Scotland and the Union
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CORNELL UNIVERSITY LIBRARY BOUGHT WITH THE INCOME OF THE SAGE ENDOWMENT FUND GIVEN IN 1891 BY HENRY WILLIAMS SAGE Cornell University Library DA 807.M43 Scotland and the union. 3 1924 028 026 585 Cornell University Library The original of tiiis book is in tine Cornell University Library. There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text. http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924028026585 SCOTLAND AND THE UNION A HISTORY OF SCOTLAND FROM 1695 TO 1747 PUBLISHED BY JAMES MACLEHOSE AND SONS, GLASGOW flnbiishfrs to the Stntbereilp. MACMTTXAN AND CO., LTD., LONDON. Neiv York, The Macniillan Co. London, - Siinpkin, Hutnilton and Co, Cambridge Mactnillan and Bowes^ EdinburgJi . Douglas and Foulis. Sydney^ Angus and Robertson. SCOTLAND AND THE UNION A HISTORY OF SCOTLAND FROM 1695 TO 1747 BY WILLIAM LAW MATHIESON AUTHOR OF 'POLITICS AND RELIGION IN SCOTLAND PEOM 1550 TO 1695' GLASGOW JAMES MACLEHOSE AND SONS PttbUshsrs to the itnihcrsito 1905 OLASOOW PKINTED : AT THE UKIVEBSITY PRESS BY EOBEBT MACLEHOSE ANI CO. LTD. PREFACE. This work is a continuation, on a broader and more comprehensive plan, of one which I published three years ago ; and the title is sufficient to indicate its scope as a history of Scotland during the period, extending from the completion of the Revolution Settlement to the enactments occasioned by the last Jacobite revolt, which may be distinguished as that of the origin, the accomplishment, and the consolidation of the Union. Such completeness as can be claimed for the epoch is political, and, to some extent, ecclesiastical. Without exceeding its bounds, it would have been impossible to do justice to social changes, other than economic, or to the rise of literature and philosophy ; and I have refrained the more readily from developing these themes as I hope to have an opportunity of dealing with them as illustrations of the material and intellectual progress which was to signalise the latter half of the eighteenth century. My principal source of information, in addition to printed volumes, has been the collection of pamphlets VI PREFACE in the Advocates' Library. I have derived some help from manuscripts in the British Museum and the a University of Edinburgh ; and, in acknowledging more considerable obligation to the officials of the Church of Scotland, I should like to thank the Kev. James Christie, D.D., for aid in investigating the records committed to his charge. My most cordial thanks are due to the Assistants at the Signet, University, and Advocates' Libraries, on whose unfailing courtesy and patience I have frequently imposed a heavy tax. Edinbhegh : October, 1905. CONTENTS. INTRODUCTION. PAGE Progress of Moderatism from the Reformation to the Revolution, - 1 The Revolution Settlement, ------ 13 The Revolution as an ecclesiastical epoch, - - - - 16 CHAPTER I. COMMERCIAL EXPANSION, 1695-1700. - Industrial activity during the reign of Charles II. , - 18 - Commercial antagonism of Scotland and England, - 20 Futile negotiations, 1668, ----- 22 THE SCOTTISH EAST INDIA COMPANY. - - - 1695. The Company established ; William Paterson, 24 State of the English East India Trade, - - - - 26 - Opposition to the Company in England ; its causes, - 29 - 1696. £400,000 subscribed at Edinburgh, - - - 31 - - 1697. The Company baffled at Amsterdam and Hamburg, . 32 THE DARIEN SCHEME. - India or Darien ? - - - - - - 33 - Paterson's intrigues ; nature of his scheme, - - 35 - - - Spain certain to be hostile ; popular delusions, 37 Paterson in disgrace, ------ 40 Vlll CONTENTS PAOE 42 1698. The first expedition to Darien ; its failure, 1699, - 46 1699. The Directors enraged, but themselves largely to blame, 4° The second and third expeditions, . - - - ^1 1700. The colony beset by the Spaniards, and surrenders, - Pate of the survivors, ..-- *^'^ - 5-^ The attitude of England reviewed, - - - National enthusiasm, ------ 56 CHAPTER II. ANTECEDENTS OF UNION, 1700-1705. - - 1700. The Darien agitation ; Parliament in 1700, - 59 - - Riot at Edinburgh ; the excitement begins to subside, 61 1701. Parliament in 1701, ..-.-- 6.? - - Projects of union ; conference of 1670, - - 65 William's dealings on this subject with the Convention, 1689, - 66 The Darien disaster shows the necessity of union, - - 68 - - - 1702. Death of William ; his popularity in Scotland, 70 - - European affairs ; the Spanish succession, - 71 - - - Accession of Anne ; England offers to treat, 74 - - The Convention Parliament prolonged ; a secession, 75 Treaty of Union, 1702 ; indifference of England, - - 76 Anne appeals to the Episcopalians and Jacobites, - - 79 1703. New Parliament, 1703 ; the Government outvoted, - - 81 The Act of Security, ------ 83 Fletcher's proposals ; the Wine Act, - - - - 85 Supplies refused ; Parliament prorogued, - - 88 The policy of the new reign a failure, - - - - 88 Queensberry discredited the - - 1704. ; "Scots plot," 91 Tweeddale Commissioner ; nature of the change, - 93 Parliament in 1704 the - - ; Government again defeateii, 94 The Act of Security receives the royal assent, - - - 95 The New Party admitted to office, - - • - 96 Scottish debate in the Lords, - - - . g^j Godolphin's policy - - - - 1705. ; the Alien Act, 99 Progress of the Whigs in England ; hostile to the New Party, 101 Green and two other - - Englishmen executed for piracy, jQg Argyll Commissioner - . ; the New Party dismissed, jQg CONTENTS ix PAGE The succession preferred to a treaty of union, - - - 107 Parliament in 1705 ; succession defeated ; treaty authorised, - 108 Union prospects, - - - - - - - 110 CHAPTER III. THE UNION, 1706-1707. THE TREATY. 1706. Choice of Commissioners, .... - 113 Progress and conclusion of the treaty, ... - 114 Incorporation likely to be unpopular, - - - - 117 Pamphlets against the Union, and for it, - - - 118 Attitude of parties, --.-.. 124 THE TREATY IN PARLIAMENT. - Preliminary proceedings ; a national fast, - - 125 - Riot of October 23 at Edinburgh, - - - 127 - The first, second, and third articles carried, - - 129 - Addresses against the Union ; their significance, - 131 Disturbances at Edinburgh and Glasgow, - - - 133 Jacobite schemes foiled by Hamilton, .... 134 - - 1707. Amendments ; allotment of representation, - 136 The Scottish amendments accepted at Westminster, - - 138 - - Queensberry's triumph ; rejoicings in England, - 139 CHAPTER IV. THE UNION FROM WITHIN. Perils of the late session, ------ 141 - The nobles favourable to the Union ; their motives, 143 The charge of bribery, ------ 144 General considerations in favour of the Union, - - - 145 The Duke of Queensberry, - - - - - 147 The Duke of Argyll, ------ 149 The Earl of Stair, - - - - - - 152 - Scottish nationality an indirect cause of the Union, - 155 CONTENTS PAGE " - - 155 The Scottish Parliament ; its defects, - Corrupt influence, 160 The Earl of Seafield, .----- 1^2 The Earl of Cromarty, ------ THE COUNTRY PARTY. 164 The Country Party splits into Nationalists and Unionists, - 164 Fletcher of Saltoun, his political ideas and character, - - 167 Lord Belhaven, - - - - - - - 168 The Duke of Hamilton, - - - - - - 171 The Duke of Athol and the Marquis of Annandale, - - 172 The Squadrone, - - - - - - - Baillie of Jerviswood, - - - - - 173 The Earl of Roxburgh, ------ 174 The Scottish Parliament makes a good end, - - - 176 CHAPTER V. THE CHURCH AND THE UNION, 1706-1712. The Church and the Darien scheme, . - - - 178 The Union as a violation of the Covenants, - - - 180 1706. The Assembly Commission addresses Parliament to secure the Church, ------- 182 The Act of Security gives rise to a second address. - - 183 1707. Private representations ; a third address, - - - 185 The Church unfriendly, but not hostile, - - - 187 TOLERA TION. Toleration a necessary consequence of the Union, - - 188 Episcopal dissent under William and Anne, - - - 189 statutory - - Proposed toleration, 1703 ; its failure, 191 1709. The English Liturgy ; Greenshields imprisoned, - - 195 Saoheverell, 1711. 1710 ; the Lords decide in favour of Greenshields, 197 Growing intolerance in Scotland, - - - . jgg 1712. The Toleration Bill in the Commons, . - . _ 20O The abjuration oath added to it by the Lords, - - - 202 Mischievous results, -.--.. 203 CONTENTS XI PATRONAGE. PAOB - Patronage before the Reformation, and after, - - 204 - The Church complains of it as a grievance, - 206 Act of 1690 abolishing patronage, . 208 - Patronage restored, 1712, - - - - 209 The Toleration and Patronage Bills in relation to the Union, - 211 The Union a moral, not a legal, security to the Church, - 213 - Death of Carstarea, 1715 ; his character, - - 214 CHAPTER VI. THE CHURCH AND DISSENT, 1712-1740. DOCTRINAL UNREST. Heresy hitherto almost unknown ; Arminianiam, - - 218 Deism; execution of Aikenhead, 1697, - - - - 220 Bourignonism ; its significance, ----- 222 - 1717. Professor Simson censured ; his tenets, - - - 224 Antinomianism ; liberality of English and Irish Presbyterians, 226 "The Auchterarder Creed," ----- 229 1718. The " Marrow " controversy, 1718-22, - - - - 229 1728. Simson convicted of Arianism, 1726-28, - - - - 232 1729. Controversy as to his sentence ; suspended, - - - 233 THE SECESSION. Cameronians and Hebronites, ----- 235 The abjuration oath, ..---. 236 Patronage dormant ; the jus devolutum, - - - - 237 The minister called, as in 1690, by heritors and elders, - - 239 - Popular pressure ; congregation claims to elect, - - 240 1732. Act of Assembly, 1732, in favour of heritors and elders, - 242 Ebenezer Erskine opposes the Act ; his Synod sermon, - - 243 1733. He and three other ministers