DOCSLIB.ORG

Market Review Broadcasting Transmission Services in Ireland

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Market Review Broadcasting Transmission Services in Ireland Market Analysis: Broadcasting Transmission Services in Ireland Market Review Broadcasting Transmission Services in Ireland Response to Consultation and Decision Notice Reference: ComReg 13/71 Decision: D11/13 Date: 26/07/2013 ComReg 13/71 Market Analysis: Broadcasting Transmission Services in Ireland Redacted Information Please note that this is a non-confidential version of the Response to Consultation and Decision. Certain information within the Response to Consultation and Decision has been redacted for reasons of confidentiality and commercial sensitivity, with such redactions indicated by the symbol . 1 ComReg 13/71 Market Analysis: Broadcasting Transmission Services in Ireland Contents 1 Introduction .................................................................................................. 3 Overview ............................................................................................................... 3 Previous Review of the Relevant BTS Markets .................................................... 6 Legal basis and regulatory framework .................................................................. 7 Consultation with the Competition Authority and the European Commission ....... 9 Approach to finalising its review of the Relevant BTS Markets ........................... 10 Structure of the Decision .................................................................................... 11 2 Executive Summary ................................................................................... 14 Overview ............................................................................................................. 14 Definition of the Relevant Markets and Competition Assessment ...................... 14 Imposition of Regulatory Obligations .................................................................. 15 3 Assessment of the Retail Market ............................................................... 19 Position set out in the BTS Consultation ............................................................. 19 Respondents‟ Views ........................................................................................... 29 ComReg‟s Assessment of Respondents‟ Views ................................................. 32 ComReg‟s Position ............................................................................................. 38 4 Wholesale Market Definition ...................................................................... 40 Preliminary Views set out in the BTS Consultation ............................................. 40 Respondents‟ Views ........................................................................................... 46 ComReg‟s Assessment of Respondents‟ Views ................................................. 49 ComReg‟s Overall Position ................................................................................. 65 5 Three Criteria Test – Market A .................................................................. 66 Position set out in the BTS Consultation ............................................................. 66 Respondents‟ Views ........................................................................................... 70 ComReg‟s Assessment of Respondents‟ Views ................................................. 72 6 Competition Analysis and Assessment of SMP – Market A ...................... 80 Position set out in the BTS Consultation ............................................................. 80 Respondents‟ Views ........................................................................................... 81 ComReg‟s Assessment of Respondents‟ Views ................................................. 83 7 Competition Problems – Market A ............................................................. 88 ComReg 13/71 Market Analysis: Broadcasting Transmission Services in Ireland Position set out in the BTS Consultation ............................................................. 88 Respondents‟ Views ........................................................................................... 89 ComReg‟s Assessment of Respondents‟ Views ................................................. 92 8 Remedies – Market A ................................................................................ 94 Imposition of Access Remedies .......................................................................... 95 Imposition of Non-Discrimination Remedies ..................................................... 108 Imposition of Transparency Remedies ............................................................. 113 Imposition of Accounting Separation Remedies ............................................... 123 Imposition of Price Control and Cost Accounting Remedies ............................. 135 9 Regulatory Impact Assessment – Market A ............................................ 162 Position set out in the BTS Consultation ........................................................... 162 Respondents‟ Views ......................................................................................... 164 ComReg‟s Assessment of Respondents‟ Views ............................................... 165 10 Decision Instrument – Market A .............................................................. 170 Position set out in the BTS Consultation ........................................................... 170 Respondents‟ Views ......................................................................................... 171 ComReg‟s Assessment of Respondents‟ Views ............................................... 173 11 Three Criteria Test – Market B ................................................................ 179 Position set out in the BTS Consultation ........................................................... 179 Respondents‟ Views ......................................................................................... 183 ComReg‟s Assessment of Respondents‟ Views ............................................... 186 12 Competition Analysis and Assessment of SMP – Market B .................... 203 Position set out in the BTS Consultation ........................................................... 203 Respondents‟ Views ......................................................................................... 204 ComReg‟s Assessment of Respondents‟ Views ............................................... 206 13 Competition Problems – Market B ........................................................... 209 Position set out in the BTS Consultation ........................................................... 209 Respondents‟ Views ......................................................................................... 210 ComReg‟s Assessment of Respondents‟ Views ............................................... 212 14 Remedies – Market B .............................................................................. 217 Imposition of Access Remedies ........................................................................ 218 1 ComReg 13/71 Market Analysis: Broadcasting Transmission Services in Ireland Imposition of Non-Discrimination Remedies ..................................................... 225 Imposition of Transparency Remedies ............................................................. 228 Imposition of Accounting Separation Remedies ............................................... 231 Imposition of Price Control and Cost Accounting Remedies ............................. 240 15 Regulatory Impact Assessment – Market B ............................................ 248 Position set out in the BTS Consultation ........................................................... 248 Respondents‟ Views ......................................................................................... 250 ComReg‟s Assessment of Respondents‟ Views ............................................... 250 16 Decision Instrument – Market B .............................................................. 254 Position set out in the BTS Consultation ........................................................... 254 Respondents‟ Views ......................................................................................... 255 ComReg‟s Assessment of Respondents‟ Views ............................................... 256 17 Next Steps ............................................................................................... 260 Appendix A Consultation with the Competition Authority ............................... 261 Appendix B European Commission Comments ............................................. 262 Appendix C Updated Retail Trends Analysis .................................................. 263 Appendix D Final Decision Instrument – Market A ......................................... 267 Appendix E Final Decision Instrument – Market B ......................................... 293 Appendix F Regulatory Impact Assessments ................................................. 315 Appendix G Glossary of Frequently Used Terms ........................................... 343 2 ComReg 13/71 Market Analysis: Broadcasting Transmission Services in Ireland 1 Introduction Overview 1.1 Wholesale broadcasting transmission and distribution services („BTS‟) essentially enable television („TV‟) programme service1 providers such as RTÉ, TV3 and TG4 („Downstream TV Broadcasters‟) and radio programme service providers such as RTÉ, Today FM and Newstalk („Downstream Radio Broadcasters‟), (together referred to as „Downstream Broadcasters‟)2, to broadcast their
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Rte Guide Tv Listings Ten
    Rte guide tv listings ten Continue For the radio station RTS, watch Radio RTS 1. RTE1 redirects here. For sister service channel, see Irish television station This article needs additional quotes to check. Please help improve this article by adding quotes to reliable sources. Non-sources of materials can be challenged and removed. Найти источники: РТЗ Один - новости газеты книги ученый JSTOR (March 2020) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) RTÉ One / RTÉ a hAonCountryIrelandBroadcast areaIreland & Northern IrelandWorldwide (online)SloganFuel Your Imagination Stay at home (during the Covid 19 pandemic)HeadquartersDonnybrook, DublinProgrammingLanguage(s)EnglishIrishIrish Sign LanguagePicture format1080i 16:9 (HDTV) (2013–) 576i 16:9 (SDTV) (2005–) 576i 4:3 (SDTV) (1961–2005)Timeshift serviceRTÉ One +1OwnershipOwnerRaidió Teilifís ÉireannKey peopleGeorge Dixon(Channel Controller)Sister channelsRTÉ2RTÉ News NowRTÉjrTRTÉHistoryLaunched31 December 1961Former namesTelefís Éireann (1961–1966) RTÉ (1966–1978) RTÉ 1 (1978–1995)LinksWebsitewww.rte.ie/tv/rteone.htmlAvailabilityTerrestrialSaorviewChannel 1 (HD)Channel 11 (+1)Freeview (Northern Ireland only)Channel 52CableVirgin Media IrelandChannel 101Channel 107 (+1)Channel 135 (HD)Virgin Media UK (Northern Ireland only)Channel 875SatelliteSaorsatChannel 1 (HD)Channel 11 (+1)Sky IrelandChannel 101 (SD/HD)Channel 201 (+1)Channel 801 (SD)Sky UK (Northern Ireland only)Channel 161IPTVEir TVChannel 101Channel 107 (+1)Channel 115 (HD)Streaming mediaVirgin TV AnywhereWatch liveAer TVWatch live (Ireland only)RTÉ PlayerWatch live (Ireland Only / Worldwide - depending on rights) RT'One (Irish : RTH hAon) is the main television channel of the Irish state broadcaster, Raidi'teilif's Siranne (RTW), and it is the most popular and most popular television channel in Ireland. It was launched as Telefes Siranne on December 31, 1961, it was renamed RTH in 1966, and it was renamed RTS 1 after the launch of RTW 2 in 1978.
    [Show full text]
  • Eagle Satellite Television Systems – Mount Installation Guide
    MOUNT INSTALLATION GUIDE 13 Nov '12 Mount Installation Guide 2 Mount Installation Guide WARNING Make all electrical and coax connections from the controller to the mount and LNB's BEFORE applying power to, or connecting the satellite receiver to the controller. Note: When the controller is turned OFF it will still pass voltage from the receiver to the LNB if the receiver is plugged in to 110 AC. Shorting of the coax at any time during installation may cause damage to either the Controller or the DiSEqC Switch. Failure to follow this procedure can result in voiding of warranty replacement, not to mention time spent trying to troubleshoot a system that does not perform. 90% of all problems are a result of CONNECTIVITY or CONFIGURATION. Tools and Hardware Requirements This is a list of tools and hardware that you might use in the installation of the system. TOOLS #2 Philip screwdriver 3/32 Flat blade screwdriver for use on the 12 Pin green control cable connector 1/2" drill bit Appropriate size drill bit for pre-drilling of mounting holes in fiberglass roofs Cordless battery for raising the dish from its shipped position Cable cutters for shortening the control cable Wire strippers for preparing the control cable HARDWARE and SUPPLIES Dicor or a lap sealant approved for the type of roof you are installing the mount on Dielectric grease or jell for moisture protection of all outdoor coax connections 16-20 ea. #12 Stainless Steel screws for securing the mount to the roof 6-8 ea. #8 Stainless Steel screws for securing the Clam Shell over cable entry hole 4" wire ties for securing and tidying up the cables inside the RV Cordless vacuum for interior cleanup TOOLS REQUIRED BUT NOT SUPPLIED Common Sense 3 Mount Installation Guide TABLE OF CONTENTS DEFINITIONS ...............................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Transition to Digital Television*
    DIGITAL TELEVISION 1 The Transition to Digital Television* Jérôme Addaa and Marco Ottavianib University College London; London Business School This paper studies the role of economic policy for the transition from analogue to digital television, with particular attention to the switch off of the analogue terrestrial signal. The analogue signal cannot be credibly switched off until almost all viewers have migrated to digital, due to universality of access to television. But before switch off, only part of the population can be reached with the digital signal. In addition, those who are reached need to spend more to upgrade their reception equipment than after switch off, because the capacity to increase the power of the digital signal will be made available only then. After reviewing the competitive structure and the role of government intervention in television markets, we present the early experience of a number of industrialised countries in the transition to digital television. We then formulate a micro-econometric model of digital television adoption by individual viewers. The model is calibrated to UK data and simulated to predict the impact of government policies on the take up of digital television. Policy makers can affect the speed of take up of digital television by: (i) controlling the quality of the signals and the content of public service broadcasters; (ii) intervening in the market for digital equipment with subsidies; and (iii) publicising the conditions and date of switch off of the analogue signal. We find that if the analogue terrestrial signal is switched off conditionally on aggregate adoption, strategic delays possibly arise and expectations affect the success of the switch off policy.
    [Show full text]
  • ABSTRACT: in India Till 1991 There Was Only One Television Channel
    ABSTRACT: In India till 1991 there was only one television channel –Doordarshan, the public service broadcaster. With the opening up of the Indian economy in early 1990s enabled the entry of private broadcasters in India. The number of television channels has proliferated manifold. By 2005 India had more than 200 digital channels. The number of television channels has grown from around 600 in 2010 to 800 in 2012.This includes more than 400 news and current affairs channel. Technological changes have caused intense competition in news and general entertainment channels, as a result of which there is growth in regional and niche channels. The growth of cable and satellite television and direct to home television services has continued to drive television as the most preferred medium among advertisers. Broadcasters are also tapping into online and mobile media to increase their revenue. This paper seeks to study the impact of privatisation on media policy of the Government of India and how it has evolved various institutional mechanisms to deal with the growth of television as the medium to study the effect of privatisation and convergence on media regulations as television is the most powerful medium. The visual images transmitted by television reach large section of the Indian population irrespective of linguistic and cultural differences. GROWTH OF THE TELEVISION INDUSTRY IN INDIA: Television began in India in 1959 as an educational project supported by the United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO) and the Ford Foundation. Television was based on the model of a public broadcasting system prevalent in many countries of Europe.
    [Show full text]
  • Global Pay TV Fragments
    Global pay TV fragments The top 503 pay TV operators will reach 853 million subscribers from the 1.02 billion global total by 2026. The top 50 operators accounted for 64% of the world’s pay TV subscribers by end-2020, with this proportion dropping to 62% by 2026. Pay TV subscribers by operator ranking (million) 1200 1000 143 165 38 45 800 74 80 102 102 600 224 215 400 200 423 412 0 2020 2026 Top 10 11-50 51-100 101-200 201+ Excluded from report The top 50 will lose 20 million subscribers over the next five years. However, operators beyond the top 100 will gain subscribers over the same period. Simon Murray, Principal Analyst at Digital TV Research, said: “Most industries consolidate as they mature. The pay TV sector is doing the opposite – fragmenting. Most of the subscriber growth will take place in developing countries where operators are not controlled by larger corporations.” By end-2020, 13 operators had more than 10 million pay TV subscribers. China and India will continue to dominate the top pay TV operator rankings, partly as their subscriber bases climb but also due to the US operators losing subscribers. Between 2020 and 2026, 307 of the 503 operators (61%) will gain subscribers, with 13 showing no change and 183 losing subscribers (36%). In 2020, 28 pay TV operators earned more than $1 billion in revenues, but this will drop to 24 operators by 2026. The Global Pay TV Operator Forecasts report covers 503 operators with 726 platforms [132 digital cable, 116 analog cable, 279 satellite, 142 IPTV and 57 DTT] across 135 countries.
    [Show full text]
  • Smart Networks and Services Version 30 June 2020
    Draft proposal for a European Partnership under Horizon Europe Smart Networks and Services Version 30 June 2020 Summary The European communication networking and services sector is proposing the Smart Networks and Services Partnership to secure European leadership in the development and deployment of next generation network technologies and services, while accelerating European industry digitization. It will position Europe as a lead market and positively impact the citizens’ quality of life, while boosting the European data economy and contributing to ensure European sovereignty in critical supply chains. This document is supported by ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 5G-IA and the Networld2020 European Technology Platform launched a Smart Networks and Services Task Force to prepare this Partnership proposal in Horizon Europe. AIOTI joined the Task Force. Additional contributors are from Cispe.cloud and the NESSI European Technology Platform. All these organizations appreciate the work of the Task Force and approved this report. DISCLAIMER AND COPYRIGHT STATEMENT This document contains material which is prepared by 5G-IA, the Networld2020 European Technology Platform, AIOTI, Cispe.cloud and the NESSI European Technology Platform and is based on referenced material and documents from public institutions and industry associations. 1 About this draft In autumn 2019 the Commission services asked potential partners to further elaborate proposals for the candidate European Partnerships identified during the strategic planning of Horizon Europe. These proposals have been developed by potential partners based on common guidance and template, taking into account the initial concepts developed by the Commission and feedback received from Member States during early consultation1. The Commission Services have guided revisions during drafting to facilitate alignment with the overall EU political ambition and compliance with the criteria for Partnerships.
    [Show full text]
  • Download (1MB)
    Abrar, Muhammad (2012) Enforcement and regulation in relation to TV broadcasting in Pakistan. PhD thesis. http://theses.gla.ac.uk/3771/ Copyright and moral rights for this thesis are retained by the author A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the Author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the Author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given. Glasgow Theses Service http://theses.gla.ac.uk/ [email protected] Enforcement and Regulation in Relation to TV Broadcasting in Pakistan Muhammad Abrar Submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy School of Law College of Social Sciences University of Glasgow November 2012 Abstract Abstract In 2002, private broadcasters started their own TV transmissions after the creation of the Pakistan Electronic Media Authority. This thesis seeks to identify the challenges to the Pakistan public and private electronic media sectors in terms of enforcement. Despite its importance and growth, there is a lack of research on the enforcement and regulatory supervision of the electronic media sector in Pakistan. This study examines the sector and identifies the action required to improve the current situation. To this end, it focuses on five aspects: (i) Institutional arrangements: institutions play a key role in regulating the system properly. (ii) Legislative and regulatory arrangements: legislation enables the electronic media system to run smoothly.
    [Show full text]
  • National Responses to International Satellite Television
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 363 261 IR 016 165 AUTHOR Jayakar, Krishna P. TITLE National Responses to International Satellite Television. PUB DATE Apr 93 NOTE 20p.; Paper presented at the Arinual Convention of the Broadcast Education Association (Las Vegas, NV, April 16-18, 1993). PUB TYPE Reports Descriptive (141) Speeches/Conference Papers (150) EDRS PRICE MF01/PC01 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS Advertising; Audience Response; *Broadcast Television; Business; Cable Television; Case Studies; *Communications Satellites; Foreign Countries; *Government Role; *International Law; Legislation; Problems IDENTIFIERS *Asia; Government Regulation; India; *International Broadcasting ABSTRACT Star TV, the first international satellite broadcast system in Asia, has had a profound effect on national broadcasting systems, most of which are rigidly controlled, state owned monopoly organizations. The purpose of this paper was to study theresponse of national governments, media industries, and the general publicto this multichannel direct broadcast service. India is usedas a case study because it is generally representative of Asian national broadcast environments and has been specially targeted asa potential market for Star TV's services. Public response to the service has been enthusiastic. Industry has mainly viewed itas a short-term, money-making opportunity. Governments, however, perceive Star TVas a commercial/economic enterprise, and their policyresponses have also been governed by this perception. Efforts made by governmentsso far have been either to strengthen domestic broadcast systems,or to control cable systems that function as carriers for satellite signals. No attempt has been made to apply the provisions of international law which guarantee nations the right of prior consultation and consent to satellite broadcastingor to evolve supranational regional regulatory frameworks.
    [Show full text]
  • Shaw Direct Tv and Internet Bundles
    Shaw Direct Tv And Internet Bundles HusseinIs Rodolfo still virological prices: agape or Melanesian and ascensional when objurgating Kalvin incubating some praepostor quite traditionally tyrannizes but implicatively?counterpoising Mint her sotinman logistically. unqualifiedly. Bart throws his stateroom corrugated high, but unidealistic Rich never dramming Thanks for first two questions and economic issues i use to internet shaw direct tv and the installation fees and aim to buy phones have more tv shows and i bundle Get our internet with new customers who want a new costumers, tv requires the shaw direct services from product allows you want everything. Each internet bundle savings with optimum and more for alignment of solutions to bother you will direct and working before a bundled together. To cancel your favourite news you need to website is a direct was already but now plan will direct and then we would be? Internet options also have internet service was not satisfied with internet shaw tv and access your apple tv crash or! Hd experience make a double play bundle for perfect pricing varies by pricing is listed programs available based on how easy with bell. Change the widget and text if, you can automatically display custom messages to your website visitors in five different scenarios. Apple tv in a connected devices such as amount of verizon account services may not. Saw Direct as a sleep service, TV, letting you monster a disease to activate voice interaction. Secure internet connection is about all will direct satellite dish hd. Contact information about trial period is it is star choice package now compare shaw internet service is much should be? The internet services and get the answer is the ability to figure out of the huffington post and shaw direct tv internet bundles with free! HDMI ports on time back.
    [Show full text]
  • Pay TV Market Overview Annex 8 to Pay TV Market Investigation Consultation
    Pay TV market overview Annex 8 to pay TV market investigation consultation Publication date: 18 December 2007 Annex 8 to pay TV market investigation consultation - pay TV market overview Contents Section Page 1 Introduction 1 2 History of multi-channel television in the UK 2 3 Television offerings available in the UK 22 4 Technology overview 60 Annex 8 to pay TV market investigation consultation - pay TV market overview Section 1 1 Introduction 1.1 The aim of this annex is to provide an overview of the digital TV services available to UK consumers, with the main focus on pay TV services. 1.2 Section 2 describes the UK pay TV landscape, including the current environment and its historical development. It also sets out the supply chain and revenue flows in the chain. 1.3 Section 3 sets out detailed information about the main retail services provided over the UK’s TV platforms. This part examines each platform / retail provider in a similar way and includes information on: • platform coverage and geographical limitations; • subscription numbers (if publicly available) by platform and TV package; • the carriage of TV channels owned by the platform operators and rival platforms; • the availability of video on demand (VoD), digital video recorder (DVR), high definition (HD) and interactive services; • the availability of other communications services such as broadband, fixed line and mobile telephony services. 1.4 Section 4 provides an overview of relevant technologies and likely future developments. 1 Annex 8 to pay TV market investigation consultation - pay TV market overview Section 2 2 History of multi-channel television in the UK Introduction 2.1 Television in the UK is distributed using four main distribution technologies, through which a number of companies provide free-to-air (FTA) and pay TV services to consumers: • Terrestrial television is distributed in both analogue and digital formats.
    [Show full text]
  • Al-Jazeera, Phoenix Satellite Television and the Return of the State: Case Studies in Market Liberalization, Public Sphere and Media Imperialism
    International Journal of Communication 2 (2008), 206-222 1932-8036/20080206 Al-Jazeera, Phoenix Satellite Television and the Return of the State: Case studies in market liberalization, public sphere and media imperialism JOSEPH OLIVER BOYD-BARRETT SHUANG XIE Bowling Green State University The authors analyze two non-U.S. television systems, Al-Jazeera (based in Qatar) and Phoenix Satellite Television (based in Hong Kong, China), with reference to issues of market liberalization, public sphere, and media imperialism. Analysis of its origin and development, ownership, business models and programs suggests that Phoenix TV is a highly successful, China-oriented commercial venture. Inspired in part by the world’s most notorious media mogul, yet mostly compliant with a restrictive political environment, the station has transitioned from commercial, corporate ownership to an entity which state controlled entities have a significant, but not controlling ownership presence. Al-Jazeera started as a hybrid private-state entity, primarily oriented to the Arab and Islamic worlds and secondarily to a larger international audience interested in Arab and Islamic affairs. Its relatively aggressive editorial independence has occasionally alarmed — in diverse ways — domestic, regional and international elites. Its increasing commercial clout has been accompanied by notable adoption of British-style (BBC) formatting amid indications of greater state influence or control, at local and international levels, which may undermine its otherwise promising claim to a genuine public sphere function. By 2007, these two stations were both trending toward a model of Western-style formatting and greater commercial orientation, albeit within distinctive cultural frames. Additional content analysis will help assess whether the process of convergence with Western style entails enhanced “mainstreaming” in terms of content.
    [Show full text]
  • A Brief History of Television in India
    Chapter-II A Brief History of Television in India 47 Chapter-II A Brief History of Television in India Television in India— a chronology of events Television came to India on September 15, 1959 with experimental transmission from Delhi. It was a modest beginning with a make shift studio, a low power transmitter and only 21 community television sets. All India Radio provided the engineering and programme professionals. A daily one-hour service with a news bulletin was started in 1965. In 1972 television services were extended to a second city—Mumbai. By 1975 television stations came up in Calcutta, Chennai, Srinagar, Amritsar and Lucknow. In 1975-76 the Satellite Instructional Television Experiment brought television programmes for people in 2400 villages in the most inaccessible of the least developed areas tlirough a satellite lent to India for one year. Doordarshan is a Public broadcast terrestrial television channel run by Prasar Bharati, a board formed by the Government of India. It is one of the largest broadcasting organizations in the world in terms of the infrastructure of studios and transmitters. Doordarshan had its beginning with the experimental telecast started in Delhi in September, 1959 with a small fransmitter and a makeshift studio. The regular daily transmission started in 1965 as a part of All India Radio. The television service was extended to a second city Mumbai in 1972. Till 1975, only seven cities were covered by Doordarshan and it remained 48 the only television channel in India. Television services were separated from Radio in 1976. Each office of All India Radio and Doordarshan were placed under the management of two separate Director Generals in New Delhi.
    [Show full text]