Questionnaire State Budget Transparency Survey (Sbts) in Nigeria
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
F QUESTIONNAIRE I S C A L STATE BUDGET TRANSPARENCY P SURVEY (SBTS) IN NIGERIA O L I C Y P IMO STATE R O G R A M M JUNE 2020 E Civil Resource Development and Documentation Centre (CIRDDOC) No. 9 Second Avenue, Independence Layout, Box 1686, Enugu, Nigeria Tel: +234-803-3132-494; E-mail: [email protected]; [email protected]: Website: www.cirddoc.org CIRDDOC-NIGERIA Research on Sub-National Transparency THIS QUESTIONNAIRE WAS COMPLETED BY RESEARCHER: OHAKA AMAUCHE C. STATE: IMO RESEARCH ORGANIZATION: CENTRE FOR PEACE ACROSS BORDERS (CePAB) ADDRESS: #10 MBONU OJIKE STREET, IKENEGBU LAYOUT, OWERRI, IMO STATE TELEPHONE NUMBER(S): 08037301840, 08169312217 ORGANIZATION'S WEBSITE: E-MAIL ADDRESS: ORGANIZATION EMAIL: [email protected] RESEARCHER’S EMAIL: [email protected] STATE SUPERVISOR: DR. BEN NWOSU INSTITUTE FOR DEVELOPMENT STUDIES, UNIVERSITY OF NIGERIA, ENUGU CAMPUS email: [email protected] ZONAL CONSULTANT: DR. COSMAS C. OHAKA - Nigeria SBTS Questionnaire 2020 - 2 CIRDDOC-NIGERIA Research on Sub-National Transparency SURVEY ON STATE BUDGET TRANSPARENCY IN NIGERIA Section One: Public Availability of Key Budget Documents Table 1: Budget Year of Documents Used in Completing the Questionnaire Table 2: Key Budget Documents Used: Full Titles, Release Dates and Internet Links 1. Pre-Budget Statement: State Budget Call Circular, MTEF/FSP 2. Executive Budget Proposal (EBP): State Budget Draft Estimates 3. State Citizens Budget 4. Approved Budget: State Budget Appropriation Law 5. In-Year Reports: State Quarterly Budget Implementation Reports, 6. State Mid-Year Review and 7. Year-End Report: State Accountant-General’s Report, 8. State Auditor General’s Report Section Two: Public Participation in the Budget Process Section Three: Public Availability of Information on Procurement Section Four: Legal Framework: Access to Information and Fiscal Responsibility SECTION ONE: PUBLIC AVAILABILITY OF KEY BUDGET DOCUMENTS TABLE 1 · BUDGET YEAR OF DOCUMENTS USED IN COMPLETING THE QUESTIONNAIRE Budget Documents Used in Completing the Questionnaire Please indicate below for which fiscal year responses to questions relating to each report or experience were based on. Budget Documents Budget Year Used 1. Pre-Budget Statement: a) State Budget Call a) 2020 Circular, b) State Medium Term Expenditure Framework b) 2020 (MTEF) and Fiscal Strategy Paper (FSP) 2. Executive Budget Proposal (EBP):State Draft 2020 Budget Estimates 3. State Citizens Budget 2020 4. State Approved Budget Volumes / Appropriation 2020 Law 5. In-Year Reports: State Quarterly Budget 2020 Implementation Reports, - Nigeria SBTS Questionnaire 2020 - 3 CIRDDOC-NIGERIA Research on Sub-National Transparency 6. State Mid-Year Review 2020 7. Year-end Report (Consolidated Annual Budget 2018, 2019 Performance Report) 8. State Auditor General’s Report 2019 TABLE 2 · KEY BUDGET DOCUMENTS USED: FULL TITLES, RELEASE DATES, INTERNET LINKS AND AVAILABILITY STATUS For each document, please include: 1. Full Title; 2. Date of Release, 3. Internet Link (if the document is Budget Document available online) or any other availability information, 4. Availability Status. 1.Title: Call Circular for submission of proposals for 2020 Budget State Budget Call 2.Date of Release: 1st July 2019 Circular 3.Internet Link: Not available 4.Availability: Produced for Internal Use (PIU) (Annex 1) M e d i u m T e r m 1.Title: Not Produced Expenditure Framework 2.Date of Release: Not applicable ( M T E F ) a n d F i s c a l 3.Internet Link: none Strategy Paper (FSP) 4.Availability: Not Produced (NP) 1a. Title: 2020 Budget Rebuilding Imo Budget One Imo State Government 1b. Title: Atumatu Mkpata Na Mmefu Ego(BojetỊ) Nke Afo Puku Abuo Na IriAbuo Goomenti Imo Steeti BojetỊ Nwughari Imo Nke Mbu State Citizens Budget 2a. Date of Release: 29th March 2020 2b. Date of Release: 6th April 2020 3. Internet Link: https://www.imostate.gov.ng/IMSG/Services/EGov/Budget?ID=7 https://www.imostate.gov.ng/IMSG/Services/EGov/Budget? ID=8 4. Availability:Produced and Publicly Available (PPA) 1.Title: Imo State of Nigeria, Draft Budget Estimate -2020. “Rebuild Imo State Draft Budget One” Estimates 2.Date of Release: December 2019(the Budget Director was not sure of the specific date) 3.Internet Link: None 4.Availability:Produced for Internal Use (PIU) (Annex 2) - Nigeria SBTS Questionnaire 2020 - 4 CIRDDOC-NIGERIA Research on Sub-National Transparency For each document, please include: 1. Full Title; 2. Date of Release, 3. Internet Link (if the document is Budget Document available online) or any other availability information, 4. Availability Status. 1.Title: Imo State Government of Nigeria Approved Estimates, Rebuilding Imo Budget One – 2020 2.Date of Release: 29th April 2020 State Approved Budget 3.Internet Link: https://www.imostate.gov.ng/IMSG/Services/EGov/Budget?ID=12 Availability: Produced and Publicly Available (PPA) 1.Title: Imo State of Nigeria Law No.43 of 2019 – Imo State Appropriation Law 2020. State Budget 2.Date of Release: 27th December 2019 Appropriation Law 3.Internet Link: None. Although the law was published in the Imo State of Nigeria Official Gazette, No. 9 Vol. 44 it is not online. 4.Availability:Produced for Internal Use (PIU) (Annex 3) 1.Title: Government Of Imo State Of Nigeria 2020 First Quarter Budget Implementation Report State Quarterly Reports 2.Date of Release: First Quarter - 27th April 2020 3.Internet Link: https://www.imostate.gov.ng/IMSG/Services/EGov/Budget?ID=2, 4.Availability: Produced and Publicly Available (PPA); 1.Title: Government Of Imo State Of Nigeria2020 Second Quarter And Mid- Year budget Implementation Report State Mid-Year Review 2.Date of Release: 10th December 2020 3.Internet Link: https://www.imostate.gov.ng/IMSG/Services/EGov/Budget? ID=20 4.Availability: Produced for Internal Use because it was not made publicly available on time. Year-end Report 1.Title: Not Produced (Consolidated Annual 2.Date of Release: Budget Performance 3.Internet Link: Report) 4.Availability: NP 1.Title: Report of the Auditor-General on the Accounts of Imo State of Nigeria for the Year Ended 31st December, 2019 State Auditor General’s 2.Date of Release: 22nd July 2020 Report 3.InternetLink: https://www.imostate.gov.ng/IMSG/Common/Services/ Audit 4.Availability:Produced and Publicly Available (PPA); Note the options for Availability: (1) Produced and Publicly Available (PPA); (2) Produced for Internal Use (PIU); (3) Not Produced (NP) - Nigeria SBTS Questionnaire 2020 - 5 CIRDDOC-NIGERIA Research on Sub-National Transparency SECTION ONE: PUBLIC AVAILABILITY OF KEY BUDGET DOCUMENTS A. STATE BUDGET CALL CIRCULAR AND CALENDAR 1. Does the State Ministry, Department or Agency in charge of Budget produce a State Budget Call Circular? A. Yes, it is does. B. No, it does not or document is not publicly available. C. Not applicable/other (please comment). Citation: Mr. Victor Okereke (08060506676), Budget Director, Imo State Ministry of Budget and Economic Planning. Ref: MPED/S.320/111/94 of 1st July 2019 (Cover page is attached as Annex 1) Comment: Q.1: Ans: (B). According to the Budget Director, Mr. Victor Okereke (08060506676), during my interview with him on the 4th August 2020 in his office confirmed that Call Circular for submission of proposals for 2020 Budget (6 pages) Independent Reviewer: Government Reviewer: CIRDDOC: 2. How far in advance of the budget year is the State Budget Call Circular released? A. It is released at least five months before the start of the budget year. B. It is released at least four months before the start of the budget year. C. It is released at least three months before the start of the budget year. D. It is made publicly available but released after the State Draft Budget Estimates have been presented to the State House of Assembly, or it is not produced. E. Not applicable/other (please comment). Citation: Mr. Victor Okereke (08060506676), Budget Director, Imo State Ministry of Budget and Economic Planning. Ref: MPED/S.320/111/94 of 1st July 2019 (Cover page is attached as Annex 1) Comment: Q.2: Ans: (D) Although we sighted the call circular for submission of proposals for 2020 Budget (6 pages) Ref: MPED/S.320/111/94 dated 1ST July 2019, the document is not publicly available. Independent Reviewer: Government Reviewer: CIRDDOC: 3. Is the State Budget Call Circular made available to the general public? A. Yes, it is made available to the general public, in addition to being submitted to all key stakeholders B. No, it is only submitted to key stakeholders including Civil Society groups, Trade Unions, Speaker and Clerk of the State House of Assembly (SHOA) and MDAs only. C. No, it is only submitted to the Speaker and Clerk of the SHOA and MDAs only. D. No, it is only submitted to heads of MDAs only or document is not publicly available E. Not applicable/other (please comment). - Nigeria SBTS Questionnaire 2020 - 6 CIRDDOC-NIGERIA Research on Sub-National Transparency Citation: Mr. Victor Okereke (08060506676), Budget Director, Imo State Ministry of Budget and Economic Planning. Ref: MPED/S.320/111/94 of 1st July 2019 (Cover page is attached as Annex 1) Comment: Q.3. Ans: (D) According to the Budget Director, Mr. Victor Okereke (08060506676), during my interview with him on the 4th August 2020 in his office, “…Call Circular was not put in the Press or published anywhere for public use. Also, I did not know that I was meant to upload in the internet but I promise you that we will upload that of 2021 in the internet.” Independent Reviewer: Government Reviewer: CIRDDOC: 4. Does the budget process adhere to a publicly available calendar for preparation and release of the State Draft Budget Estimates? A. Yes, a detailed budget calendar is provided to the public and the deadlines are adhered to.