^ m r ^co t n m ^!wi ^ I n ^ i ^n ! ^'I o ^ •+ M Mo ^ N d ^+ Of 11f 1y1 V o CO N V lD rl Vl o.^ N .-1 .-1 V O 0 . O .-t^ ^ M rIrNI^,9^ Oi ^ Vf ^.-1 .N-1 N lmD N N !O nvf M ' N ^t0 ZM! ^ N ^ ^ . . m .-t i M .y ei M .H .--^ .-1 M .-t .-a -t a i .i .i m r1 .ti ^1 F M -.. ^ . __. i.. ;- 1 ;- -- ^•^ N _^- _.-- --- I . - -,_-`^ -M;^ o 0^ m^ O fl ^ N W o ^ N tlt l0 M I o M ^m O' a ut n rv n CO o N ^^ V1 C ^0,01 00 C' n ICD 00 V1 tp M Vl . Op N.V .-1 K T nrn h O0 : 01 N m pp M N O'C I N a O Sp N n CO u1 n O ^O O ' G O M Vt -t vI tn . n .-i I. , ( ri t/1 tD p V kp O rri .-7 ^ M ti Oi M t^ O' Oi m W N ^ I . . i ..i . i +f m ^ ^ N ( M O I .-~t O o N V ti ^rry Ns-< ~.-1 'i M 'N-1 ~a-i ~-t M^O N.- ~ nt N ~e-t r N , N ^... M N r . . - ( ^ _^_^r (V ^lp^N ^i.t v o o^ ^ w r oo`^• ^^oiNl a o^: O -' ^O p O •p N ^ I O^O I N 1 N^OI E O O i iO C r N i p ^ N^ ^ ^ IN OI IOC^^I Q'^p i N e-1 w C Q C, p a ^+ N d•f ..... ^ IF Ul ^Ic oE c o n^^, „ O m.m > ^ C ) N c l ai^ .p `^ `` L :'u O ci >u p! N o L d J + N N d Y V U d Q,' 10 VI C tO ^ 0 = T^"^ O J C Y) !O O ^ m Vf . ^ V' ^ g I K ^0 j l7 9=• ^N.. m y m , OC O^^I^t0 d , d ^ i y QC m C t^ p ^ ^0 ^ o .^- ^ ` c C cd ci 41Y ^ ^^ .c c u e ^ a p cN d N 0 u L C O) ]. O 40 N 10 d C N • Y 0^ J K ro 1' m Q Q Z _ I Y 0. ^ mIO^..r^ U M ^< ^Y1{ m Ot ^ O Ot h0 ^O n^t0 x V tn LD tD m ^ Mlfv{ '.. ._^ n I G lD a ^ ^I - ^ r1 N N V1 !!} 1lI ^ M Q n' AMp ^ . V - _. ^D il6 ^ tA ^ N I I M 1 II ^ ^ I _. 2' ^T° `e°. 3' o° V ti n!i M V O m r-M1 >^O N ^0 ONp 0N1 l0 o tno N a N ONIm ^0 Q^1 d o W n o ^ U1 W O O v1 N ei ^.-i ^ei ON M.^-^ ^ ^ %. nO N m, ^N N^ .-1 N N N h . _ _. o 0 3^ 4 o l. 3^ 3^ 3^ 3^ o;\o ^° o^ ^ Q V1 IA V1 M n Of N it IXI h n^ n O "'1 ^ O 10 O oD . a M ^^ ^ ^ v1 Oo n !^It+I^VS ^ CD, 10 O ^ r..^ M N O MIf1 p a pj.-t -11Y Vl OC tV V N e ... o .._ o _ e.. o L- I .. a0 N V N QI N 00 a^0 H n ^ O Q1 t!1 V CO Of V ul d C Cl ^t1 N T N q L/1 ttl n l0 O Uf Ol «f Ol n 00 0 rl20-a ^(f VI O ^D N N .'+ M ^ O ^/11 ^D ^O p N N M .-i rv ael a° ,.p a e II d IT° ZR e e a o h ^D O N O^ if1 i C m^p pl OD tD m 1ll , eY M M N y o Of ei n o ^ n ML/1 N, N V N N OI 01 O n M ^ ^ 9 V N O O N CO 1^ O Ol N M M Vf ^ O6 n O 00 G a C Vt GO CO T .-i O n a .-1 V N m ^w IXI'Ic, LD Vl Vl I n M V N NI ^w ^t to M M O d tD Vl tD tO _- O , rcx a3 ui C rv ^O iC r ^ti d n Q t M Q1 a, V M .--1 ( V! b ^l CC M 40 N^ ^^' Q ry 41 C l0 1 MN lzt U p p^O II1 M .-1 QOi ts'. In _ oCny f.1{ l0 n H N: ^ rC 10 01 ei Ol C ' N t0 1^ N^N ^._.. . . ^ ...... - . ....-_j(( _ \\ 1 ^ a_ ^II 3, a :R. r.`I M y^ e 3° ^°e ^ ai ^.I 2o ro 3- I vi w Ui m N ^ OI' O1 Ifl V' Vf Ol n Vi M M tl1 G^ N 41I5 ^ O1 O'. m <'i 4l +K+I 'J1 'W h W N V O CF tl' . N f^ ^ 1'^ M N G O m^ ^ '4T N' 1; O O N O Q M.. C 06 GC . C a" O ^ ^ :A^ et d' pMlroO+f i\ thC 'ry j^I W^.cj ^ O^ OI Oi N O V t^0 V1 = O ^ ^ ^ 1l/ CO .'i !^t N lG N n`N lll M 3 _O A' O.Qt.l rl 0 .= V NI :^ ^ N N Vi ^. tD' M..n ri ^ 0 R _ ^ .. e ^___". W _^ 00 p p ^°y . e I d^ ^° \ C m G. , N 31 Vi 4 n N C A p'i iA M1 00 H 00 . N O ^O t^ r-1 O O d:' Of iD 1'^f M: ^f1i `q Q N :a tD ^: n ; H N OIn O tG %j O N O r^. . M N C N . N N a-1 O W O) N ^7 lD Vt n.i ^.+': ut p O^ O M^D M Oi . .y Vt n (TI 00 Vl M ItD ^ V N ^1IN 1 M p^ Iff i^ NeH 01 ^ ^m^ p M O1 Myj Q^ Op O ^ V O Om1 N m cf N M n tD l0 00 .-1 Ol V 00 M ` Hf M . N ^D 0 d N.D M lp 00 M I h Kl N O O O 01 O V N O N I rl .1 0 r^ ^ r1 n O N V M O ^ T'^ . M .-1 '1 e1 M r1 c-^ e1 (fl r-I m r-1 .-1 .-1 M .-1 .-i .-1 N ri N ^ m pl p . m n .. 01. y M nC^lh O Co Y1 ILtf d M LO ..N 01i M 00 n k6 d' n !f' V O pjI 1 6^ M h 9 ry N I/j 00 06 0 M V 00 EO O M ut ^ N'C Vf N 0 dCp ^ e{ pi a0 h M tn O .ti ri .^ O .1 v O , rl • •y O t ei n N O . -.ti __.. N 0 Of O Nm O _ A loo O I O O ^ I p' O C) I 0 N I^ ^ N ; O ^ ^ Ci rvlii .'{ N 2 N v^ d' L d' ei L N C m Y O O L N E N^ ^ l N LL I Q - p. A^ ^^ a0 U .-^i C 10 N OC ^ lu j= d ^ ^ 0 Qa c aw, ^ I ^ ^ ' m ^ a ^ ai E o m I a A i a, o 'w o o O Q _ 'v^ aoc ^o_ o r _g ig ^ C 6. 1' ^d y V J J _ yq O _ m .^ " LL .'. ^.I . L ^ n. OC N V A n a0 1I O^ a C Q Vf 1^ N 0p Oi O y.^ N m ^> O In l n M v n i^ 00 W a ^ I ^ _ Y y M M lC m N N IM ^ M M i r L Y ^ a 0 99 9 ZR 9 ^'^ O m;Ml n O v1 u1 . n O! n 'D' O O=.OlfOl ul n rn o O 7* O OI ry ci^mlO N uJ ti Nj M Q M Q M,. M V Q' O Oi = -^ i ae ^ * 8° o CL ^° ^° ^ a° aq A Vll m V M m ' ^ n m N V^ O M N Qei M mV1 N t0 ew t0 N ^ O ^ 1-4 O I N ui o v o f o N ttl N' N ,~-^-m o ^• -''^^ o N- -- M M -~ e a° ^ ^ 3^ ^} N vl ^/1 lO O l0 m m N ^ m 1A Q O^ u1 .^ n ^O O ^ m M ^D m Q M' n O p c e-^ h .-^ n O O? D:O ' OT n Q O 7 tp M M ^ N Op tD Ol O1 CO ^ N^D n Ol '1 Q M l^i f V 00 ^O ^n ^n ,, p Q N^ Q Q ^D \O to ut N m .-1 ,, r1 a a ^n Q ..., ^n ^n .-. ..{. ___. u^ O O O^ N u1 n ^D n v1 N tD ♦+ m i O, N l .._ N rn O ^D. m N N . . M O Ot C^ C N.-^ O N O 0^ M n l.: N m • -O Uf tO %O tD Q N V a-1IN rl ^tl tA ^/1 ^ p, Q M Ul ^ n . - ._ . I m,, ___^ \ t^- m N Q N M O' Q O m nt r M o] ^n ^y O 00 M O N rt O Q M C ^ M o0 O U^ O m^ N O N Q' I m m E 01 01 M N ^lt Q .i O , N fy ^, {I N M f^inl^i N Ol Q fYf N n N O M ^^ m I ^ M m^ O^ O .' ^"' p^ N Q V C ,-1 ^ .C N CI O M O ^ ^-1 rl M ^ 1!1 N .- M o o m > T E NOt M ^o N n m N ^ ,C' Q 4 N ^ N G O m'^ ip m m `n m mvi l M w 14R LD ^ w 'R M Jt ^i ti m ^ V M d o ' Q N ^..^ GO ^..^ m n'1 1^ . m . N I ^^ R N I^ O O ^ Q I^f Nt0 M C N C p^ N 06 m OfN 'NIM `^' N ^ VI 1ff 1t O: ?X1 ^ u1 Ot a a;. i O O N Vt I N ^n m ci i!1 Q U N N Qj C Qy '^ ^- .-i N M N N ; , I ^ ry G e1 ^ O N ^ +^ ^ n ^ pp O m ^ 0 nh O ' ^e t l ^ tmD T O O j M V Q N N Q M O ^ O N Q Q. M O^ O V "7 N IW^m^ p O pt M Vf ' .-1 .-1 00 ^/1 M f"^ V1 M`K 0 y^ N fp O O M n tJ- n N N ^ W h n M n W m m ml ^trn c^'^ ^ ^ M ^ ^m lmN . mml1 Ql4 N „'^ m N ( m N lD N Q,--^ N Y -i^ ^ N ^ Mi. M N OD- M N N --- N lD O 00 N ^I1 40 ^Y OW ^p Ol M t0 O ^/1 N' a ^ M O^ Q ^ O ^ OV1'^ ^ ^ a ^ p_ ^ M.; O ^.-F tN^D ^ ..- t~i,' tND^ a ^ a .l mrv v, nl 0 cj -1 rl p 16 O ei M^-f Ne-t ^'i f^^f .-i eN-1 ,-1 m O O ^"^ M e N r M _- -1_ _-- 10 I m N O 0' N OD N ci tp a .-1 N m^'y H N O N i N N ^ O C =m OC ^ N ^ ^ : m O^ ^. a 6 N ?. N N a N ' C I>i Ol O W ^ y^v ^ C T m r!? E m E o a ^ u m o .c w ^ ^^ u ^_Lr) I w , o V G^o ^ m .N Ci T ^ IO O: ^ U1 ^ 6 aC D C n L w .^ W ^ C T H U V ` ^ L I C C a"+ d W =°....-._ _.-" ._. I ._ ^ _ ._.^ ^l- Z n = N m Q ^ N ^ n ^ t0 n 00 ^^ ^O I W Of ^' Vf ^D > m m 00 ^ y^ y^ N F ^O m m = N N N ^ N N N ile L ^ T w = I^' ^ i, N 00 01 00 H a •rll d .^ V3 oq. ^ N N r N N ^R > OOO00 Qf ^qI 6 R M H N` N'N O' M^IN A 14 H O n = O O O t0 ^l N^.{ V ^ _.- ^/f H.-t t+ O+ xi t0N I^ O a H Q ^p ^T Omi ti D h^ N Ir ONO. ^ W ^y M^y pi - - N M.-i tD^ N Vl N . MI O ri 1 O Op Q^ NirII N I V m MO 01 .N tt1 Q Ol .. N^ ^A ^ t(f M Of M V1 M V'' T N GO ^lf M ^f1 vf O 00 d' n n N O^ N m N tC H tYl Ml O O^ O Vf Vf O Ol H O a a G M N H N ! 00 06 I ^ 6 pp O 00 Oi O " I ^n I ^n m Q M a . ^n in ^nO d' o ^n in N f+ '"' O ^n e I -- o_ 7 ^ a a^ ^ a a aa e, as a 9 a a a° v m,c ^^°e o o^a m N i0 N O ei M N O tr a+ ^ OM n N 1, .0 0.7 N N ^ O^I 06 c4 N nc6 ^p^ c6N M VI Vt- V^lul 0 N i 1 ^ ^ NI tG rt1 M rn^l l V a C ^,t N ^D a O' i N ', __- i n^ ati M I f^ u' 01 O 01 n ^ 0 ^na a' n ^ t0aHn O N N 6 49 CJ l .n, ^H m M. ^p O ao ^r,Qrn O^ N E d^ Uf ^ ^ n H O M at r. N LT C^ M ^ O^ vl e-I CIl M1. M ! Q1 .-i Gp y ^. ^ lD G N.- OD M ^ ^. ^ Y- d = \D hI O ^ 00 tD T e-I a \ N N lV . ^eY -- ^o r Ni 01 N M `0 1f1 OD n O N H 0 O ^ ^ T N Vl O H e r:, rw^ L O O M M'r. ^ tl;^ Oi! ^R rl' -r - - p p p .^ s^ M M llir MV r.. N C Y^ T m'D ^o ^^^ NI tf{ vJ M ^P ! ^ I11!N !q `s ,. r` I;^, ^, c ^u^ ° ^ `7 u°' nIo ^°• `' ^ ^ » i ^ q! tr v; o ^ ei y.Q N V ^ , . n i O O C r1 ; ^' N^ I R ~ O - ^ ' h ON t!t ul OO Mi Vcm) ^h nm ^ Vt ^n DO M N p O^ O R V,^ V l...._ 1A a0 h M N O .-1 00 ^ N ^O^ CG V! M l O O MN l O ^ ^D dpOI N1 N u1 M n O n M I rr 'd' ' d. ti I ^ m T I 0 ^.. ^ ^ ^ •, ^ N Ul N r1 f-1 W M ry^^ ei 4 1^ O F O m ^ ' N O01 ,0 N M ?IN 00^^-i ^^y^ ry H V n t0 O 00 O tD m .^ C T t0 ^D N I R n O 00 00 I N O^ N M n n O tff R tp ^p O T M O . V u1 n rrl i M O ^T .-i i lD NI H Om N rN'.00 rIl .-1 ^tl ^l0 Ol M ul O 4 O d O ^^00 rOI Vf NitD t0I M ei N M ^-4 O O .-I l0 H I N H O Of . H ul N Vf N^.i .-1 Q1 Ol O^t O1 ^ n m H H '1 M `y . . H^ ~ ^4 ^ 'y ^._ _ N ..- I . i-_R ^ m H N I rl N ip ^+-1 m rl r-I 1 eM ei i H T I 1^ _ __ _ ( ^ ^ I I I ^I o a ^ ei pp •. '^ O N ^ ^ ! ^I o ^a o o ^ N O ^ O ^ N Q O O^ Q N 0 N^ IN ^ Q N Q N N N dN O^n a v ^ I ^.. ti OIv Iy. W YI ^ E ^ O^-^ ^ m Q Y.0 K M clOi ^^ pOL C m H Q = L N 0 > V > d I 'I O I v Q- N IL ^ ^ ^ d F- - I O' m E > ^ in « =d p QCl I p df Y d' O c= E . x ^ d l o.`- m c o z y^ ,w 1 1 Ej h :1TH 1 ^I ` M -- H . li _ N _-•_ _ ^ _ .^ a II .6 _-r L« ^ 119 L Ol 0 N N N N a g^° ^u v M m N M ^., m N O ti M 1^ M N ^ rl O e^1 ^ ci O N rl r7 .+ ci ^ O •--^ 1- -1_ - ° NI^ M n ^ ^ M O ^D N v m 4 O M °D ( 00 O a ^I m NId'N N N r ^ N i.q rl j O( tD ev LL- I.R a.°\I d T T O^e, M (^ Yl LD Of f^ i l^ -^/1 a c N N` O tmD O VNj;^iMi 'tT Vl'O v1 O O e^1 N(ti .^ ^ a 0 00 V 0 00 O t^lIIU?IC' ii^ MI M' lQD V W m M .^ lp rl Ol N: V1 a a N V a mv v ^ NO N v ^ ti MI ^ ox' ^ ^ pp O l^3 O h ! N A ^ rv a o ^ o ry D CIN N ^ N ci Ol rl s{ Micr M CO" M ^ ^ N1'I pi S u V Q O V M OD! 0 9 ooIv r r^°+ w ^? O N NI p^ W N NI^Ci Q N ^ y ^ ^ a I`^ NI O Nir'^ r N^n^^h ^ O1^ N M G •-1 ^ m'mlrll ^~ N M 'y ^10 ^^-1 NIri^Ml v tiiVf 1 ^--^- - N N n^^ c^i Ol N p' ^ N^ m -^+ n O O ti ^{ 0 N `y N n !d N M^^-I._ a Mf^IN' O Oi'IT'i m vlrn' ^o m in r^.w^m'. r co^oo^0 V O ^I rn IR ^ Lq en!a ^ r^^nla V 1^ V O M a-1 N VlI M +^-1 ( O ^/i N' O 01 a^1 ^-i e-1 M rt rl N 3f N ^pVt^ O V1T.-i^^^ ei u^.ct'.N O ^-i te N ^O M r^.i ! V eN-1 N N r1 M Q 00 W l4 V1 [f ^D H lp Op ^ r1 O Vt M^ N tC Llt O^ til K? 7 ll^ O W O N' M O^iiN,N; M^I.~i^.~-^I tMY1 ^`•^-10 ti ei -^- w 0 I 0^ ^ a O N v K z ^^V, ON p O^oo O K ; p l °C -F C, K u to O V Q C O C N_a. N C I N N^ W. 6 N' Y T V! ^_]1N 3I'i+^i y^ m N R( a i 7 Y N a C m C hD N M L C pp V' ^ 0C V L y a t (U ` 2 ^ '^ I ] . J ^ C C D. C ^ w C ` rp '^ ti._ y„ _ ^O.Q C Yl o Y N lJ , Y-- Q ^ ^IY - O N O i A O N a E VIV ^I 6 uOt^v"'^i ul q 0 IT C 1^IW eN-1^ ^ WI WI WI A V a 0 LL _ I-- ^-^------tPD L L L I OM I N N Q a: ae ^^ aE \I 3^ a° 3° a: a6 W G oo , a+ oo m o, o m ti ^c Ln O m r., ^ oo aoo = .._ _. . . . ._._r_ _._ i._... ._ _ _ y ol o^ o o o { a:l Q n m m ^Ol h^ °^ m V ° '^n °D { m' nm Mi n m M 0? m vi a- n "a^v+ m V1^ m O ^ N M m M ry^jlN m -_ __t-.-- _- N M a Gp r1 M O M 6 C M S1^ w^(1 ^M U1^ VI^ ^1^ ^0^ m . ( . O0 'o !^ Vt V1 LO w N GO N O GO v y iJ Vl N 1^ Q\ 01^ N 00 O- .-i Vt n ^ ^y 'V; [T 1^ t0 1n V I^. tP c0 m O l 0 C pp O 00 ^!i i^ 1A N ct ^D 00 00 M ^ ^ tA tp V1 J1 M M ^ M V M M l ril ^l' o o Qo V1 lD 1 ^n a > E m vrni '^ ZR-^ V ^ .-I N ey N O °• o C O ^Y Y^ 1 V' . .N-1 , n d^ m^ M00 Qd . O i ° ^ v.^- 10 01 FtDi ui c0 N Oti mi M e i N ° ci . . - ...._ ^-- ....^.._ -_ __ I " pdp a^+ ° ^D O : rv M r*^ m tzl t0 W^ C °^ Cf H ., C M , u^ tL N h p tD 1'^1 m 4 n ^ h u"^ N o0 O^ = O. o N d h .^ tV fi1 MI L N N N N O `-. I N N ^S! N ry aoi N h e :. 2t '..M^ . _.. L. -._ d M N N N O ^D Kj ^ (=j ON N ^ ^ N ^ ^p ^1 O O N ei a-1 10 • r---- - a a m N p . o ^ o W ^o ^o d pt n ^ao +n vi vf M W ^/1 OD d O 00 6 ^ T y^ n e-^ 01 CO N M d rV o { p Lop IO .t i ^ ! & N i4 O^ N Q d N M N O O O N ^ N F ^-1 V a-1 I .a .1 m 'i .-I ei M e-^ rl I N.-, e~i O O r^ O d 0 p ^ bp l0 ^ a0 F lD .-1 M 1^ e+ Of m m ^p ^ft t^ t0 .-t O O O OI N M O' Mf M Ol Ifl 1f1 ^ ' N O m G d ° d ^1j N Ol M t0 ti M m ° po .i a-^ M- .i ea .y^ M .^ ^^i N ^ 7^^'1 ~ m •^ ~ei I Ne-I -^-- - '- k 4 ` I za ! o _ n'-' i o o vl ^ N I ^ . O N C ^ N p ^ Y cf ao + o m a`r z o c jI m a a S! v UI N a n o N w C OI I t+ V a O N J O Iy I ^ ` 2 S O ^ ^ N ^ C 1] . t0 N ^O N u F- ^ C C^ C^ N U a ^Y1 E '^ In m ^ tD 0) 4m° `o x_ r a N^^^^ ^^1 n N C ' ^ I IZl M nA m I Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [[email protected] Sent: Thursday, September 08, 2011 6:33 PM To. 'raydirosstftmail.com : TroY J' Pairing Optrons•xlsx Subject: Summit County Attachments: Summit County Peiring Oplions.xlsx ^ M h r? m p ^O o I 0 G ^ w X i `c .^ O N R Pa Y^ •`^ ,^ P. ^ m dd 0 I r d ^ a° o^CO ^ o c I y T I o ^ w v N r ^O M 1^ I I 0 V1 vl t G N Q' v P^y ^ G y N A Q G 'y 'V .1 N b N a I I 3 a o a, a ^ Page 1 of I Gmlail - Franklin county Ray DiRossi Franklin county 1 message Sat, Sep 10, 2011 at 5:19 PM Ray DiRossi see attached moving and asked me to follow up with him PS - Niehaus talked to Bacon about him this version keeps Minerva park in the district but IF bacon was planning an moving anyway we may be able to do a little better on HD 20 and SD 03 Raty.. . . . Franklin options.xlsx 12K f3z search=sent&th=1325 5 3... 10/25/2011 https://mail. google.com/mail/?ui°2 &ik=2cd7e5 52a7&vi ew=pt& ' p , o ^ '^ p IL mj c^o oMO py p e^ O^n O^ V O N N C tn ?i > V 3 ^ { G^ l!1 t(! ` V ^^, M V1 Q N ^ T ^ C N z t6 y. r \'\ \`Nr UI C L -_ (=in 11 YI 00 01 ct M' 1 Ot Ol ^!1 tfl . C . a 40 "' T V I C VI ( U N = 4 C V v 1I1 V! ' t!f vi m . , ( ... ___...... -..^_ . .- _.._ ^ 'O ^ . q p v pp m M N O V1 ^D M C m.C S O ap .-t .ti O^D r O W ut R Ill V1 tll a M m Vl O N 05 C N M N C . ^a !.y ^a O ^n ^rl , O O^ r^-1 r N"q a N O 6_9 9 ^ M O ^G Cp W j O^ r O^ N ^ N U1 . 3 C m Ul = ^ ! tA lp 00 ^IJ tD r-I i a-1 ^'-i n tp vl ul ^n ^n ^n, a ^ a r.n V. V -I .^ a O^vNi! s C Ol Oo N O ^plrl C Oo CO M c N C ! O r rl C V1 ^n O 00 ul'i r NC a^tl , .-AR .y ^ GO aC Cp o0 O^ .^ r O ut ^n vi ^n ^n ^n i v ( v ^n ^ u u . . _.. .._{ . . , o a ^o o.-• do ^n r m v^ c = c oi o ^. o^^rv o r m IF_ a ^ m v a. a ,n n o0 o ro ^ a? ( m o^n ,;, m a= c L6^o ^n ^n u^ N .r^ •, v . ! a .n V .. . a v Om M M avD:Yt d N O N N^ V1 ^ll N ^ C m L = C ^O O.-i 3 m v o oi o.-+ o^rl a o Nm m '^ y^ ^ V1 O M, M V1 N N ] Ql C y M N = (p O !\ \ \ \ \:\\ \ ^ r a O : __ r ti O W^D O ^+l ^D ^ I V Yn O L I C 6: : ^ o^ ,i rn^n in ` c w ou = x^ ^I ^ N N m M N^ ey tD ^ N m W 3 a. C^N 'r^Vl ^Il Wtn VI V^ d'^ { J ul . V 4 V S:n . O o N o m W' . C\ N . VI r1 C^= 3- v a. oo o l.i .oo'r^ .-+I C_ V C. ' T^ ^ L C y C v'^ ^ up _v '^ in ^ O v\t O+ !tD{NI.-^ a. C a N oIr V `m °u! x' ^' i y ^n rr nc virri vi N Vl ^f) Vl Ul V i ^V m V N. c1 V1 ^OO^r:M, ^IID th i0 O O ut .y O m r m O p A. C d' V ui ialC'i V' M v1 O^O - ^ O^ 0 O. \. \ ^. \ \ '^^ \ \ N tD N `i y• p^ a^ t0 i N ^/1 I M1^ u1 n m oo N o r oo,' o tfir C^ 0 ^ i(1' ^O W V) M^ 7^ Ol tD tO 3I V V)1 Vl VI 'VI^iO^VI M m • . . i _, . ,, i . N V t!; . Ot ^-i N^ ! lD Y- ^^D m r a N o ^01I ^C N M M, M Ul r Z O^ O^ ^D N Q ^ Ol O^ N M u1 lD rI0 O^ !MIr N I MI . V tn V, , Ul^ V' V^ ^ u1^ m , c' mi m; '^clEi ?^10 a IW Q 0:0 133 ^^NIl7 U` O N_ Z^^n tn^VN` Heather Mann From: Matt Schuler [[email protected]] Sent: Monday, September 12, 2011 10:40 AM To: Heather Mann; Troy J Subject: Re: Senator Niehaus is available those days with some constraints Saturday morninglafternoon. Matt From: Heather Mann Ray & Heather Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue. Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathe rnm annOgma iI. com EXHIBlT it- 3^ Heather Mann From: Wolff, Hallie [[email protected] Sent: Tuesday, September 13, 2011 10:13 AM To: 'heathernmann@gmail_com' Cc: Florence, Bath SubJect; Meeting Request Heather, Representative Slaby would like to meet with someone from the Speakei's office to discuss reapportionment of his district. Nathan commented you would be the person to go to. Can you please contact Beth Florence In Representative Slaby/s office to touch base with her regarding this matter. Beth can be reached at beth fforenceC^a ohr state.ob us and 614-644-5085. Take care, :}{{Clttie it -woff Sr. Legislative Aide Speaker Batchelder, 69th District Ohio House of Representatives 614.466.8140 EXHIBIT ^ ^f^o Page 1 of 2 Ginail - Top inkind races Ray DiRossi Top inkind races 3 messages mail.com> , Sep 16, 2011 Fri,at 12:01 AM J Rank [^HD SumofSumOflnkindReceived . 1 20 $3,388,/el.bs 2 18 $3,348,832.60 3 28 $2,886,826.68 4 63 $2,607,138.03 5 85 $2,598,125.06 6 - 91 $2,575,558.01 7 58 $2,436,865.37 8 46 $2,166,736.02 9 16 , $2,017,564.67 10 21 $1.,806,759.43 11 42 $1,701,251.98 12 50 $1,675,796.64 13 72 $1,581,697.84 14 41 $1,408,928.76 15 92 $1,345,646.76 16 43 $1,292,268.19 17 25 $1,135,312.38 18 22 $1,018,049.07 19 17 . $918,728.03 20 24 $711,137.69 21 62 $691,714.37 22 19 $678,579.91 23 1 $669,296.90 24 57 $635,144-38 25 68 $622,908.18 26 94 $595,994.05 27 93 $431,586.26 28 81 $424,895.31 29 73 $366,455.60 30 96 $255,523.27 31 80 $242,108.80 32 36 $233,502.39 33 61 . $230,385.49 34 59 $205,995.57 35 78 $194,090.84 36 38 $167,132.47 37 30 $134,772.54 EXHIBIT 38 64 $129,172.83 39 79 $126,293.79 iL) https://mail.google.com/mail/?ui=2&ik=2cd7e552a7&view=pt&search=sent&th=132706... 10/25/2011 Page 2 of 2 Chnail - Top inkind races 40 82 $107,848.27 41 89 $107,222.66 42 54 $106,101.72 43 88 $105,977.21 [email protected] But we have made significant improvements to many HDs on this list. Hopefully saving millions over the coming years. Sent from my Verizon Wiretess B[ackBerry From: Troy J Fr[,Sep 16, 2011 at 1:05 AM Heather Mann From: raydirossi a)gmail.com Date: Fri, 16 Sep 2011 04:22:59+0000 To: Troy Judy (oc https://mail.google.com/mail/?ui=2&ik=2cd7e552a7&vicw=pt&search=sent&th=132706... 10/25/2011 ------ S N `^N ¢ A a_ 6y 6 ^•^ y a Z Z a w a m p^p 0 0 o V N vp '} N N o m q c 8 ^,^• rv0 0„d- as a 8^' ;e zo J w ^s w a 3 ^ a -^ z u ° r- 3 0 ° m ' a n: w v. . W.: a o O . ': .. S .. p p y N 8^ T N^ b S^ O^ p 9 T :': R . O Wp fU p • <^ N -. N i`t p N S r-1 ry N N C p^ m° o. N ^ ONg t^ N^y^ N O p ry ^ p ^ OM. Z b Np O•^YS N ^• JI .y 6' O^1 ^ E K Z p^. N 8 ^ Z n O K M N m N ^7yc^ rv ^ N5{ m F 6' v a IY V m O 6 w ('J $ a w ^'1 ^ akzx-x,; i y.W Q 3 m: zo w U 5Yj ¢ Z(Q'1 " ^i W 6 J Q y. ° tA pY p a S ° y Y 'i z Z ^!'t 2 i a dY Z F ^y U LL ¢ 2 ^ J ^ _ - , N.i pp^ p ao qp • p Op 1y O O , b m p•p ,^`1 y^ m S p p N'<' ^ p O S b O N p p O b G W N N ° rpi g p p p p ik Q^p N N O^ N O N} N p p rv nN N p O. O^. O ^ N N pN NO gN ^ S ^pS; Np ^1N p ^ pp ^p O ^ N ^^y n N N N `^y' S O N ^ 0.' N OSp•^ O C O,1 O^ O ^ Tp •4 p N O q O N W p O p v'^ l7 pM p N1 N N p Z SJ •^ N N a ^ S a G N ° K y N S p^ C CI ry p Z K N ° ^ ° 2° tV ^` N O p ^ ll O ^ 8 pN O% C 2 n 0 ° p N W a K w r^ ^ ^ ^ w ¢ ^ 177 a m Q o C^ z c z ° us ^ m N a q ° Z^ 0 > z m, 2 p ^ R ^^ F$Y n U. z 4 ^ a z r a z a x W W ^- aQ.¢ a 3 S`.. > i W^ Wz ¢i iez^ap^ u a ^w ^a `^.^l o g 6o F `^ p $ z z`s° ^^ z '^ r ^ z W ,^ Fa' S` i o ^ 3 ^ m° ^ x ^- a LL ^ 7^ w 3a Q a N ^° ^ 3 ° (3 S^ h,f 3 ya^ a m tl1 ti u ^^ . ° . a x $ ^ ^ ° aypj[ 3 ^ 6 ^u^e' ^^ m lz w ° F ` $ a'§ p a z z t c ° z Z Cx^j o ^[ rQ o ^ x W x ^ p ¢ c . 'F!^ x ^^.:Z f ui ^L Q ^^ o ° V` F ^ ¢"^ W Y f Jw m ^ U ^ Y O ^ m C' N ^ . G O ^ m.^•-. OH ° V' - ^ Z Q ^L ^ ° F ^ wY 'r'9 t :tl r. ^^ y t p . ,N N o Y.yt N.:: yp^ ^° •' p y . ^ O n rc . rv p C n p ^ 1Q^ N : S n N 1r N p p ^ in W 01 ° pp S O N O te^'1 ^ pp^ O^{ 6' EC • 1 gN V ^' n N g V1 v^, Q^ Q, ^11 4.^1 ^j, Q N ^ N ° N O m N ^^ O a^. Q W Q K' ND a [^ ^j ° ^° np ^° Z pp N N 1.^ a ^ hl O {Y N ZU• U' ° ry 1 ° a ^ ¢ Z ¢ T ° d ¢ a t9 a z >^ $.> o a x ° d s uzi ° 3 ^ ^3°u J fy' u,^ a° J 0 3i3 y^-" w ,Y„ ^ x^ °a S z ^Y, m Z U• 4] ^° F, 4 ^ ag Y a'¢ Z U O W Q 0 N W K ° ^ ^ Y J Z V` Z^w M a Q .y.}. 1Y x Z N ^ N W Z^ 6 V w W ]^ O ^^Q ¢ (^ N ¢ ^ ic Z l> J 2 pJe ^ J Z ^ ^ Z u ^ 6 ^ W 2 Z A"^ K a 2 Y .^ K vl ^ ¢W ^ A r U< 2 J 5 2 W Q V Z• g ° c m p< m N m a T m r N n ry rv „ .+ n^ ^ m.+ ^n o m m m o^ W R^ ^.^ N^n ^o .+ rv p .^ N •'i ^O M 01 T 1^ N T V M n M b N CO N N W N W CO OI O N N O N P S 01 O N ^_ N*'e 41 N M „^ b ti m H N d O V rv N N N N ^ n^ T M~ m m p m e^i1 M M M d K N N T Y N^D n N O^ O N lul-I Heather Mann From: Benjamin Yoho [[email protected] Sent: Friday, September 16, 2011 6:15 PM To: Michael Dittoe Cc: Troy J; Amy Kerschner ([email protected]) Subject: Re: More Geocodes Mary Galinas (R) 9503 Elsmere Dr. Parma, OIi 44130 On Fri, Sep 16, 2011 at 4:33 PM, Michael Dittoe Linda Biuhenne 7286 Callow Rd. Leroy, Ohio 44077 Orr Thu, Sep 15, 2011 at 10:59 AM, Benjamin Yoho Richard Fair (U) 4425 Merry Lane Toledo, OH 43615 Mike Robison (R) 3118 Daytona Ave. Cincinnati, OIi 45211 JeifKrabill (R) 300 E. Water Street Sandusky, OH 44870 Andy Manning (R) 2472 Pistachio Pl Ravenna, OH 44266 I_ou Terhar (R) 5595 Bootne: Rd Cincinnati, OH 45247 Tom Bryan (R) 690 North Meadowerest Circle C.incinnati, OH 45231 EXHIBIT ()n Mon, Sep 12, 201 1 at 9:58 Altl,'froy J We need to do tnorc geocoding of candidates (R) and ( D) of inteaest for mapping purposes, i.. I larletie Holland (It-tiD 40) 2. Rndy Manning (R-HD 43) 3. 7etfKrabill (R-HD 80) 4. Mike Robison (R-HD 31) i. Itiehatrl Fair (R-t-iD 4$) 6. WHO I:LSE`r? ^,....Heather Mann r=rom- Heather Mann [[email protected] SaturdaY. September 17, 2011 70:17 PM Sent: To: 'Ray DiRossi Subject: MASTER DISTRICT F1LES.xls Attachments: MASTER DISTRICT FILES.xis t 48.31% 1! CraieNewbold-R-(2018) I48.31°/u15'2.78°Po^ 2.41% , 116% 64.73o./ 2AndrewBrenner-R-(2018) 6473%5928% 3.24"/. +_ t_oaro 59.37% 3 ^Ron Anistuta -R (2016) 5937% 56 13°f L46% 1 ^. . 67.02%' -R- (2014) - -^ 61 02% ! 59 57°.6! 11-07% 1.92% 4i Matt liuffman _ ! 60.45% SrGereld Stebelton -R- (2014) 60 45% , 57 79%^ 5.33% 1.36% ) 5I 43% -R- (2016) 51 43% 45 50% 2.51 %- 3.62% 6'Randy Gan}ner --- 12686% 7!Kcmty Yuko -D- (2012) 26 86% f21 20%1 48 25% 1.40% 1937% S,AmtondBudish-I)-(2014) 1937%'1401N 5651"/0 _1.54% 11759% _9tBarbaraBoyd D-(20}4) 1759"01257%1 5282% 1.65% 1879%I 10!Bil1 Patrntm D- (2018) 18 79% ^13 57%1 46 23010 12.800% 19.63% 111Sandra Williams -D- (2014) ^ 19 63% 14 45°h 53 15% 4.82% 87% 1.13% 121 lohn Bames D(2018) I S 46% 10 BS°,5 68 -- ^ 13 Ntckie _tonto -D- (2018) 1 31 16'h 25 03% 13 460/ 10.92% 14 Mtkte Foley -D- (2014) f 37 12ok ! 33 44%t 9.91% 15 ^Tmi De_Geeter -D- (201 2) 43 78%2 25% 2.25°/ 3.24% 16 Nan Baker R- (2016) 53 34% rr48 29% 1.41% 17 Marlene Antelskr -R- (2018) 50 51 % , 47 69"0 6.27% 18 Mtke Dovilla R- (2018) 52 65%f 49 14% 2.39% 19 ^Anne Gonzales -R- (2018) 5393% 147 34% 201Nancy.Garland -D- (2016) _ 47.93"h 41 16°A 19 33°/ 1 2I Mike DutTey -R- (2018) _., 47 62%_ 39 59%! ^^20.68% 22iJohn Carney -D- (2016) 5081% 43 84%(-- 6.04% 4.18% 23lChcrylGrossman -R- (2016) 5906°/aj53b0% 24 Ted Celeste -D- (2014) _ 50 21% 142.8 5%1 6.52% - 25 Michael 5t!niaano -D (2018) - 42 27% } 38 78°h^ 12 04°^ _' 26 lTracy Maxwell Heard Il (2014_)_ 21 86% ^ 16 42% 50 37o.n , .^ 27 Carlton Weddington -D (2016) _ 18 77% 14.08% ^ 40 52% 111 281Connic Pillich -D- (2016) 50.84% 44 710.4 _... 24 85% 01 - 291 Lou Blessing -R- (2012) ^ 57 779X.152. 93%^ 22 15% 1 - 1_68% 30ILouT'erhar-R(2020) - -74060/07262% 31 DcoiseDr}ehaus-D-(20}(i)-___ 4426%^3622%; 33.17°k 32 ' 1DaIcMallory ------U- (2014) 25.39%;I8.09%._...--- 42.79% 33lAkiciaReece-D-(2018) 28.38%422.54. 47.92% 34 PeterStautberg-R-(2016) 5819%i5152%y_820% 68.01% 64.25-% 2.86% 351Ron Maag -R- (2016) _-^-- ---^-- 59.08%7 7.66%_ 36: Michael Henne -R- (2018) _ 60 1 S% 37'Jim Butler -R- (2020) 58 52% 5 5 39%^496% 38 !Terry_B1air=R-_ (2016) 60 .998. [ 57 49%r 3 42% 18.75% 39 1 Clayton Luckie -U- (2014) 23 40°^ 44 31%- 40'RolandWnrburn-D-(2016) 3247%i279}% 4321°"_ _ 41 jl.ynn Slahy R(2018) 50 38% 47 13%^8 36% 2 42% 51.89%°, 42 Kristina Roegner-R- 0078}, Sk_89% 4S 57% F_ 49.59°.% , 43 iTndd McKenncy -R- (2018) 49.59%1 49.75% 1.45%_ --- 22.11% 44 Vemon S} kes -D- (2014) 22 11 %'16 99%42.38% 36 93"/0 . 4SZachMilkovich-D-(2018) _ 36.93%13508%0l 11.7 52.78% 46 Barbara Sears -R- (2016) 52.78%. , 49 21%I 3.98% -- - - _- 35 23% 47TeresaFedor_-_D-(2018)_ 35.23%^2918%I }587% I __4777% 20.27% 437Michael Ashford -D- (20}8) n27% 1444%I - - 37.96% 149I Matt Szollosi -D- (2014) 37.96"/0 i33.80%1 6.10°/0 4_42% 52 78%I 2.41 °'o 1.16% 48.31% 1 ^Cratg Ne-wbold -R- (2018) ._ 48.31% 5272% 1;09%0 0.81% i5356% 50 C1tnstinaHaoan-R-(2020) 53.56% 133% 52 91% 51 Kuk Sthurmg R-(2018) 52-91%149 51% 4.45% 3641% 521Stephen.Slesmek -D- (2016} , . , 36.41% 132 60%1 16.63% 1_77% ... - _. 6162% 53 Tnn Derickson -R- (2016) 61.62% 160 87%1 3.30% 1-26% 60.74% 54^CourlneyCombs-R-(2012) _. . t 60.74% 5864°fo^__8.84% 4.38% ,,. i 65.84%0 55 AduBUlCondttt k(2020) 65.84% 16192°1oi 797% 4_01%_, 1 31.08% 56 ^Dan Ramo4 D(2018) 31.08% ^26 75%I 13.76 /o 14.15%__-- ... 150.68% Lundy D (2014) 50.68°/ 4710%.-_3.97°o 2.47%_- 571Matt _ ^ 52.80°/d 58 Terryoose-R (2Q16} 52.80% 4976%! 3.08°1o 3.15°/n . 38 8I%o 591Ron Gerberry D- (2016) 38 81 %42 33%^ 3.77% 1.89% _ 18 95% . 60 Rohert Flagan D- (2014) 18.95% 20 04% 31.48% 7.46 /o 48 38% 2.53 j 0.81%_ 48.07% . 63 M.uk Okey D(20k4) 48 07°/ 62LoaaineFende D- (2012) 51214913%^ 3.93% _ 63Ron Young R(2018) 5149% 4816% 2.68% - f - 1-08% ..-., 64e3om Letsoa D (2014) 35.59% 37 5710' 11.88% SeanOBnen D-(2018)_____._ 32.42%1675% '; 3.98% I._0:99% 65I _ 1.41% 66 JoeUecker R(20t2) 68.29% 164-96%, 1_38% f 1.84% ) 69.07%q 67 1'eter Beck R(2016) + 69.07% 67, 19% 4.60°/ 1.23% 45 70% 68 athieen Cly& D- (2018) -_ 45.70% { 42 61 4.68 /0 K 1.29% 55.91% 69fiBt11 Batchelder R- (2014) 55 91% j 53 09°/n^ .22 /° 1195% 60.53°l0 70^lntrod M_ arhn R(2016) 60 53"/0 57 44% 8.68% . . 58.72% 71 Vvy Hoitinger R_ (2034) 58 72% i55 58°0 3.73% 1.18% _ 1 4825% 72'RoxsMcGTeggor-12-{2014)__, 48.25)_46.82%10.54% 2.hGi° 54.27% 73JayGoyat D-(2014) 5427%:5415/° 1093/0 1.21% 13.74% ^63.75% 75 Lynn Wachtntann -R- (2014)_ 63 75% 6t 79% 0.46 /° ------r -F---° o 64 58% 020) 64.58% _16182%1_. 1 . i5/o 2_54f° 76!Robert SOrague R_(2 65.79% 7 Jim Buchy R(2020) 65 79% 67 08% 0.35 /o Q.85% 0.94°°_ ^64.35% 781JohnAdarns R (2014) --. 6435%16496% _1.56% , 0.92:/0 65.17°/u 79^kichardDtck" _Adams R(20[b) 65.17%. l6422% .1.67% -. ° 46.52% 80'• Denois Murray- -D_(2016) 46.52% 1 43.34°Jo^ 5.73% 2.86=0 2.40% 5.39% 52.30% 81^Rex.Damschroder-R-.(2018) 5230% 4774°J° 1 S3% 56.78% $_2 7e#Trey MeClatn -R- (2D! h} _. 56.78% ^54 55%1 4.04% ._- 0_96%. 165R0% 83'DarolhyPelanda-R-(2020). 6540% ^6232%1 191% 61.11% 84Roben Backeft R- (2016) 60 39 h4 4.25 /o LU9%-_ 55 72% - HS^obPeterson R(2018) _ 5572% 5637% 6.32'o 0.98/0 59 13%0 86 CifffRosenberger-R-(2018)_ 59 13% 59.76%. o 0.70% f o3/o_ 544]% 87 John Carey Jr R (2018) --__ 54 41 No ^ ° I.27 163 62% Danny Bubp R(2012) 63 62% I63 60%[ 0.60% 0.59% 8$ i I 47 44% 89,Ter[yJohnson R(2018) 47 44%153 0262% ' 6164% 90^Marga*'et Ann Rnhl -R- (20i 6) ^ 61 64% i GO 23%t 0 81% o.88%0 -7 55.67% 91TBillHayes R(2018)^ ._55b7°,/u _ {5536"/m089% i 0.66% 06%0 92'Debbie Phdbps D- (2016 43 06% +1 43 55°'o Z 37% ^ 1.00% 0.51% _ ^50 43% 93 Andrew Thompson-R (2018) 50 43% 153 00%^ _ I 16 /o 51 98%1 2 95% 0.54% 5120°/q Hill R- (2020) 53 20% . _ 94;Brien 40.33% 95 Lou GenUle -D- -(2Q18) -.- - 40.33% 14% 46 61%^ . 4 ^ -0.75% ---- 1350 6 50164%I 96 At i,andtx R- (2018 _ __- ^ 50.64%50. . 50'!n! 0,78% 61.56% 7IDavid Hali R- (2076^ 6156% r5943°l0i 0 57% 0_97°. 58_31% 98 Richard Holltngton_ R- (2020) 58 31 % 55 64%j_ 2 24% C 44.78"/0 99 'Casey Kozlowski -R- (2016) 44.78% i 42.89'Y° 1 3.54% 2.380/. Gmail - Index Analysis of Proposed Districts Page 1 of 2 Ray DiRossi Index Analysis of Proposed Districts 1 message Heather Mann Attached is a helpful analysis of pre and post proposed House Districts. Proposed House Districts UNIPIED ANALYIS Current House Districts 62 u I seat Number of Seats 50+ _ 61 57 u 9 seats Number of Seats 52+ = 48 44 (up 8 seats) Number of Seats 55+ = 36 Proposed House Districts 2008 Presidentiat Index Current House Districts 53 u 9 seats Number of Seats 50+= 44 45 u4 seats Number of Seats 52+ = 41 35 (up 4 seats) Number of Seats 55+ = 31 A few statistical blurbs: • We are now have a majority of seats that lean Republican (50% or better) on 2008 Presidentiat numbers. • Previously, to retain a 50+ seat majo(ty under 2008 Presidential year conditions, we had to win all seats above a 49.14%; now we only have to hold 50 or more seats that are 50.94% or better. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 EXHIBIT 1614) 352-5819 ^ heathernman n Cn2a mail.com I Zi E ^ _rn CAgC L Vl t Gmail - Index Analysis of Proposed Districts 2 attachments 2011 Proposed House Indexes.xls ^ SaK ^ ^0{0111 Proposed Senate Indexes.xls ivj https:llmail.google.com/maill?ui=2&ik=2cd7e552a7&view=pt&cat=Redistrictingolo20Em... 10/18/2011 dM, as adopted 9=x8-xi- PolitiW Indexes Ffna1 Nouse 61s► bem PeP n^"' PaP Pcxe BVQp VAF Fa,4s•n Pmnun 6}a 43 2324Y< 075'Y 5046% 4954% „ a507e.;, 549iqn ,470°4 i4°S a2nl% 179?•Y< .- 77 _3q:. __'3>°i^. JJ d6 Y°:. 3 4.74:. AI RA^/.. 18 If Y.. 37 053r, 67 95".n 45. 7543% 6279% 3721% •t 5? fkP.. ? Snq;, .,`. IF. YR-. %fl 10 I3'•'n t: 1"b 4S `dLr'!e +4 Od'vs 6 06°6 .707% 4293 : +,t II J'R. I Pr;. 348i?w E517°.4. 47 2T% 343"6 4234^/0 5766% 4s 35r^•e 121'A 4514% 54UY.^!e '11 4 64'^'. I ^5••:. K)GI-::. 'Oi±^^ 13P••C, 6H744. 31 Y e Aq 1721@.. 117% 62544b 3746% 14".: 7 e?^%. X 21^.e so 334<':. 097% 4194^.b 58(>r.% 51 9 46°b 442% 37 72% 6_^ 28% tt 51L^.> !C^•:, .23T%?763% ?4814u 699^1, 3701% 81 05'1, 5895`0 ga n 91's 1 99% 3766% 62 34"/n a^1?i4i?:• I 34% 62 15•0 37 OS"h en 4l5 Ila81. 494f+°r 505+1'.. >J 6.'0'r 266 % 31 94 % 6216% jzs Final Hause DisWcts, as adopted 9-28-11-Politirai tndexes M... Al.^tn Ntn. P.nns;n ya nn.x. Mn.nl.uk V^ VAV 06. Puin..w 4H'S V.ununVPV YhY VAr' 4ubF IneMw hlJea bM _^71 G;4".% 1=rm ?iinna. fil3lx. _.4'nl S7`L. R s3W- dkuG]`6 eu:J'e 4) o'- bl 1:'8'r 1 J4e;^ 4` X^2. CYS°, r.: 4J.', 9t 182°m 069°b 3P 16"fe 5104%x JP.14* ,j t!Si 1 C61. .% 1216"b 5784?;• xx ag•... r3f.i':. A+ 6?1°A 013' n^ I 63% 9 63 0 4: Y% 57 89% R{ " 65% I 0d^e 54 $4'L, J5 IE°/o n^5u . a5 287> 052k 4sa(Nt, 5560% 18'R 46821. NT Of'tR.. f t[". aiC.V^°•`i??:h, ory 4(Kq. 069:8 53 ..... !17 369% 060% 4357% 564?%a !IA 0 137"« 43.^`i% GbQd?A M1O . ls, . li : F?^.. J.1 qJ^. -'.t ^m•:I. nn 376% 239"N 5095% 4905°4• 12L Final Senate Districts, as adopted 9-30-11 - Political Indexes Dem Pep Hm_ D7st. 61ack Pa1119.10 P.NtI3al1 UAP VkP Index Index 1 1.09'>0 3.41% 35 22% 64.78'.1e ' 2 3.75°.0 3-31°In 47.57% 67-2.43% 3 15.76°k 3.70°!u 49.04% 50.96% 41.54% 58.46% 4 7_ 13°.°'0 329% 35.02% 64 98°Fn 19 955% 2.99% 5 25.31% 127% 51.39'6 4861°ro 20 4000/o 0.91% 41_21°u 5879% 84.97`Jn 15.03% 6 6 27°,ra 1.94% 38 58iS 61.42` n 2-1 55.59% 4.703n 1 11°! 39 4r''% 60 53% 7 3.93io 192 0 32.45% 67554/0 22 424% 61.00% 39.10% $ 11 59% 211% 3713% 62 ft'°fn 23 0 60°!0 7.40°l0 45.38":10 54 62% A 4369% 2 20°10 71 66 :/n 28 34% 24 3 41 clo 1.72% 2.10% 71.24% 28.76% 10 0.30 Fo 1 65?ru 40.06% 59 94% 25 38.51% 39.72% 60.2i e I I 22.1 % 537% 67.45% 32.5h°.u 2S 293% 266% 43.20% 56.80"l0 12 4 82% 1 29S/u 31 76% 68.24"!0 27 3.85% 1.10% 18.45% 1.429e 61.75°!0 313.25% 13 737% 635% 52.82`•b 47.18% 28 48.78% 51.229lu 14 172°fo 095% 3646% 6364% 29 791% 1.31% 319% 0.75% 50.63''0 49 37°.%0 15 30-61 % 370% 76.75 i'o 23.25% 30 41.20°(O 58.80°./ 16 4 55"k 388% 43.81% 56 19% 31 2.03% 1.07% 1.46% 58.05% 41.95% 17 3,47% 0.76% 40 8'1 0 59.19% 32 640% 3.08°!0 58.88% 41.12% 18 3 09% 1.16% 44 41 °o 735.5940 33 11.06% 12? _From the desk of State Representative Bitl Haues 195 BroadF,. St., P.O. Box958 Pataskala, OH43062 Septcmber 22, 2D11 Speaker Batchhelder, I am very pleased with the new house district I may have the honor of serving (New House District 72) in the future, if elected. '1'harilcs to those who worked on the maps. While the new areas in E-ID72 include areas that I have had little or no previous contact with, I'm excited about meeting the fine folks in Coshocton and Muskingum Counties and serving them in the Ohio House. I write to request reconsideration regarding the assigned areas to new HD72 within Licking County, which I understand would include as the rnap presently stands the following, to wit: Townships of Fallsburg, Perry, I4anover, Madison, Hopewell, Bowling Green, Licknig, Fraxiklin, Union, Harrison, the Villages of Hanover and Ifebron, and the City of I-Ieath. I acn very passionate about representing Southwestern Licldng County, an area where I have lived for more than 40 years. My wi.fe makes some light of the fact that we move every 5 or 6 years, but not farther than 5 or 6 miles from our old address. We've actually had seven different addresses in the Pataskala area. We also lived in neighboring Reynoldsburg, to the immediate southwest of Pataskala, for several years where Carolyn and I both taught school and I serveci on School Board for a short tirne after leaving the teaching career for industry. My desire to represent Southwestern Licking County has had a bit of a setback in that I stand to lose Etna Township (out of current HD91) and did not have the City of Pataskala added to new HD72 as I had hoped and asked for. It is important to note that it was Etna Township, along with Harrison, that provided the votes for victory in the 111, hour during the 2010 campaign against Dan Dodd. My enthusiasm for the Southwestern part of Licking County (Etna Tow-nship and City of Pataskala) stems from ihe following facts: l,. M^r family has lived in the area for more than 40 years 2. I served as a School Board Member in Southwestern Licking Schools in the 1980's; my wife Carolyn before she retired taught School in all three of the elementary schools in Southwest Licking Schools (including Pataskala) as well as the Middle School; our son, Scott, served as a School Board Member in Southwest Licking until just recently; our daughter, Sallie, taught at the husband was transferred out of Southwest Licking Middle School before her state; we raised all three of our children in the Southwest Liclcing Schools; we have three grandchildren presentiy attending in those same schoois now. Our two daughter-in-laws teach in the Southwestem Licking County schools, too- 3_ Our connection with the City of Pataskata is also significant in that we , previously lived in the City for 13 years; I've practiced law in Pataskala for over 33 years; my sons now practice taw in Pataskala with me; I served as City Law Director from the time Pataskala merged with Lima Township (now the City of I'ataskala) until 2002 and saw this new city through its infant stages, codified it's ordinances, created and established its tviayor's court, and attended all council meetings during my term. Presently, our son, Dan, serves on City Council in Pataskala. 4- In addition, our church life is centered around the Pataskala Community. I've been an Elder at Tri-Village Christian Church for more than 40 years, our raised and baptized in the church, Carolyn and 1, along with other children were menibers of the family have been involved as members of the choir, the praise team, Sunday school teacJiers and members of the church board. The Tri Village Church is located in Harrison Township (within new HD72), but very close to Pataskala. A large part of the congregation iives in Etna Township and the City of Pataskala. 5. Finally, I should men6on that because of the many relationships we have established in the Southwest Licldng Community (Etna Township and the City of Pataskala) a great deal of our support in both man power (door to door, mailings, fLmdraisers) and financial aid comes from these two communities. My suggestion is to remove from proposed HD72 FaIIsburg and Madison Townships as well as the City of Heath and add them back to Jay Hottinger's District- These commurnities are in his present HL? 71. Jay attends church and has inany contacts in the Cityof Heath. I have few to none in comparison. I would then suggest that EtnaT^^,,wnCiup Townshig, Licking County) and City of Pataskala be added to the proposed HD72. Essentially, the result would be that the areas in Licking County in new HD72 would be the same as current HD91, except the City of Pataskala would be added. Jay's district would remain the same as it is now, except he would not have the City of Pataskala and those portions of Reynoldsburg in Etna Township. if more population were needed, Franklin Township, which is adjacent to Heath, andJor Perry Township could be added to jay's district as well. Maps are attached (A) HD72 as proposed, (B) (Etna & Pataskala added - Fallsbury and Madison removed and (C) like B, Franklin also removed). The un-sbaded portions of Licking County are Hottinger's District. In future elections, the likelihood is that the person who will run for the Hottinger seat will be a person from the Granville/ Newark/Heath area as nearly all of the county's elected officials aze from these communities. As Pataskala grows, having Pataskala and Newark in the same Hoiise District will., potentia7ly, cause primary elections in the future as these comrnuruties do not relate to one another well. I say this because Republicans in Pataskala and Newark have a]on.g history of a less than copasetic telationship- It is rumored that a western licking County official may primary a sitting comrnission from Newark next year. Further, having Heath and Newark in the sarne district makes more sense from a community identity standpoint, as does keeping Harrison Township, Etna Township and Pataskala together. I am well aware that my request may be easier said than done, however, I would not be completely satisfied if I had not presented these maiters to you. Thank you for your consideration and leadership on this matter. Sumcerely, ('V'i" a' 44^^ Bill Hayes Representative 91s' District IVot printed at tax-payer expense Heather Mann From: Jeff Jacabson Umj1961 @gmail.coml Sent: Friday, September 23, 2011 12:22 PM -ro. Ray Dirossi; Heather Mann Subject: Re: fix for Baldersonlhottinger ob and the inclusion of Trimble township;,,, Jm11961 0ds*tnaiLcotn.> wrote: On Fri, Sep 23,2011 at 11:52 AM, Jeff Jacobson <' Senate districts still have sanae House distriets as current. J-Iouse districts changed as follows: Hayes District: Same parts of Licking, plus Coshocton and Perry Hill District: Guemsey, Muskingum (except for Blue Rock, Brush Creek, Clay, Harrison, and Meigs "1'ownships). New District: Same parts of Fairfield, Pickaway, Hocking, and Vinton, plus Morgan, Muskingum (only Blue Rock, Brush Creek, Clay, Harrison, and Meigs Townships) and one township (Trimble) in Athens County. Phillips district (same except loses Trimble Twp in athens county) If you do this, then the 71 st and 72nd districts and Landis' district would be designated the 31 st Senate distriet, is greater population than the combined Fairfield, Hocking, and (from what I can because Licking plus Perry tell) the part of Pickaway that was in the old 31 st District (if I have by chance on Pickaway miscalculated there are two ways to easily fix, but I don't think I have). Balderson would live in the 20th District. (So would Schaffer, but that's not an issue because he is not a candidate and can serve the remainder of his term even thougb he doesn't reside in the district. Obviously, because I do not have access to political index software, I have no idea how this might affect the uncertain political balance of the districts. I dont think the Senate will be affectedsignfcantal^ ;e,li^i y) in the 1 stt lJayes, though fter example, I think thal St Albans and Granville'l'wps i ' District eould be added to the 72nd district to help shore up Hayes if his numbers were to fall. EXHIBIT I; ^S rageiozr vrrmu - rapporuorunem rran coumaown..... Ray DiRossi Apportionment Plan countdown..... 1 message .__.------__.._. Sun, Sep 4, 2011 at 1:47 PM Ray DiRossi Hey guys... Friendly reminder tha'^: as of Monday (tomorrow) we will have 18 days until the maps are to be submitted And I would like a sofd 7 days post final decisions / pre unveiling to get everything polished checked and ready to introduce_ So that's 11 days from Monday This will allow time for geography checks, population verifications, getting the legal descriptions prepared, district by district statistics being compiled to be ready for the scrutiny that will come... i.e. number of county splits, number of split wards, and twps and cities etc Ray EXHIBIT R https:.l../mail.google.com/maill2ui=28zik=2cd7e552a7&view=pt&search=sent&th=132358:.. 10/25/2011 Pagelofl Gmail - (no subject) (no subject) 1 message ..... ,.. -- Sep 22, 2011 at 1:08 AM Heatber Mann Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt- B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (6141352-561 heathemmann2gmaii.00n 2011-09-26 Apportton Plan Sponsor Teetimony.docx 1m EXHIBIT LAp https:Omail. google.com/mai I/?ui =2&ik=2ed7e552a7&vieEr-pt&cat=Rcdistricting%20Em... 10/ I 8/2011 Apportionment Plan Testimony Testimony • ICeep it short • Compliance with VRA, Ohio Constitution, Ohio Constitntion • County splits • Address NE Ohio constita6on violation with precent • Single member districts - reqttested in every heanng - consistent • We believe that we created all the majority nvnority districts that could be created in House and Senate incontgliance with provisions of state constitu6on and popnlation of • Members drawn in together - note if it helps us, if even. Heather Mann From: Heather Mann (heathernmannQgmail.wm] Friday, September 23. 2011 8:57 PM Sent: To: . . . 'Troy J' Cc: 'Michael Lenzo' Per your request, I am making a list of member calls I received today and yesterday. I took care of the easy ones, the others are listed below. If you would like me to call them back twill, but I would like to prioritize preparing for next week and making any changes you and President Niehaus jointly direct Ray and I to implement. Kathy Cortez called me on behalf of Rep. Hoilington and asked me to call him on his cell. She implied he might be upset with losing Chardon. Jay Hottinger- asked per his conversation with 5peaker and Niehaus would like us to see if we can explore his issue -Heather ♦s. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43205 (614) 352-5819 heathe rnmann ftmail. com 1 vage I ot ' unaau - t ne super partisan aemocrauc maps Ray DiRossi [email protected]> The super partisan democratic maps 7 messages `--"f- Sat, Sep 24, 2011 at 6:06 PM Ray DiRossi I just got my first look at the detailed house and senate democratic caucus maps With all of the attacks coming at the maps Heather and I submitted claiming they were hyper partisan and blatant political gerrymander maps that simply attack democrats I just want to point out that they slammed us for negatively affecting 9 democrats through forced primaries and geography chanoes..... See list below: Scolozi and Fedor Celeste and Stinziano -Wilson andSciavonl Garland and Gonzalez Driehaus and Tehrar Oakey and Thompson I just want to set the record straight... and hope we get out there with this My inltial analysis of t ow the Democratic House and Senate caucus maps treats republicans It pairs or negative!y effects 28 Republicans! R's in forced primaries Maag and Beck Hottingerand Hayes Slaby and Roegner Peterson and Hackett Wachtman and Goodwin Johnson and Carey Hite and Wagoner Burke and Jordan Beagle and Widener Ba!derson and Schaffer Patton and Obhoff R's in Dem districts Landis and Okey Thomson and Phillips Koz and Letson Butler and Lucky Baker and Foley Anielski and Budish EXHIBIT Hope this is useful... hUps:/lmail.google. com`maii/?ui°2&ik=2cd7e552a7&view=pt&search=sent&th=1 129d7... 10/25/2011 imzau - i ne super parusan aemocranc maps rage z ot s Sat, Sep 24, 2011 at 6:40 Mary Amos Augsburger From: Ray DiRossi [mailto:raydirossi(o^gmail.coml Sent: Saturday, September 24, 2011 06:06 PM To: Mike Dittoe iQuoted text hiddenl [email protected] I thought yost and you would want to know Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry From: Mary Amos Augsburger Mary Amos Augsburger I thought yost and you would want to know Definitely! From: raydirossi@gmai!.com [maiito:raydirossiC?gmaii.coml Sent Saturday, September 24, 2011 07:05 PM To: Mary Amos Augsburger tQuoled text haldenj Sat, Sep 24, 2011 at 1:08 PM [email protected] Hopefully more to come eru=pt& search=sent&th= l 329d7... 10/2 5/2 011 https://p.lai l. goo g te. com/mai l/'?u i=2 & ik=2cd7 e 5 52 a7 &vi Heather Mann From: Mike Dit!oe (dittoemr@gmai!.com] Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2011 11:17 PM To: heathernmann@gmai!.com Cc: Ben Yoho; Troy Judy Subject: Re: DamschroderlMcLean numbers Haha I'm glad you enjoyed that heather! lust giving you a hard time. You've been kicking ass! Hope you are feeling better! Thanks, Mike Dittoe 740.215.8214 - mobile 614.466.0863 - office Sent from my iPhone On Sep 22, 2011, at 10:46 PM, "Heather Mann" > That was worth a laugh at the end of a long day :) -----Original > Message----- > From: Mike Dittoe > Thanks, > > Mike Dittoe > 740.215.8214 - mobile > 614.466.0863 - office > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Sep 22, 2011, at 10:21 PM. Benjamin Yoho »> This is a no way. No how. No nothin. »> »> >>> On Sep 22, 2011, at 8:45 PM, "Benjamin Yoho" » > , EXHIBIT 9 ^'l »» The switch scares me on the prez index for Rex 3» > »» Sent from my iPhone »» 2011, at 8:23 PM, "Heather Mann" 3 eage 1 ot z Gmail - Plati roll otit tomorrow Ray DiRossi Plan roll out tomorrow 4 messages - -- - Thu, Sep 22,2011 at 11:45 PM Ray DiRossi Hey atl... Heather and I just sent our plan to the printer a little white ago... We plan to put the maps out for display at the disp[ay area outside of the House clerks office tomorrow (Friday) at 11:00 a.m. my guess is media swams - so it would be best tn have spokespeople there We will be at the Clerks office most of the day waiting to receive plan submissions and then do distdbution... Ray Fri, Sep 23, 2011 at 1:11 ANt Michaet Lenzo -Mike [(]uo[ed [ext hidden] Fri, Sep 23, 20111 at 7:45 AM Troy J Seriously though, you guys have done a tremendousJob. Thank you for everything you've done for our insGtution! [Quoted text hidden] [email protected] 52 a7&vi ew°pt&search=sent&th=132946... 10,125/2011 https://maij. google.com/mait/?ui=2& ik==2cd7e5 Yage 1 ui 1 Gmail - Plan roll out tomorrow Hai! Thanks Troy Heather and I printed out a set of large maps for you guys and speaker and president last night We will get them to you this am jOunted text hiddanj Sent from my Verizon Wire!ess BlackBerry https:lhnaii.google.com(mai U?oi=2&ik=2ed7e552a7&view=pt&search=senl&th=132946... 10125,12011 rage i UL I Cimait - t3tade aCtlcle Blade article ^___2 messages Jessica Auman httg:Itwww.UDdobiaoe co:i,f?ol9tics12011108/221cornments-souaht-fvr-redrawi d istricts.html ---^------Ray DiRossi ive been looking forward to this for 10 years iQocleo text hidtlenl htt{sJrmail.goagle.conalmail?ui=2&ik=1_cd7c$52a7&view=t:t^search sen ^.dr°I31i28... 74/2512{t11 Heather Mann [[email protected]] From: Ray DiRossi Sent•_ Monday, September 26, 201111:36 PM To: Troy J. Cc: Heather N. Mann - gmail; Matt Schuler sbc email SE ohio options 5ublect: existing shape files_rip; perry split shape files-zip; athens sRid shape file.zip Attaefiments: SE Ohio.pdt; I am attaching shape files for the existing Hl)s and 2 options as well as a svmmaty sheet so far of where we are.... We are continuing to work and improve tonight Ray Page 1 of I Gmail - House Districts 58 159 Ray DiRossi House Districts 58 / 59 1message ,.._._....-_-'-°--...___..-....._. . . __._.__.__.^ .,. Tue. Sep 27, 2011 at 1:22 PM David Johnson From: Mark iNunroe [mailto:markpmmocand.comJ Sent: Tuesday, September 27, 2011 12:21 PM To: ravdirossi amail.com Cc: David Johnson Subject: House Districts 56 / 59 Ray.. Atf of map fn Mahoning County Is designed to protect Ron Gerberry. it looks flke the proposed house create an open seat Austiirtown TWP In Mahoning County should be Included In the 58°i district, which witl include Gerberry) are inctuded in aff of Austintown (except a few precincts that in the new 59r^. Given that Gerberry. We have had good will be obvious that the GOP has caved to Dem pressure !o protecf the 58m it to protect Gerberry witi be kfcking sand in candidates spend many thousands of dollars to win that seaL and the face of your local GOP. shift a few precincts from Poland Township in To make your numbers work, t would hope you could instead other. the 59ei to the 580', and fat Bob ffagan and Ron Gerbeny face each Mark Munroe. Chairman Mahoning Co Repubiican Party 10/24/2011 https://maiLgoogle.com/maiU?ui=2&ik=2ed7e552a7&view pt&eat=Redistricting%20Em... PageloFl tima)1 - (no subject) Ray DiRossi (no subject) I message Wed, Sep 28,2011 at 9:09 AM Mann, Heather Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office 16141719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather mannCaZohr staie oh us CONFIDENTIALnY NOTICE im the use oi fhe end^urdirei or enGty to which it is eddressed and M my oonlam informa5on ihat f5 infomctrion conl2ined in Ihi5 ornatl I5 uNended oniy pnviregee. Ccrt:den!lai; aitorney ^'xk proeuct aadfar exem0l hom disclosure hntler appiiraYbla i?m- Iflhe reader of Ihis message is nol the intended reeiperd (.or Ih9 emWOyae or agent respons,ble to deliver it to Ihe Intended recipient). you am hemoY eotiFed that any dissemina8on. tlisUlbution. or capyinB of mis e- mad w proh,bited it you have recewed tMS e-ms® in erro: Dlease notify the sender by return e?rel: Suggested Comments for Auditor Yost.doax 25K U?ui=2&ik°2Cd7e552a7&vievrpt&cat=Redistricting%20Em... 10/24/2011 https:/lmail.google.eom/mai Satnple Comments for Apportionment Board The Board must first detennine whether a proposed plan complies with the U.S. Constitution, federal statutory provisions and requirements of the Ohio Constitution before debating "policy" considerations. I believe the plan from the Joint Secretaries does comply with all federal constitutional and statutory requirements. The Joint Secretaries' sought population equality of the blouse and Senate districts as required by the Equal Protection Clause of the 14`h Amendment. The total range of population division in the plan is caused by the constant observance of Ohio constitutional policy on the creation of whole county honse districts in Article XI, Sec. 9 7'his policy has been followed tivitltout exception since the 1960s. The plans are within the population limits set forth by the U.S. Supreme Court. At least one other plan did not consistently apply the provision allowing the creation of petntissive single county districts. The Secretaries' plan has provided for Ohio's African-American citizens an equal opportunity to elect their preferred candidates of choice. The plan creates more majority-ininority non-I lispaitie black House and Senate districts than any other proposal presented to the Board. These majority-minority districts were created in complete conformance with Ohio Constitutional redistricting requirements. They are communities of interest which deserve representation under any analysis of traditional redistricting criteria. From the materials received by this Board, I do not believe any of the other plans would provide a greater opportunity for the election of candidates of choice of Ohio's African-American contmunities. As recognized by all presenters, every requirenient of the Ohio Constitution cannot be observed without exception in both House and Senate plans. Every proposed Senate Plan, including the Secretaries' plan, contains a violatiott of Article II, Section I I on Senate districts in northeastern Ohio. 7 he Joint Sect-etaries' plan does not violate Article 11, Sec. 8 on House districts. Every other proposed plan does violate this Ohio Constitutional provision. This fact along should prompt this board to reject the other proposed platis and adopt the Secretaries' plan as the one which does the least violence to the Obio Constitution. Unlike the drafters of other plans submitted to the Board, this body does not have the option ignore xequirements of the Ohio Constitution. Unlike sonic of tlu plans drafter, the Board does not have the option to ignore requireroents of the Ohio Constitution. 'I"he Board does not have the option of ignoring Ohio Constitutional provisions with which it inay disagree. Article I I Section 7 (D) requires a reasonable effort to preserve existing district boundaries and is certainly designed in part for a consideration of incunibency: The Campaign for Accoutttable Redi-stricting decided to totally ignore this Constitutional provision, aad any consideration of incumbency. In fact, they decided to insert a competitiveness requirement or goal in their plan drafting content. Whether conipetiveness is an itnportant and ever proper consideration aiid how it is measured is a matter of signiticant disagreement. It certainly is not a universally recognized requirement, nor even a widely used or accepted goal. Competitiveness as a redistricting requirement was specifically rejected by the voters of this State_ The Campaign may get to pick and choose the criteria for its contests;, however the Board is bound by the will of Ohio citizens as expressed in the Ohio Constitution. The secretaries' plans were drafted using existing precinct lines-an unportant cost and administrative consideration for the state. It was not a criteria for the Campaign for Accountable Redistricting contest. I believe after consideration of compliance with all other legal requirements, it is proper to consider where ineutnbent members live. They were elected by the voter of their present districts. The Board should not arbitrarily pair members wliich can be avoided without impairing other important considerations. The Board should reject plans which ignore incumbency totally. T"hereis some confusion from some testimony provided to the Board on the number of political subdivisions divided by various plans. I would direct interested parties to the user notes on plan issues addressed in geography found in the Secretaries' legal definitions of September 23. The their note uttdoubtedly explain to great degree the differing analysis. As the Secretaries' testimouy froni Monday revealed, the fact remain that there are many ways to count county and political subdivision splits. The Secretaries' map splits 15 political subdivisions, five of them major cities (Coltunbus, Akron, Dayton, Toledo, Cleveland) are major urban areas where the cities are too big to contain single districts. At the ward level, the Secretaries' plan splits 14 wards, while the Deniocrats caucuses plan splits 41 wards and the Fortner map split over 100 wards. For these reasons, I will be voting in support of this plan. STATEWIDE ISSUES Mandatorv and Permissive counties Allen County 8.8% light Columbiana county 7.5% light Wayne Mandatory Richland County 6.8% Heavy Wood County 7.7% Heavy County Splits in general Maiority minority districts versus minority influence districts Legal issues and recent litigation 1 SD in Sutler countv SW Ohio 3 HDs and Montgomery County 6 HDs and 2 SDs (Miami and Darke and Preble) Lucas County 6 HDs and 2 SDs NW Rural areas 9 HDs and 3 SDs Lorain I Huron 3 HDsand 1 SD Niehaus et all 3 HDs and 1 SD (TerrV lohnson) SD 14 - HDs and 1 SD (Clarke, Green... ) Ross McGrep,eor Option 3 1 SD (Peterson Rosenbereer and Carevl HDs in SD 17 3 HDs and NE Ohio Constitutional issue Mahoning and Columbiana Schavoni & Wifson Franklin county plus 10 HDs and 3+SDs in Franklin County Speaker Batchelder HD ! SD 22 Summit / Wavne County Stark County 9 HDs and 3 SDs Rural SE Ohio STATEWIDE ISSUES Data Yost Visit Decision Tree going forward / timeiines Mandatory and Permissive counties Allen County 8.8% light Coiumbiana county 7.5% light Wayne Mandatory Richiand County 6.80/Heavy Wood County 7.7% Heavy Countv Snlits in eenerai versus minorit infiuence districts Ma'orit minorit districts Legal issues and recent iitigation 15 Decisions - Apportionment NE Ohio Constitutionaf Issue Mahonina and Coiumbiana Schavoni and Wilson 3 HDs and 1 SD Lorain / Huron 6 HDS and2 SDs Lucas County 9 HDs andl S-Ds NW Rural i a!'eas 6 HDs and 2 SDs tilAiami and Darke and Preble Monteomerv Count 3 HDs and 1 SD in Butler coun SW Ohio 3 HDS and 1 SD iClark__e Green• Ross McGreesor Option 3 HDS and 1 SD (Terry Johnsonl SD 14 - Niehaus et all and Careyl 3 HDs and 1 SD iPeterson Rosenbereer HDsinSD17 10 HDs and 3+ SDs in Franklin County Franklin county plus sneaker Batchelder HD / SD 22 Summit / Wayne County Stark County !0 9 HDs and 3 SDs Rural 2011Di ies Ikiiousd-Man^"^ ^.,- ^9F til^^`, ` =a Muskingum Ashtabula Greene(must) ilton (must/ border) Perry Auglaize Ham Pickaway Beimont Holmes Portage (must) Butter (must) Lake (must/ border) Ross Clark (must) Lawrence Seneca Clermont (must) Licking (must) Shetby Cuyahoga (must / border) Logan Stark (must) Darke Lorain (must) Summit (must) Delaware (must) Lucas (must) Trumbull (must) Fairfield (must) Mahon ing (must I. border) Vinton Franklin (must / border) Marion Warren (must) Fulton Medina (must) Washington Geauga Montgomery (must) ^y^^^ Muskingum Auglaize Hamilton (must) Pickaway Butler (must) Holmes Stark (must) Cuyahoga (must) Lake Summit (must) Darke Lawrence Vinton Fulton Logan Franklin (must) Lucas (must) Geauga Montgomery (must) 254 i'vistupsllAvard3l Di3retinti5 52i93f Po19E(eaf3uEidiy^siuri5xt1otise Man1 "--,' Middletown (Butter / Wards 3) Cincinnati (Hamilton / Wards 25) Cuyahoga Falls (Summit / Ward 8) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 22) Austintown Township (Mahoning on precincts) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 31) Marietta (Washington) Columbus ( Franklin / Ward 45) Brunswick ( Medina) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 81) Mentor (Lake) Cleveland (Cuyahoga / Ward 2) Plain Township (Stark on precincts) Cleveland (cuyahoga / Ward 10) Massillon (Stark) Cleveland (Cuyahoga / Ward 15) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 7) Akron (Summit / Ward 2) North Ridgeville (Lorain /Ward 3) Dayton (Montgomery/ Ward 3) 7 sv{2^iivlsiaiis` ulit PdiitleaF SubdtylSToni `t^m$te-fi^a») Middletown (Butler) Cincinnati (Hamifton) Mentor (Lake) Columbus (Franklin) Massillon (Stark) Cleveland(Cuyahoga) Dayton (Mcntgomery) Mercer Ashtabula Geauga Montgomery (must) Belmont Greene (must) must / border) Paulding Butler (must) Hamilton ( Portage (must) Ctark (must) Hardin Stark (must) Clermont (must) Lake (border) Summit (must) Cuyahoga Licki ng ( must) Trumbull (must / border) Delaware (must) Lorain (must) Vinton Fairflield (must) Lucas (must) / border) Warren (must) Franktin (must / border) Mahoning (must Fulton Medina (must) tnust ^-4 3'iN/O 8brder ^tllifCtlunt(e5(5enate-0ulaisl ^; 113ota} '- ' 3 W!O Paulding Athens Geauga Stark (must) Butler (must) Hamilton (must) Summit (must) Cuyahoga (must) Lucas (must) Franklin (must) Montgomery (must) tlPmsi4ns`7uwardsf 4pacintt§ 5pfltil+oiitii'at ^trtfdivSirirtslllausE Ma Columbus (Franklin Ward 1) Akron (Sunimit Ward 1) Columbus (Franklin Ward 12) Akron (Summit Ward 8) Columbus (Franklin Ward 33) 3 HDS Akron (Summit) Columbus (Franklin Ward 38) Amherst(Lorain) Columbus (Franklin Ward 42) Boardman (Mahoning) Columbus (Franklin Ward 54) Canton (Stark) Columbus (Franklin Ward 6) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 13) Columbus (Franklin Ward 61) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 16) Columbus (Franklin Ward 66) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 22) Columbus (Franklin Ward 7) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 23) Columbus (Franklin Ward 70) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 25) Columbus (Franklin Ward 72) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 26) Columbus (Franklin Ward 79) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 6) Dayton (Montgomery / Ward 1) Cincinnati (Hamikon Ward 8) Dayton (Montgomery/ Ward 16) Cleveland (Ward 12) Dayton (Montgomery / Ward 3) Clevefand (Ward 17) Delaware (Delaware) Cleveland (Ward 3) Fairlawn (Summit) Cleveland Ward 13 (3 HDs) Green (Summit) Clinton Township (Fulton) oara Toledo (Lucas / Ward 15) Hamilton(Butier 1+1 precincts) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 17) Heath (Licking) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 24) Huber Heights (Montgomery) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 5) Licking Township (Licking) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 7) Miami Township (Greene) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 9) Miami Township (Montgomery) Union Township (Ciermont) Middletown (Butler on wards) Union Township (Montgomery) Middietown (Warren) Worthington (Franklin Ward 1) Niles (Trumbull) Worthington (Franklin Ward 2) Perry Township (Franklin) Worthington (Frankiin Ward 4) Toledo (Lucas ( Ward 12) 5'ol(t Lucas (must) Butler (must) Montgomery (must) Cuyahoga (must) Stark (must) Franklin (must) Summt (must) Geauga Hamilton (must) I^li3 wariils l"2t3 ilrscitfdt3 SrifitPoltieat'$ubiFnristonS' Huos^Mau) '''%_ SO divisions Cincinnati(Hamilton Ward 10+ 1 precinct) Akron (Summit Ward 1 + 2 precincts) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 16 + 1 precinct) Akron (Summit Ward 10 + 1 precinct) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 17 + 1 precinct) Akron (Sum mit Ward 2 + 2 precincts) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 18+ 1 precinct) Akron (Summit Ward 3 + 6 precincts) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 19 + 2 precincts) Akron (Summit Ward 4 + 3 precincts) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 2 +1 precinct) Akron (Summit ward 5+ 5 precincts) (4 HDS) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 20+4 precincts) Akron (Summit Ward 6 + 3 precincts) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 21 + 1 precinct) Akron (Summit Ward 7 + 1 precinct) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 22 + I precinct) Akron (Summit Ward 8+ 6 precincts) (3HDS) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 23 + 1 precinct) Akron (Summit Ward 9 +2 precincts) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 24+2 precincts) Canton (Stark Ward 1+2 precinct) Cincinnati (Hamiiton Ward 26) Canton (Stark Ward 2 + 1 precinct) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 3 +3 precincts) Canton (Stark Ward 4 + 5 precinct) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 4+2 precincts) Canton (Stark Ward 6 + 1 precinct) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 6 + 2 precincts) Canton (Stark Ward 7+ 1 precinct) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 7+3 precincts) Canton (Stark Ward 9 + 2 precinct) Cleveland (Cuyahoga Ward 10+3 precincts) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 1+ 1 precinct) tt^ se an: Columbus (Ward 51 +1 precinct) Cleveland (Cuyahoga Ward 10 +4 precincts) Columbus (Ward 53 +1 precinct) Cleveland (Cuyahoga Ward 12 + 2 precincts) Columbus (Ward 55+1 precinct) Cleveland (Cuyahoga Ward 14 + 3 precincts) Columbus (Ward 56 + I precinct) Cleveland (Cuyahoga Ward 14 + 4 precincts) Columbus (Ward 57+1 precinct) Cleveland (Cuyahoga Ward 18 + 2 precincts) Columbus (Ward 58 +1 precinct) Cleveland (Cuyahoga Ward 3 + 5 precincts) Columbus (Ward 59 + 2 precincts) Cleveland (Cuyahoga Ward 4 + 1 precinct) columbus (ward 6+3 precinct) Cleveland (Cuyahoga Ward 5 +3 precincts) Columbus (Ward 61+1 precinct) Cleveland (Cuyahoga Ward 8+ 2 precincts) Columbus (Ward 63 +3 precinct) Cleveland (Cuyahoga Ward 9 + 3 precincts) Columbus (Ward 7 +1 precinct) Columbus (Franklin Ward 60+1 precinct) Columbus (Ward 8+2 precinct) Columbus(Frankltn Ward 64+2 precincts) Columbus (ward 83 +1 precinct) Columbus (Frankiin Ward 69+1 precinct) Columbus (Ward 84+1 precinct) Columbus (Franklin Ward 76 +1 precinct) Columbus (Ward 86+2 precinct) Columbus (Franklin Ward 78+3 precinct) CoEumbus (ward 9+1 precinct) Columbus (Frankiin Ward 79+2 precinct) Dayton (Montgomery Ward 1 + 2 precincts) Columbus (Ward 10+1 precinct) Dayton (Montgomery Ward 15+3 precincts) Columbus (Ward 11 +1 precinct) Dayton (Montgomery Ward 16 + 1 precinct) Columbus (Ward 12 +2 precincts) Dayton (Montgomery Ward 2 + 5 precincts) Columbus (Ward 14+1 precinct) Dayton (Montgomery Ward 21 + 1 precinct) Columbus (Ward 15 +1 precinct) Dayton (Montgomery Ward 22 + 2 precincts) Columbus (Ward 16 +1 precinct) Dayton (Montgomery Ward 3+4precincts) Calumbus(Ward 18+3 precinct) (3 HDs) Dayton (Montgomery Ward 3 + 4 precincts) Columbus (Ward 2 +1 precinct) Dayton (Montgomery Ward 5+ 4 precincts) Columbus (Ward 21 + 1 precinct) Dayton (Montgomery Ward 6 + 2 precincts) Columbus (Ward 21) NorwichTownship(Frankkn) Columbus (Ward 23+1 precinct) Orange (Delaware) - 3 precincts Columbus (Ward 25 +6 precinct) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 11+ 1 precincts) Columbus (Ward 27 +1 precinct) Toledo (Lucas/ Ward 12+2 on precincts) Columbus (Ward 32 +2 precincts) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 16+ 3 precincts) Columbus (Ward 33 +1 precinct) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 2 t 1 precincts) Columbus (Ward 36+2 precincts) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 3) Columbus (Ward 37) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 4 + 2 precincts) Calum bus(ward 38 +1 precinct) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 5+ 1 precincts) Calumbus (Ward 39+1 precinct) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 6 + 2 precincts) Columbus (Ward 39+1 precinct) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 7+ 1 precincts) Columbus (Ward 43 + 1precinct) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 9 + 3 precincts) (3 HDs) Columbus (Ward 46 +1 precinct) Turtle Creek Township (Warren on precincts) Columbus (Ward 5 + 1 precinct) FlrtiWSE:aia gl^11) P'iyiitical $ubdivisions°[itouse Maul S:aliai'st^rns t 33ativards (^? Columbus (Franklin / Ward 31 + 1 precinct) Akron (Summit/ Ward 1+2 precincts) Columbus(Frankbn / Ward 43 + 1 precincts) Akron (Summit / Ward 10 + 2 precincts) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 46+1 precincts) Akron (Summit / Ward 5 + 3 precincts) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 5+ 1 precinct) Akron (Summit / Ward 6 + 3 precincts) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 51+ 1 precinct) Akron (Summit / Ward 7 + 4 precincts) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 55 + 2 precincts) Akron (Summit / Ward8+2 precincts) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 57) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 22 + 1 precinct) Cofumbus (Franklin / Ward 6 + 2 precincts) Cincinnati (Hamilton Ward 26) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 78 + 1 precinct) Cleveland (Cuyahoga / Ward 17+6 preciricts) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 84) Cleveland (Cuyahoga / Ward 8 + 2 precincts) Columbus (Franklin ( W a rd 85 + 2 precinct) Cleveland (Cuyahoga I Ward 9 +4 precincts) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 86 + 1 precinct) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 10 + 1 precinct) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 9 + 1 precinct) Columbus (Franklin /Ward 12) Columbus ( Fra nklin / Ward 14 + 2 precincts) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 11) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 16 + 3 precincts) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 2) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 3) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 18 + i precinct) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 22 + 1 precinct) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 3) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 4 + 2 precincts) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 23 +1 precinct) Toledo (Lucas / Ward 9 + 1 precinct) Columbus (Franklin / Ward 25 + 2 precincts) CLARKE 2Uli Finat House and Senate M^ 13 W(D Border 29 total 13 W/O must Shcit Counties iHouse Mao): Portage (must) Greene (muat) Butler (must) Ross (3 splits) Hamilton (must / border) Clark (must) Shelby Huron champaign stark (must) Lake (must / border) Clennont (must) Summit (must) Licking (must) Clinton Trumbull (must) border) Lorain (must) Cuyahoga (must / Warren (must) Lucas (must) Delaware (must) Washington Ma honing (must / border) Falrfield (must) Wyandot Medina (must) Franklin (must / border) Montgomery (must) Geauga (3 splits) 11 totai 3 W!O must 3 W/O Barder Solit ounties (Senate Maal: Hamilton (must) Stark (must) Butler (must) Summit (must) Lucas (must) Cuyahoga (must) Wyandot Montgomery (must) Franklin (must) Ross Geauga House Districts SenateDistricts 2001 SPLIT 14 Adams -1 -° --- 4 12 Allen i SPLIT SPLIT Ashland 32 Ashtabula i 99 20 Athens 92 SPLIT ....__- .Auglaize SPLIT SPLIT 30 ^B etmont 88 14 Brown 4 Butler SPLIT 61 33 Carrof! 12 11 Champaign 78 SPLIT 10 Clark 14 Clermont SPLIT 86 17 Clinton 1 30 Columblana 94 20 Coshocton 82 26 Crawford SPLST 18 ahoqa SPLlT CuY_ _. SPLIl` 19 Darke SPLIT 1 SPLIT 20 Defiance 49 2 21 Delaware SQ 2 Erie 3 2a22 Fairfield 17 Fayette 85 24 SPLiT Franklin _ SPLIT 25 _ _. 74 ^s- Fulton 87 27 - Gallia - 98 Geau a Greene SPLIT 93 Guernsey Hamilton SPLlT 76 Hancock Hardin 76 Harrison 96 75 Henry 17 _ Highland 86 91 _- _` - _Hocking 97 Holmes 58 Huron 87 17 Jackson 95 30 Jefferson 90 19 _ Knox 18 Lake SPLIT SPLIT Lawrence SPLIT SPLI7 31 Licking 26 Logan 13 Lorein SPLIT Lucas 10 -7 Madison House Districts Senate Districts 33 SPLIT 50 Mahoning 26 SPLIT 51 Marion 22 Medina SPLIT 52 92 20 Meigs 53 77 12 Mercer 5 54 79 Miami 55 93 20 56 Monroe SPLIT SPLIT Montgomery 57 92 20 Morgan 58 90 19 59 Morrow 20 Muskingum SPLIT 60 93 20 61 Noble SPLIT SPLIT1 5? Ottawa 75 Pautding 63 91 31 ' Perry sa SPLIT SPLIT_ ss Pickaway 17 66 Pike 86 SPLIT 28 67 Portage 12 77 Prebke 1 s6 75 89 putnam 19 SPLIT Richland 17 SPLIT 71 Ross.--- ... 26 . 72 Sandusky _81 89 14 73 °- -- - Scioto SPLIT SPLIT 74 Seneca 12 78 75_ Shelb^_. SPLIT Stark SPLIT 76 SPLIT SPLIT 77 - Summit SPLIT 32 78 ------Trumbuli SPLIT SPLIT 79 --^Tuscarawas 83 26 80Union 75 81 VanWert 87 82 - Vinton__ SPLIT 83 Warren Washington SPLIT 84 1- 85 Wayne 74 86 Wiiliams 6 87 Wood 82 88 Wyandot 15 Splits TOTAL SPLITS 35 splits 30 splits 14 splits REMOYE WROR SPLITS-", 15 splits - - ' 9 splits Page i of I Gmai1- Amended with Rays comments Ray DiRossi Amended with Rays comments t message Thu, Sep 29, 2011 at 12:43 PM Ray DiRossi 2011-09-30 Apportionment Board Meeting Scriptdoc ^ 33K EXHIBIT --)- 7 l I ^ https:l/mail.google.com/mail/9ui=2&ik-2ed7e552a7&cdew=pt&eat=Redistricting%20Em... 10/24/2011 APPORTIONMENT BOARD MEEfING SCRIPT SEPTEMBER30,2011 (EWERGENCY MEETING) GOVERNOR KASICH: Pursuant, to notice, this emergency meeting of the Apportionment Board will now come to order. The Secretary will please call the roll. SECRETARY: [calls roll, announces quorum] [:btemhers s•tale nanrej SECRETARY: All members are present; we have a quorum. GOVERNOR KASICH: At our last hearing there was some confusion with regards to an an7endment offered by the joint Secretaries that proposcd to amend the pairings of 6 Hottse districts in NE Ohio to form 2 Senate districts. The Chair recessed the committee in order to clear up the confusion, but we were not able to get clarity during qur recess. The Joint Secretaries now feel they have accurate information and have asked us to reconvene. GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretaries have circulated for review in your folders transcripts from our meeting from September 281h. At this time, I will ask for a motion to dispense with the reading of the minutes. AUDITOR YOST: Mr. Chairman, I move that we dispense rrith the reading of the minutes. SECRETARY HUSTED OR PRESIDENT NIEHAUS: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been moved and seconded. Any objections? Hearing none, the reading is waived. Is there a motion on the minutes? AUDITOR YOST: Mr. Chaitman, I move that we adopt the minutes of the last meeting as submitted in the transcript. SECRETARY HUSTED OR PRESIDENT NIEHAUS: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been moved and seconded. Any objections? Seeing none, the minutes are adopted. At the last meeting of the Board on Wednesday, September 28, Auditor Yost moved that we adjoum subject to the call of the Chair as he deems necessary. I've called this emergency meeting to reconsider an amendment that was proposed on Wednesday September 28`h. I would ask Secretary DiRossi to explain "Amendment B" which is now being distributed to all members. Secretary DiRossi "Explains Amendment B" GOVERNOR KASICH: Any discussion of Amendment B? AUDITOR YOST: Mr. Chairman,l move that we adopt Amendmcnt B. SECRETARY HUSTED OR PRESIDENT NIEHAUS: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: Will the Secretary call the roll GOVERNOR KASICH: I will now entertain a motion to ask my office to pubiish this amended plan by October 5'h, 2011, as provided in Article XI of the Ohio Constitution, the Ohio Revised Code, and the Board's Rules. AUDITOR YOST: So moved. SECRETARY HUSTED or PRESIDENT NIEHAUS: Second. GOVENOR KASICH: The motiomhas been moved and seconded. Are there any objections? Seeing none, my otlice will comply forthwith with the publishing of the adopted plan of apportionment. 'Phe business of the 2011 Apportionment Board having been completed and a mandate having been met, is there a motion to adjourn? ALTDITOR YOST: Mr. Chairman, I move that the 2011 Apportionment Board be adjourned subject to a further call by the Chair as he deems necessary. NIEHAUS: Second. SECRETARY HUSTED or PRESIDENT GOV'ENOR KASICH: The motion has been moved and seconded. Are there any objections? Seeing none, this meeting of the 2011 Apportionment Board is hereby adjourned. I Heather Mann From, Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, September 29, 2011 1:49 PM mail.com);'Matt Huffman' To: 'Mike DfOoe'; 'Ben Yoho';'Mtchael t.enzo'; Troy Judy (troy.]udy@g Subject: Indexes.xlsx Attachments: Indexes.xlsx Updated indexes. EXHIBIT I I ^-l 5 48310/. 4S_31% 2.41% 1.16% 67 64.03% 3.24% 1.68% 64.73010 59.28% 1 59.37% 1.46% 1.28% 59.37% 56.13% 4 61.02% 11.07% 1.92% 61.02% 59.57% 77 59,83% 60.45% 57.79% 5.33% 1.36% 3.62o/a 3 51.43% 51.43o/u 45.50% 2.51% 48.2.5% 1.40% See Budish 7 -ICevny Yuko D. (2012) 26.86% 21.20% 8 24.53% 56.51% 1:540/a 8 Annond Budish -D- (2014) 1937% 14-01o/u 9 18.89n/o 52.82% 1.65% 9 Barbara Boyd -D- (2014) 17.59% 12.57% 10 16.20% 46.23% 12.80'4'0 18.79% 13.57% 11 18.26% 10 Bill Patmon -D- (2018) 53.15% 4.82% 11 Sandra Willimus -D- (2014) 19.63% 14.45o/n 12 20.68% 68-87o/n 1.13% 15.46% 10.85% 13 30.67% 12 1ohnBames -D- (2018) 13.46% 10.92% 13 NicidcAmonio -D- (2018) 31.16% 25.03% 14 40.46% 9.91% 7.65% -D-(2014) 37.12% 33.44o/u 15 42.57% 14Milce Foley 2.25% 3.24% 15. Tim De6eeter-D- (2012) 43.78% 42.25% 16 53.34n/n 1.41% 2.21% 53.34% 48.29% 6 52.42% 6.27% 1.22% 50.51% 47.69o/n 7 52.65n/o 2.39% 1.79% 52.65% 49.14°/n 19 56.92% 53.93% 47.34% 18.12n/n 2.49% 3.68% See (ionzalez 47.930/0 41.16% 1933o/n 20 Nancy Garlar^d -D- (2016) 5.92%n 21 57-57% 47.62% 39.59% 20.68% 6.04% 3.59% 22 41.92% 50.81% 43.84o/u 23 56.78% 4.18% 4.06% 59.06% 53.60% 18 3036% 6.520/6 4.59% -D- (2014) 50.21% 42.85% 24 Ted Celeste 12.040/6 4.31% See Celcste Stinaiano -D- (2018) 42.27% 38.78% 26 25.88% 25Michael 50.37% 4.05% 26 Tracy Maxwell Heard -D- (2014) 21.86% 16.42% 25 22.24% 40.52% 3.40% 27 Carl6on Weddington -D- (2016) 18.77o.u 14.08% 28 56.93% 24-85o/u 3.97% 28Conuie Pillich-D- (2016) 50.84% 44-71% 29 65.40% 22.15% 1.41% 57.77% 52.93% 30 71.31% 74.06% 72.62% 1.68% 0.73% See Terhar 44.26% 36.22% 33.17o/n 3.10% 31. Denise Driehaus -D- (2016) 32 31_96% 25.39% 18.09'Yo 42.79% 2.43%n 32 Dale Mallory -D- (2014) 33 32.07o/n 28.38%n 22.54o/n 47.92o/u 2.13% 33 Alicia iteece -D- (2018) 27 64.88% 58.190/ 51.52% 8.20% 1.71% 54 63.82o/n 68.01% 64.25% 2.860/ 1.88% 40 57.73% 60.18% 59.08% 7.66% 1.27% 41 58.29% 58.52% 55.39"/o 4.96% 1_86% 0 42 62.28% 3.qp/o t. 5 0 60.99% 57.49yo 39 21.65% 23.40% 18.75%n 44.31% 2.85% 39 ClaytonLuckie -D- (2014) 43 47.94o/n 32.47% 2791% 43.21% 1.58% 40 Roland Wiobum -D- (2016) 38 52.47% 50.38o/ 47.13% 8.36% 1.06o/n 37 52.91% 51-89% 48.57% 2.42o/a 1.13% 36 47.32% 49.59% 49.75% 1-450/. 0.73% 34 27.17% 11% 16.99% 42.38% 2.32% 44 Vemon Sykes -D- (2014) 22 . 35. -36:600/ 36.93% 35.08% 11.78% 1.19% 45 Zach Millcovich -D- (2018) 47 56.12% 49.21% 3.98% 236% 52.76% 46 42.33% 29.18% 15.87% 8.26o/n 47Tecesa Fedor-D- (2018) 35.23% 44 20.72% 20.27% 14.44% 47.77% 4.44% 48 Michael A.shford -D- (2018) See Fedor 37.96% 33.80% 6.10% 4.42% 49 Matt Szo1loGi -D- (2014) 50 54.10% 53.56o/n 52.72% 1.09% 0.81% 48 52.80% 49.51% 4.45% 1.33% 52.91% 49 37.34% 36-410.0 32.60o/n 16.63% 1.77n/n 52 S[cghen 3lesnisk -D- (2016) 53 60.79% 61-62% 60.87% 3.30`/o 1.26% 51 60.73% 60-740/o 58.64% 8.84% 4.38% 52 69-02°/n 65.84% 61.92% 7.97% 4.01°/n 14.15%, 56 3528% 31.080% 26.75% 13.76% S6 Daa Rmnos -1)- (2018) 55 47.1M 50.68% 47.10% 3.976/o 2,47% 57Matt l,undy -D- (3oi4) 57 54.22% 52.80% 49.76% 3.08% 3.15% 59 43.10% 38.81% 42.33% 3.77% 1.89% 59Ron Gerbeny-D- (2016) 58 21.56°/u 18.95% 20.04% 31.48% 7A6% 60 RobeA Hagan -D- (2014) See Thompson 48.07°/n 48.38o/u 2.53% 0.81% 61 Merk Okey -D- (2014) 60 46.70% 51.21% 49.13% 115% 1.03% 62 Loerauw Fende -D- (2012) 61 55.19% 51.49% 48.36% 2.68% 3'.93% 64 3620% 35.59% 37.57% 11.88% 1.08% 64 Tom I.efson -D- (2014) 63 33370A 32:420% 36.75% 3.98% 0.99% 65 Sean O'B`ien-D- (2018) 65 68.63% 68.29% 64.96% 1.38% 1.41% 62 70.84"l0 691)7% 67.19% 4.60% 1.84% 75 43.75% 4170% 42.61% 4.68% 1.23% 68 BatWeenClYdo-D- (2018) 69 57.62% 55.91% 53.09% 1.22% 1.29% 73 61.00% 60.53% 57.44% 8.68% 1.95% 71 58.35% 58.72% 55.58% 3.73% 1.18% 79 50.20% 4825% 46.82% 10_54% 2.61% 2 55.71% 54.27% 54.15% 10.93% 1.21% 93. Jay Gayal-D- (2014) 82 60-55% 57.69% 53.56% 1.01% 5.33% 81 61.08% 63.75% 61.79% 0.46 % 3.74% 83 63.73% 64.58% 61.82% 1.15% 2.54% 84 69.01% 65.79% 67.08% 0.35% 0.85% 85 62.63% 64.35% 64.96% 1.56°k 0.94% 80 65.13% 65.17% 64.22% 1.67"/o 0.92% 89 46.90% 46.52% 4334% 5.73% 2.860/. 80 ^Dennis Muiray-tY(2016)^ 88 52-75°i° 52.30% 47.74% 2.40% 539% 87 60.00% 56.78% 54.55% 4.04% 1.53% 86 6133% 65.40°/u 62.32% 1.91% 0.96% 74 60.81% 61.11% 60.39% 4.25% 1.09% 92 55.32°/a 55.72% 56.37% 6.32% 0,980/0 91 58.96% 59.13% 59.76% 1.58% 0.70% 93 54.13% 54.41% 59.05% 1.27% 0.63% 66 64.22% 63.62% 63.60% 0.60% 0.59% 90 49.17% 47.44% 53A6o/u 2.62"/0 0.74% 68 64.00% 61.64°/n 60_23"/n 0.81% 0:88% 72 56.24% _ 55.67% 5536°/. 0-89°u 0.66% 94 42.66% 43.060/a 43.55% 2.37% 1.00% 92:Debbie PLillipa -D- (2016) 95 50.87% 50.43% 53.00% 1.16% 0.51% 97 53.40% 53.20% 51.98% 2.95% 0.54% 96 40.12% 40.33% 46.61% 4.14% 015% 95 LouGentile _D- (2018) 98 54.09% 50.64% 50.50% 2.51% 1.35 % 70 57.32% 61.56% 59.43% 0.57% 0.78% 76 57.72% 58.31% 55.64% 2.24% 0.97% 99 46.89% 44.78% 42.89% 3.54% 2.38% 17 4431% Franklin Conairy (OPEN) 20 51.43% Franklin County (OPEld) 24 56.50% Franklin County (OPF.N) 31 34.55% Hamilton County (OPEN) 45 36.93% Luces County (OPEN) 78 55.39% SE Ohia (OPEN) Hocking base 0.00% 52:78% 0.00% -0.708/6 58.49% -0.79% 0.001y. 56.13% 0.00% 0.00%u 59.57% 0.00% -0.62% 56.60"/0 -1.19% 0:00% 45.50"/0 0.00% 5.16% ^ 19.47% 5.46% 1.30% 13.31% 0.74% -2.59% 10.99% -2.58% -1.37% 13.08% -1.37% 5.22% 16.32% 5.47% -0.^#9%^ 24.55% -0.48% 3.34°u 37.75% 4.31% -1-21on . 40-42% -1.83% 0.00% 48.29% 0.00% 1.91% 49.54% 1.85% 0.D0% 49.14"/o 0.00% 2.99% 50.43% 3.0.9% 9.95% 49.69% 10.10% -8.89% 34.85% -8.99o/u -2.28% 5 L 10% -2.50% -19A5% 25.86% -16.99% 4.02% 19.65% 3.23% 3.47% 16.00% 1.92% 6.09o/n 51.33% 6.62o/u 7.63% 62.29% 9.36% -2.75% 68.89% -3.73% 6.57% 23.10% 5.0i% 3.690i6 ^ 25.28% 2.74% 6.69% 58.51% 7.29% -4.19% 63.06% -1.19% -2.45%' 55.86% -3.22°/n -0.23% 54.81% -0.58% 1.29% 59.44% 1.95% -1.75% 16.66% -2.09% 15.47% 46.10% 18.19% 2.09% 50.98% 3.85% 1.02% 49.08% 0.51% -2.27°/n 46-40on -3.35% 5.06% 21.68% 4,69% =0_33'.10 34.56% -0.52"0 334"/0 . ^52.35% 3.14% 7.10% . 37.57% 8.39% 0.45% 14.77% 033% 0,54% 52.87% 0.15% -0.11% 49.86% 0.35% 0.93% 33.23% 0.63% -0.83% ^ ^ 60.26% -0.61% -0_01% 58.60% -0.04% 3.18% 65.50% 3.58% 420%o 31.51% 4.76% .-3.50%43.11% -3.99% 1.42"/ 50.85% 1.09% 4,29% 46.91% 4.58% 2.61% :. 22.96% 2.92°/n -4.51% 44.35% -4.78% 3.70% 52.49o/u 4.13% 1.21% 38.60% 1_03% 0.95% 37.61% 0.86% 0.34% 65.59% 0.63o/a 1.77% 67.31% 0.12% -L95% 41.43% -1.18% 1.71% 54.73% 1.64% 0.47% 58.68a/o 1.24% -037% 54.94°0 -0.64% 1.95% 49.10% 2.28% 1:44% 55.68o/n 1.53% 2-86% 58.78% 5.22% -2.67% 58.43% -3-36% -0.85% 60.53% -I.29% 3.22°/ 70.41% 3.33% -1.72% 61.08o/n -3.88% -0.04% 64.26% 0.04% 038% 43.63% 0.29% 0.45% 48.19% 0.45% 3.22°/a 58.65o/a 4.10% -0.07% 57.70% fi-62% -0.30% 58.77%a -1.62% -0.40% 55.99% -0.38% -0.17% 59.45% -0.31% -0.28% 59.12% 0.07% 0.60% 63.62% 0.02% 1.73% 53.80% 0.74% 236% 59.94% -0.29% 0.57% 55.54% 0.18% -0.40% 43.56% 0.01% 0.44% 53.85% 0.85% 0.20% 52.74% 0.76% -0.21a/° 46.35% -0.26% 3.45% 50.94% 0.44"/0 -4.24o/a 55.64% -3.79o/a -0.59% 55.20% -0.44% 2.11% 44.04% 1.15% 40.89o.u 4537% 50.03% 28.41% 32.21% 54.68% Page i of 2 t3inail - Fw: After todays hearing Ray DiRossi Fw: After todays hearing 1 message Fri, Sep 30, 2011 at 2:21 PM [email protected] Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry From: Halle Pelger Thanksl Halle Pelger 614.202.3043 - Cell Date: Fri, 30 Sep 2011 14:10:52 -0400 Subject: Re: After todays hearing From: raydirossicfgmail.com To: halle3333Cu?hotmail.com stand by On Fri, Sep 30, 2011 at 2:04 PM, Halle Pelger Ahead of tme would be preferrable Halle Pelger 614.202.3043 - Cell Date: Fri, 30 Sep 2011 13:56:27 -0400 Subject: After todays hearing From: ra d'[email protected] To: halte3333(rDhotmaiLcom CC: heathernmannpgmail.com https:!/mail.googje.comlmaij/?ui=2&ik=2cd7e 552a7&view=pt&cat=Redistrictin g:'o20Em.:. 10/24/2011 Gma.il - Fw: After todays hearing Page 2 of 2 katte Assuming the hearing today goes the way Heather and I expect it to -adoption of Amendment "B" and no other amendments or amendments to that amendment we will have some files that It would be very helpful to have posted to the web site updated DBF fiels and shapefiles for the house and senate map A final statewide color map of the house and senate districts zoom ins for the house and senate distriots in major urban areas Is it helpful to send that stuff ahead of 6me.._ noting that until the board adopts the amendment they are not official? or wait until after the heartng? https:l/mail.google.eomlniail!?ui=2&ik=2cd7e552a7&viei*-pt&cat=ftedistricting%20E:m.._ 10l2412011 0 62 Miem Map layers Districts BOE County BOE MCD1PIace 2 Precinct Mask 0 1.5 3 4.5 Miles Mto 70 Map tayers Districts BOE County BOE MCDiPlace ^ Precinct Mask 3.3 6.7 10 Miles 95 ns.0• , i; N.rtimn ^ Waninyum Po. CnrroHOH m Ih Lw bn P.m Nod 7: innNin C u- I ille • m Nn^^i Ntlrrl.on OH W.•Finpim G.ei snonc^L ` Mm rt(.Id A•V & m N• ilk Xnl • y^. f'ImM1intl r y °, Whacline Kitkv" Uniun I SL^Ik I Mn^fiiuwn IM WuMqfon OH Map layers Q Districts BOE County BOE MCDIPIace ® Precinct Mask 5 10 15 Miles R C 102 0A(D) STATHML+NT OdfDl of tfs Revised Coele° C")=m Reauircd bv the Oluo Ethics La v nnder Seetion 102 wm 1. Nnme oBPUblic OEftcial or Empioycc' Q ^tj^ 131(2tlSSt "< prz^or =d Home AddresS:, 573Z 5P21N127-t3v2AY rJ oNio L13DtZ 7RANSAOR7RT±O^ /!K^ 2. NanuofyourPublieAgency: dKt(Z_^V°^ nf Agency Address:. Name of PubLc Agency before tvitich the ntatter is pending or with which business is to be conducted(note that the exception provided by R.C. 102_04(D) does not oxtemt to matters pending before your own agency or business to be conducted with your own agency): _ L^(s^SlhT d4 "IRSLt Fof2-U' - sT/11c7r/uCr {^i^E1 5^N2^7 rJ7 FR AgencyAddress: 7Z 7 SOUTN tLS fJEtifl 1^1 3 115- 4. Brief description of the panding matter and of the personat services to be rendered before the agetuy Bsted in nnmber 3, or brief description of the goods or services to be purchased by the agcncy listed in number 3: CUNi(ZACT F'a2 il.e. beoelOPwW-r, toNSn¢ucriav. p(ftrSC)yT4^`1N D+ ^c 4KiA A'PPO2i"tOftrM.l^1'.^'f y2r"4`ts-rrt'•fz`,ti1^ Fuf^owlr.v i1..c 2010 ct^vsv.s Declaration-Ihcreby disqualify inyself for a period of two yatrs frown any official participation as an ofFicial or employee of: . . . /oDoT/7R.4c- ©}{^d ^t'Pktc7Me^vC tlF T2h+.^ PoQThi:JoW (Agencyas listed in nnmber 2) in any matter involving any public urricial or entployce of: `t(oi SII, 7i U b` ilfS K drLt6 DIl) ^k DSSTJ? i C i^14 ! G SC is pcnding or with wtuch bustncss rs to be conducted as bstc d tn nun r (Ageycy before which t1nC^ ^ ^^1^ " (Datc: t 1 ^'1 ^^ Signature: ^ statetnent must be filed with die public agencies designated in numbers 2 and 3 above, and NOTE: Copies of this Spring Street, L3, Cotumbus, Ohio with the Ohio EthicsConvnission, William Grectt Bttilding, 30 West Corntnission-(614) 466-7090. 43215-2256. Please refer any questions to the Ohio Ethics 66 Heather Mann with Rep. Huffman Subject: Meeting Rep. Huifman's offioe, 14th Floor Location: 5tart, Thu 8118/2011 12:00 PM End: Thu 8/1812011 1:00 PM Recurrencet (none) Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: Heather Mann Required Attendees: Troy Judy EXHIBIT 1 ql^ Nsather Mann Subject: WeelttY Redistricting Meeting Location: 14ttb FloorConterence Rootn, RNte Bldg Starr Mon 8/15f2011 3:00 PM End: Mon 8115/2011 4:00 PM Recurrence: Weeldy Meeting Status: Meeting organiaer Organizer: Heather Naetie Mann Heather Mann Meeting SabJeet• Weekly Redlstri4fing Locatton: 14tth Floor Conferencs Room, Riffe Bltlg Start: Mon B/2212011 3:00 PM End: Mon 8/2212011 4:00 PM Recurrence: Weekly Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: Heather Moetle Mann I HeatherlNann Weekly Redistdcting Meeting Subject:Location: 14tth Floor Confererroe Room, Riife B1dg 8129PL011 3:00 PM Start: Mon End: Mon 8/29/20114:00 PM Recurrence: Weekly Meeting Status: Moeting organizer Organhcer. Heather Noelle Mann Heather Mann Auditor Yost SubJeet: Meeting with Mon 8/29124114:30 PM Start: Mon 812912a11 5:00 PM End: (none) Recu►rence: Organizer. Heather Mann I eather Mann HOLD for maeting with Ray, Heather, Halle Pelger SubJect: Conference Room ouGside 8enator Faber's otfios Location: Thu 9/1t2011 12:30 PM Start: Thu 91112011 1:30 PM End: Recurrence: (none) AAeeting Status: Meeting organizer Heather Mann Organker. Ray D1Rossf; Michaet Lenzo; Troy J Required !►ttendees: Heather Mann _ with Ray & Heather Su6ject: Meeting Thu 911/20114:30 PM Stan:End: Thu 911120117:30 PM Recurrenca: (none) Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Heather Mann il.com QrganFzer. A4ike Didoe: Benjamin Yoho; r^+dirossi^dgma Required Attendees: Heather Mann Su6#ect: Meeting with Batch, Niehaus, and Srdden gtart: Fri 9!2/2011 9:30 AM End: Fri 91?l2011 10:00 AM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: Heather Mann I Heather Mann Subject: Weekly Redis[ricting Meeting Location: 14tth Floor Conterence Room, Riffe Bldg Start; Mon 9/5720113:00 PM End: Mon 916/2011 4:00 PM Reeurrence: Weekly Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer. Heather Noelle Mann Heather Mann Subject Weekly Redistrictin9 Meeting Location: ^ftite Start: Tue 9162011 5:00 PM End: Tue 91612011 6:00 PM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Accepted 6rganizer. HeatherNpeOe Mann i Heather Mann Subject: Judge Nodene Miller Meeting Location: Conference Room - 14th Floor Policy Start: Wed 9/712011 2:00 PM End: Wed 9l7/2011 3:00 PM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Accepted 0rganizer: Lenzo, Mike RG Appart.ionment Board Heather Mann Subject: Weekly Redisiricting MeeGng Location: 14tth Floor Conference Room, Riffe Bldg Start: Mon 9I12f20t1 3:00 PM End: Mon 9112120t1 4:00 PM Reeurrence: WeeMy Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: Heather Noetie Mann L Heather Ma nn Subject: Call with FiaBe Petger (814.387,7355) Start: Thu 9/15/2011 2:00 PM Cnd: Thu 911512011 3:00 PM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Mee#ing organizer Organizer: Heather Mann Required Attendees: Ray piRossi Heather Mann Mtg w Pres N, Troy, Chad, Dittoe, Nathan, Lenzo, Heather, Ray Subject: Apportionment Location: 14th Floor, Speaker's Office Start: Fri 8/96/2091 2:30 PM End: Fri 911612011 6:00 PM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: Batchelder, Bill 1 .._.^.__..-.-Heather Mann qppurtionment Mtg w Troy, Chad, Dittoe, LenzO, Heather, Nathan $ubject: start; Fri 9/18/2011 12:00 AM End: Fri 9118/20112:00 PM Recurrence: (none) Meating Status: Meeting organizer Urganizer. 6atchelder, BIII i Heather Subject: Secretary Husted mtg Location: Offsite Mon 9119/2011 10:45 AM Start: Mon 9I19/2011 12:45 PM End: Recurrence: (none) Meeting 8fatus: Meeting org8nizer organiser: Heather Mann Raquirad Attendees: Troy J; 'Lenzo. Mike' Heather Mann SublacG Weekly Rediatricting Meeting Conference Room, Riffe Bldg Location: 14tthFkior 9/19/20113:00 PM 5tart. Mon End: Mon 9119120114i00 PM Recurrence: Weekly Meeting 8tatus: Meeting organizer Noeiie Mann Organizer: Heather Heather Mann gupject. Malt Carte mtg Location: dflsite Start: Tue 9120I2011 2:00 PM End: Tue 912012011 3:0D PM RecOrrence: (none) Meeting Status: Meeting organFzer Qrgahizer: Heather Mann Ray DiRossi; Michaei Lenzo; Troy J; Matthew T. Schuler Required Attendees: Heather Mann Subject: FW: Leadership Meeling Location:. Speaker's Office, Statehouse Start: Tue 9127/2011 9:00 AM End: Tue 9127l2011 10:00 AM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Accepted t3rganizer: Batchelder, Bill ---Originai Appointment --- From: Batchelder, Bill Bent; Thursday, September 22, 2011 11:57 AM To: Batd elder, Bii(; troy iudvbumaii.mm; Hawiey, Ghad; Dittoe, Michaei; Slonaker, Nathan s'ubject: lzadership Meeting Tuesday, September 27, 20119c00 AM-10:00 AM (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time (US & Canada). When: Where: Speaker's Office, Statehouse When: Tuesday, September 27, 20119:00 AM-10:00 AM (GM7 05:00) Eastern Time (US & Canada). WEoere:Speaker'sOffke,Statehouse time adjustments. Note: The GtvTi offset above does not reflect daylight saving yv..iwYn.Y•.f wYwy....4wY. W Y t Heather Mann Subjecti: Weekly Redistricting Meefmg Locatian: 14tth Floor Cenference Room, RFtfe Bldg Start_ Mon 101312011 3:00 PM End: Mon 10/3/2011 4:00 PM Recurrence: Weekly Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: Heather Noelle Mann 1 Heather Mann Subject: Meeting with Haiie, Heather, & Ray Location; SOS CHfce Start: Fri 10L7/2011 1:00 PM End: Fri 1017120112:00 PM Recurrensei (none) Meeting Status: Meet+ng organizer Organizer: Heather Npeile Mann Required Attendees: Halle Pelger, Ray DiRossi Mann, Heather From: Mann, Heather ' Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 12:15 PM To: [email protected] redistricting stuff Subject: 2011-06-20 Co-Chairs Approval Letter to LSC for SOS Public Process Website.PDF Attachments: Christine, Just following up on my voicemail on a few redistricting-related matters. First, attached for your records is the letter from the Task Force Co-Chairs authorizing the funds for the public process website. Mark Flanders indicated to me that they are going to be issuing guidance to the Co-Chairs and any other party receiving funds on what LSC needs in terms of invoices, documentation, etc. Along the same lines, we wanted to ask if you had any information on the planned content of the website. Second, Mark Braden - the special counsel to the Task Force and the Apportionment Board - will be in Columbus next Thursday, July 7 and Friday, July 8"'. We'd like to set up individual meetings with the Apportionment Board members and their key staff with Mr. Braden and John Morgan, who will be consulting. Would the Secretary be available to meet at time and place of his convenience during that timeframe? Thank you, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather mann(a)ohr state oh us CONFIDENTIALITy NOTICE The information conlained in Nis e-mail is intended only for the use of the Individual or engty to which it is addressed and it may contain information that is pdvileged, eon6dential, altorney wom product andror erempt from disclosure under appecable law. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient (or the employee or agenf respoesible fo deliver it to the imended recipent), you are hereby notified that any dissemin2tion, distribution, or cppying of this e-mail is prehibited. II you have received this e-mail in error, please notlfy Ihe sender by retum e-mail. I9 ':lebther Mann From: Michael Lenzo [[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, July 27, 2011 9:06 AM To: Heather Mann Cc: Ray DiRossi; Troy J. Subject: Re: FW: redistricting presentation I saw him give this at the RNC redistricting conference in May 2010. Memories... On Tue, Ju126, 2011 at 8:19 PM, Heather Mann This is actually pretty funny... **^ Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmannQa gmail.com From: John Morgan [mailto:imorean appliedresearchcoordinates com] Sent: Tuesday, July 26, 2011 12:44 PM To: 'Heather Mann' Subject: redistricting presentation Heather, Attached is the redistricting presentation you requested. -John EXHIBIT t 5'l ^Uather Mann From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, July 26, 2011 8:19 PM To: 'Ray DiRossi'; 'Troy J.'; 'Michael Lenzo' Subject: FW: redistricting presentation Attachments: Drafting_tips_Jan2011.pptx This is actually pretty funny... *s* Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmannpemail.com From: John Morgan fmailto:imoroanCalappliedresearchcoordinates com] Sent: Tuesday, July 26, 2011 12:44 PM To: 'Heather Mann' Subject: redistricting presentation Heather, Attached is the redistricting presentation you requested. -John Mann, Heather From: Hansen, Beth [[email protected]] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 2:42 PM To; Mann, Heather; Rench, Karrie; Carle, Matt; Grodhaus, Michael Subject: Re: redistricting meetings Karrie Can you check with Mike and Matt on Thursday? Mopnday 7/11 does not work. T, Th or F? From: Mann, Heather [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 11:53 AM To: Hansen, Beth Subject: RE: redistricting meetings Would Thursday, July 7'h from 9:15-10:15 work for your contingent? I will suggest 3PM for the weekly meetings starting on the 11th and get back to you. Any morning the week after next is fine. 8:30/9AM Monday the 11'"? Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather mann(rilohr.state.oh.us CONFIOENTIAIITYNOTICE or enfity to which it is addressed and it may contain informafion that is privileged, The intormaUon rpnlalned in this e-mail is intended only for the use of ihe indwidual rqnBdenUal, attorney work product andfor exempt from disclosure under applicable law. g Ilre reader of this message is not the intended redplent (or the employee or agent responsible to deliver il to the intended recipient), you are hereby noliried Ihat any disseminagon, distribution, ur copying of this e+oaN is prohibHetl If you have received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender by return e-mail - From: Hansen, Beth [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 11:12 AM To: Mann, Heather; Rench, Karrie; Carle, Matt Cc: Grodhaus, Michael Subject: Re: redistricting meetings The Governor is out of town next week. But Mike Grodhaus, Matt Carle and I would like to met with Braden and Morgan. Thursday is best Weekly meetings on Monday are best in the afternoon. 3? Finally, I'd love to grab coffee - week after next is best! 15 ' EXHIBIT qwl Zo Mann, Heather From: Mann, Heather Friday, July 08, 20117,19 AM TotSentc '[email protected]'; Scott 9orgemenke ([email protected]); Morrison, Christine deviation charts and maps 0YAB Subject; Ohio ANacfrments: ^9piYDEV ptlt^39pXDEV.pdfP39p1YRH0 pdR39pIXRHO.pdO.pdf; 39pIHDEV.pdf: Scott, Christine, and Kate: Attached are the maps and data sets that I brought to the meeting yesterday. I wanted to make sure we shared them with you and the Secretary (we provided these to the Governor and Auditor's offices as well). Thank you, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redlstncting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Faz (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather mann0ohr state.oh.us CONFIDFMWUT'NO,TIGE The Inrcrmation contained in lhis e-mail ,s Intended only for the use of Ihe Individual or entity to whicb B rs addressed andd may eontain inrormaon that is pnvdeged, eonfidenlYal atromey wone prnduct and/er exempt rrom dlsclosure under aPPlicabte law. If the reader v1 rhis message is not the intended reciprent (or ihe employee ur aaenl respar's;ma k+deliver It lo the intended reclplenQ. you are hereby noti6ed that any disseminalion. distribuuon or cvpYin9 or Ihls e-mail ia prohibiletl Ir you 4ave recnived Ib^e e-mali In errot, please nolrfy the sender by retum e,mail. Mann, Heather From: Mann, Heather Sent: Friday, July 08, 2011 7:26 AM To: Hansen, Beth; MichaeLGrodhausQgovernor.ohio.gov; Matt:[email protected] Ohio deviation charts and maps Subject: OH10HABR:pdf: OH10XABR.pdf; OH10YABR.pdf; 39pIHRHO.pdf: 39pIHDEV.pdf; Attacbments: 39pIYDEV.pdf; 39pIXDEV.pdf; 39pIYRHO.pdf; 39pIXRHO.pdf Dear Beth, Michael, and Matt: Attached are the maps and data sets that I brought to the meeting yesterday. I wanted to make sure we shared the full set with you (we provided these to the Auditor and Secretary's offices as well). Please do not forward these to other parties at this time. Thank you, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614)1719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 -Cell heather mannOohrstate oh.us CONFIDENi18 L!D^NOTICE a mtended only for Ihe u5e of the inolvioual or enfity to whlcn It is edereseed and n may cpntain iniortnatiun thal is prNlleged. Tne inPolmahon contained in tms eanaJ eni rmrn disclosure under epplicaMe law. If Ille readar of this messe9e1n n^ t^s e ,maal ^ r n blee It n e e conhoent'.a!, anorney worrt pmduct antlibr esempt ^eeerveA rNs responslWetooellverillolneinlendedreclplen!),youareherebynolVfiedthatanydlssemination,distriburbn,orcopy g pro You e-mail In error, please nolrfy Ihe sender Dy relutn e-malL EXHIBIT -- ^' CONSULTING AGREEMENT This consulting agreement ("The Agreement") is made as of the 3 day of August 2011, between the Republican Members of the Legislative Task Force on Redistricting, Reapportionment, and Park Avenue, Unit Demographic Research ("The Task Force") and Policy Widgets, LLC, 827 City B, Columbus, OH 43206 ("Policy Widgets"). WHEREAS, the Task Force is an entity which was created by R.C. 103.51 for the purpose, among other things, of engaging in such research studies and other activities deemed necessary or appropriate in the preparation and formulation of a plan for the next apportionment of the Ohio General Assembly and a plan for the establishment of distocts for election of representatives to the United States Congress; and, Force is empowered to engage such experts and WHEREAS, pursuant to R.C. 103.51(D), Task technical advisors and fix their compensation, and to obtain such services as are necessary for the Task Force to perform its duties under R.C. 103.51; and, of Policy WHEREAS, the Republican members of the Task Force desire to retain the services Widgets to aid them in carrying out their duties under R.C. 103.51(D) including but not limited to, the preparation and formulation of a plan for the next apportionment of the Ohio General Assembly, and a plan for the establishment of districts for election of representatives to the United States Congress, and Policy Widgets agrees to render such services to the Republican Members of the Task Force, on the terms and conditions set forth herein. The Task Force and Policy Widgets mutually agree as follows: I. Consultin¢ Services. During the term of this agreement, Policy Widgets shall make available Heather N. Mann to render such consulting services as may be needed or requested by the Republican Members of the Task Force to carry out their duties under R.C. 103.51. 2. Term. The term of this agreement will commence on August 3, 2011, and shall expire on December 31, 2011, unless terminated in accordance with the provisions of Section 8 of this agreement or extended by the Task Force by agreement with Policy Widgets. 3. Consultintt Pavments. In consideration of the services to be performed by Policy Widgets pursuant to this agreement, The Task Force agrees to pay Policy Widgets the total sum of seventy-£ve thousand dollars ($75,000) payable as follows: forty thousand dollars ($40,000) on August 22, 2011, and thirty-five thousand dollars ($35,000) payable on October 17, 2011. Further, should litigation be commenced challenging the redistricting plan passed by the General Assembly, the reapportionment plan adopted by the Apportionment Board, or any similar litigation pertaining to the duties in this contract, Policy Widgets shall be paid an additional thirty thousand dollars ($30,000). 4. Expense Reimbursement. During the term of this agreement, Policy Widgets shall be entitled to reimbursement of all reasonable and necessary travel and lodging expenses incurred by Policy Widgets in connection with Policy Widget's performance of the consulting expenses hercunder, provided that Policy Widgets submits to the Task Force EXHIBIT ' Y4 I (071le invoices or other documentary verifications of such expenses. The determination of whether any such expenses submitted by Policy Widgets are reasonable and necessary shall be within the sole discretion of the Task Force; provided, however, that the Task Force shall not deny reimbursing Policy Widgets for any properly verified expenses that the Task Force approved in advance of such reimbursement. The Task Force shall provide parking access to Policy Widgets, the use of which shall be limited to the purpose of benefiting the Task Force in the performance of statutory duties. 5. Other contractual oblieations. Commencing on August 1, 2011, and continuing through October 31, 2011, Policy Widgets shall not engage or hold any other contracts for consulting services related to the General Assembly in the state of Ohio. 6. Independent Contractor. The Task Force and Policy Widgets expressly acknowledge and agree that the consulting services to be provided by Policy Widgets under this agreement shall be performed as an independent contractor and not as an agent or employee to the Task Force or the Republican Members of the Task Force. The parties expressly acknowledge and agree with respect to any payments made to Policy Widgets hereunder, Task Force will not: (i) withhold any federal F.I.C.A. or other federal, state or local taxes; or (ii) contribute to any applicable workers' compensation, unemployment or any other state or federal programs. Further, Policy Widgets agrees that it has no right to bind the Task Force, or the Republican Members, to any legal commitments to third parties. 7. Indemnification. The Task Force shall indemnify and hold harm}ess Policy Widgets including Heather N. Mann, against any and all liability insofar as such liability arises out of or is based upon any plan for apportionment of the Ohio General Assembly or the establishment of districts for election of representatives to the United States Congress, or the formulation or creation of any such plan or for any such matter that the Republican Members of the Task Force use the services of Policy Widgets. For this purpose, liability shall mean any: (i) judgments, damages, costs, charges, expenses, or other liabilities imposed by any court, administrative agency, or other govemmental authority in any executive, legislative, judicial, regulatory, or administrative action, suit, or other proceeding, including any appeals, (ii) costs, charges, and expenses (including, but not limited to, attomeys fees, filing fees, posting of bond, etc.) reasonably incurred in connection of the defense against any such liabilities, in any such action, suit, or other proceeding; and (iii) costs, charges, and expenses (including, but not limited to, attomeys fees) reasonably incurred in connection with investigation or defense of any claim made or threatened (whether or not made or resulting in any action, suit, or other proceeding.) The indemnification from liability as discussed in this section shall continue in full beyond the end of this Agreement on December 31, 2011. 8. Termination. The engagement of Policy Widgets by the Task Force under this agreement shall terminate automatically upon and in the event of death, disability, termination or employment, or other removal or separation of Heather "N. Mann as a representative of Policy Widgets during the term hereof. In the event of termination of Policy Widget's engagement, prior to the expiration of the term of this Agreement, Policy Widget's compensation shall be prorated to the date of such termination and no further compensation or cxpense reimbursenients shall be due or paid, but Policy Widgets will still have right to indemnification in Section 7. t/> 9. AssiQnment. Without the written consent of the Republican Members of the Task Force, Policy Widgets shall have no right to assign or otherwise transfer any rights created under this Agreement. This Agreement shall be binding upon, and shall inure to the benefit of, Task Force and Policy Widgets and their respective successors, personal representatives, executors, administrators and assigns. 10. State Property. All equipment, documents, and data purchased or created with Task Force funds shall remain the joint property of the House and Senate Republican Caucuses upon completion of the tetm of this contract, and shall be transferred to the custody of the House or Senate Republican Caucus upon approval of the Republican Members of the Task Force. appropriate authorization 11. Con6denGalitv. Policy Widgets shall not disclose or use, without by the Republican Members of the Task Force, any information acquired by Policy Widgets in the course of its contractual duties with the Task Force that is confidential because of statutory provisions, or that has been clearly designated to Policy Widgets as confidential when that confidential designation is warranted because of the status of the proceedings or the circumstances under which the information was received and preserving its confidentiality is necessary to the proper conduct of government business. 12. Entire Aereement. This Agreement, together with any attachments hereto, constitutes the entire agreement between the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof and supersedes any and all written or oral prior agreements and understandings between the parties. IN WITNESS THEREOF, the parties agree to the above terms and warrant that they have the authority to bind the parties. Legislative Task Force on Redistricting, Reapportionment, and Demographic Research .b'^ _... Ma d ew T. Schuler 0 'o Senate Chief of Staff Troy Ju House o`}`RepresentativesJChief of Staff Policy Widgets, LLC Heather N. Mann Policy Widgets, LLC pxoe 1 of 2 REVISED 3/2011 Joint Legislative Ethics Committee Office of the L.egjslative Inspecmr General 50 West Broad Street, Suite 1308 Columbus,Ohio43215 OfBcial Use Only (614)728-5100 jxnvy, 'lec-olio ctatc oh u.s INITIAI. POST EMPLOYMENT DISCLOSURE STA'I'EMEN financial disolosure statement filers leaving public service need file this,forrn. Attention: Only There is no fee to file this Statement. If this is an amended statement, please check here:__. 1. Name:1aC n^r1^e c )J . N^ c n ^ t ^nS¢ ^ ^20 't5v ^';JQ 3 - Agency/OffieeofPublicEmpbymenc^dh o `'^v n i,astDareoEPublicService(Employme^t: ^q f ti ^ ^v^ 2 ^ A Home Address: 2' ^ G ! Stare: G4f_ zIP: y3Zo6 city: 1°i u rvl EmaiL- f'Pn4 hetnmann(^ Ma:^. caM Phone: ^( {H ) 352" II. Employert If known, please indicate your place of employment following State Service/Employment. If d tn Seetion IV. unknown please eheck here_ and procee Date of Employment: g 5 I^ Name of New Employer•. Streer Address: ZIP U 3 Z6^ ^u^m6aS State: City: lr v ^` Zr ^ II. Ldentifying Qvalitying Sources of Income tnm oT other &9on f^^ Revised Code § 102.021 (A)(2) requires that sotsces of income received in your own name, or by atty p your use or benefit, from any of the following categories be disclosed: s M. an executive agency lobbyist or legislative agent; to D the employer of an executive agency lobbyist or legislative agent (that is not aw te agency or political subdivision of the state); any entity, assodation or business that, at any time during the two immediately preceding calendar years, was awarded one or more conttacts by one or more state agencies that in the aggregate had a value of $100,000 or more, or bid on one or more contracts to be awarded by one or more state agencies that in the aggregate had a value of $100,000 or more.•ieefnrtberinfarmction below If you will receive income from any of the above Qualifying Sources please proceed to Section III A on the following page. if you will not rec e income from any of the sources listed above please check here: and proceed to Section IV on the following page. EXHIBIT + 'o of income to be received from a qualifying soutce: III A Please identify all sources tbe h¢e ofQuatofng Soxrse and provide If plea+e rheck hen.__. Pkme induate If thirQxaGfying Samre is the rame as Brted in Seekon the.ronree's mntott perron and fekpbone nnraber. (please check all that apply) Type of Qualifying Source: A. _ B. _ C. _ Date, Name of Quabfying Source: Type of Business: Street Address: CityState: ZIP: Contact Person: Telephone: (__) (please check here) I will be lobbying on behalf of this qualifying source: iii A. icondnued) Additional QuaBfping Sources Source: A. _ B. _ C, ____ (please check au mat appryt Type of Qualifying Datc Name of Qualifying Source: , Type of Business: Street Address: State: ZIP: City: Contact Person: Telephone: on behalf otthis qualifying source: (Please check here) I will be lobbying Itr, Cettification d The undersigned hereby cettifies that all reasonable efforts and duc diligence have been undcrtaken in the preparwon an completion of this statement and that the contents are true and accutate m the best of his or her knowledge. The undersigned also acknowledges an affirmativc duty to file an Amended Initial Post Employment Disclosure Statement should any of the above information change within two years following public service or public employment. The amended statement must be filed within ten days of obtaittink a new qualifying s ce of income. -F1r " a^^ N ea Mre Type or Print Name Signamre 'Please utilize the Controlling Board's website www ecb ohiuxov under'Search Requests' and/or contact your new of $100,000.00 or state contracts that in the aggregate had a value employer to deterurine if the entity received, or bid on, more in the preceding two years. htr // 2 ile • olig tate oh ti .^^• For a list of lobbyists and employers of lobbyists, please visit Inspector Post Employment Disclosure please contact The OfBce of the Legislative Should you have questions tegarding General at 614.728.5100. Pzge2of2 REVISED 3/2011 011-1-04 Officers; participation of members; minutes. The AppeAierffiefA Beordapportionment board shall, by majority vote, elect aQiaifchair and aViee Ghaifvice-chair. The BlslaMboard shall also elect, by majority vote, a Seeretar-psecretarv of the Beafdbord, who does not have to be aNFettibetmember. The Viee Chaifvice-chair shall assume the duties of the Qiairchair when the Ckairchair is unable to attend the meeting. Each iVFertA)er7nember shall be entitled to participate in all voting and debates, regardless of position held on the Apportionment Board. Minutes of each meeting of the Ap agportionment board shall be maintained by a court reporter chosen by the Bees-dboard by majority vote. At exeh •'-eSuch minutes shall be ffleeti-iigr the A+t---ei4 + B eff circulated among the lt4embersmembers and adopted by majority vote at a subsequent meeting of the board. Upon any M,roefemember's request, a transcript shall be provided upon completion and verification. u Effective: 08/15/2011 CERTIFIED ELECTRONICALLY Certification 08/05/2011 Date Promulgated Under: 111.15 Statutory Authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Prior Effective Dates: 9/7/91, 8/13/01 Heather Mann From: Benjanein Yoho [benpohnQ9mait.00m] Sant: Monday, Au9ust 08, 2011 10:57 AM To: Heather hUnn Cc: Troy J Attachments; house L,4 chD(1),:ds I-Icatlier, attached is the updated list of address for potential candidates and opponents. 'fhanks, Ben I I EXHIBIT ^w;- ad E Z ^p o a0 N o m p0 0 .-I .-^ vf n ri y^ m m o R ^^ O y .i* n y^ v^ o n M n^ m N M +-1 v1 O T n W n n a O N ti n N ut N c0 T T 'y bN V M H^ n n N M^^ N~ N^ n N m ^^ m~ N r N^.^i ^^ firmro^rv^°ve^m^o .-^v.^mro^.im m o mM m:^.-^•^n mme Om b 6 b b K ¢ b b n^ rt K K 2 b q C] b b b b a• oc ^ ac b K b K b a oC ^¢^ ^ K b 6 O ^ V R YI L C d ^ O N N R ` O 0 c E '° c t.' uL_'- E m=' m o ^'R c P R dR m R= R Pzgi=z2 ^az^ u.vQ ¢217w^Qm vs £ ^n = C L O m d P^. aai y y m`N m m' d ^a ^ a u a'u^` -a y? q d Y^y u Z.°P C^ E m ^ c^°-' c'" plc i^ ^9-O 3 d ^°c'vR 3 3 a« O _R c (6 P Cv c7O Rx 1ps c Cti O O R 9 R d 1+ d C ^ f0 Q 1t_ b Cl 4. Ll U^ V` b V{J U Vt S^ R m ^ b F [C N^' S[D m J Z' p'^ Q 2 N V^ Y f^f0 G. N 0 N N N d v 0i udi h N N N w 0 N N 0 N 0 Ol N 0 N N OY W 01 pl 7 G 3^ J^ 6 3 3 01 W YI 91 W R N 4{ N '3 J 3 3 J O'3 '3 'J q 3 3 3 D 3'9 ^ O 6 J -'d O3 "O N O J PJ ^O I^] O 7O ^ O 3 O7 O3 O O O O O P O O O O O O O O O P O O P O O O O O O O P O O 2 2 2 S= 2 2 2 2 T 2 S 2 2 S= 2 S= 2 2 S 2 2 2 2 2 T 2 2 2 2 2 S S S S 2= i^, np O^ O .i N m a ui .n r oo m o0 O: C.: N M R ^. ^c it 'V N M 7 V1 ^p n OD OI iyO.i iy N ^y m N^.{ d' ^/1 ^y VT ^y nr{ {i ei N N N N N N N N N N M M M M m M M M M M ts > V, 0 ^ O m'a M M m^^ r N O O^ m N Ep ? O N O N M M d' M O1 M ei M N^ N N H M M Q^D ^O I^ Of tG Vf O^ M,p ^ N at M b^ r N r^^ N W ^O ^ N n 1^ uf O^C m c0 M f^ N O M N N N v-01 ^O f^ m n 4 o`t0 T^ M N N 1A N N M N N e'1 rl ^0K¢^ 0p^ ^ Q OO x Onacxo mKK¢0¢rc rc rcm z a aC rc K ^ 0 a' O ^ ^ K m ac t TY m`w C aa va a d^ C ^m m c L° m rs .^-- ^ oF=u°^oE^¢° 0mDrvi 2D' ^ iC Y 7 N m 1a- si ^ U C C ^ m D C ^ a aT. s m `a ^ c^ v^md '3E^ 'aC c C y a ^a ^ ^ C c > ^^ C C= Y^ ^ o>' ..a. a m .+ " C7 T o U^ ^ m E ^ T m a O^n ^^ O^p ^ NO N^U '6O a^^'O d.O D NO- m YN NY T^p a O ^ O O R 4^"O a £ ^^nnc^v^^vru.¢C N D L^ Y W W L nDiv^x a .n^nocgc.^^.-+mc7xOu_> U a d O^mum^x2U* V 3^nm¢¢ N N a N,a, „a ,a„ N a N a N a a a N y N a a a a a a a N a N N N a a a N a N a a y a D 30 0^0 30 'D o o'D 'o 0 0'D oD o 0 0'o 0 0 0 D ^o o'D ' yp xo x==q o 0 x 0 x 'o x' xo ox 'x o x'o x0 x0 0x= ^ x x x x x S x x x x x x x x=__^ m.^ ^ m^ m^, n{^ 1+ r r I^ I^ 1+ O rY N-J y U^ W f^ op L'^ G ei N M^ N tp M1 W 61 O^-i N MiU V ^O M ^o aO ^U 1^ m t0^ Vfto 1^O 1^ Yf N U1 VI VI vl ^D N ap cr p V Q d ^ a V R R vt. N N v) ^n v^n ^n O.r n aa n e m.°n° ^ Nroo^•^orn^ m,y „' y'n ^u rv o 1^ n^n w^m m ^ n O O N f^ N N O N tn N tt Q ^^ o rc ac^^^ac acsca^cac^rtrc o^ ot rc¢ d ^ 3 a = N c^ j- m V m N W^ O O O^ q"Y N^^ m O Q m Q O^ U p¢ d p 2 m UO h m Y^ V R m G C y Oy d . C W C N Q ^ N E N ^ ,Yo ;o w ^ c T a i o o ac ^x JI N N N Mw Nw N N, Nd^^0 N N N N N M M N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O S 2 S S S S S= S S S S S S S S S 2 S o°mmrn.mo^irn^tnm ^. °wmo^oo^^nc`JOmmwmc°1 av„ o 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a o o o o o a o 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 oL aL oL 0.C 0_0t S L L L L L F. L^G .G t t L 3= L L L L L L SL L L -16 ,-C 000000000000000000000000000000000000O t OL SO SO OS OL.G O Ot SO O O o O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 00 L G m ^ GI OI N T UI UI m N^ G a C C C C a C Y ^'a 3] U^.Q A A °{ C C Cc cC 'c C c^° O C o Cyv, i C ° ^`a, m o 3 m m m m o m m c m 4 s E v a E E E«° c v v 3 d'O o m } c^ o o c u u 'u u y 5• c^• E m o E ^ v m m m w a ^ a^"i m i' vi a o 0 o co c 0c o c c c v m u^• ^ ?g °3 E^5 c^ m'¢u 1Om um wv w}v u}`u a 3 3 3 z 3 c^t^ u u u^ 7 0 u'u G u u o u o m N ^ m v o _a m v v i v y > m om u Q Ni u z ^a^0 v > ya ^^}^ 4 0^ x« ^«m vN^ . V ca 4 c :n'a m C" Q'^ Q aci m"-Q.«n .p^v W N'n .se }_^ o o^ a z° ^^^ o v v m°0 3 ^ ^ a1 3 c o`^ v ^_ a° L^ t aC m^ y!^ X C b A O Y L N O ^ V^ a T TE Q az 1%1 m^ m p v m o'- ^ C N i N'-" ^% m W - N 4- ^q ?D 0 ^ O Na¢ m o ^nm Q Y v^ CS 0 l7 S ,^W^3^waar3wLL^m^^0 L4 ° v'^ g m v^° w m v v^o ^^ Q S^7 ^ LL ti a O= ll 2 2 o 0 0 0 o p o 0 0 o g o 0 0 0 q o 0 0 0 o 0 o p o 0 0 0 q p p o q o 0 0 0 0 0 0 o o o o o o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o 00000000000 r c c a 3 c y ^ ^ p y p p v Q r y a {n' w v Y 3 N [.` ^ SU ^ Q 16 C ry c d c u YI Y~ C « p a=' ^^ m 3 ^' c o 2z q N 5 ^ c a v N v ^ a a ^° w m L 4 9 q o a^i ^ o O ^^ a9i w v m um u z o m x ^^ p^^ w o z m u ro+o u 3 ^a i°3 Oym^ 'aS `°x^ a o z^n o z.^ c^ v^ r= ouo=aaa m ^ ^ p m O p w Z^ q a-, p y N Z> z y V y p C ^j -^ N^ q^ v d y^ y^ ^ C^ D> V1 ^ U'n LL^ N^ p O Q y N•- a^ N W^ C Q!Y ^ p^ d N r v Y ^ L' ^ C d V y,, O y m m t CG1 . ^ u O^ Q^ ^ p m >?> N N C t _m r^o ^ p ^ p 4 N ^ N N C^^"O .D p^ 9 "1 v^ Ul N a ^ M N p Q L N N r i 10 9 L V cL' b0 _ ^ a 15 .c. m 3^- ^ m ^ ^ K w o m y m t m ^ M^ O^ ^ 4 Q w LL o>^ 2 S w vi O mq S 3vw^'u`m^u°o- 3^QUi^r O O O O O O O O O O O O tl O O O O O O O O O O O O D O O O O O O O O O O O O O 4 t m N O p m a'> o Yjjj... E d R'- c S] dU c 3 O N N tl^ N N= N G^ C GI N.L] 4! N C O. ^ d Q m C :O m m w^ O m w'° % W o= =' ^L NNQfL=a N^7^J^n u33n 2 isQ R y a o mO 3p o^ Q , 23 cro^ tl • J 1Y t M n 2 N 2 N ^ K O >> N y^'^' G^^O > ^> L Q y' C^ u y ai a 0 C d U o-o ^>, ^ O a fl ^ O m O ^ a• ^ n N N^ v R R^^ O 2 O O N C i a^ n, 9 tY: >^ ^y ^ lo L N y^ ^ 61 ^ vm^' Zat^"'^z^.^nux^na."nxwuz Heather Mann Froni: Heather Mann [heathernmannggmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, August 03, 2011 5:42 PM To: 'Halfe Petger'; '[email protected]'; 'Barron, John': Mary Amos Augsburger ([email protected]) Attachments: 2011-08-04 Apportionment Board Meeting Script.docx Per your request, the most recent version of script. Will send full updated packet later tonight. Technical changes to rules and public records policy will be only substantive changes. .sa Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614)352-5819 heathernman n0ema il.com t ' EXHIBIT ^-^6 INt7lAt, APPORTIONIIGNT BOARD MEETING SCRIPT 1. Call to Order C GOVERNOR KASICH: Pursuant to Article 11, Section 1 of the Ohio Constitution, I hereby call to order this meeting of the 2011 Board of Apportioning Persons. 'T'here is a quorum of inetnbers present, but for the record, would each member of the Bo.ud please indicate thcir presence by stating their name. [Mentbers state names and litles] This meeting is called pursuant to Article IT, Section 1 of the Ohio Constitution, which requires that atter each decennial census, the Ohio Board of Apportioning persons - inchuling the Governor, Secretary of State, Auditor of State, and two persons selected by the ieadership of the General Assembly convenes between August 1 and October 1 of the year the census figures are released to establish the district lines of the Ohio General Assembly. Article 11 of the Constitution govems the procedures for this apportionn-lent, and we will therefore proceed under itS provisions. IL Present Indieia of Office and Letters of Appointment GOVERNOR KASTCH: Members have been provided with a copy of the proposed agenda for this meeting, which was distributed in advance. The first item of business is for the members of the Board to verify their membership on the Board by presenting their letters of appointmeirt, in the case of legislative apportioning persons, and oaths of office in the case of other members. We will now receive these doculnents. I would like to indicate for the record that I have the certificates of office for Secretary of State Husted, Auditor David Yost, and myself as Govemor. t also have a letters from House Speaker Bill Batchelder, Senate President Tom Niehaus, Senate Minority Leader Capri Cafaro, and House Minority Leader Armond Budish, choosing and to serve on this Board. appointing [Senator/Representative X and Senator/Repre.rentative Y] We now have received the appropriate documentation from each member, and it all appears to be in onler. 111, Flection of Chair of the Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is the selection of a chair. SECRFTARY HUSTED: Mr. Govemor, I move that Governor Kasich be named chair of the 1 Apportiomnctit Board. GOVF;RNOR KASICH: We have a motion. Is there a second? AUDITOR YOST: I second the motion. GOVERNOR KASICFi: Auditor Yost seconds. The nornination has been made and seconded. Are there any other nominations? lf not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say avej. Those opposed'? Motion is caniefl, I will serve as chair. 1 V. Selection of Secretary of the Apportionnient Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is for the selection of a secretary to the will keep the niinutes, call the roll, and record all Board of Apportioning persons. The Secretary votes and maintain custody of all the records of the Apportiotunent Board, including the proposed plan to be filed with the Board. I will now entertain a motion for secretary. be named Secretary of the SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chainnan, I move that [name] Apportionment Board. GOVERNOR KASICH: We have a motion. Is there a second? AUDITOR YOST: I second the motion. GOVERNOR KASICH: Auditor Yost seconds the motion. The nomination has been made and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination'? If not, Those opposed? Motion is carried, [name] will all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. serve as Secretary. I will now give [narne], the custodian of the records, the documentation provided to me. V. Election of Vice Chair of the Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agettda is the selection of a vice chair to the Board of Apportioning persons. I nominate Auditor Yost to serve as vice chair of tbe 2011 Apportionment Board_ Is there a second? SECRETARY HUSTED: I second the m.^.ti^r GOVERNOR KASICH: Secretary Husted seconds the motion. The nomination has been tnade and seconded. Are there any other notninations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If Those opposed? If not, will the Secretary not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say myej. 2 SECRETARY: For ihe selection of Auditor Yost as Vice Chair of the Apportionmertt Board, Icalls roll]. Auditor Yost is selected Vice Chair of the Apportionment Board by a vote of X-X. VI. Announcement of Attorney Representation GOVERNOR KASICH: Historically, the Attorney General has represented the Board and all persons serving on the Board. Attorney General Mike DeWine has appointed Mark Braden to be here today to be available to the Board. I would like to ask Mr. Braden to identify himself on the record. MARK BRADEN: Mr. Chairman, Members of the Board, I am Mark Braden, Counsel to the Board. GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you, and welcome. ViI. Appointment of Official Court Reporter GOVERNOR KASICH: At this point, given the official and historic nature of our proceedings, we need to appoint an official court reporter fbr the proceedings of the Apportionment Board. Accordingly, I will now entertain a motion to appoint an official court reporter for these proceedings. SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chainnan, I move that the firm of [nanre] be the official court reporter for the 2001 Apportionment Board and that said court reporter please prepare and provide each meinber of the Board a copy of the transcript of each of our nieetings. AUDITOR YOST: I second the motion. GOVERNOR KASICH: Auditor Yost seconds the motion. The nomhiarion has been made and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? Ifnot, all if favor signify by saying aye (all say aye]. Those opposeti? If not, will the Secretary please call the roll. SECRETARY: For the appointment of [nanae] as official court reporter for the 2001 Apportiontnerit Board, [calls rotl]- The motion carries X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you. For the record, I'd like to ask our court reporter, who is here from the firm of [name], to please identify [hesfher]self. REPORTER: My name is [name], court reporter with Vii-m name] in [city], Ohio. 3 VII[. Adoption of Rules and Procedures GOVERNOR KASICI-I: This brings us to our next agenda item, which is the adoption of the rules of the 2011 Apportionment 13oard. All the members should have a copy of the proposed rules which I provided to each of you in advance of today's meeting. These proposed rules are, in essence, a revised version of the rults of the 2001 Apportionnieait Board which are on file with the Legislative Service C.ommission. Our intention is to vote on the rales as a block unless there is an amendment. At this time I woutd entertain a motion regarding the rules. jIf there is n motion to adopt tGe proposed rnles as a block] Rules X-X. SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chainnan, l move that we vote to adopt AIIDITOR YOST: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded- Any discussion? If nane, the Secretary will call the roll. The motion carries X-X. SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt Rules X-X [calls rofl]. (]f there is a motion to amend the proposed rules] GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and secoaded. Any discussion? MEMBER: Move to amend. GOVERNOR KASICH: [narne] moves to amend. Please describe your amendment. Member proceeds to describe anaendment. GOVERNOR KASICH: The amendment has been moved. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRE'I'ARY: [calls roll]. The motion to amend passes X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: Is there furthet discussion on the proposed rules as amended? If not, will the secretary please call the roll on the motion to adopt the proposed rules. "fhe motion to adopt rules X-X as amended passes X-X. SECRETARY: [calls rollJ. 4 _.. _.__... ^_. ------C ER VOR I^ASIC`.kl: ' fhe rules hdve 6een adopt.ecl. I 3nstruct the Secretary of the Board to ceHtify and file these rules tortb-with as prescribed by the Ohio Revised Code. DC. Adoption of Public Hearing Schedule of public GOVERNOR KASiCH: The rules we havejust adopted provide for provide for a series plan- At this hearings around the state to receive public input and comment on the apportionment point I would entertain a motion to establish a scliedule ofthese public hearings. SFCRETARY HUSTED: Mr_ Chainnan, a proposed schedule had earlier been distributed stating the times and places for eleven public hearings to be held in varions locations around the state from August 22 to August 26, 2011. 1 would move that we adopt the proposed schedule as the schedule of public hearings as required by our rules. GOVERNOR KASICH: Is there a second? AUDITOR YOST: Second. If none, the GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seeonded. Any discussion? Secretary will call the roll. The motion SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt the public scltedule of hearings, [calls roll]. caeries X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary is instnxcted to make the schedule available to the press and the public. X. Adoption of public records policy GOVERNOR KASICH: The rules also call for the Apportionment Board to adopt a public records pursuant to Ohio Revised Code 149.43. A proposed public records policy was distributed to members earlier and is in your folders. Do I have a motion on the proposed policy? SECRETARY HUS1'ED: Mr. Chairman, I move that the Board adopt the proposed public records policy. AUDITORA YOST: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary wiil call the ro11. 5 [calls roll]. 'I9te motion carries S1:CRETARY: On the motion to adopt the publie rewrds policy, X-X. GOVERNOR KASICI l: The Secretary is instrttcted to ntake the records policy available to the public and the press, XI. Designafion of place for public review of proposed apportionment plan GOVERNOR KASICH: At this time, I would like to ask Secretary Husted to provide us witlt an overvieev of the Secretary's redistricting website. SECRETARY HUSTED: [discu.sses website]. GOVERNOR KASICH: The tvles call for the apportionment board to designate a place or places where the public mav review the plans of apportionment that are filed with the Board. Is there a motion on the designation of a place for public review of submitted plans? SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Cltairman, I move that the Board designate a website with the address of www.reshapeohio.or^ and a physical space adjacent to the Ohio House of Representatives Chambers, 2"a Floor Statehouse, Colmubus Oltio 43215 where the public may review the plans that were subniitted to the Board. AUDITORA YOST: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretar_v will call the roll. SECRETARY: On the motion to designate the place where the public may view apportionment plans, [calls roll]. The motion carries X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary is instructed to make the location and website as the designated places for public review of plans available to the press. XiL Establishing time, date, and place of next meeting GOVERNOR KASICH: At this time I will entertain a motion to establish the date and place of the next meeting of the 2011 Apportionment Board. SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairman, I move that the next meeting of the Board be set for Monday, Sept. 26,2011 at 9AM in the Ohio Senate Finance Hearing Room. 6 AUDITOR YOST: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and smorided. Any discussion? Ifnonc, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: On the motion to set the date and location of the next Apportionment Board meeting for Monday, Sept. 26, 2011 at 9AM in the Ohio Senate Finance Hearing Room. The motioti carries X-X. XIII. Adjourn GOVERNOR KASICH: Any furtherbusiness to came before the 20t I Apportionment Board? If not, I will entertain a motion to recess the Board until Monday, Sept. 26, 2011 at 9AM. SECRETARY HOSTED: Mr. Chairman, so moved. AUDITORYOST: Second. All in favor? Opposed? GOVERNOR KASICH: The tnotion has been made and seconded. Thank you, the 2011 Apportionment Board is adjourned. 7 Heather Mann Prom: Benjamin Yoho [[email protected] Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2011 12:21 PM To: Clark Bensen7POLIDATA Cc: Heather Mann; Ray DiRossi Subject: Re: OH^o^^ty RBV Pr^^^ry Election Off cal Resuttse^#n Official Results.pdf; March 4 2008 Montgomery Attacbments: Clark, the SOS website does not have the data in excel format nor does the county BOE's. Here are the PDF reports that are available online. I have put in a public recrods request to the SOS, Lucas County and lvlontgomery County BOE's for the excel versions. Will keep you posted as things come in. Thanks, Ben Yoho 740-624-3417 Sep 6, 2011 at 7:39 AM, Clark Bensen/POLIDATA What we need is the precinct-level results for the elections I mention. I'm not even sure the SOS has this information. A good starting point would be the Obama primary for 2008. POLIDATA 0 Demographic and Political Guides I www.polidata.us POLTDATA 0 Political Data Analysis I www polidata.ora POLIDATA 0 at CafePress J w'ww cafevress comlpolidata POLIIIATA (9) at Lalu f www.lu1u.com1uolidata Clark Bensen I POLIDATA LLC I Tel: 703-690-4066 Vermont Office: 1303 Hayward Road I P.O. Box 530 1 Corinth, VT 05039 Virginia Ofiice: 3112 Cave Court I Lake Ridge, VA 22192 efax: 202-318-0793 ( email: clark@,poljdata.org From: Heather Mann [mailto:[email protected] com] Sent: Sunday, September 04, 2011 3:26 PM To:'Clark Bensen/POLIDATA';'Braden, E. Mark' Cc: Ben Yoho; Troy J'; 'Michael Lenzo'; 'Ray piRossi' Subject: FW: OH RBV Clark or Mark, Could you please follow-up with Ben on what exactly you need from the SOS? Ben's cell phone number +1(7401624- 3417 and his email is benyohoCDRrnail.com. 7hankyou, Heather Mann .s.+ Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 [email protected] From: Benjamin Yoho [mailto:benyohoagmail.coml Sent Friday, September 02, 2011 12:02 PM To: Heather Mann Subject: Re: OH RBV What exact data is he looking for_. I am confused. Please advise On Thu, Sep 1, 2011 at 5:06 PM, Heather Mann Ben, is this something you could get for us? ------Forwarded message ------From: Clark Sensen/POLIDATA Heather and Ray, Now that Ben Yoho has given us some elections in which a minority candidate has run, can we task someone with procuring the data for them? I don't need any data for the general elections for the obvious races: legislature/amgress/statewide but any primary data for these races and the local races will be needed. In reality, there are only a handful for which data are needed: these are in BOLD in the attached xls file. The otbers I have already or aren't worth the work due to the margin. 'I 6anks, clark POLIDATA ® Demograph"tc and Poli6cal Guides I www polidata us POLIDATA ® Political Data Analysis I www.polidata.ori POLIDATA V at CatePress I www.cafevresa wnJnolidata POLIDATA 9at Lulu jwww lulu.com/nolidata Clark Bensen I POLIDATA LLC I Tel; 703-690-40b6 Vcrmont Office: 1303 Hayward Road I P.O. Box 530 1 Corinth, VT 05039 Virginia OfPice: 3112 Cave Couit I Lake Ridge, VA 22192 efax: 202-318-0793 4 email: clark(a^polidata.org 3 Heatlier N. Mann $27 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, OH 43206 614 352-5819 heathenunanno'};mail.r,om 4 Heather,Mann ,..^.^ From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Saturday, September 24, 2011 11:18 PM Sent: 'Matthew T. Schufer'; 'johabarron@senate_state.oh.us'; 'Mary Amos Augsburger; Halle Pelger To: ([email protected]);'Lenzo, Mike';'Troy J'; 'Grodhaus, Michael'; 'Matt .Carle@govemor. ohio.gov' Subject: 2011-09-26 Apportionment Board MeetingScript Attachments: 2011-09-26 Apportionment Board Meeting Script_.doc All: Please see attached a revised version of the script for Monday, which includes a report from the Secretaries on the plans received, a motion to accept all plans submitted, and a brief report on the technical amendment being prepared. if you have any additional changes, please let Ray or I know. Sincerely, Heather Mann :3. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmann@r EXHIBIT At'rOR1'tOIVMEN'r BOARD MEETING SCRIPT SEE"rE\4BER 26, 2011 (TES'rIMONY ON PtANS) 1. Call to Order & Introduction of Panel GOVERNOR.ICASICEI: The meeting will now come to order. Purstiant to notice, I now reconvene the 2011 Ohio Apportiontnent Board. The Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: [calls roll] [iYfembers state names and titles] SECRETARY: All niembers are present; we have a quorum. GOVERNOR KASICkl: Pursuant to the rules adopted by the Board on August 4,2011, the Secretary laave circulated for review, to all members, transcripts from our initial meeting on August 4"' and the regional hearings held August 22 - 26. At this time, I will ask for a motion to dispense xvith the reading and adopt these transcripts as the official minutes. AUDITOR YOST: Mr. Chairman, I move that we dispense with the reading and adopt the transcripts as the official minutes of the previous meeting and the regional heatings. SECRETARY HUSTED OR PRESIDENT NIEHAUS: Second. GOVF,RNOR ICASICH: The motion has been moved and seconded. Anv objections? Seeing none, the minutes are adopted. The Board at its last meeting adopted rules for the submission of proposed apportionment plans for the taking of public coimnents and testimony regarding the plans so submitted. The purpose of this meeting is to allow the presentation of timely submitted plans and public testimony on those plans. Any person wishing to present a plan or offer testimony regarding a plan should fill out a witness form available on the table and give it to our staff. Those who helped draft and create submitted plans know what a tough job this is, and I would like to thank eaeh of you for taking the time and effort to draft a plan for our consideration. To summarize our rules, any person or organization that has submitted a proposed plan of apportionment will be aliowed to have its sponsor personally, or through a tepresentative, present the substance of their plan to the board, for a period not to exceed 10 minutes unless extended by a majority of the board. In order to conduct this meeting in an orderly fashion under our rules, I will call each plan's sponsor or designated representative to present their plan. At the end of each sponsor's presentation, we will have time for questions by Board members as recopnized bv the chair. Once a plan has been presented, the public may offer testimony in the order designated by the Chainnan for a period not to exc:eed five minutes, unless extended by a majority of the board. T7ie Chainnan may limit testimony as he deems necessary. I would ask witnesses to limit their testiinony to the apportionment of state legislative districts, which is the sole charge of the Apportionment Board. At this time I would ask the Secretaries to report to the Board the number of plans that were received and whether they were submitted in accordance with the rules. SECRETARY: Mr. Chairman, four plans were submitted to the Board by the Friday, Sept. 23'd deadline. The rules adopted by the board required submissions to include hard copy and electronic versions of the legal definitions and visual representations of the proposed boundaries. One plan was submitted by the Joint Secretaries of the Apportionment Board with all board- required eomponents. "I'wo plans were subinitted from the Ohio Campaign for Accountable Redistricting and included all components except a legal definition. The fourth plan was submitted by the Senate and House Democrat caucuses and included all required components except a legal definition. SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chainnan, in the interest of considering all citizen input, I would like to move at this time that the Board accept these plans as submitted and reccive testimony on them today. AL`DITOR YOST: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been moved and seconded. Are there any objections? Seeing none, we will now proceed with testimony. H. Public Testimony GOVERIVOR KASICH: At this time I would like to call our first witness, the sponsor or representative of the plan submitted by ,____.__-.._-_._.-. Please state and spell your name for the record. [Sponsor presents plan to the Board] GOVERNOR KASICH: Any questions for the witness? [Direct questions from the Board] GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you for your testimony. We will now take )ublic testimonyon the plan submitted by [plan sponsor]. Our next witness is 2 [,Secretaty will hand you wintess slips in turn for any public tesliniony on the plan just prc-sented] GOVERNOR KkSICH: Any questions for the witness? Secing none, I now call the sponsor or representative of the plan submitted by [.Etc, unfil all plans have been presented] III. Adjourn GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you to all to who have offered testimony today. All plans submitted have now been presented to the board. I would like to give members of the Board until Wednesday to review the plans and consider testimony that has been offered here. If any Member of the Board intends on offering an amertdment to any plan, they may submit them in advance to the Secretaries at the redistri_cting(czredistricting.ohio.aov email address, and they will be timely conveyed to members of the Board. I would ask the Secretaries to provide the Board with an update on some technical amendments to their submission_ SECRETARY: Mr. Chairman, we are preparing a technical amendment to our original submission that makes non-substantive eorreotions to the legal definitions sueh as the spelling of political subdivisions and references to various precincts, none of which makes apy changes to the overall boundarics of the map itself. We w6ll endeavor to email this to members of the Board as soon as possible. GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you. I will now entertain a motion to RECESS this meeting until Wednesday, September 28 at lOAM. AUDI'I'OR YOST: Mr. Chairman, I move that the Board stand in RECESS until Wednesday, September 28 at I OAM in the Senate Fiuance Hearing Room. SECRETARY 13USTED OR PRESIDENT NIEHAUS: Second. GOVSRNOi{ d{AfiIC:FI: Will the Secretary please call the roll`? SECRETARY: [Calls roll and announces vote.] GOVERNOR KASICH: "I'he motion passed. The Board stands in recess. 3 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent: Monday, September 26, 2011 4:55 PM To: 'John Stacy' Subject: RE: franklin county house districts question john, I do not have the authority or ability to do any changes at this time. You would best be advised to speak with our leadership regarding your request. 13# Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 [email protected] From: John Stacy Lmz ilto:istacYCditrvourtrip•coml Sent: Monday, September 26, 2011 10:52 AM To: heathernmanntalomail:com Cc: jpstacv2001'cactmail com Subject: franklin county house districts question Hi Heather, I hate to bother you with this question but I really am not sure who else to ask.ln the proposed reapportionment map my subdivision of Columbus, Forest Park, was put into the 22HD which is the new John Carney district. We used to be part of Duffy's 21" HD but were removed to make that district a stronger Republican district. That makes a lot of sense andl heard rumors a couple weeks ago that we might be put into Carney's district which is okay as I had hoped to run against him next year. It will be a tough race but could be winnable. was placed into the much more heavily democratic HD 25 instead of the The problem is that my Ward, Columbus 54 Carney district. Four of the wards that are adjacent to mine were placed in the 221" HD (Columbus Wards 30, 52, 53 and 61) the remaining four were divided between HD 19 (Columbus Ward 66, Ward 81 precincts B, C & Minerva Park Village) and HD 25 (Ward 81 precincts A,D, E & noncontiguous parts of Blendon Township that are surrounded by Ward 81. The connection of my ward to the 25`" HD appears to be Columbus Ward 81E & one of the noncontiguous Blendon Twp. Areas, both of which are adjacent to Columbus 54F). I wanted to see if there was any way my ward coutd be moved to the 22HD so I can run against Carney next year. If you cannot move the entire ward maybe you can emulated how Columbus Ward 81 was divided up between two House whicf. v;era f`.tB to the north. That way Districts and movejust my precinct which is Columbus 548, you do not disrupt the parts of Sharon Township A was assigned to the 25HD. That would probably be the simplest solution to my situation. As it stands now ihe 25'h HD has 119,779 people in its boundaries, the 22HD has 118,513 people (or a difference of 1,266. As both HD are above the 116k threshold requirements, moving Columbus 54B would appear to be a simple move. 5 1 EXHIBIT '1b Again I hateto ask but I would prefer not to wait another ten years until the next reapportionment and risk a non- friendly apportionment board. Carney will be a tough opponent but I am ready to take him on. I have spent the past three and half years since I left the Ohio House getting ready for a challenge such as this. For the past two years I have served as the Executive Director of an inner-city nonprofit that provides educational programs to low income minority adults, for the past five years I have served on the board of two urban charter schools (including one in Forest Park Ward S21) which is in 22nd HD and accounts for 200 families and potential volunteers), I am a member of the largest church in the area with over 7,000 members, am past President of the Northland Kiwanis Club, I have ru n my own business since 2001, served as a past trustee of the Noi thland Area Business Associationand for the past three years have been an adjunct faculty member of ttie University of Phoenix's Columbus Campus. As a Libertarian Republican I think that I am well positioned to make this a credible race against Garney. Asyou can see my only stumbling block is being drawn into the right district. Thar.kyou for your consideration of my request. Please let me know if there is anyone else I should talk to about my situation. I would be happy to talk to either Batchelder or Huffman if you think that would help. Regards, John Stacy (614) 306-6091 cell phone istacV Cdiitsyourtrip.CO m 6 ^ ^ p Frd N ..a 0 1