DOCSLIB.ORG

Repurposing the Suburban Mcmansion: a Congregate Living Proposal for Seniors, Families, and Young Professionals Ashley Mcgrew

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Repurposing the Suburban Mcmansion: a Congregate Living Proposal for Seniors, Families, and Young Professionals Ashley Mcgrew Florida State University Libraries Electronic Theses, Treatises and Dissertations The Graduate School 2008 Repurposing the Suburban Mcmansion: A Congregate Living Proposal for Seniors, Families, and Young Professionals Ashley McGrew Follow this and additional works at the FSU Digital Library. For more information, please contact [email protected] FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF VISUAL ARTS, THEATRE, AND DANCE REPURPOSING THE SUBURBAN MCMANSION: A CONGREGATE LIVING PROPOSAL FOR SENIORS, FAMILIES, AND YOUNG PROFESSIONALS By ASHLEY MCGREW A Thesis submitted to the Department of Interior Design in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science Degree Awarded Fall Semester, 2008 The members of the Committee approve the Thesis of Ashley McGrew defended on October 14, 2008. ______________________________ Jill Pable Professor Directing Thesis ______________________________ Eric Wiedegreen Committee Member ______________________________ Tock Ohazama Committee Member Approved: ________________________________________________ Eric Wiedegreen, Chair, Department of Interior Design ________________________________________________ Sally McRorie, Dean, College of Visual Arts, Theatre, and Dance The Office of Graduate Studies has verified and approved the above named committee members. ii For my Family: Thank you for always believing in me; I am so grateful to have you all in my life. And to Mom and Dad: I would not be where I am or who I am today without your love and support. Thank you, for everything. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to extend my sincere gratitude to the Interior Design department at Florida State University. My professors and colleagues have taught me so much throughout my educational career. A special thank you goes to Professor Tock Ohazama and Professor Eric Wiedegreen who have been so generous with their time and guidance. A special thanks to Adrianne Kautz, Marlo Ransdell, Robyn Flowers, and Mike Morton for their assistance with research for the study. I would like to express my deepest gratitude to Dr. Jill Pable, who has not only provided countless hours of dedication and support, but the encouragement to succeed. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Figures vii List of Tables xi Abstract xii 1. Introduction 1 Purpose of the Study 1 Design Opportunity and Justification 2 Goals of the Project 2 Design Concept 3 Definition of Terms 3 Research Components 4 2. Review of Literature 5 The United States Housing Market Past and Present 5 Washington, D.C. Housing Market 7 The Rise and Fall of McMansions 9 Is this the End of Suburbia? 13 The Small House Movement 16 Housing Options and Opposition 19 Multi-Family Rental Units 20 Drop-Houses 20 Repurposing Buildings 22 Cohousing Communities 23 Population Groups with Specialized Needs 26 Seniors 26 Small Families 31 Young Professionals 34 Summary 36 3. Design Program 38 Project Description 38 Existing Site Conditions 39 Social, Psychological, Political, and Economic Context 54 Social 54 Psychological 54 Political 55 Economic 56 Client Profiles, Philosophy and Goals 56 Seniors 57 v Small Families 59 Young Professionals 60 Client Operation and Organizational Structure 60 Image Portrayed 61 Type of Construction and Materials 62 Codes and Regulations 63 Exterior 63 Interior 63 Energy Conservation and Green Design Issues 64 Analysis of Individual Space Requirements 65 Further Design Requirements 67 Senior Common Areas 67 Senior Individual Residences 68 Small Families Common Areas 68 Small Families Individual Residences 68 Young Professionals Common Areas 69 Young Professionals Individual Residences 69 Summary 70 4. Proposed Design Solution 71 Senior Design 71 Small Families Design 88 Young Professionals Design 101 Cost Estimate 114 Summary 117 5. Summary and Conclusions 118 Reflections of the Project Thesis Research and Design 118 The New Solutions 118 Future Avenues of Study 121 Recommendations for Other Congregate Living Designers 122 Summary 123 Bibliography 124 Biographical Sketch 129 vi LIST OF FIGURES Figure 2.1. Map of Washington Metro rail 8 Figure 2.2. McMansion in McLean, VA, a suburb of 11 Washington, D.C. Figure 2.3. Brick front façade with vinyl siding applied to other 12 dwelling elevations Figure 2.4. A New Urbanist community 15 Figure 2.5. Custom small home 18 Figure 2.6. Manufactured ‘Granny Flat’ 21 Figure 2.7. Brainard Warner Mansion located in 23 Kensington, Maryland Figure 2.8. Cohousing communities 24 Figure 2.9. Silver Sage Village in Boulder, Colorado 28 Figure 2.10. A universally designed kitchen 30 Figure 3.1. The Preserve at Small’s Nursery 40 Figure 3.2. Street-level map of the Preserve 41 Figure 3.3. Entrance to the Preserve 41 Figure 3.4. Community amenities 42 Figure 3.5. Leisure World 42 Figure 3.6. The McMansion selected to be repurposed 43 Figure 3.7. Homes for sale 43 Figure 3.8. Home exterior 44 Figure 3.9. Outdoor spaces 44 Figure 3.10. Basement floor plan 45 vii Figure 3.11. First floor plan 46 Figure 3.12. Second floor plan 47 Figure 3.13. Attic floor plan 48 Figure 3.14. The two-story foyer 49 Figure 3.15. Home office off the foyer 49 Figure 3.16. Formal living area 49 Figure 3.17. Eat-in kitchen 49 Figure 3.18. Kitchen dining areas 50 Figure 3.19. The formal dining room 50 Figure 3.20. Step-down family room 50 Figure 3.21. Family room features 50 Figure 3.22. Basement features 51 Figure 3.23. Bedroom of master suite 51 Figure 3.24. Sitting room of master suite 51 Figure 3.25. Master bathroom 52 Figure 3.26. Bedroom 2 52 Figure 3.27. Bedrooms 3 and 4 53 Figure 3.28. Shared bathroom 53 Figure 4.1. Senior residence site plan 73 Figure 4.2. Senior stacking parti diagram 74 Figure 4.3. Senior first floor plan 76 Figure 4.4. Perspective of senior lounge area 77 Figure 4.5. Unit 2 ADA bathroom detail 79 viii Figure 4.6. Senior basement level floor plan 80 Figure 4.7. Senior Unit 2 ADA kitchen 81 Figure 4.8. Senior second floor plan 82 Figure 4.9. Senior attic floor plan 84 Figure 4.10. Senior structure cross-section 86 Figure 4.11. Materials specified in senior structure 87 Figure 4.12. Small families site plan 89 Figure 4.13. Small families stacking parti diagram 90 Figure 4.14. Small families first floor plan 91 Figure 4.15. Perspective of shared childcare area 93 Figure 4.16. Small families basement floor plan 94 Figure 4.17. Small families second floor plan 95 Figure 4.18. Perspective of living area in Unit 3 96 Figure 4.19. Small families attic floor plan 97 Figure 4.20. Small families cross-section 99 Figure 4.21. Small families specifications 100 Figure 4.22. Young professionals site plan 102 Figure 4.23. Young professionals stacking parti diagram 103 Figure 4.24. Young professionals first floor plan 105 Figure 4.25. Young professionals lounge perspective 106 Figure 4.26. Young professionals basement floor plan 107 Figure 4.27. Young professionals second floor plan 108 Figure 4.28. Perspective of Unit 3 109 ix Figure 4.29. Young professionals attic floor plan 110 Figure 4.30. Young professionals cross-section 112 Figure 4.31. Young professionals unit specifications 113 x LIST OF TABLES Table 3.1. Common Area Space Requirements 66 Table 3.2. Individual Residence Space Requirements 67 Table 4.1. Cost Estimate for the Young Professionals Unit 114 Table 4.2. Sales Trends for Rockville, Redland, Olney, North 116 Bethesda, Brookeville, Brinklow for Single Family Residences (SFR) and Condominiums xi ABSTRACT The mortgage lending crisis of 2008 in the United States has become a major political and social issue (Reuters, 2008). Within this dilemma are two specific problems which may be solved to mutual benefit. First, there is an abundance of empty homes on the market; and second, there are people who cannot qualify to buy acceptable housing due to stricter lending standards. Specifically, this study will address the need for affordable housing and the concurrent problem of empty ‘McMansions’, a dwelling type increasingly available due to the current mortgage crisis. In an effort to provide a solution to the housing crisis for various population groups, three different residential designs will be designed within a McMansion, with one unit each designed specifically for seniors, small families, and young professionals. Each will incorporate design features that seek to promote community, mutual support amongst the residents, and principles of sustainability. The McMansion to be repurposed will be located in a suburban area of Washington, D.C. where the cost of housing is especially expensive. As this is not yet a familiar housing solution, opposition to the project design is anticipated. This presents challenges to provide both affordable housing options as well as solve the issue of vacant homes across the country. Further, this study’s proposal for congregate, mutually supportive living may also offer social benefits for certain types of persons in western culture. These groups include the elderly, families with young children, and young professionals who have yet to achieve full financial stability. Several design solutions will be presented that will utilize vacant houses and turn them into affordable homes while also facilitating community interaction and sustainability. The design will take advantage of sustainable aspects such as higher- density living, mass transportation, and proximity to local necessities. It proposes to accomplish this by using existing housing stock, and specifically the particular type of house some sources have derided as ‘McMansions’, or dwellings which are larger than the average 2,500 square foot home, generic in style and packed in close together on insufficiently-sized lots (Smith, 2007). This repurposing also serves xii to make timely use of existing dwellings (which themselves use considerable natural resources to construct) in a different way, thus avoiding the unnecessary construction of further dwellings.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Housing in the Evolving American Suburb Cover, from Top: Daybreak, South Jordan, Utah
    Housing in the Evolving American Suburb Cover, from top: Daybreak, South Jordan, Utah. Daybreak, Utah St. Charles, Waldorf, Maryland. St. Charles Companies Inglenook, Carmel, Indiana. Ross Chapin Architects, Land Development & Building Inc. © 2016 by the Urban Land Institute 2001 L Street, NW Suite 200 Washington, DC 20036 Printed in the United States of America. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission of the publisher. Recommended bibliographic listing: Urban Land Institute. Housing in the Evolving American Suburb. Washington, DC: Urban Land Institute, 2016. ISBN: 978-0-87420-396-7 Housing in the Evolving American Suburb About the Urban Land Institute The mission of the Urban Land Institute is to provide leadership in the responsible use of land and in creating and sustaining thriving communities worldwide. ULI is committed to n Bringing together leaders from across the fields of real estate and land use policy to exchange best practices and serve community needs; n Fostering collaboration within and beyond ULI’s membership through mentoring, dialogue, and problem solving; n Exploring issues of urbanization, conservation, regeneration, land use, capital formation, and sustainable development; n Advancing land use policies and design practices that respect the uniqueness of both the built and natural environments; n Sharing knowledge through education, applied research, publishing, and electronic media; and n Sustaining a diverse global network of local practice and advisory efforts that address current and future challenges. Established in 1936, the ULI today has more than 39,000 members worldwide, representing the entire spectrum of the land use and development disciplines.
    [Show full text]
  • The Future of the Millennial Generation in the Age of Automation
    OGILVY CONSULTING Union of Humans The Future of the Millennial Generation in the Age of Automation Jess Kimball Leslie Chief Futurist 2 Table of Contents (00) Prologue A Look Back & A Look Forward p. 4-23 Reflections (01) Chapter 1 Millennials & the Economy p. 24-73 The Human Union (02) Chapter 2 Millennial Culture p. 74-91 Evolution & Contradiction (03) Chapter 3 Millennials, Advertising, p. 92-107 & Media Drone or Billboard or Both? (04) Chapter 4 In Conclusion p. 108-111 The Adultings Will Be All Right (05) Endnotes Sources p. 112-118 Further Reading 3 4 00 PROLOGUE A Look Back & A Look Forward Reflections 5 PROLOGUE F.01—Inequality: A Huge Issue +6% But now, the very affluent (the 99.999th percentile) see the largest income growth. 5% The poor and middle class used to see the largest income growth. 4% 3% 2% 5th Percentile Income Growth (Over Previous 34 Years) Previous (Over Income Growth 1% 0% 0 10th 20th 30th 40th 50th 60th 70th 80th 90th 100th Lower Income Income Percentile Higher Income Figure 01 1980 Source (Inequality, above): Leonhardt, David. “Our Broken Economy, in One Simple Chart.” New York Times, August 7, 2017. 2014 Source (Upward Mobility, next page): Chetty et al, Science, April 24, 2017. 6 A LOOK BACK & A LOOK FORWARD A Look Back to 2015 The Year We Predicted Inequality Was About to Change Everything Back in 2015, Ogilvy Consulting authored a trend report on Millennials (“States of the American Millennial”)1 that was structured around one overarching insight: inequality would soon become the Millennial generation’s key defining issue.
    [Show full text]
  • Council Report II Infill and Plazas
    Council Report II Page 1 Council Report II T HE S AN T A F E C OUN C IL O F T HE CNU S AN T A F E , N EW M EXI C O O ct OBER 2001 Drawing by Bill Dennis S OU T H P RE sc O tt ■ OCEAN VIEW ■ AQUA DEL MAR ■ MISSION MERIDIAN ■ UCLA WESTLAKE ■ ST CROIX ■ MUXBAL ■ GHANSOLI Case Studies of New Urban Infill Development By Members of the Congress for the New Urbanism Page 2 Major funding provided by the Knight Program in Community Building Pushing the Boundaries of New Urbanism and Smart Growth The Knight Program in Community Building addresses today’s urgent issues associated with community building, including the complex problems of suburban sprawl and inner-city disinvestment. The program’s goal is to advance the knowledge and practice of New Urbanism and Smart Growth across disciplines through an innovative series of initiatives. The program is funded by the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation, which promotes excellence in journalism worldwide and invests in the vitality of 26 U.S. Com- munities. The Knight Program extends the Knight Foundation’s commitment to community service with a mid-career program of professional development. ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ Fellows Scholars Publications Symposia/Charrettes Each year, the Knight Program The Knight Program offers schol- A variety of publications on top- The program sponsors semi- selects 12 mid-career profession- arships to promising students ics of community-building, smart nars, conferences and an an- als from diverse fields to take entering the University of Miami growth and new urbanism are nual charrette in a Knight part in intensive community- School of Architecture gradu- sponsored by the Knight Pro- city.
    [Show full text]
  • Fig. 1 Fig. 2 Mark Rakatansky How Serlio Haunts Us Still: Wittkower's
    Mark Rakatansky How Serlio Haunts Us Still: Wittkower’s Paradoxical Parallax In regard to Serlio there will always be more questions than answers. Did Serlio give license to licentious rule-breaking in architecture or did he seek to normalize and contain its codes and coordinates? Did he seek to promote the Extraordinary — as stated in the title of his Extraordinario libro di architettura — or rather restrict and codify it into the now conventional and widespread all too Ordinary as a regularizing ordination? Did his professed intention to ac- commodate French comfort with Italian décor result not in their recombinative mixture but rather in a one variation after another of prescriptive and proscriptive commodified simulations of decorum, in other words, a catalogue of fixed social rankings of “proper” comportment? Is it he, and not Palladio, who is principally responsible for initiating the process by which certain intricate Cinquecento modes and motifs became, in Rudolf Wittkower’s phrase, “legalized and aca- demically petrified?”1 Wittkower used that phrase in his essay “Pseudo-Palladian Elements in English Neo-Classical Architecture,” wherein he tracks the developments of two Cinquecento motifs in later centuries: the “Palladian” window and the combinative tectonic figuration of quoins and voussoirs superimposed on frames of doorways and windows. Why does Wittkower refer to these elements as “Pseudo-Palladian?” First, because Palladio used the former motif only in a very limited number of instances, and the latter motif not at all. Second, because the neo-Palladians analyzed by Wittkower used the former motif in ways contrary to the ways Palladio utilized them.
    [Show full text]
  • FEATURES Wednesday, May 9, 2007
    14 FEATURES Wednesday, May 9, 2007 KEEPING UP WITH THE JONESES WILLY KORCHEK ‘09 often using the same siding materials. simple renovation would not make sense. Online Editor But the list of McMansions only Teardowns have been present as long as continues—and the Stansbury area is not homes have been present, but in recent years, A McDonald’s Mansion the only neighborhood riddled with huge they have been targeted as perfect locations houses on comparatively small lots. for McMansions that hinder neighborhood The McMansion. One part massive unity. single-family home worth an outlandish The McMansion Multiplies Xchange Properties, headquartered in sum of money, another part McDonald’s, the Clarendon Hills, Illinois, makes a business omnipresent fast food chain seen repeatedly According to the United States Census, of marketing over 100 teardown properties across America. Together, a McDonald’s 1,654,500 single-family houses were built each year countrywide, including Southern mansion, or McMansion, is an idiom applied in 2006, the most since 1973. These houses, California, and facilitating the selling of the to those houses that are similar in appearance, however, had an average of 2,434 square land for redevelopment, in essence brokering garish in effect, and seen negatively by city feet, a nearly 47 percent increase in square teardowns to consumers. planners, environmentalists, and the average footage when compared to 1973’s average “[Teardown activity] is perceived as neighborhood dweller whose sunlight—and of 1,660 square feet. smart growth,” said Andrei Vorobiev, a pride of ownership—have been taken away In 1973, 64 percent of all single-family founder of the company.
    [Show full text]
  • FADING PROMISE: Millennial Prospects in the Golden State 1
    Many of California’s problems are self-inflicted, the result of mis- guided policies that have tendedCENTER to inflateFOR land prices and drive up the cost of all kindsDEMOGRAPHICS of housing. Since housing & POLICY is the largest house- hold expenditure, this pushes up the cost of living. RESEARCH BRIEF California still hasCHAPMAN the landmass andUNIVERSITY the appeal to power opportu- nity for the next generation. It is up to us to reverse the course, and restore The California Dream for the next generation. CENTER FOR This report presentsDEMOGRAPHICS detailed data about & POLICYthe state of the economy, population base, and employment picture of California. The implications of the data are inescapable:RESEARCH California, despite BRIEF its great natural blessings, needs a new strategyCHAPMAN and a focused commitmentUNIVERSITY to execute it. CENTER FOR DEMOGRAPHICS & POLICY RESEARCH BRIEF CHAPMAN UNIVERSITY CENTER FOR DEMOGRAPHICS & POLICY RESEARCH BRIEF CHAPMAN UNIVERSITY CENTER FOR DEMOGRAPHICS & POLICY RESEARCH BRIEF CHAPMAN UNIVERSITY CENTER FOR DEMOGRAPHICS & POLICY RESEARCH BRIEF CHAPMAN UNIVERSITY CENTER FOR DEMOGRAPHICS & POLICY RESEARCH BRIEF CHAPMAN UNIVERSITY CENTER FOR DEMOGRAPHICS & POLICY RESEARCH BRIEF CHAPMAN UNIVERSITY CENTERCo-authors: FOR JoelDEMOGRAPHICS Kotkin and Wendell & POLICY Cox RESEARCH BRIEF CHAPMANLead researchers: UNIVERSITY Ali Modarres, Alicia Kurimska, Charlie Stephens, Aayush Aggarwal, and Erika Nicole Orejola Editor: Zina Klapper CHAPMAN UNIVERSITY PRESS PRESS CHAPMAN PRESS UNIVERSITY PRESS FADING
    [Show full text]
  • The Shifting Narrative of Suburbia and the American Dream Kristen Ann Greteman Iowa State University
    Iowa State University Capstones, Theses and Graduate Theses and Dissertations Dissertations 2016 The pursuit of happiness: the shifting narrative of suburbia and the American Dream Kristen Ann Greteman Iowa State University Follow this and additional works at: https://lib.dr.iastate.edu/etd Part of the United States History Commons, Urban, Community and Regional Planning Commons, and the Urban Studies and Planning Commons Recommended Citation Greteman, Kristen Ann, "The pursuit of happiness: the shifting narrative of suburbia and the American Dream" (2016). Graduate Theses and Dissertations. 14983. https://lib.dr.iastate.edu/etd/14983 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Iowa State University Capstones, Theses and Dissertations at Iowa State University Digital Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Iowa State University Digital Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The pursuit of happiness: The shifting narrative of suburbia and the American Dream by Kristen Greteman A thesis submitted to the graduate faculty in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degrees of MASTER OF SCIENCE MASTER OF COMMUNITY AND REGIONAL PLANNING Majors: Architecture; Community and Regional Planning Program of Study Committee: Nadia Anderson, Co-Major Professor Jane Marie Rongerude, Co-Major Professor Carlton Wade Basmajian Jelena Bogdanovic Iowa State University Ames, Iowa 2016 Copyright © Kristen Greteman, 2016. All
    [Show full text]
  • People in Glass Houses: the Practical and Conceptual Challenges of Public Access in Mid-Century Modernist Residences
    University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Theses (Historic Preservation) Graduate Program in Historic Preservation 6-1-2008 People in Glass Houses: The Practical and Conceptual Challenges of Public Access in Mid-Century Modernist Residences Alexandra Bevk University of Pennsylvania Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/hp_theses Part of the Historic Preservation and Conservation Commons Bevk, Alexandra, "People in Glass Houses: The Practical and Conceptual Challenges of Public Access in Mid-Century Modernist Residences" (2008). Theses (Historic Preservation). 96. https://repository.upenn.edu/hp_theses/96 A thesis in Historic Preservation Presented to the Faculties of the University of Pennsylvania in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements of the Degree of Master of Science in Historic Preservation 2008. Advisor: Randall Mason This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/hp_theses/96 For more information, please contact [email protected]. People in Glass Houses: The Practical and Conceptual Challenges of Public Access in Mid-Century Modernist Residences Abstract High Modernist residential architecture of the mid-twentieth century embodied an austere beauty of simplicity and purity of form. Applying strict design theory to material and structure, architects connected man, architecture and nature in a way that enabled a surreal experience, pushing a residential structure beyond a dwelling to a spiritual place. Over time, some of the most famous and iconic pieces of this architecture have shifted ownership and are no longer used as residences. A new demand for public access and visitation has transformed them into museums and public spaces, turning each into a piece of art in its own right.
    [Show full text]
  • Beverly Hills, West Hollywood Remember Those Lost to AIDS
    WWW.BEVERLYPRESS.COM INSIDE Help the Miracle Mile collect toys for Sunny with children in need. p.5 temps in the mid 60s Volume 26 No. 48 Serving the West Hollywood, Hancock Park, Beverly Hills and Wilshire Communities December 1, 2016 Beverly Hills, West Hollywood HPOZ plan updated, nbut opposition persists nremember those lost to AIDS Councilman Ryu wants to respect years-long effort Quilt symbolizes past ceed as planned without infringing ‘urgency’ as activists on property owners’ rights. The Los Angeles Planning An HPOZ – historic preservation continue to raise notice Department released an updated overlay zone – is a tool that has draft Preservation Plan for the become more popular in Los Miracle Mile HPOZ, and the city Angeles County to help neighbor- In 2001 when he was in his planning commission will consider it hoods like the Miracle Mile preserve early 20s, Lucas Grindley saw next week. its unique architecture. part of the AIDS quilt for the first Councilman David Ryu, 4th After “McMansions” started time when it was on display at a District, said his office is working on invading communities during the pride event in his home state of “very minor points” after what he current development boom – replac- Florida. described as a successful meeting, ing structures built from 1921-1953 “There was a real sense of where all parties agreed on clarifica- in the process – neighborhood lead- urgency about what people faced, tions to ensure the HPOZ can pro- See Planning page 26 and what we need to talk about,” said Grindley, editorial director of The Advocate’s parent company Here Media.
    [Show full text]
  • Evaluating Criticism of Smart Growth 25 June 2021
    www.vtpi.org [email protected] 250-360-1560 Evaluating Criticism of Smart Growth 25 June 2021 By Todd Litman Victoria Transport Policy Institute Victoria, British Columbia is an example of a city that benefits from Smart Growth land use patterns. Abstract This paper evaluates various criticisms of Smart Growth. It defines the concept of Smart Growth, contrasts it with sprawl, and describes common Smart Growth strategies. It examines various criticisms of Smart Growth including the claims that it harms consumers, infringes on freedom, increases traffic congestion and air pollution, reduces housing affordability, causes social problems, increases public service costs, requires wasteful transit subsidies and is unjustified. Some specific critics’ papers are examined. This analysis indicates that many claims by critics reflect an incomplete understanding of Smart Growth or inaccurate analysis. Critics identify some legitimate problems that must be addressed to optimize Smart Growth, but present no convincing evidence to diminish overall justifications for Smart Growth. Todd Alexander Litman © 2003-2021 You are welcome and encouraged to copy, distribute, share and excerpt this document and its ideas, provided the author is given attribution. Please send your corrections, comments and suggestions for improvement. Evaluating Criticism of Smart Growth Victoria Transport Policy Institute Contents Summary ......................................................................................................................... 2 Introduction ....................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Hawaii Modernism Context Study Our Special Mahalo Goes to the Peer Review Group Who Took Their Time to Review the Study
    Acknowledgements and Contributors This project was funded in part by a grant from the Hawaii Preservation Fund and Modernism + Recent Past Intervention Fund of the National Trust for Historic Preservation. Additional funding was provided by Historic Hawaii Foundation and Fung Associates, Inc. The following people and organizations have contributed a great deal to this study: Historic Hawai‘i Foundation Kiersten Faulkner, Executive Director Lisa Palm, Director of Operations Wendy Wichman, Director of Field Services National Trust for Historic Preservation Christine Madrid French, Director, Trust Modern Fung Associates, Inc. Louis Fung Tonia Moy Mayu Ohama William Chapman Don Hibbard Claire Oshiro The success of this study depends largely on the encouragement and guidelines of many others. We take this opportunity to express our gratitude to the people who have been involved in the successful completion of this study. Hawaii Modernism Context Study Our special Mahalo goes to the peer review group who took their time to review the study. Pua Aiu, State Historic Preservation Division Suzanne Bott, National Park Service George Casen, Hawai‘i Historic Places Review Board Joy Davidson, AIA Historic Preservation Committee Jeff Dodge, Hawai‘i Historic Places Review Board Stephanie Foell, PB World Denise McGeen, PB World Ellyn Goldkind, NAVFAC Hawaii Loriann Gordon, Loriann Gordon Landscape Architect Anna Grune, Historic Hawai‘i Foundation Kimo Guequierre, Hawai‘i Historic Places Review Board Tanya Gumapac-McGuire, Historic Hawai‘i Foundation Frank Haines , Architects Hawai‘i Anthea Hartig, National Trust for Historic Preservation Ken Hays, Hawai‘i Historic Places Review Board Wendie McAllaster, Helber Hastert & Fee Glenn Mason , Mason Architects, Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • The House Was Demolished: an Argument for Pragmatic and Proactive Preservation of Modern Residential Architecture
    THE HOUSE WAS DEMOLISHED: AN ARGUMENT FOR PRAGMATIC AND PROACTIVE PRESERVATION OF MODERN RESIDENTIAL ARCHITECTURE A THESIS SUBMITTED ON THE NINTH DAY OF APRIL 2018 TO THE DEPARTMENT OF PRESERVATION STUDIES IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE OF TULANE UNIVERSITY FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF PRESERVATION STUDIES BY __________________________________ ANNA JACQUELINE MARCUM _______________________ John H. Stubbs, Director _______________________ Laura Ewen Blokker, Advisor Copyright 2018 Anna Jacqueline Marcum Acknowledgements My love of modern architecture began with visits to my grandparents’ organic, Usonian-inspired ranch home and evolved into this thesis, The House was Demolished: An Argument for Pragmatic and Proactive Preservation of Modern Residential Architecture. I would be remiss not to begin this letter by acknowledging my grandparents’ role in fostering my love of modern residential architecture. Thank you, Jack and Millie Wagner. I love and appreciate you for the impact you have had on my character and academic career. The core of this thesis was developed under the guidance of Carissa Demore and Sally Zimmerman of Historic New England. Thank you both for your commitment to education and supporting my work on the Massachusetts Modern Survey. I am so grateful for your direction, commitment to diversifying the history of residential architecture, and impeccable preservation ethos. This thesis truly would not exist without the work I did at Historic New England under your leadership. Thank you. The Master of Preservation Studies Faculty at the Tulane School of Architecture has been indispensable in this process. Thank you, Laura Ewen Blokker, for your thoughtful notes and counsel.
    [Show full text]