Historical Archaeology Historical
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Historical Archaeology Volume 46, Number 42 2012 Journal of The Society for Historical Archaeology J. W. JOSEPH, Editor New South Associates, Inc. 6150 East Ponce de Leon Avenue Stone Mountain, Georgia 30083 InN assocASSOCIATIONIatIon wWITHIth aRudreyEBECCA h ornALLENIng,, JcAMIEhrIs BMRANDONatthews, ,C MHRISargaret MATTHEWS Purser, , andPAUL g MraceULLINS ZIes, DIngELLA, a ssocSCOTTIate-I RETONedItors, B; RENT WEISMAN, GRACE ZEISING, rASSOCIATEIchard V eEItDITORS, reVIews; CHARLES edItor ;E MWENary, RBEVIEWSeth reed EDITOR, co;- eMdARYItor BETH REED, CO-EDITOR Published by THE SOCIETY FOR HISTORICAL ARCHAEOLOGY Front Matter - 46(2) for print.indd i 9/7/12 9:28 AM HISTORICAL ARCHAEOLOGY IS INDEXED IN THE FOLLOWING PUBLICATIONS: ABSTRACTS OF ANTHROPOLOGY; AMERICA: HISTORY AND LIFE; ANTHROPOLOGICAL LITERATURE; ART AND ARCHAEOLOGY TECHNICAL ABSTRACTS; ARTS AND HUMANITIES INDEX; BRITISH ARCHAEOLOGICAL ABSTRACTS; CURRENT CONTENTS/ ARTS AND HUMANITIES; HISTORICAL ABSTRACTS; HUMANITIES INDEX; AND INTERNATIONAL BIBLIOGRAPHY OF THE SOCIAL SCIENCES. Copyediting by Richard G. Schaefer Composition by OneTouchPoint/Ginny’s Printing Austin, Texas ©2012 by The Society for Historical Archaeology Printed in the United States of America ISSN 0440-9213 The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of the American National Standard for Information Sciences–Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z39.48-1984. Contents Volume 46, No. 4, 2012 MEMORIAL RODERICK SPRAGUE 1933–2012 1 ARTICLES “Their Houses are Ancient and Ordinary”: Archaeology and Connecticut’s Eighteenth-Century Domestic Architecture ROSS K. HARPER 8 Evaluating Spanish Colonial Alternative Economies in the Archaeological Record AMANDA D. ROBERTS THOMPSON 48 Pueblo Potsherds to Silver Spoons: A Case Study in Historical Archaeology from New Mexico MELISSA PAYNE 70 Hard Labor and Hostile Encounters: What Human Remains Reveal about Institutional Violence and Chinese Immigrants Living in Carlin, Nevada (1885–1923) RYAN P. HARROD, JENNIFER L. THOMPSON, AND DEBRA L. MARTIN 85 Mapping the Complexities of Race on the Landscape of the Colonial Caribbean, United States Virgin Islands, 1770–1917 MARGARET C. WOOD 112 Marronage Perspective for Historical Archaeology in the United States DANIEL O. SAYERS 135 A Conversation with Ronald L. Michael DANIEL G. ROBERTS 162 REVIEWS Edited by Richard Veit Reviews are posted on the Society for Historical Archaeology website at <http://www.sha.org/> Carver: Making Archaeology Happen: Design versus Dogma IAN BURROW 185 Emery and Wooldridge: St Pancras Burial Ground: Excavations for St Pancras International, the London Terminus of High Speed 1, 2002–3 ADAM R. HEINRICH 187 Ferguson: God’s Fields: Landscape, Religion, and Race in Moravian Wachovia GABRIELLE LANIER 189 Heath and Gary (editors): Jefferson’s Poplar Forest: Unearthing a Virginia Plantation MICHAEL J. GALL 191 James: Virginia City: Secrets of a Western Past MOLLY E. SWORDS 193 King and Sayer (editors): The Archaeology of Post-Medieval Religion SCOTT D. STULL 195 Madsen and White: Chinese Export Porcelains LINDA ROSENFELD POMPER 198 McCartney: Jordan’s Point, Virginia: Archaeology in Perspective Prehistoric to Modern Times TABITHA HILLIARD 200 Monroe and Ogundiran (editors): Power and Landscape in Atlantic West Africa: Archaeological Perspectives LIZA GIJANTO 202 Shackel: New Philadelphia: An Archaeology of Race in the Heartland CAROL MCDAVID 205 Urban and Schortman: Archaeological Theory in Practice KATHERINE AMBRY LINHEIN MULLER 207 Van Wormer, Wade, Walter, and Arter: An Isolated Frontier Outpost: Historical and Archaeological Investigations of the Carrizo Creek Stage Station LESLIE C. STEWART-ABERNATHY 209 Voss and Casella (editors): The Archaeology of Colonialism: Intimate Encounters and Sexual Effects SUZANNE M. SPENCER-WOOD 212 Memorial Roderick Sprague 1933–2012 Recently the SHA lost one of its founders, and the greater anthropological community had to say farewell to a special person. You begin to realize how special the person was when the chief of a Native American tribal government appears at his memorial service to express what he had meant to the tribe’s people and the importance of his friendship. Roderick Sprague was born on 18 February 1933, in Albany, Oregon, and died on 20 August 2012, in Moscow, Idaho, following several years of debilitating health. He was the youngest of three children of Roderick Sprague and Mary Willis Sprague (both deceased). He is survived by two older sisters: Anne Geaudreau of Oldtown, Idaho, and Arda Rutherford of Prescott, Arizona; his wife, Linda Ferguson Sprague, Moscow; and four children: Roderick IV and Katherine K. Sprague (her partner Tabitha) from a previous marriage, and Frederick L. Sprague (his wife Dawn and son Jack) and Alexander W. Sprague (his wife Rebecca and son Phineas) from his current marriage. Rick Sprague lived most of his life in Idaho, Washington, and Oregon, although part of his youth had been fondly spent in North Dakota, where his father was a federal agricultural agent. He received his bachelor’s and master’s degrees in anthropology from Washington State University, served two years in the U. S. Army (honorably discharged with the rank of E-5), and received his Ph.D. in anthropology from the University of Arizona, Tucson. He worked at Washington State University as a research archaeologist for three years before going to the University of Idaho in 1967 as an assistant professor of anthropology. Within a year and a half of his arrival he became chairman of the Department of Sociology/Anthropology and director of the Laboratory of Anthropol- ogy. After 12½ years the two positions became too much for one person and the two units were separated. He chose to remain the director of the Laboratory of Anthropology, but continued to teach anthropology part-time, including summer archaeological field schools. He spent a sabbatical Historical Archaeology, 2012, 46(4):1–7. Permission to reprint required. 2 HISTORICAL ARCHAEOLOGY 46(4) year in 1986–1987 teaching at Inner Mongolia University as the first participant in the University of Idaho’s exchange with that institution. Rick did field work in Idaho, Washington, Oregon, Alaska, Arizona, Montana, and Prince Edward Island. He received both the University of Idaho Library Faculty Award for Outstanding Service and the Sigma Xi Published Research Paper Faculty Award in 1986, and the Phi Kappa Phi Distinguished Faculty Award for Research in 1996. In 2000 he was honored with the J. C. Har- rington Medal, the highest international award in historical archaeology, and in 2004 he received the Carol Ruppé Service Award, both given by the Society for Historical Archaeology. He cur- rently remains the only member to receive both of these awards and the only member to serve two terms as president of the society. During his career Rick published over 130 scientific papers, articles, and book reviews, and also authored over 100 unpublished reports to agencies, specializing in historical archaeology, culture- change theory, and artifact analysis, including such areas as glass trade beads and buttons. He conducted research and burial excavations at the request of 10 different American Indian tribal governments in the Plateau, Great Basin, and Northwest Coast, with repatriation a standard pro- cedure many years prior to the enactment of the federal Native American Grave Protection and Repatriation Act. Legal work for five different Northwest tribes and two tribes outside of the area involved testimony in Fifth District Federal Court on five occasions, including one case before the U.S. Supreme Court, as well as testimony before various state and federal legislative bodies. Editorial duties involved 40 years as senior coeditor for the Journal of Northwest Anthropology (JONA, formerly Northwest Anthropological Research Notes), 96 of the 98 issues of the University of Idaho Anthropological Reports, 20 years as review editor for Historical Archaeology, as well as serving on numerous editorial advisory boards. Rick was extremely proud of his volunteer service to the Society for Historical Archaeology. Following is a list of offices, committee positions, and contributions he made to the society. Offices and Committees Regional Coordinator for Research, Northwest, 1968–1977 General Program Chairman, 2nd annual meeting, 1969, Tucson Director, 1970–1971 Secretary-Treasurer, 1971–1974 (a three-year term plus a “Truman” year to put the Secretary-Treasurer and Editor on different three-year cycles) President, 1976 (plus the usual President-Elect and Past-President positions) Historical Archaeology Reviews Editor, 1977–1997 Editorial Board Member, 1977–2008 Parliamentarian, 1984–2008 Archivist, 1987–1998 President, 1990 (plus the usual President-Elect and Past-President positions) Associate Copy Editor, 2002–2008 Committees—far too many to list but history committee at the time of his death Additionally, he spent five “long” years preparing the Cotter bibliography for posting on the SHA website. After retirement Rick continued to live in Moscow, Idaho, with his wife Linda. He was desig- nated professor emeritus of anthropology and director emeritus of the Laboratory of Anthropology at the University of Idaho. He continued to conduct research and serve as an expert witness for Northwest tribes. Besides so generously giving of his time and integrity to the SHA and JONA, Rick was pas- sionate about supporting and keeping track of the careers of his many graduate students. Only a