The National Catholic Weekly Sept. 13-20, 2010 $3.50 of Many Things
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE NATIONAL CATHOLIC WEEKLY SEPT. 13-20, 2010 $3.50 OF MANY THINGS PUBLISHED BY JESUITS OF THE UNITED STATES ast week some boys were rum- and in the absence of moral guidance EDITOR IN CHIEF maging through the attic of a estheticism will displace the old ways, leav- Drew Christiansen, S.J. Lonce grand Victorian mansion ing only raw sensation. Popular culture on Chestnut Place in the old neighbor- will be awash in violence. Experts absolve EDITORIAL DEPARTMENT hood. The house had fallen into fore- it, saying viewers can distinguish enter- MANAGING EDITOR closure in 2007. They unpacked cartons tainment from reality; but step by step, as Robert C. Collins, S.J. of hitherto unpublished correspondence our opponents say, souls coarsen. A fasci- EDITORIAL DIRECTOR between the nephew who owned the nation with the sensations of fine dining Karen Sue Smith house through the mid-1970s and an will be muddled with the gluttony of pie- ONLINE EDITOR older uncle who visited very rarely but eating contests and the hunt for exotically Maurice Timothy Reidy wrote regularly from all over the world. repulsive menus. Musicals will be made of CULTURE EDITOR The letters explored the murky depths cannibalism; and they will think it smart. James Martin, S.J. of human behavior and the clouds of Empathy, that great bulwark of nature LITERARY EDITOR self-deception that make life seem nor- holding people back from a war of all Patricia A. Kossmann mal when it is not. against all, withers, to be replaced by POETRY EDITOR One was written in the summer of endemic rivalry. Not many years hence James S. Torrens, S.J. 1973, when the Vietnam War was com- the game shows of today will be replaced ASSOCIATE EDITORS ing to an end and the Watergate hear- by fantasies of competition plotted with George M. Anderson, S.J. ings were underway, just after the scheming and treachery. Graduates of Kevin Clarke American Indian Movement and feder- Jebusite colleges, former Jebusites foremost Kerry Weber al agents engaged in battle at Wounded among them, will make rants more accept- Raymond Schroth, S.J. Knee and about the time Ian Paisley able than reasoned discourse. What a ART DIRECTOR and his followers broke up the first sit- reversal for our relentless old enemies’ fan- Stephanie Ratcliffe ting of the Northern Ireland Assembly. tasy of educating the best and the brightest ASSISTANT EDITOR There was discontent everywhere, in service of the neighbor. Francis W. Turnbull, S.J. stoked anger leapt into flames in unex- Controversy without argument will fill ASSISTANT LITERARY EDITOR pected places, and the highest authori- the airwaves. Venting will become common- Regina Nigro ties in the land couldn’t keep what was place, and ears will “itch,” as our great hidden in darkness from being brought adversary Saul wrote—we have to give him BUSINESS DEPARTMENT to light. credit for an exact metaphor—“itch” to hear PUBLISHER I share here a portion of one of the the latest outrage. Peddling hate will become Jan Attridge nephew’s letters that may offer perspec- a religious duty, and what wrong-thinking CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER tive on this, our latest summer of dis- people take for progress in overcoming prej- Lisa Pope content. udice will be reversed. Self-anointed ADVERTISING prophets—thank you, Master, for seducing Julia Sosa Dear Uncle, them—claiming “the Spirit” speaks through We have a moment of great opportunity. them, will look everywhere to find others to 106 West 56th Street New York, NY 10019-3803 The commotion that was aroused five hate, ostracize and persecute. The Knights years ago has entered a new phase. of the White Sheets and Flaming Crosses Ph: 212-581-4640; Fax: 212-399-3596 Feelings of insecurity mix with dread will rise again. Millions will live by rage. E-mail: [email protected]; anticipation of the powerful tumbling They believe it can’t happen again. [email protected] Web site: www.americamagazine.org. from their heights. Old resentments send “Never again,” they say. But you and I Customer Service: 1-800-627-9533 the middle-aged into the streets and stir know how it begins. © 2010 America Press, Inc. young people to violence; and without rec- Your devoted nephew, onciliation, the hoped-for settlement of old Wormwood scores promises only decades more unrest. Vengeance is becoming more and more DREW CHRISTIANSEN, S.J. acceptable under the guise of justice. This local reporter acknowledges his Cover: Rosemary Gira, C.R., shares a Everyman sees television as a blessing; debt to the boys on Chestnut Place, the secret with Christian Castracane at St. Mary of the Angels School in but we both know it will prove a curse. late C. S. Lewis and the archfiend Chicago. Photo: CNS /Sandy Trivial content will drive out serious fare, Screwtape. Bertog, Catholic New World. CONTENTS www.americamagazine.org VOL. 203 NO. 6, WHOLE NO. 4904 SEPTEMBER 13-20, 2010 RELIGIOUS EDUCATION ISSUE 11 THE CATHOLIC SCHOOLS WE NEED Moving from a hospice mentality to renewed hope Timothy M. Dolan 17 LIBERATING CATECHESIS A call for imagination and renewal Robert Brancatelli 23 HABITS OF MIND AND SPIRIT What campus ministers can learn from Blessed John Henry Newman James J. Bacik 11 COLUMNS & DEPARTMENTS 4 Editorials Mosque Hysteria Hold to the Deadline 6 Signs of the Times 9 Column How Will They Know? John F. Kavanaugh 30 Poem Of the Tibetan Lion Dog M. B. Powell 41 Letters 44 The Word Grace-Filled Complexity: The Bridgeable Chasm 23 Barbara E. Reid BOOKS & CULTURE 29 MUSIC The grass-roots debate about liturgical music BOOKS The Next Generation of Pastoral Leaders; Wayfaring ON THE WEB ON THE WEB A video report on rescuing church art in New Orleans five years after Hurricane Katrina. Plus, John W. Martens reintro- duces “The Good Word,” Americaʼs Scripture blog, on our podcast, and parents and educators respond to Archbishop Timothy M. Dolan. All at americamagazine.org. 29 EDITORIALS Mosque Hysteria ichael Enright’s face betrayed fear and perplexi- for one simple reason: each Islamic ty as he became the tabloid news embodiment of mosque is dedicated to the overthrow MAmerica’s sudden binge of Islamophobia after of the American government.” his arrest for attempting to murder a Muslim cabbie in New In May a pipe bomb exploded York. Mr. Enright had returned in April from a short tour outside a mosque in Jacksonville, Fla. In of duty in Afghanistan as a videographer for an interfaith August a mosque in California was group. What demons he brought back with him we will vandalized, and a suspicious fire broke Proposed site of never know, but he appears to have carried them to New out at the construction site of an Park51 York. After an afternoon of heavy drinking on Aug. 23, he Islamic center in Murfreesboro, Tenn. The heated debate hailed a cab, questioned the driver about his religion and over Park51 has now made home-grown hate a national phe- then began slashing him with a knife. nomenon. Most of the voices that have spoken out against the A few weeks ago it might have been acceptable for peo- proposed Park51 community center near ground zero in ple of good will to support the right of Muslim Americans to lower Manhattan will deplore Mr. Enright’s attack and then practice their faith freely while objecting to the location. But deny that their campaign had anything to do with it. Fair to suggest today, as many have, that this proposed facility is enough. No one will ever be able to say for sure what pro- insensitive to the personal loss of so many survivors of the pelled Mr. Enright. But what the “no mosque” pundits can- terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, diminishes the luster of not deny is the sour contribution they have made to respect- freedom for which 3,000 men and women were killed that ful, rational dialogue in U.S. civic life. day and for which the first responders died. Words have consequences; rhetoric is not disconnect- There are valid rebuttals to the case for impropriety. ed from action. Mr. Enright may be unbalanced, and what Park51 is not meant to celebrate the triumph of terrorism, little self-restraint he possessed may have been broken by but to confront it; it is a community center, not a mosque; it alcohol. But civic leaders promoting intolerance and fear can- was intended to promote interfaith relations; it is located not offer even these excuses. The voices raised against blocks from the heart of the World Trade Center site, while Park51, formerly called Cordoba House, which would be businesses and storefronts that hardly honor the sacredness run by precisely the kind of moderate Islamic leadership the of the suffering and loss experienced at ground zero may be United States should be encouraging, have stirred up an found close by. unpleasant neo-nativist brew across the nation. But now the ugliness has become widespread. People Initial reaction to Park51 was generally positive. In are being assaulted because of who they are, and constitu- December 2009 it was described by its founders as a push- tionally protected attempts to build mosques are being back against radical Islam, and it even received a thumbs-up thwarted out of fear and ignorance. America is beginning to from the conservative personality Laura Ingraham on a Fox look like the crusading enemy of Islam that Al Qaeda claims News broadcast: “I can’t find many people who really have a it is. Political and religious leaders must cease waffling on problem with it,” she told a co-founder, Daisy Khan.